Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / The Invisible Price of Nature with Dr Cesar Ruiz
Transcript
- 0:00There are some questions we rarely ask ourselves
- 0:02when we talk about economics. What if capital
- 0:05isn't only in banks, but also in forests, rivers,
- 0:08and the soil beneath our feet every day? Who
- 0:12are the characters behind science? This is Science
- 0:15Behind the Glass, illuminating the human side.
- 0:19In this podcast, we unveil the human side of
- 0:22laboratories and science. Scientists share personal
- 0:25experiences. and will discuss their meanings
- 0:27from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:31Disclaimer, the voice for the guest translation
- 0:34was generated using artificial intelligence.
- 0:37Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, the podcast
- 0:39that builds bridges between nature and human
- 0:42beings. In Colombia, one of the most biodiverse
- 0:45countries on the planet. In Colombia, one of
- 0:48the most biodiverse countries on the planet.
- 0:50Every decision about livestock, farming, mining,
- 0:53road construction. or agriculture affects something
- 0:57that doesn't always show up in official figures,
- 1:00just sustains our very lives, natural capital.
- 1:04Today on Science Behind the Glass, we are going
- 1:06to look at nature not just as a landscape, but
- 1:10as the foundation of our economy and our human
- 1:12stories. Our guest is Dr. César Augusto Ruiz,
- 1:16biologist and researcher in natural capital,
- 1:19ecosystem services, and socioecological resilience.
- 1:23Cesar, it's a pleasure to have you on Science
- 1:25Behind the Glass. Thank you very much for accepting
- 1:27this invitation. To start, how did you end up
- 1:30combining biology, economics, and sustainability?
- 1:34Where did that come from? Thank you both so much.
- 1:37It's a pleasure to be here in this space. That's
- 1:39a very interesting question, and my students
- 1:41and colleagues ask me the same thing sometimes.
- 1:43I remember when I chose my degree. I chose biology
- 1:46back in 1994 because my gut told me it had very
- 1:50few numbers involved. I never considered myself
- 1:53good at math, statistics, or models, probably
- 1:55because of the traditional way I was taught in
- 1:57secondary school. Once I finished my undergrad
- 2:00in biology, I was working mainly with botany,
- 2:02specifically with the taxonomy and systematics
- 2:04of mosses, liverworts, and lichens. I had the
- 2:08opportunity to do my undergraduate fieldwork
- 2:10in Tarapaca in the Amazonas region. It was intense
- 2:13fieldwork with the Amazonian Institute of Scientific
- 2:15Research, CINCI, here in Colombia. And I started
- 2:19noticing something very interesting. All the
- 2:21conservation problems I could see around me,
- 2:23not just in relation to indigenous communities,
- 2:26but also involving economic actors, were tied
- 2:28precisely to economics. And I started reading,
- 2:32working, trying to understand. And I thought,
- 2:35why are we always blaming the economy, economic
- 2:37development, economic growth as the main driver
- 2:39of biodiversity loss and environmental damage?
- 2:42So instead of criticizing it, I decided to study
- 2:45it. It seemed far more interesting to understand
- 2:48economics from the inside. what the theory actually
- 2:50says, how it works, than to just criticize it
- 2:53from the outside. That's when I did a specialization
- 2:56in mathematics and then a master's degree in
- 2:58economics. And it was, let's say, quite a collision.
- 3:01But without a doubt, it opened up my perspective.
- 3:04It helped me understand the impact that a discipline
- 3:06from the human sciences, economics, has on absolutely
- 3:09every system on this planet. To understand it
- 3:11deeply, the theory, the econometric models, the
- 3:15worldview of disciplines that are often far removed
- 3:17from biology. From that came my interest, and
- 3:20I started studying economics with a focus on
- 3:23economic valuation, alongside the models and
- 3:25theories themselves. That's really interesting,
- 3:28and it actually raises another question for me
- 3:31right there. Is worth thinking about where the
- 3:35focus is placed when you give economic value
- 3:37to things in nature? Is it the individual, animal,
- 3:41a species, a plant? The functions of any ecosystem
- 3:45or what we have talked about before, what are
- 3:49called ecosystem services. Could you walk us
- 3:52through a bit about how the valuation of different
- 3:56natural components actually works? This step
- 3:59of valuing nature, ecosystems, natural resources,
- 4:03including human beings in that equation, what
- 4:05I call socio -ecological systems, has a very
- 4:08important starting point. First, we have to remember
- 4:11that, at least in the current academic consensus
- 4:13and in what the Intergovernmental Science Policy
- 4:15Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services,
- 4:19IPBES, states there are three ways to value nature
- 4:22and natural resources. And here comes the first
- 4:25question. Who does the valuing? Human beings.
- 4:27We are a complex species with a complex brain,
- 4:30and we constantly assign valuations to everything
- 4:33around us. Among those three forms of valuation,
- 4:37the first is intrinsic valuation. In practical
- 4:40terms, what I work through with my students is
- 4:42understanding that biodiversity and natural resources
- 4:45have value in and of themselves, value I cannot
- 4:48monetize, and that they fulfill fundamental ecological
- 4:51functions and processes. In some of my ecology
- 4:54classes, I discuss with students what's more
- 4:56important in a moorland ecosystem, not just as
- 5:00a hypothetical, the spectacled bear or a nematode
- 5:03that looks terrifying in a photo with those huge
- 5:05teeth and makes you think, ugh, what an awful
- 5:08creature. both have genuinely important value
- 5:10from the standpoint of ecological function. Intrinsic
- 5:14valuation brings together all the work done by
- 5:16biologists and ecologists from pure disciplines,
- 5:19taxonomy, and systematics to understand what
- 5:21we have in nature and what their roles are in
- 5:23the ecosystem. But there's another form of valuation,
- 5:26relational valuation, and this is where the concept
- 5:30of socio -ecological systems starts to come in
- 5:32because human beings are part of nature at different
- 5:35scales. Through our relationships, being embedded
- 5:38in these socio -ecological systems, we naturally
- 5:40develop cultural ties, perceptions, and notions
- 5:43about what nature is. Indigenous peoples anywhere
- 5:46on the planet have a relational valuation of
- 5:48their natural environment because they've built
- 5:50an evolutionary and historical relationship with
- 5:52their territory. That's completely different
- 5:55from the relational valuation of someone who
- 5:56is 100 % urban, who thinks water comes from the
- 5:59tap rather than from an ecosystem and a whole
- 6:01set of processes. and it's different again from
- 6:04the relational valuation of a business administrator,
- 6:06a manager, a CEO of a tech company, because those
- 6:09relational values are built from lived experience.
- 6:12And finally, we have instrumental valuation,
- 6:15what we call economic valuation. In some of my
- 6:18research, I've tried to integrate all three forms
- 6:21of value. But what exactly is the goal of economic
- 6:24valuation? Economic valuation is grounded in
- 6:27environmental economics, which has existed since
- 6:30the 1960s and 70s. as a response by economic
- 6:33theorists who wanted to make visible the social
- 6:35cost of environmental damage. That was the original
- 6:38question, how much does air pollution cost a
- 6:41society? How much does water pollution cost?
- 6:44That was the starting point, evaluating environmental
- 6:46cost. And that has a very interesting power because
- 6:50it allows us to make decisions in a world that,
- 6:53whether we like it or not, affects all of us
- 6:55in one way or another, the economic system we
- 6:57live in. add something here because it ties into
- 7:00something else we have talked about on the podcast.
- 7:03We measure things through GDP. The economic losses
- 7:07from ecosystems simply aren't reflected there.
- 7:10And that leads me to another question. How do
- 7:13you draw the line between a useful tool and a
- 7:16dangerous reduction of nature to numbers? How
- 7:19do you avoid oversimplifying even though I know
- 7:22you are actually trying to capture all those
- 7:25ecosystem services and it is incredibly difficult?
- 7:28Especially when it comes to make that understood
- 7:30in political and economic terms. And what you
- 7:33are describing is so interesting because usually,
- 7:36as you said, valuation happens after the fact.
- 7:39Like, okay, if we build a hydroelectric dam here,
- 7:44how much will people benefit? But never the impact
- 7:48before. What's going to do to the ecosystem and
- 7:51to us? Because we are part of the ecosystem too.
- 7:54That integration is always missing. That's a
- 7:57really good question, Linda. In any discipline,
- 8:00natural sciences, physics, economics, reductionism
- 8:02is very tempting. And in global economics, the
- 8:05history of our society, particularly after the
- 8:07Second World War, when economic development systems
- 8:09were set up to pursue growth in GDP, the entire
- 8:12human race unfortunately fell through sheer hegemony
- 8:15into absolute reductionism. Well -being equals
- 8:18growing GDP. Improved quality of life equals
- 8:21growing GDP. Many studies by Professor Robert
- 8:24Costanza, Rudolf de Groot, and researchers from
- 8:27Latin America have shown that quality of life
- 8:29and GDP growth don't necessarily go hand in hand.
- 8:32GDP is the total material wealth generated by
- 8:35a society in a given period of time, measured
- 8:38in money. So we're already dealing with a reductionism
- 8:40that has become hegemonic. You can see it on
- 8:43any news channel or in any newspaper. There's
- 8:46always a section for economic indicators. The
- 8:49dollar went up, the dollar went down. Where did
- 8:51oil open this morning? Inflation rose. This country's
- 8:54GDP grew 25 % and that automatically sends a
- 8:57signal that says, invest here. We have reduced
- 8:59social and cultural behavior to a set of metrics
- 9:02that we now consider natural when they're not.
- 9:05So what about the economic valuation of natural
- 9:08resources and ecosystems? It's not about embracing
- 9:11reductionism, it's about starting from a clear
- 9:13conceptual framework. The framework I work within
- 9:16is called Total Economic Value which is also
- 9:18used by IPBES and by colleagues I've worked with
- 9:22in Spain, like Berta Martín López. The idea is,
- 9:26natural resources have multiple values, relational,
- 9:29intrinsic, instrumental. I cannot, for instance,
- 9:32economically value the spiritual or religious
- 9:34importance of an ecosystem to a community, whether
- 9:37indigenous or not. That would be like asking
- 9:40you, How much would you pay to stop your god
- 9:42from disappearing? Or how much would you pay
- 9:44to stop your loved ones from being gone? There
- 9:46are limits we can't cross. So total economic
- 9:48value recognizes that any economic valuation
- 9:51of natural resources is always going to be an
- 9:54approximation. Why? Because economic valuation
- 9:57measures what societies can instrumentally use,
- 10:00directly or indirectly, from those natural resources.
- 10:04But there are other values, intrinsic and relational
- 10:06ones, like spiritual values, legacy values, existence
- 10:10values, that go to the very root of what value
- 10:13means. In economics, value means price. But in
- 10:17human societies, value means the fundamental
- 10:19principles that drive behavior. So whenever economic
- 10:22valuation is done, at least in my research, we
- 10:25state clearly that it's a methodological and
- 10:27conceptual approximation with two concrete objectives.
- 10:31The first is to reveal that monetary value of
- 10:33nature so we can inform decisions and engage
- 10:35with other actors. And any economic valuation
- 10:38is explicitly an approximation. I still review
- 10:42some articles for journals like Ecological Economics,
- 10:44and when I look at ecosystem valuation studies,
- 10:47say from Iran, the good ones say, this is an
- 10:50approximation. We cannot confuse the method with
- 10:53the purpose. Why does Iran want to value its
- 10:56mangroves? Why does Denmark value its ecosystem
- 10:59services? to help develop policies, policies
- 11:03that don't replace ecological management, economic
- 11:05management, or social management. So reductionism
- 11:09is what happens when someone says to me, so that
- 11:11mangrove ecosystem is worth $120 million per
- 11:14hectare, so if I have that money, I can just
- 11:16buy it and clear it. No, it's an approximation
- 11:19of value aimed at specific ends, one of them
- 11:22being policy development. Right, and that's really
- 11:24interesting. It makes me think of what you mentioned.
- 11:28that GDP and the ways we measure growth and wealth
- 11:32depend fundamentally on material products that
- 11:34ultimately have to come from nature. Based on
- 11:37that, we have a core problem, which is land use
- 11:40change, happening everywhere in the world. A
- 11:43lot of land that was under conservation or less
- 11:47intensive uses has been shifting, and that has
- 11:50caused enormous losses in nature and, as you
- 11:53say, in the socio -ecosystems. where peoples
- 11:56are also part of the picture. So how could we
- 12:00bring the kind of research you do in a more practical
- 12:03role, one that allow us to negotiate with sectors
- 12:06that have their own interests, livestock farming,
- 12:09housing, and agriculture, sectors using vast
- 12:13amounts of land and changing it to extract wealth?
- 12:16That's an interesting question, and here we get
- 12:18into something environmental economics also offers
- 12:21us, economic instruments. What do economic instruments
- 12:23do? Take land use change, for example, at the
- 12:27global level. You might know the concept of payments
- 12:29for ecosystem services, where a community receives
- 12:32a certain amount of money to stop doing something
- 12:34harmful or to improve a productive practice.
- 12:36Because for any human being, in any context,
- 12:39change is hard. Imagine a rural community, historically
- 12:43rural, where slash -and -burn agriculture, which
- 12:46is enormously harmful ecologically, has been
- 12:48practiced for three, four, five, six generations.
- 12:51Maybe in their relational context, they simply
- 12:54don't know there's another way. You show up as
- 12:56a conservationist and give them a strong speech
- 12:58about how they're destroying the ecosystem, and
- 13:00you tell them to switch to agroforestry, silvopastoral
- 13:03systems, all of that, and the farmer says, okay,
- 13:06but how? And if I barely have enough to survive,
- 13:09who's going to help me change? So in the context
- 13:11of land use change, it's important to understand
- 13:14three things. First, in Colombia specifically.
- 13:17The biggest driver of ecosystem loss throughout
- 13:19our history has been livestock farming. And here
- 13:22I want to make a point I make with my students
- 13:24too. The problem isn't the machine, it's the
- 13:26mechanic. I've had students say to me, Professor
- 13:29what? So cows are bad? No. The way we implement
- 13:33an economic activity, whether it's livestock
- 13:35farming, agriculture, or mining, is what makes
- 13:38the difference. We have different social actors
- 13:40at different levels. There's the smallholder
- 13:42farmer, very common in the global south, with
- 13:45a subsistence plot, whose society needs to change
- 13:47their production methods, maybe toward agroforestry,
- 13:50silvopastoral systems, different practices, because
- 13:53as a society, we… re -losing benefits and money
- 13:57through water contamination, use of agrochemicals.
- 13:59That person needs incentives, and the incentive
- 14:02might be payments for ecosystem services. In
- 14:05Latin America and the Caribbean, for example,
- 14:07we have land tax reductions for conservation.
- 14:10though I'm quite critical of those instruments,
- 14:11because like any tool, if applied poorly, you
- 14:14end up compensating actors who don't actually
- 14:16need the incentive. Then there's another segment,
- 14:19mid -scale producers. Not large landowners, but
- 14:22not subsistence farmers either. For them, it's
- 14:25a dual effort. Environmental economics has to
- 14:27incentivize, but the core goal of an economic
- 14:30instrument is to change behavior. Here I'll open
- 14:33a short parenthesis with an example. In Colombia,
- 14:35around 2016 and 2017, A tax on plastic bags was
- 14:39introduced. Before that, you'd go to the supermarket
- 14:42and get 200 bags to wrap everything. Now you
- 14:45arrive and they say, bring your own bag. Do you
- 14:48want us to charge you for one? 150 pesos, 200
- 14:51pesos, 500 pesos. Environmental taxes are supposed
- 14:55to change behavior in theory. An environmental
- 14:57tax that gets collected widely has failed. It
- 15:00actually hurts me when I see news in my country,
- 15:02and I've seen it in Peru too with carbon taxes
- 15:05and in Ecuador, where I've also worked. where
- 15:07the government announces, this year we collected
- 15:091 .8 trillion pesos from the plastic bag tax.
- 15:12From an environmental economics standpoint, I
- 15:15say, we failed. Because the best environmental
- 15:18tax is one that isn't collected because it actually
- 15:20changed behavior. And here's where valuation
- 15:22matters. If a tax is set too low, I go to the
- 15:25supermarket and think, instead of carrying my
- 15:28own bags, I'll just pay a dollar and get 10 bags.
- 15:30That's not really costing me anything. So I keep
- 15:33buying the 10 bags. The government collects the
- 15:35tax. Or instead of reducing my greenhouse gas
- 15:38emissions at the source, I buy carbon credits
- 15:41or pay a $10 per ton carbon tax because that's
- 15:43cheaper than actually changing. So an instrument
- 15:46that doesn't recognize who its target audience
- 15:48is can create perverse effects or simply not
- 15:51work. There's a lot of research on this globally,
- 15:54especially around carbon taxes. Back to land
- 15:57use change. We have to identify the different
- 15:59segments. Who gets incentives, subsidies depending
- 16:02on the country and its laws? who needs stronger
- 16:05environmental education and behavioral change,
- 16:07supported by a smaller or graduated subsidy,
- 16:10and who genuinely doesn't need incentives at
- 16:12all. Because then we have the large landowner,
- 16:15the large -scale rancher, the monoculture farmer,
- 16:17the extensive livestock operation, where income
- 16:20is not the barrier to change. For them, you need
- 16:23a tax or another instrument that actually makes
- 16:25them change. And here, economic theory is interesting.
- 16:28Even if the motivation is purely financial, the
- 16:31outcome still happens. Even if it's for the wrong
- 16:34reasons, they change, and the environmental damage
- 16:37is avoided. That's what happens with land use
- 16:39in Europe and other countries when the economic
- 16:41incentive is graduated, well -designed, and recognizes
- 16:44different actor types. We help those who don't
- 16:48know how. We persuade those who have some capacity.
- 16:51And we change the behavior of those at the top
- 16:53of the destruction pyramid. Because environmental
- 16:56economics, unlike the way we understand GDP and
- 16:59conventional economic growth models, cannot be
- 17:02applied uniformly. It has to be analyzed case
- 17:05by case, because environmental economics is context
- 17:08-dependent. And that example you gave about plastic
- 17:12bags is so interesting in relation to incentives.
- 17:15Because you're right, for a lot of people, it
- 17:17is easier just to think. Well, I forgot my bag.
- 17:21I will buy one this time. But instead of offering
- 17:24an alternative, I remember how years ago supermarkets
- 17:27had boxes, car boxes, and they almost had no
- 17:31bags. So people would just grab the box and take
- 17:35their groceries home in them. You forgot, it
- 17:39was easy. So when they offer an alternative that
- 17:41depends on the person, and I would say even on
- 17:46the socio -economical level, they accept it.
- 17:48The incentive works differently. It is about
- 17:51perception. So much of the economics is about
- 17:55perception. Exactly. And beyond that, Linda,
- 17:58what's been sold to the majority of society?
- 18:00Let's not think about those of us who know about
- 18:02environmental issues. Let's think about the 8
- 18:05billion 300 million plus people who either couldn't
- 18:08or didn't want a background in environmental
- 18:10science. For that broader population, price as
- 18:14an economic signal is extremely powerful. Returning
- 18:17to the point, the foundation in values, environmental
- 18:20education, making science more public and accessible,
- 18:23all of that is fundamental. But that generational
- 18:26shift is still catching up with us, while we
- 18:28already have the consequences of global climate
- 18:30change bearing down on us, along with many other
- 18:32planetary boundaries we've crossed through our
- 18:34economic activity. When a student walks into
- 18:36an economics class at any university in the world
- 18:39and sits down for their very first introduction
- 18:41to economics, the professor is going to say,
- 18:44economics is the science that seeks to efficiently
- 18:46distribute resources in a society. That's a concept
- 18:49that goes back to 1786. And right there, the
- 18:53construction of economics begins, built on efficiency,
- 18:56but not on justice, not on equity, and not on
- 18:59socio -environmental consequences. And in fact,
- 19:02there are critics of this. I love reading Joseph
- 19:04Stiglitz, who is a sharp critic of the economic
- 19:06system as it stands. Not because he's against
- 19:09private property or against the market, but because
- 19:11the system, as it's structured, focuses solely
- 19:14on efficiency. And the problem with efficiency?
- 19:17Think of a society like Colombia or Ecuador.
- 19:19The government has a budget. Its one overriding
- 19:22goal is GDP growth. That's the job of a finance
- 19:25minister. So that state budget has to go toward
- 19:28mandatory obligations, defense, minimum health
- 19:31care, minimum education, but there's money left
- 19:33over that the government has to invest through
- 19:35public -private partnerships or incentives. And
- 19:38what's the first instinct of the top economist
- 19:40at the ministry? Put this resource where it's
- 19:43most efficient. What's generating returns right
- 19:45now? Mining. Let's become a resource extraction
- 19:48economy. Export coal, not much science involved.
- 19:51Immediate returns. Where do I place this budget?
- 19:54on this community doing agroforestry and green
- 19:57production, or on the large ranchers who guarantee
- 19:59short -term profitability. So the problem of
- 20:02efficiency has permeated every level, and that's
- 20:05precisely why price, as uncomfortable as it can
- 20:07be when we say the approximate economic value
- 20:09of a mangrove is such and such, can be a powerful
- 20:12signal. It can help change behavior, and that's
- 20:16ultimately what drew me into researching socio
- 20:18-ecological systems. In this race for our own
- 20:21survival as human beings, imagine a kilometer
- 20:23race. We've already covered 990 meters using
- 20:26science and technology. But those last 10 meters
- 20:29that remain require a behavioral change in things
- 20:32we've normalized and believe are natural. Hyperconsumption,
- 20:36economic growth, the idea that more is always
- 20:38better, the images of what progress and success
- 20:41look like that come to us from all media, from
- 20:43our education, all of that has made us normalize
- 20:45situations like the ones we're living through
- 20:47right now. And when something is normalized and
- 20:49deeply internalized, changing it is hard. But
- 20:53when we use that normalized agent, price, and
- 20:55put it in service of something, we can start
- 20:57to get results a little faster. I agree. And
- 21:00you also have a study on the natural capital
- 21:03of the Magdalena Cauca basin, where you talk
- 21:06about enormous losses affecting 80 % of Colombia's
- 21:10population. Is that natural capital up here as
- 21:14an explicit figure in the national budget? How
- 21:16do you think it would change the economic and
- 21:19political conservation about development in Colombia?
- 21:22Because right now, if I'm not mistaken, I was
- 21:25listening to a podcast with an economist who
- 21:27won the Nobel Prize in Economy. And he was saying
- 21:30that, unfortunately, Colombia is stuck in the
- 21:3319th century. I think he was being generous.
- 21:36I once read a book by a Cambridge economist,
- 21:38Raj Patel, called The Value of Nothing. He makes
- 21:42a comprehensive assessment of economic behavior
- 21:44and how economics relates to environmental and
- 21:46social problems. In his introduction, he described
- 21:49interviewing candidates for the economics PhD
- 21:51at Cambridge, and some of them would say their
- 21:53goal was to bring economics into the 21st century.
- 21:57Raj Patel would respond, if you can bring it
- 21:59to the 19th century, that would be enough. And
- 22:02I think the same applies to Colombia. We're stuck.
- 22:05partly because of intellectual poverty in our
- 22:07environmental institutions, and partly because
- 22:09of a genuine lack of interest in reflecting the
- 22:11economic value of nature on top of vested economic
- 22:14interests. Including environmental accounts and
- 22:17GDP is not a new idea in Latin America. Chile
- 22:20tried it for years, even partly during the Pinochet
- 22:23dictatorship, and when democracy came, you'd
- 22:25think political style wouldn't matter, but it
- 22:27turned out the interests remained the same. CEPL,
- 22:30the Economic Commission for Latin America, has
- 22:32been insisting since the 1980s that the best
- 22:35path for developing countries rich in natural
- 22:36resources, and I'm not talking about oil, coal,
- 22:39or gold, I am talking about ecosystems, air,
- 22:43water, complex ecological relationships, is to
- 22:46start reflecting those in forest accounts, in
- 22:48ecosystem accounts, accounts that speak to the
- 22:50complexity these systems actually have. But then
- 22:53comes the concern. If we include environmental
- 22:55accounts in GDP, accounting for lost or conserved
- 22:58ecosystems, our GDP might not grow the way we
- 23:01need it to for the world to keep seeing us as
- 23:03a viable nation. The world decides whether a
- 23:05society is viable based on whether its GDP grew
- 23:08between 1 and 2%. If it drops or stays flat,
- 23:11then it's a collapsing society that needs intervention.
- 23:14So against that globally entrenched principle,
- 23:16that economies need infinite growth, which has
- 23:18been debated for over a century, countries like
- 23:21Colombia remain, economically speaking, operating
- 23:23with institutions that haven't changed since
- 23:25the colonial period. And it's not just Colombia,
- 23:29many countries that had our experience, Haiti,
- 23:31Indonesia, where I had the chance to work for
- 23:33a time, South Africa. So the GDP question, the
- 23:37idea of showing, as in this publication, that
- 23:39we've lost 80 % of our natural capital and converted
- 23:42it into infrastructure with a relatively limited
- 23:44lifespan, and that this represents many billions
- 23:46of pesos, is about showing the glass half full.
- 23:50We lost this much, but we still have this much.
- 23:52If that were reflected in GDP, the economists
- 23:55inside the governmental machinery of the global
- 23:57economy would say, don't include it. How are
- 24:01we going to say that in 2020 we lost 1 .3 trillion
- 24:04pesos in natural capital? Better leave that out
- 24:06and stick to manufacturing, energy, and other
- 24:09elements. But this is changing. I'm very enthusiastic
- 24:12about the European Union's environmental accounting
- 24:14initiative, where they're starting to be genuinely
- 24:16transparent, for the first time in many years,
- 24:19about what they've lost and what they have left.
- 24:21Countries raising their hands and saying, yes,
- 24:24we acknowledge that today only 3 % of our natural
- 24:26forests remain. We've lost a lot, but what's
- 24:29left, we're going to develop in specific ways.
- 24:31That starts to create a different global logic.
- 24:34But in South America and Central America, we're
- 24:37far from that, because we haven't internalized
- 24:39that value. So measuring it, promoting it, making
- 24:42noise from wherever you stand, that's a first
- 24:44step toward recognizing it. That's really interesting.
- 24:47It actually leads me to the next question. Bearing
- 24:51in mind the evaluation you have done of the Orinoco,
- 24:54Magdalena and Kaukabasins, which are enormous,
- 24:57and the way the results are framed largely in
- 25:00terms of what has been lost through not conserving
- 25:04these basins and their functions, what would
- 25:07happen if we started maybe... as a block of developing
- 25:11or tropical countries, the ones with the most
- 25:16natural resources to sink, not only in terms
- 25:18of what we have lost, but in terms of the potential
- 25:21we have to recover these major watersheds, these
- 25:25great tropical forests. started to position that
- 25:29potential as, I don't know, a different economic
- 25:32philosophy. Do you see anything on the horizon
- 25:36in the next 10 or 20 years that could take hold
- 25:39as a different theoretical framework for economics
- 25:42that makes this a central factor rather than
- 25:46just something on the margins if GDP growth slows
- 25:50down? The good news and something that, in my
- 25:52head and in my heart, set a goal for me at some
- 25:55point in my life. I want to economically value
- 25:57Colombia's natural capital. That was actually
- 25:59sparked by publications that appeared around
- 26:022004 and 2005, as revealing as the Millennium
- 26:07Ecosystem Assessment, which introduced the concept
- 26:09of ecosystem services and the value and benefits
- 26:12of nature not just to scientists but to policymakers.
- 26:16People might think, a work like the Millennium
- 26:18Ecosystem Assessment, first version in 2003,
- 26:22second in 2005, and which has continued to be
- 26:25developed and which inspired multinational and
- 26:27multilateral bodies like IPBES. How different
- 26:31is it really from the work done in the 1990s
- 26:34on deforestation and environmental damage? Technically
- 26:36the same foundation. The difference is it chose
- 26:39to position the issue at the level of global
- 26:41policy. And unfortunately, the analysis of climate
- 26:45change also helped push these topics into the
- 26:47political arena, even though it's sad that we've
- 26:49had more than 30 years of climate negotiations.
- 26:5230 COPs and haven't gotten good results, you
- 26:55have to see the glass half full because some
- 26:57results are coming. The same is true for biodiversity
- 27:00COPs. The global logic has been shifting, not
- 27:03at the speed we want, not at the speed we need,
- 27:06but it started changing 20 or 25 years ago. Initiatives
- 27:10like the Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity,
- 27:13around 2006 and 2007, led by Dr. Pavan Sukdev,
- 27:18who I believe is now the president of WWF, showed
- 27:21us that economic invisibility of nature was,
- 27:24if you think like an economist, going to work
- 27:26against us in the long run. So there are many
- 27:29initiatives. What do I think the first step is?
- 27:31The first step is generating information and
- 27:34validating it. Economically valuing the remaining
- 27:37and lost natural capital because we value both
- 27:40in the Amazon Basin, the Orinoco, the Pacific,
- 27:43the Magdalena Cauca, and the Colombian Caribbean
- 27:46to have a country -wide synthesis. That was not
- 27:49just my work, it was the work of many colleagues
- 27:51and it took more than 15 years. 15 years of finding
- 27:55the data, cleaning it, generating it in many
- 27:57cases, validating it against international literature
- 28:00and other experts, explaining why we were publishing
- 28:02a natural capital figure and what the goal was,
- 28:05making it clear we weren't. T just presenting
- 28:08a number, cause we're not accountants, we're
- 28:10academics. We wanted to present the underlying
- 28:12causes as well. Livestock farming, okay, but
- 28:16eating meat isn't the problem. The way we're
- 28:18doing livestock farming is tourism in the Colombian
- 28:21Caribbean, yes, but the policy isn't going to
- 28:24be ban tourism. It's going to be regulated, directed.
- 28:28Natural capital lets you understand the historical
- 28:30causes and identify the real problems so you
- 28:33can design the right policies. And then the ribbon
- 28:35on top of that whole package. We attach a value,
- 28:38compare it against Colombia's conventional GDP,
- 28:41as many other studies do, and the first jolt
- 28:44that creates is, how can this much money be invisible?
- 28:47That starts a conversation. Without a doubt,
- 28:50I see changes happening, not as fast as we need,
- 28:52but more and more organizations, not just researchers,
- 28:55are engaging with this. Companies at the global
- 28:57level take Puma, the first company globally to
- 29:00decide, independently and transparently, to economically
- 29:03value its environmental externalities. That was
- 29:07around 2013 and 2014. They had $300 million in
- 29:11profit. They calculated they were generating
- 29:14$94 million in environmental damage throughout
- 29:17their value chain, and they asked, how do we
- 29:19fix that? How do we simplify our supply chain?
- 29:22And it's not just Puma. Many companies globally
- 29:24are doing this, and frameworks like the circular
- 29:27economy are helping it happen. So from the private
- 29:30sector, things are moving, perhaps much faster
- 29:32than from government. And as citizens, in my
- 29:35case as a scientist, generating that information
- 29:38is step one, disseminating it is step two. Educating
- 29:42people that environmental economics isn't about
- 29:44going to a store and trading money for a pencil,
- 29:46but that it's a set of chains that help us understand
- 29:49complexity in a different way. That's another
- 29:51step. And continuing to push on the political
- 29:53front, knocking on those doors wherever they'll
- 29:56open. Yes, and what you just said about the private
- 30:00companies moving faster than public ones. The
- 30:03key word here is transparency. The transparency
- 30:06in their accounts showing how they compensate.
- 30:10how they transform, how they can offset their
- 30:13environmental damage. And that leads us to the
- 30:15next question, which is related to socioecological
- 30:18resilience. What is that? How do we apply it
- 30:22in Colombia? That topic has drawn my attention
- 30:24for a long time, even when I was still working
- 30:26mainly on natural capital. Because let's start
- 30:29with the concept of resilience itself, which
- 30:31has become very popular lately in all kinds of
- 30:33media and conversations. You have to be a resilient
- 30:36student, a resilient work. are, just be resilient.
- 30:40But what actually is resilience? What's interesting
- 30:43is that resilience is a concept born in psychology.
- 30:47In the mid -20th century, late 19th, and early
- 30:5020th centuries, actually, with the rise of psychoanalysis,
- 30:53one thing psychoanalysts studied was why we change
- 30:55or don't change. And the term resilience was
- 30:58coined. In the psychological and behavioral sciences,
- 31:01resilience is basically your ability, your mental
- 31:03model, your way of living, to absorb a great
- 31:05many external blows and stresses, many of them
- 31:08unpredictable, without losing your identity and
- 31:10without, to put it plainly, losing your mind.
- 31:13That concept started gaining traction as, by
- 31:16the mid -20th century, We began talking about
- 31:18systems dynamics, understanding that computer
- 31:21systems, economic systems, ecological systems
- 31:23have dynamics that are not linear with multiple
- 31:26feedback loops. And one of those wonderful books
- 31:28that launched systems dynamics was Donella Meadows'
- 31:31work on the costs and changes of development
- 31:33from 1972. It used systems dynamics for the first
- 31:37time, and we and science, academia, started to
- 31:40realize that systems have an identity, just as
- 31:42you have yours. Daniel has his, and I have mine.
- 31:46Systems have identities. What they are today
- 31:48depends on a vast number of non -linear factors,
- 31:51and many of those causes will generate states
- 31:54we cannot predict. So the jump from resilience
- 31:56to systems theory allowed us to understand that
- 31:59we have to see systems with all their multiple
- 32:00causes and consequences in a more dynamic way
- 32:03and to understand that s not just internal variables
- 32:07or deforestation and livestock farming that account
- 32:09for environmental damn. There are educational
- 32:12processes, even religious ones, even spiritual
- 32:15ones, that make a system what it is today. I
- 32:18tell my students when we talk about ecological
- 32:20and socio -ecological resilience, deforestation
- 32:23doesn't have the same consequences or the same
- 32:25causes in two different places. We have to understand
- 32:28what makes each one particular. Ecology, by the
- 32:32late 20th century, began adopting the concept
- 32:34of resilience and applying it to ecosystems,
- 32:37studying, for example, How long it would take
- 32:39a mangrove forest to recover all its ecological
- 32:41functions after a major hurricane or typhoon?
- 32:45How much time did ecological systems, mangroves,
- 32:48moorlands, any given ecosystem, need to recover
- 32:51after being subjected to severe stress? And then
- 32:54specifically after 2012, thanks to work by some
- 32:57Nobel laureates in economics, the conversation
- 32:59moved to socio -ecological resilience. The argument
- 33:03was, these systems are not purely environmental,
- 33:06not purely economic, we are coupled socio -ecological
- 33:09systems that we haven't understood yet, and we
- 33:12need to understand resilience as the capacity
- 33:14of those social and environmental systems together
- 33:16to absorb changes and pressures without losing
- 33:18their identity. When a system loses its identity,
- 33:22when it changes trajectory, that's when things
- 33:24become irreversible. A very interesting example
- 33:27of socio -ecological resilience research is the
- 33:29work of Professor Carl Folk. whose analysis shows
- 33:32that if we keep increasing deforestation, the
- 33:35Amazon could reach a tipping point where we,
- 33:37V, made so many changes that instead of a forest,
- 33:39we end up with a savanna. Socio -ecological resilience
- 33:42means considering not only environmental variables,
- 33:45but also social, economic, and cultural ones.
- 33:48With that concept in mind, and understanding
- 33:50the complexity of socio -ecological systems,
- 33:53a few years ago I said, why not measure socio
- 33:55-ecological resilience in Colombia and propose
- 33:57a measurement index? trying not to fall into
- 34:00reductionism but trying to bring all this complexity
- 34:02into something understandable. And Colombia has
- 34:05very particular characteristics, interesting
- 34:08and at the same time painful ones, more than
- 34:1080 years of armed violence. If someone wants
- 34:13to measure socio -ecological resilience in Vietnam,
- 34:15you'd have to factor in Vietnam's historical
- 34:17variables. But if I want to measure it in Colombia,
- 34:21I have to understand that there are drivers of
- 34:23change like levels of education and violence.
- 34:26That's why, in our resilience analysis for Colombia,
- 34:28this first index for Colombia published last
- 34:30year, what we were seeking was a first approximation.
- 34:34Where do we stand in terms of resilience? Can
- 34:36it be measured? Absolutely it can. What does
- 34:38that resilience data tell us beyond natural capital?
- 34:41More, actually, because it includes historical,
- 34:44economic, and political variables that economic
- 34:46valuation alone doesn't capture. Is it better
- 34:50than natural capital analysis or ecology by itself?
- 34:52No, it's a different way of presenting things.
- 34:55Why is it important for a society to understand
- 34:58its ecological and systemic resilience? Because
- 35:01if we see very abrupt changes, the system can
- 35:03reach a point where we don't know where it's
- 35:04headed, from a systems theory standpoint, and
- 35:07many of those outcomes could be far worse than
- 35:08what we're living through now and could compound
- 35:10the consequences of climate change. When we built
- 35:13this first socio -ecological resilience index
- 35:15for Colombia, we already knew beforehand that
- 35:18we're a country highly vulnerable to climate
- 35:20change, and that vulnerability is not only due
- 35:22to our geographic position, but to our political
- 35:24and institutional structure. When a disaster
- 35:27strikes, like the hurricane that hit San Andres
- 35:29and Providencia six years later, we're still
- 35:31talking about reconstruction. But when a hurricane
- 35:34hits the New Orleans region in the United States,
- 35:37within seven months, reconstruction is essentially
- 35:39complete. Because there's an institutional and
- 35:41social response capacity that goes far beyond
- 35:44what an ecosystem alone can do. And one of the
- 35:47central conclusions of the socio -ecological
- 35:49resilience analysis for Colombia is this. As
- 35:52long as we maintain the current scattered and
- 35:54fragmented levels of violence throughout the
- 35:56country, we can keep investing millions of dollars
- 35:59in ecological restoration. And we will keep suffering.
- 36:03Environmental and social losses. It's not just
- 36:06deforestation as a product of violent political
- 36:09dynamics, like the expansion of illicit crops.
- 36:12Behind all of that is also displacement, and
- 36:15when you lose your rural identity, you lose the
- 36:17foundation for rebuilding a territory. In Colombia,
- 36:20more than 5 million hectares are in the process
- 36:22of being returned to people displaced by violence.
- 36:25But it's not just about returning the land, it's
- 36:28about how we reconnect all those relational values.
- 36:31Resilience helps us understand that there are
- 36:33structural phenomena. and in Colombia's case
- 36:35they are very clear. The first is violence, not
- 36:39paramilitary violence, guerrilla violence, or
- 36:41dissident violence specifically, but the cycle
- 36:43of displacement it has generated. That is a direct
- 36:46cause of our social and ecological systems losing
- 36:49resilience. The second cause is economic, how
- 36:52we're directing GDP resources toward different
- 36:54activities. We're still a country, even under
- 36:57this government that promised change, that has
- 36:59subsidies to the mining and extraction sector
- 37:01of 32 -36%. If we start solving those structural
- 37:05problems, we release pressure from the pot. Because
- 37:08as long as the problems of territory and violence
- 37:10go unsolved, our resilience will keep declining.
- 37:14And one of the most striking results of this
- 37:16research is that the department performing worst
- 37:18after La Guaira is Antioquia. And some colleagues
- 37:21said to me, but wait, Antioquia is doing great,
- 37:24it's thriving, it's entrepreneurial. That's a
- 37:27cultural and mental model. Yes, I can believe
- 37:29I'm the most beautiful prince on the planet,
- 37:31but what am I really? Antioquia is a department
- 37:34where, leaving aside the case of La Guajira,
- 37:36which despite significant GDP growth, all the
- 37:39phenomena of multiple forms of violence, the
- 37:41reshaping caused by illicit crops, illegal mining,
- 37:44are very quietly doing what we call in resilience.
- 37:48Latent variables, pulling the D. Parment's total
- 37:51resilience downward, even below Vichada, Guaviar,
- 37:54or Caqueta. From the standpoint of our country,
- 37:57those might seem like the jungles where nothing
- 37:58is happening, but a lot is happening. and that
- 38:01determining factor, the incidence of violence
- 38:04and the way legal and illegal economic development
- 38:06is unfolding, is precisely what resilience allows
- 38:09us to see in greater depth. We can step out of
- 38:12the comfortable side and start asking, what do
- 38:14the country's violence statistics actually mean?
- 38:16How do I interpret human displacement beyond
- 38:19the human tragedy to understand how those flows
- 38:21of population are generating real changes in
- 38:23all natural systems? How does it work, deforestation
- 38:27first, then illicit crops? Then livestock farming
- 38:30arrives, but the community has already moved
- 38:32elsewhere. The community that moved isn't the
- 38:34villain. The armed actor is another actor in
- 38:37the system. How do we understand all of that?
- 38:39Right. That's a really fascinating angle. Moving
- 38:42on to another challenge in science and more specifically
- 38:45in academia, we have the capacity to publish
- 38:48a lot of things year after year, paper after
- 38:51paper. But in reality, very few of them have
- 38:55a tangible impact on society or on nature. How
- 38:58do you face that as someone working in economic
- 39:01research? And can you give us an example, something
- 39:05you remember where economic research had a more
- 39:07concrete effect, something that actually improves
- 39:10things in Colombia or somewhere else? Fortunately,
- 39:13there are many examples, but let me talk a bit
- 39:16from my own experience, because there's something
- 39:18I discuss with my students. I used to teach a
- 39:20course on environmental policy and legislation
- 39:23at the university where I work, the Jorge Tadeo
- 39:25Lozano University, until last year. Students
- 39:28studying environmental biology, as Linda did
- 39:31at the time, or marine biology, need some context
- 39:34on how environmental legislation works in their
- 39:36country. Because either we end up working in
- 39:39academia or in consulting, we have to live on
- 39:42something. But the interesting part was always
- 39:44the discussion about what policy actually is
- 39:46and how policy configurations work. And we have
- 39:50to look at the political context in history,
- 39:52which in Latin America and the Caribbean has
- 39:54many similarities. But the trajectories have
- 39:56made us radically different, even from countries
- 39:59as close as Venezuela or culturally similar as
- 40:01Ecuador. So, when you start to understand that
- 40:04the political context is a long -term conversation,
- 40:07the first thing you have to figure out is your
- 40:09own place in the world. My place right now has
- 40:11one foot in academia and one foot in consulting.
- 40:14I also work with an international organization
- 40:16on the consulting side. Let me give you a very
- 40:20concrete example. There's a large infrastructure
- 40:22project in Colombia, a port in the Department
- 40:25of Antioquia, and I'm an auditor on that project.
- 40:27The job is to say, look, you have to meet environmental
- 40:30standards. You have to ensure that any damage
- 40:33to biodiversity and ecosystem services is compensated
- 40:36physically through planting and conservation
- 40:38and economically in the case of social damage
- 40:40to communities. And the response is, but I have
- 40:43an environmental permit and the law doesn't ask
- 40:45me for that. Yes, but you're asking a bank for
- 40:47a loan and the bank won't lend if you don't meet
- 40:49those standards. We're back to the economic instrument.
- 40:52That's a very interesting way of starting to
- 40:54influence things. And it's a good sign. Banks,
- 40:58even more local and regional ones, are saying,
- 41:00we want to lend, that's the business of a bank,
- 41:02lending and moving money, but we don't want to
- 41:04be labeled as mercenary banks. I'm working on
- 41:07a project in Mexico where the lender is KFW,
- 41:09a major German bank, and they say, look, you
- 41:12have to solve every environmental problem in
- 41:14this project or we can't lend. And that forces
- 41:17a change in attitude. Whoever receives the money
- 41:20to build an ammonia plant has to understand that
- 41:22they have to do it better than anyone. If not,
- 41:25there's no money, and that starts to create a
- 41:27kind of pedagogy. The portfolios of all banks
- 41:29are changing at impressive rates, and that's
- 41:32where I've found space to spread this work. At
- 41:35the local level, it's sometimes been much easier,
- 41:37or in my case, it's been much easier to reach
- 41:39an international audience than to reach local
- 41:41decision -makers like Columbia's Ministry of
- 41:43Environment. Though through some national media
- 41:46outlets we've managed to get press coverage,
- 41:48and through civil society initiatives, there's
- 41:50a very interesting one in Colombia called Parkways
- 41:52Como Vamos, where we presented the economic value
- 41:55of the natural capital in Colombia, S National
- 41:58Protected Areas, and that got media coverage.
- 42:02Thinking that you'll automatically influence
- 42:04a political decision the moment you publish is
- 42:06naive, but it doesn't mean it's impossible. And
- 42:10that frustration, I see it in my students. What's
- 42:12this for, nobody's going to pay attention? But
- 42:15in education, in communication, there is enormous
- 42:17power. Why are banks today imposing such stringent
- 42:20environmental and social requirements on projects,
- 42:23costly standards that must be met or no loan?
- 42:25That didn't come from nowhere. It came from social
- 42:28pressure. And how did that social pressure build?
- 42:30Through networks and media. Every disruptive
- 42:33historical event from the French Revolution to
- 42:35today's conversations about responsible consumption
- 42:37starts with social communication networks. If
- 42:41we use these tools, if we carry this message
- 42:43clearly, it will have a significant impact. And
- 42:46in my professional life as a consultant, it has
- 42:48had an impact. Very difficult, very frustrating
- 42:51because they don't want to do it. We've never
- 42:53done it this way, that. S just how engineering
- 42:56works. But why should I build a higher electricity
- 42:58tower just to save those five trees? How much
- 43:01are those five trees worth? It's always going
- 43:03to be difficult. But that's what we are as a
- 43:05society. If we all thought the same way, we wouldn't
- 43:08be a society, we'd be a colony of bees or something
- 43:11like that. We think differently. So we have to
- 43:13recognize that those stress factors and frustrations
- 43:16are always going to be there. Everyone thinks
- 43:18differently, even those of us in this conversation
- 43:20who share a common goal. Influencing policy is
- 43:24highly desirable. But historically and socially,
- 43:27we're talking about transitions that take time.
- 43:30Revolutions and transformations have taken decades,
- 43:32centuries in some cases. Right now we're at a
- 43:36crossroads, but we have the tools of communication
- 43:38and diffusion. As an academic, I have two fundamental
- 43:41purposes in my life. One is to publish academically
- 43:45what I generate, because that ultimately gives
- 43:47you credibility when you face political actors
- 43:49who don't read. There's a very interesting publication
- 43:52from 2018 and 2019, where a team of marine biologists
- 43:56came to me and said, Cesar, we want to hire you
- 44:00and your team to do an economic valuation of
- 44:02what could be lost in the Gulf of Tribuga and
- 44:04Cabo Corrientes if the Department of Antioquia
- 44:07and the government keep insisting on a deep -water
- 44:09port in an area where the last remnants of mangrove
- 44:12forest remain, specifically 906 hectares. We
- 44:16did the consulting work. We found that Marviva
- 44:19and many organizations had been telling the Antioquia
- 44:22government and Congress for more than 15 years.
- 44:24Look, the humpback whales reproduce here. There
- 44:26are five sea turtle nesting sites here. Look
- 44:28at the mangroves. But with the government that
- 44:30came in around 2018 and 2019, that megaport project
- 44:34in the Gulf of Tribuga on the Pacific coast was
- 44:36reactivated through the National Development
- 44:38Plan. So we did the study, we generated values,
- 44:41we published in a prestigious international journal,
- 44:43so we could then bring it to the NGOs we were
- 44:45working with, like Marviva, make noise in the
- 44:48media, and even speak before a congressional
- 44:49commission to explain what they'd already been
- 44:52told for years, abo, at the turtles, about the
- 44:55whales. But this time we came in and said, look,
- 44:57this is how many millions of dollars would have
- 44:59to be paid or compensated in some way to the
- 45:02fishing communities if that port is built in
- 45:04that location. Because the problem isn't the
- 45:06port itself. It's where it's going to be built
- 45:09and how. The alternatives are A, B, C, and D,
- 45:12and that's where systems modeling comes in. But
- 45:14this is what it's going to cost society. Are
- 45:16you prepared to be responsible for that? The
- 45:18NGOs, the media, that pressure, when a topic
- 45:21makes noise and gets traction, is perhaps one
- 45:23of the personal experiences where I've genuinely
- 45:25felt satisfied that we managed not to kill the
- 45:27project, but at least to put it in the freezer
- 45:29for a while. And I'm not saying that the work
- 45:32of identifying the whale and sea turtle populations
- 45:34wasn't important, it was fundamental for the
- 45:37economic valuation. But the message of what it
- 45:39would cost, and you are going to be responsible
- 45:41for this economic loss, that did make several
- 45:43decision makers scratch their heads. In fact,
- 45:46the company leading the project decided to archive
- 45:48all the studies, perhaps waiting for more favorable
- 45:51political conditions at another time, but it
- 45:53hasn't happened. And that was accomplished with
- 45:56time, patience, and a clear awareness that yes,
- 45:58changing reality isn't ideal. but reality changes
- 46:01with time, effort, and patience. And as a public
- 46:04academic, you need that validation, the ability
- 46:06to speak with certainty, and not just anecdotes
- 46:09about what you want to change. That is the strength
- 46:12of the academy. Yes, I completely agree on something
- 46:15very important here. We recently had as a guest
- 46:18Carlos Guarnizo, the director of Ciencia Café
- 46:21Paso Merced, and he told us about a case. the
- 46:25debate over evolutionary theory and creationism
- 46:28in the United States and how scientists went
- 46:31with a mountain of books, their own conception
- 46:34of the truth. Here's the material without actually
- 46:37thinking about how to communicate with people
- 46:40who speak a different language in terms of like
- 46:44a context. For example, the politicians. How
- 46:49do you reach out people? How do you reach those
- 46:51members of Congress who have absolutely no idea
- 46:54why a humpback whale passes through there or
- 46:58why a sea turtle that are in danger are going
- 47:01to be lost? For them, it is simply not relevant
- 47:06because it is not framing economic terms. So
- 47:10it is about dumping things down. It is about
- 47:13gathering evidence and pushing. I think this
- 47:18is something science really lacks. I do believe
- 47:22science publications and rigorous studies give
- 47:25you a strong foundation and a credible voice
- 47:28that can eventually be reflected politically,
- 47:30especially in a specific case. Because when you
- 47:34are fighting for a ecosystem that is about to
- 47:36be lost or a place that is about to disappear,
- 47:39it's far stronger when you have evidence from
- 47:42that specific place. Because many times the work
- 47:45is invalidated locally because ecological or
- 47:48valuation studies come from somewhere else. So
- 47:52I would say don't stop being vocal, but be vocal
- 47:55with substance. And I think carefully about how
- 47:58to approach that politician who doesn't want
- 48:00to listen or who has their own agenda. And as
- 48:03you say, social media works enormously well for
- 48:06creating pressure at the community level. I would
- 48:09say the voice that... needs to be amplified is
- 48:12the local community level one. From my perspective,
- 48:15the historical distance between academia and
- 48:18politics. I remember when I was just starting
- 48:20my career, I went to a Latin American botany
- 48:22conference. We're talking late last century.
- 48:25I was amazed. I sat in on two working groups
- 48:28and both concluded the same thing. Academia is
- 48:31too far removed from politics. Two years later,
- 48:34I came back and the same conclusion. And I believe
- 48:36we in academia have a responsibility. We have
- 48:38a responsibility to moderate our discourse and
- 48:41our reach. Scientific publication, academic publication,
- 48:44peer validation in peer -reviewed journals, all
- 48:47of that is fundamental for academia to maintain
- 48:49its rigor. It's just as important to publish
- 48:52that we discovered a new species of mosquito
- 48:54as it is to propose a new social analysis. Academia
- 48:57has a responsibility, or it had one. Sometimes
- 49:00I look at academia and feel anxious. But that
- 49:03fundamental responsibility is precisely this,
- 49:05to disseminate, to generate. The word academia
- 49:08comes from the idea of giving, concentrating,
- 49:11sharing. Teaching and generating knowledge that
- 49:14can be validated and replicated, that's a core
- 49:17principle. If not, we're just treating in anecdotes
- 49:20or other things. Is witchcraft different from
- 49:23economics? Only in method, not in the object
- 49:25of study. So, in academia, we have that responsibility,
- 49:28but also another one, to lower the language barrier.
- 49:31I tell my students and colleagues, if you truly
- 49:34know a topic, you should be able to explain it
- 49:36simply. And it's not just that you should. It's
- 49:38a real obligation, because what we do isn't rocket
- 49:41science. We are trying to understand ourselves.
- 49:43And those objects of study deserve to be communicated
- 49:46with passion, with interest, with clarity, so
- 49:49that people may not understand the formulas and
- 49:51the model, but they understand why it was done.
- 49:53With my postgraduate students, when I assign
- 49:56an article on environmental economics, I tell
- 49:58them, I don't want you to write the economic
- 50:00model used or the economic formulas on your presentation.
- 50:04I want to know, what was the purpose? What did
- 50:07you understand the goal to be and what is it
- 50:09going to be used for? All science in all its
- 50:11forms has a genuinely deep usefulness and we
- 50:14can't lose sight of that. But those of us in
- 50:16academia also have a responsibility to communicate
- 50:18knowledge far more efficiently and to stop playing
- 50:21as if we're in the 18th or 16th century, the
- 50:24club of Rome, seven or eight enlightened people
- 50:26speaking in different tongues. That world of
- 50:29the solitary genius is over. What we need now
- 50:32is to build networks, and networks are built
- 50:35through dialogue that everyone can understand.
- 50:38It's not about lowering your level, it's about
- 50:40rising to meet everyone else's. Because we all
- 50:43have very different mental models, and all of
- 50:45them are valuable. Yes, I completely agree. Thank
- 50:48you so much for your time, Cesar. This episode
- 50:52was inspired by that other kind of accounting
- 50:55we rarely see. the accounting of rivers, forests,
- 50:58soils, and mountains that silently sustain our
- 51:01everyday lives. Cesar's work reminds us that
- 51:05natural capital is not a technical metaphor.
- 51:08It's the water we drink, the food on our table,
- 51:11the territories that have withstood conflict,
- 51:14neglect, and degradation. Putting numbers to
- 51:18nature doesn't mean reducing it. It means making
- 51:21visible what we have taken for granted for decades.
- 51:25Cesar invited us to look at the economy through
- 51:27the lens of ecosystems, to build bridges with
- 51:30farmers and ranches, and to understand every
- 51:33land use decision is also a decision about our
- 51:37collective future. Remember that Science Behind
- 51:40the Glass is on a platform that connects the
- 51:42podcast with all major streaming services via
- 51:46RSS. Just click the link in the description to
- 51:50find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon, YouTube,
- 51:53and wherever you listen to podcasts. Science
- 51:56Behind the Glass is an independent podcast created
- 51:59and hosted by me, Daniel Esguerra, and Linda
- 52:03Hernandez -Duran, with invaluable support of
- 52:05our technical director, Rafael Jordano, and original
- 52:08music by our friend and colleague, Bernardo Aguila.
- 52:11Find us on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, and visit
- 52:14our website for more stories updates. and resources
- 52:17and services. Don't forget to subscribe and share
- 52:20this podcast with your friends and communities.
- 52:22Together, let's amplify these essential stories.
- 52:25If this episode inspired you, consider supporting
- 52:28us with a contribution via PayPal. Just click
- 52:31the Support Us button on our website. Your support
- 52:34helps us grow and allows us to keep illuminating
- 52:37the human side of science. Until the next time.