Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / If I Was the Intelligent Designer (PART ONE)
Transcript
- 0:04The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheist this country is going through the rule, rejecting faith,
- 0:15pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth, it's
- 0:20because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a book
- 0:24and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take the
- 0:29risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty, and
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Okay,
- 0:56our lives would not be complete without a new Gwyneth Paltrow headline. Have
- 1:03you seen the most recent one. She has been out there pitching rectal ozone
- 1:07therapy, blowing oxidized gases into the orifice that is not your mouth. This
- 1:15is why we need actual medical experts, people like doctor Andre Viscontis, doctor
- 1:22Stephen Novella. We've had both of them on the show in the past,
- 1:25and they are part of a Wandrium series called Medical Myths, Lies and Half
- 1:30Truths, and go figure. Many of these popular notions, including rectal ozone
- 1:37therapy, are totally bogus. We may have a hole in our ozone.
- 1:42We should never put ozone in our hole. It's weird. You have to
- 1:48explain this, But you should enjoy this series and any one of over eight
- 1:52thousand hours of ad free audio and video for a whole month, a free
- 1:57month right now at wandrium. You can stream anywhere with the one dreum app.
- 2:01It's fun, it's informative. I think it's critical, and right now,
- 2:06a free month, a whole month, an entire month for free when
- 2:09you sign up with one Dream using my special u R L one dreum dot
- 2:15com slash seth. That's w O N d r I u M slash seth,
- 2:23and maybe forward the link to Gwyneth Paltrow. I don't know one dream
- 2:28dot com slash seth. Okay, it's rare that I divide a show into
- 2:38part one and part two, but the subject matter was so rich that I
- 2:44wanted to take two different passes at intelligent design. The first is me ranting
- 2:51and your calls. That's the show this week. Next week we're going to
- 2:55bring on an actual scientist who will talk about poor design quote unquote design and
- 3:02what she might do in terms of creating a better design. Doctor Abbey Hayfer,
- 3:08who is an evolutionary biologist, So she's going to weigh in on some
- 3:13of what we're talking about and offer ideas design ideas of her own. And
- 3:19that's part two next week. Let's say that you are the intelligent designer and
- 3:29you are essentially playing a large scale version of the SIMS. I guess the
- 3:34SIMS is a good way to frame it. I haven't played the SIMS,
- 3:37but you are creating your world, and you get to create the attributes of
- 3:43your world. I want to know what you would change about the so called
- 3:47intelligent design that religious people continue to talk about. You know, they're always
- 3:53like, well, we're so intelligently designed, everything so fine tuned, and
- 3:59you when I look around, just a cursory look around, and we're like,
- 4:01and don't see a lot of fine tuning. I see a shit ton
- 4:04of waste and pain. This is what I see. So what would you
- 4:10change about the quote unquote design you see? And or what new feature,
- 4:15what novel idea would you bring? What might you creates or not create?
- 4:23You are the designer, and I want to take your calls and find out
- 4:28what you think. And this is a creative audience, So I'm really looking
- 4:30forward to what you have to offer. I think the first thing I would
- 4:34do is I would make sure that it didn't hurt like a mother, if
- 4:40you'll pardon the expression, when females give birth. Of course, the Book
- 4:47of Genesis says that pain and childbirth is God's punishment upon the woman. You
- 4:54know, how dare she tempt Adam with the fruits after she was tempted by
- 4:59the serpent. It's all the woman's fault. This is the thinking in many
- 5:02religious circles. And so Yahweh in his great goodness says, oh, you
- 5:08screwed up, So the curse is now. Childbirth is gonna hurt, and
- 5:12it's gonna hurt really, really, really bad. Well, I'm the intelligent
- 5:15designer, and I think reproduction shouldn't you know, make you want to wrap
- 5:20your hands around somebody's throat. You're not screaming in agony. There's no compression
- 5:27of the muscles and the tearing of the skin. And I'll spare you the
- 5:30rest of the details that women know much more than I do that it's pointless.
- 5:36Well, it needs to hurt really bad so that you have a greater
- 5:41sense of meaning when the child is delivered, get the hell out of here.
- 5:47Just leave. You're not even trying with that. Yeah, if it's
- 5:53difficult, you'll appreciate it more. Let's talk to women about that. Don't
- 6:00tell me you wouldn't look down and see a newly born child and feel that
- 6:04sense of awe and wonder and gratitude and love, and then you wouldn't feel
- 6:13it if maybe I don't know there was another system in place. I'm the
- 6:17intelligent designer. Okay, So all right, no stretching and no muscle movement
- 6:23and all those hoartnet none of those things that cause intense distress and agonizing pain.
- 6:29All right, the uterus doesn't have to contract to squeeze out the baby.
- 6:32How about a timer on the body, like an egg timer. Nine
- 6:36months your baby is ready. I don't think this is unreasonable. Your baby
- 6:44is done. Press door to open, just like a microwave. Baby comes
- 6:49out, walla. There's no screaming, you're not threatening your partner. You
- 6:55don't want to bend the rails off of the bed and throw them at the
- 7:00O. B G Y N. Right. It's like an Amazon delivery,
- 7:03but for live humans. I think that's a great design, and I think
- 7:10it makes the decision less scary for people who want to become parents. You
- 7:15say, all right, would you like a child? Great? Okay,
- 7:17start timer now nine months later. I think that's reasonable. I'd be interested
- 7:28in a female's point of view. You're talking to a male non parent.
- 7:31But I can see, right, I can assess from a distance that this
- 7:35is not great design. Speaking of pain testicles, Oh oh, oh oh,
- 7:48that is a design decision I would do differently. Let's talk those away
- 7:55nice and safe. You know what I'm saying. Well, you see said
- 8:00the testies need to be located outside the body because the testies require a cooler
- 8:05temperature. No, no, I'm the designer. I can design a place
- 8:13in the body, a safe spot that is cooler than the rest of the
- 8:18body. Nobody can kick it in there, right, Nobody can kick your
- 8:22testicles when they are safe inside this little house. Maybe encase it with little
- 8:28bones. It's like prison bars, right, so nothing can get to it
- 8:33for protection. A scrotum safe house. This would be part of my design,
- 8:41instead of hanging them out where anybody can kick it, or you can
- 8:45hit it with a baseball or no no, no, no, no,
- 8:48that's terrible design. There are other animals in nature, you know, they
- 8:52have testes and they're hidden safely in the body. Why humans, That doesn't
- 8:56make any sense to me. That's a design chain that I would make.
- 9:03I would separate the windpipe and the esophagus right right next to each other,
- 9:09and then there's a flap that has to close. What hundreds of people choked
- 9:16to death every single year. Why would you put these right on top of
- 9:20each other where the food could cause you not to get air and you might
- 9:26die. Poor design. Just keep those suckers way separate. You can still
- 9:33taste the food and swallow the food and digest the food just like you normally
- 9:37would. We just keep them separate, right, like siblings that don't get
- 9:43along all that great, You just separate them just a little bit. Better
- 9:48design. You are welcome. Yahweh. Here's one that's relevant to a man
- 9:56in his fifties mid fifties. How about knees that don't wear out? And
- 10:01if you are younger and still agile and have no arthritis in your body,
- 10:07oh, you are in for a real treat. I guess it was five
- 10:13six years ago I noticed walking the stairs. I started hearing, grinding,
- 10:20grinding. Oh, I guess that's bone on bone in my knees. To
- 10:26try to stay in shape, I played tennis four times a week. There's
- 10:31a ton of people in the tennis community and they've got big scars right down
- 10:35where the kneecap is because they had to have knee replacement surgery. Now,
- 10:41you and I already know this is part of our evolution. We are evolved
- 10:45from our primate ancestors who were not totally bipet. Right, They used to
- 10:50use their arms as well to be able to traverse the trees, the jungle
- 10:56trees, etc. Right, it is us as biped putting all of this
- 11:01extra stress that was not once on our knees. This is causing a lot
- 11:05of the problem. But if you think it's design, it's poor design.
- 11:09I'm let's call it a little past midlife, all right. Let's say I
- 11:15lived in ninety all right, let's call it thirty five more years. Well,
- 11:20that means that, for I don't know, thirty plus percent of my
- 11:24life pushing forty percent of my life, my knees are going to give me
- 11:28trouble. This makes no sense to me. It's poor design. Why would
- 11:31you put in a part that wears out midstream. I would change that.
- 11:37Your knees will last a lifetime. You have a lifetime warranty. There's no
- 11:43grinding, there's no aches, there's no pains, no knee replacement surgeries.
- 11:46By the way, have you've seen some of the artificial knees. They're kind
- 11:50of awesome. There's like sports knees that you can buy like they are made
- 12:00for athletes. High end artificial knees that are kind of bad ass. But
- 12:05I've also seen the surgeries that they do to put them in. I don't
- 12:11want any part of that. If I can help it. I'm worried in
- 12:15ten years, I'm looking at a knee of replacement and I would sure love
- 12:18to have been intelligently designed so this was not a problem and if you have
- 12:24to replace it. How about an interchangeability model with the body. A part
- 12:33goes out on your car, what do you do? You put another part
- 12:35in, You replace the part. Oh, look the carburetor's bad, you
- 12:41whip it out, you switch it out. Oh the muffler needs to be
- 12:43replaced, the tires are bald, you switch it out. No harm,
- 12:50no foul, no pain. How about a little door. You open it
- 12:56up, pop in your new knee, right you're born with like some excess
- 13:01parts. Hey, my knee's bad. I've got half an hour on Wednesday.
- 13:05Can I come in for the swap? That sounds really good, thatunds
- 13:11really good. I wear glasses, buyfocals now. I make myself feel better
- 13:20about this by calling them progressives. Progressive lenses got readers, and I got
- 13:26distance. And then there's this weird little hybrid, an old medium spot in
- 13:31the middle that's almost useless to me. And I can't wear glasses while driving
- 13:35for that reason, because if I'm moving from near to far to mid to
- 13:39near to far to mid, it freaks me out. My brain can't handle
- 13:43it. So I actually can't drive with these things on, but I use
- 13:46them pretty much everything else. I would design the eye so it did not
- 13:52wear out, it did not lose focus. We think about the eagle.
- 13:56I would love to have eyes like the eagle. Did you know that eagles
- 14:01can see like eight times eight times further than human beings. They've got this
- 14:09razor focus at distance. They can see up to two miles. They're always
- 14:13scanning for prey. Or imagine us being able to see something and lock in
- 14:16and focus two miles away. Hey, is anybody seeing the dog? I
- 14:22let him out back, but I think he got through the fence. Dada,
- 14:26Oh there he is. Look he's over near the house in another field,
- 14:31in a neighborhood that's five hundred yards away. I'm just saying. Eagles
- 14:37can see color well enough to be able to detect things that are camouflaged.
- 14:43They can see UV light. Now, they don't have great vision in the
- 14:48dark. But I'm the intelligent designer, so let's put in some night vision.
- 14:54Let's put in some night vision. I'm let's say I'm I'm omnipotent.
- 15:00I can do whatever. I forgot to add that caveat, because that's the
- 15:03claim about the designer, right, The designer can do all things without limits,
- 15:09powerful, beyond measure. It's he she can design at will. So,
- 15:15okay, great night vision. Eyesight would be a constant. It would
- 15:20not degenerate over time if we did have degenerating eyesight. How about a little
- 15:26knob. Have you seen those new glasses that they market and instead of getting
- 15:31a prescription, you buy these glasses and they have a little knob, an
- 15:35adjustment knob on them, and so you can change the focus. Oh you
- 15:41need it for mid Oh you need readers, Oh you need distance. You
- 15:46don't have to change your glasses. It just does that. I mean they're
- 15:48ugly as hell, but apparently they work. I would do that with eyes.
- 15:52Your brain could just adjust the knob perfectly. Readers, bifocals, trifocals,
- 16:00whatever that are wired right into our tissue. Something's blurry, no problem,
- 16:06I'll set my focus. I'm all set boom intelligent design. I would
- 16:11actually allow wisdom teeth to fit in the freaking mouth. Did you know that?
- 16:21Like eighty I think it's eighty to eighty five percent of American adults have
- 16:27to have their wisdom teeth pulled out. The procedure, I think used to
- 16:33be a lot worse. I mean it's it's no picnic now, but it
- 16:37used to be like four hours in a chair and they would just jack you
- 16:44up to get the wisdom teeth out. I mean, it's awful, and
- 16:48it's still awful. I think they've gotten it down to it ninety minutes something
- 16:52like that. I've got wisdom teeth. They ach occasionally. I've been fortunate
- 16:56that I haven't had to have them removed. But the whole idea that an
- 16:59intelligent designer would give you teeth that almost all people would have to have removed
- 17:07lest they jam all the other teeth and make everything crooked and cause tremendous pain.
- 17:12I mean, that's not intelligent design. I would fix that, no
- 17:17wisdom teeth, or I just make a little extra space for everybody. That
- 17:19seems intuitive to me, how about you. I would create a world where
- 17:27maybe we were solar powered, less sleep needed. I mean, I love
- 17:34my sleep, So I'm in conflict about this, especially as I get older.
- 17:40When I was a kid, it was like, I don't want to
- 17:41go to bed. I don't want to go to bed. You can't make
- 17:45me go to bed. Now I'm I'm there. Oh yeah, oh honey,
- 17:49it's nine o'clock. I know it's let's go. Let's go to bed.
- 17:52Huh. And then you crawl in under the covers and the pillows cool,
- 17:56and the dogs come in. I've got my feet over in. Natalie's
- 18:00feet are always cold. I don't know why, they're just like icebergs.
- 18:03But I'll go over there and then she warms her cold feet up on my
- 18:07warm feet. That's bliss. If there is a heaven. It may be
- 18:11that. So I'm in conflict a little bit because bed sleep, etc.
- 18:15That's pretty nice, but it's not like you're awake to enjoy it, all
- 18:19right, But you know the process is pleasing. But if we were solar
- 18:23powered, but we were able to go outside and get energy directly from the
- 18:29sun, then maybe we could reduce our sleep time quite a bit and live
- 18:34more before we are done living. I would certainly make it so the sun
- 18:40didn't give us, you know, melanoma. Intelligent design proponents are always like,
- 18:48you know, go outside and look all around at the pretty trees and
- 18:51nature, and you know that there is a designer. Hey, you see
- 18:55that big orange orb in the sky. It's giving us answer. This is
- 19:03not intelligent design. I would either put hair on our arms and legs or
- 19:12no hair if I was the designer. Like someone explained this to me.
- 19:18It's not long enough and thick enough to keep me warm in the cold,
- 19:23or to help me to ward off predators by making me look intimidating. It
- 19:29just looks like somebody left an old outdoor rug outside for three hundred years and
- 19:34now I'm wearing it. Doesn't do anything. It's just useless. Hair.
- 19:38I would say hair, no hair, but this half ass hair that sometimes
- 19:45is actually on your ass, I would not have that. I would omit
- 19:48that in my intelligent design. Tons more examples relating the humans. But let's
- 19:56go beyond the human body for a second. I think i'd make sugar a
- 20:03diet food, right. I mean, the reason we crave sugar is that
- 20:10it's a high energy food. In our ancestors out on the African savannah,
- 20:14we're always on the hunt for high energy foods. We didn't have sugars in
- 20:18you know the obscene supply that we have now. So I mean, you
- 20:23know those types of energy rich foods, they were beneficial to us. They
- 20:29were life and energy giving. Of course, now we're sugar addicted. We're
- 20:32a diabetic population, and I'm guilty. I mean, I love sweet things.
- 20:38Oh my goodness, even when I'm trying to be good. Somebody shows
- 20:42up and says, I brought donuts. Ah, crap. I don't have
- 20:48the willpower to pass up donuts, lightly glazed, stored, chocolate covered.
- 20:52I'm in ice cream. Okay. We go to the restaurant, we have
- 20:57dinner, and the white person comes out says, did y'all save room for
- 21:00dessert today, I'm supposed to say, no, I don't. I say
- 21:07what's on the menu. What do you have? Well, we've got the
- 21:08crembrewlet, We've got the Tierra Moisux. We've got chocolate cake, cheese cake,
- 21:15etc. Apple pie served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. I'm
- 21:19going to get one of those. But if sugar didn't attach to my stomach,
- 21:26legs, ass, whatever, right, if it was actually kind of
- 21:30a diet food, I think that would he still gives energy. But if
- 21:33I'm omnipotent, it's health food like sugar would be like kale. I don't
- 21:41think that's unreasonable, or at least make us so that when we hit our
- 21:47daily calorie amounts seth today, you need twenty one hundred calories and anything above
- 21:55that would be excess and might turn to fan Oh okay, well that's not
- 21:59good. So I would fine tune the body so that at twenty one hundred
- 22:03calories, everything else would just be expelled from the body, so nothing else
- 22:08sticks unless I was going on a camping trip or climbing Everest or something like
- 22:15that and might need the reserve. I think that's reasonable. This many calories
- 22:21and everything else goes. Just pass it on out, have an iced day.
- 22:25I think that's intelligent design. Somebody correct me if I'm wrong. I
- 22:32feel bad for penguins. Penguins have wings. They have been denied the ability
- 22:40to fly. I feel bad for them. Oh well, they use them
- 22:45when they swim. Now, yeah, okay, there's still wings. All
- 22:51of the other grounded birds are born with wings and they cannot fly. The
- 22:56chicken. I feel bad for chickens. I would allow chickens to experience winged
- 23:02flight. The ostrich big ass bird. Can you imagine how amazing it would
- 23:07be to see something that big airborne? I would intelligently design that. Of
- 23:14course, it'd be kind of terrifying. You know, if I was out
- 23:18walking the dog and I looked up, Now, oh god, look at
- 23:21that big ass bird. I mean, I look like a bomber flying overhead.
- 23:26But I feel bad. You know winged creatures that can't fly because of
- 23:32the limited wing, or they have these really heavy bones that won't allow them
- 23:36to get off the ground, or they're simply not shaped arrow dynamically. I
- 23:38mean, what kind of design is that I would fix that? Fish that
- 23:45have eyes and remain blind. This is sadism. Who would do that?
- 23:53Here, little fish, I'm gonna make it so you can go here and
- 23:56go there. Oh look, eyeballs. Now I'm going to make them completely
- 24:02useless. I would activate those eyes. Oh they're at the bottom of the
- 24:10ocean, or they're the cave fish. They don't need to be able to
- 24:12see. Why do they have eyes? Don't go halfway with that shit.
- 24:18Either give them eyes and night vision or the ability to see perfectly in total
- 24:23darkness, or don't give them eyes and give them some other kind of awesome
- 24:27sonar capability. You know, infrared, I don't know, maybe not infrared.
- 24:33Wouldn't you need visuals for infrared. We'll stick with sonar, or invent
- 24:38some new vision technology for the natural world. But don't give them the eyes
- 24:45and say, aunt sorry. I would give whales and dolphins the ability to
- 24:52just stay underwater. I don't understand, and maybe someone who is in the
- 24:57no can help me understand why it might be good design to create an aquatic
- 25:03animal that is forced to surface to breathe. Let them stay under if they
- 25:11if they want to come up, if they want to breach, if they
- 25:15want to do their little dance, and you know, they're amazing when they
- 25:18do. They come up and breach and you see the fins and the giants
- 25:22splash, and it's just awesome. They can do that all day. But
- 25:26to have to surface because if they don't, they will drown. They swim
- 25:30in the ocean and they'll drown. I think that's poor design. I would
- 25:34change that. I would create nature so that animals didn't eat each other alive
- 25:42for food. Can you imagine the pain and suffering that would immediately vanish.
- 25:48Shift that was the case, sharks would not go and tear little baby seals
- 25:55apart. They could be pals with the seals. But look over here,
- 26:00I the designer. I have created little seal flavored algae, and the shark
- 26:06can just go over sharks, I'll eat anything anyway, right, Just go
- 26:08over here. There's some seal flavored kelp. Enjoy. There's plenty for everyone.
- 26:18Lions and tigers, instead of going and ganging up on and shredding these
- 26:22poor animals, you know, Oh, look over here, I have conjured
- 26:26and created antelope flavored protein plants just for you. Enjoy. There's plenty for
- 26:34all. I would make it so that tornadoes never touched the ground because I
- 26:42love tornadoes. I've been through too in my life. I was five years
- 26:47old and we were huddled in the bathroom at tornado skips right over the house.
- 26:52I am not exaggerating. It was exhilarating. It was terrifying, one
- 26:56of my first memories. And we didn't have a safe room. This is,
- 27:00you know, back in nineteen seventy three, I think. So we
- 27:07grabbed a twin mattress off one of the beds and we threw it in the
- 27:10bathroom when we were all kind of on the floor underneath it, waiting for
- 27:14the house to come down on top of us. It was insane. The
- 27:18trees out front, we had these new trees and they were bent over so
- 27:22they almost touched the ground. And finally when it was all over, we
- 27:26went out front. We lost some shingles and whatnot, but the neighbor's roof
- 27:30was in our front yard. Of course, everybody was like, it's a
- 27:36miracle. The Lord had the tornadoes skip over our house and fucked up the
- 27:41one next door. They didn't say it that way. Actually, I've never
- 27:48heard my parents use the F word. They've used the other ones. When
- 27:53Mom used to swear a highly conservative evangelical Puritan mother. She would swear every
- 28:00six months, like she it's the word you knew, like deep down in
- 28:04her flesh, in her natural self. She wanted to cuss, but she
- 28:08knew it was improper. But we as children, and she had a house
- 28:11full of us, we would frustrate her so much that she couldn't help herself.
- 28:17And when she cussed, her face would twist up like one of those
- 28:21trees and the Wizard of Oz. Mom, I don't want to clean my
- 28:26room. I'm ganging, man, I don't want to do my homework.
- 28:29Not only so did it. We're bickering about something dumb. And she would
- 28:33finally just have enough and she would say, oh it, and it just
- 28:41her whole face just contorted when she said it. And it was so satisfying
- 28:49to see this holy roller, the grand holy matriarch of the family, the
- 28:56Bible banging mother who just good and herself. Oh it was beautiful. What
- 29:03was I talking about? I'm sorry I went off on a tangent. Oh,
- 29:07the tornado. Tornadoes are awesome. The second one, I it was
- 29:12a few miles away, but it was in our window. We could see
- 29:15it, and it was approaching and it actually roped out and disappeared before it
- 29:19got close to us, but it was the same house and it was just
- 29:22a few years later. And ever since, I've had a fascination with tornadoes.
- 29:26I've even back before I knew better would go out and chase. Now
- 29:30I wouldn't do that because I lacked the expertise, and I've grown a little
- 29:33bit smarter with age. But they're still amazing. So you know, let's
- 29:37put them up in the sky so we can see them, but they don't
- 29:40come down and destroy lives and tear up property, etc. You know.
- 29:44But tornadoes, that's that's kind of awesome. But the other natural disasters,
- 29:48I don't think that an intelligent designer would require those to have a functioning planet.
- 29:55I was talking about on intelligent Design and a video that I released probably
- 30:00ten years ago, and there was an apologist who did a response video and
- 30:04he gave the excuse that, well, if you want to have life,
- 30:10then you have to have disaster. Right. If you don't want life,
- 30:17then you know, you can have a perfect planet. But if you really
- 30:21do want life, then you're going to have to have tornadoes and floods and
- 30:26droughts and tsunamis and earthquakes and volcanoes and chaos and panic and disease. And
- 30:30then he went on to say that actually, most of the reason people died
- 30:34during natural disasters is because governments are corrupt. Oh, it's corrupt government,
- 30:41that's the problem. It's man's fault. Okay. Indian ocean tsunami kills what
- 30:45two hundred and fifty thousand people? By his reasoning, eighty percent of those
- 30:49people died because their government was corrupt. This is what religion does to people.
- 30:56Christianity made me talk like an idiot lightning storms. I know, lightning
- 31:03kills people, but let's create a scenario where lightning happens. We enjoy the
- 31:08Majesty's strength and beauty of lightning, that kind of thing, but it happens
- 31:12in a way that doesn't actually touch us. These are just a few examples
- 31:17of some of the things that popped into my head. If I was the
- 31:19designer, what would you do? You are a designer right now, you
- 31:25are omnipotent. Your creative hand stands over a fresh new orb that will one
- 31:33day become the earth. But will you do? Plenty of people queued up
- 31:40on the switchboard. I want to talk about your ideas for intelligent design.
- 31:47We'll continue next. Okay, before we continue our conversation about intelligent design,
- 31:55I need to let everybody know I'm about to get on a plane. I'm
- 31:57going to be speaking at the we Can Reason conference that's in Calgary, Alberta,
- 32:04Canada, first weekend of May. Specifically it's May the fifth and the
- 32:08sixth r and Raw is going to be speaking, and Janice Selby from Divorcing
- 32:14Religion and Godless Mom and a bunch of other great speakers and so if you
- 32:19are anywhere near Calgary, Alberta, I will see you there. Details.
- 32:23We Can Reason dot com is the conference website, and yes you can still
- 32:30get tickets. And then I'm working on a bunch of other stuff that I
- 32:35will have details for on my personal website. Specifically, I'm going to Denver
- 32:39end of May, working on a Tulsa event in my hometown for mid July.
- 32:45Rochester is coming up. I've got Sarnia, Ontario, and so many
- 32:51others. Seth Andrews dot com. Slash Events is a great way to follow
- 32:57those as details are coming in love, chance to meet you and hang out
- 33:00and we can just fellowship together, not in the Lord, we can just
- 33:06do it for the hell of it, which is a much better reason.
- 33:09But again, first weekend of May, we can reason dot com for details.
- 33:15We are talking about how you might better design the universe if you were
- 33:22the creator four seven five it's vincents, Thanks so much for calling. You're
- 33:32a designer, you have the power. What do you do? Okay,
- 33:37it depends on what kind of designer you're talking about. Because if you're talking
- 33:42about a intelligent designer that wants to make the world work right, Okay,
- 33:46that's cool and all. But if you're talking about like a mad scientists designer,
- 33:51I'm going with superpowers, like everybody who's gets a superpower. Okay,
- 33:55so your main thing would not be necessarily too optimiz is the world or eliminate
- 34:00suffering. You're going for more of an awesome factor. Everybody, can you
- 34:05know, move metal or fly, levitate, read minds, walk through walls,
- 34:08turn invisible, that kind of thing. If we're going with the guy
- 34:12that we have now the superpowers, because it's more like a let's just see
- 34:16what happens. You just want to see people bounce off each other like this
- 34:22is just curiosity. But you're the guy who creates the simulation, and then
- 34:27you put five rogue elements in a room and you seal the door shut and
- 34:31then you just watch what happens with amusements is like thee Yeah, if we're
- 34:37going like the absentee designer, if I want to if I if I wanted
- 34:42to be like the mild kind of like the designer that we have now,
- 34:44and then probably yeah absentee. Yeah, we'll just see what happens. So
- 34:49you wouldn't be a benevolent, involved, intelligent designer. You would just spin
- 34:53everything in motion, sit back and kind of see what happens. I would
- 34:59try to be benevolent, but I would probably have kind of like a little
- 35:01corner somewhere where I like that that little experiment, that little boat experiment.
- 35:10Like I would definitely try to like main earth everything fine and great and dandy.
- 35:16I would just have like a little corner, like a little tea tree.
- 35:20It's like escaped from New York. You would just have our here's the
- 35:22walls, and then you just throw some people in there, some rogue elements,
- 35:27and you sit back with arms folded, and what happens happens. Okay,
- 35:30all right, well that's interesting design and I appreciate you. Colin Vincent,
- 35:35thanks for being a part of this show. No problem. I'd see
- 35:37you David at five four zero. What's up? I am very happy to
- 35:44be here with you and to be talking to you on behalf of three million
- 35:51IRAQI atheists. Wow, Okay, when I want to say thank you very
- 35:55much? Where does that number come from? I'm curious. I've never heard
- 36:00it, you know, through social media and through all these network I know
- 36:07we have a little over three a million, if yet some of them are
- 36:10still in the closet, by the way, and now I just wanted to
- 36:14say, on behalf of them, thank you for this show. Thank you
- 36:17for coming out for years and years and enlightening us with these information. Now,
- 36:22as I was listening to you, I started laughing and laughing on this
- 36:27perfect design. Guess what I am doing? Now? What are you doing?
- 36:31I am here making an immediate denture. An immediate denture is speaking of
- 36:37biology. Here is when a person has crooked teeth all over the place.
- 36:44I take them all out, and I put new plastic dentures in and then
- 36:49we insert them. At the same time, the dentist pulls all the crooked
- 36:52teeth out So how about some perfect design here? This is divine intervention as
- 36:59far as I'm concerned, You're doing God's good work, except you're the God,
- 37:02so to speak, exactly exactly like I was sitting here listening to you
- 37:07talking all about the body parts as that. I wish if I could have
- 37:12a camera to show you the keieth before God's design and my design. I'm
- 37:16upset. Yeah, I mean, you'd think God would have at least invented
- 37:22in visilignes or whatever instead of leaving all of that hard work to us,
- 37:28to us pithy humans. So right, and if this was like a design
- 37:31of a company here and there, that company would have been closed long time
- 37:36ago. So what is your title? What is it that you do?
- 37:39What's on your business card? Because now you have me intrigued. Well,
- 37:44I am a dental technician, full dental laboratory technician. And what I do
- 37:49I make a smile. I am actually the hidden hands of the dentist.
- 37:52That's amazing. You are probably bringing so much joy because you know you often
- 37:59when you walk in a room. I think a lot of people lead with
- 38:01their smile, and if they are self conscious about it and unsatisfied or dissatisfy,
- 38:07whichever the word is. As you know, they're they're embarrassed. I
- 38:10think it hits your self esteem, it hits your confidence when it comes to
- 38:15meeting other people. So by giving people that smile, by allowing them to
- 38:21feel more confident, you've in many ways liberated their lives. I don't think
- 38:23that's an exaggeration. Has that been your experience? Actually, every single day
- 38:29I have two to three patients coming in and leaving the clinic with happy tears,
- 38:35And actually, yes, it does affect me positively a lot. And
- 38:39I know how important is me being here and making these beautiful, perfect dentsures
- 38:45to all these clients and patients. So it's something I experience every day.
- 38:51Sometimes I have young people coming in for different reasons, help reasons. You
- 38:54know, they lose all their teeth and we make those perfect dentists and they
- 39:00are surprised and they have tears on their eye. I'm kind of used to
- 39:06this situation and I always ask that guy up there could have made something a
- 39:10little better. Well, this work that you describe, in my opinion as
- 39:15humanism incarnate, and it's inspiring. Thank you so much, David. Thanks
- 39:20for Colin man I thank you, thank you so very much, and thank
- 39:22you for giving me the chance to speak on they have three million Iraqi atheists.
- 39:29All right, all right, thanks again, bro, you have a
- 39:30good day. I'd have to look that number up. I know there's an
- 39:36underground of atheists sin Middle Eastern countries, in Islamist regime nations. And the
- 39:44reason I know there's an underground is because I speak to a lot of x
- 39:46Muslims that talk about how their networking off the grid, so to speak,
- 39:52outside the eyes of the clerics, and they are waiting for the day where
- 39:58they can come out and speak without being imprisoned or having their families assassinated,
- 40:04etc. And I am convinced there is a big underground of atheists in these
- 40:08Middle Eastern countries even now listening to this show. Maybe it's oxygen in their
- 40:14ears and there maybe dreaming for the day when they can join us out in
- 40:19the sun. If you're listening, I see you, and our caller sees
- 40:22you, and we know our hearts are with you, and we dream of
- 40:27a better world together. By the way, I have to share this story.
- 40:32I saw a video of there's a woman who had had a tremendous drug
- 40:38problem, and whatever the drug was that she had been using destroyed her teeth.
- 40:43I mean they just rotted the teeth out of the mouth. And she
- 40:46was able to overcome her addiction. She went through a very difficult road.
- 40:52She was a young woman in her mid twenties, but she lost all of
- 40:54her teeth, and she suffered so much. She was so self conscious,
- 41:01she was depressed in all of those things. And someone donated to an orthodontist
- 41:08or whatever the dental surgeon is called, and that person put in anchors and
- 41:15gave her brand new, perfect teeth. And somebody was rolling phone video when
- 41:22the procedure was done, and they put her in front of the mirror and
- 41:25they asked her to smile. And I am not kidding. I got teared
- 41:31up watching her transform. It blew her mind. She couldn't stop hugging and
- 41:38kissing everybody and thanking them and thanking them, and it was just an amazing
- 41:44moment of humanity. And I think, well, a benevolent, intelligent designer
- 41:49would have caused her teeth to regenerate, you know, would have created us
- 41:52solution. Right, we're back to the replaceable parts. I don't think that's
- 41:55unreasonable. Here's another one. They just opped into my mind. Dogs would
- 42:01live a hundred years at least or at least my lifetime. Is that selfish?
- 42:09What kind of intelligent designer brings a dog into your life? And when
- 42:16I had Great Danes it was what seven years? Seven year lifespan? I'd
- 42:22have to stop having large dogs because my heart couldn't take losing a dog every
- 42:28seven eight years. Even the smaller dogs you might get fifteen sixteen? What?
- 42:35What? What kind of intelligent design is that? Why build heartbreak into
- 42:40the human canine union? What's wrong with you? Man? I would I
- 42:49would design that totally. This is a lifelong friend, and we're going to
- 42:53do the lifelong thing with a long life. That would be my design for
- 43:00dogs and cats, if you want. I've heard that parrots live a long
- 43:07time. What are the birds that live a hundred years? They live so
- 43:09long that you actually have to put something about them in your will. I'm
- 43:15trying to think of which bird it is. They're intelligent, and they mimic
- 43:20you and talk back to you if I guess that's how you say it,
- 43:23and they live a hundred years? What birds are those? Somebody in the
- 43:29chats tell me what that is, Joshua? Four zero five? What's up?
- 43:35Hey? I think that you're thinking a little too Simply, if I
- 43:39were God, we would just live forever and always be in a constant state
- 43:46of orgasm. How would you get anything done if you were in a constant
- 43:57state of orgasm? Who cares, Joshua? It would not matter. You
- 44:01would just be simply in a state of complete ecstasy a time. I don't
- 44:07know. I mean, isn't much of that about the journey as much or
- 44:12more than the destination? Yeah? Right, this is something I don't think.
- 44:16I don't want to. I don't want to get too much into deta
- 44:20All right, don't you feel like there's there are steps, you know,
- 44:24there's anticipation, and there's fantasy, and there's infatuation, and there's all you
- 44:30know, there's all of these things that lead up that I think are integral
- 44:35parts of that whole thing. I it's got to be about more than just
- 44:38go ahead. Yeah, But the fact that they lead to this doesn't mean
- 44:45that they aren't important or pleasurable. In fact, they might actually make the
- 44:50or I can't believe I'm having this conversation. They might even make the orgasm
- 44:53better. Because because it is the destination, right, you have some thing
- 45:00on the horizon that you were looking forward to. He's not convinced. Joshua
- 45:07is not convinced. All right, what was the first part? It was
- 45:10constant state of orgasm and what we'd live forever? Yes, okay, yeah,
- 45:16that would that would be pretty heavenly. All right, all right,
- 45:21well let me pray in fast on this, my brethren, and thank you
- 45:23so much for calling the show. See later, all right, thank you.
- 45:29I think we did a broadcast years ago asking would you like to live
- 45:32forever if you were given the chance. And this is a great philosophy conversation,
- 45:38isn't it. If you had the opportunity to never die, would everything
- 45:45become meaningless because you didn't have a clock. I mean, there's an urgency
- 45:49to everything I do because I know that I have a finite existence and one
- 45:53day my ticket is going to be punched and there may be no tomorrow.
- 45:58We are all born with a death sentence, and there's a magic to that.
- 46:02I don't think I'm romanticizing the fact that we are mortals when I say
- 46:07that it gives a real urgency to not waste time, not waste life,
- 46:14to not sit around on our hands, passing the buck or worrying too much
- 46:17about what other people think. Right, it's my life, damn it.
- 46:21I'm gonna live it because I'm on the clock. But if you live forever,
- 46:24does that urgency go away? And does everything become kind of a numb
- 46:28meaninglessness? And I've had this conversation about the biblical idea of heaven. You
- 46:35go to heaven and do what essentially you live in a mansion and you kiss
- 46:39God's ass and you do it forever. That doesn't sound appealing to me,
- 46:47not remotely. And for the record, I disagree that constant orgasm for eternity.
- 46:54I just it just doesn't sound like. I don't know what to do
- 47:02with that call. I don't know. I'm ill equipped. I don't have
- 47:07what you need. I'm not serving you as the audience today. I just
- 47:12what do you think about it? I don't know? Five four zero,
- 47:16Mark you there, yes, a lot of biblical names today. I just
- 47:21talked to Joshua Now I got Mark. Hey, what's up? Brother?
- 47:23I love your podcast, thank you? And I love the book by Octavia
- 47:29Butler, where the main one of the main characters in the Parable of the
- 47:32sower can feel other people's pain, and I think that would be great for
- 47:38keeping people from doing bad stuff to each other. Oh that's good. That's
- 47:45good because many of the people on this planet that frightened me the most are
- 47:51the sociopaths. Those who have no are a very limited ability to empathize.
- 47:58Those people terrify. But what if we had empathy times ten or something like
- 48:01that. Yeah, wouldn't that be nice? You could call it kind of
- 48:06a natural karma. Right. If I go out and I mess with somebody
- 48:08and I caused them pain, it's going to fall back on me. I'm
- 48:12going to feel that directly. I kind of like that mark. Good stuff,
- 48:16but an excellent author. All right, I'll make that note, and
- 48:22if we are ever given the opportunity to design, I'll have my people call
- 48:27your people. Okay, sounds good. All right, thanks for calling,
- 48:30Thanks so much. Six one four justin? Are you there? Certainly am
- 48:37Sith Justice from Australia. How are you going? Oh? I love the
- 48:39Australian accent. Justin, So glad you called my friend. You're what seventeen
- 48:44hours ahead of me? I think something like that. So I've just been
- 48:47to the gym it's about eight am and I'm about to go to work.
- 48:51So I'm glad you called. We're talking intelligent design You've got the power.
- 48:55What would you do? Oh? Nice? If I were intelligent designer,
- 49:00I would not create people with the proclivity to tailgates you on the freeway.
- 49:09That would be fantastic. What will we have some sort of a natural energy
- 49:15bumper around us so it was impossible to get too close. Oh, I
- 49:21don't know. If I were intelligent designer, what would I do? I
- 49:23don't know. I probably would have a no dickhead policy. All right,
- 49:29there's a story here, justin there's a story here. Somebody wounded you?
- 49:34All right? Is it? Is it drivers in your city? Specifically,
- 49:38because we've got cities here where it's death raised two thousand, right, I
- 49:43mean it's offensive driving and people will tell you that out right. Is it
- 49:46that way where you live? Oh? Absolutely? Everyone thinks that they've got
- 49:51the most important thing to be too at any time, and they're happy just
- 49:55to you know, drive right up the back of you in the middle of
- 49:58traffic. My last favorite one is when you come to merge lanes and you
- 50:04just get those occasional people who decide. Oh yeah, I'm gonna use the
- 50:06merger lane to overtake everyone who's clearly waiting in line. You wouldn't do that
- 50:09at a bank, you wouldn't do that the DMV. But you know we
- 50:14did that on the road because the car is an anger box on wheels.
- 50:17All right, anger box on wheels. I'm writing that down. The car
- 50:23is an anger box on wheels. That's I'm stealing it. I'm stealing it,
- 50:30justin be safe on the drive back, my friend, and I hope
- 50:35you get a chance to come to Australia one day. Maybe we can shake
- 50:37hands. Okay, that'll be fantastic, Thanks, Seth. Take it easy
- 50:40later, I should say, come back to Australia. I was there for
- 50:44the Unholy Trinity Tour in twenty fourteen. Has it been nine years? Nine
- 50:52years? That's crazy. I think it's Jada at five four one? Are
- 50:57you there, Javis? Javis? Easy, forgive me, my friend.
- 51:01I'm glad you called. We're talking intelligent design and you are the designer.
- 51:07What would you do? I would create humans with the ability to critically think
- 51:13naturally, if only, if only that would be mine? Where does that
- 51:20weariness come from? You like the rest of us where you log onto the
- 51:22world and then you want to go put your face through the sheet rock or
- 51:25what I just hied it in a pillow. I mean, there's nothing I
- 51:30can do. If I could, i'd pray. I mean it's nonsensical.
- 51:35Every day. Yeah, the more I study the other, world's going really
- 51:39well. I mean, numerically, we're doing this better than we have in
- 51:43the past. I think the common sense then needs to come into play,
- 51:46more critical thinking. We'll just program that right end from the front end.
- 51:52Yeah, the birth, you're born with it, all right. You know,
- 51:54people can't dissuade you anyways. Every we have a great day, all
- 51:58right, see you later? Almost said amen, brother. I mean I
- 52:02guess I could say amen, brother. I was going to say something else,
- 52:08and it just slipped my mind. It's gone. Memory. That's another
- 52:19thing I would give myself the ability. I don't know if I would call
- 52:22it a photographic memory, because I think there are probably some things that you
- 52:28don't want full and complete and absolutely clear recall of to at least feel along
- 52:35with remembering the horribly traumatic things in your life, I think if you could
- 52:39maybe browse those in kind of a database, A little more objectively. But
- 52:44how many times do I walk in a room and go why did I walk
- 52:46in this room? How many times has someone asked me for something that I
- 52:52spoke about on a show two weeks ago and I can't remember the specifics and
- 52:55I have to go back to the archive or look up the footnote, the
- 53:00reference or the book or whatever. Wouldn't it be nice if whatever we saw
- 53:04and heard and read and whatever. What if that was part of a database
- 53:07that we could then go back and refer to, and then we could update
- 53:13it. So, oh, wait, this information here, I'm gonna I've
- 53:15got a new information. So once I retrieved the old thing, it actually
- 53:19pinballs up to the new thing, so I've always got the up to date
- 53:22info. Would you want a photographic memory? I think it'd be great.
- 53:28Why do we have brains that cause us to forget someone's name the second we
- 53:32ask what their name is? Hi? What's your name? Bomb? Okay?
- 53:37Guy? I have gone into situations with Natalie and here's somebody that I
- 53:44played tennis against I don't know eight times over the course of five years.
- 53:50Right, they're on another team and we see each other. Hey, seth,
- 53:53good to see it. I don't know who this per. I don't
- 53:58know their name, and I will find somebody who does not know them,
- 54:02and I will say, go, I've and introduce yourself so I can hear
- 54:07their name when they introduce themselves to you, and then I will leavesdrop.
- 54:14Hey, Susan, I'm Tim, Tim, I'm Susan, and then I'm
- 54:17able to follow up right behind Susan. How you've been? Haven't seen you
- 54:22in forever? You're looking good? You look great? Yeah? Oh yeah
- 54:28you've been. Oh you've been good. Great? How's the family? Oh
- 54:30yeah, I don't know. I would like a much better memory. I
- 54:35would design that I don't know. Okay, that's gonna wrap up part one
- 54:40of this conversation about what we would do as an intelligent designer. Next week,
- 54:45we're gonna go into a much deeper dive. It's going to be a
- 54:49lot more science. See talking with an actual scientist, and it's gonna be
- 54:53amazing. Doctor Abbey Hafer is going to join me as we are the omnipotent
- 55:00designer. What what a scientist do? We'll find out next week and I'll
- 55:06see you then. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete
- 55:10archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking
- 55:15Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free
- 55:21thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com