Latest / The Narrative with Aaron Baer / Megan Basham on The Church and the Secular Shift: Who’s Controlling the Narrative?
Transcript
- speaker-0: So what I would say is, hey, set aside whatever you think your genius plans are and just be faithful and God's gonna work it out. a lot less than you think you do about cause and effect in all of these things. And so speak truth, be faithful, evangelize, and then let God decide how these things work themselves out. speaker-1: All right, Aaron Bear back on the narrative with my good friend Megan Basham from the Daily Wire joining us. Megan's sitting in today for our friend Samuel Say, who is unfortunately, as many of you have seen online, detained by ice right now. I wanna unpack that a little bit. but before I do, I wanna just read this statement from the Says that just came out right before we recorded. this is from from the Says. My husband, this is Annie Say, Sam's wife. My husband Samuel Say entered the United States legally and has been working ever since in good faith with a lawyer to obtain permanent legal status. Our family is trying to understand understand what went wrong in the process. In the spirit of Romans thirteen, our family fully supports and respects American law and are prayerfully working to get him home through the legal process. I I wanna say just off the top, before before we dive too much into the the conversation around the Says. I don't speak for the Says. Sam and Annie are are good friends. We are pr praying for Sam right now. I know for a fact Sam and Annie both thought Samuel was here legally, that he was undergoing the process and and was submitting properly to American law. I do just to all of our friends online speculating about what's going on I want to pour you a big glass of settle down juice. because the the conversation online has been absolutely over the top, especially the conversation demanding answers from Annie right now, in particular, of what's going on. I will say, again, what I know in this process is that Sam and Annie were under the assumption that he was in process with his green card and that he was allowed to be here and he was doing everything right. Sam had flown. Multiple times over the last few years and had never gotten held up at at TSA before, had never had any of these issues before. Again, thinking that they had done all of the proper things. Obviously, something has gone wrong. and they are working right now with their attorneys to figure out what those issues are. Sam holds ICE, holds American government, holds DHS in the highest regards. he is a he is a godly man that would not want to ever violate the the sovereignty or the laws of this country. We've talked about that on this very podcast before. the the one thing I I I really would call out in particular is that, if Sam were on a visa, expired visa and was trying to, you know, stay in the country secretly, illegally, all of those types of things, the last thing you would do is go to TSA. The last thing you would do is try to go into an airport and get on a plane and and have to present your Canadian passport and all those documents that he has right now. a mistake or or or something was messed up somewhere along the process. and Sam and and Annie are trying to work through those things right now. I will say, even when I I I I've spoken to Sam since he's been detained, and he made the comment about how he was when he was pulling up to the ICE detention facility, he saw the ICE protesters and he said to me, I wanted to tell them I'm not with you guys. I'm not like I I don't agree with you, right? Like I He he he understands it's important for American sovereignty to maintain our borders, to to deport folks who are in the country illegally, and he's working through that right now. I think my my big encouragement to everybody is to number one, give some space and patience to the SAIs as they work through this. This is this is unbelievably difficult on the family, unbelievably difficult on the community. I do want folks to understand Sam is not an employee of C C V. We've never paid Sam. we we stand with him as a brother and a friend and are hoping that we're able to get him home shortly. But Megan, I guess this is as good a place as I need it to bring you into this conversation as you've been seeing this, processing this, what's been going through your mind? speaker-0: Yeah, the big thing to me, Erin, is one, people always want to sort of supplant the information we don't have with their conjecture. And there's a lot of conjecture on both sides. And, you know, part of what I'm even hearing are people who are Sam's supporters saying, well, this is now a bad law, and this proves that, you know, we shouldn't enforce our borders and that we should change the law. And I think it's really important to underline that Sam and Annie's own statement. belies that and says, no, don't do that on our behalf. We do actually support the rule of law here. We do support border enforcement and, national sovereignty. So, I would encourage people who see themselves as Sam and Annie's friends and supporters to maybe refrain from doing that, since that's obviously not what is on their heart based on their statement that, you know, they don't want people saying, hey, let's now question these laws or question border enforcement. And the simple reporter It we just don't know yet. And it's hard for people to wait. And you know, people kind of wanna rush in and you give the best information that you have at the time. And you see this, you know, not just in this story, but in so many stories, where maybe someone misunderstood something or there was a failure of the process somewhere along the way. And so people wanna assume there must have been nefarious motives, or someone's lying, or, you know, somebody Was deliberately being deceptive. And we don't know what the case is here yet. So I would tell everybody to cool your jets. Because the fact of the matter is there can be miscommunications, there can be balls dropped, and we simply don't know. So it's not helpful to assume that anyone on any side of this has been deceptive or dishonest because new information comes out. And reporters like me, as we get that new information, We give it to you and that will be the case here. And so that really the best thing to do is just wait until more information comes out. And once that's in the rear view mirror, then everybody kind of forgets about this conjecture period. speaker-1: That's right. And I think one d to to to that point in particular about the conjecture period, to to take anything that the say say and say, well, they're not saying this. I I've seen some folks already since the statement come has has come out start to parse, well, they didn't say this and they didn't say that. Well i if if I'm the say's right now, I'm saying as little as possible to not, you know, I I don't want to upset DHS, I don't want to upset ICE, I don't want to upset. Any of the folks involved in this, as we are trying to work through, okay, what happened that that as you said, some some ball got dropped. And was it was it the Saves? Was it was it the attorneys? What what what happened that that led to this conclusion? Because this certainly, again, was not Sam's intent. He's willing to, you know, deal with whatever consequences or or things that that go along with it. But I think first and foremost, To to give some grace and some space in particular to the the Say family as they navigate this and be careful to not just try to take every little word and and try to project meaning on it right now, because the the biggest priority, if if I'm the Says, the biggest priority is how do we get Sam home? and not so much how do I answer every rando on X that wants to have a hot take about what's going on here. speaker-0: Yeah, and not every situation has to be my tribe versus your tribe. These are real people and it's a real situation. So, maybe now is a good time to let's all just sit back and wait for the process to play out. speaker-1: B big old gulp of settle down juice and and then we can all just move on with with our lives. well I will say on top of just you know hurting for my friend and and his family right now, I'm bummed because this would have been a real we we have been trying for quite some time to get Megan on to because we've had a number of disputes that that Sam and I have had over the past few weeks that Megan, we were counting on you to come on and resolve for us. I I certainly would have won almost all of them if you had come on. but but because unfortunately, now we're talking about one that I know Sam would have a lot of fun to talk about, which is the the Christianity today, New York Times like the the the story afterwards, right? Like the the the this always happens every time there is some big fallout, big crisis. and there's always the now you tell us story of what was actually going on on the inside. and Yeah, th this is unpacking why CT continues to hemorrhage staff, continues to hemorrhage you know, readers and and subscribers and things like that. I will say what's what's really disappointing about this story. Now it's the New York Times, so I'm not particularly surprised by it, but it seems like all the wrong lessons are being learned by this New York Times story. And the the title is it's from Ruth Graham. It's Christianity Today. A voice of centrist evangelicalism is in turmoil. So I I got a bunch I want to unpack with you here, Megan, on this story. But when you first saw this one, what was your just first reaction to the to the story? speaker-0: a few things that occurred to me off the top of my head, and this is not going to be new to people who follow me or know my work, but I did do a lot of coverage of Christianity today, in my reporting at the Daily Wire, but also in my 2024 book, Shepherds for Sale, How Evangelical Leaders Traded the Truth for a Leftist Agenda. And I promise this isn't just a plug, Aaron. I'm going somewhere with this. But that was the fact that for a period of time now, particularly since Russell Moore went over and took over first as editor-in-chief and now I think executive editor and then editor at large. So he's had a lot of editorial hats in a really short span of time. But what I wrote about in the book and what I've done some reporting on is one, the fact that Christianity today's constituency over time moved from Christian subscribers and readers and to secular NGOs. So a lot of their funding was coming from grants and from donations. And when you look at some of the people who have been giving money to CT, it's been organizations like the Hewlett Foundation, which is the last time I checked, I think this is still true, the second largest funder of Planned Parenthood in the country. So you know there should have been a very large disconnect and very big alarm bells at one of the most prominent Proponents of the murder of the unborn giving money to a Christian organization. And I think, that should have been something that a lot of people had questions about. And yet, you know, when I brought it up, there was a lot of attack on that. Like, why are you bringing this up? And well, can't they just, you know, fund some things and not others? But the fact was, you know, as that funding was coming in, we also saw Christianity today's editorial stance shift. And the fact is, they have had past editors who have actually come out and talked about this. Mark Galley, who was the former editor-in-chief, when he left, he talked about the fact that the Christianity Today newsroom got to a place where they were very much craving the validation of places like the New York Times. So, you know, he said it wasn't so much what we said as what we didn't report. Like if you took an issue like, say, women in the pastorate, we didn't come out and take an official editorial stance. For women in the pastorate, but we would craft our coverage in such a way that made it look like the people who are for maintaining the pastorate and the eldership within the church as a male only office as something that was a little bit kooky and a little bit disreputable. And so we kind of saw that movement towards that. And, you know, in addition to that, some reporting that I had done was that at one point I went and looked at. All of the donations from everyone on staff at Christianity Today, the political donations. it's been a minute since I did this story. So if I, you know, mess up the years here, give me a little grace. But I think it was from pr roughly like 2016 to 2022. And there had been 72 donations, including from at that time the news editor and the CEO. Of the magazine. So, very prominent people who had donated politically, who were on Christianity Today staff and who were shaping the coverage, all of it went to Democrats, every single penny. And I'm talking about, you know, in some cases, quite extreme candidates like Elizabeth Warren, who has you know argued for shutting down every crisis pregnancy center in the country. So, you know, we're talking about some extreme candidates, and it should have been a no-go for journalists. At a Christian magazine to give money to me. This is my opinion, but to give money to candidates like that was astonishing. And so, you know, when this came out, it wasn't surprising to me. I think it's been going this way, but it's also been kind of this vicious cycle that as they have lost Christian readers and audience, they've had to rely more and more on this outside secular money. And I think it's just, you know, continued. And, you know, I will note, as I did in my book, that pretty much everywhere Russell Moore goes. That secular left money tends to follow. speaker-1: Yeah. Go figure. And that's we I wanna get into Russ Moore a little bit more. someone that, you know, I I've I've known for years and have haven't spoken to for a while, but I think for a lot of us in the evangelical movement have sort of been exposed to really where his positions are. but I I wanna go back to just Shepherds for Sale for a moment. I I gotta tell you just complete random as an aside, just two weeks ago I came into my office and I and somebody had sent me a copy of Shepherds for Sale just fresh on my desk. So so somebody had just read it and was like, You gotta read this book. It's unbelievable. so it's still it's still making making I know. It it's still I at first I saw I was like, boy, am I in is this like second part part two and Megan's coming after me now, but no I was kidding. never the the the W for a lot of Christians, I think it was Shepherds for Sale was eye opening and this is something we'd I I'd been seeing on the political end for a while, right? Things with like the evangelical immigration table, these these sort of grass tops, astroturf organizations that were throwing around the name evangelical, throwing around the name Christian, dressing up what they were doing and really kind of tickling the ears of Bible believing Christians. and Your book showed how systematic it was. Can you just talk a little bit the fact that this was bigger than just a handful of groups? This was bigger than just, a handful of editors at the Christian a group like Christianity today drifting leftwards or, you know, maybe following, you know, succumbing to pressure from the mainstream media, wanting to be accept accepted in the academic circles. This was a systematic effort that is still going on today. Can you talk a little bit about what the the scope of what your book found? speaker-0: Yeah, really when we talk about the the left wing march through the institutions and in many cases the Marxist march through the institutions, it makes sense that After they had captured Hollywood, because it's hard to remember, right? There was once a time that there were a lot of, actually conservative studio heads. And Ronald Reagan, and he was a Democrat at the time, but he was a very, you know, blue dog conservative Democrat who moved. And so you had people like that in the golden age of Hollywood, and over time it became more and more left as they took control of that institution, took control of academia. And then you have the church. Of course they were going to target the church because in this particular case, you had a captive audience. who's not just you know, sitting there every week on Sunday in a pew looking for guidance on how best should we live and how best should we order our nation and our lives. They were also looking for someone to tell them here's how we apply scripture to these questions. And so, you know, it it was in a way kind of inevitable that the same actors and organizations that were looking to capper capture these other institutions were eventually going to turn Their attention to the church, particularly evangelicals, because for so long, evangelicals have been that firewall, holding back the worst of the left's excesses. So if you look at issues like abortion, like authoritarian climate policies, like open borders, all of these things, even when Catholics, even Mormons, I mean, people who you would think would be natural religious conservatives, if you look at the statistics, the majority Slightly favor often the Democrats, all except evangelicals. So, that and evangelicals also happen to be the largest religious constituency in the United States, Protestant Christians. So, it was inevitable that they were going to want to say, okay, how do we get over this firewall? I didn't mention LGBTQ issues either. That was a big one that they went. These are the people who are holding us back at that time legislatively from achieving things like same-sex marriage, marriage, in quotes, of course, from erasing gender distinctives and even male and female and pretending that these are malleable categories when they're not so you know these are the things that happened over I think a a long period of time and then once that happened I think evangelicals were naive So when they had certain leaders telling them, hey, listen, we don't want to be political because we don't want to be too identified with the right or the left, with the GOP or with the Democrats. to a certain extent, I can understand that instinct, but the problem was that proverbial third way and we don't want to identify with one side or the other, assumed that the two sides were about morally equally weighted, and they're certainly not. And and I'll let you jump in here, Erin. But the other problem with that was that it was also a question of category confusion. There was a conflation of evangelism with politics. And they're two entirely different categories. So it was almost like this assumption that you cannot do what is best for your nation and what's going to be, best even for your neighbors, even if they don't know it, I would argue it's best for your neighbors if we have national sovereignty and we control our borders as we can look over in Europe and see. But there was this argument that If we do what's best for our nation, it's going to harm our witness and we're not going to be able to evangelize our neighbors. And so I would argue that was a total category confusion. But well-meaning Christians who wanted to, see as many people brought into the kingdom of God and gaining that eternal life as possible were understandably very susceptible to this message. And it did come from places like Christianity today, like theologian Timothy Keller, the you know, well-known Presbyterian theologian saying, We we have to chart this third way, except that we don't tack on the ground, we don't live in a third-way world. We don't live outside of politics. Politics is policy and it impacts all of us, us, our neighbors, our kids, the gener what we're going to leave to the next generation, the legacy that we're going to leave and the nation that we're going to leave. So it was all kind of to me a little bit if I if I put the most charitable spin on it, it was naive pie in the sky thinking that. You could separate those things and we could just step out and it was all gonna sort itself out. Well, it didn't. Somebody took the steering wheel and the direction they took the car wasn't good. speaker-1: I think Megan, what what's helpful in a conversation like this is l to define terms. I don't I don't want to put you on the spot here, but how would how would you define evangelical? I mean that that's even one of the things that I I I had a problem with this New York Times article's framing in the first place is is the way they talk about what an evangelical is. So when you hear the word evangelical, what does that mean to you? speaker-0: to me it has to be really doctrinally distinctive, right? And I think we can call it mirror evangelical a little bit. Because there are even and this is maybe gonna blow some minds, but I do think there are some people who if you ask them, they would say, I'm Catholic, but if you drill down on their doctrinal distinctives, they they might actually be a little bit more in the evangelical bucket. So they would say things like, You must be born again. Okay, so what does that mean? It means you must put full faith in the sacrifice of Christ on the cross. Whose substitutionary atonement is what gets me into the kingdom of heaven, not my work. So there's an acknowledgement of that. and beyond that, I would also say there is a little bit of a political evangelical movement. And I wanna be honest about that. There are some people who, if you tried to drill down on their doctrine, they wouldn't really get it, but they're just sort of instinctively God and country. They, they, they maybe haven't thought it through, but if you ask them, Do I believe that babies in the womb are full human beings? They would say yes. If you ask them, is male and female real? They would say yes. Can you cross these categories? They say no. so some of it is a little bit of a cultural category, but it is also a doctrinal category. And so, that's part of what the United States is. I think we are we are characterized by a a Protestant Christian founding. So that I I have a good friend who actually told me, and he's a Catholic, so I'm gonna like. put my Catholic shield on that a Catholic friend told me this. He goes, even our Catholicism in the United States, if you compare it to European Catholicism, is very Protestant in flavor. So to me that would mean very evangelical in flavor. And then the other, one other distinctive I would have on that is that it tends to be a lower church approach. It's a little bit more populist. So if you look at, you know, compare it to the main lines, your Episcopalians, your, you know, the the PC USA, Presbyterian I I always forget. I'm a Southern Baptist, so I have to So not the Presbyterian Church of America, but the PC USA, which is the liberal rainbow flag, Black Lives Matter, right? So that's a different group. So they're a little bit more high church and elitist, where I would say, you know, the other group, the PCA, is a little bit, I don't want to say populist because most Presbyterians would probably reject that, but at least they're not mainline. And there are much more, and this is maybe the big one, is that they would all agree that the the final word on what is true is scripture. And so that is the other thing that I would say, even if you are somebody who identifies as an evangelical, but maybe you don't go to church every week, you would still be someone whose grandma and you would say, The Bible said it, I believe it, that settles it. That to me is characteristic of an evangelical. speaker-1: I Megan, I would agree with all that. I tend to use the the word evangelical for me is is most useful in the cultural political sense of understanding a group of people who we order our lives a certain way, we hold to certain truths around you know sort of the inerrancy of God's word. again, whether he would even say that, right? It's just we just about the truth of the Bible would probably be the best way of of putting it. Like I I want to be careful when when defining this because You don't wanna you honestly don't want to get too high minded with it. It's it's a it's a baseline of a of of a a tie that bind to what I think is best used to understand how folks vote and how folks order and structure their lives. Right. E everything else, that that's where I think denominational ties or or very specific theological, identifiers can can help us better understand things. But evangelicalism at large is a conservative, Culturally minded, politically engaged group of people that make up a very large section of the population. maybe one of the most, coherent, connected voting groups in the country, that that tend to go a very certain way. It's one of these things that I I talk a lot about that, you know, evangelical voters will almost never vote Democrat. They just won't vote. Right. Right? They'll just stay home. Right. that the these and and I think this is an important conversation when understanding this New York Times story about CT and understanding where CT went astray is that the fact that the the word centrist evangelical is an oxymoron. speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. speaker-1: It it it is it's and I think your what you added to start this off so perfectly explains how CT got here because they took something that you know honestly. hits home for me because one of my one of my great mentors, the f somebody I I I very much was honestly his book changed my life. Tom Minery, why his book, Why You Can't Stay Silent, he was the former vice president of Focus on the Family. he was the first news director at Christianity Today. He worked for for Billy Graham. and, you know, to see where CT went from when Tom was there, which was, hey, you know, we wanna write news that this This population of the American public is going to be relevant to them, to where it came to today is heartbreaking that that that it went that way. And I think even just the the title of this of this article shows why what CT has been doing, is doing, is is destined for financial failure, just because one, there's not enough people to financially support this, and then all that's out there left. is the sort of left-leaning hackery foundations that want to hijack names and brands for their useful purposes. so I I do though I I want to throw out three names because this is one of these things that I I never want to revel in naming names at the same time. I think it's important when we're looking at what's going on in Christianity and not just What's going on Christianity in America today? There are people that are leading folks astray and and have done some real damage, I think. So there's there's three names that jump out to me when I think of Christianity today and where it's gone over the last five years. Mike Cosper, Russell Moore, Marvin Alaski. I'm interested in your perspective on on these three men. And again, I w Megan, I want to be extra careful. This is not meant to be gossipy, but these are three men that have. Put themselves out there as Christian leaders. And I think it's important for us to be able to say, hey guys, hey, Christians at large, we need to be careful of these three men. I I would say, I want to interest in your perspective. We need to be c careful of their writings and their perspectives because it's it's I would say not leading people faithfully towards God's word and sort of cult a a biblical Christian engagement in culture today. speaker-0: Yeah, and one of the marks that has sort of characterized gentlemen like that, as you just brought up, was this obvious disdain. For the evangelical voter as they moved into the Trump era. And not a lot of questioning about, well, how did we get here? Yeah. What caused the rise of Donald Trump? And what did we support and promote that sort of allowed that to happen? Because you know, sometimes I like to correct the record because the New York Times and other outlets will sort of pretend that Donald Trump was an evangelical phenomenon initially. And that's actually not true. speaker-1: Very much not the case. speaker-0: Not at all. If you go back and look at where evangelicals were in the primary of twenty sixteen, they the the the bulk of them were aligned behind Ted Cruz prom pro predominantly and a couple of other candidates, but predominantly Ted Cruz. And most of them said they didn't like Donald Trump in twenty sixteen in the primaries and they did not move over to him. I was one of them. And I to total transparency, I was one of them. speaker-1: So here's my limit test. Were you a cruise person or a Rubio person? speaker-0: I was a cruise person. speaker-1: See, I I was a You were Rubio? Me, me and Eric Tietzel, we were like the the the team like Rubio. And you know, and I like it was we always joke because it was like there we were getting ready to have the big debate between like I remember like FRC and all these groups, we're gonna have the big debate between Cruz and Rubio, and then the Trump train just came through and bulldozed all of us. And it was like what is going on here? We we we miss something bigger going on in culture. speaker-0: Erin, I I distinctly remember during that twenty sixteen primary, we had a dear friend of ours. She was getting married and her lease was up, and she c you know, kind of one of those single people things when you're getting married and you don't you haven't moved in with your husband yet because the wedding hasn't happened, so you need somewhere to live for a few months. So she was living with us and she was a sweet teacher, still a good friend, but you know, in her early twenties and just kind of becoming politically aware and here I am, this reporter world and and sh so she's living with us and she didn't really pay attention to politics and she would ask me a lot of questions during that primary season and she'd come home from work and see me raging at the television at whatever the new political news was that day in terms of how the primary campaigns were going. And you know, I would tell her, This is terrible, this is gonna destroy us, that you know, and and look, I mean some are gonna seize on this comment and go, and it did. Now I don't believe that. I think, you know, we're just We're seeing growing pains and things are going to change and shift. And I don't think the Republican Party is ever going back. But at the time, I was with all of them. So but I think there was a certain hubris, and I experienced it in a front row seat in terms of people like now I didn't know Mike Cosper. I had interviewed Russell Moore, I think I'd met him once, but I didn't really know him personally. But obviously, Marvin Alaski I had worked under for a lot of years. I watched the crack up in real time and it was a very personal thing for me. And so you know, with Marvin, I it felt like there was this almost this anger that the the evangelical movement, once we l once Ted Cruz and Rubio and all, you know, the other choices lost and it was Donald Trump, there were some of us who said, Okay, what is our alternative? It's Hillary Clinton. We want the best for our nation and for our kids. And so we're going to line up and we're going to say, he may not be everything I would want. And there are certainly things that I would disagree on. And, we can get into all the tonal questions. Yeah. But, as a Christian, I have to steward this vote to the best of my ability. And at at the time, and even still, I go, I can understand sitting out. I could not understand the people who moved over into Camp Hillary. And even further, those woke wars were very much as Vodie Bacum. called it the fault lines that cracked open. So we started to realize that Donald Trump was n in my opinion, not the cause of this crack up. He was symptomatic of it because I suddenly realized all of this time I thought we were all on the same page. And I'm now starting to realize that we are not on the same page. And it was with things like COVID, you know, when the government authoritarianism came out and there were these directives from various state and local governments to shut down your church. As a journalist working under Alaski, I was waiting for us, we question, right, the powerful. We ask, why are they doing this? Is this something that we as Christians should support? And we try to provide the breadth of Christian thinking on this. And suddenly it felt like, no, we're not going to do that. Our job is actually to prop up the the respectable line. And to me, it was more a question of Of culture than conviction. they were embarrassed about who the audience was. And I I say that because I think this is a really important piece of this Christianity Today story now. And that is the fact that I believe that the three gentlemen that you just mentioned, all of them in various ways started to evidence that they were embarrassed of the base that they were a part of, and they were embarrassed of the coalition that they were a part of, because there was a certain hubris that, hey, We don't like this and we've been the leaders of this movement and we have been the prominent voices and now you're not doing what we say. And so instead of, you know, kind of reflecting on, well, why? Why are they viewing this differently? Instead it became a demonization effort. And it became here is why these people who are continuing continuing to support Donald Trump are somehow morally lacking. Like if you remember, for example, Timothy Keller put out a piece, and I don't remember the exact title, but it was in The New Yorker, I think it was. That was can evangelicalism survive Donald Trump? And that was such a wrong headed question to me because it was asking, Will the church survive Donald Trump? And the question is, the answer is yes, of course. that of course the church is gonna, you may not like it, it may, shape us in different ways, but the church is gonna be fine. And the Donald Trump era is very soon gonna be in the rearview mirror. So, that was part of it. But then the other piece of it was realizing. On things like ethnic partiality and critical race theory. I speaker-1: my gosh. Yeah. speaker-0: watched people that I thought I knew. And again, I didn't know Cosper and Moore very well. I didn't know Cosper at all. I knew Moore very superficially, but I knew Marvin Lasky. And it felt like there I I didn't recognize the kind of coverage that we were doing. I have told this story before, but the reporters who left World magazine, and I Always preface this by saying they left World magazine, they're not there, because I constantly get people saying, Well, didn't World and listen, those people left, they were disgruntled, they were angry that World would not kneel to this, wouldn't buckle to it. So they left and went to Christianity today. And I am assuming that a lot of them are no longer there and I haven't checked on individuals, but so you saw a very distinct direction of the two, Christian evangelical publications. The people who left and went over to Christianity today. These were the same people who, for example, when I wanted to schedule an interview, in fact, I did schedule an interview, and everyone has to remember this is before Vodi Baccom was very well known to wider evangelicalism. He was he was known to people who were very in the know, but you know, to a lot of the broader evangelical movies. speaker-1: He wants speaker-0: Deep track is a good way to put it. He was sort of a revelation when he came out with fault lines. And before that book came out, I had scheduled an interview with him. And I I felt great, right? Because I'm like, I've scored this great interview. This is definitely going to be a buzzy book. He's an insightful, extremely biblical teacher. So I think it's going to be beneficial to our audience to hear what he has to say about these subjects. And quite frankly, you know, he was a six foot three or something, imposing black man who was has this deep baritone and coming into the pulpit and saying, Here are the scriptural problems with this critical race theory teaching. And so when I scheduled this interview, I'm like, this is journalist gold, And that I had colleagues at that time who later departed to Christianity Today who rebelled and complained. And I actually had to put that interview on the shelf. It I didn't get a chance to do it because they I was told it's going to offend these reporters who were very close to Marvin if you run this interview. And that to me was so inimical to inimical to everything I knew about reporting. That I went, look, we're gonna present his point of view. And if you want to interview somebody else and you know we can have a debate about that, fine. But this was, you know, reporters who should know better saying, we don't think you should interview him at all. Because if you do that, it's going to be hurtful. And that was a form of not just of journalism, but of Christian discourse that I didn't recognize. That I go, well, we don't get hurt Feelings when someone is not, being abrasive or being insulting or, deliberately hurtful, but just saying, here, here, here is my scriptural perspective on why the CRT stuff is not biblical. And so now all of these things, ironically, it turned out that when I wasn't able to interview Bodie Bacum in that season, it turned out that he was predicting that everything that was gonna eventually come from that. speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah, I I Megan, I I wanna ask you just as a reporter, and this is again, we're we're literally trying to walk this line right now as we speak. just just to the Mike Cosper side, because Mike is very talented person. you know, the rise and fall of Mars Hill podcast was, you know, just from a as a as a produced product was was well done. But there was such a One, th there was such a reveling in the fall and the fallout of this church falling apart. and so and that again, that was one of these things and you'll see this sometime in like the the Royce report and Julie Royce and and you know, th there there's there's other folks that that will do this from time to time. And, you know, there obviously is a place in in journalism today, especially in Christian journalism, for talking about failures. within the church and and things like that went on with Ravi Zacharias and things like that, we we should be able to talk about those things. And I think it is good when Christians bring these things forward. as you cover the church, what's what's your when you find something going on within the body of Christ that is embarrassing, that is, you know, is going to be used by some leftist or atheist to be like, see, you can't trust these Christians. What's the way you go about it? What are the thoughts that go through your mind as a reporter on trying to cover failures and and and mess ups and embarrassments within the body of Christ? speaker-0: Yeah, and just to circle back really quick, I I realized as you brought up the Mars Hill podcast, I wanted to make one more point about Christianity today. And that is that I think it a little bit became, in addition to these other factors I've brought up, a victim of the success of that podcast. Because they found an outside audience beyond evangelicals with that podcast. And it sort of became their brand. So we can talk about Mark Driscoll. And I'm gonna be totally transparent. I did not finish that podcast. I was I I had a lot going on in life at that time and I have listened to I think maybe the first four or five episodes. the speaker-1: The end of it especially is where you could tell they start drinking their own Kool-Aid. Right. speaker-0: And that's speaker-1: There there's interesting stories to talk about what happened at Mars Hill and all of these different things and lessons to be learned and and and all of that. But there there was just by the end of the podcast, was just look how and and look how awesome we are. We're the good Christians that are willing to talk about this. That just was gross. I don't I don't know how to say it. speaker-0: You well, and you in those first four or five episodes that I did listen to, it was very evident that it was a it was intended to be a critique of much more than Mark Driscoll and his church. It was intended to be a critique of conservative evangelicalism, but more specifically, the complementarian evangelicalism that does believe that the pastorate is reserved for men and that men and women have distinct roles and that Male headship, yes, still holds in the family and in the church. And so it became very evident that their purpose was to critique more than that. And to that aim, when you listen to the experts that they interviewed, they were LGBTQ affirming leftists who were the experts. And that was what was so unbelievable. And I went, okay, if you wanted to critique these things, that's fine, but you should get doctrinally sound people to do the critiquing. And that is what I mean by Christianity Today became a victim of that to the point that I then think that, they felt comfortable with things like publishing that Elizabeth Elliot piece, which and this gets to your other question that you say, okay, if they found something like that on Elizabeth Elliot, and if I found that, as much as I treasured and benefited from Elizabeth Elliott's teaching, what would I do if I came up with a piece of information like that? Well, the first thing you have to do is absolutely document and verify and get, further proof because otherwise we are trafficking in the realm of gossip. And not just that, but a lot of Melissa Griffin, I think she goes by Melissa the homemaking mater on Twitter was just an ordinary person who came along and looked at that Christianity Today reporting and somebody who knows Elizabeth Elliott's legacy very well went, Hold on a minute. I went and listened. To the original interview, and you are mischaracterizing this, and you have these details wrong. And that is the kind of thing that I went. They became a victim, I think, of wanting to serve the audience who was actually evangelical critical rather than the evangelical audience who was supposed to be their readership when Billy Graham started the magazine back in the 1950s. Because remember, it was actually started to provide a conservative and less elitist alternative to other Christian magazines at that time. And so they actually became the thing that it was founded to to interrogate. And so, you know, there's just this huge irony in that. So I think you can draw a direct line from what Marshill was to that Elizabeth Elliott piece. and and one more piece on the Marshill thing and I'll wrap it up. But it was so ironic to me to have the same magazine that had sort of looked askance. At John MacArthur for his early, early voicing of concerns about Mark Driscoll. Yeah. And had then turned around and go, well, you know, however many years later, now we're producing this podcast and we're quoting MacArthur on it, but we're still not giving any Mc MacArthur any credit for having had some early discernment on this question. Yeah. Because, you know, he was in the wrong camp. So there was also a very tribalistic nature to it. And so all of that is is of a piece and it was just a a train that couldn't be stopped in a certain sense at that point because that was where they had found their success until eventually they ran out of track in that direction. speaker-1: Well, Megan, this is a good place. I want to play this clip for you that I that was just on X earlier. This it's a segment from Josh Howarton's podcast. and when I saw it, it it hit home because it ties so much into I I really do think there there needs to be a a full unpacking of what happened in evangelicalism, especially in the twenty tens. Cause I I just really saw on a real personal level, lived through. What this sort of cultural wave that was led by Tim Keller and Russell Moore and so many, what it did across the country and was exposed by by Donald Trump and some of these other things that happened down the line. and I I love the humility of of Josh Howarton in this. Joe, let's go ahead and run that clip. Until late 2019, I was more that hey, neither left nor right. Hey, j just in general, try to stay switzerland. Don't say something. That would alienate people who are more committed, politically progressive. You know, that was me. And honestly, there's a little bit of like where I just like I look back and I I see I'll be very honest. Where I look back at like 2000 late eight 2018 Josh's preaching, I have like a heart of repentance and sorrow for it. And then I I just had a breaking point where I realized, like, like we actually have a moral responsibility as the church to oppose evil. You guys know that there's the parable of the the wedding banquet. And Jesus is like, Hey, so like there's this group of people that I invited to the wedding, and I kept inviting and I kept inviting, and they and they wouldn't come. And it was all the like elite people of the city, and they didn't come. And so eventually then Jesus went, Well then fine, I'm gonna go out to the fields and I'll I I'll invite the blue-collar dudes that are out there with dirty hands, and let let's see if they'll come. And and they came. And in a little bit, man, I honestly feel like that's what happened to Pat. In the last like six to eight years is this like we tried to tailor make this missiology from like this imagined secular progressive elite person that was in our heads and we spent all these years going, Hey, why don't you come? Why don't you come? And man, God saves everybody. He saves everybody and it's a heart for everybody. But in general They didn't. And what I feel like is happening right now is God's going, you know what, man? Let me go get that dude with his hands that are dirty out in the field. And that that guy that people said was a a little deplorable and really didn't matter. And and he's like, Will you guys come? And it's like, yeah, hey, I've chosen what's weak in this world to shame what's wise. And I've I've I've chosen what's foolish in this world to shame what's strong. There's so much more that could be said. I'm not saying there's only one type of person that Jesus is saving right now, et cetera, et cetera. Caveat, caveat, caveat. But what I what I would say is hey man, the five of us. Are saying to you as a pastor, the fields are really ripe for a harvest, if you're just willing not to have to be the dignified guy? speaker-0: I love that clip. speaker-1: When I my gosh, when I when I saw that, that that wrecked me. Cause it cause it really is when I think back to you know the the the the twenty tens and the the tribe that I was sort of following at the time, right? Especially pre 2016, it was this pseudo intellectual Christianity. You know, we all love Tim Keller books. You know, honestly, Russell Moore's book onward was like a Really impactful book for me. and and it it was one of these things that like there was an idea of like we were gonna do Christianity better than our forefathers. Right? We can we can be more loving, we can be smarter, more scripturally based. and you know, and and again, I would throw the Acts 29 stuff in this, and and you know, it was. It was really big again in in a lot of those like the the young reformed and restless movement that a lot of folks would talk about. but it was also it was all over the place, right? You you see even Josh Howerton who's coming more like an Assembly of God background talking about this stuff. And I'll say two things with it. Number one, you know, I remember at the time we were living in Phoenix. I was you know, we were really connected to a community in this way and we had a small group and It was pretty good sized small group, about twenty to twenty five of us, young professionals, starting families, all of that. And honestly, Megan, like two thirds of those people in that small group who I loved dearly, like we did life together. We were the church together. Two thirds of those people aren't following Jesus today. Right. It was it was so much of the, you know, w especially when the Trump stuff hit. well, we shouldn't talk this way and then starting to question some of the LGBT stuff. I I literally remember one of them was like, Well, g does God really have this view of homosexuality? And you know, I was like, Yeah, it's pretty black and white. And then like literally like a month later we get the call of like, Yeah, I don't think blood atonement was necessary. And I'm like, Well well then you're just not a Christian now. Like I I don't I don't even know what to like we're now now we're on a whole other conversation. but just for for you personally, outside of the the the broader movement and and I will say the thing to me that was the the end of whether we want to call it winsome Christianity or whatever it was, for me it was wasn't even the twenty sixteen election. It was twenty s 2017 when Trump started appointing, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh and all of these like I think for all of us that had questions about Trump, it was like, well, hey, hey, listen, he was married three times. He's a liar. He's telling us all these things, but he's not going to do them. And then he starts doing them. And instead of our reaction being like, thank God I was wrong. Like this was this is phenomenal. The answer was, no, he still is evil and I was right the whole time. And he look, he's still being mean on Twitter. And it's like, no, that that's not what the conversation ever was. And that that to me was the the beginning of the end of okay, I'm I'm done with trying to prove myself to some amorphous progressive elite that I'm gonna somehow win over with how much nicer and smarter I am than than the rest of what they expect evangelicals to be. I d I don't know, what what was your walk experience with this? speaker-0: Yeah, and look, that was my exact experience, is that, in twenty seventeen I started to go, huh? Okay. And look, I I did hold my nose and vote for him, but it was a hundred percent holding my nose. I was bitter, I was angry, I really did expect him to be a disaster in that first term. I If you had told me that this is going to and I understand that we, still have a lot that we have to work out on how to capitalize the overturning of Roe and how to convert that into real meaningful policy wins. And obviously that hasn't happened yet, but it created the opportunity to do it. So we're still figuring that out. If you had told me that the election of Donald Trump was gonna lead to the overturning of Roe, I there is zero way I would have believed that at the time. But what it showed me was also a fracture. Of what we saw in that clip, and that was the difference between arrogance and recogniz recognition that you could be wrong and how things will play out, and that none of us are prophets or the sons or daughters of prophets, and we don't actually know how this is going to work out. And you know, that was what I saw is that look, God can throw you a lot of curveballs, and you don't know how this is going to go down. So, you know, steward. Your vote and your political influence and all of these things to the when we're talking about things in this sphere to the best of your ability. And there was also this question, as you talked about that parable, of assuming that we know what gets to people, that we know what will reach someone for Christ, that if we are less distinctive about some of these Culturally divisive issues like abortion, sexuality, gender identity, if we minimize those, that's going to be the best way to win people to Christ. If we if we sort of do this thing where we bait and switch and we don't talk about those hot button things up front, then maybe we'll get them in the door. And eventually they'll figure out what we will really think. And by the time they get there, they'll be persuaded. Well, that didn't work. As you just said, a lot of people fell away. And so I think there was a certain arrogance in truly thinking that we know better than scripture that if we do this little cool program, this sophisticated program, it's going to bring all the people in the door. When instead what it did was lead, for example, Russell Moore's ministry partner, Ray Ortland, to put up posts saying vote for the most pro-abortion candidate that this country has ever seen. And so, you know, that's how far this got from any sort of Christian logic. in how we should do politics to say vote for Kamala Harris. that was the most stunning just refutation of that entire philosophy that I'd ever seen. And you know, when I look back about it, I I just go, I talked for I'm I'm not gonna name names here because I haven't asked permission, but I yeah, I just happened right before we came on the show to have lunch with a friend. and you know, I've covered film and entertainment for a lot of my career. Who is very plugged into Hollywood. He's had a lot of success with secular, but he's a Christian, and there are Christian themes in the entertainment that he has created, both novels and movies and series, and and so He was telling me that he's talking to people like the biggest names, some that you would not believe in the entertainment industry, in both music and film, who are actually now either becoming Christians or becoming very open to Christ in this atmosphere, in the very atmosphere that we were told would be repellent. And I bring this up because I think you can also see it on the ground. Like nobody would have said, Hey, if these things happen. Young men are suddenly going to become much more interested in Christianity. no one could have predicted that. And I wouldn't have predicted it. So what I would say is, hey, set aside whatever you think your genius plans are and just be faithful. And God's going to work it out. So that's really, my what I learned from all of this is a lot less than you think you do about cause and effect in all of these things. And so, speak truth. Be faithful, evangelize, and then let God decide how these things work themselves out. speaker-1: Well, especially again when you look at the things that they were telling us to to walk away from or downplay, right? things like the the abortion or things like transgenderism or things like homosexuality, which again are are so much bigger than just the the sinful act or thing itself. It's it's a whole identity that is consuming people and and and destroying souls. or d again, the the the race piece of it, of just even that piece of your your entire identity rests in your race and and who you are in this whole system of of oppressors versus the oppressed. and again, this is one of these things that I I I do frankly still have a little bit of of bitterness at it, and and my wife and I, Maria, we'll we'll talk about this sometimes of like we took that real seriously, right? If somebody comes And calls you a racist or or or somebody says, hey, there is systematic racism going on here. Your your first impulse as a Christian, you you you want to hear. You want to say, okay, let me let me try to understand. And especially when it's somebody who's an authority, who's written books, who's all all of these types of things, you take it at face value. And then you actually look under the hood of it and you're like, this is actually super dumb. Like, like not just wrong. But just intellectually hollow. And and like this very quickly we can understand why this is stupid. And and again to to not you know, e even like with things like Islam, right? Like I I remember so much push around, well, we gotta be friendly around Islam. It's like you know what actually is more friendly if we're talking about Islam is is saying women shouldn't have to cover their heads and should be allowed to be around men, right? That that's actually more loving to my Muslim neighbor. Than being like, your worldview is a good one. And it's like mine. We're both basically the same. no, that that's actually not helping them, and especially not helping when we look at Islamic majority countries, the the prosperity, the the my my least favorite word, and I I I I I'm serious, Megan. This word is banned at CCV my our comms team is gonna laugh at me when I say this. human flourishing, like we're a bunch of flowers. I I have no idea what it means to flourish as a human be as a person that is just the most nonsensical word that I've ever heard. I I I I want my family to do well. I want us to to earn. I want us to learn. I want us to to continue to to to grow. But like we we've we allowed ourselves to get I don't know, really bullied, I I guess is the best word for it. So I I do want to ask though right seriously. w what do you do to this day with say the writings of Tim Keller. 'cause I will say there are some things. Tim Keller's book on prayer, I still think is one of the the best books on on prayer there is today. How do you any of those folks that we we read a lot in the twenty tens, how do you engage with their their writings, their work today? speaker-0: Well, I'll be totally transparent that i in the in the busy season that I'm in, I d I kinda don't go back and engage in a lot of old books these I just don't have the time. So but is it but as a hypothetical question, I I guess I would say You look back on it and you don't assume that we throw anyone out part and parcel. And I think what we've seen is a lot of straw man debates where you're like, look, if I criticize something about this, even I th if I think someone was wrong on some really big questions for our moment, it doesn't mean I'm saying that person's a heretic or not a believer, I'm not gonna see him in heaven or there was nothing valuable to take from them. Not saying that. And so, you know, the first thing I would say is that, you know, we need to back away from assuming that if I have said that someone's teaching in this area Or particularly his political commentary or his cultural commentary was not helpful on these issues. It doesn't mean we're saying that person is in hell. And I want to add to that, I have actually seen people say that. And I think it's fair to rebuke that, you know. I because I have seen it and I'm like, wow, that is speaking of arrogance, that's an incredibly arrogant thing to assume that you can render that judgment. So I would say that. But on the flip side, obviously you have to read it in the light of experience now and not you so we can look at it in scripture and go, we already had an issue with it scripturally. And I think now we can also have an issue with it practically because we can see that it did not work in the way that we were told it was going to work. And I I also think we have to be a little bit unapologetic about it because there was very much and personally I felt it and I I'm sure a lot of people watched me experience it publicly who bought the book. this touch not the Lord's anointed, you know. And I think we very much have to not do that. So there was this, and I understand it, you love that person, but there was this how dare you, you know, and I go, if you want to bring in how dare you to me, then you better back it up and say, You're wrong. He did speak about because I'll I'll give you an example. I have frequently said, look, Kirsten Powers, for example, wrote a memorial about Tim Keller where she said, I was in that church for many years and I never heard him preach about abortion or, sexuality or these issues from the pulpit. And I have said, I have not been able to find it. And I have had people come to me and say, You are wrong. He did. And I will go, Great, give me the link, and I will listen and I will happily say, But if you're going to say you're wrong and how dare you, then you need to back that up with evidence and say, look, I'm not trying to be rude, I'm not trying to be combative, but here's the evidence, you're wrong, he did. And that's fine, but I don't see that happening. Instead, I see an approach of we're gonna make you disreputable if you don't concede this. And I don't know if, like Donald Trump, I have a particularly pugnacious personality, but I'm like That's not going to work. You're just gonna make me disreputable, and I'll be disreputable then, and that's fine. but we have to do that too, right? and I've had to do that myself with you know the own my own sort of revered in many ways the father of my faith, John MacArthur, when people have come after him and I say that's not true. I have to be prepared instead of just going, How dare you say this about someone who is beloved to me? Say, no, no, no, that's not true. And here's the sermons where he addressed that, and here's how you're taking them out of context. So let's all of us be willing to do that. Instead of just, writing these screeds that are the how dare you screeds, let's just reason together. So that is probably my, biggest piece of advice. speaker-1: Well, Megan Basham of the Daily Wire, I I'm so grateful for the work you do and for you taking the time to to hop on with us today. I know you've got some morning wire pieces coming out. speaker-0: We do, yes. speaker-1: Yeah, w what what are you covering right now? What what can folks be looking out for that that you're working on right now? speaker-0: Yeah, I actually have an immigration story tomorrow, ironically enough. So I'm gonna go work on that this afternoon. But I I would always make time for you. You guys are my favorites. So I love you and I love Sam and I'm I'm sorry that I'm sitting in this seat right now, but to bring it full circle, just praying for him and for all of you who are close to him. speaker-1: Yeah, amen. We appreciate you, Megan. And again, go listen to the Morning Wire. For everybody who wants that good morning news, follow Megan there. Follow our on X. It's always a lot of fun. And we'll catch you here next time on the narrative.