Latest / Black Holes and Bubblegum / Brian Selznick’s Paper Cinema
Transcript
- 0:00If you hold a typical picture book in your hands, it, um, it usually weighs barely a
- 0:05few ounces.
- 0:06Thin cover, exactly thirty two pages, lots of white space.
- 0:10But in 2008, the committee that awards the Caldecott Medal,
- 0:14which is the biggest prize in American picture books, gave the gold medal to a
- 0:19literal brick.
- 0:20A brick that weighed almost three pounds!
- 0:23Five hundred and thirty three pages long.
- 0:26People in the children's literature world genuinely gasped.
- 0:29Some traditionalists were furious.
- 0:31Wait, wait, how can a five hundred page book be a picture book?
- 0:35Isn't that just a novel with drawings in it?
- 0:38See, that's what makes Brian Selznick so fascinating.
- 0:42When he made The Invention of Hugo Cabret, he was not putting little decorations
- 0:47next to paragraphs.
- 0:49The pictures do not just illustrate the words.
- 0:52The pictures take over the storytelling completely.
- 0:56He described it as not quite a picture book, not really a graphic novel,
- 1:00or a flip book or a movie, but a combination of all those things.
- 1:04Right!
- 1:05You will be reading prose, and then suddenly the text just stops.
- 1:10And for twenty, thirty, even forty pages in a row, there is not a single word.
- 1:15You turn the page, and the camera zooms in.
- 1:19You turn another page, and someone turns their head.
- 1:22He literally used the physical page turn like a movie projector shutter.
- 1:27Like a flip book mechanism, but slowed down so your fingers are doing the work!
- 1:31Wait, does it feel like silent film?
- 1:33Because Hugo lives in a train station in Paris in the 1930s,
- 1:37right?
- 1:38Yes!
- 1:39Gare Montparnasse in Paris.
- 1:41And the cinematic pacing comes right out of Selznick studying Georges Méliès,
- 1:46the early French movie pioneer who made A Trip to the Moon,
- 1:49and Remy Charlip, who wrote picture books and taught Brian how flipping a page can
- 1:54create a shock.
- 1:55And there is this tiny physical secret about how he drew those two hundred and
- 2:00eighty four pictures.
- 2:01Santi, you will love this part.
- 2:04Usually, illustrators paint huge canvases and shrink them down so the detail looks
- 2:09sharp and tight.
- 2:10Right, like Chris Van Allsburg, so the graphite looks super crisp and micro
- 2:14detailed.
- 2:15Brian did the exact opposite!
- 2:17He drew every single sketch tiny, just one quarter the size of the final printed
- 2:23page, working under a magnifying glass.
- 2:27Then the publisher blew them up four times larger.
- 2:30Whoa.
- 2:31That means the pencil grain got stretched out!
- 2:34It makes it fuzzy and grainy, just like flickering black and white nitrate film
- 2:38running through an old mechanical projector!
- 2:41Exactly.
- 2:42And what blew my mind reading it is that you cannot skim the pictures.
- 2:46When Hugo is tiptoeing behind the station walls, avoiding the station inspector,
- 2:51you have to do detective work.
- 2:53You are inspecting the shadows, looking at eye directions, noticing a stolen toy or
- 2:59a key glinting in someone's pocket.
- 3:01The mechanism I kept obsessing over was the automaton!
- 3:05Hugo steals gears and springs from the toy booth because he thinks if he can rebuild
- 3:12the broken clockwork man his father left behind, it will write a secret message.
- 3:18It is like an engineering puzzle where gears and emotional memories interlock.
- 3:24It really is.
- 3:25The boy fixing a machine, hoping the machine will bring back the father he lost.
- 3:29Here is the wildest part, though.
- 3:30Selznick won this massive award for writing and illustrating,
- 3:34but he admitted in an interview with Publishers Weekly that writing prose is,
- 3:37in his own words, absolute torture.
- 3:40He literally said that!
- 3:42He said, I can see the story in my head, but when I have to describe it with words,
- 3:47I struggle.
- 3:48He would agonize over a single sentence.
- 3:51Did the boy run quickly?
- 3:53Or did the boy run down the marble hallway?
- 3:56He felt trapped by sentences.
- 3:58Wait, if writing hurts that much, why write five hundred page books?
- 4:02Why not just draw comics all day?
- 4:04Because he discovered that alternating between words and pictures creates a rhythm
- 4:08you cannot get any other way.
- 4:10And four years later, in 2011, he took that experiment even further with
- 4:15Wonderstruck.
- 4:16That book is six hundred and forty pages, even thicker than Hugo.
- 4:20And the architecture of Wonderstruck is pure genius.
- 4:24It tells two stories fifty years apart.
- 4:27Rose in 1927, whose story is told entirely through pencil drawings with zero words.
- 4:33And Ben in 1977, whose story is told entirely in written sentences.
- 4:38Until, at the very end, their two worlds intersect.
- 4:41Wait, why tell Rose's entire half only in pictures?
- 4:44Because Rose is Deaf.
- 4:46Brian watched this documentary called Through Deaf Eyes, and there was a line
- 4:51describing Deaf culture as people of the eye.
- 4:54Their world is visual, spatial, observant.
- 4:59So he realized telling her life through silent pictures honored that visual reality
- 5:03directly.
- 5:04And the structure came from a puppet show, right?
- 5:08With Bunraku puppets, where one story had spoken words and the other was told by
- 5:14three foot tall puppets moving silently?
- 5:18Yeah, Dan Hurlin's show Hiroshima Maidens.
- 5:20Brian helped build those puppets!
- 5:22And the physical setting of Wonderstruck came from him sneaking behind the scenes at
- 5:26the American Museum of Natural History with his friend Sean Murtha.
- 5:30Going through doors marked employees only, seeing half finished plaster dinosaur
- 5:34molds, dioramas with cavemen missing half their hair.
- 5:38It gave him that place where runaway kids hide.
- 5:41Think about what connects all of this.
- 5:43In Hugo Cabret, an orphan takes broken gears from trash heaps to rebuild a forgotten
- 5:48mechanical man.
- 5:49In Wonderstruck, two kids who lose their hearing wander through museum archives to
- 5:54find where they belong.
- 5:56In The Marvels, stories span centuries across a theatrical house in London.
- 6:01It is always about kids who do not fit into the world they were handed.
- 6:04Exactly.
- 6:05Brian talked about how many people grow up feeling like the family they were born
- 6:10into is not a good fit, whether you are Deaf, or an artist born to athletes,
- 6:14or just a kid who feels quiet in a loud room.
- 6:18His books whisper to young readers: if your biological family cannot see you,
- 6:23you can go out into the world and assemble a chosen family from forgotten,
- 6:28beautiful pieces.
- 6:29Just like winding a spring in a clock and watching everything click together.
- 6:33Alright, that is our look at Brian Selznick's paper cinema.