Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E052: Bitcoin is Winning with NVK
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extremism
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1970. 419-8790,
- 0:16297-2000 and whatever we want to call this, it's all just the
- 0:20same thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we. Sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK, so I'm behind. I say when we sell.
- 0:33Thank you for joining us for this week's episode of The Last
- 0:35Trade, a podcast from On Ramp Media.
- 0:37On today's show, we're joined by MVK, the founder of Coin Kite, a
- 0:40leader in Bitcoin security and hardware devices.
- 0:43MVK is also a board member of Opensats and hosts a fantastic
- 0:46podcast focused on Bitcoin development called Bitcoin dot
- 0:49Review. As MVK articulates, it's often
- 0:52important to zoom out and recognize that Bitcoin is
- 0:54already winning in terms of adoption and network growth.
- 0:57It has steadily gained traction over the past 15 years and has
- 1:00attracted highly intelligent people, from individuals to
- 1:02corporations to state actors. In this conversation, we
- 1:06discussed the potential mismanagement of assets in the
- 1:08cryptocurrency space and the turbulent nature of
- 1:10transitioning to a new monetary system.
- 1:13We also explore the role of regulations in Bitcoins
- 1:15trajectory, the embrace of Bitcoin by traditional financial
- 1:18institutions, and the importance of custodial considerations in
- 1:22Bitcoin ownership. We also touch on the future of
- 1:24stablecoins and the potential for open source developers to
- 1:27build cipherpunk tools that enhance the user experience of
- 1:30Bitcoin. And now, time for the show.
- 1:33We're live with MVK. Hey, I got.
- 1:39Product placement front and Center for this episode block
- 1:42clock Look at that mini here what is that it's.
- 1:44At my desk. One thousand 1781 blocks to
- 1:49Linux retarget. This is a stat we have.
- 1:52This is a product developed by MB K.
- 1:56I got a queue, I got a queue getting delivered to a, a random
- 1:59location because I, I got actually pressured from, you
- 2:02know, this stuff matters when people keep posting about it.
- 2:04You're like, well, I, I guess I have to own one or I'm outside
- 2:06of the club. So.
- 2:08Absolutely. You're not really good winner
- 2:10unless you have a queue. No, just joking.
- 2:13Everyone keeps them as backgrounds.
- 2:15I like looking at it through the day and it's like it's nice on
- 2:19the desk. Well, I'm on camera most of the
- 2:21day, so like I actually see it just looking at myself like.
- 2:23Oh, I can tell. You know, I have like 50 of them
- 2:25in my office. Like it's like no place.
- 2:29Marty's on camera during the day.
- 2:31He is a he's a professional influencer.
- 2:34And I heard something you said the other day, heard awful about
- 2:38everybody becomes a podcaster. Everybody in Bitcoin becomes a
- 2:41podcaster before it's all said and done so.
- 2:44Even though I think I think it's because like it's a very
- 2:47efficient way of getting your thoughts out, like Twitter is
- 2:52too noisy, right? And you know, in long form
- 2:55writing realistically, nobody reads.
- 2:57So like, you know, the, the, the podcasting really is like a, a
- 3:02very, very good way of, of getting the word out.
- 3:05And I mean, you could say I'm an influencer or a first mover.
- 3:09We live in the digital age. You have to own your message.
- 3:12Content marketing is key in this world.
- 3:15And yeah, I was just the first one to step out and say one of
- 3:18the first to step out in the Bitcoin space.
- 3:19I'm gonna end the message. That's right.
- 3:22I mean, influencer, thought leader.
- 3:25It's the same picture. We're doing bum bum checks
- 3:29today. Is that?
- 3:31No, I'm moving on. I don't even engage that
- 3:33subject. Neither do I and then I'm I'm
- 3:35embarrassed I brought it up, but we have a list of topics to talk
- 3:40about. I mean, mentioning the queue,
- 3:42Mike, I'm excited for you to get the queue in your hands.
- 3:46And for anybody listening who doesn't have contacts, NVK is
- 3:49the founder of coin Kite, which has been around for over a
- 3:53decade now building hardware for bitcoiners to secure their
- 3:57Bitcoin hardware devices, hardware wallets.
- 4:02Now NFC card SATS card tap signer and the latest iteration
- 4:07of their Bitcoin security hardware is the cold card Q,
- 4:11which is a form factor looks somewhat like a a BlackBerry, a
- 4:16calculator, whatever you want to refer to it.
- 4:19And I've been using it for months now and just want to say
- 4:21like in terms of like hardware, I don't want to disclaim our
- 4:241031's an investor in coin kite. Coin Kite's a sponsor of Rabbit
- 4:26Hole Recap, another podcast that I host, but honestly the the
- 4:31battery pack and being able to pass around transactions and
- 4:37sign transactions using NFC and QR scanner is one of the best UX
- 4:42upgrades I've had in terms of like Bitcoin hardware, just
- 4:46literally not having to plug it into anything.
- 4:48Having a battery pack and being able to scan AQR code with
- 4:53Sparrow wallet to pass back PSBTS to sign and then
- 4:56broadcast, it's an incredible experience.
- 4:59It's like, you know, I mean, we, we do this because we, we, we
- 5:04want to, not because we need to, you know, like we make the
- 5:07devices for ourselves. So, you know, it's, it's a
- 5:11product from bitcoiners to bitcoiners.
- 5:13Like, you know, it's not like focus groups on ship coiners and
- 5:16let's like open the funnel as big as possible.
- 5:19It's, it's very concerted effort into making a product that works
- 5:23for us. If it works for us, it's going
- 5:25to work for other Bitcoiners. It's it's very focused that way,
- 5:29yeah. It works for Bing.
- 5:32At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 5:34important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 5:37Our Multi Institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 5:40secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your and your
- 5:43family's possession for decades to come.
- 5:45Multi Institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 5:48counterparty risk, leveraging Bitcoin's native properties to
- 5:51eliminate single points of failure that have historically
- 5:54complicated Bitcoin ownership. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 5:57for your Bitcoin journey. For more information, check us
- 6:00out at on rampbitcoin.com. I want to throw a spicy take
- 6:04out. I hesitated.
- 6:05I'm just going to do it as I'm curious MVK how much the queue
- 6:08was influenced or accelerated because of foundations harbor
- 6:13device and why? Why I bring when I bring it up
- 6:16is because I haven't played with the queue, but I got it because
- 6:19I was nicely sent a foundation device.
- 6:23And I like the form factor in this idea of like not V1, but
- 6:27the hardware device that had dongles and all the things
- 6:29associated is just like clunky and messy building on chain.
- 6:32You're getting old people on a call, you got to like plug in,
- 6:35you know, the USBC it doesn't match to the drivers and all
- 6:39that. So that form factor of like QRS
- 6:41tap signing or NFC was really awesome.
- 6:44And then to see you guys do it, like how much was the market?
- 6:47I guess where I'm going at is, was it a part of that that
- 6:50helped drive it and because I personally think it was, but I'd
- 6:54be curious and I think it's a good thing from the industry
- 6:56perspective because we're all like working towards a certain
- 6:58goal and that angle of like. Iron sharpening, yeah.
- 7:03So, so like I, I, I don't think it was them.
- 7:06I think it was Spectre DIY mostly that like that had the
- 7:10biggest effect on that. We we've been building the
- 7:12device for many years. We just sort of like never felt
- 7:15the market was ready for it. I think that because, you know,
- 7:21realistically speaking like that, that company doesn't have
- 7:24any market share, right? It's like, you know, there's a
- 7:26few devices only out there. So there wasn't enough user
- 7:31demand that came from that with the experience using that device
- 7:37to influence the market demand for it.
- 7:41I think the, the biggest demand from users came once Jade from
- 7:48Blockstream and Seed Signer both had a lot more market share and
- 7:55probably like, you know, 10s hundreds more market share than
- 8:01than the device. So those, those two devices are
- 8:05sort of like cheaper, less secure kind of thing.
- 8:08And, and, and, but they had the very, very interesting UX paths
- 8:15they took that that helped create some, some demand or at
- 8:20least rhetoric around having QRS.
- 8:24And, and I think that the main thing that made the QR come come
- 8:28to fruition was the fact that on that year that we decided to
- 8:32launch the queue, the, the supplier for the QR scanner
- 8:40found some economies of scale that were further advanced and
- 8:45lower the price a lot of the of the scanner.
- 8:49So we could economically create a product like that.
- 8:53The idea of the queue has been something on our bench for many
- 8:56years. The, the QR per SE, I don't like
- 9:00it. I feel like most people don't
- 9:04use it. It is a nice thing to have for
- 9:09you to check addresses, but realistically speaking, most
- 9:11people want NFC or USB. The problem is, and chain never
- 9:17created an app with NFC and, but, but you know, like and
- 9:24chain and chain is a small market in terms of like user
- 9:27count. It's, it's a, it's a much more
- 9:29higher net worth folks that are interested in that sort of set
- 9:33of trade-offs. So you know, that did it's a
- 9:39shape they never added an FC because you'd have made the
- 9:41device a lot cheaper. But but anyways, the, the point
- 9:44is, I, I think the, the market has evolved with more options.
- 9:51Another device that actually had very good UX and FC and and QR,
- 9:56but again, lower security threshold is Kobo Kobo Vault.
- 10:02I think now it's called Keystone.
- 10:04They also had like good UX and camera, but it was sort of like
- 10:08all over the place. You know, not enough people
- 10:11using, you know, 90 percent, 80% of the market still is Trezor
- 10:17Ledger, which neither have QR code scanners and and you know,
- 10:23they're still USBUS by Trezor with and chain as well.
- 10:31So we're trying to find ways to move people out of USB, if that
- 10:37be via QR, if that be via NFC or SD card, as long as people get
- 10:41out of USB, I think we're in a better place.
- 10:45Yeah, I'm gonna stand up for QR here.
- 10:47I like the QR experience in because you can interact with
- 10:50your laptop where most laptops aren't NFC enabled yet.
- 10:54Yeah. And part of bringing that up is
- 10:56just internally like we have a lot of individuals that, you
- 10:59know, want to mix between thinking through what does it
- 11:02look like from our product and multi institution to be able to
- 11:05participate whether it's holding 2 keys or one keys.
- 11:08But there's this also dynamic of like when you send, we joke
- 11:11around plastic device of a little treasure one in somebody
- 11:15who's holding $10 million. And as that appreciates, you
- 11:18just naturally like holding this device and wondering like, is
- 11:20this thing gonna last very long? And so that was part of looking
- 11:24at foundation and the queue is like, what does it look like
- 11:26from our product mix as we grow? But then the other side of it
- 11:29and, and I've shared with Marty and I'm sure you guys have
- 11:31chatted about Rodolfo about just, and this is an interesting
- 11:35topic to get your take on a you've been probably the loudest
- 11:38about video verification being doomed from just like
- 11:42authentication independent. End of it.
- 11:44Yeah. And so I'd love to hear those
- 11:46thoughts. But the thing I keep anchoring
- 11:48back to is like the idea of like obviously having a private key
- 11:51on one of these devices and being able to authenticate in
- 11:53some way, whether it's, you know, leveraging movement of
- 11:56Bitcoin across the protocol or other things that I see these
- 11:59devices playing different roles in authentication outside of
- 12:03just participating in a quorum for your asset.
- 12:07But curious on the the video verification because I don't
- 12:09think a lot of people have heard of this taken.
- 12:11It's very valid. It's something we're thinking
- 12:12about deeply. Rather get into it early versus
- 12:15a lot of existing companies. This is all they rely on and now
- 12:18they're just like almost going to be trapped for the next
- 12:20decade or at least next couple of years.
- 12:22You know, there is a service provider I use for some, some
- 12:25legacy interfacing that I have to do on, on, on institutional
- 12:29side that, you know, they, they said at some thresholds they
- 12:37require video, which I simply not willing to do because
- 12:41there's going to be fake videos of me because AI can do that
- 12:44now. And also I don't want an image
- 12:46of me on video talking about a specific Bitcoin number because
- 12:50that just sounds completely retarded.
- 12:53Because, you know, reality is all companies will get hacked.
- 12:57It's a when, not an if, right? So Unchained, we'll get hacked
- 13:01and we'll leak those videos eventually.
- 13:04So it's better not to have those videos.
- 13:08So then the answer is like, how do we authenticate people,
- 13:12right? And you know, voice is gone,
- 13:17video is gone. So, so the way to do it is with
- 13:21private key pairs, right? Why why don't we use a tap
- 13:25signer, right? Maybe it's not for signing a
- 13:27transaction, but it's still a Bitcoin curve and you can preset
- 13:30the device send to your customer or the customer has to come pick
- 13:34up in person when they set up the account, right?
- 13:36So you have a nice solid chain of custody and they use that to
- 13:41authenticate into the app on top of the signature they provide
- 13:44with their hardware device, right?
- 13:46I, I think, I think that puts people in a much better place.
- 13:49I don't think see like biometrics, which is video or
- 13:53voice, It's not something you know, it's something you have
- 13:58and something you have can be taken from you.
- 14:03Yeah, if you've seen and just like talking about it all on air
- 14:06because they'd rather it's better they have it out and then
- 14:09everybody do it or or compete to do it is we have on ramp
- 14:12branches and we have team all over the US And the idea is as
- 14:15we grow you have a certain balance.
- 14:17You come meet a representative at the local branch and you can
- 14:20authenticate this as me before starting.
- 14:23No, that, that's nothing beats in person, right.
- 14:26So for example, it's funny, but I, there is a few business
- 14:32service providers of legacy services that I, I deal with,
- 14:35right? Like that, that are like either
- 14:37Bitcoin bridges or, or they are banking partners, right?
- 14:43And one of our corporate requirement is that all the KYC
- 14:46be done on paper, right? Like, I understand they have no
- 14:50choice. They have to do KYC, they need a
- 14:51picture of my penis, you know, but let's do that over paper,
- 14:58right? So what we do is we FedEx a
- 15:02photocopy of, of any document that they need.
- 15:05And if they need to see it in person, we either fly them in or
- 15:08we fly out, right? They check the photocopy versus
- 15:11the, the, the, the original and they're good to go.
- 15:16Like legally we've checked and, and like most jurisdictions are
- 15:19perfectly fair fine with that, right?
- 15:22How that scale for like a, you know, like a smaller, more
- 15:25retail kind of customer, I don't know.
- 15:28But for, for institutional investors or institutional
- 15:31clients, it definitely scales right.
- 15:34So, you know, I know that you have a safe somewhere in your
- 15:39office that has my identity in a photocopy, which is fine.
- 15:43And you know, remote attackers can't get that right.
- 15:46Worst case that happens is that burns or whatever and we do it
- 15:49again. But but I think that's a much
- 15:51more sane path forward. I think how that scales is
- 15:55you've got companies that, you know, if that, that becomes the
- 15:59standard, you've got companies that, that focus on, on that and
- 16:01only that. And you know, you, you outsource
- 16:05identity, identity verification and, and KYC just like you know,
- 16:09many, many firms do already today to programs to companies
- 16:13that, that might do that best. And I think a lot of people
- 16:17overkill. Their thing is overkill.
- 16:18But anybody that's listened to the Jenseth deal or should go
- 16:21listen, or Marty had a great, you know, post right after that,
- 16:24It's like this stuff's happening.
- 16:26You have never seen a digital bare asset live natively on the
- 16:28Internet. Like they're coming for
- 16:30everything you have. Well, I mean, even even like
- 16:33shopping carts, you know, like Treasure lost all customer
- 16:36information once, Ledger lost it more than once.
- 16:40I don't know. I think that Coin Square, an
- 16:44exchange in Canada lost all their customer data as well, you
- 16:49know, and you can't just force this to a third party that's
- 16:54going to lose the identity, right?
- 16:55It's even worse if you outsource the third party that, you know,
- 16:58scams people faces and whatever. That's how a lot of exchanges do
- 17:02it because they will lose it right?
- 17:04Like somebody that has it on the server will lose their identity
- 17:08information and it's very scary Bitcoin, right, because now
- 17:12somebody, you know, can can go and scam people out of their
- 17:15coins or go kidnap them right. So I think it's very important
- 17:20that, that I, I think we can already make the legal case, you
- 17:24know, as long as some company ends up taking this to the
- 17:27courts to, to prove that, you know, like online identity KYC
- 17:33requirements are, are actually detrimental to the, to the
- 17:37citizens, right? Like you're causing actual harm.
- 17:40That's that, that then people can sue, right?
- 17:43Their service providers. You know, I got kidnapped.
- 17:46I'm going to sue you for damages now because you lost my, my
- 17:48identity and my, my, you know, home address.
- 17:53I think we're gonna get to a point.
- 17:54It's just it's early, right? I mean, banks used to just
- 17:57photocopy your stuff. They still do.
- 17:59You can go, You go to a breakage, they photocopy your
- 18:00stuff and they put in a file, right?
- 18:03Yeah, I mean, you're speaking my language now.
- 18:05We need to abolish the Bank Secrecy Act, which all of this
- 18:08KYCAML nonsense stems from. And the data's out there.
- 18:13The the, the goal of these KYCAML compliance regulations is
- 18:18to prevent money laundering and identity theft and the the stat
- 18:24is that it's in terms of money laundering over the 1st 50 years
- 18:28of the BSA proliferating and these compliance regulations
- 18:32getting more and more insane, they've only stopped point 1% of
- 18:36global. I mean laundering.
- 18:38Flows and then you get down to the question like what is money
- 18:40laundering like? Does that even exist?
- 18:42Is that even a good? Term.
- 18:43Well, I mean remember the bad guys by the law use HSBC.
- 18:48They don't use Bitcoin, Yeah, right.
- 18:50When they want a money laundering, right, like the
- 18:51cartels require that HSBC has bigger windows for bigger bags
- 18:56of cash. This is a briefcase, right?
- 19:01There's. A.
- 19:01There's dimensions that are required, yes.
- 19:04They they ask HSBC to have bigger windows and they put
- 19:08bigger windows for more cash like.
- 19:10Yeah, they said. OK, we'll do that.
- 19:11Just make sure the briefcase has to be 30 inches by 18 inches and
- 19:15you can push it through. Speaking of Morgan, that does
- 19:19the the money laundering for what's his name, Jeffrey
- 19:22Epstein, the eye look there. We go Speaking of Speaking of a
- 19:25little money laundering, was it Solana, Solana ETF was approved
- 19:30yesterday or the DOGE? There you go.
- 19:31Oh no, it was ETH. It was ETH.
- 19:33It was the ETF. No, I mean, like, what is the
- 19:38biggest tax scam is like you, you whether the people go and
- 19:42they they buy a NFT from themselves for a lot of money
- 19:48and then they sell it at a loss and then they harvest that loss,
- 19:51right? It's like with people's
- 19:58pictures. I mean, come on, you know?
- 20:03Yeah, it is. We're getting off kilter here a
- 20:05little bit. But what I wanna bring it back
- 20:08to is something we discussed briefly pre recording and it's,
- 20:13I mean it's actually ties to what we're just talking about
- 20:15these KYCAML regulations and the the ambiguity of what a money
- 20:23service business is these days. What are your thoughts on
- 20:27everything that's happening in terms of the the Western
- 20:31regulators coming after open source developers and the
- 20:36reaction to the actions of the government over the past two
- 20:41months? Are we winning?
- 20:43Yes, I mean and people are losing their fucking panties for
- 20:46no reason. I mean like you know, like yes,
- 20:49that we have an overbearing like legal system that like mostly
- 20:53goes after, you know, the wrong things.
- 20:55Sure, you know, like we we can argue about all that stuff all
- 20:59day, right, But realistically speaking, I mean, there is no
- 21:02law on the books that says you can't have your own Bitcoin on a
- 21:05harder wallet, right? What what they're after is not
- 21:08your Bitcoin on your harder wallet.
- 21:10Is there after is people like evading taxes, right.
- 21:13So they want to make sure that, you know, when people buy and
- 21:17sell Bitcoin and all that stuff, they're capturing some of that.
- 21:19Is that wrong? Absolutely.
- 21:21But let's not confuse that that over burgeoning and overbearing
- 21:28taxation regulation and and the side effects of that with with
- 21:34the state saying you can't have Bitcoin, which is not true.
- 21:39Yeah. I mean, it's very important
- 21:43because the what's the IT? There's no shortage of like
- 21:49recent things that come out and people generally like to isolate
- 21:52and talk about like the one was the qualified custody, but I'm
- 21:54for in the trust, but there's in the trust charter.
- 21:57And then the most recent one, yeah, it was money transmission.
- 21:59It's like these things we look at in like microcosms of Bitcoin
- 22:03or digital assets like this impacts everything else down
- 22:06through my business. Yeah, it's nothing to do with
- 22:09it. I mean, maybe.
- 22:09Has I would make the case, I don't know how much has to do
- 22:12with Bitcoin, but it's this idea of it disrupts.
- 22:14So many. Other.
- 22:15People certainly most threatened by Bitcoin because.
- 22:18Do do you know what that meme with that ad guy under the
- 22:21elevator with the the madman guy in the elevator and he the other
- 22:26guy says something that he goes turns to him says I don't think
- 22:29about. You.
- 22:30OK, regulators don't think about Bitcoin like they don't think
- 22:34like, you know, from time to time, a, a, a crypto between
- 22:38quotes, right? Like comes up like a, like a
- 22:40bill or something related to us comes up in their desk, right?
- 22:43But like 99% of the time we don't exist to them.
- 22:49They're preoccupied with like, you know, let's bomb someplace,
- 22:52you know, let's let's like, you know, like go after Landers and
- 22:57like other shit. Well, and what for what actually
- 23:01supports that is this past week because everybody thought there
- 23:03was like one side and trying to stifle innovation and then it
- 23:06like Trump says crypto and then they're like I like let it all
- 23:08go through whatever we don't care ETF ETH go it's taking how
- 23:13long has it been 10 plus years for the.
- 23:16But like another thing that people don't notice with the,
- 23:19with all the KYC shit show and, and, and a lot of this like tax
- 23:26sort of like this tax recovery efforts, is that like it's, this
- 23:33is international, right? So the, the OECD changed a bunch
- 23:36of rules and, and whatever the the name of the other group
- 23:43organization that handles taxes internationally too.
- 23:47What they're trying to do internationally pretty much
- 23:49since 2014 is like they're trying to find loopholes that
- 23:54like average people like dentists and lawyers can use to
- 23:57shelter income and, and they've been going after that.
- 24:01It has nothing to do with Bitcoin and, and they've been
- 24:04changing it so that, you know, only Halliburton can do it, you
- 24:08know, but like dentists and lawyers were sheltering the
- 24:11Caymans, you know, pre 2014 successful.
- 24:14So they're trying to remove those loopholes, right?
- 24:17And and that has a lot of consequences to KYCBSA and other
- 24:21shit locally as well. There's 34.
- 24:29There's $34 trillion in debt, with 220 trillion in unfunded
- 24:33liabilities. What's another trillion, Marty
- 24:36like? These numbers don't even like
- 24:38represent things anymore in real life.
- 24:41Now if you made $1,000,000 a day going all the way back to when
- 24:45Jesus Christ was born, you would not have made as much money as
- 24:50U.S. government has printed this year.
- 24:51Not even a like a very small fraction of it.
- 24:55It's insane. But how much does this money
- 24:56buy? Not a lot, not less and less
- 25:02every day. The SAT's per dollar number go
- 25:06down. Is is very aggressive right now.
- 25:10We're winning. Moscow Time is getting smaller
- 25:13on the on the block clock. I was thinking about like, I
- 25:16didn't run the numbers, but I was thinking directionally.
- 25:21If you just move dollars to Bitcoin over the past few years
- 25:25and you look at inflation and what you could have compounded
- 25:27if the money wasn't losing purchasing power, If you had
- 25:29dollars and we're just investing or building, you're almost just
- 25:32staying even. You're not actually like really
- 25:34winning. You know, like that's how messed
- 25:37up, like how bad people are from businesses and like people going
- 25:40backwards on holding dollars is like just by moving into
- 25:42Bitcoin, I think you're basically keeping keel with what
- 25:45how things were supposed to be. I don't know Meli, if you bought
- 25:50like a few, a few cycles, even DCA, you're pretty much ahead.
- 25:58Well, I think, yeah, that that breaks down.
- 26:01I think at a certain point, like call it, I don't know, maybe I
- 26:04think it's like epoch 3 post like the 17 after 1000 where I
- 26:09think that might. But then you have to take into
- 26:11like, if the money wasn't losing value, you would have been
- 26:13making money with it somewhere else.
- 26:16Yeah, but he was right. But that, yeah, that's what I'm
- 26:19saying. So like, what would that money
- 26:20like? There's still, you would have
- 26:21had a net gain if the dollars were just static.
- 26:23You would have still increased those dollar amounts independent
- 26:26of Bitcoin if it wasn't, if it wasn't inflating the supply, so.
- 26:29That's can you really can. Can you make more than 7% a
- 26:33year? Realistically speaking, no.
- 26:35I mean, unless you're super risky.
- 26:38Well, if you build businesses that are productive and you like
- 26:41do things in the world, that's what I mean.
- 26:43That's that's what I'm but that's the company's the risk,
- 26:46right? Yeah, it's just an interesting.
- 26:48I was just like basically thinking about like businesses
- 26:51and treasury management and it's like you have to if you want to
- 26:53live or you're just going to die is have your position in Bitcoin
- 26:56and was like looking at it's like you just have to play the
- 26:59game or you're not going to make it.
- 27:01I mean, you really have two choices, right?
- 27:03You either have a PhD in finance so you can beat the market or
- 27:07you buy Bitcoin like there's no middle ground.
- 27:09Like how? How is an average person out
- 27:11there going to like, you know, beat S&P, like the P the PhD in
- 27:16finance? Has structured the Solana or EE
- 27:18TTF because I don't think you you go further out in the risk
- 27:21curve because you're not even can you can't even eat it by
- 27:23traditional like 7 to 9 percent is not beating it.
- 27:26You might be like losing 2 real percent year over year at 7% or
- 27:30not. Exactly.
- 27:34It's it's pretty brutal out there man.
- 27:36And DCA is a terrible strategy too.
- 27:38I mean, like nobody should DCA like you know, you should lump
- 27:41by it. But anyways, that's a different
- 27:45most. People don't watch.
- 27:46Most people don't have the luxury.
- 27:48Most people don't have the luxury.
- 27:50OK, OK, some people. No, I mean they can earn and
- 27:53then wait a little and then buy it.
- 27:54Like they don't have to buy as they earn.
- 27:58Yeah, but my again Fiat high, high time preference box, I
- 28:02think most people are like I need to stash this way in
- 28:04Bitcoin now I'm going to spend it.
- 28:06It's better than it's better to DCA than to not buy Bitcoin.
- 28:09Absolutely. Yes, yeah.
- 28:17So I guess in the broader context of things, let's make
- 28:20this, let's make the case for Bitcoin is winning.
- 28:27And despite what many in the industry who, who are hyper
- 28:30focused on everything that's been going on from a regulatory
- 28:32perspective may think is an attack on Bitcoin, but you're
- 28:38putting forth that like these people really don't care.
- 28:40Things come, things go. How do you think Bitcoin?
- 28:44Why do you think Bitcoin is winning right now, 'cause I
- 28:46always say we're going to win and you hop in my menchies,
- 28:50whether it's on Noster, on Twitter, somebody, we're already
- 28:52winning. Why are we winning?
- 28:54Yeah, I mean, like, listen, like, OK, like this started as
- 28:57like literally a, a magical Internet money joke.
- 29:01Like, you know, like it's like it's so hard to convey to people
- 29:05what Bitcoin the early, very early days look like.
- 29:11You know, it's like you, you could either buy shifts on Silk
- 29:14Road or like, you know, you know, spend 40,000 Bitcoin, buy
- 29:19some pizza or you know, like the the idea like moon, the original
- 29:25moon mean was $1000 Bitcoin. OK, so we're, we're in Venus
- 29:30now, right? So I mean, Bitcoin is over
- 29:34$60,000, right? And, and steadily
- 29:38programmatically like making its adoption wave cycle increments
- 29:43for the last 15 years, right? 15 years is a very decent track
- 29:47record. You know, we managed to have a
- 29:53legacy finance interface added, which is the ATF.
- 30:00They were not able to prevent that.
- 30:03You know, majority of Bitcoin is in the hands of individuals, not
- 30:08institutions and that's the great majority of Bitcoin is out
- 30:13there. You know, we have state actors
- 30:17accumulating coins. We have state actors fighting
- 30:20each other on how they see Bitcoin D, which is perfect,
- 30:23right? We need flight theory for
- 30:24Bitcoin. You know, we have the software
- 30:29being upgraded and updated and garden, we have no single source
- 30:35of truth in Bitcoin. So that means that like, you
- 30:37know, somebody says, oh, we need to go this way with the Bitcoin
- 30:40code, It goes it doesn't. It's always contentious.
- 30:43The more contentious it is, the more we're winning.
- 30:46That means nobody can run it through.
- 30:48We have the the biggest computation capacity on Earth by
- 30:54probably 1100 X anything else. That includes every
- 30:58supercomputer, every single state actor owns, all combined
- 31:01together. You know, we have this
- 31:07incredibly asymmetric defense mechanism where like, you know,
- 31:13an individual with $100 device can protect itself and it's it's
- 31:18like its economic value more than, you know, a trillion
- 31:24dollar bank can protect it for them.
- 31:28You know, the Bitcoin supply has not changed its schedule since
- 31:32its inception. You know, like we attract a lot
- 31:37of smart people. The the low time preference
- 31:41still rules Bitcoin. You know, it's just like, it's
- 31:46not like every property of Bitcoin is working.
- 31:49I mean like I don't understand why people freaking out like
- 31:52it's weird. At at the same time, too, I
- 31:56think this was probably the most encouraging bullish week that
- 32:02I've seen since since I've been following the industry since
- 32:062017 and watching I I I've been on the pod a few times here
- 32:11calling out, but I I haven't understood the political
- 32:16calculus of the Biden administration attacking
- 32:19Bitcoin, attacking the industry just because it it hasn't made
- 32:24sense from. No, it does.
- 32:26It's it's it's Bitcoin white Bitcoin is white supremacy.
- 32:29It's like the you know, it's like it's a what is it?
- 32:32No, it's, it's a white privilege to hold Bitcoin now, right?
- 32:35It's just, it's just for the masses.
- 32:37Like it doesn't make much sense but but it sells.
- 32:40But at the same time, you've got, you know, 27% of Americans
- 32:43holding crypto are, are you, are you gaining votes by attacking
- 32:48crypto broadly or are you losing them by attacking and the
- 32:53answer? Is you're losing.
- 32:53Them because the people outside don't care.
- 32:56And with the SAB 121 vote that happened last, you know, last
- 33:01week, seeing Democrats come across the aisle and say, Hey,
- 33:04there's a bipartisan majority here that, that is supporting
- 33:09the issue. I, I think, you know, the, you
- 33:13know, it was two weeks ago the Biden administration came out
- 33:16saying they were going to go veto this bill.
- 33:18I, they started feeling the heat.
- 33:20They started feeling the heat on Trump coming out.
- 33:22And we're watching the game theory play play out a lot
- 33:26faster than I thought it would the national level, the
- 33:28presidential level. And you're seeing crypto become
- 33:32a a truly presidential debate stage issue.
- 33:37And you've got the Biden administration now backtracking,
- 33:40approving an ET EE TF you know, in over over the course of three
- 33:45days. All of a sudden, it's not a
- 33:47security after two years of attacking it, but they now
- 33:52realize they're in they had the incentive over, you know, until
- 33:56November to go pump number go up any way that they can to to not
- 34:01lose these votes because they feel threatened in the five
- 34:03states that matter in a presidential election that
- 34:07they're going to lose voters as a result of what they're doing
- 34:10here. And like we're this is the game
- 34:13theory. This is what we go on these
- 34:15pods, you know, every week talking about the incentive
- 34:17structure of Bitcoin. This isn't playing out.
- 34:20They're fighting for our votes to in in trying to do their best
- 34:24to to increase the number right now so that, you know, they can
- 34:29make people forget what happened the last two years.
- 34:33Is that true? I like, I'm curious, like it
- 34:37sounds good in my opinion. Mitch and Mitch has been pinging
- 34:39me about this all week that it's insanely bullish.
- 34:41So we had him on to talk about this exact comment and others,
- 34:45but I don't know, it feels too obvious or too simple in that.
- 34:49Form yeah, I am on the mallards camp on this reality is the
- 34:53banks don't want to buy more shitty paper that doesn't pay
- 34:56them. So you know, they want, they
- 35:00want to cut like it's the same shit that happened in 2016 with
- 35:04the Icos that all the VC large funds wanted a cut of the crypto
- 35:08market, right? So A-16 Zed caused that pump,
- 35:13right, with all the, the ICO insanity.
- 35:16So now I don't think it's about votes.
- 35:19It's about like the, the, the scammers have way more money to
- 35:22lobby than Bitcoin does, right? When, when they were talking
- 35:26Bitcoin, nobody was with that effect against politicians.
- 35:30But now that the scammers are behind crypto and and have to
- 35:35fight the politicians that that battle is going to get fought in
- 35:38one right, because the scammers are much closer to the money
- 35:43printer in the contillionary fact that we are right.
- 35:47So they will go knock on the door of the representatives was
- 35:51saying, Hey, do you still want to like, you know, get get that
- 35:53cash that Sam is not going to give it to you anymore because
- 35:56he's in jail for your next election.
- 35:59And they're like, yeah, you know, I'll I'll take it.
- 36:01And and they're, you know, they're it's the playbook of
- 36:04Wall Street, right? Like I mean there there really
- 36:05is no difference on that. But there there is the path that
- 36:09it helps us and and I I agree. Oh, absolutely.
- 36:12I mean like you. Know, yeah, you're saying the
- 36:14same thing. We're saying the same thing
- 36:16because what? They just don't care about
- 36:18Bitcoin, they're just to care about dollars.
- 36:20Exactly. But what I don't think enough
- 36:24people in this industry realize how much of A detriment Seb 121
- 36:29is for for I'd say, you know, as the plebs and the people still
- 36:36have access to cheap Bitcoin here.
- 36:37But the same time, you know, your corporate treasuries,
- 36:41they've got to get comfortable with Coinbase's.
- 36:45The bit goes of the world in single party custody with
- 36:49institutions that you know, are are crypto native to be to be
- 36:53custodying their, you know, their treasuries here because
- 36:56the Bank of New York Mullins and state streets.
- 36:59They don't have the opportunity to step into the space because
- 37:02of SAV 121 and it's just it it hasn't been worth it for them.
- 37:07And you've got all these, these these backwards incentive
- 37:11structures of how, how large companies would have to hold
- 37:18their Bitcoin and, you know, trust single party custodians,
- 37:24you know, try to figure out ways that they can be covered on, you
- 37:27know, insurance or, you know, balance sheet recovery, you
- 37:30know, in case of loss. And it's just, it's not the way
- 37:33this industry scales. And if we want to get the
- 37:35corporates involved, the way that adoption is going to take
- 37:40place, you've got to let these companies with larger balance
- 37:43sheets step in that they're comfortable with.
- 37:46And yes, they're absolutely going to make money off of us.
- 37:49They if that's what the ETF. You know you're going to have
- 37:52this is the thing. Yeah, I've been harping at this
- 37:54for a while, right? Like I, I find this anti ETF
- 37:57like thing that bitcoiners do extremely childish and sort of
- 38:02like very like almost ignorant in a way.
- 38:06Like the, the reality is like we have to get economically big and
- 38:12fast and if we don't get killed, OK, and it's not going to be
- 38:16pretty, it's not going to be on our terms.
- 38:19You know, it's not going to be nice.
- 38:22Reality is like, you know, monetary systems or, or assets
- 38:26or whatever you want to call it, you know, if they don't get big,
- 38:30they get killed. And, and you know, if the ETF is
- 38:34how like a lot of this, this entities coming to Bitcoin and
- 38:38we suck that value in and we become more powerful, then so be
- 38:41it, right? Like we're going to need 50
- 38:43things like that. What do people think was going
- 38:46to happen when Bitcoin gets big? Like, you know, like a, a big
- 38:51teachers pension fund is going to have a gold card in the
- 38:54office. No, right.
- 38:56Like that's not how like all these legacy systems work.
- 39:00Like these things need to to happen in in in a way that's
- 39:04possible to them. Is it?
- 39:05Is it great for them? No, because they have shitty
- 39:09paper Bitcoin. But it's better than than no
- 39:12Bitcoin exposure at all, Right? And and do this force a
- 39:16centralized Bitcoin a bit? Yes.
- 39:18Is that great? No, but it's also better than
- 39:21Bitcoin getting killed because it didn't value fast enough.
- 39:25And I, I totally agree. And what I see here, look, I, I
- 39:29don't think anyone here is, is, is going out to go buy the
- 39:31Ethereum ETF or like it's, but what I see going on is we're
- 39:36getting wins for the industry, broader crypto.
- 39:40What does that do for, for Bitcoin?
- 39:42That provides us insulation and the when the industry gets
- 39:48attacked, you know, it's, it's going to be on the outer stuff
- 39:52that or like the the edge cases that are getting approved here.
- 39:57You know, whether it's Solana ETFs or what, whatever it is,
- 40:01it's we're, we're we're providing layers of, of
- 40:06insulation that they're they, they, they.
- 40:08We're going to become more untouchable because the like
- 40:14assets are going to grow. Assets are going to grow for the
- 40:16industry. It's going to be more meaningful
- 40:17businesses to the black rocks of the world, to the teachers funds
- 40:21out there and the pension funds. And it's we're, we're growing
- 40:26fast. Just like you just said.
- 40:27It's it we, it's not bulletproof, but it's the more
- 40:33we become part of the stories for these companies, the revenue
- 40:38models, the, the harder it is going to be to, to, to break it.
- 40:42Well, I mean, yeah. Besides, you know, MVK is like
- 40:46we are winning in the sense of MVK live through these cycles
- 40:49and I remember previous cycles building other businesses of
- 40:51like everything get they eat it, they eat themselves.
- 40:54Like you know, it's a lot ETF will effectively eat itself and
- 40:56then everybody's sitting there and the people that were doing
- 40:58it the right way exist and then you just take larger market
- 41:01share. So you just have to stay around
- 41:02long enough. Which is part of the other.
- 41:05And this gets to something that Michael, you and I talk a lot
- 41:09about behind the scenes and bringing this back to SAB 121
- 41:13particularly the problem with SAB 121 is that the regulators
- 41:17were expecting banks, if they were to custody crypto to hold
- 41:22the same amount of dollars. They had to basically have the
- 41:26same amount of dollars as crypto.
- 41:28And like one company that did this went under.
- 41:31I mean, not this is not why they went under.
- 41:33They, they basically folded, decide to shut their doors under
- 41:41their own volition with Silvergate.
- 41:42I mean, they had to do this. And it's just completely insane
- 41:45when you consider the fact that these banks are 0 reserve banks
- 41:49at this point. They don't even do it for their
- 41:51dollar assets. But now that 121 has been passed
- 41:55and it seems like they're going to allow these institutions to
- 41:58hold Bitcoin on behalf of their customers.
- 42:01That then begs the question is, do we think that they will
- 42:05recognize that this asset is wholly different?
- 42:08And will they turn into just like block fives on a much
- 42:11bigger scale where they're like, oh, we can just lend this out,
- 42:14get yield, give it back to the customers and have rugging's on
- 42:18the scale of which we we have not seen maybe since Mount Cox
- 42:22in terms of Bitcoin lost on the balance sheet.
- 42:25So like I think that's the big question.
- 42:26Like everybody's happy at the institutional level that this
- 42:29bill has been passed, but I think that's a big question.
- 42:33Do these institutions recognize what they're working with and
- 42:37how bad are they going to mismanage this asset, if at all?
- 42:41You know, I mean, Supergate was scam, but let's not even go
- 42:47there, you know, like they, they, the government didn't like
- 42:50them, so they made sure that they don't exist anymore, right?
- 42:53I mean that that's the truth about Supergate.
- 42:56But, but going back to this, you know, the, the more freedom we
- 43:02have and the further we, we, we have this, this freedom options,
- 43:06the more freedom to scam the scammers are going to have too,
- 43:10right? And it just still man, the, some
- 43:13of the Bitcoiners argument against the ETF is like, you
- 43:15know, you're going to have the scam coin ETF and then they're
- 43:18going to make us look bad. Yes.
- 43:20But you know, if you have the low time preference mindset, you
- 43:23know, we're going to have the next 80% crash.
- 43:27You know, we're going to get Bitcoin gets the $1,000,000, you
- 43:31know, every pension fund buys it and then it crashes 80%.
- 43:35And then there's going to be, you know, screaming on the on TV
- 43:40that, you know, crypto is evil and it could cause problems.
- 43:43And look what happened. And you know, and people are
- 43:46going to say that you have to make the laws that the price
- 43:48can't go down by law or whatever.
- 43:51Or, you know, it's going to be too big for them to take away
- 43:54from us anyways. You know, it's, it's going to be
- 43:57very messy. It's going to be very, very
- 44:00messy. Like, you know, you don't just
- 44:03replace a monetary system, you know, like, in any pretty way,
- 44:09like, you know, look at, look at like gold had 5000 years, right?
- 44:15And, and, and like, look at the amount of like killing, fighting
- 44:20and, and like stealing and, and, you know, faking it.
- 44:24And that happened through, through this time, right?
- 44:26And then, and then look at the amount of shit, how many places
- 44:29they bombed and raped when they when they ended the gold
- 44:34standard. Look at the 70s and 80s, what
- 44:37countries, first world countries did to other countries that had
- 44:40gold, right? So it's like, you know, this is
- 44:46just a path, right? You know, it's not like for the
- 44:49people that want to be aware while the thing happens, you
- 44:52have to be mindful that, you know, shit's going to be Massey
- 44:57and and if you don't want to, like if you don't want to accept
- 45:02and then close your eyes, stack your sacks and go do something
- 45:05else and don't pay attention. But like you screaming on
- 45:08Twitter that the scammers are going to have ETF and that's
- 45:11bad. It's not going to change the
- 45:12fact that the scammers are going to have an ETF.
- 45:16Whether you're a seasoned bitcoiner or brand new to the
- 45:18asset class, On Ramp provides a best in class private client
- 45:21experience to ensure that your Bitcoin remains accessible,
- 45:24secure, and in your control. You'll have a dedicated advisor
- 45:27to guide you every step of the way.
- 45:29If you want to meet in person, we now have On Ramp branches in
- 45:32New York, New Jersey, Philadelphia, Nashville, Dallas,
- 45:35Austin, Houston, Los Angeles, and Denver, with more on the
- 45:39way. Check out on
- 45:41rampbitcoin.com/branches to learn more and get connected
- 45:44with our team. It's important like the the
- 45:47messy dynamic is what I think people are afraid of not knowing
- 45:51order. It's a it's a proxy for
- 45:52volatility, right? Like fiat's dampened volatility,
- 45:56but volatility always exists. And so then when it doesn't fit
- 45:59in the box because certain, you know, rules around privacy and
- 46:02you know, the idea of money laundering and it gets mixed up
- 46:08with, you know, the the KYC and what you know, samurai was going
- 46:12through or other firms or people leaving when you can make the
- 46:15case certain people were probably either going out of
- 46:16business or leaving either way for this.
- 46:18And it could have been an excuse.
- 46:19Like all these things happen and they get lumped into certain
- 46:21reasons versus this stuff's going to be naturally messy.
- 46:24To your MV KS point, like there's a lot changing in the
- 46:27world outside of Bitcoin. And so it all starts to look a
- 46:30little uncomfortable, but you have to just recognize that.
- 46:32And we've lived in a world there.
- 46:34There hasn't been a lot of volatility historically outside,
- 46:36you know, the past four years have been a little crazier, more
- 46:38volatile, but this is just how it's going to move for the next
- 46:43next decade. And you have to be prepared and
- 46:45you have to plan accordingly and have redundancies and all the
- 46:48things that are involved to like actually make it and not be in
- 46:52jail and play by the rules. There's something you said with,
- 46:56with Peter, which is like you have to have good accountants
- 47:00and you have to have good lawyers if you're going to, you
- 47:02know, want to operate, because you have to have people that
- 47:04make sure that you're, you're playing by the rules.
- 47:07Yeah, I mean, like, you know, like you can't change the world
- 47:10from jail, right? Like really like, you know, like
- 47:15and you wanna have a life and, and you know, you have to exist
- 47:18and there is no freedom in any country, right?
- 47:21Like, you know, some countries, you know, like you have the
- 47:24freedom of shooting somebody entering your house.
- 47:26Some countries like to like have less KYC requirements.
- 47:29But like, but at the end, every country that we have in the
- 47:32world right now is common in. So like you have to play within
- 47:37the environment you're in to, to have a reasonably fulfilling
- 47:41life, right? And, and, and sort of like
- 47:43hopefully build as fast as you can, like power and, and
- 47:47ammunition so that you can like fight way, fight your way
- 47:50through a better world, right? Like, it's not like the person
- 47:54screaming in front of the government office that changes
- 47:57the world, right? I want to like first the, you
- 48:03know, talking about those builders like the win this week.
- 48:08I think about the all the like it was cathartic because at
- 48:12Bicco, my job was working with all the builders in the industry
- 48:15or as many, many as we could. Hundreds people that I saw
- 48:19affected by sulfur gate and signature going down as a result
- 48:22of the government largely fighting us to, you know, all
- 48:26the wells notices that were served and all of that
- 48:30compounding over and over again every single month to, you know,
- 48:35the, I think the the SECK, you know, losing, losing against
- 48:38grayscale was, was the the first chink in the armor.
- 48:41But this felt like that it was cathartic that like for once, we
- 48:45weren't being fought against and we were actually being embraced
- 48:48the way that, you know, we're, we're voters in this country
- 48:52and, you know, we should our, our our vote should be fought
- 48:55over. And it it realizing how much it
- 49:00helps all those builders out there.
- 49:03Yeah, Marty, I think you're totally right.
- 49:05I think the, you know, there will, the, the amount of
- 49:09bullshit that we're about to see from the traditional finance
- 49:12system where they're going to be lending, you know, the Bitcoin
- 49:15that's sitting in custody. That's absolutely coming.
- 49:17Michael, you're right. This is just like that cat's
- 49:20going to be out of the back. This is the world we're
- 49:21operating in. So we don't have a choice.
- 49:24It's it's going to be there Will there be failures to the degree
- 49:28of block fi? It'll be worse.
- 49:30You know, you're going to have traditional financial
- 49:31institutions that are getting hurt here rather than the block
- 49:34fives of the world. So it's all coming.
- 49:36We're we're absolutely going to see a cycle again where, you
- 49:40know, where we're going to see the appreciation.
- 49:42We're going to see the people who come late to the space.
- 49:44We're going to see them get hurt by, you know, over leveraging in
- 49:48the system. We're going to see, you know, it
- 49:51won't be NFTS this time. It'll be mean coins or whatever
- 49:54the hell it is. But there, there will be, you
- 49:57know, the reaching out on the risk curve and the people who
- 49:59get misguided, you know, and find shit rather than, you know,
- 50:03actually, you know, finding, finding the way that money
- 50:06potentially could be stored in this industry.
- 50:09And we're going to go through it, rinse and repeat all again.
- 50:11But it's when these traditional financial institutions are
- 50:16coming into the space, it's just I, I, I keep sitting back to
- 50:20we're getting protection with, they're going to help us get
- 50:23big. They're going to help us provide
- 50:27really get sticky where where they're not like the the attacks
- 50:31are not going to to to be able to come in the fashion they did
- 50:34the last couple years. It's it's new.
- 50:36I, I wanna, I wanna be, I wanna be clear, I wanna be clear.
- 50:40My comments on SAB 121 weren't like, I don't think this should
- 50:43have been passed. It was like, I'm an
- 50:44accelerationist. I'm like, let's speed run this
- 50:46shit. Get the get the Come rocket ETF
- 50:49out there. Let people speculate on it.
- 50:50Let all these companies blow up. The reason bringing that up is
- 50:53for the listener. I do think we do have the
- 50:56potential. Obviously that's what On Ramp's
- 50:57doing. It's what you're doing.
- 50:59Your small part at Queen Kite, Rodolfo, is there is a right way
- 51:03to do this stuff and to like educate the listeners of this,
- 51:06like now that this is now that this law's passed, like this is
- 51:09all possible. However, we do have ways in
- 51:12which this could be prevented and the market has to demand it
- 51:15at a certain. Can we just like at least
- 51:17acknowledge? I think like this is another
- 51:19truth that the cleaners refused to acknowledge.
- 51:21Is that like, you know, Bitcoin is available to everyone, but
- 51:24it's not for everyone. The majority of the people are
- 51:26going to use Bitcoin the same way everyone in the world uses
- 51:29dollar, right? Like, you know, if you, if you,
- 51:33if you are a Brazilian government, you know, that's
- 51:36dollars with risk Brazil, right? Like there, there is no such
- 51:40thing as other currencies in the world.
- 51:42It's all dollar. Like the euro is dollar because
- 51:45at the end of the day, for you to build that truck in Europe,
- 51:49they're like dollarizing that debt to either the external
- 51:52countries debt or their own debt as a company, then buy
- 51:56commodities. They're all dollar assets,
- 51:58dollar, dollar, dollar, dollar that you, you know, it's going
- 52:01to be the same as Bitcoin, right?
- 52:03Eventually you're just going to have Bitcoin being the
- 52:06underlining of everything, regardless if you have a gold
- 52:09card or Bitcoin in it, right? You're just going to be more
- 52:12ahead if you have the underlining asset.
- 52:15But at the end of the day, you know, that's the path, right?
- 52:19Like, and, and you have to accept it like there is only two
- 52:22quadrillion Satoshi's, right? And and that's not enough for
- 52:25everybody because, you know, it's not equally distributed.
- 52:29You're going to have 1% of the world population, which is
- 52:32already 100 times better than the current distribution and
- 52:35having the majority of the the Bitcoin and yeah.
- 52:41And this is where like it gets messy and the the point is
- 52:45really well taken in the sense of like both things can be true
- 52:48in the sense of it's good for the industry to Mitch's point.
- 52:52But then to Marty's, to answer your question directly, like
- 52:54this is foundationally why we exist and why like took, you
- 52:58know, the opportunity to build. This was after FTX and seeing
- 53:02what was coming from like the existing incumbents.
- 53:05We're building centralized entities into MV KS point.
- 53:08You basically ultimately for for a long time, you either had a
- 53:12cold card or you had Coinbase, right?
- 53:15And I know it sounds hyperbolic, but at the end of the day, like
- 53:19it's Coinbase, FTX, Block 5, Celsius, BNY Mellon, like it's
- 53:23all centralized custody. And so if you have orders of
- 53:26magnitude larger carnage in the future with the existing market
- 53:30structure, because they will re lend it and they'll do all the
- 53:32same things. Because in my mind, nothing's
- 53:34changed since 2022. And it's kind of crazy that
- 53:35nobody talks about that, that we will see all of those losses and
- 53:39those will be individual. There'll be a lot of people,
- 53:41there'll be institutions that are made-up by individuals.
- 53:43There'll be individual losses. So while it's good for the
- 53:45industry, it's also bad in the sense of a lot of people are
- 53:48going to lose a lot of money, but it's also messy.
- 53:50And that's just part of this process.
- 53:51And so part of the education and conversations is figuring out
- 53:54all the different ways that you can store your asset, knowing
- 53:56the different counterparties, all the things that we talked
- 53:58about. So there's like, it's all right
- 54:00and it's all wrong in the sense like it has to play out this
- 54:02way. And it's just like, do you want
- 54:04to play with the way I think of it like gravity, you either like
- 54:07live in it or you know you, I guess you don't.
- 54:09You either have to kill yourself or just like go in a corner.
- 54:11But the point is it all is going to go in One Direction whether
- 54:14we like it or not. You just have to play.
- 54:15With it, I think, Mike, what's your point?
- 54:18Like I think the most important thing now is this, like with
- 54:22Bitcoin, you don't need permission to own it, right?
- 54:25With everything else like ever, you needed permission to own it.
- 54:30And if gold they come knock on the door if I can take it too.
- 54:33So at least you have a thing now that a person can go and buy it,
- 54:40you know, without any permission and and like quietly too, right?
- 54:44And they can travel with it. So we can enter this new massive
- 54:49world in a much better place as individuals, right?
- 54:54Like so, so how can how can this not be better?
- 55:00You know, how can this not be winning?
- 55:03Like everybody has this opportunity.
- 55:05And and at this current prices, even if you're somebody in like
- 55:09Africa, you can still buy a little bit of Bitcoin, right?
- 55:12That's not going to be true in 10 years, right?
- 55:15But you can still buy the underlining asset even if you're
- 55:18very poor. So, so like it, it's hard not to
- 55:22be like bullish on this. Yeah, you can.
- 55:27Yeah, still by the underlying asset of, of something that I I
- 55:31I keep coming back to it. The the, the where our votes are
- 55:37being fought over here in the US and there are so like you saw
- 55:41the dynamic last week or this last week of, you know, when
- 55:45when Biden got bullish and, you know, started to to talk about
- 55:49the the Ethereum ETF. What did Trump do?
- 55:51He accepted crypto payments to try to change the narrative and
- 55:56and become more positive. You know, crypto in that
- 55:59direction. It's going to go back and forth.
- 56:02These people are are Lombardi's got guns over there.
- 56:09Yeah, the only winning move is to play.
- 56:10It's like. Exactly.
- 56:12You know, this is many years ago, OK, 2014, I think they were
- 56:18trying to get politicians to accept Bitcoin, OK, for
- 56:22political campaigns because if the politicians had Bitcoin,
- 56:25they wouldn't make Bitcoin illegal.
- 56:27In those days, you could make Bitcoin illegal and kill
- 56:29Bitcoin. It worked.
- 56:30It's this same mechanism. It's like these guys have bags.
- 56:34Nancy is not going to make unrealized cap gains on stock
- 56:39because she is a big stockholder, right?
- 56:42Like we want all these assholes to have the assets so they don't
- 56:46master them. And when in the world, though,
- 56:49can someone someone in Africa or wherever they are in the world
- 56:54benefited from game theory that played out where you know,
- 56:59they're holding an asset? And then you've got presidents,
- 57:03potential presidents arguing over who's going to increase
- 57:07their value in buying power more.
- 57:08The dynamic is totally changed. This is this is never existed
- 57:12before and this. Is the game here?
- 57:14On that note, Mitch Logan, pull up the tweet I put in as we went
- 57:19live breaking news. Not that one.
- 57:21Oh yeah, this one. Marathon Digital partnered with
- 57:25the country of Kenya to harness their underutilized energy
- 57:28assets to mine Bitcoin. So we have a public private
- 57:32partnership between the Kenyan government and Marathon Digital,
- 57:36publicly traded miner here in the US to basically mine Bitcoin
- 57:40with their excess energy assets. I mean, it's, it's pretty
- 57:44insane, right, that you can monetize stranded energy
- 57:47remotely like it has never been possible, right, to like because
- 57:52you have to take that energy, right, put in a capacitor or put
- 57:57it in a line and to take it somewhere else, right?
- 58:00And you have a lot of loss to do that.
- 58:02And you know, now it's like, hey, oh, look, I have a hole in
- 58:06the ground. It's not doing anything like,
- 58:08but it has energy in it. You put a minor on the Internet,
- 58:11it's like, boom, I'm making money.
- 58:13You can't compete with these incentives.
- 58:17You can't illegalize profit. Like like I think this is the
- 58:22part that people don't fucking get it.
- 58:23It's like you can't make profit illegal.
- 58:26Like communists have tried. They always fail like you know,
- 58:31people will find a way to make a profit.
- 58:36They want their freedom credits right and and, and like, and
- 58:40they will try to rope in the politicians who are all corrupt,
- 58:45you know, on their 'cause right, and then and then you can't.
- 58:50It's just the incentives are impossible to fight with.
- 58:52It's just that every single sort of like more moral, ethical way
- 58:59of, of like storing money and, and monetizing the money, right?
- 59:04Have always been things are less moral or, or, or, you know,
- 59:08ethically not great or, or they were not extremely monetizable,
- 59:15right? And, and, and, and that's why we
- 59:18always lost like, you know, it's like, it's always been this
- 59:21choice. It's like, do I have to be
- 59:23ethical or I want to make money right?
- 59:25Like and with Bitcoin, it's like, fuck you all.
- 59:28I'm just gonna hold my Bitcoin into appreciates being moral in
- 59:31my corner. Like I've got to be sitting on
- 59:34my little tongue flourishing, you know, until you all fucking
- 59:37fight each other to death and sort it out.
- 59:39But number go up and it can do number go up actically, right?
- 59:44You can't fight this. Fucking incentives.
- 59:46Yeah, I mean, that's a key thing that Marty's been talking about.
- 59:49He brought up the other week about what's more important,
- 59:51it's like the banks or the energy sector.
- 59:53And he made the case and I think it's the energy sector because
- 59:55once you have the energy, when that's what powers the world and
- 59:58you tie it to Bitcoin. And it reminds me of this quote
- 1:00:00because everybody talks about the UAE and what's happening in
- 1:00:03Dubai. And they say like, UAE is like a
- 1:00:04speedboat, like you can move and it shifts fast.
- 1:00:07And Saudi Arabia is like. Like a battleship, and it takes
- 1:00:11a while to turn, but when it turns, it can like take over the
- 1:00:13world. And this notion of like when
- 1:00:15they start to grok and they're starting to get there and they
- 1:00:17start mining Bitcoin and leveraging a lot of the excess
- 1:00:19energy and a lot of the renewable stuff that they're
- 1:00:21powering over the next decade. Like those incentives from a
- 1:00:24geopolitical jurisdictional perspective just completely wipe
- 1:00:28out a lot of this, like conversation around, oh, where
- 1:00:31am I going to live? Who's going to be fair?
- 1:00:32It's like everybody wants your Bitcoin and they're going to
- 1:00:35make it known and you're going to have a lot of places to go in
- 1:00:37the future. I mean, and, and if you have
- 1:00:39your shit coin in mining, they're all going to have to
- 1:00:42move to proof of stake because the AI companies are going to
- 1:00:45pay more for computational GPUs then they will, right?
- 1:00:50So they're all going to move to proof of stake.
- 1:00:51So they're all fully capturable, right?
- 1:00:53Bitcoin, you know, you already have all the tendencies of money
- 1:00:57to become monopolies. So like Bitcoin has that going
- 1:00:59for it. It already has the lending,
- 1:01:01right? It has the computation.
- 1:01:03So nobody's going to like come for the king that way.
- 1:01:07You know, it's again extremely bullish.
- 1:01:10Well, and to add to that, so this is something you're really
- 1:01:12passionate about. You know, Marty is like this
- 1:01:14whole idea of Noster and all the open Internet is like starting
- 1:01:17to think about you have price and then so utility of the
- 1:01:20assets better right on an open network standard.
- 1:01:23But then you have price and those are going to converge
- 1:01:26where the person wants Bitcoin. So they naturally are going to
- 1:01:29adopt it as a price appreciates. They're going to just opt in for
- 1:01:31these other avenues that aren't, you know, Twitter or aren't
- 1:01:35these other like open standards. And so these things are both
- 1:01:37like combining together and it's not one or the other that comes
- 1:01:40to the market. They literally just like grow
- 1:01:42together at the same. Time, you know, like contrary
- 1:01:45again to you know what the feel good people think it's like.
- 1:01:49It's not like, you know, Bitcoin documentaries or you know,
- 1:01:54freedom loving stories that get people to adopt the technology.
- 1:01:59It's number go up. You know, number go up is the
- 1:02:02best marketing that Bitcoin has. Don't tell Rockstar that he just
- 1:02:06put a good documentary out. You know it's a.
- 1:02:07Great documentary. He feels great for us.
- 1:02:10I love it right, but but I am not the 99% of the people who
- 1:02:14had do not give a flying fuck about this stuff, right And and
- 1:02:18and what's cool is that like, you know, number go up is going
- 1:02:20to get them. Yeah.
- 1:02:22And what's going to do that? It's giving the ability for
- 1:02:26financial institutions for Apple to go buy Bitcoin that's going
- 1:02:29to make number go up. U.S. government saying we're not
- 1:02:32going to go dump the, you know, the, the Bitcoin that you know,
- 1:02:34we've seized. We're going to hold on to it as
- 1:02:37a strategic treasury reserve. That's what makes number go up.
- 1:02:40And everything I'm seeing over the last couple weeks, that's
- 1:02:45that's the, it's starting to move us in that direction.
- 1:02:50Yeah. I mean, I think the US
- 1:02:53government's going to dump the coins and then buy the ETF, but
- 1:02:56that's a different story. Well, that's it's like the it's
- 1:02:59like the meme with the the guy behind the guy or whatever.
- 1:03:02It's like the US government is the ET they?
- 1:03:04Can't help themselves. The government was.
- 1:03:06Completely confident. I disagree.
- 1:03:10You know, I I have some of like the I I.
- 1:03:13Do think you have? Was that?
- 1:03:15Disagree with what? The the, that, that they would
- 1:03:18dump it and buy the ETF. I, I do think from a national
- 1:03:22security standpoint, you know, that red software, it's on the,
- 1:03:25the, the shelf behind me. I do think we have, we have
- 1:03:29friends in, you know, in the government that, that understand
- 1:03:34some of the, the national security concerns of, of maybe
- 1:03:39keeping, not, not holding on to that Bitcoin.
- 1:03:43And I, I do think there's a little bit of infighting right
- 1:03:44now between, you know, between different, different branches
- 1:03:48that potentially hold on to some of that.
- 1:03:50Part of the problem is the mandate.
- 1:03:52No, no, it's even legally the mandate of all this.
- 1:03:55This government entities that, that acquire the Bitcoin from
- 1:03:59people forcefully. They, they have a they, they
- 1:04:02have to sell. It's not a choice.
- 1:04:04They have to, to, to, to forgo the asset.
- 1:04:07And then what happens is it's other entities of government
- 1:04:10that are involved in other things that buy the asset.
- 1:04:14They can't just transfer from 1 branch to another.
- 1:04:18It's, it's, you know, it's government incompetence like,
- 1:04:23you know. It's money.
- 1:04:24We talk, we talk about this like I don't, I think of Coinbase and
- 1:04:27whatever Bitcoin they hold as the government.
- 1:04:31Like I don't think there's any difference in the like if you
- 1:04:34don't have, if you Coinbase and the ETF is holding the Bitcoin,
- 1:04:36then it's the government's. And whether that line is
- 1:04:39tomorrow or three years or five years, there's a there's a
- 1:04:42certain point. Like, I mean, Condoleezza is a
- 1:04:44board member at Coinbase, right? It doesn't get more deep state
- 1:04:48than that. Yeah.
- 1:04:49Or at least was interesting. Yeah.
- 1:04:54Those guys are not playing to lose.
- 1:04:56They're incompetent, Spock, but they're not playing to.
- 1:04:59Lose. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:01I mean, you see this with their partnership with the IRS, the
- 1:05:05partnership with the Hacking Team back in the day, their
- 1:05:08partnership with USDC. They're trying to be the
- 1:05:12compliant government friendly. I mean their partnership with
- 1:05:16Feather, right? I mean, they told Tether, OK,
- 1:05:19you guys can all have anything else.
- 1:05:20It's not Treasury. It's Tether becomes the 16th
- 1:05:24biggest purchaser of U.S. Treasuries on the planet.
- 1:05:29Let's just say that they have full freedom, right?
- 1:05:31Yeah. Yeah, they don't get talked
- 1:05:34about it enough. Like you can't move that amount
- 1:05:35of money through a banking system without having certain
- 1:05:37relationships. It doesn't.
- 1:05:39No, I mean helicopters show up. Like, you know.
- 1:05:42Helicopters show up, those Apaches and Chinooks show up for
- 1:05:46a lot less then the it's true. But we need companies like this
- 1:05:55doing it like they pave the way so that like the builders in our
- 1:05:59like you need the coin bases, you need the tethers to go cozy
- 1:06:02up because that allows the framework for companies like on
- 1:06:07ramp to, you know, to come into the space and and go do this
- 1:06:10better and. It's the framework, right?
- 1:06:14Like this is this, the Bitcoiners need to shed this
- 1:06:16framework of like thinking that we have some agency of what
- 1:06:20people are going to do or not do.
- 1:06:22It's like we don't allow or disallow Coinbase to exist.
- 1:06:26Like fuck Brian, right? Like, I mean, those guys are
- 1:06:29horrible human beings in that entity and they hate Bitcoin.
- 1:06:33But but like it's not in our control.
- 1:06:37Like, you know, in this free market that we're building, you
- 1:06:41know, to like have any agencies to like, you know, they can't
- 1:06:44exist or they can't exist, right?
- 1:06:46People normally argue about these things as as if we have
- 1:06:49any agency. We don't, right?
- 1:06:50I mean the the incentives are such that they exist.
- 1:06:55It is funny though, on Twitter, people thinking that they have
- 1:06:57the agency of these sort of things, but they they did grab
- 1:07:01the popcorn and watch. That's that's that's all you can
- 1:07:04do. And I think we come. 20 days
- 1:07:07started. Sorry.
- 1:07:08No, no, go ahead. I was just going to say, I think
- 1:07:10they conflate the agency of them versus the agency of themselves
- 1:07:13because we're saying both the same thing.
- 1:07:14It's like the market's going to do, the market does.
- 1:07:16You don't have to participate in it and you shouldn't because
- 1:07:18you're probably get rugged, which is the.
- 1:07:20Point. This leads to a good last topic
- 1:07:22too. It's like while all this go is
- 1:07:23going on and MVK won't put words in your mouth, but I think we're
- 1:07:26aligned in the sense that we think a lot of the regulatory
- 1:07:30quote, UN quote, regulatory clarity and Wall Street getting
- 1:07:33introduced provides cover for people building out cypherpunk
- 1:07:37tools like whether that's on chain be the lightning network
- 1:07:41now, these chomi immense, combining all of this with
- 1:07:44Noster, like we could look up a decade from now.
- 1:07:47And while everybody's focused on institutionalized white glove
- 1:07:51Bitcoin, you have this movement of open source developers
- 1:07:56building out sci-fi tech that is fundamentally better from a user
- 1:08:00experience point of view that enables people to actually like
- 1:08:05use Bitcoin in a truly sovereign and, and as a medium of exchange
- 1:08:10over over these protocols. Yeah, I mean you know, like we
- 1:08:15like money is not very good, even the best money is not good
- 1:08:20if you can't coordinate commerce, right and and the
- 1:08:26comms are all compromised and and censored, right.
- 1:08:30So if you can't have clear means of coordinating that commerce
- 1:08:35and price discovery, then then money could die.
- 1:08:39And so like, we can't depend on Twitter, we can't depend on
- 1:08:42anything that's centralized, right?
- 1:08:44Like we've learned that with money that you cannot depend on
- 1:08:47a database to have a fair monetary system.
- 1:08:50So Bitcoin exists and exists outside of this centralized sort
- 1:08:54of like dynamics. And, you know, for a long time,
- 1:08:58we didn't have a solution to go around like Twitter and to go
- 1:09:01around e-mail and, and things that are sort of like very, very
- 1:09:04centralized or have centralizing tendencies.
- 1:09:07And, and Noster resolves a lot of this, this problems, you
- 1:09:11know, and, and I think the two combined like give us like, you
- 1:09:15know, a superpower, right? Like you can now coordinate
- 1:09:22price, discover and exchange, right?
- 1:09:24And, and I mean, you don't need anything else to build
- 1:09:27civilization, right? The rest is just people being
- 1:09:31people and sorting shit out. Yeah.
- 1:09:34Yeah. What is it?
- 1:09:38What can you break down? The something I'm working
- 1:09:42through is like the idea the E cash is 1 component, but the
- 1:09:45dollar peg and this idea of the guys working on it, like one of
- 1:09:51the angles from the use case is just because people aren't used
- 1:09:54to seeing sats and the numbers in decimals.
- 1:09:55So that this natural way to receive the dollar kind of
- 1:09:59obvious gate. What's happening in the
- 1:10:00background. And then if you want to get out
- 1:10:01of it, you know, obviously need the edges to get into back in a
- 1:10:05Fiat. But like where you see the use
- 1:10:07case there if there is a use case, because I know this left
- 1:10:10this, this stuff just like started to get, you know, more
- 1:10:13popular the past few weeks. But curious like how you guys
- 1:10:15are thinking about it. I I think there's like two parts
- 1:10:19to this. One is we have the unit bias
- 1:10:21problem, right? But don't worry when, when SAT
- 1:10:24dollar happens in the next few years that resolves that
- 1:10:26problem. The the issue is like, you know,
- 1:10:31the best shit coin in the planet is the US dollar, right?
- 1:10:34Like what people want is not Ethereum, Solana or any of the
- 1:10:39shit or even Bitcoin, but they want U.S. dollars, but they want
- 1:10:42freedom dollars, right? And if you are in in pretty much
- 1:10:45any country on the planet, there is no freedom dollars unless you
- 1:10:48use cash and even then you know you're losing on you're losing
- 1:10:52if you try to store it. But people for commerce, they
- 1:10:55need stability, right? You need to know that your
- 1:10:57contract that you signed today has similar economical
- 1:11:02purchasing power in six months, right?
- 1:11:05Otherwise, like if you ever dealt with currencies that are
- 1:11:08very volatile, it's a fucking right.
- 1:11:11I mean, Canadian dollar lost like, I don't know, 30% in the
- 1:11:14last few years, right? It's very unpleasant to the
- 1:11:16business in USD denominated that if you were doing a Canadian, a
- 1:11:21Canadian underlining transaction, right?
- 1:11:25So you know, for business to operate, business needs to be
- 1:11:28concerned with that contract being similar in six months so
- 1:11:33that they can close that trade. Now you can't do that with
- 1:11:36Bitcoin, right? I mean, like it's very difficult
- 1:11:39to to to price out six months in Bitcoin for you to do that
- 1:11:42contract. So what do people do is they use
- 1:11:45tether, right, because tether is freedom dollars.
- 1:11:48I mean, at least kind of, I mean they, they, they block a lot of
- 1:11:51people, but a lot of people get through, right?
- 1:11:53And so think about Tether as the old school Swiss bank account,
- 1:11:59right? It's like, you know, it was
- 1:12:00Frank denominated. Really, you could have US
- 1:12:02denominated at a time, But but the point is you have you have a
- 1:12:06stable coin. That's what U.S. dollar is and
- 1:12:10the demand is high for that. But people need freedom, which
- 1:12:12the dollar doesn't offer anymore.
- 1:12:14So what you need is how can you dominate, denominate in USD but
- 1:12:19still have an underlining freedom asset, right?
- 1:12:21And people are trying to do that with Bitcoin.
- 1:12:23It's complicated, it's tricky. You can get very fucked because
- 1:12:26the price moves so much. So, you know, creating those
- 1:12:30hedges is tricky, but the point is you can now create a stable
- 1:12:37coin based on Bitcoin. It's as as risky as it is, but
- 1:12:42the people using those, those those freedom dollars on E cash
- 1:12:48that are backed by Bitcoin, they don't need that money for a long
- 1:12:51time and their alternatives available to them are horrible,
- 1:12:56right? What's the alternative to that
- 1:12:59for an Argentinian person, Argentinian peso?
- 1:13:01Good luck with that, right? Or, or somebody in Africa
- 1:13:05somewhere, like good luck to that using your local currency.
- 1:13:08You don't want that shit. So the demand for stable dollars
- 1:13:13backed by something they have access to, to have those stable
- 1:13:17dollars is only going to grow. And E cash is absolutely perfect
- 1:13:22for that. E cash is free banking, right?
- 1:13:26And, and we all know the free banking, you know, like it or
- 1:13:29don't like it is a very natural demand, sort of like a service,
- 1:13:37right? Like there's very natural demand
- 1:13:39for that because people need credit or you need credit to
- 1:13:42create stability on some hedge, right?
- 1:13:46And, and I think E cash is going to feel that issue very well
- 1:13:48because it can, it can always be cleared between the mints on
- 1:13:52Bitcoin that'd be lightning or on chain.
- 1:13:55So, so sort of like sorry for the roundaboutness, but it's
- 1:13:59kind of important that like we, we recognize why the stable
- 1:14:03dollar is important and, and why the underlying thing that holds
- 1:14:07the dollar is important. No, that's helpful context.
- 1:14:11I mean, it's why I've thought for a very long time, and I
- 1:14:14don't know if this would be controversial take or not, but a
- 1:14:16lot of these E cash mints look a lot like on ramp or term because
- 1:14:21the reality is whether it's the consumer wanting to know who's
- 1:14:25running it and the like, idea of exit scam.
- 1:14:27And all these things become a lot less likely when you have
- 1:14:30not only a single custodian that can't unilaterally move and rug
- 1:14:34you, but they also have laws and regulations and balance sheets
- 1:14:37that protect it. And then as it starts to play
- 1:14:40around with this like dollar denomination, as you know, when
- 1:14:43it's 10 million hundred million, maybe nobody cares, but you're
- 1:14:45talking five $10 billion now people start to care and you
- 1:14:48have to be able to, you know, navigate the accounting, legal
- 1:14:52and tax perspectives from it. So yeah.
- 1:14:57Of this term called Million mints.
- 1:15:01So when you move the trust to the edges, right, that's what
- 1:15:03the cash does. And if you have a million mints
- 1:15:06each holding $5, which state actor is going to go after a
- 1:15:10dude holding $5? It's sure there's going to be
- 1:15:15selective enforcement, whatever, right?
- 1:15:17Like, it's not pretty, it's messy.
- 1:15:18But reality is you can't shut down a million mints each
- 1:15:22holding $5. Like good luck.
- 1:15:25And that's the idea behind this, as well as when you think about
- 1:15:27ETFs and financial service partners as we work with banks
- 1:15:30and other things step in, they just hold one of the keys in a
- 1:15:32quorum for their own partners and they can't rug themselves.
- 1:15:35And they also can't be rugged because they don't have
- 1:15:37unilateral control. And he's just spread that game
- 1:15:39theory. Two parts of Rodolfo, he doesn't
- 1:15:41know his involvement in this business.
- 1:15:42When we first were bringing this out, I showed him it in his
- 1:15:45mind, you know, most people looked at multi institutional
- 1:15:47like, what do you what is this? He's like, oh, of course, like
- 1:15:49this makes complete sense. And the other one was, I think
- 1:15:51it was in Utah at a beef steak. I brought up, we were talking
- 1:15:54about, I think you and your wife referenced the last trade as
- 1:15:58like this is just the last trade.
- 1:15:59And obviously this is the the name of the show.
- 1:16:01It was, it was a mutual, I think you may have said it first or we
- 1:16:04were both talking about it, but the idea wasn't solely mine.
- 1:16:06And I haven't, I don't think anybody knows that yet.
- 1:16:08So you're very foundational even in this show in the last trade.
- 1:16:12I. Appreciate it.
- 1:16:14I mean, it really is right. I mean, once you buy Bitcoin,
- 1:16:17you don't, you don't like you might, you might have to spend
- 1:16:21some Bitcoin to do things, but like nobody sells Bitcoin to
- 1:16:25hold. There's nothing else.
- 1:16:28Or to or to buy gold or to buy stock.
- 1:16:31Can Can you imagine like who's selling Bitcoin out there to go
- 1:16:35buy some NVIDIA? Like nobody's doing that.
- 1:16:38They might, they might just like have new cash flow that they are
- 1:16:42locating some to NVIDIA, but nobody's selling Bitcoin to buy
- 1:16:45NVIDIA. I I think you're wrong.
- 1:16:47I think it is happening unfortunately and but I don't
- 1:16:52think we're, I think it's our. I think he just boxed himself.
- 1:16:57Yeah, I don't know. I don't want to.
- 1:16:59So I think this is actually this podcast.
- 1:17:02Now, no, no, now we're going to have to wait for two parts.
- 1:17:06We're going to kind of quasi rug.
- 1:17:10I don't want to. There are a lot of people short
- 1:17:13Bitcoin that we thought held, you know, or you know, talk
- 1:17:16about being having. Oh, absolutely.
- 1:17:19Everything is a large. Yeah, So you, everybody's on
- 1:17:22Twitter, you look at these large exchanges and you think people
- 1:17:25there holding Bitcoin they like might have zero Bitcoin.
- 1:17:27That's all, all I'll say about that.
- 1:17:31So maybe he did docs himself in his NVIDIA position.
- 1:17:34You heard it here, Mitch's NVIDIA Maxx.
- 1:17:37Mitch's an an NVIDIA Maxx. We're going to spread that
- 1:17:40rumor. I, I, I So number one, I think
- 1:17:44you think about like the ETF flows, like those people are
- 1:17:48100% selling Bitcoin to go into something else for whether it's
- 1:17:51rebalancing. Or, Oh yeah, but that's not
- 1:17:53Bitcoin. That's not Bitcoin #2 like
- 1:17:57they're, I mean, messages with friends that, that don't, that,
- 1:18:01that we've dragged into Bitcoin that don't totally understand it
- 1:18:04yet focused on, you know, maybe they're up 10% and they get out
- 1:18:09and go buy something else. They, they, they don't get it
- 1:18:11yet. It's the last trade happens not
- 1:18:14when you first buy Bitcoin, it's when you actually understand
- 1:18:17it's the last trade. So I, I, I think there's.
- 1:18:21Let me put it to you this way. Yeah, I, I think I don't want to
- 1:18:24sound like goal posting, but I guess it should have qualified
- 1:18:27that comment a little. Think about it this way.
- 1:18:30I I don't think a single person like who has Bitcoin in a
- 1:18:35hardware wallet right that they took self custody is moving that
- 1:18:38Bitcoin back to an exchange to buy NVIDIA.
- 1:18:40Totally agree. Totally agree with you there.
- 1:18:43You know, and that's what I would consider a bitcoiner.
- 1:18:46The rest is just in for the ride, right?
- 1:18:48But I'm talking about the people who actually took self custody
- 1:18:51of it, right? Like I, I, I can't imagine that
- 1:18:53flow. I I, I seriously cannot imagine
- 1:18:56a person doing that. Yeah, it's a it's too early.
- 1:19:05They had their earning calls today, right Mitch?
- 1:19:08What? What's how?
- 1:19:09How good did NVIDIA do they? Crushed it.
- 1:19:11No, I I think it was up like 10% yesterday.
- 1:19:13But. People are saying.
- 1:19:16What do we think? Are they, are they in the next
- 1:19:18Enron? I've seen people say.
- 1:19:19No, the next Enron, that's real. It's real.
- 1:19:22Like the amount of fucking silicon those guys are selling
- 1:19:25it, It's it's absolutely lunous. Like you can't do AI without
- 1:19:30that. It's like, it's like somebody
- 1:19:32just discovered oil, right? And, and, and like whatever
- 1:19:36thing you need to do oil say steal, right?
- 1:19:39Like they're the only people who have the best steal.
- 1:19:44Like think about it that way. Like you, you just, you can't
- 1:19:47exist in this new attack. You doubt them for now.
- 1:19:53This was an amazing pod and it's very different than our regular
- 1:19:57pods MVK. So you just know that I think
- 1:20:00some of the listeners are going to appreciate and some are going
- 1:20:02to be like, wow, that was that had some range from the the last
- 1:20:04trade. But the reality is this there's
- 1:20:06a lot of pragmatism and like first principles thinking that
- 1:20:09go into this minus, you know, a little of the shit coins and and
- 1:20:12the cursing. It's OK, but.
- 1:20:13Appreciate it. Beep all my curses.
- 1:20:15Beep all my curses so you guys can keep it.
- 1:20:19Nobody told me it had to be. No, it's it's, it's better when
- 1:20:23it's authentic so that Marty, Marty knows.
- 1:20:25Beep it. It's all good.
- 1:20:26Beep, we're. Not gonna Logan's sitting there
- 1:20:28shaking his head like I'm not spending time to go through and
- 1:20:30beep all this. There's a lot.
- 1:20:36Of beeps the So I guess what would be the parting note for
- 1:20:39anybody that you think is listening to this podcast?
- 1:20:43Institutional investors are trying to navigate the space.
- 1:20:48How should they be approaching this?
- 1:20:51I, I, I think that, you know, like it.
- 1:20:54It's very difficult for a person in an institution to be the
- 1:20:57person who sticks the neck out because you lose your neck if
- 1:20:59the price drops. But, but, but the, the truth,
- 1:21:03the uncomfortable truth is like, you have no choice.
- 1:21:06You're going to be buying Bitcoin.
- 1:21:07So better buy early cheaper than buy later expensive.
- 1:21:11And you know what, if you lose your job, it might be a great
- 1:21:14thing too, because you buy some Bitcoin and you might be in a
- 1:21:16much better place later. You know, you, you drown your
- 1:21:20your, your firing pension package into PTC and move on.
- 1:21:25There is no avoiding it. You know, your company depends
- 1:21:29on it like you, you can't. It's like saying you have
- 1:21:33treasury strategy and you don't have SMP 500 on it.
- 1:21:36Like, you know, like you would sound like an insane person.
- 1:21:41It's no different, no different. And and it sounds all insane
- 1:21:44now. You know, it's all very
- 1:21:46comfortable for me and these other three crazy people here to
- 1:21:49to talk about the stuff with so much certainty.
- 1:21:52But you know, you either keep the take the leap of faith and
- 1:21:56and be ahead, or you know, just be dragged later.
- 1:22:06Yeah, anybody's listening is unaware of MVK Queen Kite, what
- 1:22:09he's built. We just sat down with an with an
- 1:22:12OG for for an hour and a half. You're getting high octane
- 1:22:16alpha, a builder in the space too.
- 1:22:18I mean, you are a rare breed of somebody who's been building in
- 1:22:20the space for over a decade. Most people don't last that
- 1:22:24long. We're.
- 1:22:26Having too much fun. It is a lot of fun.
- 1:22:31Yeah. Michael, Mitch, anything you
- 1:22:34guys want to end with? No thanks for joining.
- 1:22:37And like MVK said, you can't find economic reality, so you
- 1:22:40better figure out what your strategy is.
- 1:22:44As much Bitcoin as possible. We'll see you guys next week.
- 1:22:49Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:22:52If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:22:54episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:22:57app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:22:58today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:23:01Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:23:04for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:23:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:23:10Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:23:12to hear from you. Visit on
- 1:23:14rampbitcoin.com/contact. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:23:18of our private client advisors.