Latest / Jew York Times / What Is Bibi Netanyahu Going To Do? Israel Election Update
Transcript
- Eitan: Welcome to the Jew York Times 120 Angry Seats the Road to the Israel's election at the end of October. My name is Ayton Levine. As always, I'm joined by Shani Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. On today's episode, Major Shakeups in the Election. We have a Jew that is gonna be running in an Arab block. We have a new bunch of wild I don't know how to describe them, the overwinter people. There's internet people. Shanie: A bunch of a bunch of tiny random parties that are all identical to each other. Eitan: Internet people are getting involved. Lots of internet people are happening. It's a lot of some fun stuff. Also, we have a great interview we did with Shauna Orlick about grassroots organizing and what it takes to build a new party and get traction with the upcoming election. She is with the Democrats. so it was a very nice conversation. All the stories and more on today's episode of the Junior Times 100 running angry seats. Sha Shanie sing it with me. Yeah, the third. She need, how is it going? How's your life going? What's new? Is anything happening in the world? Shanie: Life is good. Life election season is always good. Election season. I you Eitan: Election season is happening. Shanie: know, I've been waiting for this moment for four years. So election season the Israeli elections, yeah. The second this Eitan: The election? Shanie: government came in, I was like counting down and the you know. Eitan: Need it. I need it. What is happening? Is there anything that's happening with the world world? You what the thing is is that like my algorithm right now is just like like sports stuff because of Kawhi Leonard and everything. Stuff that I don't think that you are paying attention to. So Shanie: I don't even know who is that a person? Eitan: the biggest thing happened. Let me tell you right now, Shanie: Tell me. Eitan: famous basketball Jew, Commissioner Adam Silver, punished famous Jewish basketball Jew, Steve Bomber, because he circumvented the cap. Basically, there's something called a salary cap. You go and Shanie: Okay. I do know about this. I do know about this. Eitan: Exactly. And it's like the biggest punishment that ever happened over all times. The whole thing to me reads kind of Shanie: Is it anti semitism? Eitan: Well the thing is it's Jew on Jew violence and I hate to see the Jews fighting. Adam Silver's a Jew, Steve Bomber's a Jew, they're fighting over one guy in Kawhi Leonard and Shanie: Wow. Eitan: it's chaos out there with Shanie: the basketball player himself is not Jewish. Ugh. Just wait, just wait. Give him time. Things are not funny. No, Eitan: He's unfortunately not Jewish yet. Chabad's not gotten to him at all. It needs to happen. do you you don't follow any sports? You're not, this is not your uniform. Shanie: I don't, but I'm married to like a basketball y Jew, you know? Eitan: This is a big wheat. This is probably a big week for him. What does he follow? What's his Shanie: the Knicks, the Jets, the Yankees. Eitan: Okay. Okay. That's a good team, a bad team, and a good team. I'm a Jet fan. Shanie: Ha ha. Eitan: It's prison. Being a Jeff fan is absolute prison. Shanie: You're a Jet fan, right? Eitan: I I am a Jeff fan. Actually, there's so many videos of me because I had a sports show when the Jets got Aaron Rodgers, and there's a lot of videos of me yelling and being like, we got him, we got him, we'll never be unhappy again. I think I there's somewhere there's a clip of me going, We'll never be unhappy again. And then Yeah, I know. Silly Shanie: The Jews will be unhappy. Eitan: me. I think I also said this pre-October seventh, to be completely honest. His tenure in the in in the in the in the whatever it's called it in the NFL or on the Jets was about three and a half minutes. So that did not go well at all. Yes. On nine eleven, he runs through these two silver beams that Shanie: I remember this now. that was really tough. my God. That was a Shiva in my house. There was a Shiva. Eitan: were he runs out with an American flag and then immediately is crushed. And they spent the entire preseason Shanie: No, it was literally Eitan: making us excited about it. It was it was not fun at all. Shanie: No, it was literally a shiva in my house. I remember this now, yeah. That's a reason. Eitan: Okay. Thoughts and prayers. And this year I'm telling you right now, it's not gonna be a good year. Not gonna be a good year. So please at Nick's band, I'll be fine. Okay. Let us Shanie: It's a good time to be an ex fan. Yes. Eitan: talk a little bit about updates that have happened in the Israel in the election that is coming up. it's Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: still on October twenty seventh. Shane, before we go into individual stories, what is the polling looking like? Shanie: Okay, so I just wanna say something very important by really stealing this quote from Dahlia Shinlin, who is a really smart Israeli pollster who works for Haaretz. And what she says is that polls are only measuring voters on what's in right in front of them. And so you can't actually measure polls based on choices that voters don't have yet, which means that we don't actually know what the parties look like, we don't know the party lists, we don't know the party compositions, we don't know who's gonna merge and who's gonna disappear. So we're measuring people. Eitan: The prices are supposed to are they're supposed to be solidified though w within the next like week or yeah. Okay. Yeah. Shanie: Hmm. September 8th. We're we are recording September 3rd. September 8th is when you solidify the list. After that, it'll be much I'll be much more confident. Right now, like we genuinely don't know what's happening. There's a bunch of small parties emerging. There's a lot of potential. If they all run separately, they're basically irrelevant. Although relevant in the sense that they waste seats, waste votes. but if they run together, that's a totally different conversation. So we'll talk about who they are, but I just want to emphasize that. I thought I think it's always like Important to contextualize the polling as you know, that the nuance focus. Eitan: Yeah. And it does feel like over the past like two weeks specifically there's been a lot of like new new parties shooting up and personalities kind of like like edging Shanie: Yes. Eitan: towards t towards starting a party and then once again like social media people being added to parties and and all that stuff. Yeah. Shanie: Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah. So Netanyahu's block is always between like 43 and 53 seats, which means he's nowhere near what he needs to actually form a government. And I just want to make that clear. Like, unless he does something weird, like he just doesn't have the numbers, okay? Pretty clearly for now. the Eisenblock, as we called it, without the Arab parties, Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: and I think it's that's important to say without the Arab parties, because he could end up running with an Arab party, but right now, without the Arab parties, Is somewhere in the high 50s range. Okay. But he could join forces, like he could form a government with the Rom Party, Mansura Basas' Rom Party. And Shauna's gonna talk about that. and we're gonna talk about that too. right, because I actually don't like the idea that we're separating out the Arab parties when realistically one of them could end up in this in a coalition. Eitan: Eisenblock is is trending in the high fifties, the B B block is trending in the the low fifties, high forties, low fifties. What is it? And then otherwise, like what Shanie: High high forties. Low fifties, yeah. Eitan: is n where's Bennett at? Where the where the Democrats at? anyone else that's kind of like interesting, that is any movement, or is it are those kind of like solidified? Shanie: So I, you know, you continue to see the Democrats around eleven, more or less. They actually like are not changing very much from around that eleven. you continue to see Bennett Lepede somewhere or between like fourteen, fifteen, something like that. Sometimes they're they go down to twelve. so somewhere in that range. But again, you know what I think, which is that it does not matter where the Democrats and Bennett Lepide are. Like what matters is Eitan: Yeah yeah. Shanie: the whole block. Don't forget, does not matter. Where any it matters where Isencott and Likud are because it that affects things. Everything else, like if you're just changing seats from one le one opposition party to another, one right wing party to another, literally doesn't matter because you just need to form a government. In a coalition, you're never gonna have a government that doesn't have a coalition. You're never gonna have one party that's big enough to sit on its own. We're nowhere near that at this point. Eitan: And the only way for the Isenblock to actually gain governmental dominance is, like you said, through the through one of the Arab parties. Specifically for now. Shanie: For now, that's how it seems. Yeah. Based on all the polling right now, it's pretty obvious they're going to need a party. That will probably be Mansoura Bas's ROM party, because that is that is the party, as I've mentioned before, that sat in the Bennett Lepede government, the change government back in 2021. And so it's and it it's it's pretty clear that everyone's positioning themselves to allow it. Although there is, of course, of course, you still have a lot of denial. you have Netanyahu saying, can you believe those crazy people are gonna sit with the Arabs? And then Isencott's like, us, well, I don't know, maybe we wouldn't, we will, you know, like just trying to talk around it. so. Eitan: Well, so the the question so my question with that is that like this week the big news to come out was that Joh Sagalovic, a Jew, believe it or not, has officially joined Rom and that he is going to Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: be running with Rom, which is insane. It's it seems like it's very unique. Stuff like that doesn't happen that often. my first question with this is one, who he who is he? But two, I Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: know that there are Arabs, Palestinians that serve with Israeli parties. Is there ever been a case of Israelis serving with one of the Arab Shanie: Yes. Eitan: parties? Shanie: Yeah, the the Kadash Party, the the Arab, like communist hardcore party, has, I think right now is Ofer Kasif. he's like a real far-left like anti-occupation ju Jewish Israeli. but historically it is technically an Arab Jewish party. The reason this is unusual is because Ram is an Islamist party. so it it's like very strange. They're actually trying to become less of an Islamist party. and I I also think it's important to say that like Over Kasif is very different from Johav Segalovich, who was a member of Knesset with Yeshatid, which is a really centrist liberal party. Okay. This guy is not the far left by any stretch. he's a former senior police officer, actually, and he really believes in Arab Jewish unity. It's super important to him. And he gave a really powerful speech talking about it. So I think this goes a long way. Having a pretty normal mainstream politician from a normal mainstream party, he just left Yeshatid, which again is not the Democrats. Like Yeshat. It's technically a left wing party, but it's not far left at all. Having him join Rom, I think will go a long way in helping the Israeli public realize that it's kosher, so to speak, to join a coalition with them. So I see this as a really powerful positive move. Eitan: Why Yoav? Why is a boss trusting Yoav to be the one to come in? Shanie: so he actually he has a history like back working in with the police as well, back in twenty twenty one. I don't know if you recall the May 2021 violence erupted, but he has a long history of of working between the Arab and Jewish communities. And this is something he apparently really believes in in a in a really powerful way. And I also think it's a pragmatic move. Like I said, this makes Mansur Abbas's likelihood of joining a coalition much higher by having a Jewish Zionist centrist on his slate. Like this really benefits him as well. So I think it helps everybody involved. Eitan: And with Yoab, is that like a weird move for him? Like that's you know, going into territory? Yeah. Shanie: I was surprised. I was surprised. A jump from Yeshatid to Rom is like a pretty far stretch. Like I know a lot of Yeshatid voters, they're not like between Rom and Yeshat. Like they're not, that's not line I there's a big ideological gap. Eitan: So so talk to me then so, you know, with Gaudi Isencad, the idea, you know, the idea of him partnering up with one of the Arab parties has been a big question mark with him. You know, he wasn't saying much, and then the one thing that came out about him, the Palestinians, was that he was not gonna have a Palestinian state under you know, under his under his reign if he was to become Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: the prime minister. And now you have a situation where there is someone that he potentially trusts in Joav Segolovic. Does Yoav also give him the go ahead to kind of to work with with rom. Shanie: So I should add, I don't while Matsur Abbas obviously believes in a two-state solution, that is not his top issue. And he doesn't say, I d will only join a government if they advance a two state solution. Like he doesn't say that. He cares about budget for education system, for Arab communities and crackdown on crime, police enforcement, things like that. He is not trying to be someone who focuses on like the international relations foreign policy stuff because he knows that that's not gonna be a successful route for him. The Eitan: He's also, if I'm not mistaken, is like pro having Arabs serve in the military. Like he fully. Shanie: He has national service. I I think it's more national service, but yeah, it's which is really important because obviously the ultra Orthodox parties don't support that and that's a a huge voting issue for the Israeli public. Eitan: you know, can we actually talk about that? this week I had heard some chatter. It seemed to be like there was some conversation around a new orthodox block that had been started where one of their where they're not gonna get seats. You know, it seems to be that they're a far shot to even get any to get into Knesset, but they're an ultra Orthodox block who is pro having some percentage of the Haredim be mandatory to serve, where like, yes, you can go. And you can learn in Yeshiva. And I think I don't know what the number breakdown was, but it seemed to me that this was a pretty seismic shift in having an ultra Orthodox group being okay with some version of participating in the IDF. Shanie: Yeah, this is from Mordechai Leitner's party is the deputy mayor of Beit Shemish. I think it's great to have Haredi parties representation that are advocating for conscription. I think this is something that you you could see more and more modern ultra-orthodox people voting for. Again, because most of my friends from the Haredi community are feminist women, I have to say he's not having women on his slate as of now, which is still a huge problem. And I need to name that because as soon as I texted all my Like liberal Haredi friends saying, What do we think of this guy? They like, Well, there's no women on his slate. I'm like, you know what? Screw him. so I do need to name that, but I do think it's still I am I am happy to see that there's another ultra-orthodox party emerging, even though, by the way, if you waste seats for the ultra-orthodox, I'm perfectly fine with that. that he doesn't make in the threshold. But I think it's good to start to create momentum. Like this side, there's been this like scare tactic, obviously, or people are terrified to to come, you know, go head to head with the rabbinate and with The ultra-orthodox parties because they're so strong in their communities. And I think it's great to see them being challenged by somebody. I think it's awesome. So I love to see it. I'm sure I don't agree with this guy on a whole bunch of things, but it's good that he's promoting, you know, secular studies in schools, workforce participation, military draft. Like these are really, really critical. and and it's I also think it's good for like Haredi secular relations or Haredi non-Haredi relations because it shows secular Israel or non-Haredi Israel. I you see like there are ultra Orthodox who recognize the problem and they want to address it. and they're coming in as partners, realizing that they need to change things. And I think that's also really important. So I I hope it helps ease the tension between the communities too. Eitan: Something that was interesting by the way it was framed was about how the angle for the party was like giving Haradium who want to make money and want to participate in society having the IDF buy-in as the way for them to as the ticket for them to do it, which I thought was very interesting. Where it's like if you serve in the army, it opens up your ability to serve in society in general, and there is A want and a need and you know, there's a want out there within the Haredi community to have that as an option. The way that they had set it up of having it be a certain small percentage of the community and having certain thresholds about who gets to go to yeshiva and not go to yeshiva. to your knowledge, is this the first time that there's been a you know a party? And once again, it doesn't look like they're gonna get a seats in Knesset, but has there been a push from the ultra-orthodox community to do something like this? Shanie: Listen, at least a quarter, if not more, of of Haredi people are more modern. So they live in the world and they think about these things. They realize that they're separate from Israeli society. And I don't know that they doesn't mean they wanna serve in the army, but they know that they're separate. And this this does people care about integration. They wanna integrate into Israeli society to some degree. Is do they want to enough to say, like, I'm gonna serve in the military when no one I know does it? Like that's a huge step. But I I think there are a lot more people than you'd think who are attuned to this problem and actually want to address it in some way. You just need a lot, you need more momentum. You need to shape the ch change the discourse around it and you need to change the leadership around it. But on an individual level, if you talk to people, you can see there are cracks in it because people know it's unsustainable, by the way. Like there's a lot of, you know, educated ultra Orthodox people are aware how unsustainable this is. Are they all doing something about it? Again, no, this guy is, but in general, like they're not. But if you give a if you give a political option and you you can create momentum over time. so I I'm I'm I'm hopeful to see it. Eitan: Yeah. They're gonna be dragged into it. It feels like it feels like they're gonna get dragged into it. Whether they acknowledge that it's a problem or not, some of the strategy is like, Okay, we're gonna put our feet in the sand that eventually like we'll get pulled into some version of it. So if we put the stakes Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: where they are, then you know, they'll be where you know, where they are. I got Shanie: Yeah. And of course a lot of a lot of ultra Orthodox are very extreme, right? Really deep religious. But but Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: you again, you have a sector who are increasingly modern and do want to live in an Israeli society. And without the army, it's very hard to integrate. Without it with a different education system, et cetera, like it's hard to actually integrate into the employment mark force. So yes, there is a path from like army, there is an army Eitan: I think it was Shanie: to job trajectory that's helpful. Eitan: I think you're also missing the big point about how fun it is to in your suit pants stand in cement while while they're I think you're missing how fun it looks like those guys are having. And you know what's funny about that? Whenever they show like them protesting and then they're in the cement piles and whatever, they're always they always have their tefillin bag with them still. It's the funniest like Shanie: You gotta take it everywhere, no? Eitan: you gotta take it everywhere. I you can't leave it at Yeshiva because you make it stuck in the in the cement and they'll be able to get out of it. I got a broad question on Shanie: Please. Eitan: on where the ultra-Orthodox community is with this election right now. Because it seems to be that over the past couple of weeks, the f there was a story about Netanyahu trying to figure out how to separate himself from, you know, the ultra-Orthodox side. People are talking more and more about involving the Arab side versus the ultra-orthodox. It was almost like these are. There's mainstream Israel with all the little parties, and then there's the ultra-orthodox Jews, and then there's the Arab side. And it was a question of like who is gonna work Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: with the Arab side or the ultra-orthodox. The only way for BB to have his coalition was to work with the ultra-orthodox. The only way for Isencod to potentially or BB, you know, whatever, it was also through the Arab Party. Now that the it seems to be that they're all playing ball with the Arab side. And finding out all these ways to have a coalition that doesn't involve the ultra-orthodox. What is the what is it like what is going through their mind? Are they trying to figure out a way to to hop on? What they Shanie: Who's the they? Who's the they? Eitan: would say that how are the ultra orthodox voting Shanie: Yeah, I'll draw exactly. Eitan: blocks navigating this universe where it seems like they are kind of running out of allies here? Shanie: Netzanyao is if Netzanyao is going to try to form a coalition with the Ultra Orthodox if he's able to. This is who he's been running with for a very long time. That those are his coalition partners. Without them, he l really doesn't have anybody. so he's pretty screwed without them because Isencott's not sitting Eitan: But can you but can you also not win with them? Like isn't Shanie: He can't, I mean, he can't win at all. He's not, I don't think he's going to win based on the numbers right now. But if he abandons them, he can he's not a Victor Lieberman, Yashelle Baytanyu said he's not sitting with BB. Isencott's not sitting with BB, Ben and Le Peter not sitting with BB. So who does he who is he replacing the Ultra Orthodox with? Nobody. There are not enough parties willing to sit with him. So unless Eitan: But there was Shanie: someone goes against what they said. Which I mean, I would be shocked if these people end the end sit with Netanyahu. I it'd be really surprised. You never know. Benny Gans went against what he had said and did it. But generally speaking, like it is it's a it would be a surprising move. And he wouldn't he would need more than one of them. He would need multiple unless he got Isencot. So Eitan: Yeah. Yeah. Shanie: I don't see it happening. I think he's trying to distance himself from the Ultra Orthodox because they're very unpopular. His Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: own voters are jumping ship, going to Eisencott potentially, because they don't want to continue with the draft evasion. So Obviously, it benefits him to say, like, don't worry, we're gonna figure something out. We're gonna draft them. Don't worry, don't worry. But like, no, he's he's not. He just had four years working with them to figure out a way around this. And he didn't. He just continued to pass laws to try to get them out of the military. So it's pretty obvious that he's willing to play ball with them. and yes, you're right, it's deeply unpopular. I also Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: wanna say I don't like the comparison between like the between Gaudi Esencott working with the ROM party. Not all the IRPs, the Roman party, and who Netanyahu's partners are. Netanyahu's coalition partners to me are infinitely worse than Mansura Bas. His coalition partners are Itzamar Bangvir, who is like been arrested dozens of times and like threatened Yitzhak Rabin and, like, you know, like really horrible, horrible person. And the ultra-orthodox who don't serve, right? So, like, I don't want to compare Mansoor Abbas to I Mansur Abbas's party, especially with Segalovich in it, like. A much more savory figure to me and much more acceptable in an Israeli coalition compared to Netanyahu's partners for the past four years. Eitan: I was just say the the comparison is just in context alone. Like it it purely is just in the fact that like these seem to be two little islands that the community are trying have no idea how to fully interact with or, you know, integrate with. Shanie: It it is interesting. It is interesting. It's a fair comparison on a tactical level, Eitan: Yes. Shanie: just not a values level. Eitan: W you know what? This podcast, we don't talk values, okay? We're only numbers. You know, thought thoughts don't care about your feelings, Shinee. Didn't we learn anything? Shanie: That's actually my favorite quote. Eitan: Welcome to Prager You Alright, Shine, Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: I there was one other news story that I wanted to cover and that was about the disastrous Sarah Netanyahu. Shanie: No, no, no, wait, wait, wait. We didn't talk about all the small parties. We have to talk about Ofer Winter because everyone's talking about him because he actually managed Eitan: Yes, yes, yes, yes. Shanie: to take a bunch of seats from like Batsalas Motrich mostly. and he's another right-wing party. He's a retired IDF general. and again, like all of these small right-wing parties are indistinguishable from each other. They all are right wing and they say they care about an IDF draft. Great. Like, why are you not the Likud party? I don't know. But they've decided that they are doing something different. Well, I the Likud party. even though they support the draft, their partners don't. So there's all these different parties coming up and saying like, we are very right wing and we care about drafting the the Haredim. Offer Windsor is one of those people and he's the only one who's actually getting across the threshold. he's actually like he's but again he's taking seats from the Likud. So it doesn't really matter. Cause remember he's just sh he's just shifting around seats from the same side, the same block. So again it's irrelevant. he we don't actually know Eitan: Well talk to me about it. Who who is he? How did this party come to be? Shanie: Wa one dude starts a party. All you need is one dude to start a party, okay? Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: So he was a military, career military guy. he actually is beef with Isencott because Isencott passed him up for a major army liberal role. Like Isencott didn't like him. BB didn't intervene. He is beef with everyone. He the only thing he said, like to to like convey his ideology is that he didn't want a government with anyone responsible for October 7th, which you would think would mean Netanyahu. But then a day later, Eitan: That's right. Shanie: he was like, The only person I'll recommend for Prime Minister is Bibi Netanyahu, like two days Eitan: Okay, thanks. Shanie: later. So whatever, like this is like some sh some guy. Eitan: We all think stuff. Shanie: We all say stuff. interestingly, he has Yosef Haddad on Eitan: Yes. Shanie: his, who's an Israeli Arab, like who works like the Hasbrah space, pretty right wing guy on his list, who's supposed to be the public Eitan: Who also trended this week. And here's the thing is that like a week and a half Shanie: diplomacy minister, which is actually probably except a good job for him. Eitan: Yosef Adad is the public diplomacy minister? You're out of your mind. Shanie: Yeah. I don't know if like I don't know if Yosef said he would do that or like that's official, but in theory, like that's what he promised him. Eitan: There's never been a less diplomatic person on the entire planet than Yosef Hadat. A couple Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: of weeks ago he was he had a moment trending because he was on some podcast yelling at some anti-Israel guy, and the anti Israel guy started to like attack him and then I will say Yosef could have decked him and then kind of didn't Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: hit him back, which I thought was good. But then then afterwards Shanie: That's good. Eitan: they got in a fight in the parking lot and it looked crazy. We can't have the diplomacy minister getting Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: into fights in the parking lot. That is this isn't a this is not a Apollo Tel Aviv game. You can't just have our diplomacy minor minister picking fights with and the guy he got in a fight with was like a he's up for Congress election or something. He's he's running on some ticket in Congress. that's Yeah. Shanie: Well, that's actually pretty embarrassing. the other person on the ticket was Fleur Hassan, Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: who's the deputy mayor of Jerusalem. So there's like a few names on the ticket who are I would say like people pee Eitan: We she's not I'm sorry, she need she's not just the deputy mayor of of Jerusalem. She's also a rabble rouser, is what I would say about like Yosef Adad. This is an internet person. When you know, when you told me that this was his first or for a second, I like, That's the that's the the lady who goes on the internet and has that show, the scumbag of the week award thing is her. So I guess the big question that I have about this Shanie: Mm that is her show. Eitan: overwinter party is, is this just like we could with internet followers, it's just just like you know, Twitch streamingly Shanie: You know what? Yeah, I Eitan: could. Shanie: I wouldn't say Twitch streaming Likud, but yes, I think that ideologically it's hard to distinguish it from Likud Party, which is which is fine. I don't know how I don't know why we need so many Likud parties, but yes, I think it's very similar to Likud Party. it's it's no shade to the people on the list. I just I do think it's very ideologically similar. and people are trying to distance the right wing from Netzanyau potentially. So, you know, you I mean, I obviously in the end they're gonna support Netzanyau, but I can understand the desire to distance yourself from him. and say Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: like the right wing doesn't have to equal Netanyahu. but you know, we also have Gilad Erdan, we also have Moshe Faglin, we all I mean and so on and so on. Benny Gans, by the way, might, who's not making it over the threshold in most of the polls, might join forces with Gilader Dan. I haven't seen if they'll make it in if they're together, I'm not sure. But again, hard to distinguish them from all these other right wing parties. I mean, they're not as right wing as some of the others, obviously, but they're not as like messianic. Moshe Faglin is joining with Batsalos Motric. because smotrich was going below the threshold. So maybe together they'll make it in. I'm not sure. and again, the final decision is still in a in like four or five days. So we'll see who ends up running together and that will actually give us a better sense. but I don't think people are deciding between Gadi Eyes and Kodambatzal Smotrich, right? Like these are just ping-ponging between the same block. Eitan: Yeah. Is there the same kind of a a it seems to be that there's a lot of parties popping up on the right. Is on the left also in the center? Are there a lot of parties popping up in the same way or is it Shanie: We speak later about the Standing Together party, but that's about it. because there is there isn't as much of a left. And I think they're being a little more strategic in this election, which is good. I'm I'm very grateful that I don't see a bunch of small left-wing parties. And and standing together, you know, is clearly trying to run together with the United Arab list. And hopefully if they are not able to, they will not run unless they see that they're able to make it over the threshold. I'm not sure. But they claim that they're only gonna run if they're able to make it in. and that if the polling shows that they're gonna waste votes, they're not gonna waste the votes. So I don't know, we'll see if that happens. and by the way, of Eitan: I think they'll make Shanie: course, Netanyahu is losing his mind because he sees all these right-wing parties that are going to waste votes for him. Like if none of them make it in, he's screwed. He's gonna lose a ton of right-wing votes, they're gonna go in the garbage. So he's freaking He's like, please just run together. Like, just run together. Which if I were him, I would be saying the same thing. but obviously, in an attempt to do that, he's bringing in like, All these cra every random crazy guy who decides he's running, he's bringing into the folds, which is a problem. Eitan: Is he is historically he is he a good whip? Is he a good like getting everyone in in line kind of a politician? Shanie: Well, back maybe it was twenty nineteen, he got Betsy Smultchurch and Itzamar Benveer to run together because he didn't want to lose their votes. And to me, that was the beginning of the end for Netanyahu. Like that was when I was like, Holy crap, this guy will do anything. He will go to the Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: furthest extreme messianic people. At the time, Ben Gveir was like more than a kahonist, okay? More than a kahanist, like admired by Rach Goldstein type crazy person. And he's like pretended to moderate since then. Eitan: in a shrine. In in his in his living room there was the Rebbe and then there was, you know, Kana up there. Yeah. Shanie: Mm-hmm. And Mayor Kana, yeah. and so, you know, he tr the when he said, like, you need to run together, I need to make sure that we don't lose votes, like that means you want to make sure they get into the Knesset, into your coalition. And that's, you know, that was the beginning of the end. And since he has success doing that. He for he forced them to run together and they did it. and they've continued to at different times since then in order to maintain power. So I do think that Sunyao, like, he's a big figure. He's been the prime minister for a very long time. He is very sophisticated and he is good at this. So If anyone can do it, I actually I I think he can. I think he'll he might have success. He doesn't control all of them. Like Benny Ganson, Giladardani has a lot less control over compared to maybe Ofer Winter or some of the people who are obviously aligned with him. Eitan: Yeah. Interesting. You see, by the way, the commercial that was it Ben Gavir with the concentration camp my god. The the video was Shanie: No. no. Eitan: I don't even know how to describe this. It was a a a a conveyor belt that is concentrating Shanie: Okay. Eitan: what I think was a bunch of AI versions of Monsora Boss into a prison. like it was it Shanie: my god, what? Eitan: was weird. I they're stepping up their AI game. I gotta know what the deal is with the AI marketing that's happening within this election right now. It seems to be that like they're all kinda doing doing AI. I it's it's interesting. Yeah. Shanie: Yes. And they're all like taking each other's commercials and then flipping them and doing like the almost identical commercials with like a different shtick. It's very strange. Eitan: Does it does it work? Does that like I feel like this is probably the first election where they've had to deal with like the in like this internet memefication kind of attempt at at getting audiences? I I'm curious if it if it does actually sway anything. I don't know. There's and there's no way to really Shanie: No, no. Who is being swayed by this? Absolutely not. It riles up your base. Maybe it gets out the vote. What you want to do is get your voters out. You're not I don't think you're swaying Eitan: The thing is is that Shanie: people this way. Eitan: that the thing is I don't even think it gets the we there's no way to to know if this actually gets the the voters out. I think that there's a big thing where and I wanna say I don't I Shanie: Well you can do message testing. Eitan: don't have access to their back end is what I will say. I don't have it, you know, obviously I'm saying this is a purely objective, but there's one thing I've learned about all of these internet campaigns and all this stuff. A lot of it is boost. A lot of it, the success of the video is clicks and likes that is often paid for and Shanie: For sure. Eitan: it's a question of whether those are Good views, are those good likes, or are they kind of just like paid for bots in Pakistan or whatever? And I'm and it's hard to look at the videos that do well, because these videos do well views wise, but the idea that it translates over into having people come out to the election, like I don't know yet. And there is really no precedent for it because this is a brand new thing, you know, that was not around last time there was an election. Shanie: Yeah. Well, I think you're conflating two things. The way that you decide if an ad campaign is effective is not by how many views and likes or comments it gets. It's by testing it in advance. You have to do testing on people. That's how you know. Not from like how many people look at it. People watch things they hate Eitan: but the thing is, you're a hundred percent right. But these organizations No, I know, but the thing is that these Shanie: all the time. Eitan: the thing is is that the people that the people that fund and the people that pay for this stuff, they oftentimes it's ignored, that fact. When over the Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: past couple of years, when I'm not gonna say names, but when someone wants to do an XYZ anti-Semitism commercial or they want to fight anti-Semitism, so they go to XYZ organization and they say fund this. The way that they get that funding is by showing the numbers on their past videos. And that it's just the numbers. That's the only metric that is ever asked for by this stuff. So i I it happens to be that the same people that have funded the Hasbara mission over the past couple of years, I assume there's someone involved on the Israel side in some of this marketing that's happening. I don't once again I this is all like a guess, but I can imagine that numbers and views are the things that they are using as success metrics. To say let's do more of this stuff because we're getting numbers and views on this. Whether it actually works in getting people to the to the the polls, I you know, what's there's no way to tell. And that's that's kind of like the point with it. I Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: gotta I gotta you know what we gotta get in the AI game. Shine. We're in the wrong game here. We're in the a hundred percent. This is what it is, okay? Yeah. Shanie: We do not. We do not. By the way, by the way, speaking of how horrible the internet is, I want to talk about a conspiracy theory because Shauna Orlich joins us later and she works for your Yurgolan. Eitan: Yes. Shanie: And there was a story this week that made me absolutely insane, which was Sarah Netanyahu, the first lady of Israel, the queen of Israel, if you will, spreading a conspiracy theory that yet Yergolan Head of the Democrats Party, retired major general of the IDF, former deputy chief of staff of the IDF, had advanced notice of October 7th and allowed it to happen. And this is a conspiracy. I just want to say this idea that I've actually heard on the far left, not about him, but on the far left in America, I hear people say October 7th was a false flag operation. And the purpose was so that Israel would have an excuse to bomb Gaza and to resettle the Gaza Strip. I hear that, and you've heard that too from crazy people. Okay. This is the same thing coming from inside Israel, saying that Yet Yir Golan and other people from the in within the IDF intentionally let October 7th happen because they wanted to push BB out of power and they wanted to win the next election. This is insane. This is horrible. It is disgusting. He's suing her right now, which I'm like really happy about. Eitan: Right here. Shanie: by the way, just for like context of of why she claims it's suspicious, which is because the second Yet Yir Golan heard about what was happening, he started getting a Like flooding in of text messages, WhatsApps on his phone, saying, My son is it hiding in a ditch by the Nova Festival. Can you go and save him? And in within an hour and a half, he was in a uniform with a gun and on the road driving to the south. Okay. So this man was a legitimate hero on October 7th. He went back and forth into war zones, in and out, in and out. And she, what's she, what's she saying while her husband, Netanyahu, was like doing literal nothing on October 7th? Why was he so quick? How did he know to get up? his damn phone and he he went into the line of fire. What is wrong with you? Eitan: Can I ask a broad question on this? Do you think Shanie: Sure. Eitan: that she believes this? Because when Shanie: Yes. Eitan: I saw the clip, in Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: my mind, I'm like, this is someone who gets all of their news from a very specific algorithm. And and I think that she actually Shanie: And I think she believes it. I for sure think she believes it. Eitan: bel I think that she believes it, which is the craziest part of this. Shanie: Hundred percent. Eitan: Absolutely the craziest part of this to me was the fact that she wasn't just going out there and being political. It wasn't like she was going out there and being like, hey, here's a scoop. I hope that the Voters don't hear this, she really, really, really Shanie: No. Eitan: believes it. And to me that 'cause sometimes Trump will say stuff. Like with the with the Lysol, you know, to fight COVID and and you know, like whatever. And you realize that these are people that are in insane places of power. Now, granted, how much power does Sarah and Anthonyho Whatever. These are people in really high ranking Shanie: More than you would think, but yeah. Eitan: more I you know, whatever. If you're Michelle Obama had power. You know, these are all she the fact that Shanie: She's a powerful first lady, but go on. She's a p she's po she's more power she's not Melania Trump. She's a pretty powerful first lady. Eitan: Totally, totally. is she more powerful than Michelle? Shanie: interesting. I don't know. But she has quite a reputation for influencing pol she is Sarah Eitan: She Shanie: Natanyao does have reputation for influencing politics and influencing her her husband and politics in general. Eitan: If anyone wants to know how powerful she is, ask Alone Levy how powerful she is. And then we can go from there. You know. She's gotten fired. Anyways, Shanie: good call. I forgot she got him fired. Eitan: what I'm saying is that this is someone who is an incredibly high-ranking, high-level person who's exposed to a lot of stuff that has a say in some stuff, that also is getting their news from fucking wack-a-doodle places. And that, Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: I think, to me is also the big B-level part to the story. It's the most inappropriate thing of all time. The guy's a hero. Like say we want about him politically, the guy clearly is is one of i of the the kind of of of of fighter that became really huge after after October seventh, the people acknowledging that there were so many people that just ran to the fight that like just the second that wherever they were, they just were on the way the second Shanie: Yeah. Noam Tibon also. Eitan: what? Shanie: Noam Tibon is just another name. He's also in running in one of the li one of the opposition lists. I Yeshotid's list. is another guy who did mm hmm. Eitan: But these are people that are that went down there and the conspiracy theories in the internet are gonna attack these heroes. And the fact that she's getting her news from conspiracy theory places and is high ranking is kind of crazy to me. It is kinda wild. Shanie: I I know that I think she has to believe it because otherwise she like you wouldn't say it. Like otherwise she would know what I know, which is that of course everyone's gonna come out and defend Iirgulan. Because mo like most Israelis like, that's insane. Every single member of the opposition, including people who don't like Iir Golan that much, came out in his defense and were like, say what you want about the guy, but he's a freaking war hero. So it I think only made him look better. so I can't, I don't know. I don't think it helped. It helped him. Eitan: You know what's funny? Is that I don't know if this is a thing that happens normally, but this is the second time where a bunch of like opposition people had to come out and either defender whatever someone else running. A couple of weeks ago when you had the Netanyahu was gonna get arrested by Zoran Mamdani, it Shanie: I'm Donnie. Eitan: forced like Gaudi and Bennett and and and Golan, everyone Shanie: Mm. Eitan: had to run out and and put out their own statements of saying, like, we don't like b BB, but you know, don't arrest our guy. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: So it's interesting, is that this is the election of opposition coming to the defense of people that they're they're running against, which is fascinating. Shanie: Yes. That's it's a g it's an interesting comparison that you made. Yeah. Totally. Eitan: Yeah. is there anything else on on that story? Shanie: no, he's suing her for like a million. I don't remember if it was shekels or dollars, but he's suing her for a bunch of money. Eitan: Right. Shanie: for defamation as he should, and we'll see what happens. I'm like skeptical that that she's like gonna pay him the money, but but I think it like it's there's a point here and it's important. Like you can't just say whatever you want about people. Especially it's election season. Hmm. Eitan: Some lawyers I think the important part is that some lawyer is getting billable hours off of this. And that at the end of the day is what these Yeah. Shanie: Is the most Jewish thing there is. Eitan: Billable hours. Shanie: A little hour. Eitan: I don't think there's anything else that I want to talk about because we have an Shanie: Now we're good. Eitan: amazing interview that we did with Shauna Orlick about grassroots organizing. She's involved with the Democrats and but she also had a lot of great insight into talking about engaging with voters outside of the central parts of Israel. There's you know, in Israel we talk about the main parts and then the periphery. The periphery are kind of the outside areas that are more towy, like Des Moines, Iowa is the periphery. Shanie: And they're more affected because a lot of them are on the northern border near Lebanon and Syria, some of with many of which were evacuated over the course of three years, some of which came back. And then you have the south, the Gaza envelope, and people who are also affected by October seventh and are, you know, under missile and rocket attacks at different times. So it's it's the periphery because of geographic location, but it's also disapportionately more likely to be targeted by violence. Eitan: Yeah. And they they vote. They have different things that they vote for. There's different class and infrastructure problems that they have versus people that are in the more populated areas. So it was an awesome conversation with Shauna Orlick and here it is. the next thing that I wanna get to and we'll bring i is our missile is our listener mailbag. Do we have a should we get a slog? We need to get a song. We need to, by the way, this podcast in general, we need to start getting Like jingles and stuff to have like Shanie: was actually gonna say your podcast needs fewer songs, not more songs. Eitan: What are you talking about? I'm I bought the rights to Mr. Bright Side for this podcast, okay? We are on we are under Sony Music. I owe Scooter Braun about 15 million dollars We do have one more thing that I wanted to Shanie: You have one more thing you want to talk about. Eitan: bring up. and then we'll get into the listener mailbag. And by the way, when we get into it here, I'm gonna unveil. the the jingle. So just get ready for it. major interesting news update with APAC and the upcoming elections happening here in America, the midterms that are happening. this is according to Axios. And give a shout out by the way the Yashar Ali who who flagged this. You you follow Yashar at all? Shanie: Yeah, he's great. Eitan: Yashar is phenomenal. Yashar Ali APAC has shelved an ad planned to run in support of Mike Rogers, the staunchly pro-Israel GOP candidate for the US Senate seat in Michigan. The decision came the day after Rogers met with APAC's chair. Allies of Rogers have urged APAC not to advertise in the general election against Abdul Al-Sayed or in support of Rogers because they believe doing so will backfire as it did in the Democratic primary. Another super interesting point in this story, and I just want to give a shout out to Sammy Sage. For highlighting this is that apparently behind the scenes, Rogers' team warned APAC before August 4th, the Democratic Part primary in August 4th, that it believed El Saeed would beat Stevens. Though APAC held out hope Stevens would prevail, the two sides agreed to keep talking. So Stevens's side also told APAC that they don't think that he has a chance of beating El Sayyid, at least back on, you know, was that 20 days ago or something. Anyways, a lot there. Why is this important? It is important because APEC over the past couple of years, I think that they gotta go into their mean girls burn book moment, just burn it all down, release every bit of gossip they have on everyone, allies, enemies, neutral parties. I wanna know And they have all that information right there. No one wants to deal with APEC. APEC is finally running into a wall with Republicans where it is unpopular on that side. To get APAC funding. The big question I wanna ask you, yeah, what is your Shanie: just hate well, don't make Apex sound like it's it's Epstein's Island. Like that's you're gonna be used for like Eitan: They don't know it. Shanie: anti Semitic Reddit threads, but go on. Eitan: Listen, okay, obviously APAC was not on Epstein's Island. All I'm saying is that over the past couple of months, specifically with the elections, it's become very out of vogue to work with APAC in a way that is very, very pronounced now. They have lost Republicans or they're starting to lose Republicans in places. I don't know if I've seen that really before, and the fact that it's kind of leaking is is interesting. What are your kind of thoughts on? Shanie: I I think that in general, getting money for your campaign is really helpful and really good. And so your brand has to be pretty toxic for someone to say, keep your damn money. Eitan: Yeah, right, right. Shanie: and so we're definitely reaching a point where the the APAC brand is obviously become and and again, some of it's warranted. I know you think it's all warranted, some of it's not warranted. A lot of it is because of crazy anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. Eitan: I don't think it's all wait, wait. I don't think it's all warranted. this is the big push and pull of this is that there are people that are crazy and they hate the Jews and they'll always think weird conspiratorial stuff about APAC. That'll always be there. The question is, when do those how much of that is doing the damage versus how much of whatever we're doing the Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: damage? And to be honest, APAC plays into a ton of those tropes. A ton they spent a lot of money in this election to try and fight a very popular candidate. I know it was a bit of a squeaker. more than I think I've acknowledged on Instagram, but it was still like they're not cool. And you know, Haley Stevens is a weird is a weird one. I yeah. Shanie: Okay, but and on the other hand, if you're a if you're a pol a pro-Israel pack, of course you're going to push back and and fund the candidate against Azul Al-Sayed, who's a really radical candidate. I think the the tipping point for many Jews, especially especially in Michigan, actually, was several months ago when an American citizen rammed a pickup truck into Temple Israel, a synagogue and preschool. And if he hadn't gotten jammed, could have killed a hundred kids. Okay. And so I think that After that happened, Abdullah Sayyed made a video, which I watched several times because I wanted to make sure I was being nuanced enough about it. But he said, hurt people, hurt people, because this man had family members who were killed in the Middle East. I'm sorry, but that's like the perpetuation of the cycle of violence, saying hurt people, hurt people. He said it like four times in the video in response to this attack. So and this Eitan: Yeah, we he Shanie: is like a full legitimization. No, even if you say, I'm so sad, I'm so sad, I'm so sad, but you continue to repeat that over and over. I could take that. We're the Jews. We could say hurt people, hurt people to justify anything forever. That's not how you end the cycle of violence. So I think it's reasonable that people, that the pro-Israel community said, We can't let this guy, we can't let this guy into office. We have to do everything in our power, which means mobilizing political capital to get him out. You're right that it failed. And you are right that there are a lot of other strategic choices in in the APAC camp particular that have led to the toxicity. but I do wanna say it's reasonable for them to say we need to get involved in this race. If there were ever a race to get involved with, it's not crazy to get involved with this one. Eitan: Totally. But also they should recognize that by them getting involved, it's like a net negative. And like I know that they spent and they gave like Haley Stevens a ton of money. And once again, it was like close, close only like I think two or three points. But if the money is not being used, then someone there needs to be some group or some adult in the room has to stand up and say, we cannot get involved because we are not helping the situation. And the problem is that everything you said is right. The fact that he said hurt people, hurt people about that, and it wasn't an immediately disqualifying thing is crazy. The fact that Graham Platner Had a Nazi tattoo is crazy. There's a million, the fact that what's her name in Denver, that monster in Denver who refused to say that firebombing the protest, not the the rally for hostages, you know, that's a problem. These are all like big problems. But if the way the strategy that we're going about it is not working, and saying Israel, Israel, Israel, Israel, and bringing Israel up all the time and and you know, just not being very specific, even bringing up anti-Semitism. If that's not working, then don't bring it up. I think that we just have to be way smarter about the ways that we attack these people. And I really hope that this is kind of the first the fact that it was a Republican in a very high profile election against a big, strong anti, you know, anti-Z Israel person. I'm not gonna say anti-Zionist because who knows what that means here. The guy that doesn't like Israel, that has weird opinions on Jews, and the fact that this guy is going out there and saying APAC, I don't want your money is a major, major turn in kind of like the political system out here. And I will say, a pretty good segue, it does show how. After a while, Israel is really, really, really starting to affect how these primaries and elections are playing out in a way that hasn't happened before, which is a great segue into my favorite segment, the listener mailbag. Okay, you know, we'll get an AI to do this. All right, Gotti, a couple of questions that I wanna sorry, Gotti, Sean Shane, a couple of questions that I wanna run. for you and then we will get into our interview. The first one I want to give a shout out to Yenti Fisher. Think BB finds new reasons to bomb Syria, Gaza, et cetera, cause it helps him get votes slash c cancels elections. Shanie: I think canceling an election is really strong. I think it'll take a lot to cancel an election. I'm hopeful that they're not gonna cancel an election. But if you do have some kind of war, I mean there are 30,000 Israelis abroad who are planning to come to Israel to vote, which is a separate question as well. There could be up to 70,000 who are eligible who come back to vote. so obviously if there are no flights, what'd you say? There is, Eitan: Isn't there an issue? There's an issue now. Isn't there a problem? Shanie: yeah, yeah, there is an issue with votes getting canceled. the head of the transportation ministry, Miri Regev, who's from the Likud Party. There were there was there was a lot of reporting released about her having conversations about maybe we should limit the flight. It's like, why do we need to let these people come back to Israel to vote? which is obviously anti-democratic. they that you know, then they put out statements saying, of course you would never do that. Meanwhile, I've spoken to several Israelis yesterday about how who whose flights were canceled to come back to vote. So it we're seeing it happen right now. Remember that a a lot of non-Israeli airlines are still not flying, and so th It's it's really in the hands of the Israeli transportation ministry whether or not there are going to be flights coming in. So it's it's a big problem. So that's part one, which is unrelated to war. Yeah. Eitan: By the way, I don't know if you heard this, by the way, that JFK is getting Israel. I don't know if I don't know if you Yeah, one yeah, which is gonna really Is Shanie: Really? I don't even know what Israel is, but Eitan: Israel let me just say that Israel coming to America is gonna really be bad for anti Semitism. I'm just saying that is a that is not a good flying theory. Anyway Shanie: I'd be scared. I'd be scared to f I'd be scared to fly. sounds like a target. I'll stick to. so w whatever prices. and then in terms of this this other question of war, if there's if there's a war, even if you continue to have your polling you if your polling stations open, I don't know if you have to if there's a way you can extend it by several days because you'll have people in the north and the south who are not gonna be able to vote. They're gonna be in shelter. and so that that is a possibility. I'm again, I am not. saying that's going to happen. I've heard no inkling that will happen. I really hope it doesn't happen. It doesn't mean it can't. Of course it can anything can always happen in this situation. And it wouldn't be it wouldn't be out of the realm of possibility, but I'm optimistic that it won't, but we'll we'll see. In general, Netanyahu is known for pulling tricks up his sleeve to win elections like two, three days before. So it's not out of the realm possibility that this would be the thing he does to to to win and push him over the edge. I don't know. Eitan: Small question on that. You know, over the one of the news stories that happened kind of in the background was about how Lee could primaries were happening like a week ago, I think, maybe a week and a half ago at this point. Shanie: Mm. Eitan: And there was a conversation about if war would postponed the primaries, and Lee could voted to have it not like say no. They're like the war will Shanie: Mm. Eitan: not, and that was against something that like Bibi had proposed. So it does seem like if he wasn't able to do it in Lee Could, is there any glimmer of hope that that would kind of carry over to like the generals to kind of assuage people's Shanie: Netanyahu has publicly said he's not gonna allow war to to delay or cancel elections. I don't doesn't mean that he won't, but that's what he has said. So that which is the the hopeful piece. Eitan: Yeah, he said that about his son's engagement and you know that kept on anyways. I moving right along. this next question we are gonna bring in our guest Shauna, who now gets taken off of the non-speaking role of this Shanie: Ha ha Eitan: has a question from A green B music. What is the role looking like for Arab parties? Are they at all consequential in a coalition? Shauna. Shini. Okay. Yeah. Shanie: No, no, no, hold on. I need to introduce Shauna first. Shauna, my God. Shauna Orlich is a very close dear friend of mine who who blessedly agreed to be on this podcast, despite Atown's shenanigans. Shauna is a hola, Eitan: Name for the Shanie: an Ola to Israel over a decade ago, from France. So she's French Israeli political organizer. She's been working very closely with Ya'ir Golan for many years. She is the ran his grassroots movement, Hitora Root, for years, which did a lot of incredible work. especially in the periphery communities, which she can talk about as well. has been a senior political advisor to him, is an elected member of the Democrat team party. we are bringing her in to talk about for on one hand, the of course she will talk about the the left in Israel and and what that means and what that looks like, because that's the party that she's from, but also a lot of grassroots movement building. A ton's been annoying me for the the past like six months about what does grassroots organizing look like in Israel? Is there door knocking? Is there Canvassing, is there phone banking? Like, what does it even mean to run a political campaign in Israel? So that's what Shauna's gonna talk about mostly. but in this question of the Arab parties, I think there's a big distinction between the like what are the Arab parties? There are a bunch of Arab parties, and there is one that is sort of sits apart from the rest, which is Ram Party, historically an Islamist party run by Mansoor Abbas. And he is someone who has positioned himself to be much more pragmatic and much more able to sit in a coalition, in a Zionist coalition. Even though he is not coming from a Zionist party himself, but he has been on the record saying he understands Israel as a Jewish state, Jewish and democratic state. he he has come out as as pretty moderate. I would say there are a lot of forces on the right, and in even in the mainstream in Israel that try to position him as this crazy anti-Israel anti-Zionist. He's not. there I think there's some there's some credibility to some of the concerns, but again, he needs to, just as everyone else needs to speak out of both sides of their mouths to different communities, he's doing the same. and so I I but I know that Shana, your the last government worked with him because he was the first Arab, he was the head of the first Arab Party to actually sit in an Israeli government in the last government which you were in when you had the Bennett Lapide government with your with like merits and not merits with with Labor Party and all of the sort of left wing merger I don't remember what we call the change government. Sorry, change government. and that was like a big milestone. Eitan: And it really just was missing sunflower seeds in the middle. It looked like yeah, just looked like a bunch of grandpa's getting to get together on the street. Yeah, way snacks. Enough pets. Shanie: Yeah, they need better snacks. so we'll we'll work on that. but I think there's I think there's a lot to say about like what the role is of the IR Party. So Shauna, I'll turn it over to you to answer this one. Shanna Orlik: Hi. It's been Shanie: Welcome. Shanna Orlik: great to be listening. It's been, yeah, I'm very excited to be here with you. interesting to start with this question. I think it's basically what is the like most important topic about those elections. And I think everyone understands this. And each party is trying to understand. Jewish and Arab parties are really trying to understand what's the strategy around this. And so right now it's so like I agree with you, Shani, that really we have basically we traditionally have four Arab parties, which like the main question is always are gonna are they gonna run together or not? And then this time we have also the standing together party, which is also like this Jewish Arab party that is like kind of like strategically targeting what Arab women, from what I understand, but they're also like under the threshold, so it's not clear what they're gonna be doing. we're getting closer also to the moment where parties have to like basically declare the lists and basically give it to the Knesset. So then we finally will know which parties are just like proxies of someone, which parties are actually running, which party are like uniting. So for the Arab list, a few days ago they Basically, the three parties that are running together have announced that they will be running together without Ram, which without Mansoul Abbas, and they haven't said anything about the standing together party. So we're kind of on the same like situation where we don't really know where it's heading. I will say that the partnership, because I think it is a true courageous partnership that we had in the change government. Is something very unique. We also had in Meretz, we had Isawi Frej, who was the second minister, Arab minister in the history of Israel. He was in charge of regional cooperation. and then we have been working. So I was the advisor to Yer Golan in the Ministry of Economics, and I was in charge of the policy to basically advance equality in the industry and workplace. And employment for Arab society. And it's been very interesting working with him and with his team. Because I think where maybe in the past they have been like questions about where, you know, where does he stand? And but then we saw just like the reality of it. And the reality of it is that it's a lot of like fake news, everything that's been said, that he says different things in Arabic and all of this. This might have happened, but like. You know, I'm French Israeli. I said different things when I'm talking to you in English than when I will say the same thing in French, just not because I'm trying to like change the content, just because it's like a different Eitan: Guys are mean. No, I'm joking. I will say a friend Shanna Orlik: Cool. Shanie: Shauna's so nice in English. I would be scared to hear what she's like in French. Shanna Orlik: Definitely not that nice. Eitan: of mine is a comic, you know, whenever I go to Tel Aviv I perform out there, and my f one of my favorite jokes is that the French in Israel are the only ones that experience anti-Semitism. Shanna Orlik: I mean Yeah. I have other jokes about anti Semitism in Americans, but I'm not gonna go there. I feel I feel like that's not the platform. Eitan: listen. yeah. Shanie: Six only talk about that in French. Eitan: Yeah. Shanna Orlik: anyways, so I think I'm very privileged to have worked with Mansoul Abbas and really seen you know, it's also like a religious, like Islamic list, but on the on the one hand, but on the other hand, he has like women on his list, right? Like religious women, which is not the case Shanie: Mm. Shanna Orlik: in like the equivalent, you know, religious lists from the ultra-orthodox that we have, or like even Iqud, which has only one. woman in the 21st seats right now from the primaries. So yeah. And Netanyahu Shanie: Really? I didn't realize. I thought they had several women. Wow. Shanna Orlik: is gonna like put you know people on the list in his like eight privileged seats. Shanie: Right. Shanna Orlik: but from primaries, she's the only one in 20 seats. so Eitan: I mean standing can standing together can now really poach those votes. You know, that's Shanie: Yeah. Shanna Orlik: Yes. Eitan: similar, you know, all the all the feminists, you know. Shanna Orlik: Well we're it's an interesting, yeah, situation. So actually both Yeah. Eitan: Standing sorry, let me just can we give a quick at home on Standing Together? Because Standing Together is a ultra, ultra, ultra left lefty. They do they're that kind of like like pita in America where they throw blood on themselves outside of places. They're very vocal with their protests. Not saying good or bad or whatever, because you know his arguments on the other side on this, but like their whole thing is that they're the very the loudest. they are against the government and against the war and are, you know, very, very ultra lefty, but also very not per I don't want to say performative 'cause I think that diminishes it, but they're very into big acting. Yeah. Shanie: They're activists. They're act they're activists more than like policy political folks, I think is the best way Eitan: Yes. Shanie: to describe it. Shanna Orlik: So I will say just not to put them in a difficult situation because of Israeli law that separates grassroots and civil society from parties that they're not running as a non profit. Shanie: Mm. Shanna Orlik: standing together is running and people growing in this movement and leading this movement have decided to leave momentarily the movement and basically create this party. Yeah, yeah. I mean I hope for them. I feel like I I trust Shanie: Yes. It's all legal, don't worry, it's all legal. Eitan: Man. It's very legal. It's never been more legal. Shanna Orlik: No, I mean, I don't know. I trust Bibi that if it wasn't, we would know about it. That's my that's my point. and Eitan: Yeah. I trust B B is what I heard there. Anyways, continue. Shanie: Yeah. Yes, true. Shanna Orlik: so so yeah, they are much more in their like essence. I think they're also like very like they're like if you see what's happening when they go somewhere in like air vis villages, they're like superstars. Like people love them. They've been like promoting coexistence and really like this like very clear narrative. That doesn't exist today in Israeli society, that is not, you know, pro-Palestinian, not Zionist, but just like a one, let's be together, let's coexist together, let's end wars. And it's like a very and also doing some kind of like yeah, affordable, like things about affordability and like trying to get young people more active in politics. So I think they're like really doing interesting work in terms of like grassroots. And now in this party, they promised that they wouldn't like. waste votes, they say, according to their polling, that they're about two and a half seats right now. And the threshold threshold is at four, more or less, because everything's proportionate obviously, but so they're Eitan: People are annoyed with them on the left because there's a chance that if they vote for standing together, they're not gonna vote for a party that could hit the threshold. Is the that's the conversation right now but Shanie: Yeah. Yes. Eitan: yeah. Shanie: But their claim is that they are bringing people to vote, especially Arab citizens of Israel who would not be voting otherwise, which if that's true, is overall a positive thing for the bloc, I would say. Although I'm not sure where they will fit into a possible opposition bloc, but I still think like bring greater ver voter turnout is a good thing overall. so if that's true, then it's positive. Shanna Orlik: I think it's it's I do think it's true. I don't think they would lie about it. And we we don't see, you know, like when Isencott is taking seats from somewhere, you see it. It doesn't change the whole dynamic. Here you see new seats coming in. the real question I think is what's gonna happen when they actually have to save their running, because probably they won't be able to run. Shanie: Mm-hmm. Shanna Orlik: they will decide not to run, just not to throw all those votes, you know, to the Shanie: Mm. Shanna Orlik: Trash and so far they are not saying who they're gonna support and they're not joining any list like the Arab three parties don't want them, from what I understand, because they've been trying very intensively to join the United List. but I don't. Shanie: I was surprised. I Why don't they like join Kadash or one of the like lefty parties or something? Shanna Orlik: Well, I think they don't want to unite. I think I mean yeah. Shanie: Okay. that'll be interesting. and then in terms of how, in terms of how things are looking with with Mansurabas in general, right? You have this ambiguity, I would say, from a lot of the Zionist or Jewish political parties saying we are not going to join with the Arab parties, but the w they don't explicitly say it. Sometimes they say, you know, we're only gonna work with parties who support XYZ statements, and those statements are Zionist. But What about your party? What about the Democrats? What do they say that's 'cause I hear them speaking a very different language around Monsour Abbas and the Rom Party. Shanna Orlik: yeah, so it is very different, I think, and it's actually a bit disappointing if I have to be honest, the fact that this is the level of yeah, of public discourse, but also just playing into Netanyahu's, you know, game like completely blindly. We're just like playing his game, we're doing what he wants, and I mean I'm not saying we because we're not the ones Shanie: Yeah. Shanna Orlik: playing this game, but basically Netanyahu was the first one. We know it, and you've said this in previous episodes, that Netanyu been wanting one thing and one thing only to stay in power. And he's ready to do anything. He's brilliant politician. I think we can all agree. so he's the first one saying, like, hey, I'm not gonna have 61, let's go to the Arabs. Who are like who can I talk to Shanie: Mm. Shanna Orlik: with the Arabs? None of the three parties, but the Ram who really wants to promote equal and services for their You know, constituency, those people can like, you know, be like the Khanadim. I give them some something Shanie: Mm. Shanna Orlik: and they support me, and that's it. and so he's been the one trying Shanie: Exactly. Shanna Orlik: to get them on board, which I think kind of legitimated the whole thing. And then we formed the government with them. And what happens now is that specifically Lieberman, Bennett, and Isencott are just like saying, like, hey. We're gonna play into this narrative of Phoebe of like, we promise we're gonna be only in a Zionist coalition, right? Which I agree. It does, it's not very clear what a Zionist coalition means. I think what I would say, if I can be not PC for a moment, I think it just sounds like, hey, let's do a coalition without Arabs. which we believe is not a very democratic thing to say and to believe. So that's why we're not saying this. We're saying the Zionist thing to do is actually to give security to all citizens of Israel and to take responsibility in protecting our democratic rights. And that means just going to elections, seeing the results and you know playing the game. Like have each party like advice and support one candidate and have this candidate be elected to be the prime minister. So I think that's a very you're right that in the last couple of weeks I don't hear Isencott Bennett And Lieberman really much talk about this, but I think it was part of the discourse. And then you have, I think, an interesting, we'll maybe talk about it later, but we have another discourse, which is those like little right-wing, small parties where everyone was in Likud a few weeks or a few months ago, suddenly they're creating new parties, and it's definitely not proxies of Netanyahu. So those parties basically are. Turning the narrative even more right, because that's not enough to say, like, hey, let's not sit with the Arabs. What they're doing is even smarter, I think, in their strategy, is saying, hey, let's not build a coalition with extremists who are extremists, the Arabs and Yir Golan. And so then it shifts to even more delegitimization of Eitan: The concept of like so you're saying that like B B is that a is that a strategy on B B side to have his formerly could party people go out there and create new parties? Is that like a strategy from him or is Shanna Orlik: What I that's what I say. I Eitan: Is that it but Shanie: That's Shauna's a political assessment. It's not like on the record, but it's a I think it's a very fair political assessment. Shanna Orlik: And I think he's done this in the past, so it's not like the crazy Eitan: So what's the strategy there? And 'cause is then you're poaching votes from your own different Shanie: They're gonna they are poaching gonna poach seats from from Bennett Lapide Isencot, I think. I Eitan: Okay, got it. Shanie: think it's pretty clear that they're they have the ability to do that. because because one of the issues a lot of Likud voters have with Netanyahu is that he has enabled draft evasion. And so this is their making their core issue and saying we're not gonna enable people to avoid the draft, the ultra-orthodox to avoid the draft. and I think Eitan: Interesting. Shanie: that and that's like a core issue that he's been the one of the reasons he might lose people to Isencot is because of exactly that. 'Cause Isengott says, I'm not gonna allow that. So now you have people who are just as right wing as him, but they're saying we're not gonna allow the ultra Orthodox not to serve or we're gonna deal with this problem somehow. That's gonna help him keep people. that's what I don't know, Sean, Eitan: And are these Shanie: if you have what to add, but Eitan: it's like the Diet Coke. This is like Diet B B. You know, it's Yeah. B one. Yeah. Shanie: That's a great that's a great examp assessment. I I w Shanna Orlik: It's definitely diet enough, but yeah. Shanie: I wanna I wanna ask you a little bit more about this, Shauna, because this extremism notion, because yeah, Yirgolan, he is he was a deputy chief of staff of the IDF. He's a a general, a reservist general in the IDF. On October 7th, he was a a 61-year-old retired general who put on his old uniform, grabbed a personal weapon, drove his car into active combat zones on October 7th when the state and the IDF was nowhere to be found. And he went and he saved people back. He went back again and again and saved people, which is like a really amazing heroic story. And I know was like a lot of your inspiration for your work with him as well. he has been people are promoting him as people on the right are promoting him as an extremist. And he actually made a really, I thought, very well done video of his party list saying, like, I'm so extreme that I believe in democracy. But you know, I'm not extreme. You who's really extreme? Nah Malazimi, who's incredible. And then she goes, You think I'm extreme? What about this guy? But then they name all of the like really incredible values that I I think they stand for and policies they stand for. So he they've been playing on that really strategically. But there is this perception that Yergolan is extreme. I think part of it stems from he does suffer from foot and mouth syndrome on occasion, and he does tend to say he's not like so politically savvy always, and over the years has said things sort of that really alienated some of the Israeli public comments, alluding to comments about soldiers that were, you know, didn't sit didn't sit well, didn't land well, things like that. but I don't, I don't we don't need to bring all of that in. But like today, I'm curious, like how dominant is this perception of Yeah, your Golan as being extreme and like what what do you say about that? What do you think about Shanna Orlik: okay. I'll say a few things. First of all, I'll say that this is really scary. Cause you can agree and disagree, but there is a very clear targeting and incitement against not only Yeir Golan but everyone who supports him. And before he decided to run with and build a Democrat, it was very clear that it was again Kaplan, like the like protest movement, and before that it was against the left. And so I want to mention just like, you know, the most like basic let's say book about how to define what you know, how do you do you know that a a society has turned fascist? And Umberto Echo just like gives us like 14 points. And one of the first points is basically saying that you turn like the most like democratic and like, you know. the the like the most opposition forces like the the like the strongest opposition forces into yeah the enemy and I think that's Shanie: Mm. Shanna Orlik: really what we're seeing. I think yeah he has said things that were not very PC, but they have also been taken in out of context. And I can say about Shanie: I agree. Shanna Orlik: some of the interviews he's run, I was next to him where I was like listening And I just like called him with the last one, being like, this was such a great interview. And then we just like discover how it's been like taken out of context. And yeah, it might not be like the most like, but I think a lot of people, and that's also what people love about Gaddy Eisencott. I think those like army generals are just giving Israelis a sense of like, you know, yeah, a change from Netanyahu and his people who's like Build their entire lives around these political careers and strategy and everything so disconnected from people's reality because it's all about interest and politics. And I think about Yair and and I think Gaddi is also on the on the verge of getting his ton of of incitement against him. I think, made it his like life mission to protect Israel and to protect Israeli citizens. And I think he entered politics with this idea that this is the next stage for me to be able to kind of advance this policy. And for him, the one topic is very much what he calls the separation between Israelis and Palestinian, which is leading to a Palestinian state. We'll talk about this. He also agrees with you, Shani, I think. That the term Palestinian state is definitely not something that is gonna make us get to this reality. And therefore, Yay Golan and our party has been like, we've been thinking of how to convince the Israeli public. And where you spoke earlier about Ghadiaizenkhod and what he mentioned about the Palestinian state, I I do think that this is a very unique trait about Yahir, that whether it is something that is gonna be creating this like crazy amount of noise. he does stand by what he believes, and he believes that there will be no security for Israelis and Palestinian, and the only way for Israel to stay a Jewish and democratic state is to separate from the Palestinian, to have our own independence from them, and to be able to apply the laws of defense and also attack when it's necessary against our enemies, whether they're further away or very much in the Palestinian territories. That's why he was opposed. To what led to the to the 7 of October, of like this government basically bringing like paying, like taking money from Qatar to bring into Hamas to weaken the Palestinian Authority in the purpose of you know, getting Ben Gvir and Smotlich and all the settler movement very much on board with him and getting basically the only allies that he could get to form a coalition. So by, you know, Bibi has been on trial, which He's been very corrupted, he's been doing things that people don't really agree. And so in the last few years to stay in power, he has to have like he has to find new allies. And so he's been going from like this more like central right government to a right wing government, to sitting with the Khalidim, to sitting with the Khanist movements, which he said himself he would never sit with. and those people's interest is to not have a Palestinian state ever. but on the other hand, Bibi did sign the Trump plan, which does say actually, black on white, that there will be a Palestinian state. And that's why I don't understand why, you know, the discourse is still the same when Bibi actually signed this thing and Isencott, who's probably gonna be our next Prime Minister, will have to stand by it. Eitan: Let me just say I'm yeah. Shanie: Mm-hmm. I I I need to add that I think more than more than saying like the Kahanist parties and Smutrich and Ben Gvir want to prevent a Palestinian state, they want to deep more deeply entangle the 50% of Palestinians and 50% of Israelis between the river and the sea, and they want to intertwine them so much that they can never be be separated again. and I think that that's like a very important distinction for me, that they want to have annexations so that you have this like ongoing terrible situation and conflict that we are never able to extricate from. Shanna Orlik: But it's also a danger for the Jewish state as a Jewish state. And I think that's where it's like really crazy in my mind that this coalition is trying to convince Israelis and Jews around the world that this is the most Zionist and the most Jewish coalition, because they're actually doing the opposite while disconnecting the diaspora from Israel on the one hand, while disconnecting obviously international community from us, but specifically by like promoting on the ground the annexation of pal of Palestinians and Palestinian territories into Israel. And so pushing us to a place where there will be an equal number of Palestinians and Jews in this country. And so if you enact like annex the Palestinian territories, then you don't have a Jewish state anymore. Or you don't give citizenship to this people because you do want a Jewish majority, but then you are de facto in an apartheid state, which is not a democratic state. So this government is pushing us by his policy to either being, you know, a democracy that is not Jewish or a Jewish state that is not a democracy anymore. Eitan: walk me through, like we had mentioned at the beginning of this episode. I've got a bunch of questions about grassroots movements and what it's like to kind of get a party up and running. The Democrats are the gr Democrat team. You what's funny is that in America the Democrats, the Democrat I it feels weird when I say Democratum, but like your your party's new. I have worked in in door knocking and I've worked for I actually worked for Mike Bloomberg years and years and years ago on his and on his illegal third run, I was door knocking in Saturn Island. and I will say one actually crazy thing that happened while I was door knocking is that I was knocking on someone's door, a guy came out two in the afternoon, blitzed, drunk, holding a beer, and I was like talking to him about Mike Bloomberg. He was like, I Mike Bloomberg, I love him, I love him. And then I was like, great, great, great. Is your wife home? They want us talk to your wife and everyone else at his residence. And then he gets beat red and just turns around and goes, I don't know, because everything's a mystery with this woman. Like right in front of it. It was it was wild. But, anyways, when you start a political campaign, you gotta get let people know. You gotta walk around, you gotta do signatures. When I was in Tel Aviv for the summer, to be honest, it was the only group of people I saw tabling anywhere. a bunch of those blue t-shirts were out in the different city centers. Walk me through what grassroots organizing is like in Israel. Shanna Orlik: So I have to say we get our inspiration from you guys. So it's not gonna be like very new to you. I think we've been like working a lot on professionalizing what we do and really trying to like understand what works for Israeli public. So I will talk about our strategy. We do basically a little bit of everything you know, right? From like canvassing to phone bang, from door to door. The door to door is specifically run by like our young Democrats. So that's like really interesting. They go and we're doing it mostly in like big cities. they're having like really cool reactions from people and people get really like because it's not a normal thing in Israel, right? I have to say that usually when you knock like the concept of like someone knocked on my door in Israel means like the the say the s saying means like an army person is coming to tell you that your son or daughter has died in the war. Okay, so that's a very sorry for like making it like a very heavy moment. Eitan: No, no, no. That's that's an interesting one. Shanna Orlik: So the concept of having someone knock on your door is something pretty traumatizing for Israelis. so we've been like really, really, really careful with this. We actually don't go with the data that we have, we don't go to knock on doors of people that have kids in the army at the moment. we don't go to knock on doors with people who are Miloemnic, like reserve people, so that they don't have this like scare that would be horrifying. so we actually Do a lot of this and we've seen like really nice reactions because it is new to people and it's exciting. We have like what we call duchanim. So we have stands and booth like all over the country. We go on the weekend also. We have this like there is this cafe in Jerusalem in the city center where basically it is open on Shabbat and a lot of Kharidim are going and like kind of like screaming and trying to like now in the last couple of weeks actually be kind of violent towards the people drinking coffee and buying coffee on Shabbat and the police has been coming. And so all of our Paile volunteers are actually going there and supporting like the Israelis that just want to have coffee and we're like coming there, you know, with these like flyers about separation of religion and state and how it would look like to be a Jewish state and also offer freedom of religion to everyone. We have phone banks. It's definitely a really cool thing. We actually have, I'm in the office right now, we have this like huge screen with like live discussions, like phone bank discussions, where like you can see like the name of like each person and there is a competition between like each like neighborhood or region team and who's the one, like who which team is the most efficient. And like we're doing a lot of social listening also, trying to understand what are the pain points for people. Like how can we really represent them and we adapt our program yeah Eitan: You know, I while I was in Israel for the summer, the big difference I see between you guys and like the Bennett committee. I don't see any advertisements from Gaudi. Like that, I I don't think he has much, unless you're in Cyprus, apparently. That's the only place that he does advertisements, which is genius because that's where the Israelis are vacation. You know, you're going, you're driving on the highway in Tel Aviv and you look up and the two kinds of s you see three signs. You see my friend Matan Peretz, who's a comic, you see him holding up a credit card. And then you Danny Abdia sitting in an L seat. And then you see Naftali Bennett hugging people, you know, in black and white photos. That to me is like very established on like huge, big, you know, big billboards, big advertising you know, big whatever. Then you guys are kind of t-shirts, walking around, you know, signing people up a little bit more, like you said, like grassroots-y. How do you s separate yourselves or how do you kind of, if he's you know more buttoned up and more like look at me, I'm professional. You know, I have this thing. How do you get people to look at you guys and and trust you guys versus looking at you guys and saying like, there's bunch of young kids on a street, you know, they're the ones that are walk, they're the ones that harassed me at not harassed, you know, but they're ones that are bothering me as I'm walking out of an AMPM or something like that. How do you kind of distill to people that they can trust you, even though you are a newer entity? Shanna Orlik: I think we are a new party, but we're the union of two historical parties. And we have had this like crazy moment of one hundred and twenty thousand members signing up to be able to vote in the primaries, which was a very big high in our party, but also in hi Israel history, I think. when you look at Likud, Likud had their primary like like you said ten days ago. And they had 140,000 members and only I think 90,000 vote voted or less. So we're literally the biggest party in terms of like a democratic party. We're also the only one on our block running primaries and not having someone decide who's gonna lead the party and who's gonna be on the list of the party, which I think when democracy is at you know at risk, people do appreciate that very much. I think also we've been For the last four years, whether against the judicial overhaul or to free the hostages and end the war, we've been the one like Israelis like have been on the street. And I think they see us as their representative who's gonna who are gonna do this again. And whereas they may see, you know, Bennett and Isencot and Lapid as like people that are gonna be like, you know, maybe like professional and they have been in the Knesset or they have been in high tech or whatever, I think. People on their list are not people that Israelis know. And people on our list not only have been elected with like tens of thousands of votes, but they're like actually superstars of the protest movement, of going in the kibbutzim and you know, volunteering for months on and months on, of being next to the families of hostages, of like really fighting next to the people. And I think this is what we Define as grassroots. Basically, we're coming from the bottom up. And I think that's definitely something that seemed to convince people that they can trust us. There nobody's like new. People are either like former elected on the list of labor of Merit, or just like people that they've been seeing in the streets and on social media and TV for the last four years fighting with them. And I think that's our strength. And I'm really, really proud of our list. Which is very diverse. It has, you know, Ashkenazi and Mizrachi in north and south, and you know, people from high tech and people from social civil society and lawyers and activists and whatnot. So I think it's and security people, obviously. So I think it's a very diverse list and it's definitely our strength. And now we yeah, we need to continue. Eitan: I got another question, about your work in the periphery with B B supporters. just explain to me what is like engaging you know, that universe. And just for people at home, the big cities, you know, Jerusalem, Tel Aviv in the center, the concept periphery are the ones kind of like out that are a little bit more towny. I don't know how to describe it. It's you know, there's a difference between Des Moines, Iowa and and and New York is what I would say. Shanna Orlik: Yeah. Yeah, Israel is very small. and I feel like we have two kinds of what we call periphery. We have definitely like the outskirt of the country and that have definitely their issues with infrastructure and the job market and getting, you know, like culture and whatever, access to like yeah, to to to culture and and the social periphery, which you can be living very much close to Tel Aviv, but or in Jerusalem. Jerusalem is one of the poorest cities in the countries in the country. I'm in charge of this like periphery thing in the party. So we've been lucky to be working really building together with the people. So if you look at our members, you know, you you have this like maybe vision of people that think of the left maybe like five, ten years ago, which is very elite, very Tel Aviv. And I thought it was a really bad when this was the case. And I honestly believe this was the case. but I think we're doing something very different and it's very exciting. First of all, we've been with Yeer Golan before the creation of the party. Since October 7th, we've been, you know, in the north and in the south, like basically bringing volunteers and helping out and learning also. It's not just about helping, it's about learning what are the issues, how to tackle them, how to best represent those people. And I'm not gonna say that everyone who's voted for Bibi their entire life are just gonna switch and vote for Yeer Golan, but I do think that they've been like meeting people and we've been meeting people that Israelis don't meet, you know, it might be a very small country, but like people who've been like, you know, in the periphery period, people in the center, people that are like leftists and people that are BB and whatever, like people don't meet. And I think October 7th kind of like sadly allowed us to have these like meetings for the first time in decades and really see what we have in common and understand that we can find what we have in common. And I think that is, in my opinion, really much the Zionist thing to do. Which is to look at policies in a way that they're gonna serve all people, not necessarily based on their identity or where they live, but really train to think of like what's the best society we can have and what's sustainable for us. and we've been doing this, like we basically have work groups on every single topic you can think of. we have like the most intense and it extensive program, I think, that you can imagine. So yeah. Eitan: I got I got a question. What what are the top you know, when working with the periphery voters, what are the top three issues that are kind of hitting like someone in Tel Aviv or Jerusalem in one of those city centers versus what are like the top three issues that are hitting the periphery that the people in the bigger cities don't really care about or don't even think about? Shanna Orlik: So I think something that is like for all Israelis, but it's very much felt in the periphery is the cost of living. I think that's very clear. You might think that, Tel Avis is expensive, but it's not actually the case. Like it's the same prices everywhere, except for beyond beyond the green line and in ultra orthodox where they get like special discounts on a lot of things. But all of us, whether in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, the north, the south, we don't get this kind of discounts and like help from the government. And so You might work in Tel Aviv and get a salue from Tel Aviv, but then you might also work in Ofakim or in Afula and get the same prices as Tel Aviv, basically, which is insane. So I think this like kind of cost of living and education, the level of education is terrible in the periphery. It's bad all over Israel, but definitely the the level of school, the school system is really poor in the periphery. And I think the third thing would be infrastructure and access to like healthcare. you have very few hospitals and access to healthcare, which in Israel, you know, is mostly free. but then when you don't have hack like access to it, then it just basically doesn't exist. And the infrastructures, there are places in Israel where you don't have access to like you don't have a network, you don't have internet, things that you wouldn't believe, you know, when you're in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem or Khaifa. But then you get out, and then obviously the employment, which is you always hear about s the startup nation, but very much like when you get out of like those big hubs, then you see that there are very few options for high level employment and that has a impact direct impact on people's lives in you know, and their cost of living and their reality. Eitan: Yes. I got one kind of last question here. frequently, you know, a conversation that is brought up is about the left in Israel being dead. And I'm just curious what would be your answer to that. Because people, you know, when they talk about and once again, this is the Americans that are talking, I'm sure that the Israelis also have very similar, you know, opinionated views on this stuff. But like when you're talking about this in America, the concept is is like okay, like the left is after October seventh, everyone shifted right, which I think is accurate or fair. It's just a question of like how far right did they shift and if the you know if they if they shifted what is the concept of a left mean compared to everyone else. So when you hear someone say that the left is dead in Israel, what is your response to that? Shanna Orlik: My response is asking what does sleft mean? Eitan: I would say anti-Arab would be kind of the the concept here. If the any policies that are going be made going forward would be towards making decisions that are more anti-Arab, keeping the West Bank in kind of chaos. Who knows what's gonna happen with Gaza and the future of Gaza being treated fairly? you know, those are there's you know those are kind of the issues that people think about here. So when you hear someone say that the left is dead in Israel, what do you what do you think of that? Shanna Orlik: I think that BB is brilliant. That's my first answer. I think also when you look at like what is called left or progressive in the world, then definitely you can compare this to Israel. But I think it's a good thing. Like I wouldn't want, you know, I see like what's going on in the US or in France, for example. I don't think we need this in Israel at all. so I don't necessarily see this idea of like the left is dead as like a problem. What I Reason why I don't see it as a problem because I in terms of like the essence of the values, of the policy, of the vision, this is not dead. It's actually growing. And I think that is becoming very clear when you hear after, and you are right that after October 7th, most of Israeli society has shifted like more to the right, but I don't think it's a shift to the right in terms of like partisan politics. I think it's a it's it's just fear and trauma. And I do think that when you have those like components and it makes sense and we're on this ongoing war, you are you have difficulties like imagining that things can be different. And you know, like obviously we're not saying like, hey, let's make peace with like our best friends. Like those people are trying to kill us, and and most of them don't want us here. But I try to actually look at what we do know and not what is gonna potentially happen. What we do know is that we are at war with every single neighbor and every single person, like country that is beyond, except for two countries. Those two countries are Egypt and Jordan. Those two countries are the only ones that not only are not in a current war with us, they also helped protect themselves, protecting us against the missiles from Iran. And the reason for that is very simple. We have a peace agreement that simple. We have shared interests for security and for economics. And that is just, you know, one plus one equal two, in my opinion. That's the like, and those agreements were not necessarily made by r like lefties, right? Like we know that. But on the other hand, that's the reality. The reality is that peace brings security. And we're the only one today on the left being able to say this. And it's like basic facts, right? Like we don't want to live in a current war. And when I see the politics or the program that even the center. is proposing. They're proposing like they're offering the exact same thing as BB, or they're just not saying how they're gonna be different. so that's also just like more of the same, more of this insecurity. I don't see how we, if we don't take a clear shift, things are gonna change. And then strengthening of democracy, if that's left, then yala, let's be left. equality is just like you know, stated in the in the declaration of independence. I think it's a very, very basic thing to ask for. Israel to be a democratic state with full equality of rights and of duties, that's left and yeah, let's be left. We want a separation of religion and state, with a very clear Jewish state, but not nothing that will impose religious Judaism. We want pluralism of like yeah, like what we know in the diaspora of having different streams of Judaism. That's insane that as a Jew you can get married. As a reform or conservative Jew anywhere in the world except in Israel, that's insane. So yeah, if that's left, then great. And I'll end with like, you know, economy and social welfare. And if we want to make sure that we build Israel based on a true platform for Jews to feel safe and equal and grow and imagine their lives and the kids' lives and their grandkids' lives, then we need to offer. a true plan with health care and education and employment and everything that an you know like herzel said fet like a perfect society and we're never gonna be a perfect society but I think what we hop what we offer is actually getting us closer. Eitan: Nice. Shana, thank you so much for coming on to the episode. This has been another edition of the Jew York Times, 120 angry seats leading up to the Israel election happening on October twenty-seventh. make sure to like, subscribe, tell your friends, Venmo me personally. we do have a Patreon that I'm excited about. We finally set up. but all of all of that, you know, hit us up. Sean, thanks again for coming on, and Shanna Orlik: Thank you for having me. Eitan: we will see you guys. Next week, we end every episode by yelling the same thing. A shout out to my roommate, Richard Templeton. Barstool!