Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Siege of Montreal 1189: The Last Crusader Castle
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Saladin's big victories—Hattin, Jerusalem, even the long siege of Acre. But there's one siege that often gets overlooked, and it tells us a lot about how Saladin's campaign actually unfolded on the ground. I'm talking about the siege of Montreal in 1189. Luna: Montreal? That's the Crusader castle in the desert, right? Shawbak? Lucas: Exactly. Shawbak in Arabic—though the Crusaders called it Montreal, or sometimes 'Mons Regalis,' the Royal Mountain. It was built in 1115 by Baldwin I of Jerusalem, way out east of the Jordan River. And it was a linchpin of Crusader control over the region they called Oultrejordain—literally 'beyond the Jordan.' This was the frontier. Lucas: Now, by 1189, Saladin had already smashed the Crusader army at Hattin in 1187 and taken Jerusalem. But he hadn't captured every castle. Some held out. And Montreal was one of the toughest nuts to crack. Luna: Why was it so important? I mean, it's out in the middle of nowhere. Lucas: That's exactly why it mattered. Montreal controlled the trade routes from Syria to Arabia and Egypt. It sat on a hill overlooking the caravan routes. Whoever held Montreal could tax or block the movement of goods—and more importantly, troops. For Saladin, leaving a Crusader fortress in that strategic spot was like having a splinter in his supply lines. Lucas: And there was a personal angle too. The lord of Montreal was Raynald de Châtillon—the same guy who had raided Muslim caravans and even threatened Mecca. He was captured at Hattin and executed by Saladin himself. But his wife, Stephanie de Milly, was still holed up in Montreal with a garrison. Luna: So she was the one leading the defense? Lucas: In a sense, yes. She was the lady of the castle, and she had her son Humphrey with her. When Saladin offered terms—surrender and they could leave safely—she refused. She had heard what happened to other garrisons that surrendered, and she was determined to hold out. So Saladin left a force to besiege the castle, commanded by his brother al-Malik al-Adil. Lucas: Al-Adil was one of Saladin's most trusted commanders. He knew the terrain well, and he settled in for a long siege. But Montreal was a formidable fortress. It was built on a plateau with steep cliffs on three sides, and it had its own water supply from cisterns. The Crusaders had also stored up provisions. Luna: How long did it take to starve them out? Lucas: Almost two years. The siege began in late 1188 or early 1189—sources differ a bit—and it didn't end until early 1191. That's a long time for a medieval siege. The garrison was eventually reduced to desperate measures. According to Baha al-Din ibn Shaddad, who was with Saladin, the defenders started selling their own children for food. Luna: That's horrific. Lucas: It is. And it's a sign of how complete the blockade was. Al-Adil had built a wall around the castle to prevent any relief force from getting in. He also dug trenches to cut off access to water sources. The garrison was completely isolated. Lucas: But what's interesting is that Saladin himself wasn't there for most of it. He was busy with the siege of Acre, which was the main event of the Third Crusade. So Montreal was a side show, but a crucial one. If it fell, it would free up troops and resources for Acre. Luna: So how did it finally end? Lucas: In the spring of 1191, after nearly two years, the garrison finally surrendered. Al-Adil offered generous terms—the defenders could leave with their lives and some possessions. Stephanie de Milly and her son Humphrey were allowed to go to Antioch. It was a relatively bloodless end, which was typical of Saladin's sieges when the defenders surrendered. Lucas: But here's a detail I love: after the surrender, al-Adil discovered that the castle had a secret tunnel leading to a spring outside the walls. The defenders had been sneaking out for water, which is why they held out so long. That tunnel was the reason they lasted two years. Luna: So if al-Adil had known about that tunnel, he could have cut it off and ended the siege much sooner. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the kind of thing that makes these stories so compelling. Medieval sieges were as much about intelligence and logistics as they were about brute force. The fall of Montreal was a slow, grinding process, but it was also a testament to the determination of both sides. Lucas: The castle itself was then held by the Ayyubids for decades, and it eventually fell into ruin. But its story is a reminder that Saladin's conquest wasn't just about the famous battles—it was about methodically taking every stronghold until the Crusaders had no foothold left. Luna: It's amazing how these smaller sieges are sometimes the most revealing. Lucas: Absolutely. And speaking of revealing, I want to be honest with you about something. Making these deep-dive episodes—especially on the lesser-known sieges—takes a lot of time and research. And we're able to do it because of a small group of listeners who chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what funds this many episodes. Luna: Yeah, and it's nice that we don't have ads. It's just us talking about history. Lucas: Exactly. So if you've been enjoying these conversations and want to help keep them ad-free, you know where to find us. Anyway, back to the desert—after Montreal fell, Saladin turned his attention fully to Acre. And that's a whole other story. Luna: Before we get to Acre, I want to ask about the garrison. What happened to them after they surrendered? Lucas: Most of them were allowed to go to Christian-held territory. Stephanie and her son Humphrey ended up in Antioch. But the rank and file soldiers were probably absorbed into the local population or eventually went back to Europe. It wasn't a massacre—Saladin usually kept his word when terms were agreed. Lucas: One thing I find poignant is that Imad al-Din al-Isfahani, Saladin's secretary, wrote about the siege. He described the castle as 'a nest of vipers' that was finally cleansed. That's the rhetoric of the time—but the reality was more mundane. Just a lot of waiting, hunger, and eventually negotiation. Luna: I've seen pictures of the ruins. It's still impressive, even now. Lucas: Oh, absolutely. You can still visit Shawbak in Jordan. The walls are crumbling, but you can see the scale of it. It's a UNESCO World Heritage site now. Standing there, you can imagine the Crusaders looking out over the desert, waiting for help that never came. Lucas: And that's the thing about these castles—they're physical reminders of a conflict that shaped the region for centuries. The siege of Montreal wasn't the biggest battle, but it was a key moment in the Crusader collapse in the east. Without it, Saladin couldn't have secured his rear while he fought Richard the Lionheart. Luna: So it was a necessary step before the final showdown at Acre. Lucas: Exactly. And it shows that Saladin's strategy wasn't just about winning battles—it was about systematically dismantling the Crusader state, castle by castle. Montreal was one of the last to fall, and when it did, the Crusader dream of holding the Transjordan was over. Lucas: There's a lesson there about persistence and logistics. Siege warfare is slow, ugly, and often forgotten in popular history. But it was the bread and butter of medieval conflict. And Montreal is a perfect case study. Luna: I'm glad we covered it. It adds a whole new layer to the Saladin story.