Latest / Politics with Paul / How to Find Common Ground in Politics w/ Nathan Smolensky | Politics with Paul #61
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics With Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05politics and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08We've got another guest on the show, as you can see.
- 0:11And when I have guests on the show, I always give disclaimer that I do not take a stance for
- 0:15or against the guest political views or groups they support, but the nature of today's topic
- 0:20makes that a nonissue.
- 0:21And that's how to find common ground in politics.
- 0:25Conflict is, unfortunately, what sells in politics and media in general.
- 0:30The more divisive, loud, and obnoxious you are, the more engagement you get.
- 0:35With all the bickering and fighting we do, it can seem like an endless cycle of strife and
- 0:39can feel suffocating, like there's no way around it, like we just can't find common
- 0:44ground.
- 0:45But we can find common ground.
- 0:47We have more shared values than we realize.
- 0:50I believe that, and so does my guest, Nathan Smolensky.
- 0:54Nathan has a fairly eclectic professional background, including writing and editing
- 0:58marketing copy, overseeing databases, leading nonprofit boards, and even chess instruction.
- 1:04In the political realm, he used to be the state director for the Florida Forward Party.
- 1:08And just recently, he became the self published author of the book titled Common Ground from
- 1:13the Ground Up, How Rethinking Politics Can Help Us Feel Heard, Heal Relationships, and Fix Our
- 1:18Democracy.
- 1:18Right there is the book.
- 1:20So let's get into this book and some actionable tips he has for how we can all do better in
- 1:25finding common ground and fixing our broken dialogue.
- 1:30Please welcome Nathan Smolensky to the show.
- 1:33Nathan, thanks for joining me today.
- 1:34How are you?
- 1:36Thank you for having me.
- 1:37I'm doing great.
- 1:39Fantastic.
- 1:39Yeah.
- 1:40I really appreciate you coming on.
- 1:42So let's go ahead and get right into it.
- 1:44So I noted in the intro that a lot of your background actually isn't in the political
- 1:48realm.
- 1:48You have some experience, of course.
- 1:50Most of my guests are typically more ingrained in politics in some way.
- 1:54So what brought you into the political arena?
- 1:58So there's
- 2:00a few elements to that.
- 2:01Some of, you know, what may be seen as, oh, I'm doing a lot of non politics.
- 2:09It's because within the independent space in particular, opportunities are a little more
- 2:14limited.
- 2:15And if I'm doing something as a volunteer or in volunteer capacity, I like to say I was usually
- 2:22sun lighting during those times as something else.
- 2:26And my professional background, my education is in marketing, messaging and communications.
- 2:35This was not always something that I was able to apply to politics or had the opportunity to
- 2:41apply to politics.
- 2:42And over time I came to realize how much I was missing out because I do and I think quite a
- 2:49lot of people do seek out that sense of purpose, sense of doing something positive with
- 2:55their skills, doing something positive with their life, and that sense of I can contribute
- 3:03something within the political arena is something that I came to adopt a little more
- 3:08after 2016.
- 3:10Not that my foray was a reaction against Trump necessarily in his first election, but that
- 3:18that moment of, hey, this sort of style of politics that I had some concerns about that
- 3:27seemed to be working better and better and that people around me were kind of underestimating,
- 3:33that was a point of validation.
- 3:35And I was saying, alright.
- 3:37This is getting more and more divided, and there's a need for a counterbalance for
- 3:44something more unifying within our political realm.
- 3:48And it has continued to be somewhat divisive since then.
- 3:55I don't know if you've noticed that.
- 3:56But Yeah.
- 3:59Yeah.
- 3:59It's been a little while, and I've been fortunate enough to be able to dedicate more
- 4:04and more of my time and my energy to politics.
- 4:08Obviously, when it comes to education in particular, when it comes to promoting chess,
- 4:14this is something that I'm also close to and still very much passionate about, but that is
- 4:19just one issue that I care about.
- 4:23And one of the things I touch on in the book is whatever issue it is that's important to you,
- 4:29having a functional conversation, having a healthy discourse allows you to share your
- 4:35voice, share your thoughts on that issue much more effectively.
- 4:39So some of the work I do is ultimately in service of, well, I I wanna be part of the
- 4:45conversation too, and I know so many people who want to be part of that healthy conversation
- 4:50and share their voices.
- 4:51So there's a little of that in there as well.
- 4:55Yeah.
- 4:55Obviously, the whole fostering dialogue, that's a big part of the book, and we're, of course,
- 5:00gonna go into that.
- 5:01But that that's that's one of the big things for me too is just I had to learn a lot of
- 5:05those skills throughout college and even since then and trying to refine it over time.
- 5:09And and sometimes it could seem easier or you can it can seem like you know how to have a
- 5:15conversation with people, but you really figure out, oh, actually, I didn't really know as much
- 5:20as I thought to.
- 5:20And to the point that you had at the beginning about, you know, it's seeming like there's not
- 5:24a whole lot of nonpartisan avenues.
- 5:27I I've I've felt that way a lot too, and that's probably kind of why I've just tried to forge
- 5:32my own path here is just try to create something fairly new.
- 5:36And, yeah, it it could feel like there's just you you either gotta pick a side or you just
- 5:41gotta stay out of it.
- 5:42A lot of people unfortunately do stay out of it.
- 5:45But Yeah.
- 5:47We're hopefully gonna be fixing that soon.
- 5:49Sorry.
- 5:49Go ahead.
- 5:50No.
- 5:50No.
- 5:51No.
- 5:51No.
- 5:51No.
- 5:51Just echoing that.
- 5:53So
- 5:54Yeah.
- 5:55So let's get a little bit more into that political foray for you, the more concrete
- 6:01foray you had.
- 6:01So like I said, in the intro, you were recently the director of the Florida Forward Party for
- 6:07three years.
- 6:08And, of course, talked about it before the show.
- 6:11Always appreciate meeting another either fellow Floridian or somebody who spent a lot of time
- 6:14in Florida through the civics work of mine.
- 6:17How how were you involved in the formation of that party, or were you involved in that
- 6:21formation that party?
- 6:22And and and for people who don't know what the forward party's about, can you tell people what
- 6:27exactly it is, and why did you feel the work of the Florida party forward party was necessary?
- 6:33So the forward party comes.
- 6:36The original forward party, which I did join shortly after its founding in 2021, was started
- 6:42by Andrew Yang, and it was taking a non duopoly approach to politics.
- 6:51It's trying to create a viable alternative to the two major parties.
- 6:56And there were two other organizations that had merged with with very similar goals in mind.
- 7:01Andrew Yang's organization had a little more of a progressive or a Democrat leading background.
- 7:08The Renew America movement was a lot of conservatives who were not happy with Trump.
- 7:14And then the Serve America movement is your standard, what you might think of a little more
- 7:20as centrist, and they were a little more of a lobbying group.
- 7:27And the three of them combined formed the forward party.
- 7:31The Florida chapter became one of the first official parties within the network by virtue
- 7:37of Florida's laws around party creation, which were a little more welcoming and didn't have
- 7:44quite the gaps, the weights that other states have.
- 7:50So I was involved from a technical point with the creation of the Florida Forward Party as
- 7:58its state director and that was founded in 2023.
- 8:03So it is a legal party that you can now join.
- 8:06As far as its work of being a vehicle for non duopoly candidates to credibly challenge those
- 8:18in office and to credibly in some cases, these are incumbents in nonpartisan positions who are
- 8:26being challenged by more partisan, more divisive voices.
- 8:32There were definitely some limitations to what the forward party was well positioned to do.
- 8:40But and this is something that I talk about quite a bit in the book.
- 8:44I do think that forging a better politics goes hand in hand with empowering new voices within
- 8:52our political arena.
- 8:54If you have two parties, no other options, zero sum, it lends itself a lot, and it creates
- 9:00these incentives of very negative politicking, very divisive politicking.
- 9:05And that's something that Forward and other organizations can play a role in working
- 9:11against.
- 9:13I always try to not give any opinions one way or another about about particular groups.
- 9:19But I think I could still say even without doing that that having more choices is usually,
- 9:25it's better to have more choices than fewer.
- 9:28And but it is interesting.
- 9:30You kinda lampshade it a little bit.
- 9:32But for for those at home, the state of Florida actually has it's actually much easier to make
- 9:39a third party than for a lot of other states.
- 9:41You have what are called ballot qualified parties where they have to reach some sort of
- 9:45criteria where they can actually run candidates under their banner, and Florida's actually a
- 9:49lot easier to to do that.
- 9:52For so, actually, I'll I'll then ask you.
- 9:55So did the Ford party were they able to actually field any particular candidates, or is
- 10:00it more just a general movement to just bring people under the umbrella, kinda build it up
- 10:04first, and then maybe put somebody out later on?
- 10:08There was some difficulty around that.
- 10:13So what we were able to do is endorse candidates.
- 10:16We could not effectively field candidates in partisan races because while you can found the
- 10:23party very quickly, what Florida makes it very difficult to do is to run under a different
- 10:29party or to change your party.
- 10:31Florida has a red shirt year for politicians who change parties.
- 10:35If you change your party, it has to be a full calendar year before the start of the
- 10:40qualifying cycle for the election.
- 10:43So by the time the party was founded in April 2023, that's already too late for any federal
- 10:49candidate to come and join the party and run-in the next year.
- 10:54Not that we were super well positioned by that point to field a credible federal candidate,
- 11:01but what we ended up doing is endorsing independents, endorsing some libertarians,
- 11:07endorsing Republicans, Democrats, and just anyone who we felt was aligned with a better
- 11:15kind of politics as we saw them.
- 11:17Actually, forgot about the fact that you need to sit out a calendar year Yes.
- 11:21Here here in Florida.
- 11:22So thank you for the refresher on it.
- 11:24I I was I was still thinking about the whole, you know, voters who changed their party.
- 11:29They have to do it twenty nine days before an election.
- 11:31But, yeah, it's it's that you kind of also I have a a book I self published a few years ago
- 11:39too about independence and why they have so much difficulty.
- 11:42And that a lot of that is a whole ballot access issue that you you lampshaded, and it's just
- 11:48it's it's very onerous to run a third party or independent campaign.
- 11:53You just you just showed you've just a few reasons why that is.
- 11:57So let's move to the book now.
- 11:59Sure.
- 12:00So what compelled you to write this book?
- 12:03Was it those experiences with the Florida Forward Party?
- 12:06Was it just the general state of political discussion in America?
- 12:09Have you wanted to write this for a long time?
- 12:10What ultimately spawned this book?
- 12:12Well, I think those experiences definitely spurred it on.
- 12:16And there was a point of inspiration in particular that I'll call out in so far as I
- 12:24realized that the appeals to the language that we were using, it was still falling even though
- 12:29it's all about unifying.
- 12:32It's all about this new kind of politics.
- 12:36It's all about this different way of thinking about politics, but the language, the style of
- 12:41our rhetoric was very much in line with political rhetoric these days.
- 12:46Not that it was inflammatory, but that it was geared towards the choir.
- 12:52It was built to energize rather than to reach out, rather than to persuade.
- 12:58And where that left us is in our own little bubble.
- 13:02And you may have experienced this, and I think some listeners who've been in the independent
- 13:07space or the bridging space may have experienced this, that you get this sort of
- 13:12niche political experience where you feel that's a bubble too.
- 13:18And this is all the people who care about the duopoly and depolarization, and these words
- 13:24mean nothing to a great many Americans, and that is the reality.
- 13:30And what I realized within that, you know, more so than, okay.
- 13:36Well, we have to change that wording and change that appeal.
- 13:40It was the problem that or the idea that this was a shared experience among all from the
- 13:48political spectrum that we all get stuck inside our bubble because of the way we're used to
- 13:53approaching talking about politics, because of the way we're used to interacting with each
- 13:58other.
- 13:58This is what works.
- 14:01To your point, I think in the intro, where politicians rile up instead of reach out
- 14:08because they know that's Yep.
- 14:11What actually gets people to turn out.
- 14:13It's what gets those donors donating.
- 14:14It's what gets those volunteers signing up.
- 14:17And they're not gonna have the channels to persuade anyone because the other side isn't
- 14:24listening.
- 14:24And so it works for them.
- 14:26And then for media, again, the other side isn't listening.
- 14:31So they gotta rile up.
- 14:32They gotta create more urgency, more emergency, and just more emotion.
- 14:39So it's all about energizing their base rather than making any more general appeals.
- 14:46And the problem is when we emulate that, when we talk about politics the way we're used to
- 14:51hearing about politics, it confines us into our bubble.
- 14:55It makes it so much harder for us to reach out and for us to effectively communicate with
- 15:01different people.
- 15:01And so this was an avenue that I saw to make the appeal to a more common ground approach, to
- 15:09make the appeal to a more collaborative and a more constructive approach to dialogue because
- 15:18it was not about the moral case for that.
- 15:24It's not about let's be civil.
- 15:25Let's be nice to each other.
- 15:28It's about realizing that people are being held back by the way that they talk about politics
- 15:34and the way that they think about politics and the way that they imagine politics.
- 15:38And there is benefit to all of us in in just taking this more common ground approach.
- 15:47Yeah.
- 15:47The that's something I've been trying to work on formulating in my head too is how to show
- 15:54people that this being willing to the spirit of compromise.
- 15:58You don't necessarily need to actually compromise, but just the very spirit of
- 16:01compromise actually listening to people.
- 16:03It does benefit you.
- 16:04Problem is a lot of people if they think it doesn't benefit them, and that's you have to
- 16:08find some way to actually make them realize no, this is actually is good for everybody.
- 16:13The way we're doing it right now is is ultimately not going to help you in the long
- 16:18run.
- 16:18But obviously, it's hard to do that with people who are very narrow minded have their specific
- 16:26like note.
- 16:27This is the way things have to be.
- 16:28I have to fight the good fight and you touched on it with the the echo chambers, our own
- 16:36bubbles is just this.
- 16:38There's a some sort of irony in the fact that we become more connected than ever before with
- 16:44the Internet and with how quickly we can reach each other that yet we're in some ways more
- 16:52divided than ever.
- 16:53We it's easier than ever to just find our groups and just stay in them.
- 16:57And, obviously, those are very unfortunate things that you and I are both working to to
- 17:02fix.
- 17:03So let's dive more into the book then, which you can buy on now, and I'll have links in the
- 17:09show notes for this that you can buy Amazon or buy the book on Amazon an ebook, paperback, and
- 17:15hardback or hardcover format and get so let's get more into its actual insights.
- 17:22One of the big issues confronting constructive discussions is and just talked about a little
- 17:27bit a moment ago is that some people just don't have any interest in them.
- 17:31So how can we make civility or constructive dialogue appealing to those who don't actively
- 17:36seek it out?
- 17:39That I saw as one of the the sort of critical drivers of this book and one of the ways that I
- 17:46hope to distinguish it and go beyond what traditional bridging approaches or calls for
- 17:57civility have been able to do, which is that this is not a call for civility for the sake of
- 18:01civility.
- 18:04This is not saying, hey.
- 18:07Let's not fight about this.
- 18:09It's not worth fighting about this when it comes to political issues.
- 18:13Because I think, to your point, that is a really hard case to make, and I wouldn't agree
- 18:20with that.
- 18:21I see the stakes are huge.
- 18:23Like, they're legitimately, you know, really critical political problems that would be worth
- 18:31fighting over if the fighting accomplished anything.
- 18:35But that's the thing, is making the case that this civil discourse, this healthy conversation
- 18:44as a means to getting your voice heard, as a means to working toward a problem solving
- 18:50approach and working together towards a problem solving approach is much more effective at
- 18:56approaching these issues, at dealing with these issues than any kind of fighting, yelling,
- 19:01whatever it is that may be justified in and of itself.
- 19:06That stuff doesn't work.
- 19:08And that is, I think, the critical case for civility and the critical case for constructive
- 19:13dialogue that needs to be made is, look, if you want to make your voice heard, if you want to
- 19:18make an impact on the issues, if you want to persuade others and encourage them to consider
- 19:25the points that you have to share, this is the best way to do that.
- 19:31And that's been by and large the approach with the book.
- 19:38Yeah.
- 19:39The you make a great point.
- 19:41These are very critical issues.
- 19:43And I think sometimes and and I'm gonna include myself in this too because, obviously, there's
- 19:48always ways that every one of us can improve is just this whole when we try to tell people to
- 19:54be civil, it's like, it doesn't mean you can't fight over.
- 19:57And because of how critical these issues are, sometimes we make it a more of an existential
- 20:02crisis than it actually is.
- 20:03But because these issues are so important, we can't we don't or we shouldn't expect people to
- 20:10not fight about them, but it's to the point.
- 20:13Obviously, people just take it over war as no.
- 20:16We can fight about this, but we need to still be willing to hear each other out about this,
- 20:21make sure that we at least gives other people a chance because we don't have all the answers.
- 20:26But you're never gonna I mean, I have things that I feel strongly about too.
- 20:32We're we're not going to be able to just sit there and not say anything about them.
- 20:37And some people make a try to make a clear distinction between civility and politeness.
- 20:44Not really.
- 20:45The politeness part I mean, every one of us falls into the we're being impolite towards
- 20:50other people at some point.
- 20:52But civility is about you can you can disagree sometimes vehemently, but you have to be
- 21:00willing to hear other people out and at least try to see their point of view.
- 21:04And that's that's one of the big things I think sometimes our movement doesn't quite make clear
- 21:10is no.
- 21:10You can fight for what you believe in, but there has to be a point where you scale it back
- 21:16and are not willing to, for example, inflict political violence on people or physical
- 21:21violence on people because of politics.
- 21:24Well So
- 21:25Yeah.
- 21:26And I I think the more critical point to make is that stuff doesn't work, ultimately.
- 21:30It doesn't lead us anywhere positive.
- 21:33It doesn't lead those people inflicting the violence any closer to their real goal or the
- 21:40things they actually care about.
- 21:42It is perpetuating the conflict.
- 21:45And oftentimes, it undermines your cause, undermines your side, and plays into this game
- 21:53of optics that can be very much unfavorable while also perpetuating the conflict ad
- 22:00infinitum.
- 22:02And, yeah, the common ground, I think you touched on it there as far as, no, we need to
- 22:08be able to disagree.
- 22:09When I talk about common ground in the book, I'm not talking about things we agree on.
- 22:14I'm talking about us being able to have more of a common language to understand that we have
- 22:21shared goals and shared purpose underlying all our disagreement.
- 22:27It's our disagreement that makes the conversation worthwhile.
- 22:30It's our disagreement that makes it so that we can learn from others, we can gain from others
- 22:35in the conversation, and we can refine our ideas, complement each other's ideas.
- 22:40And this is something that I think is very valuable to explore that two perspectives on a
- 22:47given issue don't need to be in conflict with one another.
- 22:52They both inform the problem.
- 22:53If you take a look at, for example look.
- 22:56There is an economic issue, and you're seeing way too much power in the hands of
- 23:01corporations.
- 23:02To say that corporations given too much power can use that power, can abuse that power at the
- 23:08detriment of the common people, at the detriment of society, at the detriment of free
- 23:14enterprise.
- 23:14Yeah.
- 23:15That's true.
- 23:17And to say that government regulation and over regulation can ultimately come in excess and
- 23:26lead to the detriment of the free enterprise, healthy economies, you know, the consumer.
- 23:34That's true too.
- 23:35All of that informs the solution.
- 23:37All of that adds to us being able to solve the problem and to understand the complexities of
- 23:42the problem.
- 23:43But it's because these issues are so deeply complex and because we need to account for all
- 23:49these different perspectives, this is why we gain from each other.
- 23:54This is why we gain from the conversation itself.
- 23:58And to your point, you know, that sense of, well, we have to listen to others, It should
- 24:06not come, and I think it cannot sustainably come out of a sense of moral obligation.
- 24:12Instead, what I encourage readers to realize within the book, it's a golden rule
- 24:19application, which is if you want people to open their minds to what it is you have to say,
- 24:26the most effective thing you can do is to open your mind to what it is they have to say.
- 24:32And starting by listening, starting by giving them space to share their ideas, and having
- 24:39that curiosity, realizing that you can gain from learning and hearing those, that leads you
- 24:46much more often than people will expect, much more often than people might expect to a
- 24:52situation where suddenly things sort of quiet down, calm down, and the person who might be
- 24:58ranting at the start will turn to you and say, well, what do you think?
- 25:05And that's where you can have this ground for healthier conversation and more productive
- 25:11conversation.
- 25:13Yeah.
- 25:14Yeah.
- 25:14I definitely can't argue with any of that.
- 25:17I think it goes back to that the whole this is a big thing with me, and I try to practice what
- 25:24I preach as much as possible.
- 25:25It's just this level of self awareness that people need to have about themselves.
- 25:29A lot of times they think, boy, that other side is so uncompromising.
- 25:33They don't listen to me and I just there's just so bigoted in but but like, okay, but are you
- 25:38doing the same thing?
- 25:39Because a lot of times you are, but sometimes it's hard to get people to realize that.
- 25:44Or even if they do realize that they're still gonna dig in and be like, nope.
- 25:47Nope.
- 25:47I've got it all figured out.
- 25:48And then, obviously, that just that keeps us from going anywhere.
- 25:52But
- 25:53Yeah.
- 25:53And Oh, you go ahead.
- 25:55There's so much, like, just to hop on that briefly.
- 26:00There is so much of they started it, you know, they're just as bad or Yeah.
- 26:06They're not being civil.
- 26:08They're worse.
- 26:08Sure.
- 26:11And you can justify all this.
- 26:13You're not gonna really argue with the justification, and I don't bother arguing with
- 26:17the justification.
- 26:18You may be justified in a more hostile approach.
- 26:21That doesn't mean it works.
- 26:23That doesn't mean it's effective.
- 26:25And that is what I'm more focused on with the book is finding that more effective pathway.
- 26:33Got it.
- 26:34That makes sense.
- 26:35So let's get a little bit more into this actually interacting with people.
- 26:41Is in your view, is it really possible to have a civil conversation with anyone?
- 26:46And where and how does one draw that line?
- 26:50Short answer is no.
- 26:53In the short term, certainly, place matters a lot.
- 26:58All of these tools for healthier conversation are a little more focused on interpersonal in
- 27:08person conversations with people we know somewhat.
- 27:14And so this is how and this is where it really starts, I think, for most people, is talking to
- 27:20friends, talking to relatives that you have differences with.
- 27:25On social media, this doesn't work because there's that impersonality, and people are just
- 27:32there for brief times.
- 27:33You don't know you don't know who's real to start, and you don't know why they're there.
- 27:41So Most
- 27:41of them being keyboard warriors anyways.
- 27:43Keyboard warriors, it's just it's very hard to have that kind of empathy and human connection
- 27:52underlying those conversations.
- 27:53You can do it to a degree, but it's just going to be a lot harder there.
- 27:59As far as in person, look, there are going to be people where it's going to take some time.
- 28:08And some people may struggle to learn.
- 28:11Now, one of the techniques, one of the the cool approaches that I share within the book is you
- 28:17can kind of take the approach that I take, you know, to the reader, which is I want to give
- 28:25you two tools for persuasion.
- 28:29I want to help you reach other people.
- 28:31And so you can apply that to the conversations you have insofar as if you're hearing something
- 28:38that is really dissonant, is way out there, rather than try to attack, well, that's wrong,
- 28:46you can make the appeal that whoever is espousing those ideas is gonna have a harder
- 28:52time reaching the audience they want to reach.
- 28:55And when you have that handout of, look, I want to share this power of persuasion with you.
- 29:01I want you to be able to engage in conversation and share your ideas more effectively.
- 29:06Suddenly, you can get a conversation to take on a much less hostile tone, to be more
- 29:12collaborative.
- 29:13You want to learn from each other.
- 29:15And half the book is about mindset.
- 29:17Half the book is about creating that initial motivation because it has to be authentic.
- 29:24All that said, look, there are gonna be people who are reticent, who may have issues with the
- 29:31trust necessary, who may have issues with their mental health that have been exacerbated by
- 29:37politics.
- 29:38We all know that that is a phenomenon that is, you know, tragically more and more common these
- 29:44days.
- 29:47And you may have issues as well where they're very hot buttons and to be able to talk about
- 29:54them constructively with someone or get someone to accept any kind of conversation or any kind
- 30:02of seemingly critical feedback on their ideas around a given issue will take a lot of time.
- 30:11And, you know, it comes down to how much time you have.
- 30:14But one of the things that I do touch on, if it's not everyone, if it's just a few people in
- 30:21your life that you can mend relationships with, that you can build bridges with through these
- 30:27techniques, that is still a huge change.
- 30:29That is still very much a positive and that can spread.
- 30:32And while it I can't promise you'll reach everyone, you will reach and I think for a lot
- 30:38of the listeners who may be more used to this hyperpolarized idea of the political realm,
- 30:47you'll reach a lot more people than you expect.
- 30:51It's all about those baby steps.
- 30:52Right?
- 30:53And I I could be an impatient person and and wanna
- 30:56For sure.
- 30:56Jump parts of the process and just get to the end.
- 30:58But, I mean, it's it's true.
- 31:00You do have to take a little bit of the the baby steps first to actually get to where we're
- 31:06going.
- 31:06A lot of times this whole talk about building common ground.
- 31:10It can, for lack of a better term, can get very woo woo, very highfalutin idealistic, and a lot
- 31:17of times doesn't really get to the actionable steps, but that's a that's a much more
- 31:22actionable way of looking at things.
- 31:24So I can really appreciate that and try to that's that's the whole thing is not just
- 31:29trying to bridge these knowledge gaps for people with this podcast and with all the other
- 31:32work I do, but give people actionable steps which they can take to actually improve civic
- 31:39and political discourse in their lives and in the lives of people around them.
- 31:43So can definitely appreciate that point of view.
- 31:47So talked about this a little bit ago.
- 31:52One of the first questions or you talked about it in one of your answers to the first
- 31:55questions, and that's constructive dialogue often isn't conducive to winning elections,
- 32:01which is why some candidates avoid it or at least limit healthy discourse.
- 32:06Now when they get into office, maybe they have to be a little bit more compromising or hearing
- 32:12people out than they would like.
- 32:13Although even then, a lot of people don't do that.
- 32:15So how do we make constructive dialogue succeed in elections?
- 32:19What would that take in your view?
- 32:24Well, going back to the initial crux of the problem as I saw it and one of the inspirations
- 32:31for the book is we're used to hearing about politics in this divisive way.
- 32:36We're used to hearing politics talked about in this divisive way because it works for
- 32:41politicians in the short term.
- 32:45The thing is, if you want to change that, you have to really get at the incentives within our
- 32:52political structure.
- 32:53And as much as we may be discouraged by of the division of the rhetoric that we hear from
- 33:03politicians, people tend to have a bit of a defeatist mindset around it.
- 33:09It's like, oh, it just keeps getting worse.
- 33:11It keeps getting worse.
- 33:12There's nothing we can do about it.
- 33:14This creates market opportunities.
- 33:17The approval rates for Congress as a whole, to give an important example, are whatever the
- 33:25opposite of through the roof is.
- 33:28Under the basement
- 33:30Yeah.
- 33:30It's abysmal.
- 33:32Abysmal.
- 33:32Exactly.
- 33:34And within that, there is market opportunity.
- 33:39There is a way to sort of tap into the hunger that people have and frustration people have
- 33:44because all this hyper divisive politics, just like it's it makes it impossible for us to make
- 33:50any progress with each other, it is not conducive to actual problem solving.
- 33:55And there is a huge need for actual problem solving.
- 33:59So one of the big things I call for in the book is ultimately, if you want to see this societal
- 34:05change, the bridging ethos goes hand in hand with empowering new voices within the political
- 34:12arena.
- 34:13I obviously had my experience with FORWARD, and there are some minor party or packs that try to
- 34:21create these vehicles.
- 34:23But the pathway just to independent success in the political arena is much, much clearer,
- 34:32actually, I would say, than people assume it to be.
- 34:36And the big examples that I'd point to, and I encourage Yorkshire Veccht as someone who's
- 34:41been in this independent space or this third party space, Twenty twenty two Utah senatorial
- 34:48election, Evan McMullen ran garnered about forty three, forty four percent of the vote.
- 34:54That would be insane for a third party.
- 34:56He wasn't a third party.
- 34:57Independents were a second party.
- 34:59It was a some all alternative in a very red state where he created a viable alternative
- 35:09sorry.
- 35:09I'm restating myself to the incumbent power.
- 35:142024, Dan Osborne running in Nebraska.
- 35:1847 to 48% of the popular vote running against a lone Republican.
- 35:24What I said in Florida when people would have their doubts about forward trying to do
- 35:32whatever it was doing, you know, does Florida really need a third party?
- 35:36No.
- 35:37Florida needs a second party.
- 35:38A lot of places need a second party.
- 35:41And this pathway created in some part by our natural division and created in some part by
- 35:48gerrymandering that's exacerbated it in a lot of congressional districts and a lot of things
- 35:54at lower levels, at state and municipal levels.
- 35:58Well, guess more state levels.
- 36:01But all of these things create a pathway to independence challenging major party
- 36:10incumbents.
- 36:12And what that ultimately leads to, if you have a positive ethos that is shining through even
- 36:19just a few successful independent efforts, suddenly you can change the complexion of the
- 36:27system.
- 36:27Suddenly you can go from a zero sum perpetual tug of war to a fulcrum of a small base enough
- 36:34to deny either party a majority within a given legislative body.
- 36:39The US Congress being, of course, the holy grail of that.
- 36:44And within that kind of structure, the incentives do fundamentally change.
- 36:49You cannot continue to just cater to this divisive negative politicking when there's
- 36:59another alternative in play.
- 37:01If you were trying to say the Democrats being in power is your main calling card, Trump being
- 37:09in power and MAGA being in power is your main appeal to voters, suddenly there's an
- 37:15alternative.
- 37:16Suddenly, doesn't work as well.
- 37:18And suddenly, instead of just strong arming when we have power and trying to perpetuate the
- 37:23conflict, we are forced into a position where we have to work together to actually solve
- 37:29problems.
- 37:30And we find ourselves and this is not to destroy the parties.
- 37:33This is to liberate the parties from these current incentives because those perspectives,
- 37:40those liberal and conservative perspectives are so valuable to the actual problem solving.
- 37:45And that conversation, that additive conversation where we're working together to
- 37:49solve the problem can start to happen as you can break through and shift those incentives.
- 37:56And I think the best pathway there is with candidates who exemplify that ethos.
- 38:03The one thing I'll also add to that, that ethos of a better politics is not in itself a
- 38:15worthwhile appeal to voters.
- 38:18Ultimately, you have to make the case that doing politics better, talking about politics
- 38:24more constructively leads to better solutions.
- 38:26And it's those solutions that are going to be the calling card of successful campaigns.
- 38:31It's the way you think about issues because you never want to put people in a position.
- 38:35I mean, this is the failure, I think, of civility efforts in the past.
- 38:41You don't want to put civility against the issues.
- 38:44You don't want to depend on people caring more about the politician being nice than the
- 38:51politician's stance on abortion, immigration, various wars, this or that, the economy.
- 38:59You have to show that your manner of doing politics leads you to better ideas, to better
- 39:06solutions on those big issues that matter to people.
- 39:10And that's where I see the real heart of the opportunity for new voices to arise and break
- 39:18through the division and shift our incentives.
- 39:21Sorry.
- 39:21That was quite long.
- 39:22No.
- 39:22No.
- 39:23You're good.
- 39:23Yeah.
- 39:23Whatever you need to to answer the question.
- 39:26I I will say you you kinda I guess you kind of answered this question already because I I I
- 39:32was just thinking about it towards the beginning of that answer because you brought up
- 39:35congress and its abysmal rating.
- 39:38That kind of goes back to what we call Fenno's paradox.
- 39:41For people at home who don't know, Fenno's paradox is people hate congress but love their
- 39:46congressperson, basically.
- 39:47People think that their congressperson is not the reason that congress sucks.
- 39:51So they keep reelecting them at astronomically high rates despite the fact everybody hates
- 39:56congress.
- 39:57So for you, Nathan, how I I guess that answer kind of already got to it, but I'll I'll ask it
- 40:04anyways.
- 40:06How do we use this whole common ground constructive dialogue framework to break that
- 40:13kind of Fennows paradox where even though people hate congress and wanna see it changed,
- 40:17but they still reelect their congressperson.
- 40:20So how how do we use this constructive dialogue framework to try to fix that for lack of a
- 40:28better term?
- 40:28I don't know.
- 40:29And you can correct me on this.
- 40:30I don't know if they necessarily love their congressperson in very large numbers so much as
- 40:40the appeal of the other side winning.
- 40:43First of all, there's not really a viable alternative.
- 40:46And that appeal of, hey.
- 40:48At least the Democrats aren't in charge or, hey.
- 40:50At least the Republicans aren't in charge is very powerful.
- 40:53It's very effective.
- 40:54There is that too.
- 40:55Yeah.
- 40:57Again, empowering independent voices, just these positive alternatives goes a huge, huge
- 41:03way.
- 41:04And you don't need all of them.
- 41:06Once again, you can have a lot of popular incumbents who aren't getting challenged, and
- 41:12it's still fine if you can break through and build that fulcrum of just a handful of
- 41:19independents or independent minded politicians, at least constructive dialogue minded
- 41:25politicians, although it's harder within the incentives of the party structure.
- 41:31You can put them in positions to succeed, That is enough to fundamentally change the
- 41:37incentives and change the political game as it were.
- 41:41So it it doesn't have to be about challenging everyone, but I do think a part of the appeal
- 41:50of creating a viable independent pathway and showing people, hey, this can work, is having a
- 42:00mechanism of of real competition in more areas than we have it now.
- 42:06Gotcha.
- 42:07Yeah.
- 42:08And that kind of goes back to some some of the independents strategists thinking about, well,
- 42:14who do you run where do you run independents?
- 42:15Do you run at a place where there there is really only one party and try to challenge them
- 42:20and bring independence and the minority party in, or do you do it in a place where there's
- 42:25two parties that are competing strongly against each other?
- 42:29And, I mean, that's that's a bit of an old another a whole other can of worms.
- 42:32But but if you've got something to add, though, you can.
- 42:36I mean, yeah.
- 42:37I mean, I I think my point has been I'm certainly on the former side as far as at least
- 42:43short to medium term viability is you want to create voter choice.
- 42:48You want to create competition in a lot of areas that are lacking for competition.
- 42:53I go back to the sort of the defeatist view we have of politics as a whole and the divisive
- 42:59nature of it.
- 43:01And what you can realize is there's market opportunity there.
- 43:05There's market opportunity for credible alternatives for actual problem solving.
- 43:13And as I've analyzed the problem and as I've worked with candidates in the past and seen
- 43:20successes and failures, that seems to me like the most viable path.
- 43:26But but, yeah, obviously, it's a it's an old question.
- 43:30And, you know, just like anything else, a variety of ideas and approaches and
- 43:35perspectives is valuable to finding the best answer.
- 43:39Right.
- 43:41So I've I probably should have actually asked this towards the beginning.
- 43:44Probably would would have made more sense to it, but it's okay.
- 43:47We're here now.
- 43:48So I've had guests in the past that have and either whether I've asked them directly or
- 43:53they've just brought it up, they've proposed different points in the past as to when our
- 43:58fracturing started.
- 43:59And I have my own opinions about about that too.
- 44:02But where do you believe it began?
- 44:04And are there encouraging signs to you as to how this fracturing can be fixed?
- 44:09Or I should say, what are the encouraging signs that you've seen?
- 44:13As far as where it started, people have a tendency to frame it as who started it, which I
- 44:22think compounds the problem Mhmm.
- 44:25Because we play this blame game.
- 44:27Wherever it started and it's a little blurry, the fact is it kept going and it kept growing
- 44:34because it works.
- 44:35So you can go back.
- 44:37In the nineteen fifties, there was some sort of oh god.
- 44:42I forget the name of the group, but there was actually a study done that said our parties are
- 44:48way too close together.
- 44:50American
- 44:50Political Science Association.
- 44:52That's what it was.
- 44:53Yes.
- 44:54Mhmm.
- 44:54They were more responsible two party system Yes.
- 44:58Was the name of the report.
- 45:00Yes.
- 45:00The more responsible two party system is, you know, hey.
- 45:04Let let's divide the parties more clearly.
- 45:07So that started over decades, and you saw a little you know, in the Reagan era, you saw a
- 45:14little more lean towards the jabs at each other and the jabs at the opposite party, and it's
- 45:21still playful.
- 45:22It's still you know, we're you know, at the end of the day, we're all friends, and that was
- 45:27understood.
- 45:29Gingrich and the Republican revolution in '94, that is a big not a turning point, an
- 45:36acceleration point.
- 45:39And I think it's very fair for people to point to that where he identified, look, most of my
- 45:45supporters are listening to me through this burgeoning conservative talk radio.
- 45:50I don't need to play so much to the general audience.
- 45:53I need to play to my base.
- 45:54This is where I can gain the most ground.
- 45:57And lo and behold, Republicans shattered all their fundraising records within that year.
- 46:04And I don't put that much blame on that because by the next cycle, the Democrats had shattered
- 46:10all their fundraising records and were emulating the same strategies.
- 46:14And this works more and more and more as we become more siloed and more fractured by our
- 46:19communications infrastructure, which is not to say that social media was created to divide us.
- 46:26Social media was created as a tool to make money and that people would be interested in,
- 46:31and we are.
- 46:32It's exciting for us.
- 46:34But one of the byproducts of it is it silos us and it creates these little bubbles and it the
- 46:42best way to cater to that kind of communications paradigm is by playing to the
- 46:49bubbles, is by riling up and energizing these rather alienated groups of people rather than
- 46:56reaching out because there's no general audience to speak to.
- 46:59There's nowhere you can speak to the general audience.
- 47:02So as far as where it goes from here, the encouraging sign is there's a lot of fatigue
- 47:10from that.
- 47:11And I think what you see in rising independent registration numbers among the younger
- 47:19generations, a lot of that is a big signifier of people, you know, especially young people
- 47:26being really tired of just the constant partisan tug of war, the constant insanity,
- 47:33which as and this is a perspective that I've been rather blessed to have over my life.
- 47:40If you are a little outside of that, you just see how senseless it is and see how
- 47:45unproductive it is.
- 47:47At the same time while there are those positive signs and positive opportunities, this is a
- 47:56powder keg.
- 47:57And this is a divided environment where inflammatory acts, inflammatory rhetoric can
- 48:05heighten, the tension and can create hot conflict at times that is very dangerous.
- 48:12And that sometimes makes the division at least for bursts, much stronger.
- 48:18So that is, you know, while while we may have positive signs, it doesn't mean we're out of
- 48:25the woods anywhere close to you.
- 48:28Def definitely true.
- 48:29Definitely true.
- 48:29Yeah.
- 48:29That's I I think that's a good point of trying to when you try to pinpoint where this
- 48:34fracturing, this polarization began.
- 48:37I mean, really, American history has kind of had ebbs and flows of that.
- 48:40I mean, civil war, obviously, the the height of it.
- 48:44But, yeah, to your point about yeah.
- 48:47It's it's sometimes that could be unhelpful to be like, well, where did it start?
- 48:51Because then people are trying to pinpoint, oh, it's this specific group.
- 48:54And even if one specific group started it, another group carrying it on and then going
- 48:59back and forth, that doesn't justify it.
- 49:01So but so definitely good points there.
- 49:05So we kinda touched on this a little bit earlier, but I kinda wanted to save it for this
- 49:10part.
- 49:11So morality or at least what we view as moral is is inevitably gonna be part of our political
- 49:16views.
- 49:17We all have very strong opinions about well, or a lot of us have strong opinions about what is
- 49:23just.
- 49:23But oftentimes, it goes too far.
- 49:25And on a couple of previous episodes of the podcast, I talked about how moralized attitudes
- 49:31and people believing they are championing what's just can lead to a stubbornness and
- 49:36anger at others oftentimes very excessively.
- 49:39So how can we take a constructive or collaborative approach to talking about moral
- 49:45issues or at least issues in a moral sense?
- 49:49So it it is a tricky area, and it is naturally something where I will have the most feedback
- 49:59and the most not necessarily doubt, but people have a hard time imagining at times that you
- 50:07can have a a constructive conversation around a topic like whatever gender issues, abortion, a
- 50:18a lot of issues where there's a little more of a a moral undercurrent of the sentiment.
- 50:28And it comes down to a few things.
- 50:31I think, first of all, when you are basing your line of argument on your own morality, and this
- 50:38is that whole riling up over reaching out, this is how it it transpires.
- 50:44This is how it manifests is these moral declaratives as political arguments.
- 50:49If you say something like health care is a human right, life begins at conception, these
- 50:58are not statements that can gain any ground as far as persuasion.
- 51:04They're just moral declarations.
- 51:06All they're really doing, and this is what we've become so used to hearing, they just show
- 51:12what team you're on.
- 51:14And if someone isn't already inclined to agree with your moral underpinning, that's
- 51:20frustrating.
- 51:21That can certainly be frustrating.
- 51:23But just restating your moral assertion tends not to be a very good way to move them.
- 51:32What I talk about within the book is you can kind of step away from your morality and talk
- 51:42about the sort of moral outcry as a practical concern for the society and as a practical
- 51:49consideration for the issue.
- 51:51And so far as, look, if you have a given policy in place on abortion, that is going to create a
- 51:59moral outcry.
- 52:00That is something that not only you, but millions of people are going to say that is
- 52:07objectionable.
- 52:08That is not okay.
- 52:09And what are the outcomes of that?
- 52:10There is going to be a lot of distress, a lot of unrest, and a lot of reaction.
- 52:15And they're going to try to respond in their own way.
- 52:19So having that lens of a stepping outside yourself and talking about morality as a
- 52:26societal consideration.
- 52:30And then b, sort of getting to that policy level rather than the philosophical level of
- 52:37talking about the issues lends itself much more to a constructive conversation, lends itself
- 52:41much more to people realizing, okay, well, if I understand this perspective and I understand
- 52:47this sentiment, that informs how I can understand possible solutions and possible ways
- 52:53that policy is going to be potentially realized and the challenges, the obstacles that it may
- 53:00face.
- 53:01And that allows us, you know, even on these issues where we might think because we're so
- 53:07used to the, if I ruled the world line of thinking when when we talk about our own
- 53:13beliefs, that is something that lends itself much more to, oh, you can have a conversation
- 53:21and learn about this even without changing your your moral assertions.
- 53:27So Gotcha.
- 53:30Yeah.
- 53:30No.
- 53:30That that that that that makes sense.
- 53:32And it's you know, how how do you ground the moral in the more practical solutions?
- 53:37That's that's that's the big thing is because when you have a certain moral view and you feel
- 53:42strongly about it, it's gonna be hard for you to change it if you have somebody who has a
- 53:47different moral compass to try to change that.
- 53:52Yeah.
- 53:52And then you're you're asking a lot of yourself if you're making a purely moral appeal is, you
- 53:59know, you need to get someone to change their philosophy about life.
- 54:03You need to get someone to change their ideology or their religion in order to agree
- 54:08with you.
- 54:09That is a tall order.
- 54:11People will not do that, and you can gain a lot more ground and get people to understand where
- 54:16you're coming from more effectively by stepping outside of, I believe this because of my
- 54:22morals, to to that more societal and more policy lens.
- 54:28Yeah.
- 54:28That that makes sense.
- 54:30So I always like to emphasize for all my listeners how content from my guests and myself
- 54:37are applicable and useful for people across the political spectrum.
- 54:40Don't wanna just teach them, wanna be able to have them give them actual info.
- 54:46So this divide I'm going to be talking about, though, is a little bit different.
- 54:49This book is ostensibly aimed at people who don't typically look for common ground or think
- 54:54it isn't there, but might be like, oh, okay.
- 54:57I guess I can do this.
- 54:59But what about people who think they seek common ground already, but don't truly do that
- 55:04or aren't as open minded as they think they are?
- 55:07How what would you say to them specifically to get them to realize, hey.
- 55:11This is actually is something that you need to change about your viewpoint.
- 55:16Well, I mean, what everyone needs to change may vary.
- 55:20I certainly don't know all of my readers and all of their needs, but, you know, the case I
- 55:28would make is, hey.
- 55:29It's it's a tool set.
- 55:31It's a lot of things that could help you, and approaching it with an open mind, just like
- 55:36approaching conversation with an open mind, can be to your benefit.
- 55:39Allows you to learn more, allows you to expand.
- 55:42One general thing I will point to is just the need for that intellectual humility in
- 55:48conversation.
- 55:50Assuming assuming you have all the answers, whether it's about the issue or about how you
- 55:56handle the issue, lends lends itself to to some pride pride that cometh sometimes before falls.
- 56:10And it can create a weakness.
- 56:12It can make it harder for you to see your weaknesses.
- 56:16So my biggest lesson, one of my biggest things that I echo throughout the book is, you know,
- 56:24before you engage in healthy conversation, it's about wanting to learn from other perspectives.
- 56:31It's be curious.
- 56:33That is so incredibly helpful in engaging in healthy political discussion, in developing
- 56:40your own ideas.
- 56:42And I would hope that prospective readers take on the same approach with the book, which is
- 56:50just to be curious.
- 56:52To the earlier part of that question, as far as who it's aimed at, think that was one of the
- 57:00interesting challenges for me because I also try to be cognizant that a lot of my audience
- 57:05and my initial audience is people who are interested in a common ground approach
- 57:10ostensibly, is people who are closer to the bridging space or the political innovation
- 57:16space and looking to build within that.
- 57:20And for them, I really wanted to have something that is not only interesting and valuable and
- 57:25gives them tools to directly pass on, but to create a book that they could share with those
- 57:32in their lives who really need more of that common ground mentality, who really need more
- 57:38of that constructive dialogue approach.
- 57:41And it's a bit of a cliche to say the book is for everyone, but, you know, its functionality,
- 57:49its effectiveness comes down in great part to the width and the breadth of the the appeal.
- 57:58Yeah.
- 57:58And intellectual humility, that that's such a big thing.
- 58:01Sometimes when I'm if I'm doing a podcast, usually usually this applies to the ones that
- 58:06I'm where it's just me, but that intellectual humility.
- 58:10Sometimes I think I've got something figured out and sometimes I gotta push aside that, oh,
- 58:13yeah.
- 58:13I've already got this figured out.
- 58:14And sometimes I'm gonna be like, well, maybe there's something I forgot.
- 58:17Or maybe there's an angle I never thought about.
- 58:18And then I'll find something that I had originally thought.
- 58:21And I find something different.
- 58:22I was like, oh, okay.
- 58:24Well, that's interesting.
- 58:25Now, sometimes, sometimes I still got to make sure that I'm, you know, not having any level
- 58:31of hubris because sometimes I gotta I mean, you always gotta check yourself.
- 58:35Right?
- 58:37But that yeah.
- 58:38That's that's that's go ahead.
- 58:40Well, you know, one thing to that, this is, you know, a group that we tend to focus a lot on.
- 58:47We can empathize with quite a bit because we work in the political space, and we think a lot
- 58:54and talk a lot about politics as this lack of intellectual humility is risk.
- 59:00There's also there's a big audience, and there is a huge population out there that has the
- 59:07opposite problem, where they have the intellectual humility.
- 59:11They sort of they see themselves not knowing anything about politics, and it intimidates
- 59:18them.
- 59:19And they lack the confidence in their voice.
- 59:21And I think the humility and confidence go hand in hand.
- 59:26Some of us have no shortage of the confidence, and we need to work on the humility.
- 59:30But at the same time, there are so many people out there who may not realize that if you just
- 59:36have doubts, if things confuse you about a political issue and an approach to a political
- 59:43issue, sharing those doubts, sharing your concerns and your perspective is really
- 59:49valuable to the conversation.
- 59:50It informs the person you're talking with about, you know, maybe weaknesses in their
- 59:56appeal, maybe challenges that they may not have thought of.
- 1:00:00And having that confidence in your voice, that confidence that you can add positively to the
- 1:00:06conversation just by taking part with an open mind.
- 1:00:11I think that is also really valuable for so many people who are politically inactive, who
- 1:00:18are silent, and who we could really benefit from from hearing more of in our political
- 1:00:26discourse.
- 1:00:28Yeah.
- 1:00:28Definitely.
- 1:00:29I agree.
- 1:00:29And some of those people, touched on a little bit in an episode I did before, my fiftieth
- 1:00:34episode I did about political apathy.
- 1:00:36Some people are after that, not just because they don't care.
- 1:00:39They wanna care, but they just think that this is just too much for me.
- 1:00:42The device of this is too much.
- 1:00:44Or like you said, don't really know what's what's going on.
- 1:00:48I can't understand it.
- 1:00:49And those of us who are in the Civic Arena and the Bridge Building Arena, that's that's one of
- 1:00:54the big challenges, but one we gotta continue to refine.
- 1:00:58So the penultimate question here before I get to the random fun nonpolitical question of the
- 1:01:04day.
- 1:01:05Any final thoughts on Common Ground or your book that you want to share?
- 1:01:11I think I've shared quite a bit of it.
- 1:01:13Again, it's it's a book about the tools for better dialogue, the mindsets and frameworks
- 1:01:21and conversational techniques that you can use, and then how those can lead to both self
- 1:01:29improvement and to societal betterment as we apply them at scale.
- 1:01:36And at the end of the day, you know, this is something that I talked about with independence
- 1:01:41and the messaging and just being able to talk about the issues when you present yourself as a
- 1:01:47a more positive ethos, when you present yourself as a a common ground, a bridge
- 1:01:53builder.
- 1:01:56The proof is in the pudding.
- 1:01:58And ultimately, the value of this of this book really comes through if you are able to succeed
- 1:02:06with the techniques.
- 1:02:07If you are able to take on some of these ideas and reach people you wouldn't have been able to
- 1:02:13reach otherwise.
- 1:02:14If you are able to work towards solutions and work towards ideas that you couldn't have
- 1:02:19produced from standard partisan thinking.
- 1:02:24All of that is making the case for bridging far better than any kind of moral appeal to
- 1:02:32bridging.
- 1:02:33And the more that we can show, hey, constructive dialogue leads to more effective
- 1:02:41communicating, leads to us feeling more heard, leads to better solutions to real problems, I
- 1:02:49think the more clear it becomes that however justified fighting may be, this is the better
- 1:02:59way to do things.
- 1:03:01Nice.
- 1:03:01Nice.
- 1:03:02Yep.
- 1:03:02Just like just like we have been talking about in this episode, a lot of actionable tips in
- 1:03:08that book, not just very highfalutin idealistic stuff.
- 1:03:11So and, of course, I'll like I said before, I'll put the links to the book in the show
- 1:03:16notes for you at home to or wherever you're listening to this to pick it up on Amazon,
- 1:03:22ebook, paperback, and hardcover format.
- 1:03:24So now we move on to the final question of the day.
- 1:03:28For those of you who are new to the podcast, at the end of guest episodes, I like to pose
- 1:03:34random questions of the day that are fun, nonpolitical, just to get a little bit of a
- 1:03:39different side of the guests just because it variety is the spice of life after all.
- 1:03:44So, Nathan, today's random question random question of the day for you is, what is a
- 1:03:52common phrase that you think is annoying and should stop being used even if it irrationally
- 1:03:56bothers you?
- 1:03:58Oh, boy.
- 1:04:02You know, I have so many I 'm just so positive when it comes to phrases.
- 1:04:08There is some there are a few that I I love.
- 1:04:12One thing, know, one that comes to mind that's just always funny is with all due respect.
- 1:04:18And that's one but but it is
- 1:04:22fun.
- 1:04:22No
- 1:04:23offense.
- 1:04:24But, you know, the one that that grinds my gears when I hear it is not trying to be a jerk
- 1:04:33or variations thereof.
- 1:04:35Oh, yeah.
- 1:04:35It's you know, that that one is just nothing good is going to come out of this, and it's
- 1:04:42almost braggadocious.
- 1:04:44It's like, well, I don't even have to try to be a jerk.
- 1:04:48It's Yeah.
- 1:04:51And I probably used that phrase before, but Mhmm.
- 1:04:54I probably used that phrase before, but that that's No.
- 1:04:57No.
- 1:04:58No.
- 1:04:58No.
- 1:04:59It can come from a positive place, which is I I don't mean any of this maliciously.
- 1:05:04Same can be said of, with all due respect.
- 1:05:08But we have it it actually speaks to a deeper challenge.
- 1:05:12Oh, dang.
- 1:05:14I don't know if this even veers enough off course of the book because it's a deeper
- 1:05:17challenge of how we criticize and how we deal with, like, offering critical feedback to each
- 1:05:25other when we're used to this notion of politeness.
- 1:05:31But yeah.
- 1:05:31That's fascinating to me, and that particular one, I think, is not not the smoothest.
- 1:05:37Well, what are your some that bother you?
- 1:05:40So so unlike you, I'm very good about being bothered by innocuous things that don't
- 1:05:46actually matter.
- 1:05:47Funny enough that the political stuff, I'm actually, in some ways, better about, you know
- 1:05:53Sure.
- 1:05:53Being more even killed about that.
- 1:05:55Not always, but but I find I there's a little bit of catharsis I I find in getting upset
- 1:06:01about things that I know don't ultimately matter but are still bothersome.
- 1:06:05So for me, one of the many phrases that bothers me is give me a 110%.
- 1:06:12I hate that phrase.
- 1:06:14That is so annoying.
- 1:06:15I I I've heard I heard it plenty of times when I played football in high school.
- 1:06:18I whenever I coach the YMCA, I never tell my kids that just because one, it's mathematically
- 1:06:23impossible.
- 1:06:24You can't give a 110%.
- 1:06:26Otherwise, that is a 100%.
- 1:06:28And b, it's it's also like there's a certain undercurrent or hidden meaning.
- 1:06:37I can't think of the word, but you're basically implying to people that you want them to
- 1:06:42overexert themselves, and that's not what you're trying to do.
- 1:06:44You you want them to give you full effort, but overexert themselves.
- 1:06:48That's how you actually get hurt.
- 1:06:49That's how you get injured.
- 1:06:50And that that again, really not important in the grand scheme of things, but I find it
- 1:06:56incredibly annoying.
- 1:06:57Give me a 100%.
- 1:06:58I mean, I think you touch on, like, the actual practical outcome of it, which is Yeah.
- 1:07:03You know, there is this idealization we have of pushing beyond our limits, and there are so
- 1:07:09many TV shows and worst of fiction that dramatize and romanticize this.
- 1:07:13And, you know, to to your point or to their credit, like, are great athletes who talk about
- 1:07:22this, but it is also the thing that leads you to breaking something to when your body is
- 1:07:29telling you to stop, that is often a very good sign to stop.
- 1:07:33But you do remind me one of my I always had this minor dream of being able to speak to, you
- 1:07:42know, some a student athlete related audience and use the line, you know, being a great
- 1:07:51athlete is about giving a 110%, you know, to your sport.
- 1:07:56Being a great student athlete is about knowing how to manage the other negative 10%.
- 1:08:02Oh, okay.
- 1:08:03Nice.
- 1:08:04That's it.
- 1:08:04That's true.
- 1:08:04I've heard it put like that before.
- 1:08:06I like that.
- 1:08:07And there is something to the whole like, hey, you're more capable you're capable of more than
- 1:08:12you think you are.
- 1:08:13That's great.
- 1:08:13I tell tell my kids whether it's football, basketball, soccer, volleyball, kickball.
- 1:08:17I tell I tell I will tell them something along those lines, but I will never tell them to,
- 1:08:21especially because these are kids.
- 1:08:22I'm not gonna tell them to over
- 1:08:25exert themselves.
- 1:08:26And managing the other negative 10% also makes less and less sense the more you think about
- 1:08:32it.
- 1:08:33So yeah.
- 1:08:34I just It's true.
- 1:08:36But I I do I do like that better than just give me a 110%.
- 1:08:39Than just giving a 110?
- 1:08:41But but like I said, really not important in the grand scheme of things.
- 1:08:44Still find a way to bother me.
- 1:08:46You know, may I think I was it's partly also just I try to set find things that actually
- 1:08:50aren't important to get annoyed at, so I'm not so frustrated at things that are that are
- 1:08:55actually important.
- 1:08:56I'm just saying,
- 1:08:57like Yeah.
- 1:08:58Yeah.
- 1:08:59It's it's fun.
- 1:09:02You know, you have to and I actually, I talk about this, you know, to go back briefly to the
- 1:09:07book, this sort of this sports mentality around politics and when when it becomes this thing.
- 1:09:13I'm I'm all for the sports mentality around sports.
- 1:09:15I I love Yeah.
- 1:09:17You know, that.
- 1:09:18And, yeah, it can be very fun.
- 1:09:23And we have to recognize, you know, when when these sort of mindsets are attempting, like,
- 1:09:30what is the positive here?
- 1:09:31And there is you know, people want to let their emotions out and just argue about stuff.
- 1:09:36And, yeah, it's so much fun to argue about the meaningless stuff rather than Yeah.
- 1:09:41You know, this stuff that's going to ruin con ruin relationships or this or that.
- 1:09:46Exactly.
- 1:09:46Although some people could also take Oh, absolutely.
- 1:09:49Too far obvious obviously.
- 1:09:51Oh, I
- 1:09:51I mean, I I I get a little heated about teams that I hate more more than I should.
- 1:09:58But
- 1:09:58Sure.
- 1:09:59Yeah.
- 1:09:59Yeah.
- 1:09:59But as much as we could keep this going on Please, yeah.
- 1:10:03Going on, we do gotta wrap things up.
- 1:10:05So for all of you at home, thank you so much for listening and and watching.
- 1:10:10Please like, comment, and subscribe.
- 1:10:11Obviously, again, put the link to Nathan's book in the show notes.
- 1:10:15Please go ahead and buy that.
- 1:10:18Any other links you wanna share first, Nathan?
- 1:10:22You can find me so my website is nathansmolinski.com.
- 1:10:26You can also find me I post every so often on LinkedIn.
- 1:10:32You can follow me there.
- 1:10:33I do have a Facebook author page.
- 1:10:36I need to use that more.
- 1:10:38And, yeah, in general, my website is the best place to reach out to me.
- 1:10:44I do events.
- 1:10:45I do speaking.
- 1:10:46So if you have any ideas for your collaboration, I love to hear those.
- 1:10:52So yeah.
- 1:10:53Definitely get in touch.
- 1:10:56Alright.
- 1:10:56I'll I'll I'll make sure to put those in the show notes as well.
- 1:10:59So for me, I also have a Facebook page for my author stuff.
- 1:11:04Well, all all my stuff I do, but including the author stuff.
- 1:11:06So Paul Raider, author and speaker.
- 1:11:09My LinkedIn, I post on there quite frequently.
- 1:11:12My medium.com profile, my five day educational email course about how we can more effectively
- 1:11:17mitigate political polarization.
- 1:11:20My website, paulrader.org, and my book that I also wrote, Why Independents Rarely Win
- 1:11:27Elections and How Do They Become More Competitive?
- 1:11:29Not trying to argue that they should or shouldn't.
- 1:11:31It's just saying this is the issues they face.
- 1:11:34Here's how some actionable steps that they can take to fix them.
- 1:11:38But that is going to wrap things up for today.
- 1:11:40So as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 1:11:42Until next time, take care.