Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Market Edge: Rethinking Water Resources
Transcript
- 0:05Hello, and welcome back to the Market Edge, a podcast series created by the
- 0:09Market Intelligence Committee members at ACEC National, which feature industry
- 0:14experts who address the most pressing issues to members today with a focus really on market trends.
- 0:20This series is also brought to you by the Engineering Influence Podcast at the
- 0:23American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:25My name is Diana O'Lear, and I will be your host today. Now we are joined by
- 0:30Camilla Correll, a nationally recognized expert with nearly 30 years of experience
- 0:34in stormwater infiltration, watershed governance, and sustainable engineering design.
- 0:39She is a water resources engineer and a water practice lead for EOR.
- 0:43She has helped shape watershed management plans, watershed rulemaking,
- 0:46and innovative LID strategies.
- 0:48Her work sits at the intersection of climate adaptation, water infrastructure,
- 0:52and community resilience. And we're thrilled to have her with us.
- 0:57Camilla, thank you so much for joining the Market Edge today.
- 1:01Diana, thank you so much for having me. I'm really excited for our conversation today.
- 1:05Absolutely. So I'm not going to waste any time here, and I'm going to jump right in.
- 1:09So the first, we're going to look at watershed governance and Minnesota's leadership,
- 1:13because that's where I believe you are sitting.
- 1:15So Minnesota is often cited as
- 1:18one of the most progressive states in watershed-based planning, we'll say.
- 1:22From your vantage point, what makes their watershed district model so effective?
- 1:26And how does it change the way engineers could approach service water,
- 1:30groundwater, and land development decisions?
- 1:33It's a great question. And yeah, I feel very fortunate to be having my career here in Minnesota.
- 1:39Minnesota's watershed districts were created in 1955 under the Watershed Act
- 1:44to manage water resources based on how water actually flows across the landscape
- 1:49rather than, you know, along city or county boundaries.
- 1:53And the idea was to make water management more practical and coordinated across the state.
- 2:00So while a number of states like Illinois, California, Florida,
- 2:04and North Dakota have adopted legislation or regional compacts aimed at managing
- 2:11water at the watershed level.
- 2:13Minnesota's specific statutory model of independent watershed-based taxing is
- 2:20considered a really robust approach to localized water management.
- 2:24Watershed districts conserve the natural resources in the state by engaging
- 2:30in land use planning, as you noted,
- 2:32implementing flood control projects, and working on other conservation projects
- 2:36for the protection of public health and natural resources.
- 2:39And they are governed by a board of managers appointed by county commissioners
- 2:45from the counties that are within that watershed district.
- 2:49And that structure allows for local input and management that is tailored directly.
- 2:55To the specific needs of the watershed. So there are 45 watershed districts
- 2:59in the state of Minnesota, and many of the watershed districts in the Twin Cities
- 3:05metropolitan area, for example.
- 3:07Are focused on managing challenges with already developed landscapes,
- 3:12like stormwater runoff, flooding, water quality, aging infrastructure.
- 3:17And then outside in the greater Minnesota area, We have watershed districts
- 3:23that are tied to agricultural practices and drainage systems and the management
- 3:28of rural water resources.
- 3:30So we really have a contrast in what we're managing, as many states do.
- 3:34And I think it's interesting to note that in 2024, Minnesota achieved full participation
- 3:40in a program they call the One Watershed, One Plan.
- 3:43And what that means is that across the entire state, each watershed management
- 3:48organization has a 10-year plan that it's operating from.
- 3:53So I think that informs a lot of what the engineering community has to work with, right?
- 3:59These watershed districts are very organized. They have identified what their
- 4:04needs are, and they are ready to implement the projects that they've identified as highest priority.
- 4:11Watershed districts in the Twin Cities metropolitan area are currently working
- 4:15on their fifth generation plans.
- 4:17So that means that Minnesota has a long history of watershed management,
- 4:21and it also means that they're at the forefront of addressing water-related challenges.
- 4:26They've sort of addressed things that other states are just starting because
- 4:29they've been through a number of iterations.
- 4:32And the watershed districts have a lot of leverage.
- 4:36They are involved in a lot of activities. They monitor the resources and plan
- 4:41for the restoration and protection needs.
- 4:43They implement rules and standards to manage impacts of land use change.
- 4:48They design and construct water quality and flood mitigation improvement projects,
- 4:54collaborate with state agencies and their member communities and counties,
- 4:58and then provide education and outreach programs to promote stewardship because
- 5:02the watershed districts can't do the work alone and neither can the engineering community.
- 5:06It really takes everybody being involved.
- 5:09So by evaluating the systems as a whole, engineers can really identify solutions
- 5:14that typically have multiple benefits. I thought an example might be good.
- 5:21EOR addressed some localized flooding issues in one of the watershed districts
- 5:25we represent by creating a flood control project in the northern part of the watershed.
- 5:31And by designing a series of infiltration basins that retain and infiltrate
- 5:36that water, we were able to maintain base flow to a trout stream within the
- 5:42lower part of the watershed.
- 5:43So having that comprehensive look at what the needs are and what the solutions
- 5:48are just allows for more creativity and more co-benefits in the projects that
- 5:54are actually implemented.
- 5:56Thank you for that answer. The water market is very complex.
- 6:00And so I'm going to pivot us here to at least a topic that is being talked about
- 6:07perhaps across all markets, which is on climate trends and extreme conditions.
- 6:11So you've worked extensively on climate adaptation.
- 6:14What climate trends specifically, including precipitation shifts,
- 6:19extreme rainfall and drought cycles that we're seeing, you know,
- 6:22how are they almost reshaping watershed management today?
- 6:26And how should communities really plan for the next three to 10 years of these
- 6:31extreme conditions? They feel like they're happening on the regular.
- 6:35Yeah, I think that's an excellent question and one that I could spend this entire podcast on.
- 6:41I would say that all of the climate trends and all of the hazards that we are
- 6:46facing or projected to face, things like warming winters, extreme rainfall,
- 6:50like you said, heat waves, drought, they're all re-changing our approach to watershed management.
- 6:57One of the things that I like to say is, you know, it is and it isn't reshaping
- 7:01things, right? Watershed management has been
- 7:05looking at adaptation the entire time, but what we were responding to was the
- 7:10changes on the landscape, like impervious surfaces and development,
- 7:14and how do we mitigate for the impacts related to those changes in the landscape.
- 7:19Now we're throwing climate on top of that, so we're still in this adaptation
- 7:24mode. We're just doing things a little bit differently than we were used to doing.
- 7:30I think a couple of important points on this are, you know, not only are the
- 7:34climate trends changing the physical landscape, but they're also creating opportunities
- 7:39for how we design and manage our built and natural system.
- 7:42So when we talk about impacts to watershed management, it's important to recognize
- 7:47what that climate change looks like in our communities.
- 7:50Many of us are familiar with the immediate and the more visible impacts like
- 7:54flooding following a major precipitation event or hail from severe thunderstorms.
- 8:00These types of events are directly impacting
- 8:02us, our homes, our community infrastructure, our day-to-day lives.
- 8:06But it's also important for us to pay attention to the more subtle long-term
- 8:11changes that are affecting our built-in natural environments.
- 8:14So things like shifts in nighttime low temperatures.
- 8:19Fewer days with snow cover, changes in the timing and the intensity,
- 8:23or even the form of precipitation can significantly affect our lakes,
- 8:28our streams, our wetlands,
- 8:30even our agricultural systems and the communities that depend on these things.
- 8:34So over time, these gradual shifts work
- 8:38will influence ecosystem health, our water availability, infrastructure performance,
- 8:44public health, and the resilience of our communities.
- 8:47So communities should be proactively planning for climate impacts by conducting
- 8:53vulnerability assessments to identify who is at risk, what infrastructure is
- 8:59at risk, what natural systems are at risk.
- 9:01They should be incorporating climate projections and future conditions into
- 9:07the design and the management of their infrastructure.
- 9:10And they should be implementing solutions that combine traditional infrastructure
- 9:14improvements like culverts and gray infrastructure with green infrastructure
- 9:19and natural asset management approaches.
- 9:21And then I think the final thing is that they really need to integrate,
- 9:26identify and integrate co-benefits into their typical capital improvement projects
- 9:32or road reconstruction projects, because that will just build the resilience
- 9:37of the community as a whole.
- 9:38So I wanted you to find this theme of communities and the involvement and the
- 9:43engagement and how stormwater management plays into that.
- 9:47So the infiltration and groundwater recharge have been central to your work.
- 9:51How are local stormwater requirements evolving and what innovative approaches
- 9:56are community using to capture, infiltrate, or reuse stormwater as part of an
- 10:01integrated water management?
- 10:03Yeah, that's another great question, Diana.
- 10:07I would say that stormwater infiltration has really been central to EOR's work,
- 10:11because our approach to land use change and stormwater management has been to
- 10:15mimic the natural hydrology of the landscape,
- 10:18which dovetails really well with this watershed management approach to stormwater.
- 10:24And the best way to protect our lakes, streams, and wetlands has been to manage
- 10:28precipitation where it falls, instead of routing it downstream.
- 10:32Over the last 30 years, the engineering and design community has really been
- 10:36focusing on collecting stormwater runoff in ponds and pipes and then just sending it downstream.
- 10:43But now they're moving to an approach that retains that runoff on the landscape,
- 10:46allowing it to soak back into the ground.
- 10:49And using infiltration practices and green infrastructure not only supports
- 10:53groundwater-dependent natural resources like trout streams, but it also replenishes
- 10:59our drinking water systems and addresses issues like flooding of downstream communities.
- 11:04So the more storage and infiltration that we can maintain on the landscape or
- 11:08build back into the landscape, the better protected we are.
- 11:13So more recently, like you noted, the engineering and design community has begun
- 11:16to think about stormwater as an asset and increasing attention is being given
- 11:21to how stormwater can be captured and reused to offset other water demands, like irrigation,
- 11:28as a way of meeting regulatory requirements or improving water quality and reducing
- 11:33the pressure on potable water systems.
- 11:35So this approach is becoming increasingly important as communities prepare for
- 11:41a warmer future with a greater likelihood of droughts, like we were talking
- 11:45about in the previous questions.
- 11:47Stormwater capture and reuse is now an important component of sustainable design.
- 11:53Practices including capturing rainfall on the roof,
- 11:58like blue moon roofs they're called, or underground storage systems or stormwater
- 12:02ponds for non-potable uses such as toilet flushing, landscape irrigation,
- 12:08or watering golf courses is a really great strategy.
- 12:11And even beyond stormwater capture and reuse,
- 12:15more progressive communities, those experiencing stress today on their drinking
- 12:21water systems, are moving to a one water or what they also call an integrated
- 12:26water management framework.
- 12:27This framework recognizes that drinking water, wastewater, stormwater,
- 12:33groundwater, and surface water are all connected.
- 12:36So instead of managing them in various silos across a municipality,
- 12:41they're looking at ways to manage them holistically so that they can improve
- 12:46resilience, sustainability, and long-term water security.
- 12:49So I fully anticipate that things like stormwater reuse and integrated stormwater
- 12:55management or integrated water management will become the focus of that next
- 13:00generation of watershed management plans in the state of Minnesota on the next round.
- 13:06So I'm going to make a bit of a leap here. You mentioned puttable water.
- 13:10And so I'm thinking this is my segue.
- 13:12And it made me think about data centers. And so I don't think I'll have this
- 13:15discussion without talking about that.
- 13:17So data centers, you know, and other projects can be very water intensive.
- 13:23And so what concerns are you hearing from communities about water supply,
- 13:27wastewater capacity, and long-term sustainability?
- 13:30How should engineers be thinking about these pressures or rethinking?
- 13:36Yeah, that's a great question and one that a lot of people are talking about.
- 13:39So as these data centers come into Minnesota, which is a very water-rich state,
- 13:43we're the land of 10,000 lakes.
- 13:46Cities and communities and the state
- 13:49agencies are very concerned about the pressures on their water systems.
- 13:52Like I mentioned in the first response, right, that we've been practicing watershed
- 13:57management for 50 years and Minnesota places a high value on its water resources.
- 14:03So when they hear about the potential impacts that data centers have,
- 14:07their natural systems, they are very concerned.
- 14:12So my response to that would be engineers need to be thinking about what those impacts are.
- 14:20And the state of Minnesota is looking at providing guidance to communities so
- 14:24they know what it would take to evaluate those impacts of data centers.
- 14:29And so they know what questions to ask and what they can be asking data centers to design differently.
- 14:35My colleague, whom you know, Annabelle Sanford, recently attended the American
- 14:41Council of Engineering Companies Market Intel and Energy Committee meeting.
- 14:45And there she learned from the data center side that community opposition and
- 14:51development moratoriums are the primary challenges they're facing coming into Minnesota.
- 14:57And I think this reflects the broader point that I mentioned earlier,
- 15:01that Minnesotans take great pride in their water resources and their natural
- 15:06environment. And these are defining characteristics in the state.
- 15:09So after 50 years of implementing watershed management frameworks and investing
- 15:13in public education and outreach, communities are informed. And they're demonstrating
- 15:18a strong sense of environmental stewardship.
- 15:21And public sentiment plays a very critical role in shaping how water resources are managed.
- 15:27So these decades of clean water protection efforts have created a strong foundation
- 15:32for public awareness and engagement and calls for moratoriums reflect a desire
- 15:37from the public to pause, better understand the implications,
- 15:40and give themselves and decision makers the time they need before moving forward
- 15:45with this additional development in their communities.
- 15:48Well, I'm very happy to hear that feedback. Annabelle Sanford is actually joining
- 15:53us as our vice chair for the Market Intelligence Committee at ACEC.
- 15:56And so we're very happy to have her.
- 15:58And so I'm going to make another leap here because it wouldn't be an ACEC podcast
- 16:02unless I talked about policy a little bit. And so water infrastructure is really
- 16:07often described as a bipartisan issue. And you echoed that with me when we spoke before.
- 16:12But, you know, it is when even climate adaptation is not.
- 16:16That seems to kind of change with the party who is in the house.
- 16:20So from your experience, what framing or messaging helps communities,
- 16:24policymakers and partners rally around resilience projects, regardless of their
- 16:29political perspective? out?
- 16:32Yeah, another great question. I think that my first response to that would be
- 16:39cost, the cost of inaction versus the cost of taking action through adaptation.
- 16:45In 2024, the Minnesota legislature directed our pollution control agency to
- 16:52evaluate the projected costs of climate change impacts and the investments needed
- 16:57to improve climate resilience across the state.
- 17:00And that effort resulted in a report called the Minnesota Climate Adaptation
- 17:05and Resilience Cost Study, which was just released in 2026 in March. So just two months ago.
- 17:13And in that study, they found that the cost...
- 17:18That it would cost Minnesota more than $20 billion annually under a high greenhouse
- 17:24gas emissions scenario if additional adaptation measures are not taken.
- 17:30And that by the end of the century, those costs would exceed $50 billion per year.
- 17:35So that's a really compelling argument, no matter what side you're sitting on, right?
- 17:41Right. For taking action. The report also showed that adaptation measures are
- 17:47approximately 8 to 15 times less expensive than projected costs of unmitigated climate change.
- 17:53So if we can share these types of studies,
- 17:58if other states can implement those types of studies, I think it'll be really
- 18:04easy for people to see that, you know, the cost of inaction is not a viable solution.
- 18:09And this would be a huge motivator for anyone to start taking action.
- 18:15And then the other thing I think we should be thinking about is that we should
- 18:20approach our problems as a human issue rather than solely a technical issue.
- 18:25While science and engineering are definitely critical to problem-solving,
- 18:29lasting support is going to be built by understanding people's lived experiences
- 18:34and designing solutions that respond to their everyday needs and concerns.
- 18:38So, effective water management and even climate adaptation requires engaging
- 18:46directly with communities, listening to how flooding,
- 18:49water quality, drought, or infrastructure challenges affect them,
- 18:53and connecting technical solutions to the outcomes that people value,
- 18:58such as public health, economic stability,
- 19:01recreation, safety, and quality of life.
- 19:05Very well said, Camilla. Before we wrap, I just wanted to add one plug here.
- 19:09If you are interested in water resources or anything Camilla talked about with
- 19:14watershed, stormwater management, I would encourage you to get involved with
- 19:18our water committee, water and environment here at ACEC.
- 19:22And Jordan Ball would be the person to get into contact with and we'll include
- 19:27his information in our show notes as well.
- 19:29That is all the time we have for today. Camilla, thank you so much for joining.
- 19:34Thank you so much Diana I really appreciate it absolutely and thank you to our
- 19:39listeners for tuning in to another episode of the Market Edge I'm Diana O'Leary see you next time.