Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP266: Loyalty & Luxury - How Can Premium Brands Land A Winning Loyalty Strategy?
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 0:10feature in interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry thought leads and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ECOM strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James of Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an ecommerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Today's episode is sponsored by Centre and Grab and more about
- 0:38them later. Another interesting topic,
- 0:40Loyalty and luxury. How can premium brands land a
- 0:42winning loyalty strategy? We're joined by somebody who has
- 0:46worked with quite a few premium brands.
- 0:48And I'm not talking about Paul. I'm talking about our guests
- 0:50today. Some of you already know them,
- 0:52some won't. So warm welcome to Ed Balls, the
- 0:54owner at Lime Shark, who's worked with brands including
- 0:56Paul Smith and Nobie's Child. So hey Ed, how are you doing?
- 1:00Hi James, thanks for having me on the podcast.
- 1:02I'm very good. Thanks.
- 1:03Enjoying the Manic Peak season? Yes, I know it's, it's three
- 1:08days before Black Friday. We're obviously crazy, but hey,
- 1:11let's, let's see who listens or, or versus who's crying in a
- 1:14bunker somewhere. But we, we, we've talked like
- 1:17you've talked loads about loyalty.
- 1:18You've done webinars. Me and Paul talk about it a lot.
- 1:20There's lots of noise in the industry this year.
- 1:23It's almost as if a lot of people have woken up to, about
- 1:24that loyalty is a good thing to do, which is strange.
- 1:27And you've just launched a loyalty as a service.
- 1:29So we thought this was a perfect time to kind of bundle all of
- 1:31our like perspectives and do a session around what a winning
- 1:35loyalty strategy is and how do you go beyond the basics.
- 1:38So before we get into that, do you want to give people who have
- 1:42not come across you lime sharp a bit of flavour of who you are
- 1:44and what lime sharp is? Yeah, sure.
- 1:46I mean, it's really nice to be on this podcast and not talking
- 1:48about tech stacks and re platforms and migrations and
- 1:51something that I'm very passionate about Mirror, which
- 1:53is, which is loyalty. So yeah, obviously you've done
- 1:57my intro already, James. My name's Ed and I'm the owner
- 1:59at Lime Sharp. So we are a full service digital
- 2:03commerce agency. We've been in existence since
- 2:052006. So yeah, 18 years.
- 2:08I've been working at Lime Sharp for the last 15 years, which has
- 2:11been lots of fun. So typically we work with sort
- 2:14of luxury, premium fashion, lifestyle brands across, yeah, I
- 2:18guess like 3 different sort of pillars of design, technology
- 2:21and strategy. And that covers, you know, all,
- 2:23all of our kind of services that we that we work with brands on
- 2:26team of 40 agency in London and also in Auckland.
- 2:31Couldn't get further away from, from the UK as my business
- 2:34partner chasing love the other other side of the world.
- 2:37So yeah, that's a little bit about Manshot.
- 2:40Excellent. So let's start with a little bit
- 2:41of a kind of position piece from you speak with a lot of brands
- 2:45and you start building out loyalty programs some as well.
- 2:48What does loyalty mean in the E Comm space state?
- 2:50Because it's definitely evolved in the past few years.
- 2:53Yeah. It's a constantly evolving space
- 2:56and I think that's kind of come a little bit from lots of brands
- 3:01innovating quite heavily and within Naughty.
- 3:03And I think that's been the main sort of driver for that change
- 3:06that we've seen. You know, if you go back to some
- 3:10of the historical loyalty programs or what we would
- 3:13consider a successful loyalty programs with Nectar and Boots
- 3:17and those very kind of traditional points based
- 3:20systems, they kind of dominated over the last kind of 20-30
- 3:23years. But I think we're seeing
- 3:25especially with brands and and brands operating in more of a DC
- 3:28mentality or space, a real shift in not just offering points, but
- 3:35you know real variety of tiers, services points and also of
- 3:40course some quite abstract type programs, which is really
- 3:43interesting. I think everyone's standing up
- 3:45and taking note of what a multi program could do for them.
- 3:49We see lots of brands with programs that already exist that
- 3:51maybe haven't been touched, that they've just been sort of put
- 3:55and left to run. But we're seeing, yeah, that
- 3:57that we're also seeing that big shift in people putting a lot
- 4:00more prominence on it and building it into that overall
- 4:02proposition as the brand rather than just to sort of like enough
- 4:04little add on. Great.
- 4:08And then first question for me. So your client similarly to ours
- 4:12are kind of more premium luxury as James has already said.
- 4:16How are how are they positioning loyalty and how is loyalty being
- 4:19positioned in this space? Or is it loyalty?
- 4:22And yeah, how is the whole proposition being presented to
- 4:24customers? Yeah.
- 4:26I mean, we're seeing a massive variety in the overall
- 4:30positioning, and I think that's driven by, I guess, like brands
- 4:34taking a step back and understanding what a loyalty
- 4:37program can actually do for them.
- 4:40So I think historically, we've always looked at it as just like
- 4:42a way to, I guess, like increase your average lifetime spend for
- 4:47a customer at a very kind of granular level.
- 4:49But yeah, we're seeing it almost as people taking a real step
- 4:52back and saying what are our core problems as a brand that
- 4:56we're struggling with and how can we potentially use loyalty
- 4:59to solve those problems. Good example of that will be how
- 5:03do we change buying behaviour away from discounted promotions
- 5:08onto full price products? How do we increase the amount of
- 5:11people that are logged in on the sites?
- 5:13And then we can do you know, previous order based price
- 5:16merchandising for products or how do we do, how do we start
- 5:20charging for returns or delivery?
- 5:23And a lot of that has been built into the mechanics behind these
- 5:25loyalty programs. So I think people are, yeah,
- 5:27taking that step back and saying, you know, how can we
- 5:30make quality work for us? And I think that's where we see
- 5:33that differentiation in the different types of programs.
- 5:36Greben create digital flagship stores for iconic brands of
- 5:39today and tomorrow. We are the number one Centra
- 5:42agency in the world with more than 50 Centra implementations
- 5:46to date. We are also e-commerce design
- 5:48specialists, platform and tech partner agnostic.
- 5:51Try our new e-commerce design subscription.
- 5:54Visit greben.com. One thing I was going to add to
- 5:57that as well that's relevant to a couple of clients that we
- 5:59share between Liam Sharp and Vivonne is the competing with
- 6:05wholesale partners as well where they're quite often cheaper.
- 6:08So like using loyalty a bit more for that and like building like,
- 6:11yeah, additional benefits that they can't provide into it.
- 6:15Yeah, because I mean, how often do you get a brand to come to
- 6:17your pool and say, yeah, we're, we're, we're you've been
- 6:21basically monetized against the people that we've sold to on the
- 6:24sort of opera and retailer space.
- 6:26Our additional services are XYZ. How do we, you know, create that
- 6:30I guess that people customers coming back to our site to buy
- 6:34from us rather than elsewhere. And I think, yeah, loyalty is a
- 6:36real kind of key driver for that.
- 6:39Yeah, I guess you see that exactly the same for.
- 6:42Yeah. And, and I've seen this work
- 6:44with, with brands who are really trying to expand D to C and have
- 6:49historically just had a very basic property said, well, you
- 6:51can buy direct from our official store.
- 6:53And it's like customers, not many customers give a toss about
- 6:56buying from an official store. The ultimate brand loyalists
- 7:00will. And there's a bit of kudos to
- 7:01buy and direct for them, But most people want convenience,
- 7:04they want price and they want service.
- 7:06And if your delivery proposition, for example, is
- 7:08completely crap compared with leading retailers, you're going
- 7:10to struggle, especially when they're discounting heavily.
- 7:13So that leads me on to like a strategic lens on this, which
- 7:16is, and you, you, you start talking about this and about
- 7:18approaching this strategic about what behaviour you're trying to
- 7:21drive. Brands need to understand that,
- 7:23but they also need to understand what motivates their customers.
- 7:25What, how do you think brands need to approach?
- 7:27How do brands need to understand what drives customer behaviour?
- 7:30Like what? What are the?
- 7:31What are the touch points where things need to overlay that
- 7:33inside and how do they get it? I guess they probably need to
- 7:36have a really good understanding of customer behaviour from their
- 7:40own data. And I guess all that probably
- 7:44something that you work quite heavily with brands on,
- 7:47especially on the the paid side is understanding, you know, cost
- 7:51of acquisition for a new customer and then how often
- 7:53they're coming back for repeat purchases.
- 7:55What's driving those purchases? Are they making their first
- 7:58purchase at full price and they come up for discount?
- 8:00Vice versa, are they getting to 1 purchase and then never
- 8:04returning again like the all those such things.
- 8:06So I think as a brand you probably need to have a really
- 8:08good understanding of customer behaviour through understanding
- 8:12data, customer feedback, speaking to people in store.
- 8:16I think that kind of research piece initially is goes a really
- 8:19long way in, I guess identifying what the objective should be for
- 8:22your loyalty program. Yeah.
- 8:26I think that makes sense. And we'll come on to that again,
- 8:28I guess when it comes to the like, yeah, measurement side of
- 8:31it. So my next question, So how do
- 8:34you balance rewards and profitability and a loyalty
- 8:37strategy? And how do you get finance teams
- 8:39or in particular CFO on board with the idea of kind of
- 8:44investing in existing customers and potentially, you know,
- 8:47taking a margin hit, Yeah, through some of the benefits
- 8:50you're offering? Yeah, I suppose all we really
- 8:54need to dangle in front of them is moving away from discounting
- 8:57across the site everywhere. All the CFO's seem to be
- 9:00interested in that, especially with profitability.
- 9:02I think lots of brands are actually doing some really nice,
- 9:06a really nice job of having some offering like more ad hoc that
- 9:11they're already doing and already delivering.
- 9:12So when we've been mapping out rewards for certain for specific
- 9:17brands, like when you actually dig into it, they're actually
- 9:19probably doing 50 or 60% of those rewards outside of a
- 9:23loyalty program. They're just not advertising it
- 9:25or formalising it. You know, there might be
- 9:28rewarding if I spend customers in the store by giving them like
- 9:31free gift and purchase or something, but that's maybe not
- 9:33like advertised anywhere. So in terms of the like
- 9:36profitability side, you could actually argue, yeah, maybe
- 9:38you're already doing 50 or 60% of those and the loyalty program
- 9:41will be formalised based on that and it's more of like marketing
- 9:44activity. But I think from a cost
- 9:47perspective, you do really need to keep a very close eye on it.
- 9:50Obviously it goes up with scale, but you know, if you want to
- 9:52start offering free beers and champagne for X amount of
- 9:56customers in your stores, you know, what's that on the bottom
- 9:59line, 56 K fee or whatever it might be.
- 10:01So like having a really good, and I think bringing in the CFO
- 10:04to those conversations early, having them feel involved in the
- 10:07project from the start, because we're going to be be leaning on
- 10:11them to doing things like ROI calculators and cost analysis of
- 10:14the programme and at tier level as well.
- 10:17So like if you are doing tiers, you need to break it down by,
- 10:19right, how much is the programme costing for our people in our
- 10:23first tier versus our VIPs and doing that type of analysis.
- 10:26And I, I think CF OS will actually love that, that type of
- 10:30analysis. So bringing them in, embracing
- 10:32them, they're our friends at the end of the day.
- 10:34They're paying for stuff and and getting them on board at another
- 10:37stage I'd say. Centre is the only commerce
- 10:40platform built exclusively for fashion brands.
- 10:42Over 300 fashion brands run on Centre, including icons like
- 10:45Paul Smith, Jeff Ave. and Nudie Jeans.
- 10:47Centre solves business logic challenges for fashion brands.
- 10:49I know of the platform and they are on a mission to help you
- 10:51scale up rapidly globally across all online and offline channels.
- 10:55Take your fashion brand global, faster, further, stronger today.
- 10:59Yeah, I think that's a really interesting point because
- 11:01sometimes the the cost of loyalty programme is hidden
- 11:03because it's absorbed into other cost lines and budgets,
- 11:07especially like freebies and giveaways, which might be in a
- 11:09marketing part versus your cost of sale from an E com store
- 11:12through discounts and promotions.
- 11:14And yeah, it's you really need that level of transparency to
- 11:18understand loyalty as a whole and the impact as a whole.
- 11:22I've got a question related to that.
- 11:24Actually. We we started this episode by
- 11:25talking about the fact this Black Friday week where the
- 11:29whole world goes bonkers and loyalty can't exist in a bubble
- 11:35outside of like peak trade in standard discount promo promo
- 11:38cycles, because it it has impact and there is there are
- 11:43considerations about how do you treat loyalty customers during
- 11:45peak? Do you do you ring fence and
- 11:47with specific deals that nobody else can get?
- 11:49And is that part of the perch? What what I I get a question for
- 11:52both of you, because you work across sorts of brands.
- 11:53Let's start a view it how how do you see brands hand and loyalty
- 11:58specifically during peak? Do they isolate it?
- 12:00Do they make it a core part of their peak campaigns I mean.
- 12:04Yeah. Sale is a key topic as part of
- 12:07any kind of loyalty programme design.
- 12:09When we've done customer feedback or sorry, custom run
- 12:12customer surveys asking specifically what those loyal
- 12:16customers actually want, it's all early access to sale or lots
- 12:19of it's early access to sale on on will be the first.
- 12:22So you can actually build that into your, if you are going on
- 12:24the tier or you can build that into your tier structure.
- 12:26It'd be like, right, we're going to give you early access sale.
- 12:29And if you're in your our first tier, maybe like two or three
- 12:32days before everyone else. If you're VOP, you might get
- 12:35that two weeks before anyone else.
- 12:37Also exploring the ideas of like always on sales for your for a
- 12:41specific tier. So, you know, a hidden category
- 12:44that always sits on the site or something that sits in your
- 12:46account. I think the the bits you need to
- 12:49be really careful about is especially if you have physical
- 12:53stores, is how do you replicate that in in, in store?
- 12:56Like you get someone to come into the store and say, right,
- 12:59you know, you've come down to the basement downstairs because
- 13:01we've got our always on sale for you.
- 13:03So I think, you know, understanding what the in store
- 13:06experience as well as online is quite key in sort of mapping
- 13:08that out. So maybe mate, this isn't
- 13:09actually this is just going to be the digital only type
- 13:12offering. But yeah, I think I think
- 13:14customers are generally most excited about how you're
- 13:17positioning sale. And Paul, I think from previous
- 13:20conversations with you, some of your brands are doing some
- 13:23interesting things that around like discounting X percent with
- 13:28if you're in a certain tier. So I don't know if you've got to
- 13:31add there. Yes, I think and I think so
- 13:34quite a lot of brands will issue a discount as you get to a
- 13:37certain tier and that's like the main driver behind the like
- 13:40upgrading or like the main like lever.
- 13:44And I think it varies as to how people use that free peak, but
- 13:47most would just honour that discount on the sale price.
- 13:51The other thing that I was going to say, I've seen quite a few
- 13:52brands rather than maybe going all in on discount either
- 13:58straight away or a total issue in like bonus loyalty points.
- 14:01So like treble points and stuff like that as like an additional
- 14:05mechanism that's a bit more premium.
- 14:08Yeah. But beyond that, I think it's,
- 14:10yeah, it's just making sure that your comms in the discount with
- 14:13the sale price and then your early access is the big one,
- 14:18like you say, edge across our clients.
- 14:21And Paul, question for you again as well.
- 14:23So I think historically, we've always felt that maybe points
- 14:27wasn't that sort of luxury or premium, but you mentioned using
- 14:31points as kind of key levers. Are you seeing that shift back
- 14:34towards a combination of tiers and points and and services
- 14:38layered in? And what's your general
- 14:41impression on the market of how points are perceived by brands?
- 14:45So, so I feel like, I think the word loyalty, like almost like
- 14:50perceptions changed. I think two years ago if you sat
- 14:53in a premium fashion brand with like, yeah, a board or, you
- 14:57know, a leadership team or even a management team, everyone
- 15:00would like turn their noses up against loyalty.
- 15:02And you know, and then there would be like some level of
- 15:05negative like connotation around points and everything else.
- 15:09Whereas now I think a lot more premium brands are adopting it
- 15:13because I think it's the easiest way.
- 15:15One, it's like one of the key levers to get people to make
- 15:18that additional purchase because they're upgrading 2.
- 15:22It's very clear. I think it's more about for me,
- 15:26the benefits. So rather than just being like
- 15:27flat discount LED or store credit LED or whatever, it's
- 15:31more about like services and things like that.
- 15:33So yeah, Self-portrait I always use as an example of like a
- 15:37premium brand that essentially it's points and tiers just flat,
- 15:43but it's positioned really nicely.
- 15:44And then Hugo Boss is another one that's quite prominent at
- 15:49the minute. But yeah, I would say that
- 15:50perceptions definitely changed, but that's more premium than
- 15:53luxury. And I think, yeah, the big thing
- 15:57now that I feel like loyalty and VIP are kind of blending,
- 16:00whereas before they were seen as 2 completely different films
- 16:03with two completely different like stakeholders almost.
- 16:07But the the crazy thing is, is premium luxury brands have
- 16:09always done loyalty. They just don't call it that.
- 16:11Yeah, yeah, that's right. You have concierge services,
- 16:14which have been for years. You, you, you're right.
- 16:18The blurring of the boundaries. It's the semantics that always
- 16:21make me laugh about. You have brands like for
- 16:23example, Smyson who have some really Uber wealthy clients who
- 16:27get a really personalized service.
- 16:30If they don't talk about it, it's not badge publicly.
- 16:33And I think here's here's a misconception.
- 16:34Loyalty doesn't have to be a publicly advertised.
- 16:37It can be a surprising delight. You are now eligible and
- 16:42therefore we will deliver our Nord 7.
- 16:43You will know about it, but the website doesn't tell everyone
- 16:46else that you can earn it. You know, it's it doesn't have
- 16:50to be a visible public. It's the whole point is you're
- 16:52trying to influence behaviour, trying to encourage greater
- 16:56lifetime value and loyalty of shopping.
- 16:59Who gives a shit what you call it right?
- 17:00But you need to be able to put put tactics in place to reward
- 17:04people and incentivizing Tikkadi being good shoppers.
- 17:07I love so and surprising delight, James, that's come up
- 17:11quite a quite a lot with some of the brands we work with.
- 17:13There's like one of the key kind of objectives of trying to
- 17:15achieve. Yeah, it's nice.
- 17:17I've got a couple of brands who do it and they look to sort of
- 17:21pet care brand. At the moment they, they're not
- 17:24they, they are a, they're a premium pet care brand.
- 17:27They're not like a luxury fashion, but they're premium.
- 17:29They're high end products and they've got like a more affluent
- 17:31audience. And they do plenty of this where
- 17:33it's, it's things that are added to the order that appear in the
- 17:37parcel. When the customer gets here,
- 17:39they don't know it's coming because if you tell somebody
- 17:42it's coming, then it's be like, oh, that that wasn't as
- 17:45excitement. I unboxed it.
- 17:47So there's lots of things that people are doing in this space
- 17:49in terms of loyalty. They just haven't previously
- 17:51talked. You're right, haven't talked
- 17:52about it internally as loyalty. It used to be that dirty word of
- 17:55premium. Yeah, Yeah, I completely agree.
- 17:58Memberships, the other one like VIP, private client membership,
- 18:02loyalty, it's all kind of merged a bit now, which I think has
- 18:05been a driven yeah carrier. As I say, events is a classic
- 18:09one and I've, I've worked with like all membership
- 18:11organisations where they have public events and people can
- 18:14sign up. And depending on your
- 18:16membership, you might get like either discounted price and you
- 18:19might have 3. But then they've got their VIPs
- 18:22who have access to a additional events which aren't publicised
- 18:26to the wider membership, but they see that when they log into
- 18:29their account that's personalized on the website
- 18:32where you log in. And then it's like a, hey, you
- 18:34know, we got AVIP event coming up.
- 18:37I'm not VIPI wouldn't ever see that on the website anywhere
- 18:40because the content isn't triggered because of my ID.
- 18:43So there's lots of these things where people are being rewarded.
- 18:46It's funny though how that people haven't necessarily
- 18:48tracked that in the past. So affected me in terms of what
- 18:51impact that then has on the behaviour of those people.
- 18:54Yeah, yeah, I agree. So next question.
- 18:58So we talked a little bit about kind of, you know, some of the
- 19:01benefits around purchase frequency and you know, having
- 19:05the tiers, so people kind of wanting to purchase to move up
- 19:08the tiers and we talked about those kind of finance
- 19:12stakeholders who need to sign off on the margin here and
- 19:15everything Cut us to what KPIs and metrics do you think ecom
- 19:19brands should be looking to track when launching a loyalty?
- 19:23Program, Yeah, a little hat tip actually to yacht, but I don't
- 19:28know if you've come across there loyalty guide for CF OS.
- 19:33They've they've created a really nice piece of content which is
- 19:36all all based around some of those key metrics as part of the
- 19:39loyalty program that you should be tracking or your CFO should
- 19:41be looking at. So I'll definitely hunt out you
- 19:43can get the link from Google or James.
- 19:46I'm sure you can put something in the in the podcast, but that
- 19:49is a really good article just like highlighting all those
- 19:51points. I think, again, I was speaking
- 19:55speaking to Yachtbo about this recently and I think they're
- 19:59looking at creating some sort of loyalty KPI.
- 20:05You know, like how conversion rate works because there's so
- 20:07many different metrics at play that is so difficult and
- 20:10confusing to understand, like how much success our loyalty
- 20:13programs are actually driving compared to what we were doing
- 20:16before or maybe not having one at all.
- 20:19So maybe some sort of like combined data which you like
- 20:22with conversion rate that's really simple and easy to
- 20:24understand of like how successful that is.
- 20:26But I guess if you go back to your objectives with what you're
- 20:29trying to achieve, I guess it's like overall customer lifetime
- 20:32value. So that should be probably the
- 20:34the number one thing that you're tracking.
- 20:36And then some complementary metrics around adoption rates
- 20:40for your customers. Again, like it's depending on
- 20:43your consent models as well. So some brands will be signing
- 20:45everybody up to the loyalty programme if they ticked into
- 20:48marketing, whereas some brands are actually saying, right, join
- 20:50our loyalty programme that's separate to our newsletter.
- 20:53So adoption rates can be a little bit blurred.
- 20:57And then I think like things like the amount of customers
- 20:59that are logging in on the site is a really kind of critical
- 21:03one, I guess that's driving that sort of first party data
- 21:05compensation. And yeah, have I have I missed
- 21:08any, any data codes there? The only thing I was going to
- 21:12say is one of the values of tiers and particularly if you're
- 21:15using one of the vendors which is quite tier orientated, is
- 21:19that you can measure the speed of like movement between the
- 21:21tiers and like the growth of tiers.
- 21:25So you can kind of model it that way.
- 21:27But that and purchase frequency was going to be my main ones.
- 21:30Then I think it goes down more towards like CRM and like how
- 21:33people respond to like the campaigns around loyalty.
- 21:37I just think in the growth of tears sounds like a great band
- 21:40name. The one that I really like as
- 21:44well is, is if you've got a referral program is what impact
- 21:48does does the laws they have on people's propensity to refer and
- 21:51do they become more valuable referrers because they refer
- 21:53good quality people in? Because obviously the two are
- 21:56linked. Yeah, you refer people, you
- 21:58should get additional loyalty rewards.
- 22:00And then the I don't know if you, you said it, sorry, because
- 22:02my Wi-Fi went a bit funny for out of five seconds.
- 22:05It must be your voice triggering it.
- 22:07I bet the the the time cycle between orders as well.
- 22:11Do you? Because I know like lifetime
- 22:12value is great. Are people buying more?
- 22:15Are they buying more often? Are they speeding up?
- 22:18Yeah, I know 100%. And if you are going down that
- 22:22points route, and I think that's probably a separate debate of
- 22:26making sure customers understand how to spend them, but also I
- 22:31guess tracking that that spend from customers, like how many
- 22:34points have you assigned that haven't been spent?
- 22:37Is there expired? It's like getting some reporting
- 22:39and measurement on that. Also from a liability
- 22:41perspective, probably makes a bit of sense.
- 22:44I think, you know, we just listed off probably like 10
- 22:46different KPIs on metrics. So I think it is a really kind
- 22:49of confusing space and going back to those original
- 22:52objectives of what we're trying to achieve and maybe break them
- 22:54down by them with some complimentary stats in there.
- 22:58Yeah, but I really like that point that that you've raised,
- 23:00Paul, about the movement between tiers because I, I've, I did
- 23:03some work with the merchandising team with a big cattle company a
- 23:06few years back at JD Brown. And they had, they actually had
- 23:09a really good program in terms of it was annual and it's based
- 23:13on spend spending on the spend level you had, you moved up the
- 23:16tiers and the rewards got really good inside, you know, like
- 23:18birthday gifts, surprise and delights, all these additional
- 23:21benefits. But bizarrely, at the time, they
- 23:24didn't have any, any like events listen out for when people were
- 23:29were not up to the spend for that year.
- 23:31And we're going to drop down a tier to then send out comms to
- 23:34encourage people to do it. And you find out actually that
- 23:38that a lot of the time the reason people get stuck or, or
- 23:40dropped down is just because somebody hasn't reminded them or
- 23:43hasn't given them an incentive to, you know, your £50 off
- 23:46staying in the gold tier, which gives you, you know, £500 worth
- 23:50of benefits and you've got six weeks to go.
- 23:53Why not spend 50 lbs and you get all those benefits, Ian?
- 23:57Yeah, those tier movements is quite interesting.
- 23:59We have that debate quite a lot with some of the friends that we
- 24:01work with just on should you be demoted basically from a tier if
- 24:06you haven't been spending? But to go back to your point
- 24:08there, James, like if you are actually, if you've set up some
- 24:11of those automations around, right, this person joined in
- 24:14December, we know they haven't spent by November next year.
- 24:18Maybe we need to get in contact. Maybe that might be a good
- 24:19opportunity to send them a text or give them a call.
- 24:22You know, we've, we've got and winter collection dropping or
- 24:24Sprint some whatever it might be, it adds an additional
- 24:27layering to actually warrant a conversation with a customer
- 24:30important. I think we were chatting the
- 24:31other day, one of your brands is like, I think 50% of their
- 24:34marketing compounds all on their loyalty program.
- 24:37Even using that as a bit of objective about how do we speak
- 24:40to our customer more that's relative to them and like having
- 24:43that baits into a loyalty program maybe 50% insane.
- 24:47Yeah. And the other thing that that
- 24:49just reminded me of a story that I've told you before, Ed, was
- 24:53when I went to the Clavio thing in Boston, and I'm watching
- 24:57James White, who had just gone from gold to silver with BA,
- 25:02nearly spend an absolute fortune upgrading his flight to get back
- 25:06into the gold status. So.
- 25:09And it was, yeah, very interesting thing to watch from
- 25:12like a psychology perspective. And it definitely made me think
- 25:16a little bit more about around kind of how that could be used
- 25:19in motor program. Well, I think at the premium
- 25:22luxury level, I mean any level, you should look to to, to help
- 25:25your customers and reward them, not punish them.
- 25:28And there are sometimes genuine life event reasons why people
- 25:30have stunned purchasing and might be missing out on roads.
- 25:33Maybe they've had a family bereavement or, you know, if
- 25:36somebody's been ill. That ability to detect and
- 25:39understand when, when people have been good loyalty customers
- 25:41for like 3-4 years and suddenly they've dropped is maybe, maybe
- 25:45it's time to, as you said it, find out what's going on because
- 25:48you don't want to punish them. And then that really pissed them
- 25:50off and you lose them on your customer.
- 25:52You want to be a little bit flexible in understanding and
- 25:55maybe sometimes it's about OK, you know, we're not going to
- 25:57demand you, you're a good customer, but EG out six crap
- 26:00months. I'm not talking about it and
- 26:02someone that's made one order and ask them why they haven't
- 26:06posted this again, that's probably a little bit too needy.
- 26:08So I think maybe on those on those offer tears that makes
- 26:10more sense. Yeah, yeah.
- 26:13So next question. So what?
- 26:14And we talked a little bit about this in the past, Ed, What role
- 26:18can gamification and community play in a loyalty program?
- 26:22I think community has kind of been a key driving for a lot of
- 26:27like outdoor and activewear brands, very well publicised and
- 26:29advertised. It works kind of perfectly for
- 26:32them, you know, whether it's running clubs, cycling, those
- 26:36types of community driven lodge programs and they seem to be
- 26:39very popular at the moment. Gamification is a really
- 26:42interesting one and something that we're quite excited about
- 26:46with the program that we've got launching next year.
- 26:49I guess it's doing giving the customers certain tasks to do
- 26:54and then rewarding them specifically.
- 26:56Immediately when you start talking about gamification, you
- 26:58start thinking about, I know computer games and that that
- 27:01type of activity. But you know, if you flip on his
- 27:03head and look at it more on the sort of brand level, a really
- 27:07good example would be someone like Patagonia.
- 27:09You know, their whole business model and operator model is
- 27:11based around sort of sustainability.
- 27:14And they're actually, their loyalty programme is based
- 27:16around gamifying sustainability purchasing.
- 27:21So like if you buy a product or if you bring this product down
- 27:24to a store to be repaired, you'll get certain points or
- 27:28rewards. So David Occasion can actually
- 27:31work really well across the spectrum of brands, not just for
- 27:35more kind of like niche type businesses.
- 27:38And I think it's it's kind of rewarding other things beyond
- 27:41transactions as well. That is room to get people
- 27:44engaging with your brand a lot more, particularly physical
- 27:47retail. I was going to call out Bandit
- 27:50as well, Bandit running because I think one that's an amazing
- 27:53program and they've gone super bored with it and there's it's
- 27:56position really nicely, but the they've got the game on the web
- 27:59site, which I doubt has any massive commercial benefit.
- 28:03It's pretty cool, I think, and it's super engaging, but
- 28:05essentially you can if you get a high score on the game that
- 28:09issues lower every point, which is a literal example of
- 28:13gamifications. They have it.
- 28:15It's pretty cool. James, I'll let you ask the next
- 28:17question. I.
- 28:18Was going to say, I remember seeing a, a gamification
- 28:23approach a few good few years back, which I thought was, was
- 28:26quite smart and it was trying to get, it was a newish band and it
- 28:29was, it was linked into getting rewards and it was trying to get
- 28:32people to better like browse and go across sites.
- 28:35So they did like a treasure hunt on the side and there was a
- 28:38limited number of items, special items, you know, egg, golden
- 28:42eggs, whatever it was hidden around the site and he had to
- 28:45hunt to find them. And you got rewarded for finding
- 28:49it, but you got rewarded for the speed of doing it as well.
- 28:51And the aim, My name is twofold was to give people rewards, make
- 28:54it a bit of fun, but also increased product discovery and
- 28:58people's understanding of what the brand is and what it sells,
- 29:01which is quite nice. Yeah, and as soon as you say
- 29:03treasure hunt in a with a luxury and premium brand, they're going
- 29:06to go like what? Who are these people?
- 29:08Yeah, but actually on the on the flip side, if you look at so
- 29:12Burberry have created a new like flagship store in Shenzhen in
- 29:16China where is the whole store is their central loyalty
- 29:20program. So you have to do certain
- 29:23actions within the store to earn social currency.
- 29:26So like you'll go and interact the QR code, do a social share
- 29:29or report that for whatever it might be.
- 29:30And within the within the actual store itself, you then unlock
- 29:34certain products or or areas within the store.
- 29:36And also they've got this like Cafe in there where you to like
- 29:41unlock certain menu items, you have to have done certain tasks.
- 29:45So that like treasure hunt concept James, like you'd, you'd
- 29:48say, well, no luxury people brands for doing that.
- 29:50But you know, Burberry are are doing that exact same thing.
- 29:53So in case with Gen. Z.
- 29:55Well, the, the other example, my favorite lawyer program is KIF.
- 29:59And like there's so many products that are only available
- 30:02to people in that top tier and it's slightly different.
- 30:05But yeah, I think that's a really nice example as well of
- 30:08like, yeah, kind of building a lot more scarcity around things
- 30:12and kind of using that to drive people to want to move up.
- 30:15Bizarre. Sorry I tell you guys.
- 30:21No, I was going to say, if you, if you actually track back that
- 30:24the Burberry specific program and what we were talking about
- 30:27before have set the objectives, they've all probably all
- 30:30probably thought about it internally gone.
- 30:33Our loyalty, our current loyalty programs are really good at
- 30:35rewarding our like older VIP customers.
- 30:38How can we how can we design something that's really going to
- 30:40engage a different target audience?
- 30:42What are they really into? And you know, I, I guess like
- 30:45grow up the next generation of Burby friends and you know,
- 30:48that's, I don't know, it seems really cool, very limited.
- 30:52Again, this comes back to the understanding consumer
- 30:55motivators and behaviours. That is, if if you understand
- 30:58what motivates and how people behave, you can incentivise.
- 31:01Call me, I find it fascinating because I am the complete
- 31:04antithesis of the target customer of these brands.
- 31:06Because if someone says you need to spend more to access more
- 31:09products, I'm like sort of, but so that's because I'm completely
- 31:14the wrong profile of audience. And I've tried it.
- 31:16Fascinating to see how it works. I the especially the exclusivity
- 31:20thing of like limited drops and exclusive items, which you have
- 31:24to have been in a certainty of customer in order to be able to
- 31:27get. Because though at the high end
- 31:29brand level, an exclusive item or one that's a very small
- 31:33product run becomes something of value and holds its value, and
- 31:36it's a collector's item. Absolutely, members only product
- 31:39is quite hard to do properly though, just like you need to
- 31:43like segment some of your collection, not like it needs to
- 31:47be exclusive to the brand. So you can't sell it to
- 31:49wholesalers and retailers. Like if you come come across on
- 31:52members only products and then it's like, you know, listed on
- 31:54John Lewis, whatever the next state, you'll be pretty pleased.
- 31:57And then also, how do you actually replicate that in
- 31:59store? Do you have like that secret
- 32:00cupboard downstairs with, with members only products?
- 32:03But yeah, no, I, I think we're seeing a lot of brands doing,
- 32:06doing that to varying levels of success.
- 32:10Yeah, and I I think when you tie this up to to to other bits of
- 32:13the modern technology chain of things like, you know, digital,
- 32:18digital proof of purchase, like, you know, blockchain based,
- 32:22you've got all this ability to actually give people something
- 32:25of value beyond just being able to purchase a product as well,
- 32:29You know, proof of ownership certifications, extension.
- 32:33Let's so let's, let's move on because a question that has to
- 32:36be asked is, and we'll start with you, Ed, it's what the
- 32:40common mistakes you see or have seen brands make when when
- 32:43managing loyalty because it is challenging and it's hard to get
- 32:47it completely right. So yeah, what what I guess what
- 32:50are some of the gotchas if you need to look out for?
- 32:53I would say like launching a programme, going to that all the
- 32:57F of launching programme and then just leaving it to run for
- 33:00like, I don't know, 1224 months and not doing anything with it.
- 33:05Like we, we see that a lot, you know, whack up a landing page
- 33:07with, you know, discount on your birthday and just kind of
- 33:11expecting it to do wonders for the, for the brand and the
- 33:14revenue. So I'd definitely say, you know,
- 33:16once the program's launched, are you optimizing it?
- 33:19Are you looking at those key metrics of, you know, moving
- 33:21people between the tiers, understanding how the points
- 33:24mechanics are working? I would say taking away rewards.
- 33:30So like restructuring your program quite frequently can be
- 33:33very detrimental. So let's say you've done you
- 33:36launch a loyalty program, you've made a real kind of marketing
- 33:39push around some of those key rewards.
- 33:41And then all of a sudden you go one second, that's not
- 33:43profitable for us because we need to spend next to keep it
- 33:47up. And then all of a sudden have
- 33:48like taken that away that like could really upset and damage
- 33:51overall kind of appearances for the brand and customer.
- 33:54And then I think the other thing just in turn is around like
- 33:57ownership of the program. So typically we see loyalty
- 34:01sitting within ACRM on marketing team, but actually really
- 34:05heavily involved everyone through from like retail store
- 34:08managers, CF OS. We've talked quite heavily on
- 34:12marketing team, digital teams. And it really needs to be part
- 34:15of that like brand offering and not just like a plug in or an
- 34:18add on. It needs to be like, yeah, that
- 34:20kind of continuity with all your communication.
- 34:23And yeah, I suppose they're the kind of like 3 pitfalls that
- 34:26we've seen. The only one thing I was going
- 34:28to add to that is making sure there's actually value in the
- 34:31tiers because I have seen loads of loyalty programs where people
- 34:34there just isn't enough value and like just doesn't result in
- 34:37like triggering the actions. Next question, So I know you've
- 34:42been doing a few evaluations recently.
- 34:44Which vendors are you seeing most in the loyalty's face, and
- 34:48which ones have impressed you the most?
- 34:52Yeah, we've just done a huge project closely analyzing,
- 34:55sorry, of four different, different vendors as part of the
- 34:59selection process. I think in the Shopify space, I
- 35:04think Yacht PO's awesome and they've got a really great team
- 35:08there, really knowledgeable around loyalty as well.
- 35:12Because, you know, I was quite impressed with the fact that and
- 35:14they don't just do loyalty, but the, the internal knowledge that
- 35:18they have around loyalty programs was, was really strong.
- 35:20They have like dedicated people within there.
- 35:22You know, if you think they've got reviews, UDC, e-mail, SMS,
- 35:27like they've got so many different products.
- 35:28So I was actually really impressed with the, I guess the
- 35:31level of it expertise they have in house and from a product side
- 35:34as great. I think looking at Ontario,
- 35:39we've been really, really impressed as a like stand alone
- 35:43loyalty software that doesn't do anything else.
- 35:46So like complete opposite from a yacht though I guess more on the
- 35:50enterprise space it's, you know, it's all API first.
- 35:53They have really kind of tight integrations with Clavio with
- 35:58Salesforce Promise. So the e-mail, Salesforce e-mail
- 36:01come in from school. But yeah, tight e-mail
- 36:04integrations and like they're just facing on their product in
- 36:06terms of the, I guess the loyalty specific features, they
- 36:11probably have the biggest amount that they've built themselves.
- 36:14So whereas like a Yoko will partner with like a Novell for
- 36:18their digital wallets that you know, and tired, I've got all
- 36:22that kind of baits in. They've also got UGC elements,
- 36:25they've got NFTS in there, they've got points fidding.
- 36:28So I think from a loyalty only product, they're they're often
- 36:31really strong. We've been working quite closely
- 36:35with Viado as well. So I guess quite a different
- 36:39offering to your own Ontario and that you need to use their
- 36:43e-mail CRM products. But I think that kind of makes a
- 36:47lot of sense because a lot of programmers essentially
- 36:50segmentation events driven through CRM activities.
- 36:55So it kind of makes sense to have that baked in.
- 36:58So yeah, they're the they're the three main ones that we've seen
- 37:01or come across and been impressed by on different,
- 37:03different levels. James Bull and anything from you
- 37:07guys I've missed? There's one that I've seen quite
- 37:09a bit in the Shopify space recently called Revo.
- 37:12So they do the accounts piece quite nicely as well after what
- 37:17was it a status stops or like terminated their service.
- 37:21So I think they've won a lot of business as a result of being
- 37:24able to like take those customers and then they've got
- 37:27that loyalty solution as well. So it's seen them quite a bit
- 37:29recently. And your dad, James?
- 37:32I think it really goes it depends on how sophisticated you
- 37:36are versus if you just want basic.
- 37:39So there I mean, I think there's there's other vendors out there
- 37:42who have like, yeah, just simple points, but don't have the wider
- 37:46feature set. I really like your payouts
- 37:48because they also can work on AB to B but it depends on how
- 37:52complex you'll be to be set up get and that's probably out of
- 37:56my knowledge saying to be honest the really fault B to B ones
- 37:59I've not section for somebody is like a manufacturer for example.
- 38:04Suspicions as well aren't there, but maybe in econ we may be a
- 38:07little bit blinking in terms of the the vendors that only
- 38:09support, you know, your econ platform.
- 38:12But yeah, there's a lot of like points own solutions, like is it
- 38:14Amex cloud or Anex cloud or something?
- 38:17Anex mate, surely it used to be quite big in the magenta space?
- 38:20Didn't they like years ago? I remember them at like Imagine
- 38:23in Vegas. Yeah, I haven't heard that for
- 38:26ages. Annex Club.
- 38:28Well, you've got you've got people like recharge the the
- 38:31subscription specialist who've got their retain product, which
- 38:34is about encouraging loyalty and subscribing customers.
- 38:37So depending on what your need is and which audience is, you
- 38:40can sometimes find these that somebody else has like a core
- 38:44set of features that you could use.
- 38:46And maybe you don't initially need to launch with a specialist
- 38:49loyalty pond. And maybe that's like a phase
- 38:51two. I'm all I'm a big fan of launch
- 38:53light and simple POC. It get it working.
- 38:56I know when you're at high end brand level, that doesn't
- 38:59generally work. It's like launch with all the
- 39:02bells and whistles and make it the prettiest thing in the
- 39:04world. Yeah, I think it'll be
- 39:07interesting without ruining the next question.
- 39:09I think it'll be interesting to see kind of which other vendors
- 39:14go into loyalty because anyone that's got access to customer
- 39:18data, I think there's a room for them to play in the space for
- 39:20sure. But that take me on for the
- 39:23final question. So how do you see loyalty
- 39:25evolving in the next kind of three to five years?
- 39:28I realise it's very hard to see anything in five years with
- 39:31everything that's going on, but maybe three years?
- 39:34Well, we've got to the end of the podcast and we haven't
- 39:36really talked to no one's mentioned AI at all.
- 39:42But interestingly, I think I think the something we might see
- 39:46is like hyper personalisation based on, on what's really
- 39:51important for me within, within that rewards, so personalized
- 39:54rewards based on like what makes me tick.
- 39:56I think that could be quite an interesting play.
- 40:00I definitely, I definitely think the gamification is going to
- 40:06really evolve quite heavily. Over the next few years and
- 40:10yeah, I think James to go back to your point you were making
- 40:12before round, you know creating those exclusive assets as part
- 40:17of the kind of I guess like the the sort of brand in there,
- 40:20whatever you want to call it as part of your loyalty programmes
- 40:22will become pretty big. I don't know what you anything
- 40:27from you guys. Think, I think, yeah, I think, I
- 40:33think data will probably be more readily available and I think AI
- 40:36will support that. I think segmentation and
- 40:40personalization will be native and more econ platforms, I think
- 40:44that will support what you were just saying as well.
- 40:49Yeah. And I think maybe there'll be
- 40:50more use of blockchain technologies.
- 40:52So for like the Omni piece, I think that might be a bit
- 40:57easier. And I also think a bit
- 40:58consolidation and like the OMS space and bits of the back
- 41:02office, which will probably make it a bit easier for like really
- 41:04complex brands. But beyond that, I think in the
- 41:08same principles, it'll just be a bit easier to roll it out.
- 41:12And if you're looking at, I guess like overall brand trends
- 41:16over the last 10 years around influencers and celebrities and
- 41:19endorsements, we're, yeah, we're seeing a lot of brands
- 41:23leveraging those partnerships with people to create really
- 41:25nice experiences and rewards for all their customers.
- 41:29So whether it's like really kind of behind the scenes or bidding
- 41:33points for certain activity with these like influences and celebs
- 41:37invites us knows like VIP access to stuff, I think that's
- 41:40definitely going to be pushed forward in the next couple of
- 41:42years. I think there's room for those
- 41:44two areas to merge a bit. So Lululemon have a loyalty
- 41:46program specifically for like PTS and like influences in the
- 41:50fitness space, and then they get quite a big discount.
- 41:53And then there's like gamification around it.
- 41:55And I just pitched that to a client, actually a similar idea.
- 41:59So yeah, I feel like, yeah, influences generally, I think
- 42:02there's a few areas that can probably merge into that.
- 42:06But yeah, that's a really good point.
- 42:09This is only the conversation that could go on and on, isn't
- 42:12it? Lord be such a big, but it's a
- 42:14really interesting area as well. And there are so many examples
- 42:16of brands doing things like uniformly versus those doing
- 42:20things a little bit different. And the take is constantly
- 42:22evolving. So let's, let's let's pause
- 42:26there before we we turn it into a 16 hour long episode.
- 42:30But hopefully everyone listeners enjoyed it as much as we have.
- 42:34Lots of stuff we talked about, lots of practical advice.
- 42:37Anything you agree with, disagree with, do let us know.
- 42:39If you want to find out more about what Ed and the team at
- 42:41Line Shop are up to with their loyalty as a service, please do
- 42:45reach out the links on the landing page or just hit up Ed
- 42:48Bull on LinkedIn. Thanks for joining us, Ed.
- 42:52No thanks. I mean I've really enjoyed the
- 42:53conversation. As you said, we could be going
- 42:54for another 2-3 hours. A a deed or days, you know,
- 42:59because we all three of us can ramble on in namely.
- 43:02But thanks again everyone for listening and do join us next
- 43:05week for the next episode. You're listening to the Inside
- 43:09Commerce podcast, hosted by experienced consultants James
- 43:12Gerd and Paul Rogers. Inside Commerce is your fast
- 43:15track to digital knowledge, featuring interviews with
- 43:17leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 43:20C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 43:23strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 43:25Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 43:28advice based on experience to help fine tune your ecom
- 43:31strategy and tech stack. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 43:34out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an ecommerce
- 43:37project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 43:39episode.