Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Mega Edition: The OIG Report Into The Death And Circumstances Of Epstein's Death (Part 4) (6/13/26)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04In this episode, we're going to pick up where we
- 0:07left off with the OIG report. In the last episode,
- 0:10we ended on part four talking about events of July
- 0:15twenty third and the placement of Epstein on suicide Watch
- 0:19and psychological observation from July twenty third to July thirtieth.
- 0:24In this episode, we're going to be looking at parts five, six,
- 0:27and seven. So let's start off with Part five. The
- 0:31psychology departments post July twenty third determination that Epstein needed
- 0:36to have an appropriate cellmate. Following the events of July
- 0:41twenty third, the mcc new York Psychology Department determined that
- 0:45Epstein needed to be housed with an appropriate cellmate. To
- 0:49ensure Epstein's cellmate requirement was disseminated to mcc new York staff.
- 0:55On July thirtieth, twenty nineteen, at twelve thirty pm, the
- 0:59staff psychologists sent an email to over seventy mcc new
- 1:04York staff members which read, inmate Epstein number seven six
- 1:09three one eight dash zero five to four is being
- 1:13taken off psych observation and needs to be housed with
- 1:17an appropriate cellmate. A review of the email recipient showed
- 1:21that the email was sent to, among others, the warden
- 1:24Associate Warden two, the Captain, the Shoe Lieutenant, the Sis Lieutenant,
- 1:30the day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant,
- 1:35the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, the day Watch Activities Lieutenant,
- 1:40and CO Number one. The staff psychologists also completed a
- 1:45postwatch report which stated that the Shoe Lieutenant informed inmate
- 1:50Epstein needs to be housed with an appropriate cell mate.
- 1:54The wharden told the OIG that the chief psychologist had
- 1:58advised him that Epstein was not suicidal and was ready
- 2:01to return to the Shoe. According to the warden, when
- 2:05he spoke to the chief psychologist regarding Epstein, she told
- 2:09them to assign Epstein a cellmate. He added that mcc
- 2:13new York would typically house an inmate who was previously
- 2:17on suicide watch with a cell mate. The warden stated
- 2:21that there was no BOP policy mandating that an inmate
- 2:24coming off suicide watch have a cell mate, but they
- 2:27usually house such inmates with the cell mate. During their
- 2:31interviews with the OIG, Associate Warden I, the Captain, and
- 2:36the Shoe Lieutenant each said they had verbally informed the
- 2:39shoe staff of Epstein's cellmate requirement and were confident that
- 2:44all shoes staff members knew of Epstein's cellmate requirement. Additionally,
- 2:49the captain said he visited the shoe on multiple occasions
- 2:53and directed his staff to be alert and attentive about
- 2:56Epstein's special needs. To Associate Warden One, the captain was
- 3:02in charge of correctional services, including the shoe. Associate Warden
- 3:07One said the captain should have told the shoe lieutenant
- 3:10and that the shoe lieutenant should have told the shoe
- 3:13staff about the cellmate requirement. Associate Warden One further told
- 3:18the OIG that the shoe lieutenant was responsible for ensuring
- 3:22that everything within the shoe was in compliance. Associate Warden
- 3:27One told the OIG that the shoe staff knew that
- 3:30Epstein was required to have a cell mate and said
- 3:33she personally heard it being discussed on more than one
- 3:36occasion when she would visit the shoe while performing rounds.
- 3:41The captain, who supervised all of the lieutenants NCO's working
- 3:45in the mcc New York, said that after the cellmate
- 3:49requirement was issued for Epstein, he spoke with the shoe
- 3:52lieutenant and directed him to ensure that Epstein had a
- 3:56cell mate similar to the warden. The Shoe lieutenant told
- 3:59the OA that while there is no BOP policy addressing
- 4:04the necessity of assigning cell mates two individuals coming off
- 4:07of suicide Watch, it was common practice in the BOP
- 4:11for prisoners coming off of suicide Watch to be assigned
- 4:14the cell mate. The Shoe lieutenant confirmed that a BOP
- 4:18psychologist told them that Epstein had to be housed with
- 4:22the cell mate when Epstein returned to the Shoe, and
- 4:25said that he passed the directive down to the Shoe staff. Additionally,
- 4:30the daywatch Shoe officer in charge on August ninth, twenty nineteen,
- 4:34said he and all other Shoe staff were aware of
- 4:37Epstein's cellmate requirement. Mcc new York Psychology department personnel told
- 4:43the OIG that mcc new York staff members knew of
- 4:47Epstein's cellmate requirement because it was discussed during staff meetings,
- 4:52department head meetings, Shoe meetings, morning meetings, and during required
- 4:57staff training. Forensic Psychology one told the OIG that on
- 5:02August ninth, twenty nineteen, she was present during the meeting
- 5:06in which one of Epstein's attorneys opposed Epstein having a
- 5:09cell mate. Forensic psychologist one said she explained to the
- 5:13attorney that Epstein needed to have a cell mate because
- 5:16he was housed in the shoe and he was a
- 5:19sex offender. Part six. Selection of Epstein's cellmate after psychological observation.
- 5:28The Captain told the OIG that he compiled a list
- 5:31of possible cell mates for Epstein, vetted those inmates, and
- 5:35provided the list of names to the mcc New York Warden.
- 5:39The warden told the OIG that he identified two potential
- 5:43cell mates and tentatively decided on inmate number three. The
- 5:47warden said he passed this information onto the BP director's
- 5:51chief of staff and later received word that he should
- 5:54assign in May three to Epstein's cellmate. The warden told
- 5:59thea that no inmates were pre vetted to replace in
- 6:03May three if he left mcc New York. The Warden
- 6:07and the Captain told the OIG that if Inmate three
- 6:10had been moved as Epstein's cellmate, they would have had
- 6:13to review a new list of potential cellmate candidates to
- 6:17ensure that Epstein was housed with an appropriate inmate. According
- 6:22to the warden and the Captain. If inmate three was
- 6:25no longer detained at mcc New York, Shoe staff should
- 6:29have informed a lieutenant on duty, who should have informed
- 6:32the Captain, who would have ensured that the process of
- 6:35selecting a new cellmate for Epstein would begin. Part seven
- 6:40Epstein's cell assignment from July thirtieth to August tenth, as
- 6:45a result of Epstein's cellmate requirement. On July thirtieth, twenty nineteen,
- 6:50following his release from psychological observation, Epstein was initially assigned
- 6:55to sell Z zero four Dash two zero six with
- 7:00in May three in the J tier of the shoe.
- 7:04A BOP medical record note reflected that on this same
- 7:07date Epstein was provided with his personally owned medical device.
- 7:12BOP witnesses told the OIG that on the same date,
- 7:15Epstein and in May three were moved to sell Z
- 7:19zero six Dash two twenty in the L tier of
- 7:22the shoe to accommodate the electrical needs of Epstein's medical device.
- 7:26Of all the cells in the shoe, cell Z zero
- 7:30six Dash twenty was the closest sell with a direct
- 7:34line of sight to the shoe officers station in the
- 7:36common area of the shoe, which was approximately fifteen feet away.
- 7:43In May three told the OIG when he and Epstein
- 7:46were first assigned to cellmates in cell Z zero six
- 7:50Dash two twenty in the l tier, the day Watch
- 7:53operations lieutenant told in May three that he had a
- 7:57cool bunkie for him, an old guy who would not
- 8:00bother inmate number three. Inmate number three said he told
- 8:03the day Watch operations lieutenant that he slept on the
- 8:06bottom bunk, and the day Watch operations lieutenant said that
- 8:10would not be a problem because his new cellmate slept
- 8:12on the floor. In May three said he was surprised
- 8:16by his response because he understood that sleeping on the
- 8:19floor was not allowed and he had previously been disciplined
- 8:22for doing so. When Epstein arrived in the cell inmate
- 8:26number three, he recognized him and said he in May
- 8:29three told the day Watch operations lieutenant that the day
- 8:33Watch operations lieutenant had jammed up in May three. In
- 8:38May three said he knew Epstein had tried to hang
- 8:40himself and had just come from suicide watch. According to
- 8:44in May three, the day Watch operations lieutenant told in
- 8:47May three not to worry that Epstein was okay, and
- 8:51that in May three should keep an eye on him.
- 8:54In May three asked the day Watch Operations lieutenant if
- 8:57he was supposed to serve as a suicide prevention advocate,
- 9:00that is, an inmate who was assigned to the suicide
- 9:03watch area. In May three said the day Watch Operations
- 9:06lieutenant laughed and brushed off in May three's comment. According
- 9:11to in May three CEOs brought two mattresses to the
- 9:14cell for Epstein and placed them on the floor. Epstein
- 9:18put the mattresses on the right side of the cell,
- 9:21which is only partially visible through the cell door window
- 9:24when the cell door is closed. In May three noted
- 9:28that Epstein also had two extra blankets, which in May
- 9:31three said was unusual because none of the inmates had
- 9:35extra blankets. In May three said he asked Epstein to
- 9:38please not kill himself or hang himself while in May
- 9:42three was his cell mate, because in May three had
- 9:45a chance to go home soon. Epstein told in May
- 9:48three not to worry and that he was not going
- 9:51to cause in May three any trouble. All right, folks,
- 9:54we're gonna wrap this one up right here, because the
- 9:57rest of this chapter, starting with Part eight is pretty massive,
- 10:02so we'll pick up with the conclusion of chapter four
- 10:05in the next episode and keep it rolling. All of
- 10:09the information that goes with the episode can be found
- 10:12in the description box. What's up, everyone, and welcome back
- 10:17to the Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're picking right
- 10:21back up where we left off in chapter four. Chapter four,
- 10:26we left off with Part seven, and now we're diving
- 10:30in to Part eight. Psychological evaluations of Epstein. From July
- 10:36sixth to August ninth, during Epstein's detention at mcc New York,
- 10:42a variety of medical professionals, including a medical doctor, a
- 10:46clinical nurse, and physician assistant one who is a mid
- 10:51level practitioner, conducted multiple medical appointments with Epstein, and Epstein
- 10:57was prescribed a variety of medications for various ailments and
- 11:02health needs. Epstein was also given an eye and dental exam,
- 11:07as well as a blood panel screening. This section details
- 11:10Epstein's psychological evaluations while he was in mcc New York
- 11:15custody prior to his death on Saturday, July six, twenty nineteen,
- 11:21at nine thirty eight pm. Upon Epstein's intake into mcc
- 11:25New York, he was medically screened by Physician Assistant number two.
- 11:30Screening included taking vital signs and asking various medical history questions,
- 11:35including questions related to Epstein's mental health, among other things.
- 11:40Physician Assistant II annotated that Epstein did not have current
- 11:45suicidal ideation and had denied having a history of suicide attempts.
- 11:50Physician Assistant number two instructed Epstein how he could obtain medical, dental,
- 11:55and mental health care. At two fifty eight a m.
- 12:00On Sunday, July seventh, twenty nineteen, a facilities assistant emailed
- 12:05the Psychology Department asking that someone evaluate Epstein because he
- 12:10appeared distraught, sad, and a little confused. On July eighth,
- 12:15twenty nineteen, Forensic Psychologist I of the Psychology Department conducted
- 12:21an intake screening of Epstein that included a self report,
- 12:25staff observation, and a review of information in century. Forensic
- 12:30Psychologists number one noted that during Physician Assistant one's initial
- 12:35intake evaluation, on the intake questionnaire, Epstein denied having a
- 12:40history of mental health treatment and any history of mental
- 12:44health symptoms. Additionally, Forensic Psychologist I noted no suicidal ideation
- 12:51attempts or self harm, no history of substance abuse or treatment,
- 12:56and no sexual offense convictions. During the evaluation, Epstein stated
- 13:02he had been previously incarcerated for three months for prostitution
- 13:06and that he was currently charged with sex trafficking. Epstein
- 13:10denied recent or present morbid thoughts and denied passive or
- 13:14active suicidal ideation. It was noted in BOP records that
- 13:20Epstein's verbalizations were future oriented and did not have indications
- 13:25of helpless or hopeless thinking. According to Forensic Psychologists Number one,
- 13:31Epstein did not meet the criteria for any psychological diagnosis
- 13:36and was designated as mental health care Code one. This
- 13:40is indicative of an inmate who does not show any
- 13:44significant level of functional impairment associated with a mental illness
- 13:48and does not demonstrate a need for regular mental health intervention.
- 13:55Epstein was educated on emergency procedures for contacting the Psychology
- 14:00d Department staff, and Epstein agreed to contact staff if
- 14:04he needed Psychology Department services in the future. The mcc
- 14:09New York Chief Psychologist told the OIG that, based on
- 14:13the Psychological Services Intake Questionnaire, inmates have four different care
- 14:18code ratings. Code one means there are no concerns about
- 14:22the inmate's mental health status. They have no needs and
- 14:26will not be followed up with unless requested by staff
- 14:29or the inmate. Code two means there is some history
- 14:33of mental health issues, but the inmate has them under
- 14:36control and the psychology department will follow up monthly. Code
- 14:41three is more severe, requiring weekly visits by the psychology
- 14:45department to ensure the inmate is stable, and if unstable,
- 14:49would be moved to observation. Code four inmates are seen
- 14:53daily by the Psychology Department and are under constant psychological observation.
- 15:00The Chief Psychologists stated that a Code one inmate can
- 15:03beyond suicide Watch suicide watches for inmates who are showing
- 15:08immediate and exigen signs of being suicidal. Subsequent to the
- 15:13intake screening, on July eighth, twenty nineteen, the Chief Psychologists
- 15:18consulted with the National Suicide Prevention Coordinator from the BP's
- 15:23Central Office regarding the various risk factors associated with Epstein
- 15:28for suicide. These risk factors were that Epstein was involved
- 15:32in a high profile case with media attention, had been
- 15:36charged with sex offenses, was on pre trial status, and
- 15:40there was potential for bad news from a court proceeding
- 15:43that day, a determination was made. Upon Epstein's return from court,
- 15:49staff were to notify the psychologist and place Epstein on
- 15:53a watch status until a thorough suicide risk assessment could
- 15:57be conducted. When Epstein returned from court on July eighth,
- 16:01twenty nineteen, it was after duty hours, and mcc new
- 16:06York staff contacted the Psychology Department and informed them that
- 16:10Epstein denied suicideality. However, for precautionary reasons, Epstein was placed
- 16:17on psychological observation status until Psychology Department staff could conduct
- 16:23a suicide risk assessment the following day. During Epstein's period
- 16:27of psychological observation, inmate companions continuously observed them and kept
- 16:33a log that detailed Epstein's activities in fifteen minute increments.
- 16:39Under BOP policy, on a case by case basis, the
- 16:43warden may authorize such an inmate companion program at an
- 16:47institution to utilize inmate observers who were selected, trained, and
- 16:53supervised by the institutions suicide Prevention Program coordinator. On July ninth,
- 16:59twenty nineteen, the chief Psychologists conducted a suicide assessment of Epstein.
- 17:06She reviewed Epstein's medical record and interviewed him, which revealed
- 17:11that he possessed some risk factors for suicideality. Epstein denied
- 17:17having any past or present suicidal ideation, intention, or plan,
- 17:22and also denied having any history of mental health treatment
- 17:27or any current mental health symptoms. The chief Psychologist's assessment
- 17:32was that Epstein had numerous protective factors that outweighed his
- 17:36risk factors for suicideality, and that he had a positive
- 17:41outlook regarding his legal case. Epstein remained on psychological observation
- 17:46pending a suitable cell assignment, and the chief psychologist noted
- 17:51that a suicide watch was not warranted at the time
- 17:54of a report. On July tenth, twenty nineteen, the chief
- 17:59psychologists with Epstein for a psychological observation and noted that,
- 18:04according to the psychological Observation logbook, Epstein had been eating
- 18:09his meals, sleeping, and interacting with other inmates. During this
- 18:14meeting with the chief psychologist, Epstein voiced concerns over being
- 18:19housed in the shoe. Epstein asked the chief psychologist to
- 18:22be single selled if he were to be housed in
- 18:25the shoe, and had also requested a shower his property,
- 18:29pen and paper. The chief psychologist stated Epstein had been
- 18:34provided a shower on this date. She provided Epstein with
- 18:38coping skill strategies to which he was receptive. Epstein continued
- 18:43to deny any suicidal ideation, intension, or plan, and Epstein
- 18:47stated he was looking forward to his upcoming court hearing.
- 18:51Regarding pre trial release, the chief psychologist's assessment was that
- 18:56Epstein was psychologically stable at the time and then that
- 19:00he could be released from the psychological observation area. She
- 19:04noted that Epstein would be housed in the Shoe with
- 19:07a cell mat and would be seen the following morning
- 19:10to evaluate his mental status and stability. Following his July
- 19:16tenth assessment, Epstein would be taken off psychological observation and
- 19:21return to the Shoe with documented recommendations for his cellmate
- 19:25and next day contact by the psychology department. The following day,
- 19:31July eleventh, twenty nineteen, the staff psychologists attempted to see
- 19:36Epstein in the morning and afternoon, but he was meeting
- 19:39with his attorneys. Since the chief psychologist was unable to
- 19:43meet with Epstein, the chief psychologists met with Epstein in
- 19:47the attorney conference area for a psychological observation follow up.
- 19:52During this meeting, Epstein expressed concerns about a number of issues,
- 19:56including not yet receiving his property, not having enough water
- 20:00during his attorney conference, and the desire to attend recreation.
- 20:05Epstein was upset about having to wear an orange uniform,
- 20:10and the chief psychologists explained the orange uniform was because
- 20:13he was being housed in Schewe. During this clinical contact,
- 20:18the chief psychologists provided Epstein with additional coping strategies, to
- 20:22which he was receptive. Additionally, Epstein was educated about routine
- 20:28and emergency procedures for contacting the psychology department staff and
- 20:33reminded of self help books and audio tapes available through
- 20:38the psychology department. Epstein continued to deny any suicidal ideation, intention,
- 20:45or plan, and was scheduled to be seen again the
- 20:48following week. The chief psychologist told the OIG that Epstein
- 20:54and his attorney mockedor for thinking Epstein was suicidal. On
- 20:58July sixteenth, nineteen, at Epstein's request, the chief Psychologists met
- 21:04with Epstein during his attorney conference. The chief psychologists noted
- 21:08that Epstein did not have any psychological concerns and denied suicideality.
- 21:15The Chief Psychologists noted that she provided Epstein with psycho
- 21:19education regarding additional coping strategies. Epstein was educated about routine
- 21:25and emergency procedures to contact psychology department staff, and reminded
- 21:31to self help books and audio tapes that are available
- 21:34to them. The Chief Psychologists noted in her clinical contact
- 21:38report that there was no need for follow up and
- 21:41that Epstein would be seen in the shoe for rounds
- 21:45and monthly shoe reviews. According to the BOP after action
- 21:49review submitted by the Southeast Regional Director, the Chief psychologists
- 21:54meeting with Epstein on July sixteenth, twenty nineteen, at Epstein's
- 21:59request during his attorney conference was inappropriate. The Southeast Regional
- 22:05Director wrote in the report that Epstein attempted to bring
- 22:08his attorneys into the fray regarding the mental health treatment
- 22:12being provided by the institution. In the after action review,
- 22:16the Southeast Regional Director wrote that it was not typical
- 22:20for the BOP to provide psychological intervention in the presence
- 22:24of others, nor was it appropriate for a GOOP psychologist
- 22:28to meet with an inmates attorney. When asked by the
- 22:32OIG about these findings, the Chief Psychologist stated the intention
- 22:36was to check on Epstein, not to breach any security.
- 22:40On July eighteen, twenty nineteen, the chief Psychologists conducted a
- 22:45monthly shoe review and noted that Epstein was unavailable due
- 22:49to a meeting with his legal team, and that she
- 22:52would attempt to interview Epstein in the near future to
- 22:55complete his monthly review as noted previously. At approximately one
- 23:01twenty seven am on July twenty three, twenty nineteen, Epstein
- 23:05was found lying on the floor of his cell with
- 23:08a piece of homemade orange cloth around his neck. The
- 23:12Chief Psychologist made a general administrative note in Epstein's file
- 23:16that she was contacted by the Operations Lieutenant at approximately
- 23:21two am and informed that Epstein was placed on suicide
- 23:24watch after he was found with a string loosely hanging
- 23:28around his neck. That morning, Physician Assistant one assessed Epstein
- 23:33for injuries and noted in BOP records that Epstein was cooperative,
- 23:37alert and oriented. According to BOP's medical records, Epstein did
- 23:43not appear distressed and was smiling during the clinical assessment.
- 23:48Epstein said he did not know what happened to him,
- 23:51and he could not explain the mark on his neck.
- 23:53Physician Assistant one noted that Epstein had a circular line
- 23:57of erythema ie superficial redness on the skin that was
- 24:02two inches wide and spanned two thirds of the way
- 24:05around the front and sides of the base of his neck.
- 24:08According to bp A report, one section of the redness
- 24:12in the front of his neck had marks of friction,
- 24:15and there was no inflammation, deformities, hematomas, lacerations, or tenderness.
- 24:22The BOPER report stated that Epstein was able to move
- 24:25his neck without any restriction and denied having any pain, discomfort,
- 24:30or respiratory problems. Physician one noted that there was another
- 24:35small redness on Epstein's left knee, about two centimeters in diameter,
- 24:41which was noted as mild. Physician Assistant one's assessment was
- 24:46that the injury was unspecified and was self inflicted. All right, folks,
- 24:51we're gonna wrap it up right there, and we're going
- 24:53to pick it up in the next episode and keep
- 24:56it moving through chapter four. The information that goes with
- 25:01the episode can be found in the description box.