Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Horizon of Mobility: Electric Evolution 2030
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we are taking a close look
- 0:13at this really intense technological race that is going
- 0:18to define global mobility. It's a battle for the battery.
- 0:20Exactly. Yeah, the shift to electric is
- 0:22happening. We all see it.
- 0:24But the real question now is, you know, not if we go electric,
- 0:27but how, and more importantly, which battery technology is
- 0:31going to power this massive $400 billion industry of the next
- 0:35decade? And we really need to pause and
- 0:37just grasp the scale of this. It's an almost unprecedented
- 0:41industrial expansion, right? Global demand for the current
- 0:43lithium ion batteries, it's set to just soar from around 700 GW
- 0:48hours in 2022. To get this about 400 and 700 GW
- 0:53hours by 20-30. Wow, that's a six fold increase.
- 0:56A6 fold increase in less than 8 years and this is creating a
- 0:59colossal new industry and mobility, you know EVs, that's
- 1:02the bulk of the demand. Which is why this deep dive is
- 1:05so essential. We have sources that compare
- 1:06today's workhorse, the liquid lithium ion battery, or Lieb,
- 1:09with the big challenger everyone's waiting for, the
- 1:12solid-state battery, or SSB. The incumbent versus the
- 1:15disruptor, yeah. And our mission today is to give
- 1:18you a simple, clear understanding of the technical
- 1:21hurdles, some really surprising math on the performance gains
- 1:25and the huge commercial and environmental challenges this
- 1:28whole sector is facing by 20-30. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:33Where do we start? We have to start with the
- 1:35technology. Doing all the heavy lifting
- 1:36right now. Standard Libs, I mean, they've
- 1:39been the undisputed champion since the early 90s.
- 1:42They use oxide cathodes, carbon anodes and a liquid electrolyte.
- 1:46They're reliable, they're pretty energy dense, and we know how to
- 1:49make them at a massive scale. But they have these these
- 1:53fundamental flaws that the industry is just desperate to
- 1:55fix. The biggest one is safety.
- 1:57That's the one. The liquid electrolytes,
- 1:59flammable, it's hazardous. And that means carmakers have to
- 2:02build these heavy, complicated and expensive safety casings
- 2:05around the battery pack. I see.
- 2:07And for you listening, if you're thinking about buying or
- 2:09investing in an EV, those flaws really show up as 2 main pain
- 2:13points. First is cost.
- 2:14How much of the cost is it? The battery itself is estimated
- 2:17to be about 37% of the total cost of a car like the Tesla
- 2:21Model 3A. 3rd of the car's price.
- 2:23Wow, exactly. And the second is performance.
- 2:26Range anxiety is still a real thing.
- 2:29For EVs to truly take over, we need cars that go further and
- 2:32charge way faster. Well, what's really surprising I
- 2:35found is how successful the current liquid Lib tech has been
- 2:40at pushing down those costs, even with those flaws.
- 2:43It is a phenomenal commercial success story.
- 2:46If you look at the cost curve for libs, the cost per kWh has
- 2:49just plummeted since 2010. And that's the gigafactory
- 2:52effect, right? Just economies of scale.
- 2:53That's it. Massive scale and constant
- 2:56manufacturing improvements. Our sources project that the
- 2:58current chemistry, the liquid ones, can and will hit cost
- 3:01parity with gasoline cars. So that's the famous $100 per
- 3:05kWh line. That's the magic number, and
- 3:07we'll likely hit it within the next five years.
- 3:09OK, but hold on. If we jump ahead a bit, the
- 3:11sources also talk about this huge raw material crunch, like a
- 3:15predicted 55% lithium shortage by 20-30.
- 3:19How does that cost parity hold up?
- 3:20Doesn't a huge shortage just wreck that whole cost curve?
- 3:24And that is the central tension in this whole industry.
- 3:27The 100K kilowatta line is doable short term based on
- 3:30manufacturing getting better. But you are absolutely right,
- 3:33the long term view post 2030 that is massively constrained by
- 3:39supply, which makes the whole circular economy idea we'll talk
- 3:42about later absolutely critical. But for now, the most obvious
- 3:47way to improve the tech itself, you know putting aside materials
- 3:49for a second, is to fix that performance issue by replacing
- 3:53the carbon anode with pure lithium metal or limb.
- 3:57That's the technical price. Why is lithium metal so much
- 4:00better? It's all about capacity.
- 4:01Lithium metal offers roughly 10 times the gravimetric capacity,
- 4:05so the energy storage per gram of the carbon anode we use
- 4:09today. 10 times. So if it's that much better, why
- 4:11aren't we using it now? This gets us to the boogeyman of
- 4:13battery tech, Dendrite. The Dendrite catastrophe.
- 4:16Exactly. When you have a pure lithium
- 4:18anode and you cycle it, charge it, discharge it, the lithium
- 4:21doesn't move back and forth uniformly.
- 4:23Instead it forms these tiny sharp needle like structure.
- 4:28They're called dendrites. You can picture them growing
- 4:30inside the battery like microscopic icicles.
- 4:33And as those little needles grow, they start to push through
- 4:36the separator material inside the battery.
- 4:38Yep, they migrate across until they finally touch the cathode
- 4:41on the other side. Creating a short circuit.
- 4:43A dead short. And because those early cells
- 4:45from companies like Moly Energy and Exxon back in the 90s used
- 4:49that highly flammable liquid, that short circuit caused the
- 4:53cell to just ignite or explode. And that's why the industry had
- 4:57to abandon it and pivot to the much safer but less powerful
- 5:02carbon anode. Right, and that failure is the
- 5:05exact reason solid-state batteries were conceived.
- 5:08The whole promise of replacing that flammable liquid with a
- 5:10solid-state electrolyte in SSE is really twofold.
- 5:14OK. What are the two things?
- 5:15Well, first the obvious safety one, the solid electrolyte is
- 5:17generally way less flammable, and 2nd, and this is the key
- 5:20performance part, the theory is that this rigid solid material
- 5:24acts as a physical barrier. It's supposed to be tough enough
- 5:27to just block the dendrites from punching through.
- 5:29Exactly. And if you can block the
- 5:31dendrites, you can safely use that high capacity lithium metal
- 5:34anode and that represents a potential about a 20% upside in
- 5:40the whole battery's energy density compared to liquid lids
- 5:43today. Safer and with significantly
- 5:45more range. That's the dream.
- 5:48That's the dream. But here's where it gets really
- 5:50interesting. The theory is great, but the
- 5:53reality is much, much harder. If that 20% gain a huge safety
- 5:57improvement is on the table, why aren't all the gigafactories
- 6:00switching over right now? Because the reality is that
- 6:03currently no reported solid-state battery meets all
- 6:06the key performance metrics of a top tier liquid battery.
- 6:09We're talking charging rate, long term life, all of it and.
- 6:12This is where we have to look past the hype and actually look
- 6:14at the math. Yes, the expected gain from
- 6:17using an anode that's 10 times better isn't a cell that's 10
- 6:20times better. The cell's total capacity is
- 6:23limited by its weakest link, which is still the cathode.
- 6:26The relationship isn't linear, it's think of it like 2
- 6:29resistors in parallel. So the cathode is the
- 6:31bottleneck. You can make the anode 10 times
- 6:33better, but you only get a modest gain overall because the
- 6:36cathode can only hold so much energy.
- 6:38Is that it? You've got it when you factor in
- 6:40everything else in the cell. The packaging, the current
- 6:43collectors, the weight of the cathode.
- 6:45The math shows that future S, S, BS using lithium metal and a low
- 6:50density solid electrolyte are estimated to hit about 480 Watt
- 6:55hours per kilogram. OK, 480, that sounds pretty
- 6:57good. It does until you realize that
- 6:59future liquid leaves. The ones without lithium metal
- 7:02are already projected to hit 400 wattage kilogram.
- 7:05So the gap isn't this revolutionary leap.
- 7:07It's a really tight race. It's a very tight race, and it
- 7:10gets even tighter depending on what the solid electrolyte is
- 7:13made of. How so?
- 7:14Well, if an SSB uses a dense stable material like a specific
- 7:18oxide, a garnet, they mentioned in the research, the theoretical
- 7:21energy density drops to only 375 wattage kilogram.
- 7:25Wait, so that's actually worse than the future liquid
- 7:27batteries? It offers no energy density
- 7:29upside, so the only way SSBS can even compete on performance is
- 7:34if they can create a solid electrolyte that's both super
- 7:36protective and incredibly light. Low density is an absolute must.
- 7:40That puts a huge constraint on the materials.
- 7:42OK, what about longevity? This hinges on a tiny, often
- 7:46overlooked number. Columbic efficiency, or CE.
- 7:49Why is that one number so critical?
- 7:51CE is just the ratio of charge that comes out of the battery
- 7:55versus what you put in. For battery to last a long time,
- 7:58that ratio has to be almost perfect.
- 8:00And why does that .01% matter so much?
- 8:02Because that tiny loss means a little bit of the active lithium
- 8:05is getting permanently consumed inside reactions every single
- 8:08time you charge the battery. It's like a tiny bit of fuel
- 8:10being burned off and lost forever.
- 8:12So over thousands of charges for years, years, that tiny loss
- 8:15adds up. Precisely, current liquid leaves
- 8:17need an average CE of greater than 99.99% just to keep 74% of
- 8:22their capacity after 10 years. OK, greater than 99.99.
- 8:25Now if that CE drops just slightly to 99.98%, that
- 8:29microscopic .01% difference, the capacity retention after 10
- 8:33years plummets to just 55%. Wow.
- 8:37So for the person buying the car, that tiny margin is the
- 8:40difference between a reliable battery and one that fails way
- 8:43too early. It's everything any new SSB has
- 8:46to meet or beat that incredibly high standard.
- 8:49So with all these tight constraints, density,
- 8:52performance, that crazy efficiency number, the research
- 8:55money is focused on three main families of solid electrolytes.
- 9:00What are they? The three main groups are
- 9:01sulfides, polymers, and oxides. Sulfides are, you know, sort of
- 9:05the front runner on paper right now.
- 9:07Why is that? They have really high
- 9:08conductivity, so they can charge fast, sometimes even faster than
- 9:12liquid electrolytes, and they're low density, which is great for
- 9:15the overall range. But there's a huge catch with
- 9:17making them, isn't there? A.
- 9:18Massive 1. Their main problem is air
- 9:21stability. They react instantly with
- 9:23moisture in the air and form toxic hydrogen sulfide gas.
- 9:27That sounds like a manufacturing nightmare.
- 9:28It's an enormous challenge and on top of that, they're not very
- 9:31stable where they touch the anode and cathode, so they often
- 9:34need complex protective coatings.
- 9:36And when you look at the actual cells people are building with
- 9:39these, the real world performance shows the
- 9:42trade-offs. I saw they're still built with
- 9:44really thick electrolytes. One example was 240 microns
- 9:48thick. And that thickness is just a
- 9:50killer for performance. For you listening, 240 microns
- 9:54is about the thickness of three sheets of regular printer paper
- 9:57stacked up right. Liquid battery separators are
- 10:00way, way thinner. That extra thickness adds weight
- 10:03and resistance. That means that in practice,
- 10:06current SSB designs just can't compete with the best liquid
- 10:10light on overall performance. OK, so sulfides are fast, but
- 10:14they're toxic and too thick for now.
- 10:16What about the other two? Next are the polymers.
- 10:19The good part is they're easier to manufacture and they make
- 10:21really good, stable contact with the electrodes.
- 10:24The big drawback is they have poor conductivity at room
- 10:26temperature, which means commercial versions like the
- 10:29ball or blue cars, they have to operate at high temperatures.
- 10:32We're talking 70 to 80°C kept hot by an external heater.
- 10:37Heating your battery to 80° just to make it work, that seems to
- 10:41defeat the whole safety purpose and it must drain extra energy.
- 10:44It does. And finally you have the oxides.
- 10:47These are great because they're stable against lithium metal and
- 10:50air, fantastic for safety and long life.
- 10:52But their drawbacks are crushing for cars too heavy, they're very
- 10:57high density so they weigh too much, and they just cancel out
- 10:59the benefit of using lithium metal.
- 11:02And they're brittle so it's hard to maintain good contact inside
- 11:05the battery as it expands and contracts.
- 11:07They have stability, but not the performance needed for a high
- 11:10range EV. So no silver bullet.
- 11:13It sounds like there's just a series of incredibly difficult
- 11:16trade-offs that these R&D teams are fighting with every single
- 11:19day. And while they're doing that,
- 11:20the current liquid leaves are just continuously improving and
- 11:25fighting to keep up with this insane market demand.
- 11:27And that huge demand is what's driving all this.
- 11:30The industry's vision for the 2030 EV is, well, it's
- 11:33aggressive. They're banking on one of these
- 11:34technologies having a breakthrough.
- 11:36What are the actual goals? What are they shooting for by
- 11:38the end of the decade? The sources are projecting that
- 11:40EVs will just dominate the market by 20-30 shares over 40,
- 11:44maybe 50% of all new cars sold and the technical goals for new
- 11:48batteries are are phenomenal and 800 to 1000 kilometer range a.
- 11:531000 kilometers. A 10 minute charging time.
- 11:56And cost dipping below $75 per kWh.
- 11:59To meet that kind of demand, the market is already incredibly
- 12:02competitive and the landscape is shifting under our feet.
- 12:06Looking at 2025 delivery data, you can really see how Chinese
- 12:10manufacturers have just taken a dominant position.
- 12:12This is the critical market context for you to see.
- 12:15Yeah, based on 2025 global EV deliveries, BYD holds 19.9% of
- 12:21the market. Julie is second at 10.2%.
- 12:24Tesla. Tesla is third at 7.7%.
- 12:27But what's significant is they saw an 11% decline in year over
- 12:30year deliveries in that period. The top five Chinese automakers
- 12:33already account for 43% of the entire global EV market.
- 12:37And the sheer scale of this transition brings us right back
- 12:39to the sustainability problem. We're not just talking about car
- 12:42emissions anymore, but the production of this whole $400
- 12:45billion industry. Exactly.
- 12:47The sources flag 21 distinct ESG risks here, but the biggest
- 12:52choke point, as you mentioned earlier, is raw materials.
- 12:55The lithium shortage. Right.
- 12:57While there's theoretically enough lithium in the ground
- 13:00worldwide, meeting that 2030 demand requires what they call
- 13:03the full potential scenario of every single mining project.
- 13:08If that doesn't happen, the base scenario shows a severe 55%
- 13:13shortage of lithium by 20-30. That's an existential threat to
- 13:16the whole electrification timeline.
- 13:18It is. And beyond just scarcity,
- 13:19there's the emissions paradox of making the battery itself.
- 13:22What's that? It's the second huge hurdle.
- 13:25While EVs have drastically lower life cycle emissions than gas
- 13:28cars, their production emissions, the mining, the
- 13:31manufacturing are double that of a traditional car.
- 13:34So we have to clean up how we make the clean car.
- 13:36We have to The industry needs to cut those emissions by up to 90%
- 13:39per kilowattage by 20-30 and that really comes down to two
- 13:42things, switching all the manufacturing to low carbon
- 13:45electricity and maximizing the use of circular materials.
- 13:47Which means the system just cannot be a take, make, dispose
- 13:51motor for batteries. It has to be circular.
- 13:53It must be repair, reuse and recycle.
- 13:56It's not just about resilience against shortages, it's also a
- 13:59huge economic opportunity. Recycling alone is expected to
- 14:03create a $6 billion profit pool by 2040.
- 14:06So what does this all mean for you?
- 14:08Listening, We hope we've given you a simple, clear story of the
- 14:11extreme competition that's happening right now, the race
- 14:14between the continuous fast improvement of liquid lives and
- 14:17the disruptive high risk potential of solid-state.
- 14:21That's what's shaping the speed of the easy revolution.
- 14:23In those 2030 targets, 10 minute charging, 1000 kilometer range,
- 14:27they show the moon shot goals the industry has, even as it's
- 14:30staring down the barrel of a potential 55% raw material
- 14:33shortage and this immense pressure to cut manufacturing
- 14:36emissions by 90%. It really raises this final
- 14:39provocative thought for you to consider that the technical race
- 14:42seems to hinge on finding that extra .01% of efficiency in a
- 14:46lab, but the entire $400 billion market hinges on solving a 55
- 14:51percent lithium shortfall on the ground.
- 14:53Which constraint do you think is going to break first, the
- 14:54microscopic science or the macro supply chain?
- 14:57A really interesting question to think about.
- 14:59Thank you for diving deep with us today.