Latest / Figure 1: an IP conversation / What Is a Part 36 Offer? | IP Litigation & Legal Costs Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Robert Games: So, Freddie, if I sue someone for infringing my patent or trademark or copyright or whatever and I win, they have to pay my legal costs, right?
- 0:07SPEAKER_01: Yes, uh loser pays, but there's a but, and it it is quite a big but.
- 0:12Robert Games: So this does seem somewhat problematic.
- 0:14Robert Games: If I have a really good case, but the other side is just not budging, I'm gonna have to run at a load of cost taking them to court.
- 0:20Robert Games: And what you are saying is that I won't get all of it back.
- 0:23SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's right.
- 0:24SPEAKER_01: It it is a problem.
- 0:25SPEAKER_01: But there is something we can do about it.
- 0:27SPEAKER_01: And it's called a part 36 offer.
- 0:29Robert Games: Okay, so you want to think carefully about making offers and make it an early offer if you can.
- 0:33SPEAKER_01: And think really carefully about offers that your opponent makes because not accepting them does carry risk.
- 0:41Robert Games: Hello and welcome.
- 0:41Robert Games: I'm Robert Games, Managing Director of Albright IP.
- 0:44Robert Games: Welcome to our podcast, Figure One, an IP Conversation.
- 0:48Robert Games: Today I'm joined by Freddie Noble, a patent attorney on our team, who is also a patent attorney litigator.
- 0:54Robert Games: Today we're going to be discussing part 36 offers, what they are, why they're useful, and strategies people can use to manage or reduce exposure to costs awards against them.
- 1:04Robert Games: So, Freddie, if I sue someone for infringing my patent or trademark or copyright or whatever, and I win, they have to pay my legal costs, right?
- 1:13SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 1:13SPEAKER_01: Uh loser pays is the sort of two-word summary of the rule.
- 1:17SPEAKER_01: But there's a but, and it it is quite a big but.
- 1:21SPEAKER_01: Um, you can't get costs which were unreasonably incurred or unreasonable in amount.
- 1:27SPEAKER_01: And I mean, no one could argue with that, could they?
- 1:30SPEAKER_01: I mean, you shouldn't be able to get costs that were unreasonably incurred.
- 1:32SPEAKER_01: But I think the key catch, it's the person who has to pay, so the loser normally, who, on the so-called standard basis for assessment of costs, gets the benefit of the doubt when it comes to deciding whether something was reasonably incurred or not.
- 1:48SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 1:49SPEAKER_01: And it's easy to be wise after the event, isn't it?
- 1:51SPEAKER_01: It's easy to say after it's all over and that there's been a decision, you know, did you really have to put that, put a piece of evidence in?
- 1:59SPEAKER_01: Was this issue really necessary to go to trial?
- 2:03SPEAKER_01: Um, but it's very difficult in the cut and thrust of complicated litigation to actually say, no, we don't need to do that.
- 2:10SPEAKER_01: Um, just forget that part of the argument, other arguments will carry us.
- 2:15SPEAKER_01: So it's actually very common when the paying party, the loser normally, um, gets the benefit of the doubt for costs to actually be struck out as well, there's we're not certain that that was reasonably incurred.
- 2:29Robert Games: Sure.
- 2:29Robert Games: So basically you never know how things are going to turn out on the day and what's going to turn out being important.
- 2:35Robert Games: On the standard basis, then successful parties tend to get back somewhat less than they had to spend on legal fees, maybe?
- 2:41Robert Games: Absolutely, yeah, somewhat less.
- 2:42Robert Games: So taking things the other way around, then, if someone sues me, uh, they say I've infringed, but I haven't.
- 2:51Robert Games: So I say.
- 2:52Robert Games: Um, when I rightly win the case, they should have to pay my legal costs, right?
- 2:56SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 2:57SPEAKER_01: So in in that case, the the rule still applies, the loser pays.
- 3:01SPEAKER_01: In this case, the loser's the claimant.
- 3:03SPEAKER_01: Um, the defendant has has won, so they should get their legal costs they used, they had to incur to successfully defend the case.
- 3:10SPEAKER_01: But again, on the standard basis for assessment of costs, the benefit of the doubt goes to the paying party, so to the claimant.
- 3:17SPEAKER_01: So the defendant probably won't get back everything that they've spent.
- 3:21Robert Games: Sure.
- 3:21Robert Games: So this does seem somewhat problematic.
- 3:23Robert Games: If I have a really good case, but the other side is just not budging, I'm gonna have to run at a load of costs taking them to court.
- 3:30Robert Games: And what you're saying is that I won't get all of it back.
- 3:33SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's right.
- 3:34SPEAKER_01: It it is a problem, but there is something we can do about it.
- 3:38SPEAKER_01: And the thing you can do about it is it is effectively to make them an offer.
- 3:42SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 3:42SPEAKER_01: To say, well, let's sort it out now.
- 3:45SPEAKER_01: Um you know, you'll pay me some, um, if you're the claimant, you'd say to the defendant, well, you'll pay me some money and agree not to infringe anymore.
- 3:53SPEAKER_01: Um and and then we won't have to go to court at all, will we?
- 3:57SPEAKER_01: So, I mean, you can do that um anyway, of course.
- 3:59SPEAKER_01: You don't need special procedural rules to negotiate and try and reach an agreement with the other side.
- 4:05SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 4:05SPEAKER_01: But we do have this um procedural code called part 36 of the civil procedure rules, is a framework for making offers which has some quite powerful consequences in terms of costs.
- 4:17SPEAKER_01: So this is what we commonly know as a part 36 offer.
- 4:22SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 4:22SPEAKER_01: And it's called a part 36 offer because as I've said, there's uh the the the procedural code and uh it's in part 36 of that code.
- 4:29SPEAKER_01: Actually, there's 31 rules in part 36 and a practice direction as well.
- 4:34SPEAKER_01: So a few more.
- 4:36SPEAKER_01: The few more rules in the practice direction.
- 4:38SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 4:38SPEAKER_01: So, you know, it is quite a complicated and technical code, and you'll be pleased to know we're not going to go through all of those 31 rules today.
- 4:45SPEAKER_01: But in in broad summary, it's an offer you can make, and if you make that offer within a specific way and within that specific framework, it it has consequences in terms of effectively moving the goalposts to redefine what counts as a win for the purposes of assessing costs.
- 5:04Robert Games: Okay.
- 5:05Robert Games: So is that why we're looking at a Sabutio set?
- 5:08SPEAKER_01: Absolutely, yes.
- 5:09SPEAKER_01: I I when I'm sort of explaining this to clients, I often find myself using this phrase uh moving the goalposts.
- 5:15SPEAKER_01: So I I thought we'd test that analogy, uh, possibly to the limit.
- 5:19Robert Games: I think I think the analogy looks good, but um, you know, to to I would just say that there's just a couple of things missing.
- 5:26Robert Games: Maybe the main thing that's missing is a really good advertising hoarding for someone sponsoring the two teams that are in front of us.
- 5:34Robert Games: So um I happen to have one that I made earlier.
- 5:37Robert Games: That's correct.
- 5:37Robert Games: There we go.
- 5:38Robert Games: So uh there we go.
- 5:40SPEAKER_01: Now we've got some good pitch sponsorship.
- 5:42Robert Games: We've got some excellent pitch sponsorship.
- 5:44Robert Games: So um, you aren't normally allowed to move the goalposts in a sport.
- 5:48Robert Games: So um what's this all about?
- 5:51SPEAKER_01: Okay, so let's let's um press forward with the strategy then.
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: So so we've got um we've got a rugby game going on here.
- 5:58SPEAKER_01: Um it we've got a team on the attack, the yellow team uh seems to be on the attack, and the the red team are um are trying to defend the goal.
- 6:07SPEAKER_01: And uh, you know, it's the 89th minute, and the yellow team can win.
- 6:10SPEAKER_01: Um if they can score a drop goal and get the ball, of course, it's got to go over the over the bar.
- 6:17SPEAKER_01: Um and and in rugby, of course, it doesn't matter whether the ball goes just over the bar here or whether it soars high above, um, it's it's still a goal, isn't it?
- 6:27SPEAKER_01: And and likewise in our analogy, if the if the claimant brings its evidence and legal arguments um just enough to tip the to tip the uh judgment over to the in their favour um and show at least some infringement, then they win.
- 6:44SPEAKER_01: And and if they manage to show you know large-scale infringement and get lots and lots of damages, millions of pounds, they win as well.
- 6:51SPEAKER_01: So that's the difference between the ball going just over and the ball you know soaring over um high in the sky.
- 6:58Robert Games: Okay, so we've got we've got the damages of 10 quid skimming the bar.
- 7:02Robert Games: Absolutely.
- 7:02Robert Games: And then we've got the damages of 10 million flying over the top of the bar.
- 7:06Robert Games: You've still won.
- 7:07SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 7:08SPEAKER_01: As far as costs are concerned, both of those are wins for the claimant.
- 7:12SPEAKER_01: And and that's um, you know, what we we can try and change with our part 36 offers.
- 7:17Robert Games: Okay, so if our claimant is insistent they have a really good case, what can they do to put pressure on the defendant to settle before going through all the action?
- 7:26SPEAKER_01: Okay, so the the the claimant uh you know they they're kind of sure they're gonna win for whatever reason.
- 7:31SPEAKER_01: Um what they need to do is have a think about how much money they might get.
- 7:36SPEAKER_01: And suppose they, you know, have a think about it, consult with their attorneys, look at all the evidence, and think, well, we could get, you know, we think this case is worth about£100,000.
- 7:46SPEAKER_01: Um, what they could do is put an offer into the other side that's perhaps a bit less than that.
- 7:49SPEAKER_01: So it should be an attractive offer, shouldn't it?
- 7:52SPEAKER_01: Say to the defendant, look, you're gonna lose this.
- 7:54SPEAKER_01: So, uh and when you lose, you'll have to pay£100,000 and all our costs.
- 7:59SPEAKER_01: But, you know, we're prepared to save time and sort it out for say£90,000.
- 8:04SPEAKER_01: Um, that that would be a good offer, wouldn't it?
- 8:06SPEAKER_01: Seems generous.
- 8:07Robert Games: Um, so you offer a bit below what you think you might actually get.
- 8:11SPEAKER_01: Absolutely, yeah, a little bit below.
- 8:13SPEAKER_01: And and obviously, depending on how hard-nosed and aggressive you want to be, it might be£99,000 or£95,000 or 90,000.
- 8:19SPEAKER_01: But for the sake of argument, we're saying um, you know, in our case, our claimant's going to offer£90,000.
- 8:24SPEAKER_01: Okay, so and that that put that would put them under more pressure by making a lower offer.
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: It would be a more attractive offer for sure, because the defendant has to pay less if they accept, but it would also put them under more pressure to accept that offer.
- 8:36SPEAKER_01: And how and how does it put them under pressure?
- 8:38SPEAKER_01: Well, it's because of the cost consequences if the claimant manages to beat that offer.
- 8:43SPEAKER_01: So we're gonna we're gonna illustrate this.
- 8:44SPEAKER_01: So this is our claimant's part 36 offer.
- 8:47SPEAKER_01: I'm gonna put us put that like another crossbar on the uh rugby post there.
- 8:52SPEAKER_01: So that's our claimant's part 36 offer of 90,000 pounds.
- 8:57SPEAKER_01: And you know, so we can now see, well, the claimant still wins if they get the ball just over the crossbar.
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: But they've they've made this sort of extra crossbar, and if they get the ball over there, so if they win and get more than 90,000 pounds, then not only have the the claimant won and the defendant lost, but the defendants have lost badly in the sense that the claimant getting the ball over here, it shows that really they should have accepted that£90,000 offer, doesn't it?
- 9:26Robert Games: So so this is the consequence on costs.
- 9:28SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 9:29SPEAKER_01: So so this is the consequence that if the claimant makes this offer and then beats this offer, if they get the ball over this higher bar, get more than 90,000 pounds when they win, then the the it has a cost consequence.
- 9:43SPEAKER_01: And that consequence is that the defendant has to pay the claimant's costs, as before, because the the defendants are the loser.
- 9:50SPEAKER_01: But because it went up here and not just up here, the defendant has to pay those costs on what's called the indemnity basis.
- 9:59SPEAKER_01: And the indemnity basis reverses that benefit of the doubt.
- 10:03SPEAKER_01: So remember we said before that on the standard basis, it's the defendant, the person who has to pay the money who gets the benefit of the doubt if it's you know perhaps a bit iffy whether something was reasonable.
- 10:16SPEAKER_01: Well, now, because of this offer and because the offer's been beaten, it's the claimant who gets the benefit of the doubt.
- 10:23SPEAKER_01: So that that can make a really big difference.
- 10:26SPEAKER_01: And in fact, the claimant should get back pretty much everything they've spent on the indemnity basis.
- 10:30Robert Games: Gosh.
- 10:31Robert Games: Okay, so they could get everything back pretty much.
- 10:33SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 10:33Robert Games: If that ball goes over the over the higher bar.
- 10:36Robert Games: So, Freddie, what if what if I'm the defendant now?
- 10:38Robert Games: I've got this offer of 90,000 pounds.
- 10:40Robert Games: I could accept it.
- 10:41Robert Games: But I'm thinking, yeah, I might infringe this trademark I chose.
- 10:45Robert Games: Maybe it was too close.
- 10:46Robert Games: Maybe I shouldn't have done that, right?
- 10:48Robert Games: But I only sold a few hundred products and then I stopped.
- 10:52Robert Games: So I really don't want to be paying 90,000 pounds.
- 10:55Robert Games: I'd accept I made a mistake and pay a little bit, maybe, but 90,000 pounds is just too much in my book.
- 11:02Robert Games: So, you know, what are they thinking about that?
- 11:04SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean, and this is a really common situation where actually the defendant's being sued on a good case, perhaps an unanswerable case.
- 11:12SPEAKER_01: But the real problem with what the claimant's saying is they're being unrealistic about how much uh the claim is actually worth.
- 11:19SPEAKER_01: So, you know, if you're being sued on a good claim but for too much money, you can make as defendant uh an offer as well under the part 36 rules.
- 11:28SPEAKER_01: And if that offer is, you know, sensibly tailored to what you a realistic estimate of what the claim is worth, then it will put the uh claimant under quite a lot of pressure to think about accepting it.
- 11:38SPEAKER_01: Okay, so so say our defendant here offers 10,000 pounds.
- 11:42SPEAKER_01: How does that work?
- 11:42SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so funnily enough, I've got a 10,000 pound offer just here.
- 11:45SPEAKER_01: So we've got that.
- 11:46SPEAKER_01: We'll attach that to our uh our rugby posts just like that.
- 11:51SPEAKER_01: That seller tape in.
- 11:53SPEAKER_01: And um, so so our defendant's offered 10,000 pounds.
- 11:57SPEAKER_01: Um so we've got a few different situations now, haven't we?
- 12:01SPEAKER_01: Still, the claimant strictly wins as long as they get the ball over the bar.
- 12:05SPEAKER_01: That's you know, your trademark was too close, too confusing.
- 12:08SPEAKER_01: There is some liability as long as that ball goes over the bar.
- 12:13SPEAKER_01: But if the ball goes over the bar, but at a lower level than that defendant's part 36 offer, then although the claimant has won the trademark claim or whatever it is, um the claimant have failed to beat the defendant's part 36 offer.
- 12:31SPEAKER_01: And what that means is the claimant is still going to have to pay for the defendant's costs, at least those costs that were incurred after the relevant date of the defendant's part 36 offer, which is uh normally 21 days after it was made.
- 12:47SPEAKER_01: So you know, if if it's all over and the claimant does win, but doesn't win well enough, so that really they should have accepted that offer, there are there are consequences there.
- 12:59Robert Games: Wow.
- 12:59Robert Games: Okay, so if the claimant wins and the damage come out at say£5,000, the claimant still has to pay the defendant's costs, even though they won.
- 13:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah, at least some of those costs.
- 13:10SPEAKER_01: And if the offer was made early enough, then it then it could well be most of them.
- 13:13SPEAKER_01: It's um normally the costs incurred after 21 days from the date of the offer.
- 13:18Robert Games: Okay, so you want to think carefully about making offers and make make it an early offer if you can.
- 13:23SPEAKER_01: Absolutely, yeah.
- 13:24SPEAKER_01: And and think really carefully about offers that your opponent makes, because not accepting them um does carry risk.
- 13:32SPEAKER_01: And and we can see um now in our illustration, we whereas before it was sort of win over the bar or lose below the bar, we've got a lot more scenarios now.
- 13:42SPEAKER_01: So still, if they don't get the ball over the bar, then the claimant have lost, and that's I mean, as is as it was before, sure.
- 13:48SPEAKER_01: The um claimant are going to have to pay the costs of the action.
- 13:51SPEAKER_01: Um if if the claimant win, though, but don't make that defendant's part 36 offer, if they win but get less than 10,000 pounds, then the claimant are still going to have to pay some of the defendant's costs, potentially quite a lot of the the defendant's costs if that offer's been made early enough.
- 14:09Robert Games: Okay.
- 14:10SPEAKER_01: If it goes in between, then it's a win for the claimant on the normal terms.
- 14:14SPEAKER_01: So if it goes in between, then the defendant's part 36 offer doesn't bite, but neither does the claimant's.
- 14:19SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 14:19SPEAKER_01: So so that would be the claimant gets their costs on the standard basis.
- 14:23SPEAKER_01: But if if the claimant does really well and the ball sails over um this 90,000 pound line and the claimant beats their own part 36 offer, then they should get their costs, at least after the date, um, 21 days from when they made that offer, on the so-called indemnity basis.
- 14:39SPEAKER_01: So that's when they're getting pretty much most of their money back.
- 14:43Robert Games: Lovely.
- 14:43Robert Games: Freddie, uh, thank you for this fun explanation of part 36 offers, which hopefully makes a complex subject quite easy to understand.
- 14:51Robert Games: I'd also like to thank our teams in red and yellow for being such good sports.
- 14:55Robert Games: If you're involved in a contentious IP matter and need some help in trying to settle, defend, or advance your claim, then please do not hesitate to get in touch with Freddie and the team at Albright IP.
- 15:06Robert Games: Thank you for watching Figure One, an IP conversation, and we look forward to you joining us next time.
- 15:11Robert Games: Thank you.