Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / AI & ChatGPT
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information please. Visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov work. That's www.mit.edu oup dot-org.
- 0:18So welcome everybody. This is I love you.
- 0:20Keep going. It is March 30th. 2023 7:38 p.m.
- 0:27Pacific Daylight Time. And I've been fascinated by the
- 0:33conversation around the emergence of artificial
- 0:39intelligence, mainly chat GPT. I don't know if you've played
- 0:45around with it at all. I tried it and it's so wildly
- 0:52inaccurate in the things that it says that I have to check
- 0:55everything with Google it to make sure that it that it that's
- 1:00a realistic or accurate, it's Christian.
- 1:08I was I was talking to my brother.
- 1:09Who's more technological than I am today about that very thing
- 1:13and I was trying to explain that because I don't think that
- 1:17there's like an epistemic Gap with that where you don't know
- 1:20the basis for where it's information is coming from and
- 1:23that it can't have Insight or meaning but it can have like
- 1:26data, right? And he was just really
- 1:29interesting that I should like try it for myself.
- 1:31So he was giving me like a little Buddhist reversal or
- 1:34something but but he he He fully believed that they had like
- 1:39meaning an insight and and I don't totally naive way which I
- 1:43found interesting. So I said to Jet gbt.
- 1:48Can you give me the percentages of popped of the population of
- 1:53earth divided by continent? And it gave me the percentages
- 1:58and when I added them up it added up to 108.
- 2:04That's what I made by it accuracies. 108 is not a bad
- 2:13number in Buddhist Circles, of course, but Not what you would
- 2:18expect. So I think of it as a, as a more
- 2:27conversational version of what what's already there in the
- 2:30world in terms of search, You know, you asked it to write a
- 2:36poem and it writes a poem. I love poetry and I spend a lot
- 2:39of time reading poetry and the poems that it generates are
- 2:43generic and an interesting to me because they don't really have a
- 2:46point of view and not really It isn't a voice, it's so generic
- 2:56and in determinant that me it's uninteresting as a poem, I'm
- 3:03seeing some of the visual art that it creates and it has that
- 3:07razzle-dazzle sort of feel to it.
- 3:10But ultimately, it's also not interesting.
- 3:13As a expression of The Human Experience.
- 3:18Now obviously artificial intelligence is not a word that
- 3:21is actually actually what we're talking about.
- 3:23We're just talking about big data, sets being crunched, which
- 3:29is a whole different thing, I think.
- 3:32But I did have somebody sent me an article about the immediate
- 3:38moratorium that we have to have on all of these large language
- 3:41models. Because if we don't all life on
- 3:45the planet will be eliminated. Which I also thought was quite
- 3:51interesting. And really what we're talking
- 3:54about here is view. I have the experience of that
- 3:58that admonishment like Y2K to remember Y2K I I actually
- 4:09couldn't understand how Y2K could be taken seriously as an
- 4:12idea. It seemed impossible that the
- 4:16whole world would collapse. And so I that's how my mind is
- 4:21orienting this conversation, although I can see that the
- 4:25military is probably making automatic sort of machines that
- 4:33are useful in the service of War to have such a problem with the
- 4:37Drone Pilots having PTSD and other negative consequences of
- 4:43flying those machines. I imagine the police would also
- 4:47like to have those Well though. That that again, is talking
- 4:58about this idea of you, there was an article in the paper
- 5:04about tightness and looseness, in View, and tightness being
- 5:12associated. With these ideas of rigid
- 5:16control of ideas, rigid control of morality, Richard control of
- 5:22what you really can believe or not believe and that that's
- 5:26associated with the kind of, Restrictions in.
- 5:38How you can actually be how you can represent yourself and then
- 5:43loose, this is more where there's a there's a range of
- 5:47Expressions. A range of ideas that you can
- 5:49express without friction from the people around you.
- 5:55So maybe we could talk about a tight view versus a loose for
- 5:59you. the geographic Association was the southern states had very
- 6:07tight views and the West Coast in the Northeast had very loose
- 6:11views and the middle of the country is was in between We
- 6:21make the conceptual reality that we have around our conditioning.
- 6:27So we have the capacity to sense something we have an object that
- 6:32can be sensed by that sense gate.
- 6:34So light by the retina, picking up photons, the are sensitive to
- 6:43narrow frequency of sound vibrations, the body sensitive
- 6:48to a narrow range of temperature.
- 6:55We can smell some things. We can taste them.
- 7:00But that pure sensing data doesn't actually line up for
- 7:03anything. It doesn't mean anything in a in
- 7:06an of itself, there's nothing intrinsic about any of it.
- 7:11And what I mean by that is three people could have the same
- 7:14experience of the same thing happening, and it's very likely
- 7:18almost a necessity of the nature of the human condition, that
- 7:23three realities emerge. You have the capacity to sense
- 7:30the object that can be sense, when it makes contact with that
- 7:33capacity, we create a sensing experience, which is unattached
- 7:39in the Buddhist sense. Not fixated on solid without
- 7:44meaning. It's evaluated for processing,
- 7:47speed, does it need? Urgent attention.
- 7:49Does it not matter if there's time for a pleasant experience?
- 7:52Do we have that time? And then it's compared to the
- 7:55perceptual database, which is filled with all of the
- 7:58previously experienced events that have been recorded and also
- 8:02the imagination. So that if there is a unique
- 8:07event that hasn't been already interpreted, we have the
- 8:10capacity to understand what that is.
- 8:13And then if either there's a previous entry or the
- 8:16imagination takes hold and creates a meaning for this
- 8:20undifferentiated, unfixed, sated, Ultimate Reality.
- 8:24It rolls into conceptual reality.
- 8:27Leti. And if the those those who use
- 8:32our tight and we, we have the sense of that meaningfulness
- 8:38being more Universal. Than if it's loose.
- 8:41We have a sense that actually applies to us because we're the
- 8:44ones who made it up. May or may not have a usefulness
- 8:48for other people. When I contemplate, the
- 8:55existential threat of artificial intelligence, taking over the
- 8:59world and killing all life. It's very hard for me to make
- 9:02sense of that. It really resonates, not at all,
- 9:06which is not to say that it is. It is or is not something that
- 9:10could happen. But then the conflict in Ukraine
- 9:19and the threat of nuclear war, which appears now.
- 9:22And then, in the paper actually is quite frightening to me.
- 9:26Now, I grew up in the 50s, where we rehearsed nuclear attacks by
- 9:33hiding under our desks. I, if you're not aware of how
- 9:40the nuclear age was welcomed in elementary schools across the
- 9:44country, they would ring the The.
- 9:51I would do even have those anymore.
- 9:53We used to have the the siren that would ring, which would
- 9:57meant, which meant that you had to run for your Fallout shelters
- 10:01is what we call them. And in the town, I grew up at
- 10:06they tested it every Thursday at 10:00 a.m. so the air raid siren
- 10:13would go off. It's quite loud.
- 10:18I remember, Everybody just assuming that it was 10 am not
- 10:26frightened by it. But everybody knew what it was.
- 10:30I'm talking about school age. Children Christian.
- 10:39I think the fear for Millennials, I don't know if
- 10:42it's still around for us but it was always the Bermuda Triangle.
- 10:49Yes, that was my My ultimate idea for suicide.
- 10:55Steal a boat and sail around the Bermuda Triangle and tell you
- 10:58vanish, My mother was very skeptical about the value of
- 11:11school children hiding under desks in a nuclear attack.
- 11:16So I don't think it was even about practicality or anything
- 11:20that was useful. It was simply to relieve the
- 11:23anxiety of. Was it the children or parents?
- 11:34The third of great existential threat of our time.
- 11:37Of course, is climate change. I have the visceral sense that
- 11:51the opportunity actually, to mitigate climate change has come
- 11:54and gone, and that we didn't do anything about it.
- 11:57So now we're just going to have climate change.
- 12:01And what that is really going to lead to is these massive
- 12:05migrations of people out of the places that are no longer going
- 12:09to be habitable, which would be the equator zone.
- 12:14So about 20% of the population of the world is going to have to
- 12:19move into different climate zones and then how willing we
- 12:26are to allow that to happen without a lot of friction.
- 12:32It looks to me now like we're not that willing, but to let it
- 12:36happen because there is a lot of friction around climate
- 12:39refugees, being able to move freely, You're not going to be
- 12:46able to stay where they are, so it it seems like an impractical
- 12:50view to think that we don't have to accommodate this in some way.
- 12:55You know, I thought the idea of the wall across the southern
- 12:58border was comical. In the sense, you build a
- 13:0330-foot wall across the southern portion of the country and then
- 13:08somebody comes along with the 31 foot ladder, and they just climb
- 13:11over it. So how do we get into these
- 13:17views? How do we construct these
- 13:20experiences of reality? There's a, there's a dialogue of
- 13:24culture wide dialogue, the society-wide dialogue.
- 13:28So, Society is this collection of all of the different cultures
- 13:33that we have. And then each of the cultures
- 13:36formed around specific ideas and beliefs.
- 13:43Do we have a container that allows all of those expressions
- 13:46of all of those cultures, or do we need to, or do?
- 13:51We feel the need to confine the structures of society that don't
- 13:56allow the expressions of some of those cultures?
- 14:09If I think back on the idea of nuclear threat, there's just
- 14:17hundreds and hundreds of experiences of that being
- 14:20presented. And the response is that we took
- 14:24that worry. We built this fantastic array of
- 14:33nuclear missiles across the country.
- 14:35I remember, that the technology got to the point where there was
- 14:46a movement to replace it with more modern technology in it, it
- 14:51was like the cost of which was some huge amount like 19
- 14:57trillion dollars to upgrade our nuclear Arsenal.
- 15:04Which was not feasible. It's just too much money for
- 15:07that. What are the views in a society?
- 15:15Where so much of our resources goes toward this defensive
- 15:22posture. One of the things I notice about
- 15:25The conversation around AI being this terrible, uncontrollable
- 15:32technology, which is going to wipe out all of life on the
- 15:35planet. It has this, this fearful
- 15:39quality, this almost paranoiac quality, but it isn't so
- 15:44dissimilar to the mentality of the dialogue that went into.
- 15:51Convincing us as a society. A culture to build this vast
- 15:58array of weapons, the weapons themselves, of course, capable
- 16:03of eliminating life. Did you read in the paper that
- 16:10Jack Ma has returned to China? The, the founder of Alibaba that
- 16:15the Chinese government is opened up to him again.
- 16:20He famously said that China has all of this infrastructure and
- 16:25all of this technological Advance, because they spent six
- 16:30trillion dollars on infrastructure and the u.s.
- 16:36spent six trillion dollars on the war in the Middle East,
- 16:39which The different value. In this in this culture that I
- 16:50live in which it, which is part of society.
- 16:57There is a strong resistance to the idea that we should be doing
- 17:00this and that at the same time, powerlessness to do anything
- 17:03different about it. And so, often the drive there is
- 17:10to move into a kind of unconsciousness about it.
- 17:16And withdraw from engagement around it.
- 17:20I think that that was particularly.
- 17:24Strong in the previous administration, there was a set.
- 17:30There was a sense of confusion about How the ideas that were
- 17:37being expressed? There were really resonating,
- 17:43these didn't in the circle that I tend to travel in.
- 17:47It seemed too obvious from that cultural view of another
- 17:51cultural View. And that that unconsciousness,
- 17:58that that desire simply to remove from it because it
- 18:01creates such term on such distress is very strong.
- 18:06How then do you come into a place of equanimity where you
- 18:08really can be in? Gauged with this experience.
- 18:15As its unfolding this understanding, this cultural
- 18:20bias this way in which you create the view of what's
- 18:23actually happening and at the same time, open to the
- 18:27experience of other cultural views, Christian, What you
- 18:35described like, very much in terms of emotions that we get,
- 18:41we get our labels or we get how we experience emotions, you
- 18:45know, transmitted to us from our parents or caregivers largely
- 18:50attachment figures, I guess. And I'm really curious how you
- 18:55think that these societal views get inside of us.
- 18:59Because I would think that there would be some You know the way
- 19:04that our attachment is might affect our ability to trust or
- 19:08not to trust kind of the outside world and take information from
- 19:11it. And so like I think of
- 19:12disorganized people as being more susceptible to conspiracy
- 19:15theory views, you know, I think of avoidant people as being may
- 19:19be more susceptible to kind of libertarian views to put it in a
- 19:24really Tried generic way. So do you think the parents are
- 19:32the sort of ultimate conduits for the views or, or there's
- 19:36like mentalizing factors involved or how do you think
- 19:39that the societal actually filters down to the individual?
- 19:48I I probably think of it more as a mentalizing.
- 19:54Capacity and high mentalizing is more associated with security
- 19:58than it is with insecurity or disorganization. but I think
- 20:07that my experience of people who get caught up in ideas that seem
- 20:16irrational to me and not very well thought about are not using
- 20:25the mentalizing of spontaneous versus monitoring very well and
- 20:31nor the one of effective versus cognitive.
- 20:37Just to use to and make it a little simpler.
- 20:40They're very swept up in spontaneity.
- 20:43Spontaneous response is they don't monitor much.
- 20:47They don't track whether an idea remains true over a period of
- 20:50time or is not is proven untrue over time.
- 20:54If they don't monitor it, they're not cognitive.
- 20:57They don't think through things. They don't have the mentalizing
- 21:00capacity to do that. They're very emotional.
- 21:03So if it feels like it matches, their emotional experience, then
- 21:10it becomes real. In the way that all conceptual
- 21:15reality is real, it's not different. their perception of
- 21:19conceptual reality is not different to fundamentally than
- 21:22your conception of Your conceptual reality, does it
- 21:29match, Ultimate Reality is really the question. if you're
- 21:36constantly in this proposition of touching into the conceptual
- 21:40reality that you make from Ultimate Reality back into
- 21:43Ultimate Reality to see whether or not the conceptual reality
- 21:47that you've made matches Ultimate Reality and you're
- 21:50constantly in a process of evaluating the accuracy of your
- 21:56perceptions of things and the accuracy of what you make out of
- 22:00those perceptions then and you have Have.
- 22:07Reliable sources of inputs. Then maybe you can make a better
- 22:12map of what's actually happening.
- 22:15If you can, if you can mentalize better, you can of course, take
- 22:19in more experience and more of that will be reflected in your
- 22:24conceptualization of things, and if you can't do that, Then it
- 22:30will be less accurate. Really?
- 22:37So then, how does that map out? A different attachment
- 22:39strategies is missing people, or people who have a dismissal in
- 22:44quality to their attachment strategies rely on internal
- 22:50working models that they've created themselves, they don't
- 22:54validate them much. That would be a place that could
- 22:57get quite distorted fearfully. Preoccupied, people are in such
- 23:02an intense. Internal state of chaos.
- 23:04They can't really make sense of What's happening too much?
- 23:10fearful avoidant, people tend to get quite paranoid and to assign
- 23:19Sinister motives to other people.
- 23:22They also don't do a lot of checking.
- 23:24That's the that concen I think of it almost as a rocking
- 23:30motion. This is what I'm sensing.
- 23:32This is what I've made. This is what I'm sensing, this
- 23:34is what I've made, how well does what I've made batch, the Sensi
- 23:38and this constant back and forth and investigating.
- 23:46I grew up in a. Republican family.
- 23:50My mother used to say that she was significantly to the right
- 23:54of Attila the Hun. Jokingly.
- 24:01They sent me to Interlaken, which is a music camp.
- 24:06And when I came back and I was talking about the different
- 24:08conversations that I had, she said that she thought it was the
- 24:12worst mistake they could have made because I was exposed to
- 24:16ideas outside of Republican bubble, but I didn't find the
- 24:23Republican bubble ideas that compelling.
- 24:27I didn't see the. Happiness. in the pursuit of
- 24:41social status and material things my.
- 24:44But, you know, I'm, I grow. But in some sense in immigrant
- 24:50family Irish, You know, Shanty Irish, not not lace curtain
- 24:59Irish. They came poor mid, 19th century
- 25:04and and there was a strong ethos of moving up the economic
- 25:10ladder, a lot of focus on education in the generations
- 25:14before. And then we in some sense
- 25:16arrived where all of that generational effort was supposed
- 25:21to land and produce this ideal life.
- 25:25Life. But it wasn't, it was clearly
- 25:28not that from my perspective. So the way that it landed on me,
- 25:33was that that was into, that was not a Pursuit that was going to
- 25:37lead to a sense of liveliness. So, it wasn't being sent to Camp
- 25:53that, that changed my view. It was that period of
- 25:56adolescence where the Mind expands in your cognitive
- 25:59ability, expands, and you can take in ideas from other places
- 26:04than the limits of your family. And in that contrast seeing the
- 26:09limitations of where I was and wanting rejecting that and
- 26:14wanting something different. but then we each grow up in our
- 26:21family systems and we learn really well the system that we
- 26:27grow up in And sometimes we have the capacity for insight into
- 26:31the nature of how that system is operating, and the effects that
- 26:36it's having on people. And if we don't simply deny it
- 26:41or suppress it particularly in that adolescent period where the
- 26:45mind really expands and its capacity to think.
- 26:50And to understand if we allow that to happen, we often could
- 26:56see it more clearly and and maybe want something different
- 27:01in than are we able to then we're then when I say move
- 27:10towards something, I'm talking about, exploration the
- 27:13exploration piece here, we have will to move into primary
- 27:17exploration where we're actually looking to satisfy the meaning
- 27:22qualities of life. Pursue meaningfulness, or do we
- 27:28get sidetracked? I grew up in a family that was
- 27:31very oriented toward secondary exploration, big house, big cars
- 27:37A lot of nice things. but the, the meaningful aspect was was
- 27:46completely unattended to The student. but I take it that
- 27:54there was a certain Either freedom for you intellectually
- 27:58or at least lack of restriction, like, during that time I think
- 28:03of I've met people that maybe came from a very restricted
- 28:07worldview. Like you said, you mentioned
- 28:10different, geographic regions that might have have that and I
- 28:14would think that during that time if a family was really
- 28:17restrictive on what they allowed in, you know, for their child or
- 28:23that they explain things in very black and white Right ways to
- 28:27the child that that might restrict the child's taking in
- 28:32those other views. Taking an opposing views but
- 28:35that wasn't the case in your family.
- 28:37Know, it was very restricted. I just learned to keep secrets,
- 28:42I learned to lie. Those were the the strategies
- 28:46that I had. I learned to pretend, which, you
- 28:59know, Ultimately was not such a horrible thing because I did
- 29:06manage to pursue the things that I wanted to pursue, I just had
- 29:10to keep them secret the consequences of making a mistake
- 29:16when we're usually pretty bad. And then I I actually, I think I
- 29:26became completely unruly and so they really just stopped
- 29:31interfering with me. It was already neglectful.
- 29:39They just disengaged altogether. I think my mother disengage
- 29:50because she found it so heartfelt and so rejecting that
- 29:54I didn't embrace the ideas that she was offering, but my dad was
- 29:58bleeding different This this is a conversation about View and so
- 30:05when you don't have that environment where you can really
- 30:10express yourself and you do end up having to keep secrets that
- 30:14you do have to end up internalizing and of course it
- 30:18distorts the the experience of that.
- 30:23What's important? I think about this is that you
- 30:28begin in your practice of meditation to pull these things
- 30:31apart so that you can actually see what happened, right.
- 30:35This is one of the skill set of secure function to to
- 30:39understand. The consequences of I have a
- 30:45have this in a brochure, we put out a brochure of the
- 30:48characteristics of secure attachment.
- 30:54Seeing clearly what happened without minimizing?
- 30:56The negative effects is an important aspect of this part of
- 31:02that is the The development of positivity, intentional
- 31:10positivity associated, with the self experience, when the self
- 31:14experience arises, we have this framework.
- 31:16This working model that has all of these memory and
- 31:21experiential. Gists these little algorithms of
- 31:26creating experiences associated with it.
- 31:28And when the sense of self arises, it's a rising because
- 31:32these gists are activating patterns of audience in the body
- 31:36that we then recognized as the experience of self, right?
- 31:41Not making sense, then when you grow up in an environment, like
- 31:46I described that array of activations is very negative
- 31:52experience of the self is very negative.
- 31:54The Reflection from Family system where your ideas are not
- 32:05embraced and you have to keep them secret because the
- 32:07consequences of retaliation for expressing them creates a
- 32:12working model of self. That has that trepidation at
- 32:15that fearfulness. That if you real reveal
- 32:18yourself, you're in, you're in danger.
- 32:20And so every time the self is activated, you have a sense of
- 32:24being in danger. That's the the realm of
- 32:28disorganized people. Now, you know, yourself is
- 32:33because you're in danger. That's one of the aspects of
- 32:37attachment functioning. How that works?
- 32:42You're not really in danger after you've left the dangerous
- 32:45environment. But because the way that, you
- 32:47know yourself, is this perception that you're always in
- 32:50danger, each time the sense of self arises.
- 32:53You have the experience of or you have the creation of
- 32:57conceptual reality. That makes the world dangerous.
- 33:01This is again. The thing that we need to really
- 33:03begin to investigate when we're exploring the view related to
- 33:10attachment conditioning. But when we create these views
- 33:12and we make them accurate and real and we then push out into
- 33:18the world with Our intention and action that our perception of
- 33:22these things is accurate and expect the group that were that
- 33:28were in to respond in the way that we experience it.
- 33:32Then we have this, this push that moves out beyond the sense
- 33:37of self into the Group them as it affects the small groups in
- 33:44the small group push against the larger group, we create a
- 33:47culture, wide or society-wide experience.
- 33:56I'm just touching into the idea. Hey, I Being.
- 34:04The significant existential threat to the survival of the
- 34:09planet that it's often talked about as that I have.
- 34:13It doesn't resonate at all for me.
- 34:16I I think we're far away from actual artificial intelligence
- 34:24but there is a caveat in the in the article I read that it
- 34:28doesn't have to be conscious, it doesn't have to be a unique.
- 34:34Identity, just the mechanic. Just the mechanical nature of
- 34:41the way that these large language models are, would be
- 34:45enough. Christian.
- 34:53And I have a fear to what you were saying earlier that it's
- 34:56going to just flood the world with really boring and crappy
- 34:59art, it's just crappy art and you can't, you can't even get to
- 35:09the good stuff. It's very funny because One, the
- 35:18word processor came out the great comic.
- 35:22Fear was the Deluge of crap, poetry as if the handwritten
- 35:26stuff weren't already a tidal wave.
- 35:34Now there's there's just no limit Chad gbt please.
- 35:38Write 500 haikus. What after the other?
- 35:53did you there was an article in the paper about a rather
- 35:56well-known author who they discovered like 75 plagiarized
- 36:04passages in the book that they just published which meant that
- 36:10they had been using these degenerative systems to write
- 36:13the Books and then hadn't bothered to run them through the
- 36:17software that would then evaluate whether or not That all
- 36:22of the, plagiarized material of was either cited or Rewritten
- 36:27enough, that was no longer plagiarized. and the fear of
- 36:35college professors, that all of the papers that were going to be
- 36:39generated in class, we're going to be these large language model
- 36:45generations, and the high school and it does create that
- 36:52self-fulfilling problem of people not really learning to
- 36:56think and just substituting non thinking, or how they begin to
- 37:06perceive the world so that they don't have a way of
- 37:09understanding their perception review of things is they they
- 37:14don't have a way of mentalizing it really.
- 37:28The public education system was supposed to to save us from the
- 37:34mom. My mother would say, And we've
- 37:41systematically stripped that system so that it doesn't
- 37:44function very well. And now We have the mom.
- 37:54So did we not know that we did know that?
- 37:57Why did we do it? Anyway?
- 37:59Because there is an advantage for some groups.
- 38:02That's how I think about it. So, Here we are at this point in
- 38:12the world, the way that the world is with these different
- 38:14things happening. How do we remain engaged in this
- 38:19process of community? Where the the tightness side of
- 38:30things wants to restrict all of this and the loose, this side of
- 38:34things thinks that all of these things should be in play.
- 38:39Where do you land in this and not want to just withdraw and
- 38:45shut down and not pay attention to it anymore because it's too
- 38:49intractable it's too painful. So That, that is really the
- 38:57intersection. I think that is useful in
- 39:01practice that we can really open into this experience of every
- 39:05moment unfolding and receive it all.
- 39:10And not have to tune it all out and fall into a kind of
- 39:15ignorance in the Buddhist sense of the world, not paying
- 39:18attention. Distraction, we are a culture
- 39:21that loves distraction above all things.
- 39:25I wish that it wasn't so violent and that it didn't kill so many
- 39:29women, but that is the form of entertainment that we've
- 39:33embraced it to distract us from the intensity of these
- 39:38experiences. So, It's not all making sense.
- 39:46In terms of a conversation about View. so that in terms of
- 39:53practice, I think one of the things to do is to begin to
- 39:55notice The way that the Mind reacts to that, and I like to do
- 40:00that by in, I call it investigating self-tanner
- 40:03demotion where you're actually tracking, your thought processes
- 40:07in reaction to the present moment.
- 40:10I talk about it in terms of the one-off thoughts that are
- 40:13related to the arising and passing of the present moment
- 40:17experience. Just that activation of the self
- 40:20experience in relationship to the present moment.
- 40:23Maybe the mind is still quiet. and then, The Mind caught up in
- 40:30repetitive thought that's where the experience of the present
- 40:33moment overwhelms and we withdraw into the thinking to
- 40:38escape from it. One of the things that is
- 40:41important to be able to do as you're out and about in the
- 40:43world and tracking things is to notice when you're actually
- 40:46engaged the experience of the present moment and when you've
- 40:49withdrawn into the thinking process, or, you know, fantasy
- 40:54process or planning process aura, Centreville sentiment to
- 41:02lies in memory process and pushing into the present moment.
- 41:08Each time coming out of that back into the present moment.
- 41:16So why don't we do a little practice?
- 41:18And Focus on that particular way of looking at things.
- 41:31Maybe the existential threat of AI is actually what that tight
- 41:38view is. And then I wonder what that
- 41:41conditioning would be. That I would have to engage in
- 41:44in order to actually experience that because it's so it seems so
- 41:48foreign We'll do a little bit of concentration to settle the mind
- 41:57and then do a period of investigating self-generated.
- 42:03Look Ringing, the bell will have any comments or questions about
- 42:12the practice that we did. So let's see.
- 42:19We have a level 2 starting in April, if you're interested in
- 42:22that. We have meditation and Addiction
- 42:29coming up which is three Saturday's around that material.
- 42:35We haven't done it in a while. So I think it would it's going
- 42:37to be good. I'm co-teaching that with stars
- 42:41fettuccine What else? Anyway, there's a bunch of stuff
- 42:51on the website. Take a look at it.
- 42:55We're going to do our first level 2 class during the day
- 42:59rather than in the afternoon, which is better for European
- 43:04time. If you're, if that makes sense.
- 43:10I think that starts in July. I'm doing a in person, level one
- 43:16in Utrecht, in the first weekend first week, or so of June.
- 43:26We're we've said some dates to do a I love you.
- 43:29Keep going weekend retreat. In Oakland in July, I think it's
- 43:39in July. So that might be something to
- 43:44consider that. I love you.
- 43:46Keep going? Des Longs are about exploring
- 43:51collaborative relationship systems, so it's the attachment
- 43:56lens on collaborative relationships.
- 44:02I think that's about it for now. We we've actually finished
- 44:06booking the whole year but I'm having a hard time remembering
- 44:09the second half of the year so let's leave that out there in
- 44:12the future. I offered this teaching in this
- 44:18format freely, but I do hope that you'll make a donation.
- 44:21If you have resources, it helps support being also the work that
- 44:25better group does. Any amount is appreciated
- 44:27certainly, but please come and practice.
- 44:34I hope to see you soon on the path.
- 44:37Appreciate you. Bye.
- 44:39Bye.