Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Cross-Examining Experts in Medical Malpractice Litigation with Benjamin Ikuta and Michelle Hemesath
Transcript
- 0:02Okay. Hello, everybody. I am delighted to introduce
- 0:10our speakers today for cross -examining experts
- 0:13in medical malpractice litigation. Oh, I think
- 0:18Ben already started screen sharing, which is
- 0:20fabulous. So our speakers today are Michelle
- 0:24Hemiseth and Benjamin Ikuta. Michelle is a founding
- 0:29partner at Akuta Hemisath LLP. Michelle's practice
- 0:33is focused on representing injured victims and
- 0:36their families. She began her career representing
- 0:39health care providers and learned from some of
- 0:41the best defense attorneys on the West Coast.
- 0:44During this time, Michelle gained invaluable
- 0:47experience and intimate knowledge of how insurance
- 0:50companies handle lawsuits, how to best position
- 0:53a case for trial, and how to wade through complex
- 0:56medical issues. Benjamin Okuda is an ABOTA member
- 1:01and a founding partner at Okuda -Hemiseth LLP.
- 1:06Ben focuses on cases of medical malpractice,
- 1:10elder abuse, and personal injury. He is a preeminent
- 1:13attorney in prosecuting medical malpractice actions
- 1:17and has tried multiple cases to verdict. He has
- 1:20presented and been published many times on medical
- 1:23malpractice issues. Ben handles complex medical
- 1:27malpractice actions typically involving serious
- 1:29injury or death. Since 2016, Ben has secured
- 1:3410 seven -figure settlements and 58 six -figure
- 1:39settlements. He has multiple plaintiff sided
- 1:42jury verdicts in medical malpractice actions.
- 1:45And in total, since 2016, Ben has recovered a
- 1:50staggering over $113 million on behalf of his
- 1:55clients. And just on a personal note, I have
- 1:59come up against Ben and Michelle numerous times
- 2:04as as adversaries. They are formidable adversaries.
- 2:10They are extremely experienced and knowledgeable.
- 2:13I'm looking forward to learning from them today.
- 2:16And so I will hand it over to Michelle and Ben.
- 2:21Thank you both for being here. Thank you. Well,
- 2:23don't learn too much, please. I'm sure you get
- 2:26those quite often. So thank you everybody for
- 2:29for watching our presentation and I see the attendees
- 2:32a lot of impressive that now lawyers in there.
- 2:35So please ask questions. I don't want to just
- 2:37hear ourselves talk for the next hour. So ask
- 2:39questions will answer right away. I think it's
- 2:41really important that we have questions and answers.
- 2:44I was already checking. Nobody's asked any questions
- 2:46yet. No, no questions yet. All right. All right,
- 2:52so our first slide is on a very basic jury instruction,
- 2:57PC 502. For those of you that do medical malpractice,
- 3:01you know that 502 is the standard of care. The
- 3:06last bit here under in the bracket says, you
- 3:11must determine the level of skill, knowledge
- 3:13and care that other reasonably careful. doctors
- 3:17would use in similar circumstances based on the
- 3:21testimony of expert witnesses. Based only on
- 3:25the testimony. Remember that it is only on expert
- 3:29witnesses and in the brackets it says including
- 3:32and then name of defendant and so it's important
- 3:36in medical malpractice cases that sometimes defense
- 3:39counsel will designate their client the defendant
- 3:43as an expert. If they are designated as an expert,
- 3:47you should notice their deposition. And then
- 3:52defense counsel will normally say, we're withdrawing
- 3:54them as an expert. Make sure that when they say
- 3:57we are withdrawing them as an expert, that you
- 4:00say, great, just understand that KC 502, you
- 4:03will not be allowed to put in including the defendant
- 4:08because the defendant will not be an expert witness
- 4:11because they were not designated as an expert
- 4:14witness. Anything else you want to add, Ben?
- 4:17Yeah, that's really important. A lot of defense
- 4:20lawyers try and sneak in that bracket. And, you
- 4:23know, typically speaking, doctors and nurses
- 4:25make the witnesses, and they want to give them
- 4:27extra credit here and use this against us. So
- 4:30really, really important that if they designate
- 4:33their clients as experts, you notice their deposition
- 4:36as an expert. And to be clear, if that happens,
- 4:40they waive the attorney -client privilege under
- 4:42a case called Shooker versus Superior Court.
- 4:45And so not only should you seek the deposition,
- 4:49but ask for all communications between the defense
- 4:52lawyer and the defendant, as well as the insurance
- 4:55carrier. Because again, the attorney -client
- 4:58privilege is waived. And so really important
- 5:00to get that little bracket out, all right? Super
- 5:03important in trial, all right? And look out for
- 5:06that when you guys exchange jury instructions.
- 5:10And if you want to look at a sample deposition
- 5:15notice on how you can ask for that type of communication,
- 5:19you can email us at the end of this and we'll
- 5:21give you the example of a deposition notice with
- 5:24a request for production of documents that specifically
- 5:27cites the type of information that you are entitled
- 5:30to receive. So a bunch of words that just means
- 5:33experts are important in med mal cases. We do
- 5:37have a question already, though. It's Rachel's
- 5:39question. We can do it later. OK. Sorry. This
- 5:41one's really important. Go over this one. OK.
- 5:45So I think that oftentimes there is a little
- 5:48bit of confusion in the community about when
- 5:52you can use a defense expert in your case in
- 5:57chief, OK? And so there is a code 2025 .620 subdivision
- 6:05D, and this allows you to play the deposition
- 6:09testimony of an expert witness. You don't have
- 6:13to show that the expert witness was unavailable,
- 6:16okay? You can take their deposition. We videotape
- 6:20every single deposition that we take, and especially
- 6:24of experts. When we videotape those depositions,
- 6:27we try to get nuggets so that we can play those
- 6:30at trial. And even if we don't get something
- 6:32great for us, we will play that, hey, defendant
- 6:36thinks that the defendant did everything within
- 6:39the standard of care and that, oh, it didn't
- 6:42cause any harm. We still play that in our case
- 6:45in chief so that our experts can address what
- 6:49the defense expert is going to say. You will
- 6:52hear oftentimes, Oh, you can't do that. Yes,
- 6:57we can. And it is not cumulative. It is permissible.
- 7:03I've heard a defense attorney tell me one time,
- 7:05well, then you can't use your own expert. That's
- 7:08a silly argument to make. Our experts are clearly
- 7:11going to be saying two different things, and
- 7:13so it's not cumulative, and I don't have to pick
- 7:15your expert over mine. You just need to designate
- 7:19that testimony, and you need to put in your notice
- 7:22of the deposition the code section that says
- 7:25you intend to play it at trial. We play every
- 7:30single defense expert's deposition, at least
- 7:33part of it, small nuggets, in all of our cases.
- 7:36And in all of our cases, the defense has every
- 7:40single time raised a fit, despite the extremely
- 7:43clear language of the statute, which says any
- 7:44witness, any expert witness. And we've always
- 7:48prevailed in this issue because the statute says
- 7:49what it says. There's also two other cases. Powell
- 7:53held that it was error to not allow the plaintiff
- 7:59to call in their case in chief a defense expert.
- 8:01And oftentimes, it's very common with the damages
- 8:03experts, because they'll make critical concessions
- 8:06about your client actually being injured or actually
- 8:08having a lot of problems. And it's not uncommon.
- 8:10And I think defense lawyers will admit this.
- 8:13Oftentimes, they won't even call their own experts
- 8:15at trial. So you need to get ahead of the ball
- 8:17and call them in your case. All right? And the
- 8:19best way to do that, the most cost effective
- 8:21way to do that, is to just play their depositions.
- 8:24All right? So very, very clear that you can both
- 8:27call and play opposing experts in your case,
- 8:30and you should. OK? Yeah, so I think the only
- 8:36last thing to add there is that when you are
- 8:41taking these depositions, you need to make sure
- 8:44that the testimony that you're getting is clear.
- 8:47Experts will often try to get around the question
- 8:50that you're asking and answer some other question.
- 8:52And so we'll talk about that a little bit more
- 8:55in more detail in our next slide. We went over
- 8:59the first two points already. You know, I think
- 9:01points three and four are really important, and
- 9:03I'm going to tell a story. It's an important
- 9:06story. It's a good one. You know, I had, and
- 9:08I couldn't find the clip, and I couldn't find,
- 9:10because it's a long time ago, this trial, but
- 9:13I had a defense expert who, in trial, was very
- 9:18polished, came in in a suit and tie, very respectful.
- 9:21In deposition, he was a total jerk. A total jerk
- 9:24to me. And he was rude. He was dismissive. He
- 9:28was, you know, he was just really, really nasty.
- 9:33And there was one part where I said, you know,
- 9:38where in the records does it say X, Y, and Z
- 9:40that supports your opinion? He said, I'm looking
- 9:41at your dog for you, Mr. Ikuta. Here, look for
- 9:44it yourself. And in his hands handed me a bunch
- 9:47of records. So rude. And I showed that part to
- 9:50a jury. And then when they actually saw him in
- 9:53trial, how two -faced he was, They hated him.
- 9:56That was the only case I've ever won 12 -0 on
- 9:58the plaintiff's side. All right? So it's not
- 10:02always just what they say, it's how they say
- 10:04it. My first lie was him handing me the papers
- 10:09in my closing statement, how rude and how dismissive
- 10:12he was. And I think that's an important point
- 10:14that Ben just made, is that it's a lot different
- 10:17when you have a deposition transcript and you're
- 10:19reading from it. Question, you know... What is
- 10:23your opinions on the standard of care? And then
- 10:26the answer and then some no context, you can't
- 10:29see the pauses, you can't see what they're emphasizing.
- 10:33It is so important to videotape all of your depositions.
- 10:39For example, I'll cut like various slides. I
- 10:42think, okay, this expert is gonna testify some
- 10:45way differently because. they really shouldn't
- 10:48have said this at their deposition. I will have
- 10:50those clips ready to go at trial so that I can
- 10:54then play it instead of just reading to impeach
- 10:57them. I will have those clipped. So it's important
- 11:00that you have all of that ready to go and that
- 11:04you know which clips you want to play in your
- 11:07cross -examination of the expert. Yes, you should
- 11:10designate the testimony and play it in your case
- 11:12in chief, but you also should have those clips
- 11:15ready because you will cross examine that expert,
- 11:18and there will be things that they will hopefully
- 11:21change so that you can play those clips during
- 11:25their testimony. And then you can also use those
- 11:28clips in your closing so that you are now refreshing
- 11:32them on what was said. It's different when you're
- 11:34just clipping the testimony and they're reading
- 11:36it. Jurors learn different ways, and so having
- 11:40that testimony playing for them can be very helpful.
- 11:45I agree with everything you're saying, but I'm
- 11:47getting bored hearing us talk. Heather, I'll
- 11:50answer your question later. We'll answer the
- 11:52question regarding qualified experts later on.
- 11:54Any questions, please ask us so we can break
- 11:57this up and answer some of them. Um, on case
- 12:01specific issues, we don't hold back, you know,
- 12:02we really go after the expert. We're not rude.
- 12:04We're not, you know, we're not, uh, aggressive,
- 12:06but we were very thorough and we make sure we
- 12:07go through every single opinion in full detail
- 12:10and the base of that opinion and all that stuff.
- 12:14So on case specific issues on general issues,
- 12:16we'll go over that later. There are some things
- 12:18you want to save for trial, but in general, you
- 12:19want to, you want to really go after them in
- 12:21deposition so you can get those good soundbites.
- 12:23And so we did talk about this a little bit, but
- 12:26it says experts are less prepared at deposition
- 12:28than trial. I mean, experts are oftentimes, they
- 12:32look disheveled. They will not know specifics
- 12:36about the medical records. I had a case where
- 12:39I was, the defense expert said, oh, the patient
- 12:42didn't go into hemorrhagic shock until insert
- 12:45later time. I'm like, well, what did you base
- 12:47that on? Oh, I based that on. The blood pressure
- 12:50is when the patient became hypotensive. When
- 12:52did the patient become hypotensive? Oh, and then
- 12:54they picked a time that was. much later in the
- 12:57case, and I was able to at trial say, well, wasn't
- 13:00that patient hypotensive at this time and at
- 13:02this time and at this time? So isn't your opinion
- 13:04that the patient was actually in hemorrhagic
- 13:06shock at a much earlier time? So it's important
- 13:10that you know your own records and that you're
- 13:13prepared, but also understand that the defense
- 13:16expert or the other side's expert for defense
- 13:19attorneys. The experts are much less prepared
- 13:22at the time of their deposition. They are going
- 13:24to be much more polished at the time of trial.
- 13:30I couldn't find the clip of the expert. This
- 13:33is actually a defendant in one of our cases who
- 13:35wore sunglasses in deposition. And we did not
- 13:38bring this up during trial. We just showed it.
- 13:40And the jury hated him for it. We didn't win
- 13:43that case. We didn't lose either. yeah we mistried
- 13:45that case six six but the six jurors that were
- 13:47on our side hated him for it and um they were
- 13:49actually prescriptions and glasses so he it made
- 13:51sense for him to wear them but you know it was
- 13:54a bad look for him to wear these um here's a
- 13:57clip of one of michelle's depositions you ready
- 13:59yeah oh yeah you want to talk about the background
- 14:00of this uh sure so um i'll give you guys a little
- 14:04bit of background about the case it was um an
- 14:07elbow surgery where my client went in um she'd
- 14:11fallen on her elbow at the doctor severed her
- 14:15nerve. And so this was the defense expert that
- 14:20I was deposing on the issues of standard of care
- 14:24and causation. And so - Well, no, no, no. That's
- 14:27the second time you deposed him. Oh, OK. Yeah.
- 14:29So I was going to talk about it a little bit
- 14:32afterwards. But so this expert, I deposed him
- 14:35twice. The first time that I deposed him, he
- 14:37said, oh, well, the nerve could have been severed
- 14:42during the fall. It couldn't have been severed
- 14:47during the surgery, but it also could have happened
- 14:51later when they had a subsequent surgery. And
- 14:54I said, well, can you tell me to a reasonable
- 14:55degree of medical probability if it was during
- 14:57the fall? No, I can't. Well, can you tell me
- 14:59to a reasonable degree of medical probability
- 15:01if it was during the subsequent surgery? No,
- 15:04I can't. I think there might have been one other
- 15:07possibility, but he could not tell me, to a reasonable
- 15:11degree of medical probability, what caused this
- 15:15harm. So I then said I would be filing a motion
- 15:19and eliminate to preclude him from offering any
- 15:21testimony on the issue of causation, because
- 15:24he could not tell me to a reasonable degree of
- 15:26medical probability. And so lo and behold, defense
- 15:30counsel says up. The doctor wants to, he has
- 15:36some new opinions based on some new reviews,
- 15:38some additional things. So we're gonna offer
- 15:41him back up. And he said, okay, well, he could
- 15:45have given these opinions at his first deposition.
- 15:46So you're gonna pay for it. So they paid for
- 15:49it. And then I took his deposition. yet again,
- 15:52um, in this case, and I, is that what - Yeah,
- 15:55so it was, it was a Klein versus Zimmer issue,
- 15:56right? Or what was the code section? 801? Whatever
- 15:58the code section was, it changed standards. It
- 16:00said for both sides, you, you, your opinions
- 16:02have to be probable, not possible, right? And
- 16:06so he said possible the first time around, was
- 16:08not prepared correctly. And Michelle really,
- 16:11really did a great job, prepared, you know, really
- 16:13prepared and really went into full detail and
- 16:15exposed them for saying possible. And so that's
- 16:17why - get off him again, had to pay for him and
- 16:20our videographer and our core reporter, and here's
- 16:23some testimony from the second session. Hopefully.
- 16:30Dr. Gupta, I understand you're still on your
- 16:31oath, correct? Yes. Did you have a discussion
- 16:35with anyone while we were on our break? Yes.
- 16:38Who did you speak to? Alex. And what did the
- 16:41two of you discuss? I felt like I was being bullied
- 16:45and harassed. I asked him what I could do about
- 16:49it. And what did he say? Stay calm and just answer
- 16:54your questions as best as I could. Was there
- 16:58anything else that you discussed? No. Sorry,
- 17:01anything else that you said? Other than I thought
- 17:04you were being mean to me. I am sorry if you
- 17:10felt that I was being mean to you, doctor. I'm
- 17:12just trying to make sure that I get... all of
- 17:15your opinions here today, even ones that you
- 17:17may not have realized you were forming. And that
- 17:24came in because he did not want to criticize
- 17:26the second surgeon. And so I was asking him whether
- 17:29or not the second surgeon breached the standard
- 17:31of care. And he was just refusing to tell me
- 17:35whether or not he thought that he said, I wasn't
- 17:37looking at this case for that reason. I won't
- 17:41be offering any opinions about that at trial.
- 17:44And so I don't have the testimony here where
- 17:48he said, defense counsel, I said, well, why did
- 17:52you change your opinion that to a reasonable
- 17:54degree of medical probability it was from the
- 17:56fall? And he said, well, defense counsel told
- 17:59me I could not say that it was a probability
- 18:05or a possibility that I had to be able to say
- 18:08to a reasonable degree of medical probability.
- 18:11Well, obviously that case settled because their
- 18:14expert is basically saying he changed his testimony
- 18:17because defense counsel told him to. So it's
- 18:21important that you understand the law yourself
- 18:23because your expert should be able to say to
- 18:26a reasonable degree of medical probability that
- 18:29the breach in the standard of care caused X harm,
- 18:32right? And because if your expert can't say that.
- 18:36then you also have a problem. It cannot be a
- 18:39possibility or a probability. It needs to be
- 18:42to a reasonable degree of medical probability.
- 18:45And so this expert, because I went after him
- 18:48on it and I asked him a bunch of questions, he
- 18:51thought I was being mean to him. And so - I can
- 18:54empathize with that. You're mean to me quite
- 18:56often. You're bully to me. No, I'm just joking.
- 18:58I watched the transcript to him and she was not
- 19:00mean. She was just very thorough, very matter
- 19:02of fact, and exposed him. to a certain degree,
- 19:06right, and he's very uncomfortable with that.
- 19:07And so, you know, obviously it shows how important
- 19:11preparation is, both preparing to depose experts
- 19:14and also preparing to defend them, make sure
- 19:16that they're aware of their opinions and what
- 19:20they should say and what the law is. Thank you,
- 19:22Amber. 801 .1 is the section that I was referring
- 19:25to, the recently amended section that states
- 19:28that both sides have to have Possible, not possible.
- 19:32And Amber actually was a big part of that law
- 19:34being changed, because Amber had a case where,
- 19:37I think in her case, she had an elder abuse case
- 19:40where the defense tried to argue that a bird
- 19:41out of the sky hit the elder and caused her to
- 19:44fall. And that was a possibility or something.
- 19:47Anyway, so that example actually helped that
- 19:48law be passed, which was very helpful. So thank
- 19:50you, Amber, for your contribution to the plaintiff's
- 19:52bar. OK, next. This is not important. Oh, yeah.
- 20:05Well, guys, you know, this is a concluding instruction.
- 20:08When you are a plaintiff lawyer, especially,
- 20:10and you're going to show clips of the opposing
- 20:12experts, just ask the judge to read this during
- 20:15the intro. It's not the biggest deal in the world.
- 20:18Honestly, the jurors zone out during the jury
- 20:21instruction ratings, as do I typically. But nevertheless,
- 20:24just have the judge ask the judge to read this
- 20:27in the intro instructions instead of the concluding
- 20:30instructions, okay? And that's because, often,
- 20:32tamsters don't know what a deposition is. They
- 20:35don't know that this person is under oath. So
- 20:37it helps if you have this instruction read before
- 20:41a deposition is played, just the first one or
- 20:43with the opening instructions. So what we'll
- 20:46do, oftentimes, are closing. So we'll play the
- 20:48opposing expert in our case. Oftentimes, we'll
- 20:51play it during the portions of it during our
- 20:54cross -examination of the expert in the defense's
- 20:56case. And we'll play. portions are closing, of
- 20:59course. And we'll actually show this instruction.
- 21:01We'll show the most damaging portions of their
- 21:03expert's testimony. And we'll say, really? That's
- 21:05their opinion? Folks, you don't have to accept
- 21:08an expert's opinion. You don't have to believe
- 21:11an expert's opinion. This is what this instruction
- 21:13says. So we use this instruction in conjunction
- 21:16with showing the opposing clips. And it's also
- 21:20that you can choose to believe some or none of
- 21:24an expert's testimony. And so that is helpful
- 21:27when maybe an expert on the other side gives
- 21:30you concessions. So you can choose to accept
- 21:34some, like we all agree on this. Or you can choose
- 21:37to accept none. And that would be in an instance
- 21:40where, you know. they're being really crazy about
- 21:44opinions that they're offering. Maybe they have
- 21:45two experts that are offering two different opinions.
- 21:48Hey, their own experts can't agree on what happened
- 21:51in this case. So what happened in this case?
- 21:55We won this case. We do win cases every once
- 21:58in a while. It's rare, but it happens. And it's
- 22:01Michelle's case. All right. And she gives a brilliant
- 22:03opening. It's a great job. And she has COVID
- 22:06in the middle of trial. And so she calls me and
- 22:08says, Ben, come try this case. I'm like, what's
- 22:10this case about again? So I had to jump in and
- 22:12try this case with her gone for a week. And I
- 22:16sided to my cousin Vinnie, as you can see here.
- 22:19But it was really, this is actually trial testimony
- 22:21of the opposing expert. And it was so helpful
- 22:22because Michelle did a phenomenal job in deposition,
- 22:25being so thorough with the expert. And this expert
- 22:27was saying ridiculous things that this podiatrist
- 22:31negligently put this screw right into her joint.
- 22:33right? Right? We're not supposed to put it. And
- 22:36this expert's like, oh, no, no, no, it clearly
- 22:37migrated over time. It went further into the
- 22:40into the toe over time. And which is just was
- 22:44baloney. And the radiographs, he's saying, oh,
- 22:47it proves it. Look at the radiographs. It's migrating.
- 22:49And so I just showed three radiographs of the
- 22:52of the patient without any dates on them saying,
- 22:54hey, which one's which? Which date? Which date's
- 22:56which, doctor? You said it's migrating. Which
- 22:58one's which? And he couldn't do it. And so Michelle
- 23:01did such a great job in deposition that this
- 23:03really, really helped us win the case, honestly.
- 23:05I mean, even though I came in and tried it when
- 23:07she was, oh, she came back next week and did
- 23:09closing, did a great job and we won the case.
- 23:11I watched from remotely while he was, I think
- 23:14he took like two witnesses while I was gone and
- 23:16played some testimony, but. Yeah, and I'm like
- 23:18that. Your honor, I can look at my phone real
- 23:20fast. I mean, technologists from Ms. Hemisath,
- 23:22if I missed any cross -examination questions.
- 23:24So I look back at my phone and it's like, just
- 23:26pages of questions, right? I'm like, I can't,
- 23:28no more questions, your honor, thank you. Anyway,
- 23:32that was a fun trial. It was, yeah. Okay, what's
- 23:35next? Let's see. Same guy. He conceded that because
- 23:41the screw was in the joint, which migrated, that
- 23:44he needed a second surgery. She didn't even play
- 23:47it. Who cares? I mean, it's like, it's like helpful
- 23:50stuff, right? Yeah. I mean, again, this is just
- 23:52an example of you got to record your depositions.
- 23:55You got to play the helpful testimony in your
- 23:57closing. Um, I don't know that we need to play
- 23:59the video. You know, there's a question from
- 24:02Andrew Martin says, what if the defense experts
- 24:03don't resist the magic words to a reasonable
- 24:05degree of medical probability, but just says
- 24:08it was, you know, listen, in my opinion, I think
- 24:11if the expert says, more likely than not, or
- 24:14probable, or within the standard of care. There's
- 24:16no magic language, guys, I mean, in my opinion.
- 24:20Yeah, I mean, I think that, you know, you should.
- 24:24get that when you're deposing them later, hey,
- 24:27is this your opinion to a reasonable degree of
- 24:30medical probability? So the question was about
- 24:34a declaration. We're gonna talk a little bit
- 24:36about declarations later, but these can be helpful
- 24:39at the time of your deposition of an expert.
- 24:43And so Ben's right, I don't think that there's
- 24:45necessarily magic language, but sometimes that
- 24:48magic language, when you say it to the expert,
- 24:51then they're like, Oh, well, maybe I can't say
- 24:54that to a reasonable degree of medical probability.
- 24:57And sometimes you don't want to clean it up.
- 24:59All right, because if you clean it up now, we
- 25:01know the defense lawyers draft the declarations,
- 25:04but they still review them, the experts, right?
- 25:06The more they clean it up, the more they know
- 25:07the law and the less you can get out of them.
- 25:11Oftentimes, we'll go over this later, but we
- 25:13like to use declarations against the experts
- 25:15oftentimes. And so you don't want them to clean
- 25:17it up. It's not you don't play or not. Who cares?
- 25:22No, this is the next one. This was a case that
- 25:25we tried and the stand of care and there's a
- 25:29little girl, two -year -old girl who had a bunch
- 25:34of, she had a condition called spina bifida.
- 25:36It was several years ago we tried this case and
- 25:38the ER doctors did not diagnose her with a shunt
- 25:42malfunction which caused a bunch of fluid in
- 25:43her brain to build up. They sent her home in
- 25:47the waiting room before she even got into her
- 25:48car she died. And their causation expert was
- 25:52saying, oh, no, no. The fluid was already in
- 25:54her brain by the time she got there. It was too
- 25:56late. There's no way we could have done surgery.
- 25:58And the sand of care expert, Dr. Ritter, this
- 26:01guy said, oh, no, no, no. She did not have fluid
- 26:04in her brain. There's no way she did. She would
- 26:06have been symptomatic. It would have been clear
- 26:07as day. And it was reasonable for doctors to
- 26:10miss it. So we have the two defense experts saying
- 26:12diametrically opposite things. And what we did
- 26:16too, oftentimes we'll actually just show the
- 26:18transcript of the depot in the closing. We'll
- 26:21play the video in our case, but we'll just show
- 26:24the transcript in our closing because when you
- 26:26read it, you can emphasize different words. It
- 26:29can be more effective sometimes as a show of
- 26:31the words. But yeah, just again, really helpful
- 26:34to have that, but because in trial, in trial,
- 26:38this expert backed away from his opinion and
- 26:39kind of softened it and said, you know what,
- 26:41I'll defer to a neurosurgeon, right? But now
- 26:43we had the depot transcript that we were able
- 26:45to use showing they can't even agree with each
- 26:47other, folks. And that's why it's important to
- 26:50play their testimony in your case in chief because
- 26:55otherwise they will soften that at the time of
- 26:59trial and you're not going to get that same testimony.
- 27:02And so you can try to impeach the witness, but
- 27:05it makes it much more clean if you play it in
- 27:08your case in chief. And so they get to hear these
- 27:10two conflicting opinions and they don't get to
- 27:14clean that up, right? So they've heard it. In
- 27:17your case, oh, these two people are saying totally
- 27:20different things. At trial, they're not going
- 27:22to say totally different things. And then in
- 27:23your closing, you can say, here's what he said.
- 27:28And here's what the other expert said. They can't
- 27:30even agree themselves. So that's why I think
- 27:33it's important that You understand that when
- 27:35you're going into these deposition, you are not
- 27:38just saying, OK, give me all of your opinions
- 27:40on the standard of care. Give me all of your
- 27:43opinions on causation, right? I mean, you need
- 27:46to be actively listening, questioning them so
- 27:49that you can get that testimony and sound bite
- 27:52that you need at trial. There's a question. Does
- 27:55asking the defense expert during the initial
- 27:58amnitions whether they're here to offer their
- 28:00opinions to a reasonable medical probability
- 28:02cover the entire depot. Don't do that. That would
- 28:05be incredibly stupid. I'm sorry. That'd be very,
- 28:07very foolish. Because now basically it's a softball.
- 28:10They'll say yes. And then now everything they
- 28:12say is, you know, probable. Right? No, no. Wait
- 28:16till they give you the response so you can attack
- 28:18it. Don't give them a softball and then just
- 28:21authenticate all their opinions. That would be
- 28:23a big mistake. And the reason that it's a mistake
- 28:25is, again, sometimes when you confront them on
- 28:28a specific opinion... They might say, well, no,
- 28:31I mean, it's a possibility. I can't say if it's,
- 28:33you know, more than 50 percent. I think it's,
- 28:36you know, it's definitely between these three
- 28:38things or something along those lines. And so
- 28:40you want to wait for them to give you those opinions
- 28:43and then you attack those opinions after they've
- 28:46given them to you. For those that do mid mallard
- 28:50or just have a case here and there, be prepared
- 28:52for the defense to submit a motion and lemonade
- 28:55or file motion lemonade. That's extremely stupid.
- 28:58but can trick some judges that don't have a lot
- 29:01of civil or men mal experience. And here I'll
- 29:04show you the, let me put up the motion lemonade
- 29:07right now. Here's the motion lemonade on the
- 29:10left -hand side. This is the same motion that
- 29:12every defense firm files. In fact, there's a
- 29:15typo in this motion that I found in other defense
- 29:18motions, other firms. They share this motion.
- 29:21They file, and it's oftentimes number one, like
- 29:22you see here. This one that was just filed recently,
- 29:25just settled. a few weeks ago and it's their
- 29:28motion is don't let the plaintiff expert ask
- 29:31about the personal practices of the of our expert
- 29:34because oftentimes what the defense expert will
- 29:36say is you know what I think that this is acceptable
- 29:40but I would never do it this way right go ahead
- 29:45yeah and so I mean again Ben said this motion
- 29:48limiting is filed in every case and it's oftentimes
- 29:50because they know that their experts are gonna
- 29:53say they wouldn't do it this way or that they
- 29:56don't do it this way. And so that's important.
- 29:59If you have an expert on the other side that
- 30:02says, well, I wouldn't do it that way, but it's
- 30:06okay. It's within the standard of care. It's
- 30:08reasonable to do it another way. Well, when you
- 30:11think back to 502, you're thinking, what would
- 30:16a reasonably careful doctor do? And so are they
- 30:21saying that reasonably careful doctors would
- 30:26not do whatever it is that you're saying, but
- 30:28the defense expert, he's more careful. So we
- 30:31don't have to be as careful as the defense expert
- 30:33in his personal practice, but the other doctors
- 30:37out there, they could be less careful. That's
- 30:39the way it is. Oh, our expert's an A plus and
- 30:41stands care of family C grade and therefore it's
- 30:43not relevant. That's baloney. There's no California
- 30:46case on point either way. There are like 30 cases
- 30:50in other jurisdictions that have all held, of
- 30:53course that's admissible. It goes directly to
- 30:55the expert's credibility, right? I would never
- 30:57do it that way, but it's within the standard
- 30:58of care, come on. Of course it's relevant. Of
- 31:01course it's important. And in California, we
- 31:04need to have wide latitude to cross -examine
- 31:06opposing experts, particularly in med mal cases
- 31:08where everything is defined by expert testimony.
- 31:12It also goes to experience too. If they say,
- 31:14oh, I'd never do it that way, that also shows
- 31:16they're not experienced in doing it that way
- 31:17either. It goes to their experience, their qualifications.
- 31:20So to say that's not relevant, it's absolute
- 31:22baloney. But there's no cases directly on point
- 31:26under California law. So if you see this dumb
- 31:28motion, please email me and ask me for our form
- 31:33of opposition to this dumb motion. And it should
- 31:36be denied. And it has been ever since I had it
- 31:39granted one time early on when I just thought
- 31:41there was no way. the judge would grant that
- 31:43motion because it's so stupid and the judge granted
- 31:44it unbelievably and so then I did a deep dive
- 31:47into every single jurisdiction and drafted a
- 31:50very very long opposition and since then it's
- 31:52never been granted all right nor should it be
- 31:54all right so um you know and it's really really
- 31:57important it's not just as to decisions on what
- 32:01to do it also goes to the recognized risk defense
- 32:03so under kc 505 it's the most devastating instruction
- 32:07of all time it should just say defense must win
- 32:11It's actually titled success not required. It
- 32:14says basically doctors can screw up and it's
- 32:17not malpractice, right? You should address that
- 32:20in your own closing. Do not let the first time
- 32:23that they hear that be in the defenses closing.
- 32:26OK, you need to emphasize this says that they
- 32:28still need to be reasonably careful. Don't be
- 32:30confused. This instruction is the same as 502.
- 32:34And so when you cross examine expert at trial
- 32:37in deposition. Make sure that you're prepared
- 32:39to address that. Doctor, it is recognized risk,
- 32:42right? And that's why you have to be ultra careful.
- 32:43You have to visualize the common bile duct before
- 32:46you cut in a lap coli. You have to be ultra cautious.
- 32:50You know that can be devastating circumstances
- 32:51or consequences. If you do, you know, this risk
- 32:54does happen. And then ask about that expert's
- 32:57personal experience and how often that risk has
- 33:00happened to him or her. And that's what Michelle
- 33:02did in this case. How many perforations have
- 33:14you had of the subclavian artery? Oh, subclavian?
- 33:20I can't remember the last one. Probably very,
- 33:24very few, if any. OK, so as you sit here today,
- 33:30can you remember even one time where you perforated
- 33:32the subclavian artery? Not offhand, no. OK, and
- 33:37so this case. Recognized risk when you undergo
- 33:41an angioplasty that you might have a perforation
- 33:44Okay, and that and my expert had to concede that
- 33:48yeah, it is a recognized risk. Well, how many
- 33:51times has it happened to you doctor? Oh Can't
- 33:54even think of a time. Okay. So yes, there are
- 33:58recognized risks that happen and that can still
- 34:02be malpractice Oftentimes we'll do focus groups
- 34:06and jurors sometimes will say Well, you know,
- 34:08it was one of the things that they knew about
- 34:10and it can happen. And so I don't really think
- 34:12there was malpractice. You need to combat that.
- 34:17And that's where these personal practices and
- 34:20what has happened in their experience. It's important
- 34:22to know. OK. And you got to watch here on that
- 34:25issue. But again. you have to ask the question
- 34:30or the jurors will never know about it. And so
- 34:35when you're preparing to depose these experts,
- 34:38you should also know the answer that your own
- 34:41expert is going to give. My own expert had said
- 34:43that he had not had a perforation of a subclavian
- 34:46artery. But the breach here wasn't the perforation.
- 34:49It was the failure to recognize it. This artery
- 34:52is in a location where it is very difficult to
- 34:55get compression. And so a bleed is significant
- 34:58in that area. And that's why you have to be very
- 35:01cautious. And this bleed wasn't caught for two
- 35:03hours. Again, when you're doing medical malpractice
- 35:08cases, you got to know the medicine, and then
- 35:12you have to use the medicine against the defense
- 35:14experts or the plaintiff's experts, whatever
- 35:16side you're on. And always, always, always, always
- 35:18use car accidents. You got to give more explanation
- 35:23than use car accidents. Well, yeah, I mean, you're
- 35:25closing. Be like, hey, is there a recognized
- 35:27risk that you'll get in the car accident when
- 35:28you drive to work? Of course. Does that mean
- 35:30that every car accident happens in the absence
- 35:32of negligence? Of course not. Right? So that's
- 35:37what we do. And then also like another big issue
- 35:39with the recognized risk defense is you always
- 35:41want to bring up the fact that, yeah, you know,
- 35:43sure, doctor, it's your opinion that it can happen
- 35:46outside of negligence, absent negligence, but
- 35:48it can also happen with negligence too, right?
- 35:51And we won this case because the defense expert
- 35:56basically said, yo, yeah, I agree with that.
- 35:58It can happen if you're not looking. And I had
- 36:00her admit on the stand. that she wasn't looking
- 36:03when this enormous skin tear occurred and so
- 36:06he's basically supporting my case and this won
- 36:08the case for us this testimony right here won
- 36:10the case for us um so really important uh we
- 36:14went over that already oh all right you want
- 36:16to go over this uh so this is my last trial that
- 36:19i was in this is the defense expert and i was
- 36:21asking him about the standard of care um so before
- 36:24we play this um when you prepare your expert
- 36:29for their deposition I mean, it's important to
- 36:32make sure that they got all the materials. It's
- 36:33important to go over their opinions. It's also
- 36:35important to make sure that they know what to
- 36:37say if the other side's expert says, what is
- 36:41the definition of the standard of care to you?
- 36:44Just make sure they say reasonable. I mean, they
- 36:46don't have to know KC 502, but they do need to
- 36:49have reasonable somewhere in their answer, because
- 36:52otherwise you might get an answer like this.
- 36:57How do you define the standard of care? That's
- 37:00a good question. It's basically what 90 percent
- 37:05of emergency physicians would do given the same
- 37:09conditions. Okay, so the standard of care is
- 37:18what 90 percent of ER physicians would do under
- 37:24similar circumstances? Yes, I guess there may
- 37:31be something out there that says a different
- 37:32percentage, so I don't want to hang my hat on
- 37:35a 90 percent, but it's definitely not something
- 37:38egregious or something that was far off the mark.
- 37:54violate the standard of care, does the conduct
- 37:57have to be egregious? They would have to do something
- 38:12that was very atypical. Okay, so in order for
- 38:23a physician to violate the standard of care,
- 38:27they have to do something that is very atypical.
- 38:30Very atypical. Okay, so you're never going to
- 38:35get that if you just read it. Oh, he's thinking
- 38:37about it for a really long time there. It's almost
- 38:40uncomfortable how long he's thinking about whether
- 38:42or not it has to be egregious. is a poorly prepared
- 38:49expert and how are we supposed to rely on this
- 38:53guy to say what the standard of care is when
- 38:56he himself doesn't know what it means? We still
- 39:00lost that case though. We still lost that case
- 39:02because medical malpractice cases are hard and
- 39:05people love doctors. The defendant in this case
- 39:08was a very likable emergency room physician.
- 39:12So, you know, I do think these things are helpful.
- 39:15I talked to the jurors later. They thought that
- 39:16this guy was not great, but they just were like,
- 39:20well, you know, I think he, I think that this
- 39:24doctor did the best. I think emergency room cases
- 39:27are some of the hardest because these doctors
- 39:29are seeing so many patients and, you know, it's
- 39:33an, an ER setting. So I have never won an ER
- 39:36case. Never. Yeah. That's a good of a lawyer.
- 39:40I am. all right um you can hold back general
- 39:44attack points uh yeah uh do you want to go over
- 39:48the stuff or not um it's just let me let me see
- 39:51using the in the in the attendees need to pencilers
- 39:54in here before i say anything all right um Well,
- 39:58so, I mean, obviously, during a deposition, you
- 40:01want to get the breakdown of the other side's
- 40:04experts' work. So do they do, you know, 50 -50,
- 40:07100%, you know, for one side? If they're doing
- 40:11100 % for one side, Ben's got a terrific example
- 40:15he's going to give you guys later to use. Have
- 40:19they worked with this firm before? And you should
- 40:23ask in your request reduction of documents to
- 40:26an expert to get their Rule 26 report or just
- 40:29a list of the cases that they've testified in
- 40:31before. And what I did in one of my trials was
- 40:34I knew that all of those cases were for the defense
- 40:38or they were a plaintiff's case that was out
- 40:40of state. And in a medical malpractice case,
- 40:42I think that's very important because doctors
- 40:45don't wanna testify against other doctors who
- 40:47are in their community. And so I went through,
- 40:51I said, who did you represent in this case? And
- 40:53who did you represent in this case? And who did
- 40:54you, and he had previously testified that his
- 40:57breakdown I think was like, 80 -20 or 75 -25,
- 41:02there was not one single case where he testified
- 41:05on behalf of a plaintiff in a medical malpractice
- 41:08case in California. And there was only like two
- 41:11cases outside of California. So his ratio really
- 41:14was not what he said that it was. And, um...
- 41:18I'll oftentimes ask the question, can you name
- 41:19for me a single lawyer on the plaintiff's side
- 41:21that's ever retained you? Just go ahead. In deposition,
- 41:23I'll ask that question. And then in trial, I'll
- 41:25rattle off every defense from who he's worked
- 41:27with and then... And I'll say, you get depositioned.
- 41:29You couldn't even name for me a single time that
- 41:31you've tested on behalf of the plaintiff. Obviously,
- 41:34that works on the other side, too, for the defense
- 41:35attorneys that are out there. The records thing
- 41:37works on both sides, too. I mean, guys, make
- 41:39sure your exercise has everything. I make a huge
- 41:43deal at trial when I find out that the expert
- 41:46has not reviewed a deposition transcript. I'll
- 41:49show deposition to the jury. And I'll say, do
- 41:51you know why? You know, the defense lawyer did
- 41:53not give you this transcript. Did they tell you
- 41:56that? the transit set X, Y, and Z. Had you known
- 41:58that? Would that be important to you? You know,
- 42:01you know, did you dig your head in the sand?
- 42:02Did you ignore that? You know, isn't more better
- 42:05than less when it comes to providing expert testimony?
- 42:07So, you know, we go through a whole spiel when
- 42:10it comes to not, and also really important deposition
- 42:12say, are you prepared to give me all of your
- 42:14opinions today? And then go over in detail what
- 42:16they reviewed and you lock them into their final
- 42:18opinions deposition based on what they reviewed.
- 42:20But even if they reviewed that stuff after that
- 42:22bill before trial, you can still use that spiel.
- 42:26uh imes i hate giving my defense lawyers my but
- 42:30i i love the ime is a gift if you're a plaintiff
- 42:33lawyer and you see them call it an ime don't
- 42:35correct them let them call it an ime and trial
- 42:37just hammer them like so doctor uh this is a
- 42:41true and correct report that you prepared and
- 42:44everything you put in here is accurate isn't
- 42:45that right and your opinions in this case and
- 42:46it actually reflects your opinions blah blah
- 42:48the title says independent medical examination
- 42:51i'm sorry were you Were you assigned or retained
- 42:53by the judge in this case, by a third party administrator?
- 42:57Who actually retained you in this case? Who paid
- 42:59you? And you go through all the whole spiel.
- 43:02And then I say, can we assume that the rest of
- 43:04this report is as accurate as you calling it
- 43:06an independent medical examination? So there's
- 43:09gifts that they can give you that we do save
- 43:11for trial. We're kind of running out of time.
- 43:13Can we just skip past the pie stuff? Sure. OK.
- 43:17I told them you were going to give them the example,
- 43:19though. Maybe just quickly. I say, I've got two
- 43:23boys at home and they love McDonald's pie. They
- 43:27love these pies. They do. They had them yesterday,
- 43:30actually. They don't finish them. I eat them,
- 43:32which is why I'm getting a little bit chubby.
- 43:34But they always fight over the pie. They don't
- 43:37even eat it all, but they'd say they were fighting
- 43:39over it. And how would I divide this pie if I
- 43:42was a fair and impartial parent? How would I
- 43:45divide the pie? Would I divide it like this?
- 43:47Because that's what the defense does. The defense
- 43:48has 95 % defense work. Is that really fair and
- 43:52unbiased? So I use that. This is really important.
- 43:55It's embarrassing for me to show you this clip.
- 43:57It really is. And you know, this is a very emotional
- 44:02case for me. This is a case involving a very
- 44:05severely brain damaged child. I was very close
- 44:09to the family. We did settle this case eventually,
- 44:11but it was a fight. And you should always just
- 44:16stay calm and collected, right? especially with
- 44:19experts, it's much better to be the disappointed
- 44:24mother versus angry. It's a much, much stronger
- 44:28approach, and jurors appreciate that more. They
- 44:32don't like the yelling and screaming and sarcastic
- 44:34comments. So I'm going to show you what not to
- 44:36do based on what I did in this case, okay, in
- 44:39this deposition, all right? So don't do this
- 44:40in deposition or in trial, all right? Here we
- 44:42go. defense in this case, it states that you
- 44:44are expected to testify on issues regarding standard
- 44:47of care, is that correct? Yes. Is it your medical
- 44:51opinion that the nurses in this case met the
- 44:54applicable standard of care? Yes. Is it your
- 44:57medical opinion in this case that the nurses
- 44:59followed all the policies and procedures at Loma
- 45:01Linda University of Marietta? It's my opinion
- 45:05that they followed the guidelines to the rationale
- 45:09that they needed to correct. So the answer is
- 45:12yes. I believe that they followed them to the
- 45:16reasonable level that they needed to, yes. Respectfully,
- 45:20it's a yes or no question. Did the nurses in
- 45:22this case follow the policies and procedures
- 45:23in place at Marietta Lumalinda back in 2014?
- 45:30It's not a yes or no answer. Policy and procedures
- 45:33are guidelines and therefore they're subject
- 45:36to nursing. um decision making and judgment and
- 45:39clinical um thinking skills or critical thinking
- 45:42skills i'm sorry there's a bug i will move the
- 45:45strike is unresponsive um my yes or no question
- 45:47is this and ben ben your motion is denied and
- 45:50she answered the question but you can answer
- 45:52thank you thank you judge thank you judge cannon
- 45:54thank you judge cannon i know you think you know
- 45:56the law even though you don't uh nurse taylor
- 45:58my question is this did the nurses in this case
- 46:03follow the policy procedures in relation to hypoglycemia
- 46:09in place at Loma Linda Marietta back in 2014,
- 46:14yes or no? Again, it's not a yes or no answer.
- 46:19If they use them as guidelines, then yes. So
- 46:22the testimony that, the testimony is gold, right?
- 46:26I mean, clearly the nurses did not follow the
- 46:28policies and procedures. It resulted in this
- 46:30girl being brain damaged. It was a really sad
- 46:31case. And the actual testimony I got was gold.
- 46:35But I can't play that, because I come off like
- 46:37a jerk. All right? And don't ever move to strike
- 46:41in the deposition. It's so stupid, because then
- 46:43they can use it against you, and they can actually
- 46:45join the motion or whatever. Don't do that stuff.
- 46:47Be calm. Be collected. Talk slower than I did
- 46:49there. That was supposed to be gold, and it wasn't,
- 46:54because of my attitude. And again, disappointed
- 46:57mother. That's the approach you want to use,
- 47:00not angry guy, all right? We have questions here.
- 47:06Are you ever able to get the defense expert testify
- 47:08at depot before your expert testifies? Defense
- 47:10always forces plaintiffs to put up their expert
- 47:12first, but I've never seen a code section or
- 47:14case on that. Great point, Joe. There is not
- 47:17one. And they often say that. There is no law
- 47:20that says that. They'll also say, well, we have
- 47:23priority if they do it first. But if they don't
- 47:25do it first, they say, there's no such thing
- 47:26as priority. I think it's a gift. Honestly, your
- 47:30expert goes first. And guess what? Their expert
- 47:32testifies to something. And you always say, well,
- 47:36my expert may have additional opinions based
- 47:38on the review of your expert's testimony. And
- 47:40then they get to review that transcript. And
- 47:42guess what? Your expert might have additional
- 47:44opinions. And so you just message them and say,
- 47:46My expert has some additional opinions based
- 47:48on their review of your expert's testimony. I
- 47:52don't think that it matters. And I know that
- 47:54oftentimes defense counsel makes some huge, they
- 47:57say, well, you know, the burden is on you. Okay,
- 48:00but that doesn't mean my expert has to go first,
- 48:03but honestly... I always say, counsel, don't
- 48:05worry. I'll play your expert's testimony in my
- 48:07case before my own expert. You have my word.
- 48:08They'll go first, okay? In fact, I have the burden,
- 48:11so it's even more important for me to question
- 48:13you guys first, right? But I think it's fine.
- 48:15Honestly, I usually just say, okay, great. Just
- 48:18understand that my expert might have additional
- 48:21opinions based on their review of your expert's
- 48:24testimony or based on their review of your expert's
- 48:26file. And so great, then you get the second bite
- 48:29at the apple and defense counsel has to pay for
- 48:31it. Whereas if you just say, oh, sorry, my expert
- 48:34has more opinions now, not based on some review
- 48:38of some additional testimony. Well, then your
- 48:40expert should have had those opinions, opinions
- 48:42originally. And now. Now you have should in theory
- 48:47you should have to pay for it. So I don't think
- 48:49it should it's it's never a bother to me I just
- 48:51produce them but sometimes defense counsel will
- 48:54just say hey, it's on whoever is available first,
- 48:57Andrew That's a very specific question regarding
- 48:59PDPH reports kind of outside the scope of this
- 49:01presentation Feel free to give me a call afterwards
- 49:03Amber. You guys are so good at this. Thank you,
- 49:05Amber Do you debate whether to file mills to
- 49:08exclude? No, we typically get along I have debated
- 49:10with you more than I've debated with Michelle.
- 49:12I'm being dead serious Okay, we'll move on. You
- 49:16know what, we'll just say that in terms of, is
- 49:19this some particular exclude anything or just
- 49:22exclude something in particular? Because when
- 49:27we say, when you say to exclude, I'm just assuming
- 49:30that you're mean to exclude anything. I don't
- 49:33like exclude. Is that what she's asking? Well,
- 49:34consent forms, you always agree. You always include
- 49:36that. And consent forms, you typically get out.
- 49:38They're not relevant to anything. What the patient
- 49:42consented to, especially when everything is defined
- 49:43by expert testimony, is not relevant. We can't
- 49:46cross -examine the consent form, but we agree
- 49:48on that. On the case with the screw in the joint,
- 49:53we had some text messages between the plaintiff
- 49:57and the defendant podiatrist who was twice her
- 50:01age, was married, had kids. There were some texts
- 50:05that he was inviting her out to eat and being
- 50:08very flirty with um with my client and we thought
- 50:14they were gold we thought oh man this is like
- 50:16he looks and we knew that he actually had a prior
- 50:19podiatry board uh case where he had touched a
- 50:23minor and had lost his license for a period of
- 50:25time and so we were like this is gold right um
- 50:28he's a creep they're gonna think he's a creep
- 50:29when they see these well we did a focus group
- 50:32and Some of the jurors were really turned off
- 50:37by these text messages, but on my client Oh,
- 50:41she's just upset because he didn't date her and
- 50:45so we're like, oh defense wants to exclude these
- 50:47we kind of fought it but then not too hard and
- 50:50then they got excluded, you know, so I think
- 50:53if there's something that you want to exclude
- 50:55you should really think about whether or not
- 50:58it is Helpful or harmful to your case and if
- 51:02you're not sure or maybe you think you're sure
- 51:04you should focus group it to see We knew that
- 51:08the him touching a minor 20 years ago would never
- 51:11come in and so and we thought that these were
- 51:14creepy texts and that would super I mean We're
- 51:16biased because we know about the other minor
- 51:17stuff and he and she was 21. He's 50. We thought
- 51:20this is gold And the jury hated our client, Laura.
- 51:24I mean, the mock jury did. And so they filed
- 51:26a motion of limine. And we filed the weakest
- 51:28opposition of all time just to maintain a credible,
- 51:30appealable issue in case it got to that stage.
- 51:32But we were happy that it was out. And we won
- 51:34that case. Should we answer the first question?
- 51:38How important is it to get very qualified experts
- 51:41for medical practice cases? Yeah, it's very,
- 51:43very important. And of course, that comes from
- 51:46Rachel, who's wonderful. She's defense counsel
- 51:48in some of our cases. Listen, guys, it's hard
- 51:51on the plaintiff's side to get experts because
- 51:53experts oftentimes don't want to testify against
- 51:56other physicians, especially physicians that
- 51:59are in their community. And if the jury just
- 52:04gets to see a doctor from UCLA testifying on
- 52:08behalf of the other side, and then you have,
- 52:13let's say, you know, a solo practitioner that
- 52:16has never taught at an academic institution,
- 52:19well who did they think is more qualified? to
- 52:23testify about the standard of care. Well, it's
- 52:25going to be the doctor who is at UCLA, right?
- 52:28Because this doctor is teaching residents what
- 52:31to do. So it's very important that when you are
- 52:34getting an expert, that you try to get an expert
- 52:37that at least, you know, they say they are an
- 52:39associate professor, but really that just means
- 52:41they may go and give a lecture once a year or
- 52:44something. You can't always get somebody who's
- 52:47not a solo practitioner, but it does help when
- 52:50you have somebody who is well published or has
- 52:54teaching credentials or, you know, has had decades
- 52:57of experience. And so, yes, it's very important
- 53:01to get a well qualified expert, but well qualified
- 53:04also in the area that the defendant is in. I
- 53:09mean, sometimes you get lucky and you don't need
- 53:12that like we did in one of our trials. No, we
- 53:14should have bought that case. We got lucky. But
- 53:17again, you know, the jurors are looking at this
- 53:20from no prior experience to coming in and hearing
- 53:24this stuff for the first time so you need to
- 53:26think what would if I knew nothing who would
- 53:29I think is more qualified but if you're if the
- 53:32more qualified person comes off terribly um don't
- 53:36don't don't don't use experts from like I'm sorry
- 53:39I shouldn't say any try not to avoid people that
- 53:42like advertise okay I know uh but my form on
- 53:46the defense side my former boss Robert McKenna
- 53:48was phenomenal at like just skewering the opposing
- 53:52experts on that issue. So don't, don't, don't
- 53:55do that. Yeah. Because they often say, um, you
- 53:57know, Hey, have you ever advertised for your
- 53:58services before? And then they'll pull up the
- 54:01places where they've advertised and it just doesn't
- 54:03look good when they're advertising to be an expert
- 54:05witness versus this other doctor who's, you know,
- 54:08got privileges at UCLA or whatever academic institutions.
- 54:12Yeah. We have another great, I mean, we have
- 54:13like halfway through the presentation. We're
- 54:14not going to be close to being done, but I love
- 54:16this question. Scott Green asks, have you had
- 54:19instances where defense expert is deposed first
- 54:22and at trial refutes and disputes your expert's
- 54:24opinions via rebuttal and therefore was not obligated
- 54:27rekenemur to be redeposed for additional rebuttal?
- 54:30That's a very loaded question. I'll say first
- 54:32that that's not rebuttal. Clearly, all right,
- 54:34rebuttal is a foundational issue. So disagreeing
- 54:37with an opinion is not rebuttal. So you would
- 54:39be right in objecting under that basis. However,
- 54:43how I rekenemur And how I read De Palma versus
- 54:45Rodriguez is that the opposing experts require
- 54:48to give you all of their general opinions. Stand
- 54:51of care was met, causation wasn't the cause.
- 54:54They're not required to give you every little
- 54:56tiny little detail. Right. And I think that disagreeing
- 54:59with your expert, but still supporting their
- 55:00general opinion, I think passes the test in my
- 55:03opinion. Now, the dangerous game to play because
- 55:05some judges will actually exclude that under
- 55:07Kenamor. And to be clear, though, if they have
- 55:10an actual new opinion, let's say your expert
- 55:12said life expectancy. OK, yes. Or your expert
- 55:16said, you know, the cause of the patient's death
- 55:18was some medical condition. And then the defense
- 55:22expert never addressed that medical condition.
- 55:24They can't later say, oh, well, They didn't have
- 55:27this medical condition because of ABC reasons,
- 55:30because that is a new opinion about that specific
- 55:33condition. So I think you could there argue that
- 55:37under Kenimer that that additional opinion should
- 55:39not be allowed. I don't think you should wait
- 55:41until the person is on the stand, though. Like,
- 55:43this is something that you could put in an emotion
- 55:45and eliminate to preclude them from offering
- 55:47this testimony. File it as late as possible so
- 55:49they can't now say they're going to offer it.
- 55:51It sounds like a surprise trial. I mean, yeah,
- 55:53and then bring up obviously bring up Easter V
- 55:55versus Clark, which is a case that held that
- 55:56like you can tell the other side by way of letter.
- 55:59Hey, my guy's new opinions to post her or him
- 56:01again. So defense will always follow these kind
- 56:04of emotions. And I'm going to join them. But
- 56:07if you then had your own like, oh, I know that
- 56:10the defense expert didn't address this specific
- 56:13point, you can file your own motion and eliminate
- 56:15say the defense expert never, you know, address
- 56:18this issue. And I think this should be excluded.
- 56:21if you have the foresight to understand that
- 56:23you think that that's what they may try to testify
- 56:26to later. Be careful, guys, with declarations.
- 56:29Be really careful on both sides. Defense lawyer,
- 56:31plaintiff lawyer, be careful, all right? This
- 56:33is a declaration he signed before the defendant
- 56:35was even deposed. Really big mistake, because
- 56:37I label just hammer him on it, right? Like, you
- 56:39know, there's nothing that can change your mind,
- 56:40no matter what she said in deposition or in trial,
- 56:43you know, so just be cautious. I have like half
- 56:45an hour more to say about this, but I have two
- 56:47minutes left, so I'm not going to say any more.
- 56:49We'll just get these cool videos. I use timelines
- 56:52a lot during cross -examination of opposing experts,
- 56:55especially when that helps me. This is a case.
- 56:57I lose a lot of cases, man. I lost this case
- 56:58too. But also they were out for like three days
- 57:01at least, they thought about it. But like, you
- 57:03know, it shows the prior knowledge of my guy
- 57:05before he committed suicide. And so, you know,
- 57:09the knowledge of the defendant. And so I did
- 57:10the timeline. You would agree, doctor, this happened,
- 57:12this happened, this happened. And oftentimes
- 57:13it's very helpful for the jury to see that as
- 57:15the kind of nice timeline before the closing
- 57:17statements, because oftentimes the opposing expert
- 57:19will be shortly before closings. Reverse Kenamor
- 57:23would, oh, this is really important. We have
- 57:24two minutes, just real fast. And this might be
- 57:26the most important slide. We say it's for two
- 57:30minutes left. In medical malpractice cases, literature
- 57:32is so important, guys. It's so important. Do
- 57:35your homework. Ask your expert. Is there any
- 57:38literature on point? You know, ACOG guidelines,
- 57:40any public, anything at all. Up to date, you
- 57:43know. You need to know what they say. Do not
- 57:46have your expert. say that something is reliable
- 57:49and authoritative if you yourself have not looked
- 57:52at it because there may be things that are in
- 57:54there that are not helpful and actually more
- 57:56harmful to you. So if you have an article that
- 57:59you get that you intend to use, make sure you
- 58:01read the whole thing. Make sure you understand
- 58:03it. Make sure you talk to your expert about it.
- 58:05Make sure you ask defense expert about any literature
- 58:08that they are relying on, okay? And in my last
- 58:11trial, I had a... I had my own expert that gave
- 58:16me literature that I then used to cross -examine
- 58:20the defense expert because the defense expert
- 58:23said, oh, these medications are only 30 % effective.
- 58:26Well, I actually had a piece of literature from
- 58:29my expert that said that, in fact, no, they are
- 58:3290 % effective. And so I was able to cross -examine
- 58:36him under M721 on that piece of literature. And
- 58:42so it's very important. that if you have literature
- 58:44that is supportive in your case, that your expert
- 58:47identifies it as reliable and authoritative,
- 58:49and then you may cross -examine the defense expert
- 58:52on this issue. Let's go over this again, okay?
- 58:55721 BC says you can cross an expert on literature
- 59:05that any expert, including your own, establishes
- 59:09as reliable authority so typically speaking most
- 59:13judges won't let you your expert talk about and
- 59:16quote to you know some publication out there
- 59:18that helps you all right they won't let you do
- 59:20that but what you can do is have your expert
- 59:22establish a certain article or publication as
- 59:25reliable authority and then you can cross the
- 59:27opposing expert on it and what happens often
- 59:29yes not in the evidence but you can show it to
- 59:33a jury and what will often happen is that the
- 59:37defense experts or lawyers can help themselves
- 59:39and will cross your expert on it during your
- 59:42case. And then in redirect, you can guess what?
- 59:45They open the door. You bring on all that literature
- 59:47that really helps you. It's almost an extra expert,
- 59:48right? So guys, 721, again, save the best for
- 59:51last, I guess, but 721B3 is critically, critically
- 59:56important. And of course, this is obvious, but
- 59:58read all of the opposing experts. articles, see
- 1:00:02what they say, see what they're published, see
- 1:00:03if you can find other articles in the, you know,
- 1:00:06in those publications, find all the depositions,
- 1:00:07you know, everything, so. And then you can get
- 1:00:09them to a subject, hey, you agree with this publication,
- 1:00:11do you still hold the opinions that you held
- 1:00:15in this article that you published whenever it
- 1:00:17was, or do you still think this is reliable authority?
- 1:00:20And great, they say it's no longer reliable authority,
- 1:00:22so what they said back, whatever, a year ago,
- 1:00:25two years ago, it's not reliable authority. So
- 1:00:28just look through the publications. Sometimes
- 1:00:31experts have like 120 publications. It's a lot.
- 1:00:35Look through the ones that are pertinent to your
- 1:00:37case, or may be pertinent to your case. And Jen
- 1:00:41Liu asked if we used AI to cross. Love you, Jen.
- 1:00:44See you in Vegas. I have not used AI to cross
- 1:00:47an expert. I have started using a court reporting
- 1:00:53agency that will allow you to look through a
- 1:00:55transcript and you can like have that um AI tell
- 1:01:00you like what are the inconsistencies in the
- 1:01:02testimony um you know where what could you follow
- 1:01:05up on in other depositions so I have used AI
- 1:01:08in the sense that um one of the reporting agencies
- 1:01:11offers that um but I haven't just like gone out
- 1:01:15to I have I mean I I have a little bit you know
- 1:01:17hey here's my question I'm gonna ask the question
- 1:01:20I should ask, or how should I phrase this. So
- 1:01:21it's helped me marginally. And I will use AI
- 1:01:24to dumb down things, because I'm not smart enough
- 1:01:27to understand a lot of issues. So I'll be like,
- 1:01:30hey, dumb this down. This is why I like Zoom
- 1:01:31depositions, by the way, because even though
- 1:01:33there is a benefit to doing things in person,
- 1:01:36it's nice to be able to just quickly throw medical
- 1:01:38terms or sentences into AI and be like, hey,
- 1:01:40dumb it down for me, please, in the middle of
- 1:01:42a nice question. So I hope that answers that
- 1:01:45question. questions because we are running long
- 1:01:49here you can email myself or ben our emails are
- 1:01:51very easy it's just our first name and then at
- 1:01:55ih -llp .com we're happy to answer any questions
- 1:01:58for you or if you need examples of some motions
- 1:02:01and we can give those to you as well in retained
- 1:02:04surgical instrument cases what strategies have
- 1:02:06been most effective in establishing liability
- 1:02:08typically speaking we will actually force the
- 1:02:11defendants to point the finger at each other.
- 1:02:12And we've filed motions on this very often. We'll
- 1:02:14do RFAs and SROGs both ways. Admit that the co
- 1:02:18-defendants, so basically, right, we have a doctor
- 1:02:20and we have the hospital, right? And whose responsibility
- 1:02:22was it to make sure a sponge or a forceps or
- 1:02:24whatever should not be left in the patient, right?
- 1:02:27So we'll actually ask the question both ways,
- 1:02:29both in RFAs and SROGs. We'll be like, admit
- 1:02:32that the hospital nurses met standard care at
- 1:02:35all times. Admit they did not meet standard care
- 1:02:37at all times. Even the same for S -Rogs also.
- 1:02:39And so we can force them to point the finger
- 1:02:41at each other. And that oftentimes is really
- 1:02:43helpful. And they'll refuse to point the finger,
- 1:02:47which is great. They'll settle with one of them.
- 1:02:49And then they're stuck with those responses for
- 1:02:52the purpose of trial. And if they try to amend
- 1:02:53them at trial, we can show the prior responses,
- 1:02:56right? There's other strategies too when it comes
- 1:03:00to retained instrument cases. Just give me a
- 1:03:03call and I'll go that with you. Heather, I'll
- 1:03:06answer your question, since you're at my firm.
- 1:03:12We could have gone over a lot more stuff. Thank
- 1:03:16you guys for attending. And again, if you have
- 1:03:18any questions that you didn't get answered here
- 1:03:21or that you want to speak to one of us individually,
- 1:03:23just reach out and we'd be happy to talk to you.
- 1:03:25Any other questions? Are we done? I think we're
- 1:03:27done. They forced us out of there like we're
- 1:03:28already past the time. Thank you both so much
- 1:03:31for your time today. We really appreciate you
- 1:03:33speaking to our members and I hope our members
- 1:03:35have a great rest of their day. Okay, that's
- 1:03:38for sure done now. Okay, thanks guys. Thank you.