Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 📈 Russell 2000 at Record Discount: Small-Cap Goldmine or Value Trap? A Better Play Than S&P500 From Now On?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome curious minds to The Deep Dive.
- 0:02Today we're plunging into a truly fascinating, maybe even a
- 0:06bit perplexing puzzle in the financial markets.
- 0:09We're talking about the US small cap market, specifically the
- 0:12Russell 2000 index. Yeah, it's really interesting
- 0:15one right now. On one hand, if you just, you
- 0:17know, look at the numbers, some of them, it appears historically
- 0:20cheap, like really cheap bargain territory, maybe, potentially.
- 0:24Yeah, on paper. But then you look closer, and it
- 0:28embodies some pretty acute vulnerabilities.
- 0:31It's this real paradox, a contradiction that just begs for
- 0:35a deeper look. So our mission today is to
- 0:37unpack this whole complex picture.
- 0:40We want to get into its current valuation, put it in historical
- 0:42context, especially next to the big guys, and explore what its
- 0:45behavior really tells us about the the broader U.S. economy.
- 0:49What's the signal here? You definitely hear about the
- 0:50S&P 500, the NASDAQ 100 all the time.
- 0:53They're the Titans, right? Household name, but the Russell
- 0:562000. People often call that the real
- 0:58barometer of Main Street America.
- 1:00That's the common wisdom, yeah. A proxy for domestic activity.
- 1:03So the big question is why is this really crucial part of the
- 1:07market showing such a contradiction?
- 1:09Why is it trading at one of the widest discounts to large cap
- 1:12stocks you've seen in modern history?
- 1:15What's really going on underneath and importantly for
- 1:18you listening, what does it imply for your investment
- 1:21outlook? Let's try and figure it out.
- 1:22It is a compelling puzzle and understanding it well, it means
- 1:26looking way beyond just the surface headlines.
- 1:28We're not just talking about companies being smaller, we're
- 1:30talking about an index with a fundamentally different economic
- 1:34exposure, different sensitivities.
- 1:36And because of that, it's a profoundly different investment
- 1:39proposition compared to, say, the S&P 5. 100 right?
- 1:42Apples and oranges. Exactly the current situation.
- 1:45It really demands A nuanced interpretation, and we hope we
- 1:48can provide some clarity for you today on what could be, you
- 1:50know, either a generational opportunity or maybe a classic
- 1:53value trap. OK, so we've set the stage, this
- 1:56contradiction, this puzzle, Before we really dive into that
- 1:59valuation paradox, we need to nail down what the Russell 2000
- 2:04actually is. It gets mistaken sometimes,
- 2:06doesn't it? Like just a mini S&P 500, but
- 2:08it's really got its own DNA. Absolutely.
- 2:10That's a really common misconception.
- 2:12I mean, yes, both are market cap weighted indices, but how
- 2:16they're built and who's in them that makes them profoundly
- 2:19different. The Russell 2000 specifically,
- 2:22it's a small cap index. It comes from the broader
- 2:24Russell 3000 index. Which covers most of the US
- 2:27market. Yeah, about 98% of the
- 2:28investable U.S. equity market. So from that big list, they take
- 2:32the top 1000 largest companies and kick them out for this
- 2:35index. What you're left with are the
- 2:36bottom 2000 stocks companies ranked like 1001 down to 3000 by
- 2:41size. And this isn't just a small size
- 2:44difference. It means even the biggest fish
- 2:45in the Russell 2000 pond is still way smaller than the
- 2:48average company in the S&P. 500 right, that scale difference
- 2:51alone must change things. It fundamentally changes the
- 2:54economic exposure, the risk profile, definitely.
- 2:57And there's another critical detail maybe a bit overlooked
- 2:59sometimes, but it matters for how the index behaves.
- 3:03It's the annual reconstitution. Yes, the big rebalancing act.
- 3:07Exactly. Every June, like clockwork, they
- 3:10reevaluate the whole list based on market caps from the end of
- 3:13May. It's purely rules based
- 3:15mechanical, but it can lead to pretty significant turnover.
- 3:19Companies growing out, shrinking in.
- 3:20Are getting bought, going bankrupt, all that.
- 3:23And this isn't just, you know, shuffling paper.
- 3:25It's a huge event, billions of dollars moving all those index
- 3:28funds tracking the Russell 2000 they have to buy and sell to
- 3:31match the new list. Forced trading.
- 3:33Right, and that forced trading, it often creates real short term
- 3:37price dislocations, little bumps and dips that active managers
- 3:40try to exploit. Interesting.
- 3:41So it adds its own layer of volatility each year.
- 3:43Definitely a unique liquidity event just for the small cap
- 3:46world. That's a great point about
- 3:48reconstitution. It shows how dynamic the space
- 3:50is. But beyond size and mechanics,
- 3:53there's this other huge difference.
- 3:54You mentioned geographic revenue exposure.
- 3:57This really sets it apart from the S&P 500, doesn't it?
- 4:00Massively, yeah. The S&P 500 is full of global
- 4:04giants, multinationals getting what, like 40% of their revenue
- 4:08from outside the US? Roughly, yeah.
- 4:10They're sensitive to currency moves, global trade, what's
- 4:13happening in Europe or Asia. Global corporate America, as you
- 4:16put. It exactly.
- 4:17And if the S&P 500 is global corporate America, then the
- 4:20Russell 2000 is what's pure Main Street America.
- 4:23It's a stark contrast. Companies in the Russell 2000 on
- 4:27average get over 80% of their revenue from right here in the
- 4:30United. States wow, 80%, that's huge.
- 4:32It is, and that overwhelming domestic focus is what makes it
- 4:36such a pure barometer of the US economy.
- 4:38His performance is just intrinsically tied to American
- 4:40consumer spending, U.S. business investment cycles, the health of
- 4:44regional economies. Literally what's happening on
- 4:46the ground for folks and local businesses.
- 4:48Precisely so. What this means for you as an
- 4:51investor or just an observer is profound.
- 4:54When you analyze the Russell 2000, you're getting a much
- 4:57clearer, less diluted signal about the US domestic economy.
- 5:01So if US consumers pull back. Or small businesses face tight
- 5:04credit. Or manufacturing slows down.
- 5:06The Russell 2000 feels that pinch much more directly, much
- 5:10faster than the big globally diversified S&P 500 companies.
- 5:14It's not just scale, it's a different economic engine.
- 5:17Fundamentally different. So if you say believe the US
- 5:20consumer is resilient or maybe there's a reindustrialization
- 5:23trend happening? The Russell 2000 is where you'd
- 5:25see that reflected most directly.
- 5:27Exactly. It's the purest play on that
- 5:29domestic story. And I imagine this domestic
- 5:31focus translates directly into a very different sector makeup as
- 5:33well, giving the Russell 2000 a unique market flavor.
- 5:36It can't just be a watered down S&P 500 sector breakdown.
- 5:40You've nailed another crucial differentiator.
- 5:42It's structurally different. While sector weights obviously
- 5:45shift with the market, there are consistent key differences
- 5:48between the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.
- 5:52And these differences, they really alter its risk, its
- 5:55return profile, make it sensitive to different economic
- 5:58currents. Like what specifically?
- 6:00OK. Well, for one, it consistently
- 6:02has a higher weighting in financials.
- 6:04But not the big Wall Street banks.
- 6:06No, exactly. Think regional and community
- 6:08banks. Hundreds of them.
- 6:10Their fortunes are tied really closely to the US yield curve.
- 6:14The difference between short term and long term rates.
- 6:17Right. And local lending conditions.
- 6:18So when that yield curve inverts like it has been where short
- 6:21rates are higher than long rates.
- 6:23Their profits, right, Their margins.
- 6:25With significant sustained pressure on their net interest
- 6:27margins, it directly hits these smaller domestic banks in the
- 6:31Russell 2000. It's a much more direct play on
- 6:35US interest rate policy effects. OK, financials.
- 6:37What else? You also typically find a
- 6:39notably higher weighting in industrials.
- 6:40Again, smaller scale. Yeah, smaller manufacturers,
- 6:43logistics firms, business service providers, companies
- 6:47highly sensitive to the domestic business cycle.
- 6:50Think about indicators like the ISM manufacturing PMI if that
- 6:53index measuring manufacturing health starts to slide.
- 6:57These guys feel it first. 1st and hardest, often, they usually
- 7:01have tighter margins, less diverse revenue.
- 7:04They're really the gears and cogs of the immediate US
- 7:06production engine. Then there's significant
- 7:08healthcare exposure. But here's a really critical
- 7:10distinction for. You it's not big pharma.
- 7:12Not primarily the Russell 2000. Healthcare isn't about stable
- 7:15drug giants or insurers like in the S&P 500.
- 7:19Instead it's much more a high stakes bet on innovation.
- 7:22Think smaller biotech firms, often pre revenue medical device
- 7:25companies still in development. So more speculative.
- 7:28Highly speculative, often valued on future potential, not current
- 7:32profits, which means their performance hinges less on drug
- 7:35sales today and more on the availability of cheap capital
- 7:37for R&D. So when credit tightens.
- 7:40Or investor risk appetite dries up.
- 7:43This part of the index can get hit really hard.
- 7:45It's almost a bellwether for venture capital appetite.
- 7:47Early stage funding conditions. Got it.
- 7:50And tech it must be lower. Significantly lower weighting
- 7:53and information technology. The Russell 2000 just doesn't
- 7:56have the mega cap tech Titans. No apples.
- 7:59Microsoft's Nvidia's dominating things, it's tech exposure is
- 8:03more like smaller hardware firms, new software developers,
- 8:07semiconductor companies that are again, often more cyclical and
- 8:10tied to domestic business spending, not necessarily those
- 8:13big global themes like AI. OK.
- 8:14So bringing it all together, financials, industrials,
- 8:17speculative healthcare, less big tech, right?
- 8:20For you, the implication is clear.
- 8:22This unique mix makes the Russell 2000 structurally more
- 8:25sensitive to specific economic variables.
- 8:28It's leverage to the US manufacturing cycle, to monetary
- 8:31policy shifts, especially that yield curve impacting banks, and
- 8:34to credit conditions hitting those early stage biotechs.
- 8:37So it's not just smaller companies, it's a direct bet on
- 8:39the cyclical health of the US domestic economy.
- 8:42Almost a pure bet, which makes it fascinating, but yeah, often
- 8:45more volatile. It really gives you that direct
- 8:47pulse on Main Street's financial health.
- 8:49That breakdown is absolutely vital.
- 8:51Understanding that unique composition really sets the
- 8:54stage. OK, so now let's talk valuation,
- 8:56the price to earnings ratio. the PE is probably the most common
- 8:59metric people look at. But even this basic tool gets
- 9:02tricky with the Russell 2000, doesn't it?
- 9:04Especially distinguishing between trailing and forward
- 9:07earnings. Can you explain that difference
- 9:09and why it really matters here? Yeah, that's an excellent place
- 9:11to start. Because for an index, this
- 9:14dynamic, this sensitive, getting the PE distinction right is
- 9:18paramount. the PE ratio basically price divided by
- 9:21earnings per share. Enough Trailing PE uses the
- 9:24reported earnings from the past 12 months.
- 9:26TCM trailing 12 months. Based on actual results, audited
- 9:29numbers. Right.
- 9:30That's the big plus. It's factual, verifiable.
- 9:32The drawback? It's backward looking.
- 9:34It tells you what did happen, not what's coming.
- 9:37And for a cyclical index like the Russell 2000, whose fortunes
- 9:39can shift fast, looking backward might not reflect the current
- 9:43reality or what's anticipated. OK, so trailing is factual but
- 9:46potentially stale. What about forward?
- 9:48Forward PE uses the consensus analyst estimates for earnings
- 9:52over the next 12 months, so it's inherently forward-looking.
- 9:55It's often preferred for valuing cyclical or growth companies
- 9:59because it tries to capture expected changes and economic
- 10:01rebound to slow down. But it's based on forecasts,
- 10:04educated guesses. Exactly.
- 10:06That's the weakness. Forecasts can be wrong, offer
- 10:09are, especially when things are uncertain.
- 10:11But for the Russell 2000, because it is so sensitive to
- 10:14economic shifts, the forward PE is generally seen as more
- 10:17strategically relevant. It incorporates those market
- 10:20expectations of recovery or downturn, which is really where
- 10:23the investment risk or opportunity lies.
- 10:25OK. Forward PE is generally
- 10:27preferred here, but now here's where it gets really interesting
- 10:31and honestly pretty confusing sometimes.
- 10:33This negative earnings problem with the Russell 2000, it feels
- 10:35like it's Achilles heel for valuation.
- 10:37What exactly is it and why does it mess up the PE so much?
- 10:41Ah yes, the negative earnings problem.
- 10:43It's probably the single biggest challenge in using the Russell
- 10:452000 headline PE ratio. It causes massive distortions.
- 10:49The core issue is simple. A big chunk of the companies in
- 10:52the index, and it varies, but often 30% to 40% are
- 10:56unprofitable, they lose money. 30 to 40%, that's a lot.
- 10:59It is, and these aren't necessarily bad companies.
- 11:02Could be early stage biotech burning cash on R&D, high growth
- 11:05tech focused on market share not profit yet, or just cyclical
- 11:09firms in a temporary slump. OK, so lots of money losers.
- 11:12How does that distort the PE? It's a severe mathematical
- 11:15consequence. When all those companies post
- 11:18losses, their negative earnings dramatically shrink the
- 11:20aggregate earnings for the entire index, the total E and
- 11:23the PE ratio gets tiny. So the denominator gets crushed.
- 11:26Exactly. And when the denominator is
- 11:28tiny, the PE ratio itself skyrockets.
- 11:31You see absurd levels like 100 X or more makes the index look
- 11:34insanely overvalued. Or worse if the aggregate
- 11:37earnings for the whole index turn negative like in the 2020
- 11:39recession. Flash with the PE becomes
- 11:42mathematically meaningless. You'll see it listed as NM not
- 11:45meaningful. Right, you can't divide by a
- 11:47negative number or zero in this context.
- 11:49Precisely so. This extreme volatility,
- 11:51sometimes being totally incalculable, makes the headline
- 11:55Trailing PE a notoriously unreliable guide.
- 11:59Frankly, it often tells you more about the proportion of
- 12:01companies struggling than about the actual valuation.
- 12:04It's highly misleading for a quick.
- 12:06Look. OK, that makes perfect sense why
- 12:07the headline number can be so wonky.
- 12:09So if that's unreliable, how do the pros, the institutional
- 12:13analysts, get a clearer view? What metrics do they use for
- 12:16serious analysis? That's the key question.
- 12:18They know the headline PE is flawed, so they use several
- 12:21alternative, more robust methods to get a stable picture.
- 12:24One of the most common is the forward PE excluding negative
- 12:28earners and E. OK, say that again.
- 12:30Ford PE Excluding negative earners.
- 12:33They basically calculate the PE using only the profitable
- 12:36companies in the index. So they just ignore the ones
- 12:38losing money for this calculation.
- 12:40Essentially, yes. It strips out that distorting
- 12:42effect from the speculative or deeply cyclical loss makers.
- 12:46It gives you a more stable representative valuation for the
- 12:49core cash generating part of the small cap world.
- 12:53Like looking at the healthy part of the index.
- 12:54Exactly what's the real valuation of profitable Main
- 12:58Street America? That's what this tries to show.
- 13:00Another important one, especially given the Russell
- 13:022000s makeup, is the price to book PB ratio price divided by
- 13:07the net asset value of the companies.
- 13:09Book value is more stable than earnings.
- 13:11Generally, yes, less volatile, so PB gives a steadier read.
- 13:16It's particularly useful for valuing companies with lots of
- 13:18tangible assets, like those regional banks and industrial
- 13:21firms we talked about. Their value is often tied more
- 13:24to their asset base. OK.
- 13:25And price to sales. Price to sales PS Price divided
- 13:28by total revenue. This is super valuable for
- 13:31companies that aren't profitable yet but have strong revenue
- 13:33growth. Like those tech and biotech
- 13:35firms? Exactly where future growth
- 13:37potential is the main story, not current profit.
- 13:40PS helps value that growth trajectory.
- 13:42So analysts use these alternatives forward P/E
- 13:46XNEPBPS, Do they use them together?
- 13:49Absolutely. The real power comes from using
- 13:51them in concert. And here's something really
- 13:54insightful for you listening the difference between the headline
- 13:56PE and that PEX negative earners.
- 14:00That gap itself is a powerful indicator.
- 14:03Well, if the gap is really wide, it means those unprofitable
- 14:06firms are a huge drag on the index's aggregate earnings.
- 14:10That usually happens when the economy is stressed.
- 14:12Credit is tight, so a wide widening gap, often bearish,
- 14:16signals trouble at the riskiest end.
- 14:18But that gap starts to narrow if the headline PE starts moving
- 14:21closer to the P/E XNE. That means fewer companies are
- 14:24losing money, or the profitable ones are doing much better.
- 14:27Both potentially it suggests previously unprofitable firms
- 14:30are turning profitable or the overall quality of earnings is
- 14:33improving. It's a strong bottom up signal
- 14:35broadening market health a leading.
- 14:36Indicator for a rally, maybe. Often acts that way.
- 14:39It suggests fundamentals are genuinely turning a corner, not
- 14:41just sentiment. That's a fantastic
- 14:43clarification. Really helps make sense of those
- 14:45potentially crazy PE numbers. OK, so let's apply this better
- 14:49lens, putting the current numbers in context.
- 14:51We hear about a high headline trailing PE, maybe 28X or
- 14:55something, but that's distorted, right?
- 14:57What's the real valuation story now?
- 14:59Exactly as of, say, late 2023, early 2024.
- 15:03The picture is complex. If you just glance at the
- 15:05headline trailing PE that 28 X figure maybe even higher.
- 15:09Sometimes it is heavily distorted.
- 15:11Remember, maybe 3540% of the index components are
- 15:14unprofitable. Stop there.
- 15:15You think? Wow, expensive.
- 15:17But using the better tools. Using the better tools, a very
- 15:19different and frankly much more attractive story emerges.
- 15:22The Ford PE. Looking ahead 12 months, that
- 15:25paints a much more reasonable picture.
- 15:27Around 15X maybe? OK, 15X4, that sounds more
- 15:29normal. It does.
- 15:30And then if you go that extra step, calculate the forward PE
- 15:33using only the profitable companies, the X&E approach we
- 15:36discussed. The cleaner number.
- 15:38Yeah, the valuation looks even more compelling, perhaps in the
- 15:40range of 14.5 X. Wow, barely different from the
- 15:42overall forward PE, which tells you the profitable companies
- 15:46aren't wildly expensive. And it's this forward-looking
- 15:48valuation, especially the P/E X&E, that institutional analysts
- 15:53really focus on and crucially, this figure around 14.5 by 15X.
- 15:58It currently sits at a deep discount not just to its own
- 16:02history, small caps often used to trade at a premium, remember,
- 16:05but a very significant discount to large cap indices like the
- 16:09S&P 500. So the headline number is scary,
- 16:11but the underlying forward-looking valuation looks
- 16:14cheap, relatively speaking. That's the picture.
- 16:16It hints at potential hidden opportunity if you could look
- 16:19past the noise. But this depressed valuation,
- 16:22this cheapness, it's not happening in a vacuum.
- 16:25It isn't arbitrary. It feels like there must be
- 16:27powerful macroeconomic headwinds hitting these smaller companies
- 16:30harder and driving this compression.
- 16:32What are those forces? You've absolutely nailed the
- 16:35Core Drivers. This discount isn't just random
- 16:37market sentiment, it's a direct result of several major
- 16:40headwinds that hurt smaller companies more than the big
- 16:42guys. OK, what's #1?
- 16:43First and foremost, interest rate sensitivity.
- 16:46Small caps are just fundamentally more vulnerable to
- 16:48rising rates. Why is that more debt?
- 16:51Typically, yes. Higher debt loads relative to
- 16:54their cash flow and critically, more of that debt is often
- 16:57floating rate tied to benchmarks that follow the Fed's policy
- 17:01rate. So when the Fed hikes.
- 17:03Their interest expense goes up almost immediately, squeezes
- 17:07earnings, compresses margins right away.
- 17:10Unlike large caps. Many large caps locked in low
- 17:13rate long term debt over the past decade.
- 17:16They insulated themselves better from the immediate hit of rising
- 17:18rates. Their debt costs are more fixed.
- 17:21OK, rates are a big one. What else?
- 17:23Second, beyond just the cost of debt, it's the availability.
- 17:26Credit conditions are absolutely crucial for small caps.
- 17:29They often don't have easy access to public bond markets
- 17:32like big corporations. They rely much more on
- 17:34traditional bank lending for working capital operations
- 17:37expansion. So when the Fed tightens policy.
- 17:39Banks tighten their own lending standards.
- 17:41We see it in the surveys. Like the Feds of Report, Senior
- 17:44Loan Officer Opinion survey. Banks become more cautious.
- 17:47It's choking off the lifeline for small businesses.
- 17:49It can, yeah. It hinders their ability to
- 17:52operate, invest, grow. A credit crunch for small
- 17:56business hits the Russell 2000 directly.
- 17:59Makes sense. Rates, credit.
- 18:02What's the third big one? Their inherent economic cycle
- 18:05sensitivity. We established it's a pure bet
- 18:07on the US domestic economy. Right, Main Street America.
- 18:10So the Fed's aggressive tightening was designed to slow
- 18:13the economy down, to fight inflation.
- 18:15That naturally raised fears of a recession, or at least a
- 18:18significant slowdown. And that hits cyclical companies
- 18:21hardest. Directly impacts investor
- 18:23expectations for their future earnings.
- 18:25When recession fears rise, investors demand a higher risk
- 18:28premium to hold these stocks. They pay less for uncertain
- 18:31future earnings. Pushing the price down, making
- 18:33the PE look lower. Exactly.
- 18:35It's the market pricing in higher risk for that domestic
- 18:37exposure. So these factors, rates, credit,
- 18:40cyclicality, explain the discount.
- 18:42They do, and they reveal A deeper truth about the current
- 18:45valuation. It's not just about past
- 18:46earnings, it's the market putting a price on the
- 18:49probability of two very different futures.
- 18:51OK, lay those out. Think of it like this, buying
- 18:54the Russell 2000 now is sort of like buying a call option on a
- 18:57soft landing. Meaning the Fed beats inflation
- 19:00without a bad recession, right? Inflation cools. the Fed starts
- 19:03cutting rates for small caps. That means lower interest costs,
- 19:07better access to capital, maybe surprisingly resilient revenues
- 19:11in that world. Current earnings estimates
- 19:13proved too low, investor risk appetite comes whirring back,
- 19:16and the PE multiple expands significantly.
- 19:19So earnings E go up and the multiple P goes up.
- 19:22A double whammy rally. A powerful rally.
- 19:24That's the bull case, the generational opportunity.
- 19:27OK, what's the flip side? The bear case.
- 19:29The bear case is it's a value trap in a hard landing.
- 19:32Meaning inflation stays sticky, rates stay high, and we get a
- 19:35recession. Exactly.
- 19:37Higher for longer rates eventually tip the economy over.
- 19:39For these highly levered, cyclical Russell 2000 companies,
- 19:43disaster earnings wouldn't just stall, they'd collapse way more
- 19:47than expected. Now defaults bankruptcies would
- 19:49rise. So the current low PEU wasn't a
- 19:51bargain at all. It gets exposed as a classic
- 19:53value trap. It looked cheap but then the
- 19:55fundamentals fell out from under it, making it even cheaper.
- 19:58The initial discount wasn't enough compensation for the
- 20:00risk. So for you listening, buying the
- 20:02Russell 2000 now is really a bet on that soft landing outcome.
- 20:06It's largely that less about deep value today, more a direct
- 20:10leverage bet on the US economy avoiding a hard landing.
- 20:13The discount is your compensation for taking that big
- 20:16economic risk. It's a really high stakes setup
- 20:19right now. That framing is incredibly
- 20:21clear. It really highlights the
- 20:22conditional nature of the Russell 2000's cheapness.
- 20:25OK. So what does this mean for the
- 20:27broader market picture? Because the most striking thing,
- 20:30as you said, is this chasm in valuation between small caps and
- 20:33large caps. Is it possible we're overstating
- 20:36how unusual this is? Or is this gap truly historic?
- 20:39No, I don't think we're overstating it.
- 20:40It really is a chasm and its significance is hard to ignore
- 20:43right now. Just look at the forward PE
- 20:45ratios side by side. Russell 2000 maybe around 15 XS
- 20:49and P500 hovering around 21 X. That's a huge difference.
- 20:52It puts the Russell 2000A roughly a 30% discount to the
- 20:56S&P 500. That's not just a blip, it's
- 20:59historically wide. Rarely been this extreme.
- 21:02Remember, for long stretches, small caps often traded at a
- 21:05slight premium to large caps. People paid up for that higher
- 21:08growth potential. Right, the idea they could grow
- 21:10faster. Exactly.
- 21:11The current situation is a complete inversion of that
- 21:14historical norm, relative valuation near multi decade
- 21:17lows. It's really unusual, signaling a
- 21:20big shift in investor preference and risk tolerance.
- 21:23And you suspect this isn't just a cyclical thing, just a
- 21:26temporary blip. It feels like it's rooted in
- 21:29deeper, maybe structural differences that have just been
- 21:32amplified lately. Could some of this persist?
- 21:35That's a critical point, and I do think you're right.
- 21:37This chasm isn't just cyclical. It's definitely rooted in
- 21:40several deep structural differences that the current
- 21:42environment, high rates, economic uncertainty, tech
- 21:45dominance has really thrown into sharp relief.
- 21:48And yes, it's highly probable some of these factors will stick
- 21:50around shaping things for a while.
- 21:52Like what? What are these structural
- 21:54drivers? OK, first let's talk
- 21:56profitability and quality. The S&P 500 is inherently an
- 22:00index of quality. Big, stable companies, market
- 22:03leaders, wide moats, strong pricing power, consistently
- 22:07profitable. Resilient businesses.
- 22:09Very resilient. The Russell 2000, as we
- 22:11discussed, has that long tail of unprofitable or barely
- 22:14profitable firms, more innovative perhaps, but often
- 22:17thinner margins, less established, lower aggregate
- 22:20quality profile. So when things get uncertain,
- 22:23investors flock to that perceived safety and
- 22:25predictability of high quality earnings in the S&P 500, you get
- 22:29a sustained quality premium that's structural, amplified by
- 22:32volatility. OK, quality gap, what's next?
- 22:35Second big one, growth expectations and the AI factor.
- 22:38The S&P 5 hundreds valuation is hugely skewed by those mega cap
- 22:42tech stocks, the Magnificent 7 or whatever we call them now.
- 22:45The Giants driving everything right.
- 22:47They're seen as having this unique, almost unstoppable
- 22:50growth path thanks to AI and other tech shifts.
- 22:52That narrative pulls in enormous amounts of capital, pushing
- 22:55their multiple sky high and dragging the whole S&P 500
- 22:58multiple up with them. And the Russell 2000 just
- 23:00doesn't have that. Mostly lacks that dominant
- 23:02theme. It's more traditional cyclical
- 23:04businesses. It doesn't get that same flood
- 23:06of capital tasting secular growth.
- 23:08That's a structural demand mismatch.
- 23:10Makes sense. Quality AI growth, What else?
- 23:133rd Balance sheet strength The S&P 500 Titans Fortress balance
- 23:18sheets. Tons of cash, easy access to
- 23:20capital markets even when credit tightens Russell 2000.
- 23:23Companies generally more highly levered, thinner cash cushions,
- 23:26more reliant on bank loans, credit lines.
- 23:29Making them much less resilient to shocks.
- 23:31Far less resilient to economic shocks, rate hikes, tight
- 23:33credit, their ability to weather storms or fund growth is much
- 23:37more dependent on capital availability and cost.
- 23:39Inherently more fragile in a higher rate world.
- 23:41OK. And the last one.
- 23:43Finally, back to international diversification.
- 23:46The S&P 5 hundreds global revenue base is a buffer.
- 23:48Weakness in one region can be offset by strength elsewhere.
- 23:52A natural hedge. The Russell 2000 domestic focus
- 23:56that becomes a liability on the US economy itself looks shaky or
- 23:58is facing headwinds. No geographic diversification
- 24:01shield. They bear the full brunt of US
- 24:03specific problems. So quality, AI, growth, balance
- 24:07sheets, diversification, these structural factors really
- 24:11explain the gap. They explain a lot of it and it
- 24:13means this valuation spread, this gap between the Russell
- 24:162000 and S&P 500 PES has become a really useful real time market
- 24:21indicator for you. How so?
- 24:23What does it tell us? A wide expanding spread like we
- 24:26see now that signals A narrow defensive market, AK shaped
- 24:30market where a few big winners thrive while the broad based
- 24:33small businesses struggles. Classic late cycle risk off
- 24:36behavior, capital hiding and perceived safety.
- 24:38And if a gap narrows? A sustained narrowing of that
- 24:41gap that would signal a healthier, broader market.
- 24:44More confidence flowing down from large caps into small caps.
- 24:47Higher risk appetite. So watching this spread isn't
- 24:49just about valuation. It's a critical gauge of the
- 24:51markets underlying health, breadth and conviction.
- 24:54A narrowing gap would be a potent sign a healthier cycle is
- 24:56starting. It really helps to see how we
- 24:58got here. Let's look at the history, put
- 25:00this divergent into context. We've got the historical year
- 25:03end trailing PE ratios here. Russell 2000 S and P500 NASDAQ
- 25:08100 from 2014 through 2023, plus current figures.
- 25:13This data really tells a story, doesn't it?
- 25:15It absolutely does. A story of shifting market
- 25:17regimes. Yeah.
- 25:18And just a reminder, as we look at these trailing PES for the
- 25:20Russell 2000, remember that negative earnings problem?
- 25:23Right, the distortions. Yeah, you see NM not meaningful
- 25:26for year end 2020 when aggregate earnings tanked.
- 25:29Those high numbers in 2017 and 2023?
- 25:32They also reflect periods where lots of companies were losing
- 25:34money, suppressing the total E. So the trailing numbers are
- 25:37bumpy, but they show trends. Exactly, they reinforce why
- 25:40forward metrics are often better for comparing, but the trailing
- 25:43history is still revealing. Looking over this decade, you
- 25:45can pretty clearly see 3 distinct market phases.
- 25:48OK, Phase one. Let's call it the pre COVID era,
- 25:51roughly 2014 to 2019. This is the time of low
- 25:53inflation. 0 Interest rate policy, ZIRP from the Fed and
- 25:57look at the R2K versus SPX P/E spread ratio in the data.
- 26:01It was consistently above one point OX.
- 26:03Meaning small caps traded at a premium to large caps.
- 26:06Consistently reach 1.20 X. Sometimes that reflected a
- 26:10healthy risk appetite. Investors were willing to pay
- 26:12more for the expected higher growth of smaller companies.
- 26:15Capital flowed more freely across market caps.
- 26:18Let's worry about profitability when money was cheap.
- 26:20OK, that was the old normal. Perhaps then what?
- 26:23Then the COVID shock and recovery 2020-2021, 2020 you see
- 26:28that NM for the Russell 2000 PE as earnings collapsed.
- 26:31Huge turmoil but brief. Then 2021 saw that massive
- 26:36rebound, fueled by stimulus checks, government support.
- 26:39Which helped domestic small caps a lot.
- 26:41Disproportionately, their earnings bounced back hard.
- 26:43But here's where the Divergent started.
- 26:45Subtly Look at the S&P 500 PE. It expanded even more rapidly,
- 26:49driven by those mega caps stay at home winners.
- 26:51And for the first time in this period, the Russell 2000 versus
- 26:54S&P 500 PE ratio dipped below 1.0 X in 2021 down to .87 X, an
- 27:00early warning sign. Even a small caps rallied.
- 27:02Interesting the relative valuation started shifting even
- 27:05then. Exactly.
- 27:06Which brings us to phase three, the rate hike era 2022 to
- 27:10present. This is where the great
- 27:11Divergent really kicked in. Fed starts hiking rates
- 27:14aggressively in 22 to fight inflation.
- 27:16Both indices saw PES compressed from the 2021 high, sure, but
- 27:20the impact on the Russell 2000 was far more severe, especially
- 27:23if you look at those forward PES we discussed.
- 27:25Even if the trailing numbers here are a bit noisy.
- 27:27Right. The S&P 500's valuation held up
- 27:30much better, buoyed by quality balance sheets.
- 27:33The tech growth story. The valuation gap widened
- 27:35dramatically. The market started heavily
- 27:37punishing leverage, cyclicality and rewarding quality stability.
- 27:41You see the Russell 2000 trailing PE high again in
- 27:4420/23/27 point 9X versus the S&P 24.1 X ratio over one.
- 27:49But remember the distortion. The real story in forward PES
- 27:51was that deep discount emerging. And what about the NASDAQ 100
- 27:54and all this? It's PE is consistently the
- 27:56highest. Yeah, the NASDAQ 100's role is
- 27:59growth dominance. Look at his PE, rarely below 25
- 28:02X, often above 30X. That just screams growth.
- 28:05Stock leadership, heavy tack, high growth consumer names
- 28:08always commands a premium. It's the extreme end of that
- 28:11secular growth narrative that contrasts so sharply with a
- 28:15cyclical valueish nature of the Russell 2000.
- 28:18Really shows the markets bifurcated focus.
- 28:20So looking at this whole decade, what's the big take away for
- 28:22you? The big take away, I think, is
- 28:24that we might be witnessing A genuine market regime shift.
- 28:28That old Norm small caps trading at a premium.
- 28:30It seems broken, or at least seriously challenged.
- 28:33The drivers seem more structural.
- 28:34Now the drivers? Mega cap tech dominance, higher
- 28:37baseline interest rates than the ZIRP era, investor preference
- 28:40for quality. They feel more structural than
- 28:42just cyclical right now, which means a simple reversion to the
- 28:45mean where the Russell 2000 PE just snaps back to its old
- 28:48premium. That's not a given.
- 28:50It might need the old conditions back near 0 rates.
- 28:53It likely would. A return to that premium
- 28:55probably requires a return to near 0 rates and super low
- 28:59inflation in this new normal of potentially higher for longer
- 29:03rates. The fair value for small caps
- 29:05relative to large caps might just be structurally lower than
- 29:09it used to be. That's a.
- 29:09Critical point for long term thinking.
- 29:12Huge implication for asset allocation.
- 29:14You really need to consider the macro impact on small caps much
- 29:17more closely now. OK, let's try and bring this all
- 29:19together. It's been a deep dive, that's
- 29:21for sure. We have this picture of the US
- 29:23small cap market at a really critical point, historically
- 29:26inexpensive compared to large caps, yes, but that cheapness
- 29:29clearly reflects some very real rinse tied to the economy rates
- 29:33credit. So for you listening, how do we
- 29:36frame the investment case now? Is the Russell 2000 that
- 29:38generational opportunity or is it a classic value trap?
- 29:42That really is the core dilemma and honestly the path forward
- 29:45hinges almost entirely on how these macroeconomic
- 29:48uncertainties play out. You can frame the investment
- 29:50case through those two competing scenarios.
- 29:52We touched on almost binary outcomes.
- 29:54OK, scenario 1. The bull case.
- 29:56The bull case, the generational opportunity.
- 29:59This depends completely on a soft landing for the US economy.
- 30:03Inflation cools down towards the Feds target without a nasty
- 30:06recession. The Fed gets the all clear to
- 30:08start cutting rates. And for the Russell 2000?
- 30:11That's the perfect cocktail. Lower rates mean lower interest
- 30:13costs, boosting earnings. Easing financial conditions mean
- 30:16better access to capital. A resilient economy means decent
- 30:20revenue growth. So you get that potential dual
- 30:22catalyst rally. Earnings E rise and the multiple
- 30:25PE expands as risk appetite returns.
- 30:28And that historic discount to the S&P 500 narrows sharply.
- 30:31Leading to dramatic outperformance from this angle.
- 30:34Yeah, the current valuation looks like a highly asymmetric
- 30:37risk reward, maybe a great entry point if you believe in the soft
- 30:40landing. OK.
- 30:41But then there's the other side, the bear case.
- 30:43The bear case. The value trap.
- 30:46This is the hard landing scenario.
- 30:47Inflation stays sticky. Fed has to keep rates higher for
- 30:51longer, maybe even hike more. Eventually, that tips the US
- 30:54economy into recession. For those highly levered,
- 30:57cyclical Russell 2000 companies, it's bad news.
- 31:01Earnings don't just slow, they collapse.
- 31:03Way worse than expected defaults.
- 31:06Bankruptcies among smaller firms rise.
- 31:08Aggregate earnings could go negative again.
- 31:10So the low key E today was misleading.
- 31:13Exposed as a classic value trap, it looked cheap, but the
- 31:16fundamentals cratered, making it even cheaper.
- 31:18The initial discount wasn't nearly enough for the actual
- 31:20risks could lead to long underperformance.
- 31:23Given how different those outcomes are, what should we be
- 31:26watching? What are the key forward-looking
- 31:28signs for you to monitor to see which way things are leaning?
- 31:31That's the crucial question for anyone trying to navigate this
- 31:33tactically, and these forward-looking signs are way
- 31:35more important right now than backward looking valuations.
- 31:38Here's what you should keep a close eye on.
- 31:40OK #1. First, credit markets.
- 31:43This is the most immediate risk. Watch high yield corporate bond
- 31:47spreads, Things like the CDX high yield index or the spread
- 31:51between BA corporates and Treasuries.
- 31:52What are you looking for? If those spreads are narrowing,
- 31:55it means credit conditions are easing.
- 31:57Risk appetite is up. That's good for small caps.
- 31:59Lowers their borrowing costs. If spreads are widening, major
- 32:02red flag signals distress. Tight credit, bad for the
- 32:06Russell. OK.
- 32:07Credit spreads What? Else second key economic data,
- 32:10especially the ISM manufacturing PMI.
- 32:13It's a crucial leading indicator for those industrial and
- 32:15manufacturing companies heavy in the index.
- 32:18A sustained move back above 50 means expansion.
- 32:21It's a powerful tailwind signals stronger demand staying below
- 32:2450, especially if falling negative signal continued
- 32:27contraction ISM third. 3rd, the shape of the yield curve.
- 32:31Super important for all those regional banks.
- 32:33They need a steep curve, long rates higher than short rates to
- 32:35make money easily. So an inverted curve is bad for
- 32:38them, really bad, squeezes their margins.
- 32:41So watching for the curve to steep and especially getting out
- 32:44of inversion is historically very bullish for banks and
- 32:47therefore the Russell 2000 signals a more normal lending
- 32:50environment returning. Right credit, ISM, yield curve,
- 32:54anything else? Finally, don't just look at PE
- 32:57ratios. Track the trend of earnings
- 32:59revisions. Are analysts upgrading or down
- 33:01grading their earnings forecast for Russell 2000 companies look
- 33:04at the ratio of positive to negative revisions or earnings
- 33:06revision breath. If that starts improving.
- 33:09More upgrades than downgrades. That's a strong sign
- 33:12fundamentals are turning up often leads a rally means the
- 33:15pessimism is lifting where it counts future profits.
- 33:17Those are great concrete things to watch.
- 33:20So pulling back to the big picture, what's the strategic
- 33:22take away here? Despite all these risks, where
- 33:25do small caps fit? Strategically, despite the near
- 33:28term worries, US small cap stocks remain an essential part
- 33:31of a well diversified long term portfolio.
- 33:34They absolutely do. They offer unique exposure to a
- 33:37dynamic part of the US economy. They're often where future
- 33:40giants start, and they've historically offered high growth
- 33:43potential over full cycles. Plus, they offer
- 33:46diversification, sometimes outperforming large gaps,
- 33:49especially early in recoveries. So strategically important long
- 33:52term, but tactically tricky right now.
- 33:54Exactly. The current environment demands
- 33:56a more tactical view. That historic valuation discount
- 33:59is compelling, potentially generational, but it is
- 34:02absolutely conditional. It's entirely predicated on that
- 34:04specific macroeconomic outcome. Soft landing, Fed easing Buying
- 34:09the Russell 2000 today is a calculated bet that the market
- 34:11is too pessimistic, that the US economy is more resilient than
- 34:14feared. But not a buy and forget
- 34:16situation. Definitely not.
- 34:17It requires active monitoring. Keep a close watch on those
- 34:20signposts. We just discussed credit ISM
- 34:22yield curve earnings revisions because the risks of a policy
- 34:26mistake or a sharp downturn are real and they are fully
- 34:29reflected in that deep discount you see today.
- 34:32It's a strategic allocation, yes, but one that needs tactical
- 34:35vigilance right now. A keen eye on that macro
- 34:37horizon. Wow, what an incredible deep
- 34:40dive. We've really unpacked the
- 34:42Russell 2000, seeing it's so much more than just small
- 34:45stocks. It's this complex barometer of
- 34:47Main Street USA presenting a truly fascinating, if definitely
- 34:51conditional picture for investors.
- 34:53So as you think about all this, here's a final thought to chew
- 34:55on. What is this persistent,
- 34:57sometimes historic discount we see in Main Street America?
- 34:59Really tell us about the true health and maybe the breadth of
- 35:03the wider market and how much of this huge divergent between
- 35:06large and small, this market leadership concentration?
- 35:09How much is truly structural, maybe a new normal we need to
- 35:12get used to versus just cyclical noise that will eventually fade?
- 35:16We absolutely encourage you to keep exploring these ideas, keep
- 35:19an eye on those key indicators we discussed and form your own
- 35:21informed conclusions about this really intriguing, often
- 35:23overlooked corner of the market. Thanks so much for joining us on
- 35:26the Deep Dive. And just a quick reminder for
- 35:28you, all analysis today is based on publicly available sources
- 35:31and of course, may be subject to revisions or differing
- 35:33interpretations. This content is for educational
- 35:35purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 35:38Always conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 35:40investment decisions. If you enjoyed this, please do
- 35:43like and subscribe us on Apple podcast, Spotify or YouTube
- 35:46channel Deep Value Investing. And don't forget to check out
- 35:48the book list of value investing gems in the episode description.
- 35:51Also, if you'd like to support us and help bring a potential
- 35:54Buffett Indicator app to life, there's a link in the
- 35:56description HTTPS dot www.gofundme.com/turning Dash
- 36:03Buffett's wisdom into a daily tool for investors.
- 36:06Thanks again for listening.