Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: On Topic - Inverse Seating Law
Transcript
- 0:09This is AV Superfriends On Topic,
- 0:11a thirty-minute monthly roundtable focused
- 0:13on a single topic.
- 0:14This discussion will be opinionated,
- 0:15to the point,
- 0:16and saturated with our well-known blend of
- 0:18painfully-won expertise and
- 0:19deeply-embraned immaturity.
- 0:29For September eighteenth,
- 0:31twenty-twenty-six,
- 0:31it's the best-sounding and most
- 0:32diplomatically-focused podcast in higher
- 0:35ed.
- 0:35This is the AV Superfriends On Topic
- 0:37episode number eighty.
- 0:40Broadcasting live from the neutral zone
- 0:46between owner-furnished equipment and
- 0:48value-added services where the borders are
- 0:51disputed, scope documents are non-binding,
- 0:54and three separate parties have claimed
- 0:55sovereignty over the DSP programming.
- 0:58I'm Chris Dechter,
- 0:58chief negotiator of the Geneva Convention
- 1:01Center,
- 1:01and it's time for another Friday afternoon
- 1:03podcast adventure.
- 1:04Chris, yes, I am en route.
- 1:06I will be here.
- 1:08Thanks for checking your text.
- 1:11Let's say hello to today's panel of AB
- 1:14Super Friends with this thing here.
- 1:18Come on, fingers.
- 1:21There you go.
- 1:22Our first panel serves as the official
- 1:23diplomatic intermediary whenever by others
- 1:26appears in a drawing and nobody can
- 1:28identify who these others actually are.
- 1:30He's the attache for escalations and
- 1:32finger pointing from Kansas City.
- 1:33Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:36I like that.
- 1:37I'm going to put that on my real
- 1:38business card.
- 1:41Our next panelist establishes exactly
- 1:44where the university's responsibilities
- 1:45end, the integrators begin,
- 1:47and the disputed demilitarized zone around
- 1:49network configuration.
- 1:50He's a director of territorial AV affairs
- 1:52from Corvallis, Oregon, say hello to Mr.
- 1:54Mark Kolosinski.
- 1:56It's everybody else's fault because we
- 1:57can't afford any of it.
- 2:00That's part of the building
- 2:01infrastructure.
- 2:02That's a project cost.
- 2:04That BYOD cable is provided by somebody
- 2:07else.
- 2:08By the Y in BYOD.
- 2:11Our next panelist oversees all tasks
- 2:12jointly owned by the institution and the
- 2:14integrator,
- 2:14ensuring each party retains sufficient
- 2:16documentation to insist the problem
- 2:18belongs to the other party.
- 2:19He's a minister of plausible deniability
- 2:21from Greensboro, North Carolina.
- 2:22Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:23Yeah,
- 2:25I got nothing because that sounds like a
- 2:26perfectly reasonable thing to do.
- 2:28Yeah.
- 2:30I don't know what it is.
- 2:31Not my problem.
- 2:32It's somebody else's fault.
- 2:33Trust me.
- 2:34And our final panelist maintains peaceful
- 2:35relations with commercial integrators by
- 2:37exchanging change orders,
- 2:38vague concessions,
- 2:39and promises to circle back on
- 2:41commissioning.
- 2:42He's a vice president of strategic
- 2:44integrator appeasement from Bowling Green,
- 2:45Kentucky.
- 2:45Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:47I don't know if I'm the right person
- 2:48for this job.
- 2:50Sounds like I just signed a paycheck
- 2:51without looking at a system.
- 2:53He just rolls over every time.
- 2:55All right, fine.
- 2:59You guys have been here for at least
- 3:00a week.
- 3:00You're probably done.
- 3:04Just sign off.
- 3:05Probably.
- 3:06We're done.
- 3:09The finish date was yesterday.
- 3:10Therefore, you're probably done.
- 3:11Don't worry.
- 3:12Don't worry.
- 3:13We'll clean up the rest of the forty
- 3:14percent.
- 3:15If you haven't guessed already,
- 3:16today's show is about discussing.
- 3:17We're going to discuss the finer points of
- 3:19coordinating projects with our commercial
- 3:21integrator vendor partners.
- 3:23But first, before we get to that,
- 3:24a little bit of housekeeping.
- 3:27If you're listening to this as recorded MP
- 3:28three, you should know the first week.
- 3:29You should know that we you should first
- 3:31know.
- 3:32There we go.
- 3:33Yes.
- 3:34That we stream live on Friday is at
- 3:35about three fifteen and twelve fifteen
- 3:36Pacific or whenever the various member
- 3:37states can finally agree on a mutually
- 3:39acceptable start time, which we rarely do.
- 3:42You can join us live for that on
- 3:43Twitter, LinkedIn or YouTube,
- 3:44where negotiations are frequently tense.
- 3:45Concessions are rare and Mark retains
- 3:47permanent veto power.
- 3:48If you can't join us live,
- 3:49we still want you to establish formal
- 3:50diplomatic relations with us on the
- 3:52socials.
- 3:52You can follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 3:53Blue Sky,
- 3:53and YouTube by searching for AV
- 3:55Superfriends.
- 3:56Please don't forget to spread the word.
- 3:57Share this podcast with your friends,
- 3:58colleagues, enemies,
- 3:59competing integrators,
- 4:00consultants of questionable neutrality,
- 4:01and anyone currently arguing whether by
- 4:03others means the owner,
- 4:04the electrical contractor,
- 4:05the network team,
- 4:06some mysterious fourth party will
- 4:07apparently exist only in the specification
- 4:09docs.
- 4:10If you really want to help,
- 4:11corner someone at a conference table,
- 4:12produce several unsigned memoranda of
- 4:14understanding,
- 4:15and refuse to let them leave until they've
- 4:16listened to at least a dozen episodes.
- 4:18Remember,
- 4:18nothing says friendship like a binding
- 4:20agreement negotiated under extreme time
- 4:22pressure.
- 4:23If you'd like to support the show,
- 4:24please consider donating.
- 4:24Your contributions help us to continue
- 4:26producing the honest content you love or
- 4:27love to formally condemn through official
- 4:29diplomatic channels.
- 4:30And you can find the donation link for
- 4:31that on our website.
- 4:33Think of your donation as foreign aid for
- 4:35a tiny sovereign nation whose primary
- 4:36exports are bad opinions,
- 4:37questionable procurement advice,
- 4:38and increasingly hostile discussions about
- 4:40where the integrator's responsibility ends
- 4:42and yours begins.
- 4:44Please subscribe, follow, share, donate,
- 4:45and remember,
- 4:46when working with your commercial AV
- 4:47integrator partners,
- 4:48clearly define the borders,
- 4:49establish rules of engagement,
- 4:50document every treaty provision,
- 4:52and never assume the phrase,
- 4:53we'll take care of that,
- 4:54has the same meaning in both languages.
- 4:56And thanks for your support,
- 4:57because we couldn't do this without you.
- 5:02That was a lot.
- 5:03That was a lot.
- 5:04Before we get to that discussion,
- 5:06we got a listener email that I wanted
- 5:07to bring up because it's a fun one.
- 5:09And I said I was going to bring
- 5:10it up on the show.
- 5:11I already responded, so...
- 5:14So it doesn't matter what we say.
- 5:16It doesn't really matter at this point,
- 5:17yeah.
- 5:18because I do that to people.
- 5:19Humorous.
- 5:19What was it?
- 5:21So here is the email we got to
- 5:23the mailbag.
- 5:23They said,
- 5:24we have a project with graphic design.
- 5:26I think they mean a project with the
- 5:27graphic design department,
- 5:29where they want a high resolution,
- 5:31high color gamut,
- 5:31high dynamic range for their lab of about
- 5:34thirty students,
- 5:35though they want to do it with projection,
- 5:37which means none of that.
- 5:39Yeah.
- 5:40So how does it work?
- 5:41Correct.
- 5:42Have any of you installed one of these
- 5:43handful of one hundred and fifteen inch
- 5:45panels available out there?
- 5:47If so,
- 5:47what did you select and how did it
- 5:48go?
- 5:49Are we meant to even consider this option?
- 5:51We have used ninety eight inch Sony's a
- 5:53couple of times.
- 5:53They look great,
- 5:54but it's always a bit scary to install
- 5:56and look after.
- 5:57This one will be up pretty high,
- 5:58so at least no less susceptible to
- 5:59accidental damage by students.
- 6:01So his question is and this is why
- 6:03I bring it to the rest of the
- 6:04panel that ever popular
- 6:06What about these giant monitors and giant
- 6:09displays?
- 6:09Are we considering them in spaces where
- 6:11ordinarily we'd be doing projection,
- 6:14but maybe we want to stretch or maybe
- 6:16the budget is there,
- 6:17or maybe it's the right project that a,
- 6:19and one of these giant displays, there's,
- 6:21you know, one tens and one fifteens.
- 6:22And then you get into the,
- 6:23the kind of the small all-in-one video
- 6:25walls.
- 6:27What are we,
- 6:27what are we looking at for that?
- 6:28And what are we like for it?
- 6:30I want to do a one to fifteen.
- 6:31I just haven't yet.
- 6:33I've ordered several.
- 6:34I just haven't installed them yet.
- 6:36He should do it.
- 6:37They should do it.
- 6:38They should do it.
- 6:39I think if you can afford it in
- 6:40color and all your reasoning.
- 6:42In color.
- 6:43Not black and white.
- 6:44You need color.
- 6:45All that color gamut,
- 6:46everything you discussed as your
- 6:47requirement, that is the reason to do it.
- 6:50Definitely lean into that and say yes.
- 6:52You're going to be able to meet those
- 6:54requirements with the solution if you can
- 6:56afford it.
- 6:56I wouldn't do it.
- 6:57How high is this?
- 6:58It doesn't matter.
- 6:59I just hung up a hundred inch,
- 7:02eight feet in the air with two ladders
- 7:03and two people.
- 7:04It can be done.
- 7:05Well, the bottom of it at eight feet.
- 7:07So the front row is like this.
- 7:09No, it's a big giant lab.
- 7:11So it's not that way.
- 7:12And you put the front row on taller
- 7:13chairs and it's okay.
- 7:15Yes.
- 7:16They're sitting on ladders.
- 7:17Isn't that how all your classrooms are?
- 7:18The front row on taller chairs?
- 7:19Right.
- 7:22Yes.
- 7:23Well, because they're at the worst angle.
- 7:27It's the inverse square law.
- 7:28Inverse seating law.
- 7:29Yeah, of course.
- 7:31Doesn't Atlas have those calculations
- 7:33baked in?
- 7:34Yeah,
- 7:35but it's not computing right now in Atlas.
- 7:39My spark's back there smoking.
- 7:40Listen to y'all.
- 7:42All right,
- 7:43so I have not done this yet,
- 7:45the larger the hundred.
- 7:46You loser.
- 7:47Yeah, one screen, one flat panel.
- 7:52I am a little nervous.
- 7:54Above ninety-eight, we'll put it that way.
- 7:56I've got ninety-eight, so put them in,
- 7:57but we struggle with the logistics of
- 8:00getting the ninety-eight moved around.
- 8:02So it's a bigger van.
- 8:05Do you need bigger people?
- 8:09Or bigger vans?
- 8:10Bigger elevators?
- 8:12Vans, elevators.
- 8:16So all of it's your problem?
- 8:17It's the logistics to move the thing
- 8:19around.
- 8:20So a hundred and fifteen...
- 8:23What do I do?
- 8:25A ninety-eight will fit in a transit van.
- 8:28A hundred and fifteen will not.
- 8:29Okay.
- 8:30It will fit in one with a tall
- 8:32roof.
- 8:32And not only that, three hundred.
- 8:34Saws all that roof out there.
- 8:34I was about to say the saws all.
- 8:37Right.
- 8:38You can take care of that.
- 8:40Sure.
- 8:40You're not wrong, though.
- 8:41So to your point.
- 8:42With realistic and most places don't have
- 8:45the giant tall roof transit vans or box
- 8:48trucks.
- 8:48They have the small little.
- 8:50The regular one.
- 8:51Do you have a person on your campus
- 8:54that drives around on a forklift?
- 8:59The answer is yes.
- 9:00The answer is you do.
- 9:00Somebody in your shipping and receiving
- 9:02department has that,
- 9:03and that's your answer.
- 9:04Mark, they will ship or receive.
- 9:06They don't move.
- 9:07Right.
- 9:09That's a different political game.
- 9:12So you need to buy a fork truck?
- 9:14Sounds like you need a front loader or
- 9:15something.
- 9:16It's just one of those things where I
- 9:17haven't gotten the single pane of a
- 9:18hundred and fifteen.
- 9:20I will usually,
- 9:21once I start reaching that level,
- 9:22I will get the all-in-ones.
- 9:24Now they do come in a crate,
- 9:26but we have to take the crate apart
- 9:27and carry all the stuff in.
- 9:28I've gotten several of those crates.
- 9:29It's a lot of wood.
- 9:30But now you can put it together and
- 9:31you can get the hundred twenty twos and
- 9:33the hundred thirty sixes and you can get
- 9:34those of the all in ones.
- 9:35Twenty two.
- 9:38Don't get hung up on the bathroom.
- 9:39Don't get hung up on the bathroom.
- 9:40Yes, it is a thing.
- 9:41Yeah, it is.
- 9:42um but but i so that's where i've
- 9:44erred on on that side of that caution
- 9:46it's like now i know that i'll fit
- 9:47in an elevator i know i can get
- 9:48it in doorways i know i can get
- 9:50it down hallways i know i don't if
- 9:51i had to carry it up the stairs
- 9:52i can take one box at a time
- 9:54up the stairs not great i would only
- 9:57do a one single pan of glass over
- 10:00ninety eight if it was on the first
- 10:01floor i see and there there's there's a
- 10:03thing like so with the one fifteens that's
- 10:06where i i what if it was downstairs
- 10:10No.
- 10:11Unless they have a loading dock on ground.
- 10:16What about just a straight set of stairs?
- 10:18Not a stairwell, just a straight set.
- 10:21It doesn't actually turn around.
- 10:22You just go straight down.
- 10:24I don't know.
- 10:25But it's got to be the short stairs
- 10:27like in old churches.
- 10:29Can you just slide it down the stairs?
- 10:31Just let it go.
- 10:31Out of the way!
- 10:33So I've been tempted.
- 10:36I have several places where I'd like to,
- 10:37but the math on the measurements didn't
- 10:39work.
- 10:41I wasn't comfortable trying to get it into
- 10:43the space.
- 10:44You did math?
- 10:45Every now and then I take a measurement.
- 10:48Every now and then.
- 10:49That doesn't matter.
- 10:50So I did a handful of projects at
- 10:52UW before I left with one-fifteens.
- 10:54I did it deliberately.
- 10:55One was in a space where they wanted
- 10:56visualization and they wanted four K
- 10:57visualization and video wall,
- 10:59LED video walls at four K at that
- 11:01size are ridiculously expensive.
- 11:03Yeah.
- 11:03It's just money.
- 11:04Yeah, I know.
- 11:05It's just money.
- 11:06It was coming out of my budget,
- 11:07by the way.
- 11:07So I was like,
- 11:08if you want a wow factor display,
- 11:11but you want to walk right up and
- 11:12put your nose to it because you're doing
- 11:13visualization stuff,
- 11:14then the biggest we can get is a
- 11:15one-fifteen.
- 11:16How does that work out for you when
- 11:17you do that, Chris?
- 11:18Yes.
- 11:19I did three one-fifteens in a single room.
- 11:21It was a kind of a weird space,
- 11:22whatever.
- 11:23But it was on the first floor.
- 11:24We did have challenges getting those to
- 11:26make the turn into the room.
- 11:27That was interesting.
- 11:28And what we found out we had to
- 11:29do was there's a storage room next door.
- 11:30You just bend it.
- 11:31And then back out.
- 11:32Hold it.
- 11:34Hold it in half like a phone.
- 11:36Yeah,
- 11:36three of those one-fifteens in their box,
- 11:38after you get them uncrated,
- 11:40do fit into a transit fan that's got
- 11:43the higher roof on it.
- 11:45The ones I bought were the New Line
- 11:46STV series.
- 11:47They have some oddball mounting brackets
- 11:50because they want to be slimline sort of
- 11:51things.
- 11:52Ignore those.
- 11:52Just put them on a standard, you know,
- 11:54chief mount that you normally buy.
- 11:55That works much better and easier to deal
- 11:57with.
- 11:57And all the carpenters understand what's
- 11:58involved with that and structure.
- 12:00And so there was no real problems with
- 12:01that.
- 12:01They were larger.
- 12:02I mean, the logistics of mounting them up,
- 12:04you need a couple of big guys to
- 12:06get that stuff up there.
- 12:07You didn't use your lift?
- 12:09I did use the lift.
- 12:10In fact, we used the lift.
- 12:11You staged it, right?
- 12:13What we found was the lift would only
- 12:14get so close,
- 12:14and that was the whole thing.
- 12:15You still got to go that last six
- 12:18inches.
- 12:18There is a weight limit on that lift,
- 12:20by the way.
- 12:20I know there is.
- 12:21Are you sure it is?
- 12:22But we violated the crap.
- 12:23No,
- 12:23you just put the biggest dude on the
- 12:24backside of it.
- 12:25It counts.
- 12:25It balances.
- 12:26And then we put the smallest guy on
- 12:27the lift with it.
- 12:28It's a long story,
- 12:29and I thought that's somewhere.
- 12:30Anyway, I did a couple.
- 12:31Do you think Osh is listening to this
- 12:33shit?
- 12:33I hope.
- 12:35I did a couple other in a couple
- 12:37of auditorium spaces.
- 12:38We did four in there where they initially
- 12:40had one single four by three projection
- 12:43screen.
- 12:43It was way too small.
- 12:44And so the to fill the room,
- 12:46we did it would be two projection screens,
- 12:48but the appropriate size would be one
- 12:50nineteen.
- 12:51So I said, screw it.
- 12:51We'll do one fifteen LCD displays to give
- 12:54you that wow factor space for this because
- 12:56this was they wanted to make a big
- 12:57deal.
- 12:57So I've done them in a couple of
- 12:58scenarios.
- 13:00I will point out there is a significant
- 13:02price delta over like a ninety eight,
- 13:04which is already more expensive
- 13:05significantly than like, you know,
- 13:06sixty five, seventy five.
- 13:07Eighty five is pretty reasonable.
- 13:08You get to ninety eight.
- 13:09Things get way more expensive.
- 13:10You get to one fifteen.
- 13:11They get way more expensive than that.
- 13:14However,
- 13:15if it's in a space and this is
- 13:16why it worked for me in that one
- 13:17with projection,
- 13:18if it's in a space where you're also
- 13:19going to have to put in new projection
- 13:21structure, new new ceiling boxes,
- 13:23new power, all that and new screens,
- 13:26once you add up
- 13:27all of that and the labor costs,
- 13:28you're like within one or two grand of
- 13:30that.
- 13:30So right to heck with that,
- 13:31put a put a Walmart in the wall
- 13:33and it's a better looking display.
- 13:34So to the question that came in from
- 13:36the reader as far or the listener,
- 13:38as far as
- 13:40In a space where they want that color,
- 13:42they want that deep color,
- 13:42they want the quality of the image,
- 13:44then all day long,
- 13:45it'll beat the pants off a projection.
- 13:47But there are, to your point, Jamie,
- 13:48there are these logistics of it.
- 13:49How do you get it in the room?
- 13:50How do you get it mounted?
- 13:52All that stuff.
- 13:53There are things to consider.
- 13:54It does look really good.
- 13:55And I had people wandering in from
- 13:57elsewhere on campus to see these things.
- 13:58So it is a giant sheet of glass.
- 14:00However, I also warn you,
- 14:02Be careful if you're working with,
- 14:03whether it's your team or an integrator,
- 14:04because some of them will logically like,
- 14:06oh,
- 14:06let's just roll it flat and carry it
- 14:08up the stairs.
- 14:08And that will fold that crap like you
- 14:10wouldn't believe because all these
- 14:11displays are designed to be transported
- 14:13vertically at all times.
- 14:14Do not let someone try to turn it
- 14:16sideways and carry it upstairs.
- 14:18I caught them in the middle of that.
- 14:19It was a whole thing.
- 14:19They actually tried that?
- 14:24It'll work once.
- 14:26No, it won't.
- 14:27I don't think it'll work at all.
- 14:29It'll work in there,
- 14:30but it's not going to work afterwards.
- 14:32Right.
- 14:33Define work.
- 14:35Any other thoughts on giant displays?
- 14:38Do it.
- 14:39You can do it.
- 14:40Talk to the faculty first to make sure
- 14:42that everyone who teaches in that space is
- 14:44okay without the front wall.
- 14:45And when you do it...
- 14:47There could have been a shadow puppet
- 14:48class in there and that is gone.
- 14:50Make sure you have the buy-in with your
- 14:51installers.
- 14:52Don't let it just show up one day
- 14:53and be like, that's what we're doing,
- 14:55y'all.
- 14:56Oh, no.
- 14:57That's the only way to do it.
- 14:59Oh, it's here.
- 14:59I guess you're going to learn.
- 15:00Spring it on them.
- 15:02What's this?
- 15:04I don't know.
- 15:04Ask their opinion.
- 15:06As we normally don't do on On Topic,
- 15:07we're going to take a quick break here.
- 15:08Jamie, I did not prep you for this,
- 15:09so give me some sort of slate of
- 15:11something or other here,
- 15:12and I'll run one of these things to
- 15:13take a break right in the middle of
- 15:14this.
- 15:14Oh, well,
- 15:15we haven't done this one in a while.
- 15:18That'll work.
- 15:18All right.
- 15:19Sixty seconds.
- 15:22From Independent Amalgamated,
- 15:24the company that saw a perfectly normal
- 15:26room corner and said,
- 15:28what if we made this everyone's problem,
- 15:30comes the revolutionary new Corner Array.
- 15:34With multi-directional corner projection,
- 15:37sound goes everywhere, all at once.
- 15:41Whether you're in the front row, back row,
- 15:44or desperately fleeing the room,
- 15:47Corner Array delivers up to four hundred
- 15:49percent more acoustic confusion.
- 15:52Enjoy built-in muddiness with precision
- 15:55phase cancellation,
- 15:57because stereo wasn't chaotic enough.
- 16:00and Clarity has had it too good for
- 16:02too long.
- 16:04Ideal for over-treated,
- 16:06over-designed spaces,
- 16:08Corner Array makes every seat the worst
- 16:11seat in the house.
- 16:13Corner Array by Independent Amalgamated.
- 16:16It's not broken, it's Corner Array.
- 16:22A reminder for people,
- 16:23that is the only one of our independent
- 16:26amalgamated products that actually exists.
- 16:28It's a real thing.
- 16:30We deployed it.
- 16:31Well, we didn't play it.
- 16:35It was witnessed in the wild with all
- 16:38of the features described.
- 16:39They got the full firmware.
- 16:41And it was witnessed by the manufacturers
- 16:43of said loudspeakers, too,
- 16:45who are not happy about it.
- 16:47Never intended to do that.
- 16:50That's not what that does.
- 16:51They did it well.
- 16:54All right.
- 16:55So today's discussion is going to be about
- 16:58the process of working with commercial AV
- 17:01integrators and where that handoff is,
- 17:04where that responsibility starts and
- 17:05stops.
- 17:06Yes, we all have responsibility matrices.
- 17:08Yes,
- 17:08we all have project managers with their
- 17:10pimps coming in and telling us how to
- 17:12do our projects.
- 17:14This is based on a LinkedIn post,
- 17:16link is in the show notes,
- 17:18from somebody working for a commercial
- 17:20integrator talking about some frustrations
- 17:22that this particular person had with a
- 17:24client representative at a,
- 17:26I believe it was at a university.
- 17:28Was it a university?
- 17:29I think so.
- 17:30We didn't really, it sounds like it,
- 17:32but we don't know that for sure.
- 17:34Let's see, how did they describe it here?
- 17:36Are we sure it wasn't Chris?
- 17:37Because it's an in-house integrator.
- 17:39Yeah,
- 17:39you got to do the ones over here,
- 17:41Chris.
- 17:41So we can kind of, without reading,
- 17:42because that's a long read.
- 17:43You got to give like the- Yeah,
- 17:45so I'm sorry.
- 17:45It doesn't say university.
- 17:46It says customer's in-house AV team.
- 17:48So basically,
- 17:49the short version is this person was doing
- 17:51their commissioning.
- 17:52And as it's described here,
- 17:54the head of a customer's in-house AV team-
- 17:58wanted to be heavily involved in the
- 18:00commissioning to the point where they were
- 18:01kind of getting in the way.
- 18:03And whether they were requesting changes
- 18:04or requesting things be addressed right
- 18:06there on the spot.
- 18:07It was it was interrupting the integrators
- 18:10process of commissioning multiple spaces,
- 18:13to the point where what they they ended
- 18:14up doing was kind of cutting one of
- 18:16the the team from the the AV integrator
- 18:19loose and like you go be this guy's
- 18:20partner and you keep him busy doing other
- 18:22things while we keep working.
- 18:24And what we found interesting about it was
- 18:26it's all obviously written from one
- 18:28particular perspective,
- 18:29but I think we've all been part of
- 18:31projects like this where things are being
- 18:32done either without our knowledge,
- 18:34without our involvement,
- 18:36but yet we're the ones who have to
- 18:37own it at some point.
- 18:38And how do you kind of work that
- 18:41process with an integrator who has a
- 18:43contract, sometimes not even for you,
- 18:45they're working either for the EC or
- 18:47they're working for the GC or they're
- 18:49working directly for somebody else at your
- 18:50institution,
- 18:51say a facilities or something like that.
- 18:53But there's things being done there you
- 18:54know are not going to be correct,
- 18:56and you're either going to have to change
- 18:57them on day two,
- 18:58or it's going to be your problem in
- 19:00six months,
- 19:00or what does that process look like?
- 19:03And Justin, of course,
- 19:05being uniquely positioned here because he
- 19:06kind of lives in both worlds,
- 19:07and he said, well,
- 19:08he can see this from both sides,
- 19:09and it became an internal debate amongst
- 19:12us.
- 19:12And then somebody said, well,
- 19:13we need to just make this a topic
- 19:14for the show.
- 19:14I have lots of questions.
- 19:20there's some missing variables to that
- 19:22post.
- 19:23One, for example... I want to say,
- 19:25first off, Chris,
- 19:26I think you made it very...
- 19:30I don't know.
- 19:31Your explanation makes me feel more for
- 19:34the integrator slash delivering agent in
- 19:36this conversation.
- 19:38I feel like... All right, Joey,
- 19:40I'll let you rephrase.
- 19:41So there's this jackass who came in and
- 19:44was being a real schmuck about stuff he
- 19:46doesn't own,
- 19:48and he hates his customer at the end.
- 19:50No,
- 19:51because it reads like a bit of a
- 19:53rant in the way that it comes off.
- 19:55When you read the article, yes.
- 19:58and that that's what makes it so difficult
- 20:00because you can read the frustration you
- 20:01can read the frustration i just it comes
- 20:05off wrong and i think in your explanation
- 20:07you would easily say oh well it's easy
- 20:09for us to decide with the integrator but
- 20:10the way that it's written in the rant
- 20:11that it is makes me think otherwise which
- 20:14is interesting why this is inside out it's
- 20:16like upside down in both ways and that's
- 20:18a good point that may be my fault
- 20:19because i did not want to be
- 20:21too hard on the integrator.
- 20:22I think my comment when I found this
- 20:24article the other day, my comment was,
- 20:26this is incredibly tone deaf because it is
- 20:29from one perspective,
- 20:30but it's fundamentally the way I read it
- 20:33is this guy's wrong because he's missing
- 20:35the customer perspective.
- 20:36Correct.
- 20:37But there may be, to Justin's point,
- 20:39we're missing a lot of variables.
- 20:40There's probably a lot of extenuating
- 20:41circumstances here,
- 20:42but it kind of raised that point of
- 20:43like,
- 20:43what does that process look like for us
- 20:45all?
- 20:45And what should that process look like so
- 20:47that both sides end up
- 20:49uh uh happy at the end of the
- 20:51day there's a lot of like there's a
- 20:54lot of ifs and buts here so if
- 20:57if if i was the integrator exactly if
- 21:00i was the integrator uh this has happened
- 21:02to me a couple times um with a
- 21:05ongoing large client that we do a lot
- 21:09of business with over and over again and
- 21:11when some of these things pop up
- 21:13about, hey,
- 21:15this isn't what we talked about.
- 21:17Yeah, it is.
- 21:18It's in writing.
- 21:19A lot of the times we just do
- 21:20it for this customer because we can make
- 21:22this money and time up later because we're
- 21:24constantly doing work for them.
- 21:26However, if this was a low bid situation,
- 21:30this integrator won one bid job and
- 21:32they're trying to move on to the next,
- 21:34they don't have an existing relationship
- 21:35with that university.
- 21:37I can see that integrators response being
- 21:41more like that.
- 21:42And I'm not defending the integrator for
- 21:46his,
- 21:47take on how it played out i just
- 21:49don't like how he put the words on
- 21:52paper how to describe it it's very tone
- 21:55deaf but from an integrator perspective if
- 21:58i have a certain scope of work that
- 22:00i bid on and i complete that scope
- 22:02of work and i have some schmuck coming
- 22:04in i've never met before telling me that
- 22:06i'm doing everything wrong that's a
- 22:08problem
- 22:09Or was this person involved from the very
- 22:11beginning?
- 22:12He's responsible for signing off on the
- 22:15entire project and that signature is
- 22:17holding up their paycheck and everything
- 22:19was scoped out in the original scope of
- 22:22work.
- 22:22Like, no,
- 22:23you're going to have to do this
- 22:25commissioning with this person.
- 22:26Then the integrator is completely wrong.
- 22:28So we're doing this right now with one
- 22:30of our buildings where I'm the actual
- 22:32design consultant on record.
- 22:35And I'm the one that's going to punch
- 22:37it out.
- 22:37And all of that has been set in
- 22:39the scope of work from the very beginning.
- 22:41So whenever the first babysitting fees,
- 22:43did you got a babysitter in there in
- 22:44your scope?
- 22:46What do you mean babysitting fees from me?
- 22:50To go around the person that distracts you
- 22:53while they go and do the other thing.
- 22:54The guy who comes in with his keys
- 22:55and jingles.
- 22:57They don't get paid without my signature.
- 22:59That's been established.
- 23:00So they can distract me all they want.
- 23:02But until I see what I need to
- 23:04see,
- 23:06They're not getting paid without my
- 23:07signature.
- 23:07That's what the guy in the panel van
- 23:09told me when I was a kid.
- 23:12I still never got my puppy.
- 23:14Right.
- 23:15With a lot of universities,
- 23:16we've been in situations where we just
- 23:18found out about this whole thing and we
- 23:21weren't involved.
- 23:22And now you're coming in trying to strong
- 23:25arm some integrator.
- 23:28That's on the university.
- 23:29That's a university problem.
- 23:31and a process problem because I can see
- 23:34how that would play out because it's
- 23:35played out on our campus before,
- 23:37hence College of Business, right?
- 23:40We weren't involved with that at all.
- 23:41So we didn't even go through and talk
- 23:45with the integrator.
- 23:46We're not even sure who signed off that
- 23:48that was done.
- 23:49It just started to be a problem.
- 23:51And so I'm looking at this
- 23:54both sides going, you know,
- 23:56if you have a punch out procedure that
- 23:58a customer wants to go through,
- 24:00that extra time should be allocated in
- 24:02your bid.
- 24:04And that should be, you know,
- 24:06scoped out up front and everything should
- 24:08be very clear on who's doing what and
- 24:12when and why and how.
- 24:14And if you don't have all of those
- 24:15questions answered,
- 24:17the project's probably not going to go
- 24:18very well.
- 24:20Which is what we're seeing here in this
- 24:21LinkedIn post is
- 24:23I'm sure it was a low bid.
- 24:26I'm assuming the person that's going
- 24:29through with this integrator probably
- 24:30wasn't involved.
- 24:32I could be wrong in the very beginning.
- 24:34And I'm betting that this punch-out
- 24:37procedure that they're wanting to do
- 24:38wasn't in their original scope.
- 24:41That's a lot of assumptions,
- 24:43but none of that's been defined in that
- 24:44LinkedIn article.
- 24:45There's a lot of mystery there.
- 24:46To me, it read like,
- 24:48we just want to get through these standard
- 24:49things, get our stuff out of here,
- 24:50and move on.
- 24:51And get paid.
- 24:52And...
- 24:53their perception is probably that these
- 24:55are all these rooms should be the same.
- 24:56And you got one owner coming.
- 24:58No, no, no.
- 24:59This is actually a unicorn farm, bro.
- 25:01Like I can't have the same, you,
- 25:02this all needs to be all this.
- 25:04And they're like,
- 25:04this is not the time for that.
- 25:05Like, and I understand both sides changes.
- 25:08We're just talking about a commissioning
- 25:09process.
- 25:10And again, we don't know what that is.
- 25:11The blue, not blue enough on screen.
- 25:13Like, I don't know what that's like.
- 25:16No, no.
- 25:16I have this one person who wants to
- 25:18come in and be able to do this,
- 25:19this, and this,
- 25:19and this show me how it does this,
- 25:20this, this, and this.
- 25:21And it's like, well,
- 25:22that's not really what I'm here for.
- 25:23Yeah,
- 25:24I think there's also a discrepancy on what
- 25:28is the knowledge base of said owner,
- 25:32right?
- 25:33Is it experienced?
- 25:34Is it somebody from IT that doesn't know
- 25:37anything about AV?
- 25:39Or they know just enough.
- 25:42We know them.
- 25:43We know them in our everyday world.
- 25:45And some of our peers.
- 25:48It could have been a support desk
- 25:51technician that has one year of
- 25:52experience.
- 25:53I think they come in.
- 25:55We know they focus on, you know,
- 25:56because we've been there,
- 25:57even if it's our own internal,
- 25:59like our own internal project.
- 26:01We've worked with the deans or somebody,
- 26:03and we're starting to put it together.
- 26:04Then we have that one faculty or that
- 26:06one support person that's departmentally
- 26:10run, and they come in like, well,
- 26:11we don't do it this way.
- 26:12We want it.
- 26:13Then they throw brand names out.
- 26:15Well, hold on.
- 26:15Stop.
- 26:16We didn't do these.
- 26:17Right.
- 26:17Okay.
- 26:19But no matter what, this happens.
- 26:21We've all been there.
- 26:23And so,
- 26:23but that's not specifically called out in
- 26:26the article either.
- 26:26I think what rubs me wrong when I
- 26:28read it was it did seem like a
- 26:30bitch fest.
- 26:31Seemed like somebody went to the internet
- 26:32to bitch and moan about end user clients
- 26:35and we didn't get all the information.
- 26:38And that just rubbed me wrong because it's
- 26:39not that the message,
- 26:40like the message kind of made sense.
- 26:43Like, to Justin's point, yes,
- 26:45we should have had roles figured out.
- 26:46We should have had this done.
- 26:48Hey,
- 26:48there should be a two-way communication
- 26:50streak here.
- 26:51But that kind of was written like,
- 26:53this guy came in and he just held
- 26:54us up.
- 26:55And then we had to designate a babysitter
- 26:57to make all the changes they wanted.
- 26:59And it's just like, whoa, hold on, buddy.
- 27:01And I think that's what rubbed me wrong.
- 27:02It wasn't that we focused on process.
- 27:04It wasn't that we focused on how does
- 27:06handoff happen.
- 27:08It rubbed us wrong because it was a
- 27:10one-sided view and not a two-sided view
- 27:12post where this is what's going on on
- 27:15our side and I can kind of see
- 27:16it from their side.
- 27:18And taking a more neutral approach on this
- 27:22would have been a much better write-up.
- 27:24And being the owner representative,
- 27:27I don't have very many outside integration
- 27:29come in and do things.
- 27:31I just don't.
- 27:32Rarely, maybe once a year,
- 27:33do I ever even get this far into
- 27:35something.
- 27:36And so, you know,
- 27:39I've been in that position where the
- 27:40reason I wasn't involved from the
- 27:42beginning was because I wasn't involved
- 27:44from the beginning.
- 27:45So now we come in and it's being
- 27:46that support turnover and you're like,
- 27:48well, hold on.
- 27:49And so, yeah.
- 27:50Now,
- 27:51experience has taught me at some point,
- 27:53you're just like, fine,
- 27:53just give it to me.
- 27:54When you walk out the door,
- 27:55I'm just going to change it anyway.
- 27:56Right.
- 27:58Whatever.
- 27:59But I know that I've been there before,
- 28:01and I like the idea that
- 28:04that I want to kind of go through
- 28:05there,
- 28:05but I don't like holding them up as
- 28:08they're doing it.
- 28:09I almost want them to be done and
- 28:11then have that change process,
- 28:13that gen that, that verification.
- 28:15Because when you're involved to me,
- 28:18when I'm involved every step of the way,
- 28:20God, the thing just drags on forever.
- 28:23Get done.
- 28:24We'll identify what I don't like and then
- 28:27help me fix it.
- 28:28That's it.
- 28:28You know what we're missing?
- 28:29We're missing a variable I just thought
- 28:30of.
- 28:31Money?
- 28:31No, no, no, no.
- 28:34What if the person that came in,
- 28:37you know, oh my God,
- 28:38this is not the right way to do
- 28:39things and blah, blah, blah.
- 28:41What if that person...
- 28:43had it all lined out with the consultant
- 28:45and the consultant missed it in the bid
- 28:47specs.
- 28:48Maybe it's a consultant's fault.
- 28:50Because that's another variable to all
- 28:52these damn consultants.
- 28:54That's usually what happens to me.
- 28:55It's a capital project that has been
- 28:59consulted and then sub-integrated and put
- 29:02in.
- 29:02And then I find out usually way too
- 29:04late and need to come in and kind
- 29:05of be that owner's rep later.
- 29:08And that's where my experiences with
- 29:10outside integration usually happens.
- 29:11Most of mine, shoot,
- 29:13I'm doing it the whole way through.
- 29:14And I think that's why I tend, like,
- 29:19even after we've stated all this,
- 29:21I still tend to fall back to falling
- 29:24in line with the integrator's position.
- 29:27Because chances are, like,
- 29:28if it was exactly the scenario you just
- 29:30laid out, well,
- 29:32it wasn't designed around...
- 29:34our expectations like the integrator is
- 29:37going with what he was told we are
- 29:40changing things at the last minute yeah
- 29:42and so at that point yeah we are
- 29:44just an extra burden that's being thrown
- 29:46on him that he's not prepared for so
- 29:50in my mind as this played out when
- 29:54we get to that portion of a project
- 29:56we're not commissioning
- 29:58only speaking from some projects I've had
- 30:00on campus,
- 30:01very seldom do you have somebody from the
- 30:02integrators team at that management level
- 30:06on the ground when this is happening.
- 30:08This is some other person.
- 30:10And so the reason why I get the
- 30:12sense that this is aggravating is somebody
- 30:14from their management team is probably
- 30:16getting phone calls like, bro,
- 30:18I got this guy here who's asking all...
- 30:20And they're playing phone tag back and
- 30:21forth, right?
- 30:22And this guy's like,
- 30:23I'm on my lunch break.
- 30:23I'm just going to vent.
- 30:24And that's what this felt like to me.
- 30:25And that...
- 30:27Because there wasn't anybody in there to
- 30:29make a business decision at that juncture
- 30:32of this project.
- 30:33It's too late to make a business decision.
- 30:35It is.
- 30:35But to me...
- 30:38As we all say, oh,
- 30:38it should have been spelled out,
- 30:39should have been spelled out.
- 30:39Just as much as it should have been
- 30:41spelled out, was it communicated?
- 30:43It is on the integrator to communicate
- 30:46that agreement.
- 30:47And this clearly says that they're equally
- 30:49responsible for the unknowing that has
- 30:51been created.
- 30:52If there's some question about what it is
- 30:54they're supposed to be providing,
- 30:55have they clearly communicated that?
- 30:57And then obviously in that moment,
- 30:59give that client some grace and then say,
- 31:02guess what?
- 31:03You're right.
- 31:05We actually thought about this on the
- 31:06onset.
- 31:07Here's where it's documented as to what
- 31:08our process is, and we move forward.
- 31:11None of that happened in this situation.
- 31:14But to push back against that,
- 31:15maybe it was communicated,
- 31:17just wasn't communicated to the person
- 31:19that's not actually the client who's
- 31:21paying the bills.
- 31:22Which could be the consultant or the
- 31:23electrician if it's bid under the
- 31:27electrician.
- 31:28It's also very likely that the lead
- 31:30technician that is standing there for the
- 31:33integrator
- 31:34has none of those conversations.
- 31:36Absolutely none.
- 31:37Because why would they?
- 31:39They're like, what?
- 31:39I have no... Dude, I just flew in.
- 31:41I'm trying to punch this out and get
- 31:42out of here.
- 31:43Yeah.
- 31:44I want to go home and see my
- 31:45mom.
- 31:46That's a problem with internal
- 31:48communications with the integrator,
- 31:49and that is their fault.
- 31:51That's not my fault.
- 31:53But all of this kind of goes back
- 31:55to that, like have clear expectations,
- 31:57outline those expectations,
- 31:59and then just like when...
- 32:01Again, if we take the integrator out,
- 32:03it's just us.
- 32:04And we have that faculty member that comes
- 32:05in and says,
- 32:06I don't like that color blue.
- 32:07Well, I'm sorry.
- 32:07This is how we're going to roll for
- 32:08right now.
- 32:10You know,
- 32:10just sometimes you just got to roll with
- 32:12it.
- 32:12Make a change order later.
- 32:14But there was some things missing out
- 32:17there.
- 32:17I think the reason it struck up all
- 32:19of this conversation is just like this
- 32:20call,
- 32:20like our recording right now is we all
- 32:23had a different view.
- 32:24And most of it was.
- 32:27I think that guy is just bitching,
- 32:29but he has a point,
- 32:30but he's just bitching.
- 32:31Like he said it wrong,
- 32:32like both sides of this.
- 32:33And we're like, well,
- 32:35where's the customer experience in this
- 32:37reading back through it.
- 32:38And to your point, Mark, um,
- 32:39reading back through this, I think there,
- 32:41there is a back to the comment about
- 32:43being this being tone deaf the end of
- 32:45the day.
- 32:47The integrator does not own these spaces
- 32:49or this project.
- 32:50He's handing it off to somebody else.
- 32:51And there's a couple of comments in here
- 32:52about how we commission our way,
- 32:55turn the rooms over,
- 32:56and then work as punchless.
- 32:57Not if it's in the scope of work,
- 32:59if you bet on it.
- 33:00I get what he's saying,
- 33:01that we've got our process,
- 33:02and then we'll hand it over and figure
- 33:03out what we need to change.
- 33:06But this concept about like, no,
- 33:08we're going to do it our way and
- 33:09then you get what you get.
- 33:10And we will bill you for that afterwards.
- 33:13And they will bill you for it.
- 33:14But you get that as somebody in kind
- 33:17of these unique roles,
- 33:18and we talk about this all the time,
- 33:19that higher ed is often unique because you
- 33:21have very knowledgeable people internally
- 33:23working with knowledgeable people
- 33:24externally and sometimes there's that that
- 33:26push back and you know but the end
- 33:28you know at the end of the day
- 33:29we're the ones at the university have to
- 33:31own this stuff so maybe listen to the
- 33:34words that are coming out of my mouth
- 33:35and if you want to have a conversation
- 33:37about something that's fine but when i
- 33:38tell you that display is too high that
- 33:41camera is in the wrong location or
- 33:43whatever it is because yes well it was
- 33:45on the drawings this way was it let's
- 33:47go find out only to find out in
- 33:49recent project
- 33:51There's already a wall box.
- 33:52Said wall box already has conduit in it.
- 33:55It's at the right height.
- 33:56Oh,
- 33:56and you opted to make your own hole
- 33:59to mount the device in a different
- 34:01location much higher.
- 34:02And when later,
- 34:04when they tried to justify what the
- 34:06explanation was,
- 34:07I understand where you're coming from.
- 34:08But you also have a thing called a
- 34:10phone.
- 34:11You could probably say,
- 34:12maybe we should ask this question.
- 34:13It's called an RFI.
- 34:15Well, what I'm saying is,
- 34:17so they don't go do things first.
- 34:19Yes, request for information.
- 34:20They don't go do things first and then
- 34:22ask for it later.
- 34:22They just bold right ahead.
- 34:23Well, because this is how we do it.
- 34:26So I can see where somebody who's now,
- 34:27hey, Tony,
- 34:28can you go down to that new building
- 34:29and look at those new conference rooms?
- 34:31They're finishing them up this week.
- 34:33And this guy finds all these little things
- 34:34like that and is not part of the
- 34:36communication loop.
- 34:37I can see where that frustration comes in
- 34:38of like, hold everything.
- 34:40I need to walk every one of these
- 34:41spaces with you guys because I don't know
- 34:42what you're up to over here.
- 34:44So you get that mix between, well,
- 34:45this is our way of doing things.
- 34:47We're going to get paid and move on.
- 34:49Well,
- 34:49then who's going to come back and fix
- 34:51this?
- 34:51Because I'm the IT guy in charge of
- 34:53twenty seven other things.
- 34:54So I can see both sides of this.
- 34:56I think the article could have been
- 34:58written with a little more, I don't know,
- 35:00empathy towards somebody who's being
- 35:02handed a bill of goods.
- 35:02For both sides.
- 35:04Because there's blame on both sides.
- 35:07I really think there's integrator fault
- 35:09here with communication and there's got to
- 35:11be
- 35:12something going on with the owner's side
- 35:14too with how they communicated what the
- 35:16expectations are so there's something
- 35:19falling apart on both sides as somebody
- 35:20who's asked all the time hey we want
- 35:22to do more work on your campus what
- 35:23can we do i can tell you right
- 35:24now if you try to pull this this
- 35:26is exactly how you're not going to get
- 35:27back on campus yep like i don't care
- 35:29if you did everything right and everything
- 35:31was perfect if in that final inch of
- 35:34this race you're like
- 35:37You're going to just draw the line in
- 35:38a stand and you're just going to take
- 35:39this hard stance?
- 35:40You're not coming back.
- 35:42I will make sure that you're not coming
- 35:43back to this campus.
- 35:43And that's kind of my point, Mark,
- 35:44is like if I'm integrating on Oregon
- 35:47State's campus and this happened to me and
- 35:49I have other jobs lined up, guys,
- 35:52shut up.
- 35:53let's get this right for mark because we
- 35:56have another two million dollars ahead of
- 35:57us or is this a one-shot where hey
- 36:00this is our only bid for this company
- 36:02there's no more work then there's that
- 36:04different attitude right where i don't
- 36:06care because it's we've said in the past
- 36:08like these moments of like where this
- 36:10friction is like these are the
- 36:11opportunities to actually forge those
- 36:12relationships make it right and do the
- 36:15things and don't make it a problem and
- 36:17yes we can acknowledge like oh man this
- 36:18is a change
- 36:19Guess what?
- 36:20We're going to come back.
- 36:20We're going to address this.
- 36:21We'll find a path forward.
- 36:22Let's just work on what we can do
- 36:23right now.
- 36:24But that doesn't seem like that happened.
- 36:25And we're we're assuming like these are
- 36:27big changes like switching out equipment.
- 36:29This could just be like how things are
- 36:31tested and commissioned because this is a
- 36:33commissioning process.
- 36:34So when in reality,
- 36:36are we really talking about one person's
- 36:38salary for a week?
- 36:40And you're arguing about that?
- 36:41I have a feeling it's nothing to do.
- 36:44It has nothing to do with our definition
- 36:47of commissioning with measurements and
- 36:49everything.
- 36:49It has everything to do with the
- 36:50commissioning that we say when we actually
- 36:53mean checking the program.
- 36:54Yeah.
- 36:56It has everything to do with housing.
- 36:57You had to define what your commissioning
- 36:58process is.
- 36:59Was that another variable that did it?
- 37:01So that's my curiosity here.
- 37:04Is that it comes in and they come
- 37:07in and they say, well,
- 37:09we need different button labels.
- 37:12We need different colors.
- 37:14I want that one bigger.
- 37:16Oh, when we press this,
- 37:17I want all of it to happen or
- 37:19none of it to happen.
- 37:21I have this assumption that...
- 37:22that this is the broad structure of
- 37:25commissioning, testing and commissioning,
- 37:28and that the reason they had to dedicate
- 37:30an upper-level engineer was to take care
- 37:33of all of those things.
- 37:34Oh, like this button isn't...
- 37:36This button's named PC and it should be
- 37:38computer.
- 37:39That kind of stuff.
- 37:40That's what I'm assuming.
- 37:42That this isn't, this isn't,
- 37:44was it bright enough?
- 37:45Is it loud enough?
- 37:46Is the microphone in the right place?
- 37:48And I don't think it has anything to
- 37:49do with that.
- 37:50I think it has everything to do with
- 37:52how is it controlled?
- 37:53Yeah.
- 37:54To follow up what Jamie said,
- 37:55like very early in my programming career,
- 37:58I was doing a job at a university.
- 38:01It was never communicated to me by my
- 38:03project management that they had a user
- 38:07interface standard that they go by.
- 38:09So I just programmed the whole thing with
- 38:10my user one.
- 38:12I go in to train the users.
- 38:13They're like,
- 38:13this doesn't look like any other room we
- 38:15have on campus.
- 38:16This will not work.
- 38:18And then they give me their standard.
- 38:20And so I can see that being the
- 38:22case.
- 38:22I know the internal integrator problem on
- 38:24your case.
- 38:25Did you use that?
- 38:26Did you use a phrase like, well,
- 38:27this is how we do it.
- 38:29Customers love to hear that.
- 38:31I just stared at the project manager like,
- 38:33what the crap, man.
- 38:34To your comment,
- 38:35it could have been something even as
- 38:36simple as because I've run in this before,
- 38:37like the camera presets are not set up
- 38:40correctly and camera presets are a
- 38:41relatively straightforward thing to fix.
- 38:43But if you've got say they're turning over
- 38:45fifteen conference room,
- 38:45that's a lot of work now to have
- 38:47someone go back and burn their entire
- 38:49three or four days going back.
- 38:51OK, what about over?
- 38:51Do you want this one?
- 38:52That's another.
- 38:53We don't know how big this job was.
- 38:55Is it one room or is it fifty
- 38:57rooms?
- 38:57Is it two or three buildings?
- 38:59Yeah.
- 39:00Oh.
- 39:01And so I have a feeling it was
- 39:02all the actual user experience stuff.
- 39:05And that's why they had to dedicate a
- 39:08higher level tech to it.
- 39:09That's why they had to dedicate extra
- 39:10time.
- 39:10And that's probably why it was so
- 39:12important to them.
- 39:13Because when you start dedicating higher
- 39:15level tech, that's higher level money.
- 39:18And they are not being used.
- 39:19Potentially pulling them away either from
- 39:20another responsibility on that job or from
- 39:22another job.
- 39:24We've got to have Carl come over and
- 39:26spend the entire week over here to deal
- 39:27with this guy.
- 39:28So lessons learned for all of our
- 39:30brethren.
- 39:34Write down your expectations.
- 39:36Ask questions up front,
- 39:38and don't assume things at the end,
- 39:41and always look at things in other
- 39:45people's shoes, too.
- 39:47Don't just look at your narrow view of
- 39:48the world.
- 39:50Mark,
- 39:50you raised one thing that I do want
- 39:51to make sure I emphasize here.
- 39:54All right, Mark.
- 39:57To the integrators out there who want to
- 39:58do more work on university campuses.
- 40:00Oh, man.
- 40:01But B,
- 40:03these are the sorts of things we remember,
- 40:05these like poor experiences or whatever,
- 40:06challenges or whatever.
- 40:08I used to talk about this all the
- 40:11time at a previous university,
- 40:12and I'm building the same thing here.
- 40:15Price is about twenty five percent of the
- 40:18evaluation of a quote or of a proposal.
- 40:22So when I get multiple quotes,
- 40:23I get multiple proposals.
- 40:24Price is about twenty five percent of that
- 40:26user experience, total cost of ownership.
- 40:30You know,
- 40:31there's a lot more that goes into that
- 40:33to determine if someone's going to be
- 40:35awarded another project moving forward.
- 40:36So I will override the cost and it's
- 40:39not always the lowest, the lowest bid.
- 40:41I will override that for the right
- 40:43partner.
- 40:44So agreed.
- 40:45Be mindful of that.
- 40:47Value-added.
- 40:47It's a value-add thing that you want to
- 40:50make sure you're building that
- 40:52relationship to get future business.
- 40:53Now,
- 40:53if you're just stamping out basic MTR
- 40:57conference rooms or whatever, hey,
- 40:58go nuts.
- 40:58Do what you want.
- 40:59Throw that camera bar on the wall and
- 41:00walk.
- 41:02This is probably not the venue to get
- 41:03into all the details of that,
- 41:04but we've all just effectively said, oh,
- 41:08document, document.
- 41:09communicate, communicate,
- 41:11even being too rigid in that process and
- 41:14say, no,
- 41:15this is what we're going to do.
- 41:15This is how we're going to do it.
- 41:17And not leaving opportunity for the client
- 41:20to have a conversation about that,
- 41:23because this is your way,
- 41:24this is your recipe and how success works.
- 41:26That'll get you off the campus just as
- 41:28well.
- 41:29Great example, Mark, real quick.
- 41:31I had an integrator tell us our
- 41:33commissioning process is a week.
- 41:35The hell it is.
- 41:37It's when I say it's done because I'm
- 41:39signing off on it.
- 41:40So if you come here on a Monday
- 41:42and you fix a problem and I repunch
- 41:45it out and you expose the second problem
- 41:47that I find on Wednesday and then you
- 41:49fix that on Thursday and then you create
- 41:51another problem on Friday, guess what?
- 41:53You're into the next week.
- 41:54Deal with it.
- 41:56I have a feeling that Justin wouldn't
- 41:58punch out any of our projects.
- 41:59I know he wouldn't.
- 42:02No.
- 42:02I guarantee I would still be closing out
- 42:05one for twenty years ago.
- 42:06We'd be looking at the contract.
- 42:08The best systems are the ones that are
- 42:10best litigated.
- 42:12What's in writing in the front end?
- 42:13And it's not difficult.
- 42:14It's just,
- 42:16did you label the cables the way I
- 42:18said to?
- 42:19Or did you make up some random-ass label
- 42:22called AX Niner five, three, two, seven?
- 42:24Well, you need our reference sheet.
- 42:25If you had our reference sheet,
- 42:27if you pay the extra,
- 42:28we'll give you the reference sheet.
- 42:28No, we're not doing reference sheets.
- 42:29I don't even know why you put letters
- 42:31and numbers.
- 42:31There's red electrical tape and green
- 42:34electrical tape and orange electrical
- 42:35tape.
- 42:36Wrap one of those suckers on there on
- 42:37each end.
- 42:37You're good to go.
- 42:38This is double white?
- 42:39This is double white.
- 42:40Red, red, white, red, blue.
- 42:43Watch Justin's head explode.
- 42:45Better take us out of here, Chris.
- 42:46This is going to get ugly.
- 42:47All video is green?
- 42:51No.
- 42:53The projectors always come on with that
- 42:55green HDCP color, not blue.
- 42:59Normal process.
- 43:00Anyways.
- 43:00Alrighty.
- 43:01Well, I think we hammered this one in.
- 43:03Again, link is in the show notes.
- 43:04Read for yourselves and decide.
- 43:06Maybe we're wrong.
- 43:07Who knows?
- 43:07We're completely wrong on this.
- 43:08Yeah.
- 43:10Maybe.
- 43:11All right.
- 43:12Back next week with more fun time
- 43:14nonsense.
- 43:15Fun time nonsense.
- 43:16It helps if I hit this button.
- 43:17Yeah, hit that button.
- 43:18I was waiting for it.
- 43:25Thanks for putting up with yet another
- 43:27episode of AV Superfriends On Topic.
- 43:29You can contact us with questions,
- 43:31topic ideas,
- 43:32or general complaints at
- 43:33avsuperfriends.com.
- 43:42Nice work, everyone.
- 43:44Sharp broadcast.
- 43:45Really good.
- 43:46Everyone on the floor as well.
- 43:47Really a lot of hustle.
- 43:48I liked it.
- 43:49The opinions expressed by the AV
- 43:51Superfriends are solely those of the
- 43:52individuals and do not represent their
- 43:54respective institutions, organizations,
- 43:56companies, or clients.