Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Artificial Intelligence
Transcript
- 0:02[♪♪]
- 0:09Good evening.
- 0:11Welcome to Kentucky Tonight.
- 0:12I'm Renee Shaw.
- 0:14Thanks for joining us.
- 0:16Our topic tonight: Artificial
- 0:17Intelligence.
- 0:20There are mixed opinions about
- 0:21it.
- 0:22Some people think it’s a
- 0:23breakthrough that will improve
- 0:24efficiency and make people’s
- 0:27lives better.
- 0:27Other people are worried it will
- 0:29take millions of jobs of all
- 0:31types, and even threaten human
- 0:32supremacy.
- 0:33To discuss all of this, we are
- 0:34joined in our Lexington studio,
- 0:35by:
- 0:37Trey Conatser of the University
- 0:39of Kentucky Center for the
- 0:40Enhancement of Teaching and
- 0:42Learning; State Representative
- 0:44Josh Bray, a Republican from
- 0:46Mount Vernon; and Donnie Piercey
- 0:47of the Google Earth Education
- 0:51Experts Network and the 2021
- 0:52Kentucky Teacher of the Year.
- 0:54And joining us by SKYPE: Roman
- 0:56Yampolskiy.
- 0:58University of Louisville
- 0:59Professor of Computer Science,
- 1:00Author, and A.I. Safety &
- 1:02Cybersecurity Researcher; and
- 1:04State Representative Nima
- 1:05Kulkarni, a Democrat from
- 1:07Louisville.
- 1:08We want to hear from you. So
- 1:09send us your questions by
- 1:12Twitter at K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T.
- 1:15Send an email to K-Y TONIGHT at
- 1:17K-E-T dot O-R-G. Or use the web
- 1:19form at K-E-T dot O-R-G slash
- 1:22K-Y TONIGHT. Or you can call
- 1:241-800-494-7605. Welcome to all
- 1:25of our guests.
- 1:32IT'S GOOD TO SEE EVERYONE.
- 1:33HOPE YOU HAD A GREAT HOLIDAY
- 1:35WEEK FOR THE FOURTH OF JULY.
- 1:37WE WERE OFF THEN BUT WE HOPE YOU
- 1:39ENJOYED YOUR TIME WITH YOUR
- 1:40FAMILIES AND CELEBRATING OUR
- 1:42NATION.
- 1:42THIS IS A COMPLICATED TOPIC, I
- 1:45THINK.
- 1:45REPRESENTATIVE BRAY THIS IS ONE
- 1:46OF THOSE THINGS I DON'T THINK I
- 1:48CAN READ ENOUGH ABOUT TO LEARN
- 1:50ABOUT.
- 1:50WE ARE GOING TO DEFER FIRST TO
- 1:53PROFESSOR TO GIVE US A PRIMER
- 1:55ABOUT WHAT AI IS, WHAT DOES IT
- 1:58ENCOMPASS AND WHERE IS IT RIGHT
- 2:01NOW?
- 2:02>> IT'S BEEN A DREAM.
- 2:03IT'S BEEN A DREAM FOR MANY
- 2:05YEARS.
- 2:05THE GOAL IS TO CREATE AN
- 2:08EQUIVALENT OF HUMAN POSSIBILITY,
- 2:11COGNITIVE AND MAYBE PHYSICAL
- 2:12THROUGH ROBOTICS.
- 2:14AUTOMATION OF LABOR, AUTOMATION
- 2:15OF SCIENCE, AUTOMATION OF ALL
- 2:19SORTS OF DIFFERENT CAPABILITIES.
- 2:22AND FOR MANY YEARS, IT DIDN'T
- 2:23WORK REALLY WELL.
- 2:25WE HAD NARROW SYSTEMS MAYBE THEY
- 2:27COULD PLAY CHESS AND NOTHING
- 2:29ELSE.
- 2:29OVER THE LAST SIX MONTHS MAYBE
- 2:31COUPLE YEARS, WE ACTUALLY
- 2:33STARTED TO SEE SYSTEMS WHICH ARE
- 2:35GENERAL.
- 2:35THEY CAN DO MANY THINGS.
- 2:37THEY CAN HELP YOU WITH YOUR
- 2:38HOMEWORK.
- 2:39THEY CAN WRITE POETRY THEY CAN
- 2:43TRANSLATE PROGRAMS.
- 2:44WE ARE STARTING TO SEE WHAT SOME
- 2:46PEOPLE THINK IS EARLY STAGES OF
- 2:49ARTIFICIAL GENERAL INTELLIGENCE.
- 2:51A SYSTEM AS CAPABLE AS A NORMAL
- 2:54PERSON AND MAYBE EVEN SMART
- 2:57PERSON.
- 2:58NEXT LEVEL WOULD BE USE OF THOSE
- 3:01TECHNIQUES FOR AUTOMATION OF
- 3:02RESEARCH.
- 3:03SCIENCE, ENGINEERING DEVELOP
- 3:05MORE ADVANCED AI AND THAT WOULD
- 3:07GET US TO SUPER INTELLIGENCE
- 3:09SYSTEMS SMARTER THAN ALL OF US.
- 3:10AND THAT IS WHERE THE REAL FUN
- 3:13BEGINS.
- 3:13>> Renee: I THINK THAT LAST PART
- 3:15PROFESSOR ABOUT SYSTEMS BEING
- 3:17SMARTER THAN ALL OF US GIVES
- 3:19MANY PEOPLE PAUSE.
- 3:19AND I WANT TO GO TO YOU DOCTOR
- 3:23TO ASK YOU ABOUT THAT.
- 3:26U.K. UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY FOR
- 3:26WHICH YOU WORK THEY ARE
- 3:27EMBRACING THIS.
- 3:28YOU HAVE A GROUP OR EFFORT THAT
- 3:31REALLY HELPS ORGANIZE AND
- 3:34COALESCE AROUND THIS IN A
- 3:35POSITIVE WAY.
- 3:36BUT WHEN YOU HEAR THERE COULD BE
- 3:39SYSTEMS THAT ARE SUPERIOR TO
- 3:41HUMANS, THAT GIVES A LOT OF
- 3:44PEOPLE HEARTBURN.
- 3:44>> THE IDEA WHAT WE'RE DOING AT
- 3:47THE UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY IS IN
- 3:49FACT ENGAGE THOSE KINDS OF HARD
- 3:51QUESTIONS DIRECTLY.
- 3:52AND LOOK AT WHAT'S EMERGED IN
- 3:54THE LAST SIX MONTHS AS A KIND OF
- 3:57OPPORTUNITY TO CONSIDER WHERE
- 3:58THE PLACE OF THE HUMAN STILL IS
- 4:00IN THIS WORLD WHERE THINGS HAVE
- 4:03BECOME AS THE PROFESSOR WAS
- 4:05SAYING, PERHAPS MORE AUTOMATED
- 4:07AND SOPHISTICATED AND HAVE LEAPT
- 4:10IN SOPHISTICATION THAN EVER
- 4:11BEFORE.
- 4:12>> Renee: RIGHT.
- 4:14SO THERE ARE HUMANS, THOUGH, WHO
- 4:15ARE CREATING THIS ARTIFICIAL
- 4:18INTELLIGENCE.
- 4:18WHY WOULD MAYBE IT'S NOT A GOAL,
- 4:20BUT WHY WOULD AN INADVERTENT
- 4:23GOAL OR BE TO HAVE THEM BE
- 4:26SUPERIOR TO HUMANS?
- 4:27IS THAT A GOAL?
- 4:28>> WELL, I THINK OUR GOAL IS TO
- 4:30THINK ABOUT HOW WE CAN LEVERAGE
- 4:32THIS TECHNOLOGY IN A WAY THAT
- 4:34ENHANCES SOME OF THE GOALS WE
- 4:35HAVE AS A UNIVERSITY AND OTHER
- 4:37INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION
- 4:38ARE DOING THE SAME THING IN
- 4:40TERMS OF PRIORITIZING THINGS
- 4:42LIKE STUDENT LEARNING, THE
- 4:43RESEARCH ENTERPRISE, THE SERVICE
- 4:45MISSION AND HEALTHCARE FOR
- 4:47EXAMPLE.
- 4:48SO THAT THE PLATFORMS THAT ARE
- 4:50AUTOMATING A LOT OF THESE REALLY
- 4:52SOPHISTICATED AND DIFFICULT
- 4:54THOUGHT PROCESSES FOR EXAMPLE
- 4:56LOOKING AT MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF
- 4:57DATA OR CONSIDERING LANGUAGE AT
- 4:59A SCALE THAT A HUMAN BRAIN CAN'T
- 5:02POSSIBLY COMPREHEND CAN AUGMENT
- 5:04AND HELP US THINK THROUGH THINGS
- 5:06THAT MAYBE WE COULDN'T DO
- 5:08BEFORE.
- 5:08>> Renee: I WANT TO GO BACK TO
- 5:09THE DOCTOR TO ASK ABOUT 60
- 5:11MINUTES THEY REBROADCAST ON CBS
- 5:14JUST LAST NIGHT THE SEGMENT WITH
- 5:16SCOTT PELLEY ABOUT AI AND THERE
- 5:18WAS A SEGMENT ABOUT ROBOTS WHO
- 5:20WERE PLAYING SOCCER.
- 5:22THESE MINIATURE ROBOTS.
- 5:24AND THEY HAD LEARNED STRATEGY.
- 5:28AND IN THE BEGINNING I THINK
- 5:29MANY OF US THOUGHT THAT THEY
- 5:32THIS TECHNOLOGY WAS SINGULAR IN
- 5:34NATURE THEY ARE GIVEN A SPECIFIC
- 5:36TASK AND THEY CAN'T GO BEYOND
- 5:37THAT.
- 5:38WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT THESE
- 5:40ROBOTS WERE ABLE TO DO ON THE
- 5:42SOCCER FIELD THEY WERE ACTUALLY
- 5:44ABLE TO CRITICALLY THINK ABOUT
- 5:46HOW TO BLOCK AND MAKE THE GOAL
- 5:47AND ALL OF THOSE THINGS.
- 5:49SO THAT'S WHERE WE ARE, RIGHT?
- 5:51>> NO, WE ARE WELL BEYOND THAT.
- 5:54SOCCER IS TRIVIAL IN TERMS OF
- 5:56STRATEGY.
- 5:57WHAT MAKES IT DIFFICULT IS THE
- 5:58PHYSICAL ASPECT OF ROBOTICS.
- 6:00IN TERMS OF STRATEGY WE HAVE AI
- 6:03WHICH OUTPERFORMS HUMANS IN
- 6:06GAMES OF STRATEGIES SUCH A GOAL.
- 6:08AND BETTER AT STRATEGY.
- 6:10ALSO IT WAS ABLE TO SOLVE
- 6:13DIFFICULT SCIENTIFIC PROBLEMS
- 6:15PROTEIN FOLDING.
- 6:18IN MANY DOMAINS IT'S SUPERIOR TO
- 6:20OUR BEST EFFORTS.
- 6:22>> Renee: SO WHEN YOU THINK
- 6:23ABOUT TERMS OF NATIONAL
- 6:25SECURITY, CYBERSECURITY IS WHAT
- 6:26YOU ALSO HAVE EXPERTISE IN, ARE
- 6:29THERE CONCERNS ABOUT THIS
- 6:31TECHNOLOGY BEING A BRIDGE TOO
- 6:33FAR?
- 6:34>> OF COURSE.
- 6:35IT'S CAPABLE OF INDEPENDENTLY
- 6:38DISCOVERING EXPLOITS IT CAN
- 6:41WRITE CODE AND GOOD AT SOCIAL
- 6:43ENGINEERING ATTACKS.
- 6:45NOW WITH THE PRO LIVEIATION OF
- 6:48GENERATED CONSENT, VIDEOS,
- 6:49PICTURES THOSE SYSTEMS CAN
- 6:51SIMULATE YOUR BOSS YOUR SPOUSE
- 6:54YOUR FRIEND, EVEN BEFORE YOU HAD
- 6:56TO GENERATE A SPEAR FISHING
- 7:00E-MAIL BY E-MAILS YOU BY TIEING
- 7:01TO FIGURE OUT WHO YOU ARE AND
- 7:03STILL A LOT OF PEOPLE CLICKED ON
- 7:06THOSE LINKS MANY NOW YOU CAN
- 7:08SEND A VIDEO TO MILLIONS OF
- 7:10ACCOUNTS OF SOMEONE THEY KNOW
- 7:12AND TRUST TELLING THEM HEY WHAT
- 7:14IS YOUR PASSWORD I NEED MONEY
- 7:16SENT TO ME.
- 7:16IT IS A NIGHTMARE IN SO MANY
- 7:18DIFFERENT WAYS.
- 7:19>> Renee: AND THE EDUCATION
- 7:21SPACE Mr. PIERCESY, WE KNOW
- 7:24THAT CHAT GPT WHICH MANY OF US
- 7:27THINK DOESN'T FLOW FLUENTLY OFF
- 7:30THE TONGUE BUT THAT HAS BECOME
- 7:32IN THE ACADEMIC WORLD AND YOU
- 7:34CAN SPEAK TO THIS, TOO, HOW THIS
- 7:36HAS BECOME A CONCERN BUT PERHAPS
- 7:38NOT FOR YOU.
- 7:40PERHAPS THIS IS SOMETHING WE'VE
- 7:42TALKED WITH YOU BEFORE, BEFORE,
- 7:44ABOUT HOW YOU AND YOUR CLASSROOM
- 7:46IS EMBRACING?
- 7:47>> WHEN I'M LOOKING AT AI,
- 7:51WHETHER IT'S CHAT GBT OR GOOGLE,
- 7:55I WANT TO LOOK AT IT AS AN
- 7:58EDUCATOR HOW CAN THIS TOOL BE
- 8:00INCORPORATED INTO MY INSTRUCTION
- 8:02AND HOW CAN THAT BETTER THE
- 8:03STUDENT LEARNING AND ENGAGEMENT
- 8:05THAT TAKES PLACE WITH MY
- 8:06STUDENTS.
- 8:07SO WHENEVER I FIRST DISCOVERED
- 8:10CHAT GBT FOR THE FIRST TIME I
- 8:12DISCOVERED IT THE DAY AFTER IT
- 8:14LAUNCHED THROUGH A FRIEND.
- 8:15STARTED TO PLAY AROUND WITH IT
- 8:17AND I RECOGNIZED THAT THINGS
- 8:19WERE GOING TO CHANGE IN THE WAY
- 8:22THAT A TECHNOLOGY WAS GOING TO
- 8:24BE BROUGHT INTO THE CLASSROOM.
- 8:25AND AT THAT POINT I STARTED TO
- 8:27ASK MYSELF AS AN EDUCATOR, HOW
- 8:30ARE LESSONS GOING TO BE
- 8:31DIFFERENT?
- 8:32WHAT IS AN ACTIVITY DESIGNED
- 8:33WITH AI WHAT WOULD THAT LOOK
- 8:35LIKE?
- 8:36HOW IS IT GOING TO BE BETTER AND
- 8:38MORE IMPORTANTLY WHEN YOU THINK
- 8:39ABOUT THE STUDENTS IN YOUR
- 8:40CLASSROOM HOW CAN YOU USE THIS
- 8:42TOOL TO BETTER THE INSTRUCTION
- 8:43THAT THEY RECEIVE.
- 8:45>> Renee: AND PROTECT THE
- 8:47ACADEMIC INTEGRITY.
- 8:47>> FOR SURE.
- 8:48IT'S NO SECRET AND I'M SPEAKING
- 8:51AS SOMEONE WHEN I WAS A
- 8:5417-YEAR-OLD, IF THIS EXISTED I
- 8:55WOULD TOTALLY FIGURE OUT A WAY
- 8:57TO TRY TO USE IT AS PART OF MY
- 9:00EDUCATION.
- 9:01I GUESS YOU COULD SAY.
- 9:03BUT ALL THAT ASIDE, YOU CAN'T IF
- 9:06A STUDENT IS USING CHAT GBT AND
- 9:11THEY ARE TRYING TO USE IT AND
- 9:12PASS IT OFF AS WORK AS THEIR
- 9:15OWN, THERE IS AN ISSUE THERE.
- 9:16BUT I DON'T THINK THAT MEANS
- 9:18THAT WE AS EDUCATORS IMMEDIATELY
- 9:20NEED TO SHY AWAY FROM THIS
- 9:23TECHNOLOGY.
- 9:23BECAUSE IT'S NOT GOING TO GO
- 9:25AWAY AND IT'S ONLY GOING TO GET
- 9:27BETTER AND IT IS VERY, VERY
- 9:28IMPORTANT THAT WE FIGURE OUT
- 9:29DIFFERENT WAYS WE CAN
- 9:31INCORPORATE THIS TOOL SO THAT
- 9:33WAY WE CAN BETTER OUR PROFESSION
- 9:35AND ULTIMATELY BETTER THE LIVES
- 9:36OF OUR STUDENTS.
- 9:38>> Renee: HOW ARE YOUR FELLOW
- 9:40EDUCATORS RESPONDING?
- 9:40ARE THEY EMBRACING IT AS YOU
- 9:42ARE?
- 9:42>> I THINK I'M AS MUCH AS I LOVE
- 9:46EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, I'M
- 9:47STILL APPROACHING USING AI IN A
- 9:50KIND OF INTENTIONALLY BEING
- 9:53HESITANT ABOUT IT.
- 9:53WE HAVE DAYS WHEN I'VE TOLD MY
- 9:56STUDENTS WE ARE NOT USING
- 9:57TECHNOLOGY TODAY WE ARE GOING ON
- 9:58A WALK TO GET AWAY FROM THIS
- 10:00STUFF TO GIVE OUR BRAINS A BREAK
- 10:02FROM IT.
- 10:03IN THE EDUCATION SPACE, I THINK
- 10:05UNDERSTANDABLY THERE'S PEOPLE
- 10:07HAVING TOUGH QUESTIONS AND A LOT
- 10:08OF TIMES IT'S FOR THAT ALMOST
- 10:10LIKE THE DEHUMANIZATION THAT
- 10:11WILL COME FROM USING AI.
- 10:14IN THEORY, I COULD HAVE AI
- 10:17CREATE A PROMPT, I COULD HAVE AI
- 10:20CREATE EXAMPLES AND MY STUDENTS
- 10:21COULD SUBMIT THEIR WORK TO ME
- 10:23USING AI AND THE AI COULD GRADE
- 10:26IT AND GIVE THEM FEEDBACK AND A
- 10:27SCORE.
- 10:28AND THAT'S SOMETHING.
- 10:30>> Renee: IT ELIMINATES THE NEED
- 10:31FOR THE TEACHER.
- 10:32>> AND THAT IS THE PROBLEM.
- 10:34THAT IS ONE OF THE REASONS WHY
- 10:35AS AWESOME AS THE AI TECHNOLOGY
- 10:37IS IT IS SO IMPORTANT THAT WE
- 10:40USE WHATEVER BENEFITS IS GOING
- 10:41TO GIVE US WHETHER IT'S SAVING
- 10:45TIME, GIVING INFORMAL FEEDBACK
- 10:48OR COMING UP WITH SUBLESSON
- 10:51PLANS ON THE FLY ALL THE TIME
- 10:52WILL GIVE IT ARE WE GOING TO USE
- 10:54THAT TIME TO GET TO KNOW OUR
- 10:57STUDENTS TO SEE WHAT IS GOING ON
- 10:58AND TO HELP THEM BECOME BETTER
- 11:00PEOPLE?
- 11:01>> Renee: TO YOUR POINT ABOUT
- 11:02THE PROMPTS, OUR COPRODUCER TOBY
- 11:06ASKED THE CHAT GBT TO DEFINE AND
- 11:09TALK ABOUT ARTIFICIAL
- 11:11INTELLIGENCE AND GIVE THE PROS
- 11:12AND CONS AND THIS IS WHAT THE
- 11:15ANSWER CONCLUSION CAME OF THAT.
- 11:16ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE HAS THE
- 11:18POTENTIAL TO BRING ENORMOUS
- 11:20BENEFITS TO SOCIETY AND IT ALSO
- 11:21RAISES CONCERNS THAT MUST BE
- 11:23ADDRESSED.
- 11:24ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS, JOB
- 11:25DISPLACEMENT, ACCOUNTABILITY,
- 11:27TRANSPARENCY, SECURITY RISK AND
- 11:29THE IMPACT OF AUTONOMOUS WEAPONS
- 11:32ARE CHALLENGES WE FACE.
- 11:34IT GIVES A BALANCED PERSPECTIVE
- 11:36ABOUT AI DOESN'T TIP THE SCALES
- 11:38ONE WAY OR THE OTHER.
- 11:40DOES THAT SURPRISE YOU HOW OFTEN
- 11:42IT DOES NOT SEEM TO PRESENT
- 11:45BIASES THAT HUMANS POSSESS.
- 11:48>> ANYTIME YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 11:50TECHNOLOGY THERE'S GOING TO BE
- 11:51BIAS BUILT INTO IT.
- 11:52IT'S NEXT TO IMPOSSIBLE TO NOT
- 11:54THAT HAVE.
- 11:55NO, IT DOESN'T SURPRISE ME.
- 11:57LIKE WE'VE TALKED ABOUT IN THE
- 11:59LAST 10 MINUTES THE AI IT'S
- 12:01SMART.
- 12:01IT RECOGNIZES THAT IT HAS THOSE
- 12:05BIASES BUILT INTO IT AND AS THEY
- 12:07GO ABOUT TRAINING THESE THINGS
- 12:09MORE AND MORE IT'S ONE OF THE
- 12:10REASONS WHY WE NEED TO BE IF
- 12:12WE'RE GOING TO INCORPORATE THEM
- 12:14INTO OUR INSTRUCTION AS
- 12:16EDUCATORS, WE NEED TO START TO
- 12:17ASK THOSE QUESTIONS.
- 12:18WE CAN'T JUST BECAUSE IT SPITS
- 12:22OUT A FACT WE CAN'T TRUST WHAT
- 12:24IT TELLS US.
- 12:25WE HAVE TO FACT CHECK.
- 12:28>> Renee: TRUST BUT VERIFY.
- 12:29>> SURE.
- 12:31>> Renee: IS THAT THE KIND OF MO
- 12:32THAT YOU WOULD HAVE IN YOUR
- 12:34APPROACH TO THIS AS WELL?
- 12:35>> THAT'S ONE OF THE MORE
- 12:37IMPORTANT ASPECTS OF INTEGRATING
- 12:39AI INTO THEIR EDUCATIONAL
- 12:41MISSION IN TERMS OF DEVELOPING
- 12:43THESE CRITICAL LITERACIES THAT
- 12:45IF YOU THINK BACK TO LET'S SAY
- 12:47THE EARLY 1990s WITH THE RISE
- 12:49OF THE INTERNET AND THE
- 12:51WORLDWIDE WEB A SIMILAR
- 12:53DISRUPTIVE MOMENT FOR EDUCATION
- 12:55EDUCATORS WHERE WE HAD TO ASK
- 12:57OURSELVES WHERE LEGITIMATE
- 12:58KNOWLEDGE COMES FROM AND HOW
- 12:59WE'RE GOING TO NAVIGATE THIS NEW
- 13:02WEALTH AND SOURCE OF INFORMATION
- 13:04THAT ALL OF OUR FIELDS OF STUDY
- 13:06HAD YET TO RECKON WITH IN A
- 13:08COMPREHENSIVE WAY.
- 13:09AND FAST FORWARD 30 YEARS AND
- 13:11HERE WE ARE IN A WAY WHERE NO
- 13:13MATTER WHAT YOU STUDY YOU ARE
- 13:14GOING TO BE TAUGHT HOW TO
- 13:15NAVIGATE THE INFORMATION THAT IS
- 13:17OUT THERE WITH AN AWARENESS AND
- 13:19CRITICAL EYE TOWARDS IT AND THAT
- 13:20IS PART OF THE IMPERATIVE WE'RE
- 13:22FACING TODAY AS EDUCATORS IN
- 13:25INTEGRATING AI INTO EDUCATION
- 13:27INTO OUR CLASSROOMS AND OUR
- 13:29STUDENTS' LEARNING.
- 13:30>> Renee: AND YOU MADE AN
- 13:31INTERESTING POINT ABOUT DIGITAL
- 13:33LITERACIES IT'S ONE THING TO SAY
- 13:35ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND
- 13:36ANOTHER WAY TO EXECUTE IT WITH
- 13:38SKILL AND DEXTERITY.
- 13:40BEING TAUGHT HOW TO USE THE
- 13:42TECHNOLOGY WITH SOME EFFICACY
- 13:44AND VALUES, IS IMPORTANT LESSON
- 13:47THAT UNIVERSITIES WILL EMBRACE
- 13:49AND MAKE A PART OF THE
- 13:50CURRICULUM?
- 13:51>> AND TO UNDERSTAND IT MORE AS
- 13:54A BLACK BOX WHERE WE MIGHT PUT
- 13:56IN A PROMPT AND PERHAPS BE VERY
- 13:59GOOD AT PUTTING IN PROMPTS AND
- 14:00GETTING OUTPUT THAT CAN SOLVE A
- 14:02PROBLEM OR PRODUCE A GOOD POEM
- 14:04OR A GOOD PLAY.
- 14:05BUT IF WE UNDERSTAND HOW IT
- 14:08WORKS, HOW IT WAS MADE AND WHERE
- 14:10IT'S GOING, WHAT THE IS IN
- 14:13CONSTRAINTS AND AND HOW WE CAN
- 14:16SQUARE THOSE OUR GOALS IN A WAY
- 14:18THAT IS RESPONSIBLE AND ETHICAL.
- 14:20THAT IS THE GOAL.
- 14:21IT'S NOT NECESSARILY TO WHERE
- 14:22ALL OF A SUDDEN EVERYONE HAS TO
- 14:24BECOME AN AI EXPERT BUT EVERYONE
- 14:26HAS TO DEVELOP THE LITERACIES TO
- 14:28WHERE IN SOME WAY ARE IMPERATIVE
- 14:31IS TO RECKON WITH AI THAT CAN
- 14:33DEVELOP THAT KIND OF CRITICAL
- 14:34USE THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
- 14:36>> I READ A REALLY INTERESTING
- 14:39ARTICLE ABOUT ARE WE GOING TO BE
- 14:41EDITORS FROM HERE ON OUT.
- 14:42AND I DON'T THINK THAT IS WHERE
- 14:44IT'S HEADED THAT IS TAKES THE
- 14:47HUMAN ELEMENT.
- 14:48I HOPE WE START TO CELEBRATE
- 14:50REAL ARTISTS AND POETS AND NOT
- 14:52JUST CELEBRATING ROBOT LOVE.
- 14:54BUT WE'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
- 14:57IF SOMEONE IS A REAL ARTIST OR
- 14:59WRITER, THEY ARE ABLE TO PLAY AN
- 15:02INSTRUMENT ON THE STAGE IN A
- 15:03SOLO, I WANT TO START TO
- 15:05CELEBRATE THOSE THINGS ALL THE
- 15:06MORE.
- 15:07>> Renee: WELL, AND IT WAS
- 15:08INTERESTING AT THE END OF THE 60
- 15:11MINUTES SECOND ABOUT AI THERE
- 15:13WAS A DISCLAIMER HE SAID MIGHT
- 15:15BECOME PART OF THE MAINSTREAM
- 15:17LIKE THE PREVIOUS CONTENT YOU'VE
- 15:19SEEN WAS HUMAN DEVELOPED.
- 15:20AND SO I MEAN TALK ABOUT YOUR
- 15:23DISCLAIMERS HAVING TO ACTUALLY
- 15:25GIVE CREDENCE TO THE FACT AND
- 15:26ACKNOWLEDGE THIS WAS PRODUCED BY
- 15:28A HUMAN AND DID NOT HAVE
- 15:31INTERFACING WITH ARTIFICIAL
- 15:32INTELLIGENCE.
- 15:33REPRESENTATIVE NIMS KULKSRNI
- 15:34JOINING US BY SKYPE AT THE
- 15:36SOUTHERN LEGISLATORS CONFERENCE
- 15:38WE ARE GLAD SHE HAS TAKEN TIME
- 15:40TO BE WITH US.
- 15:41BEFORE WE TALK ABOUT AUTONOMOUS
- 15:45VEHICLES WHO JOSH BRAY WAS A
- 15:47SPONSOR OF, I WANT TO GET YOUR
- 15:49CONCERNS WHEN YOU HEAR THE
- 15:50CONVERSATIONS WHETHER IT'S CHAT
- 15:52GPT AND OTHER AREAS, WHAT ARE
- 15:54YOUR CONCERNS ABOUT IT AND ARE
- 15:56YOU CELEBRATING THIS
- 15:57ADVANCEMENT?
- 15:59>> I THINK FUNDAMENTALLY WHAT WE
- 16:01NEED TO RECOGNIZE IS THAT AI IS
- 16:04A TOOL.
- 16:04IT IS A TECHNOLOGY THAT IS
- 16:07DISRUPTIVE AND WE HAVE GONE
- 16:08THROUGH AS A SPECIES SEVERAL
- 16:11ITERATIONS OF DESTRUCTIVE
- 16:13TECHNOLOGIES IN HEALTHCARE AND
- 16:14TRANSPORTATION AND AGRICULTURE
- 16:15OUR WORLD TODAY DOES NOT LOOK
- 16:17LIKE IT LOOKED 20 YEARS AGO, 50
- 16:19YEARS AGO, 100 YEARS AGO.
- 16:20THERE IS A LOT OF POLICY
- 16:23IMPLICATIONS AND IMPACT TO
- 16:25OCCUPATIONS AND PROFESSIONS.
- 16:26SO I THINK WE NEED TO VIEW AI AS
- 16:30A TOOL THAT IS HERE AND BECAUSE
- 16:33OF THE COMPUTER PROCESSING
- 16:34SPEEDS THAT WE HAVE IS LIKELY TO
- 16:37GROW IN TERMS OF WHAT IT CAN DO,
- 16:39BUT IT IS A TOOL THAT IS BASED
- 16:41ON HUMAN INPUT.
- 16:43YOU KNOW WE'RE HEARING ABOUT
- 16:45THINGS LIKE AI HAVING A LOT OF
- 16:48DISCUSSIONS BECAUSE COMPANIES
- 16:49CREATED WAYS FOR US TO USE THEM.
- 16:52CHAT GPT YOU HAVE IMAGE
- 16:55GENERATING AI AND THOSE ARE ALL
- 16:57PRIVATE COMPANIES THAT HAVE
- 16:59CREATED WAYS FOR US TO ACCESS
- 17:00THIS TECHNOLOGY.
- 17:01SO IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT
- 17:03EVERYBODY IS GOING TO UNDERSTAND
- 17:06IMMEDIATELY.
- 17:06WE ARE NOT GOING TO UNDERSTAND
- 17:07THE POTENTIAL IMPLICATIONS
- 17:09IMMEDIATELY.
- 17:09BUT I DO THINK THAT WE NEED TO
- 17:11RECOGNIZE THAT IT'S HERE AND
- 17:13THAT WE'RE GOING TO NEED TO
- 17:15REALLY TAKE A LOOK AT IT THROUGH
- 17:16THE LENS OF HOW IT'S GOING TO
- 17:18IMMEDIATELY IMPACT OUR WORLD AND
- 17:20HOW IT'S GOING TO IMPACT OUR
- 17:21WORLD IN THE NEAR FUTURE.
- 17:23IF FIVE YEARS, IN 10 YEARS.
- 17:25BECAUSE WE ARE IN A VERGE OF A
- 17:29VERY DISRUPTIVE TECHNOLOGY THAT
- 17:32COULD BE IN TERMS OF OUR RECENT
- 17:34HISTORY A BIGGER IMPACT ON OUR
- 17:37SPECIES THAN THE INTERNET.
- 17:39SO IT'S SOMETHING THAT WE NEED
- 17:41TO BE VERY COGNIZANT OF AND VERY
- 17:43CAREFUL WITH.
- 17:44BUT ALSO RECOGNIZE ITS VAST
- 17:47POTENTIAL.
- 17:47>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE BRAY,
- 17:48THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE WITH
- 17:49US.
- 17:50YOUR THOUGHTS BEFORE WE TALK
- 17:51ABOUT YOUR LEGISLATION ON
- 17:54AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES.
- 17:54>> AS A KID WHO GREW UP WATCHING
- 17:58TERMINATOR IT IS A FASCINATING
- 17:59TIME TO BE ALIVE.
- 18:01BECAUSE YOU KNOW, IT LOOKS LIKE
- 18:04IT'S GOING TO BE REAL.
- 18:06BUT KIND OF TO ECHO WHAT
- 18:09REPRESENTATIVE SAID, ARTIFICIAL
- 18:11INTELLIGENCE IS A TOOL.
- 18:13AND WE NEED TO BE TEACHING OUR
- 18:16STUDENTS NOT NECESSARILY LIKE
- 18:18HEY WE NEED TO STAY AWAY FROM
- 18:20THIS BUT HOW CAN WE USE IT.
- 18:22I WAS IN HIGH SCHOOL 20 YEARS
- 18:24AGO.
- 18:26AND I HAD MATH TEACHERS TELL ME
- 18:28THEN YOU ARE NOT GOING TO HAVE A
- 18:30CALCULATOR YOU NEED TO LEARN HOW
- 18:32TO DO THIS BUT NOBODY SAW THIS
- 18:35COMING.
- 18:36WHERE WE HAVE IT WITH US
- 18:39CONSTANTLY.
- 18:39AND IF I WISH I HAD SPENT MORE
- 18:42TIME THEN LEARNING HOW TO USE
- 18:44EXCEL AND NOT HOW TO USE BROAD
- 18:47EQUATIONS BUT HOW CAN I TAILOR
- 18:50THAT THROUGH TECHNOLOGY THAT
- 18:51WOULD HAVE BEEN HANDY ABOUT NOW.
- 18:54WE ARE ON THE PRECIPICE OF
- 18:59SOMETHING THAT IS STRAIGHT OUT
- 19:00OF THE SCIENCE FICTION NOVEL.
- 19:03AND IT'S REALLY EXCITING BUT AT
- 19:04THE SAME TIME IT'S SCARY BECAUSE
- 19:07YOU KNOW OF THE POTENTIAL OF JOB
- 19:10DISPLACEMENT.
- 19:11GBT IT PASSED THE BAR EXAM, IT
- 19:13PASSED THE MEDICAL LICENSING
- 19:15EXAM.
- 19:16SO YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 19:19PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE WHO COULD BE
- 19:20LOSING THEIR JOBS.
- 19:23JUST KIND OF DOING RESEARCH AND
- 19:25SEEING WHERE ALL THIS IS SEEMS
- 19:28TO BE HEADED YOU KNOW, IT DOES
- 19:32APPEAR LIKE FOR CANCER RESEARCH
- 19:34OR PHYSICS OR ROCKET SCIENCE
- 19:38WHATEVER THERE'S A GREAT
- 19:39POSSIBILITY OF IT DOING
- 19:41TREMENDOUS THINGS BUT THEN
- 19:42THERE'S ALSO THE SCARY SIDE OF
- 19:44HOW DO WE MAKE SURE EVERYTHING
- 19:47STAYS CONTAINED AND THAT WE
- 19:50PERCEIVE RESPONSIBLY.
- 19:51>> Renee: I WANT TO PARS OUT A
- 19:54TERM THAT REPRESENTATIVE SAID
- 19:55WAS DISRUPTIVE.
- 19:56I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS A
- 19:58POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE BUT WE'LL
- 20:00GET TO THAT IN A MOMENT.
- 20:01WE WANT TO SHOW YOU THERE ARE
- 20:04CREATIVE USES OF AI.
- 20:05MEMBER OF OUR KET FAMILY USES
- 20:10CHAT GPT TO HELP WRITE BEDTIME
- 20:13STORIES FOR HER CHILDREN.
- 20:14WE CAUGHT UP TO THEM TO FIND OUT
- 20:16HOW IT WORKS AND FIND OUT WHY
- 20:19THEY ARE EMPTY BRACING THIS
- 20:20TECHNOLOGY.
- 20:20>> ONCE UPON IN A TIME IN A LAND
- 20:23FAR AWAY THERE LIVED PIERCE,
- 20:26CHARLIE IRELAND AND CELTIC.
- 20:27>> WE HAVE BEEN USING CHAT GPT
- 20:30TO DO BEDTIME STORIES FOR OUR
- 20:32KIDS AND IT'S BEEN A FUN THING
- 20:34TO DO.
- 20:35OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE LOTS OF OTHER
- 20:36BOOKS IN HERE THAT WE READ.
- 20:38BUT THE CHAT GPT HAS ADDED A FUN
- 20:42ONCE IN A WHILE ADDITION TO
- 20:45BEDTIME.
- 20:45YOU OPEN THE APP AND THEN YOU
- 20:49GIVE INSTRUCTIONS TO WRITE A
- 20:51BEDTIME STORY A CHILDREN'S
- 20:53BEDTIME STORY.
- 20:53YOU CAN ADD CHARACTERS AND GIVE
- 20:56AS MUCH OR LEGAL DETAIL ABOUT
- 20:57THE PLOT AND CHARACTERS AND IT
- 20:59COMES UP WITH THE REALLY SUPER
- 21:01CUTE VERY SIMPLE STORIES WITH
- 21:04OUR KIDS' NAMES IN THEM AND
- 21:06DIFFERENT ADVENTURES AND IT IS A
- 21:09REALLY UNIQUE AND FUN WAY TO USE
- 21:11CHAT GPT.
- 21:12>> WRITE A THREE-FIVE MINUTE
- 21:15CHILDREN'S STORY ABOUT FOUR
- 21:16SIBLINGS.
- 21:17>> THEY LOVE IT BECAUSE IT ADDS
- 21:18A PERSONAL TOUCH TO THE STORIES
- 21:20SO THEY ARE THE CHARACTERS.
- 21:22THEY GET TO LIKE SOMETIME ALSO
- 21:24ASK THEM QUESTIONS LIKE WHAT DO
- 21:26YOU WANT YOUR ADVENTURE TO BE?
- 21:27WHAT IS THE SETTING?
- 21:29WHAT DO YOU WANT TO HAPPEN ALONG
- 21:31THE WAY?
- 21:31YOU CAN LET THEM BUILD THE STORY
- 21:35WITH YOU.
- 21:35AND SO THEN THEY GET INVESTED IN
- 21:38THE STORY THEY ARE HAVING MORE
- 21:39FUN AND THEY ARE DOING A LOT
- 21:41MORE OF THE STORYTELLING PART OF
- 21:43IT WHICH IS COOL.
- 21:44AND THEY ARE LEARNING THE
- 21:46DIFFERENT COMPONENTS OF THE
- 21:48STORY.
- 21:48YOU KNOW YOU NEED CHARACTERS YOU
- 21:50NEED A PLOT, YOU NEED A SETTING.
- 21:53SO THEY ARE LEARNING THAT ALONG
- 21:54THE WAY.
- 21:55THEY LOVE ALL THE BOOKS BUT THEY
- 21:57LOVE THIS EXPERIENCE IT IS A
- 21:58STORYTELLING ACTIVITY.
- 21:59>> ONCE UPON A TIME THERE WAS
- 22:02A...
- 22:02>> THIS FELT LIKE A COOL WAY TO
- 22:04INTRODUCE IT TO OUR KIDS.
- 22:06AND HAVE THEM KNOW WHAT IT IS.
- 22:08BECAUSE IT'S OBVIOUSLY GOING TO
- 22:09BE SOMETHING THAT IS PART OF
- 22:11THEIR FUTURE.
- 22:12THEY ARE GOING TO PROBABLY USE
- 22:14IT.
- 22:15THEY ARE GOING TO BE INTRODUCED
- 22:16TO IT THEY ARE GOING TO KNOW
- 22:19WHAT IT IS IT'S GOOD TO LEARN
- 22:21EARLY TO USE IT FOR GOOD INSTEAD
- 22:23OF EVIL IS ONE WAY TO LOOK AT
- 22:26IT.
- 22:26I HOPE THAT WHAT THEY TAKE FROM
- 22:28THAT IS THAT WHILE THIS IS FUN
- 22:30AND SILLY AND WE CAN CREATE THE
- 22:32STORIES THAT HAVE US AS
- 22:34CHARACTERS THAT THERE IS
- 22:36ABSOLUTELY VALUE IN REAL
- 22:38LITERATURE THAT STOOD THE TEST
- 22:39OF TIME THAT HAS BEEN READ TO
- 22:42THE MANY, MANY TIMES.
- 22:44I HOPE THAT ALSO IS IMPARTED ON
- 22:46THEM IN THAT WAY IT IS A TOOL
- 22:48THAT CAN BE USED BUT IT'S NOT
- 22:50NECESSARILY THE BEST THING TO
- 22:51USE IN ALL SCENARIOS.
- 22:54AND THAT THERE'S VALUE IN BOOKS,
- 22:57STORIES WRITTEN BY REAL PEOPLE.
- 22:58>> SO THE SIBLINGS ENCHANTING
- 23:02ADVENTURE BECAME A CHERISHED
- 23:04MEMORY REMINDING THEM TO EMBRACE
- 23:05THE WONDERS OF THE WORLD WHILE
- 23:08SAYING SAFE IN THE WARM EMBRACE
- 23:10OF THEIR LOVED ONES.
- 23:12THENT.
- 23:13>> Renee: THERE'S NOTHING LIKE
- 23:14THE REAL THING.
- 23:15THERE USED TO BE A SLOGAN FOR A
- 23:17PRODUCT.
- 23:17AND THAT IS WHAT YOU HEARD HER
- 23:20ELUDE TO THERE HAS TO BE A
- 23:21BALANCE THAT YOU WANT TO GET THE
- 23:23BOOK OFF THE SHELF AND READ BUT
- 23:25SHE HAS LITTLE KIDDOS WHO WERE
- 23:29LEARNING AI AND KNOW MORE ABOUT
- 23:31IT THAN US?
- 23:31>> IT'S IMPORTANT TO RECOGNIZE
- 23:33AND WE'VE HINTED AT THIS ALREADY
- 23:35BUT WHERE WE ARE WITH AI WE ARE
- 23:37AT THE KIDS FROM MY AGE GROUP
- 23:40IT'S WE ARE AT THE ATTIRERY 2600
- 23:43OF AI.
- 23:45PITFALL AND ALL WAS GREAT.
- 23:47IT'S ONLY GOING TO GET BETTER
- 23:48IT'S ONLY GOING TO GET BETTER.
- 23:50I DO THINK IT'S VERY, VERY
- 23:52IMPORTANT THAT WE START TO MODEL
- 23:54FOR OUR STUDENTS THE WAYS WE CAN
- 23:56USE THIS IN POSITIVE WAYS
- 23:58OUTSIDE OF USING IT TO ANSWER
- 24:00QUICK QUESTIONS FOR US.
- 24:01AND I FEEL LIKE THAT'S GOING TO
- 24:03BE THE SWEET SPOT AND RIGHT NOW
- 24:05THIS TECHNOLOGY ESPECIALLY CHAT
- 24:07GPT3 IS LESS THAN A YEAR OLD.
- 24:09WE AS EDUCATORS WE ARE STILL
- 24:11TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW DOES
- 24:13THIS FIT INTO INSTRUCTION WHAT
- 24:15DOES IT MEAN FOR COLLEGE
- 24:18ADMISSIONS.
- 24:19AND THESE ARE GOOD QUESTIONS TO
- 24:20START TO ASK.
- 24:22BUT IT'S GOING TO BE THINGS OVER
- 24:23THE NEXT FEW YEARS IN THE
- 24:25EDUCATION FIELD WE'RE GOING TO
- 24:27HAVE TO FIGURE OUT THOSE ANSWERS
- 24:29TO.
- 24:29BUT, YES, I STILL BELIEVE THERE
- 24:31IS NOTHING LIKE THE REAL THING
- 24:32AND THERE IS A REASON I DO READ
- 24:34ALOUD EVERYDAY.
- 24:35WITH MY KIDS AT HOME AND ALSO
- 24:37WITH THE STUDENTS IN MY
- 24:39CLASSROOM WRITTEN BY A HUMAN.
- 24:41>> Renee: WRITTEN BY A HUMAN.
- 24:42IT HAS TO HAVE THAT DISCLAIMER.
- 24:44DOCTOR, I WANT TO TOSS OUT A
- 24:46COUPLE QUESTIONS THAT WE HAVE
- 24:48GOTTEN FROM VIEWERS.
- 24:49THIS FROM A VIEWER WITH THE RISE
- 24:51OF ELECTRIC VEHICLES AND THE
- 24:52RISE OF AI BOTH OF THESE
- 24:56TECHNOLOGIES WILL REQUIRE SHORT
- 24:58AND LONG-TERM ELECTRICITY THAT
- 24:59ARE CURRENT ALTERNATIVES TO COAL
- 25:03CANNOT PROVIDE WHAT DOES THE
- 25:06LONG-TERM DEMAND MEAN FOR COAL
- 25:07IN KENTUCKY CAN YOU ANSWER THAT?
- 25:09>> I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT
- 25:11COAL IN KENTUCKY.
- 25:12I KNOW THAT LEADERS OF OTHER
- 25:14COMPANIES THINK WE MAYBE TWO TO
- 25:15FOUR YEARS AWAY FROM SUPER
- 25:17INTELLIGENCE.
- 25:18SO ALL THE PROBLEMS WE'RE
- 25:21DISCUSSING LIKE CLIMATE CHANGE
- 25:22MAY BECOME IRRELEVANT.
- 25:25SYSTEMS SOLVE THAT FOR US AND WE
- 25:27WILL NOT BE AROUND TO DEAL WITH
- 25:29THAT PROBLEM.
- 25:29IT'S IMPORTANT TO SPEND SOMETIME
- 25:31LOOKING AT WHAT CAN HAPPEN NOT
- 25:33JUST IMMEDIATELY NOT JUST NEXT
- 25:36SEMESTER BUT WHAT ABOUT FIVE
- 25:37YEARS FROM NOW?
- 25:38IF WE ARE SUCCESSFUL AT MAKING
- 25:42THIS TECHNOLOGY DISRUPT
- 25:43EVERYTHING, ECONOMY, MILITARY,
- 25:46SCIENCE.
- 25:46AND I THINK WE'RE NOT DOING
- 25:48ENOUGH AS SCIENTISTS AND
- 25:52POLITICIANS, AS CITIZENS.
- 25:54>> Renee: SO, YES, YOU ARE
- 25:55THINKING THAT THE POLICY MAKING
- 25:57IS LAGGING BEHIND HOW FAST THE
- 26:00TECHNOLOGY IS EVOLVING, CORRECT?
- 26:02>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 26:05I THINK THERE'S IMMEDIATE
- 26:07PROBLEMS ARE VERY SERIOUS AND
- 26:08THEY IMPACT PEOPLE.
- 26:10BUT THEY ALSO DES TRACK YOU FROM
- 26:12WHAT IS IMPACTFUL.
- 26:14WE HAVE ALLEGELISM PROBLEMS WE
- 26:16HAVE UNEMPLOYMENT, BUT NONE OF
- 26:19IT WOULD MATTER IF THE SUPER
- 26:21INTELLIGENCE IS OUT OF CONTROL
- 26:22AND KILLS EVERYONE.
- 26:23AND IT USED TO BE SCIENCE
- 26:25FICTION.
- 26:2650 YEARS AGO NOW WE HAVE LEADERS
- 26:29OF THOSE AI LABS SAYING WE NEED
- 26:31TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM NOW OR WE
- 26:33ARE ALL DEAD.
- 26:34AND NO ONE REALLY PAYS ATTENTION
- 26:36AND PEOPLE SWITCHBACK TO THE
- 26:37FAVORITE TOPIC OF THEIR
- 26:39CHOOSING.
- 26:40>> Renee: SO THIS QUESTION FROM
- 26:41JEFF FROM CALDWELL COUNTY I WILL
- 26:44LET YOU OR OTHERS CHIME IN IT'S
- 26:45FOR THE LEGISLATORS IN
- 26:47PARTICULAR.
- 26:47HOW WILL DEVELOPMENTS IN
- 26:50MEDICINE AND TREATMENT DRUGS BE
- 26:52PATENTED AND MONETIZED WHEN
- 26:54DEVELOPED BY AI WILL THERE BE
- 26:56COST PROTECTIONS FOR CONSUMERS
- 26:58IN KENTUCKY?
- 26:58HAVE YOU GIVEN THOUGHT TO THAT
- 27:01REPRESENTATIVE BRAY?
- 27:01>> THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION.
- 27:05THE POLICY MAKING HAS LAGGED
- 27:06BEHIND THIS.
- 27:07AND PART OF THE REASON BEHIND IT
- 27:10IS WE DON'T NECESSARILY
- 27:14UNDERSTAND WHAT AI IS TRULY
- 27:15CAPABLE OF.
- 27:16AND THE ADVANCEMENTS ARE
- 27:18HAPPENING SO EXPONENTIALLY FAST
- 27:20NOW THAT IT'S HARD FOR US TO
- 27:24KEEP UP.
- 27:25GOING BACK TO THAT, I MEAN
- 27:27THAT'S A FEDERAL ISSUE THAT
- 27:29NEEDS TO BE HANDLED AT THE
- 27:30FEDERAL LEVEL.
- 27:31WEIGH CAN PASS SOMETHING THROUGH
- 27:32THE STATE, BUT YOU'VE GOT 49
- 27:36OTHER STATES AND I DON'T KNOW
- 27:37HOW EFFECTIVE THAT WOULD BE.
- 27:39>> Renee: YOU WOULD BE FOR
- 27:41UNIFORM STANDARDIZED FEDERAL LAW
- 27:42TO GOVERN HOW ALL OF THIS IS
- 27:45APPROACHED.
- 27:45SAME QUESTION TO YOU
- 27:47REPRESENTATIVE, THE POLICY
- 27:49MAKING SPACE HASN'T KEPT PACE
- 27:51WITH HOW THIS IS EVOLVING SO
- 27:54QUICKLY, SHOULD KENTUCKY WAIT
- 27:56FOR THE FEDS TO STEP IN AND
- 27:58CREATE POLICY THAT STATES SHOULD
- 28:00FOLLOW OR SHOULD STATES GO ON
- 28:02THEIR OWN?
- 28:04>> I BELIEVE WE NEED TO DO THIS
- 28:06ON OUR OWN.
- 28:08WE CANNOT WAIT FOR STATES TO
- 28:10CATCH UP TO WHAT FEDERAL POLICY
- 28:13MAY OR MAY NOT BE ENACTED.
- 28:16I WILL THROW OUT REAL ID IT'S
- 28:19TAKEN 20 YEARS FOR 50 STATES TO
- 28:22DO AN UPGRADE TO OUR DRIVER'S
- 28:23LICENSES.
- 28:24AND THE INTERPRETATION OF WHAT A
- 28:26FEDERAL LAW WOULD LOOK LIKE, THE
- 28:29IMPLICATIONS OF WHAT WOULD BE IN
- 28:32THAT FEDERAL LAW I THINK ARE NOT
- 28:34NECESSARILY GOING TO LOOK THE
- 28:35SAME STATE BY STATE.
- 28:36A LOT OF CONCERNS THAT WERE
- 28:38BROUGHT UP WITH BRAY'S BILL AND
- 28:41I DID NOT MEAN TO PICK ON THIS
- 28:43SPECIFICALLY, HAD TO DO WITH
- 28:45EASTERN KENTUCKY A LOT OF
- 28:47EASTERN KENTUCKY LAWMAKERS WERE
- 28:48CONCERNED WITH THE ROADS IN
- 28:49EASTERN KENTUCKY.
- 28:50THE LACK OF CONSISTENT BROADBAND
- 28:52OR SIGNAL IN EASTERN KENTUCKY
- 28:55THAT MAY NOT LOOK THE SAME IN
- 28:58ANOTHER STATE A UNIFORM FEDERAL
- 29:00LAW IS NOT GOING TO BE
- 29:02SUFFICIENT TO ADDRESS ALL OF THE
- 29:03NEEDS THAT KENTUCKIANS HAVE.
- 29:05I THINK WE NEED TO TAKE THE LEAD
- 29:07ON THIS BECAUSE OUR PEOPLE ARE
- 29:08GOING TO BE IMPACTED FIRST AND
- 29:10THE SPEED AT WHICH ALL OF THIS
- 29:11IS HAPPENING IS SOMETHING WE
- 29:14CANNOT DISMISS.
- 29:14BY THE TIME WE FIGURE OUT HOW
- 29:17MUCH SOCIAL MEDIA IMPACTED ALL
- 29:18OF US AND HAS IMPACTED A
- 29:21GENERATION, IT'S ALREADY DONE.
- 29:23RIGHT?
- 29:23SO WE'RE STUDYING WHAT HAS
- 29:25ALREADY HAPPENED.
- 29:26AND I'M STILL PROCESSING A
- 29:27LITTLE BIT WHAT THE DOCTOR WAS
- 29:30SAYING, BUT IT'S CAN BE DIRE BUT
- 29:33IF WE JUST STUDY AND UNDERSTAND
- 29:36AND LEARN ABOUT WHAT THIS TOOL
- 29:38CAN DO AND WHAT ITS IMPLICATIONS
- 29:41ARE IF WE DO THAT WELL THEN WE
- 29:42WILL BE ABLE TO ENACT POLICIES
- 29:45THAT REFLECT WHAT THOSE GAPS ARE
- 29:47OR WHAT THOSE OPPORTUNITIES ARE.
- 29:50>> Renee: WELL, YES, THE DOCTOR
- 29:52YOU WANT TO CHIME IN HERE?
- 29:55>> YES.
- 29:56HISTORICALLY, ABSOLUTELY
- 29:58CORRECTLY EVERYBODY IS SAYING AI
- 29:59IS A TOOL.
- 30:00THAT'S WHAT IT ALWAYS WAS.
- 30:02WE HAD NARROW AI, AND HELPED ME
- 30:05DO MY TAXES.
- 30:07HELPED ME WIN THIS CHESS GAME.
- 30:09THEN YOU HAVE GENERAL
- 30:10INTELLIGENCE.
- 30:11YOU GO BEYOND HUMAN CAPACITY TO
- 30:13SUPER INTELLIGENCE.
- 30:14IT STOPS BEING A TOOL AND
- 30:16BECOMES AN AGENT AN INDEPENDENT
- 30:18AGENT AN AGENT WE DON'T KNOW HOW
- 30:20TO CONTROL.
- 30:20IN FACT, THERE ARE PUBLICATIONS
- 30:23ARE SAYING IT MAY BE IMPOSSIBLE
- 30:24TO DO IT.
- 30:25THE IDEA IT'S JUST ANOTHER
- 30:27VERSION OF SOFTWARE A NEW WORD
- 30:30NEW INTERNET BROWSER IS NOT
- 30:32CAPTURING THE CHANGE.
- 30:32IT IS A COMPLETE PARADIGM SHIFT
- 30:35TO WHERE WE ARE NO LONGER
- 30:37POSSIBLY IN CHARGE.
- 30:38WE ARE NOT THE SMARTEST SPECIES
- 30:41AROUND AND WE DON'T KNOW HOW TO
- 30:44REMAIN IN CONTROL.
- 30:45THERE IS NOTHING YOU HAVE TO
- 30:47CONTRIBUTE.
- 30:48YOU CAN CONTRIBUTE TO A SUPER
- 30:50INTELLIGENCE.
- 30:50IT IS A BETTER ARTIST.
- 30:51IT IS A BETTER WRITER.
- 30:52IT IS A BETTER PROGRAMMER YES WE
- 30:55HAVE MAN MADE NICHE PRODUCTS
- 30:59SOME PEOPLE FIND INTERESTING.
- 31:01BUT IT'S NOT ENOUGH TO SUSTAIN 8
- 31:04BILLION HUMANS.
- 31:05>> Renee: THERE IS A TERM
- 31:07PROFESSOR THAT WE HEAR AND THAT
- 31:10IS JEN ACTIVE AI?
- 31:13WHAT IS THAT, WHAT DOES THAT
- 31:15MEAN?
- 31:16>> WE HAVE AI CAPABLE OF
- 31:18GENERATING ART.
- 31:20GENERATING IMAGES, GENERATING
- 31:21COMPUTER CODE, GENERATING TEXT,
- 31:25GENERATING ALL SORTS OF DIGITAL
- 31:27MEDIA AND THERE IS REALLY NO
- 31:30LIMIT TO THAT.
- 31:30IT CAN GENERATE VIDEO GAME IT IS
- 31:33CAN GENERATE FULL VIDEOS AND
- 31:35WHOLE UNIVERSES GIVEN ACCESS
- 31:38TOPHYSIC STIMULATERS.
- 31:39A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE THINKING
- 31:40THAT WHAT WE SEE FROM APPLE AND
- 31:43META WITH VIRTUAL REALITY, WITH
- 31:46AUGMENTED REALITY IS THE WORLD
- 31:48WE ARE SHIFTING TOWARDS THERE IS
- 31:49NO REASON TO WASTE PRECIOUS
- 31:52PHYSICAL RESOURCES IF YOU CAN
- 31:54GET COMPARABLE EXPERIENCE IN
- 31:55VIRTUAL SPACE.
- 31:56OF COURSE, ALL OF IT DEPENDS ON
- 31:59US BEING ABLE TO CONTROL THOSE
- 32:01SYSTEMS AND STILL BE AROUND TO
- 32:02ENJOY THOSE.
- 32:04>> Renee: I WILL LET YOU CHIME
- 32:05IN IF YOU'D LIKE PROFESSOR?
- 32:08>> TO GO BACK TO QUESTIONS OF
- 32:11POLICY THAT WE'RE DISCUSSING A
- 32:13LITTLE BIT EARLIER FROM AN
- 32:15INSTITUTIONAL LEVEL TO THINK
- 32:17ABOUT HIGHER EDUCATION OR ANY
- 32:19KIND OF SCHOOL SYSTEM, THERE'S
- 32:23CERTAIN THINGS THAT WE KNOW THAT
- 32:25WE WANT TO HAVE AT KIND OF A
- 32:28BROAD LEVEL IN TERMS OF TEACHING
- 32:31STUDENTS CRITICAL LITERACIES IN
- 32:32TERMS OF MAKING SURE THAT WE'RE
- 32:34USING AI PLATFORMS REASONABLY
- 32:38SAFELY AND RESPONSIBLY IN THAT
- 32:40CASE.
- 32:41BUT AKIN TO THIS QUESTION OF
- 32:43WHETHER STATES OR THE FEDERAL
- 32:45GOVERNMENT WHAT WE SEE HAPPEN
- 32:46SOMETHING THERE'S DIFFERENT
- 32:48AREAS OF SPECIALIZATION FIELDS
- 32:50OF STUDY THAT THEN BREAK APART
- 32:53AND NEED TO CONSIDER ON THEIR
- 32:54OWN WHAT THE MEANING OF ALL THIS
- 32:56IS.
- 32:56AND WE ACTUALLY HAVE LOTS OF
- 32:59PEOPLE ASKING VERY EXSENTENCE
- 33:04SHALL QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT IT
- 33:05MEANS TO DO WHAT THEY DO,
- 33:07WHETHER IN THE WORKFORCE OR
- 33:08ACADEMIC AREA OF STUDY AND MY
- 33:10PERSONAL AREA IS IN WRITING
- 33:12STUDIES.
- 33:13AND IT IS A VERY INTERESTING
- 33:14QUESTION TO THINK ABOUT WHAT THE
- 33:17MEANING OF MY FIELD OF STUDY IS
- 33:18NOW THAT THERE IS A GENRE ACTIVE
- 33:21PLATFORM THAT CAN GENERATE TEXT
- 33:24IT IS NOT A HUMAN AGENT THAT CAN
- 33:27PRODUCE SOMETHING THAT
- 33:29THEORETICALLY IS ENTIRELY NEW
- 33:31HAS NEVER EXISTED BEFORE AND NOW
- 33:32THERE'S ARGUMENTS IT IS NOT
- 33:35ENTIRELY CREATIVE BECAUSE IT'S
- 33:37REPRODUCING A STATISTICAL NORM
- 33:38AND IT'S NOT THAT NOVEL.
- 33:41BUT IT'S NEVERTHELESS WRITING IN
- 33:42A WAY THAT WE COULDN'T HAVE
- 33:44IMAGINED PERHAPS A FEW YEARS AGO
- 33:46BECAUSE WE HADN'T SEEN SOMETHING
- 33:48DO THAT.
- 33:48WE ARE HAVING TO PLUM OUR
- 33:51IMAGINATION WHAT IS IT MEANS TO
- 33:52DO WHAT WE DO IN DIFFERENT WAYS
- 33:54WHETHER WE DO WRITING STUDIES OR
- 33:57MEDICINE OR PUBLIC HEALTH.
- 33:58AND WE'RE HAVING TO FIGURE OUT
- 34:00IN OUR OWN AREAS WHAT THE USES
- 34:02OF USES WHAT THE DIFFERENT WAYS
- 34:04OF LEVERAGING AI ARE AND ALSO
- 34:06FIGURE OUT WHAT IT MEANS TO
- 34:08STUDY WHAT WE DO NOW THAT
- 34:11THERE'S THIS PRODUCTION
- 34:12CAPABILITY FOR THOSE WHO DO ART.
- 34:14IT CAN PRODUCE A VISUAL IMAGE
- 34:16BUT IS THAT CREATIVITY?
- 34:18IS THAT PRODUCING ART OR SOME
- 34:20OTHER KIND OF ACTION?
- 34:21THOSE ARE INTERESTING
- 34:22CONVERSATIONS.
- 34:23I THINK THE THINGS THAT WILL
- 34:24TAKE A LOT OF TIME TO SIFT
- 34:26THROUGH.
- 34:27>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE?
- 34:29>> I JUST WANTED TO I AGREE WITH
- 34:33FORT THAT EVERYONE IS SAYING.
- 34:34I THINK WHAT WE NEED TO REALIZE
- 34:38IS THE SPEED WITH WHICH THIS IS
- 34:39GOING TO HAPPEN.
- 34:42AND TO THE DOCTOR'S POINT, THE
- 34:47HOW WE TREAT IT AND THE POLICIES
- 34:48THAT WE PUT INTO PLACE RIGHT NOW
- 34:51OR HOW WE WILL CONTROL AND
- 34:52REGULATE ITS GROWTH.
- 34:54USING THE WORD INTELLIGENCE,
- 34:56HUMAN INTELLIGENCE IS WHAT WE'VE
- 34:58USED TO SEPARATE OURSELVES FROM
- 34:59EVERY OTHER SPECIES ON THE
- 35:01PLANET.
- 35:02SO YOU PUT ARTIFICIAL
- 35:04INTELLIGENCE IN THE MIX AND
- 35:05THAT'S WHAT SCARES PEOPLE THAT
- 35:07WORD INTELLIGENCE BECAUSE WHAT
- 35:09DOES IT MEAN TO BE HUMAN.
- 35:11THERE ARE EXISTENTIAL QUESTIONS
- 35:13BUT WE NEED TO BE LOOKING AT THE
- 35:16DISRUPTIONS NOT JUST IN TERMS OF
- 35:18OCCUPATIONS AND STATES AND
- 35:20COUNTRIES BECAUSE AS SOME POINT
- 35:22THOSE MAY BECOME MEANINGLESS.
- 35:24WE ARE TALKING ABOUT A RESOURCE
- 35:25THAT IS ABLE TO TAKE ALL OF THE
- 35:27DATA THAT WE HAVE SO FAR AND
- 35:31DIGITAL RECORDED HISTORY AND WE
- 35:32CAN PUT IN A PROMPT AND HAVE IT
- 35:35ALLOCATE RESOURCES.
- 35:37THE MOST EFFICIENT WAY.
- 35:38WE CAN PUT IN A PROMPT AND WE
- 35:40CAN GET ANSWERS TO THINGS THAT
- 35:42MAY TAKE YEARS AND YEARS FOR OUR
- 35:45CURRENT COMPUTING POWERS TO GET
- 35:47TO THE ANSWER.
- 35:48SO I THINK WHAT WE NEED TO BE
- 35:50LOOKING AT IS NOT NECESSARILY
- 35:53ONE INDIVIDUAL OCCUPATION OR ONE
- 35:56INDIVIDUAL STATE OR FEDERAL
- 35:57THERE IS A VERY MACRO PICTURE
- 36:00THAT NEEDS TOCK TAKEN BY ALL OF
- 36:02US BECAUSE THE DISRUPTION COULD
- 36:04BE TO THE DOCTOR'S POINT, THE
- 36:06ART WORLD IS HAVING ALL KINDS OF
- 36:08ISSUES.
- 36:08YOU HAVE TO SAY YOU USED AI TO
- 36:11GENERATE THIS MAJOR HAVING A
- 36:13HARDER TIME DISTINGUISHING WITH
- 36:16OUR HUMAN BRAIN POWER IMAGES
- 36:18THAT ARE FAKE, VIDEOS THAT ARE
- 36:21FAKE, AND BY FAKE I MEAN AI
- 36:23GENERATED.
- 36:24WHICH BRINGS INTO QUESTION WHAT
- 36:26DO WE OWN?
- 36:27EVERY PROMPT THAT YOU PUT IN,
- 36:29AND JUST LIKE IN A SEARCH
- 36:31ENGINE, EVERY PROMPT THAT YOU
- 36:32PUT IN, IS A PIECE OF DATA THAT
- 36:35CAN BE USED BY A COMPANY ARE
- 36:38THEY BEING REGULATED?
- 36:39DO WE HAVE A SYSTEM TO LOOK AT
- 36:40WHO OWNS THAT DATA?
- 36:43APART FROM THE LIABILITY ASPECT
- 36:45WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT SOMETHING
- 36:47LIKE AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES OR
- 36:49ANYTHING LIKE THAT, WHO IS
- 36:51RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMAGE DONE
- 36:53BY AN AI GENERATED MAJOR AI
- 36:57GENERATED TEXT FOR INSTANCE
- 36:58THERE IS AN EXAMPLE OF AN
- 37:00ATTORNEY THAT USED AI TO
- 37:02GENERATE THE LEGAL BRIEF THAT
- 37:06LOOKED PERFECT BUT THE CITATIONS
- 37:09WEREN'T TO ANY CASES.
- 37:10IT TAKES SOME HUMAN SCRUTINY AND
- 37:13SOME LEVEL OF ANALYSIS STILL TO
- 37:15MAKE SURE THAT IT'S ACCURATE.
- 37:17BECAUSE AI IS GOING TO BE
- 37:19COMPELLED TO GIVE YOU AN ANSWER
- 37:20TO YOUR PROMPT WHETHER IT'S
- 37:22TRUE, OR NOT.
- 37:24AND SO WHILE IT IS STILL DEPEND
- 37:26END ON OUR INPUT WHILE WE CAN
- 37:28STILL TRAIN IT WE NEED TO TAKE A
- 37:31REALLY LONG VIEW A VERY BIRD'S
- 37:34EYE VIEW OF WHAT ALL OF THE
- 37:37IMPLICATIONS ARE.
- 37:38I PERSONALLY BELIEVE A LOT OF
- 37:41DISRUPTIONS WILL BE IN
- 37:41EDUCATION.
- 37:42IN TERMS OF WHAT DEGREES DO WE
- 37:44NEED IF WE CAN SKIP AHEAD AND
- 37:46YOU DON'T TO REPRESENTATIVE
- 37:48BRAY'S POINT YOU DON'T NEED A
- 37:50CALCULATOR ANYMORE NOBODY
- 37:53ANTICIPATED SMARTPHONES AT THAT
- 37:54POINT.
- 37:54THERE IS A LOT OF DISCUSSION
- 37:56ABOUT VERY SPECIFIC THINGS, BUT
- 38:00THE TECHNOLOGY ITSELF IS MUCH
- 38:02BROADER AND MUCH BIGGER THAN ANY
- 38:04ONE ISSUE OR ANY ONE IMPLICATION
- 38:08THAT WE MAYBE TALKING ABOUT
- 38:09TODAY.
- 38:10>> Renee: TO GET BACK TO A POINT
- 38:11ABOUT POLICY, LAWMAKERS IN MORE
- 38:14THAN 30 STATES, HAVE CONSIDERED
- 38:19AI LEGISLATION, KENTUCKY HAD THE
- 38:20AUTONOMOUS VEHICLE LEGISLATION
- 38:22THAT REPRESENTATIVE JOSH BRAY
- 38:23WHO IS WITH US, HOUSE BILL 135
- 38:26IT DID PASS BUT IT WAS VETOED BY
- 38:29THE GOVERNOR.
- 38:31THE LEGISLATURE CHOSE NOT TO
- 38:33OVERRIDE IT BUT IT WOULD HAVE
- 38:34SETUP A FRAMEWORK FOR ALLOWING
- 38:37FULLY AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES ON
- 38:39HIGHWAYS IN KENTUCKY.
- 38:40WHY DIDN'T IT GET OVER THE
- 38:42FINISH LINE?
- 38:42>> SO, WE RUN INTO --
- 38:47IT WAS SHORT SESSION RAN OUT OF
- 38:48TIME.
- 38:49WE PASSED IT ON THE LAST DAY OF
- 38:51DAY AND DID NOT HAVE THE ABILITY
- 38:53TO OVERRIDE THE GOVERNOR'S VETO.
- 38:55IT WAS A NEW CONCEPT WE HADN'T
- 38:57FILED A BILL LIKE THAT BEFORE.
- 38:59AND WHEN YOU START TRYING TO
- 39:01TALK ABOUT AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
- 39:03WITH PEOPLE, THEY LOOK AT YOU
- 39:05LIKE YOU GOT THREE HEADS.
- 39:07WHO CAN IMAGINE A CAR DRIVING
- 39:11ITSELF?
- 39:11BUT THE FACT IS THAT THERE ARE
- 39:1430 SOMETHING STATES THAT PASSED
- 39:18THIS.
- 39:19MISSISSIPPI BEING THE MOST
- 39:20RECENT.
- 39:20AND YOU KNOW, THEY ARE SO MUCH
- 39:24SAFER THAN WHAT HUMAN DRIVERS
- 39:26CAN DO.
- 39:27ONE OF THE BIG CONCERNS IS
- 39:29SAFETY.
- 39:30AND IT'S JUST THE UNFAMILIARITY
- 39:32WITH IT.
- 39:33BECAUSE THE IDEA OF A CAR
- 39:35DRIVING ITSELF FROM POINT A TO
- 39:37POINT B WE'RE JUST NOT
- 39:39COMFORTABLE WITH.
- 39:40BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE DATA
- 39:43WE'VE GOT OVER A THOUSAND
- 39:44FATALITIES IN KENTUCKY EVERY
- 39:45YEAR.
- 39:46YOU CAN EVERY WEEKEND IF YOU
- 39:47WATCH THE NEWS THERE'S BEEN A
- 39:49FATALITY SOMEWHERE.
- 39:50AND 86, 90% ARE BECAUSE OF HUMAN
- 39:54ERROR OR HUMAN INATTENTION OR
- 39:56NOT FOLLOWING THE LAW.
- 39:57AND THE TRUTH IS AUTONOMOUS
- 40:00VEHICLES THEY ARE ALWAYS PAYING
- 40:03ATTENTION.
- 40:03THEY CAN'T BREAK THE LAW.
- 40:07SO THE SAFETY --
- 40:10>> Renee: CAN THEY RESPOND TO A
- 40:11EMERGENCY SITUATION WHERE THEY
- 40:12NEED TO PHYSICALLY BRAKE?
- 40:14>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 40:14THAT IS PART OF THE FRAMEWORK
- 40:17THAT WE WERE LOOKING AT.
- 40:18THEY HAVE TO BE ABLE TO GO INTO
- 40:22A CONDITION THAT'S SAFE.
- 40:24IF THEY COME UPON A WRECK AND
- 40:26THEY CAN'T GET AROUND IT THEY
- 40:27HAVE TO PULL OFF TO THE SIDE OF
- 40:29THE ROAD.
- 40:30HAZARDS COME ON.
- 40:30IF YOU GET WEATHER YOU HAVE TO
- 40:32DO THE SAME THING.
- 40:35AND THEY ARE CONSTANTLY BEING
- 40:36MONITORED NOT LIKE THESE THINGS
- 40:38ARE OUT ON THEIR OWN.
- 40:40>> Renee: AND THERE CAN BE
- 40:41CAPACITY FOR HUMAN OVERRIDE?
- 40:44>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 40:45ABSOLUTELY.
- 40:46SO IN A SHORT SESSION IT WAS
- 40:50JUST AN IMMENSE TIME CRUNCH WITH
- 40:52SOMETHING SO COMPLICATED.
- 40:54AND IT'S KIND OF THE SAME ISSUES
- 40:55WITH TALKING ABOUT POLICY FOR
- 40:57AI.
- 40:58WE HAVE FORMED A WORKING GROUP
- 40:59TO LOOK AT SOME OF THE THINGS WE
- 41:01CAN DO ON TRANSPARENCY ON
- 41:04EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES ON
- 41:05DISCRIMINATION OR BIASES.
- 41:07THAT IS BEING LOOKED AT.
- 41:09BUT YOU KNOW, IT'S JUST SUCH A
- 41:12COMPLICATED ISSUE.
- 41:13AND IN A 30-DAY SESSION OR A
- 41:1660-DAY SESSION WHEN YOU'VE GOT
- 41:18ALL OF THESE YOU ARE TRYING TO
- 41:20GET A BUDGET OUT AND OTHER
- 41:22PRIORITIES IT'S REALLY DIFFICULT
- 41:24TO EXPLAIN TO PEOPLE KIND OF
- 41:26WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO WHEN
- 41:27THE AVERAGE PERSON PROBABLY
- 41:29ISN'T KEEPING UP WITH THE
- 41:31TECHNOLOGY AND WHAT IT CAN DO
- 41:34AND WHAT THE OPPORTUNITIES ARE.
- 41:37ONE OF THE ISSUES THAT WAS
- 41:38BROUGHT UP WAS KIND OF ALONG
- 41:40WITH AI IS THE POTENTIAL FOR JOB
- 41:43DISPLACEMENT.
- 41:43AND WHEN YOU LOOK IN THE
- 41:45TRANSPORTATION SECTOR WE'RE DOWN
- 41:4780,000 TRUCKERS NATIONWIDE.
- 41:49AND YOU KNOW YOU LOOK AT WHAT IS
- 41:50GOING ON IN TEXAS RIGHT NOW,
- 41:52THEY'VE GOT AUTOMATED PROGRAMS
- 41:55WHERE THEY ARE DELIVERING
- 41:56FREIGHT.
- 41:56THEY HAVE BEEN DOING IT FOR
- 41:58ABOUT A YEAR NOW.
- 41:59NO ISSUES.
- 42:02WE LOOK AT FARMERS IN WESTERN
- 42:04KENTUCKY.
- 42:04THEY ARE PLANTING THEIR CROPS
- 42:06HARVESTING THEIR CROPS AND IT'S
- 42:08ALL AUTOMATED.
- 42:10THEIR TRACTORS AND COMBINES ALL
- 42:12OF THAT IS DONE WITH GPS AND
- 42:15AUTOMATED.
- 42:15THE TEMPERATURE IS THERE.
- 42:17IT'S ABSOLUTELY SAFE.
- 42:19AND WE WILL BE FILE TO GO AGAIN
- 42:21AT THE FIRST PART OF NEXT
- 42:24SESSION.
- 42:24>> Renee: THERE WAS A CONTINGENT
- 42:26OF DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS
- 42:27THAT VOTED AGAINST IT THAT JOB
- 42:31DISPLACEMENT BEING ONE OF THE
- 42:32CONCERNS DO YOU THINK THE
- 42:33CONVERSATION WILL MOVE AND
- 42:34CHANGE MINDS TO ALIGN WITH THE
- 42:36BILL?
- 42:36>> I DO.
- 42:39LISTEN, ABSOLUTELY.
- 42:40LIKE I SAID, IT'S SO COMPLICATED
- 42:44THE ISSUE AND YOU'VE GOT TO BE
- 42:46COMFORTABLE WITH IT.
- 42:47DO YOU WANT TO GO BACK HOME TO
- 42:49YOUR CONSTITUENTS AND EXPLAIN
- 42:51SOMETHING HEY WE'RE VOTED TO
- 42:54TURN CARS LOOSE WITHOUT A DRIVER
- 42:55ON THE ROAD.
- 42:56WE HAVE TO MAKE LEGISLATORS
- 42:59COMFORTABLE WITH IT.
- 43:00WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE
- 43:01KNOW THAT THESE THINGS ARE SAFE.
- 43:04THEY ARE GOING ON AROUND US,
- 43:07WEST VIRGINIA, TENNESSEE, NORTH
- 43:08CAROLINA, MISSOURI, MISSISSIPPI
- 43:09ALL OF THE STATES AUTHORIZED
- 43:11THIS.
- 43:12OHIO AUTHORIZED THE TESTING OF
- 43:13IT.
- 43:14IT IS A TREMENDOUS ECONOMIC
- 43:16DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITY FROM
- 43:18KENTUCKY DIVERSE LANDSCAPE.
- 43:19WE HAVE FLAT LAND IN WESTERN
- 43:21KENTUCKY WHERE THE ROADS ARE
- 43:22STRAIGHT AND WE HAVE MOUNTAIN
- 43:24ROADS IN EASTERN KENTUCKY.
- 43:25WE'VE GOT CITIES LOUISVILLE,
- 43:28LEXINGTON, NORTHERN KENTUCKY.
- 43:30AND JUST THINKING ABOUT IN
- 43:33NORTHERN KENTUCKY, THE
- 43:35DISTRIBUTION HUB OUT OF THE
- 43:37NORTHERN KENTUCKY AIRPORT,
- 43:39AMAZON ALL OF THAT, TREMENDOUS
- 43:41ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
- 43:42OPPORTUNITY.
- 43:43WE WATCHED THESE HUGE
- 43:45INVESTMENTS COME IN THE OTHER
- 43:47STATES AND KENTUCKY IT'S TIME
- 43:48FOR US TO START LEADING THE WAY
- 43:50ON SOME OF THESE THINGS.
- 43:52>> Renee: DOES OUR ROAD
- 43:53INFRASTRUCTURE DOES THAT EVEN
- 43:55KEEP PACE WITH AUTONOMOUS
- 43:58VEHICLES I'M THINKING IN THE
- 43:59MORE CHALLENGING TERRAIN IN
- 44:01EASTERN KENTUCKY?
- 44:02>> IT DOES AND SPEAKING WITH THE
- 44:04TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT WHEN
- 44:05THEY ARE DESIGNING THE ROADS
- 44:07THEY ARE THAT THEY'VE GOT THIS
- 44:09STUFF IN MIND.
- 44:11THEIR TURN RADIUSES.
- 44:13PAINTING AND STUFF LIKE THAT.
- 44:16IT ABSOLUTELY DOES.
- 44:17BUT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I
- 44:20THINK WHAT WAS HARD TO
- 44:22UNDERSTAND IS THERE WAS A FEAR
- 44:23THAT ALL OF A SUDDEN WE LEGALIZE
- 44:26THESE AND TOMORROW YOU WILL SEE
- 44:29DRIVERLESS CARS ACROSS THE STATE
- 44:30AND IT COULDN'T BE FURTHER FROM
- 44:32THE TRUTH.
- 44:32THEY HAVE TO COME IN AND TEST
- 44:33THESE THINGS.
- 44:34THEY HAVE TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE
- 44:37SAFE.
- 44:37THEY HAVE TO MAP THEM.
- 44:38THEY HAVE TO INSTALL THEIR
- 44:41INFRASTRUCTURE BECAUSE THERE IS
- 44:43A TREMENDOUS INFRASTRUCTURE THAT
- 44:44GOES IN THERE FOR EVERY COMPANY
- 44:49FOR EVERYONE JOB THAT COULD BE
- 44:51DISPLACED THEY ANTICIPATE 8 MORE
- 44:53JOBS CREATED FOR MAINTAINING
- 44:56THIS.
- 44:56IT IS A TREMENDOUS OPPORTUNITY
- 44:58THAT KENTUCKY NEEDS TO BE ABLE
- 45:00TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF.
- 45:02>> Renee: AND CREATE THE HIGHLY
- 45:04SKILLED WORKFORCE WE HAVE TO
- 45:05KEEP UP WITH THAT.
- 45:07REPRESENTATIVE, I WANT YOU TO
- 45:08WEIGH-IN BECAUSE YOU ARE ONE OF
- 45:09THE 40 NO VOTES I BELIEVE ON
- 45:11HOUSE BILL 135 OF THE LAST
- 45:14LEGISLATIVE SESSION THAT ENDED
- 45:15MARCH 30TH.
- 45:16TELL US ABOUT YOUR OPPOSITION?
- 45:18>> YEAH, AND I AGREE WITH
- 45:21REPRESENTATIVE BRAY IN TERMS OF
- 45:25CONCEPTUALLY THE OPPORTUNITY FOR
- 45:26SOMETHING LIKE AUTONOMOUS
- 45:28VEHICLES.
- 45:28I THINK IT'S GOING TO HAPPEN.
- 45:29I DON'T THINK WE'RE NEAR HAVING
- 45:32THAT TECHNOLOGY YET.
- 45:32WE DON'T KNOW HOW SAFE IT IS.
- 45:34WE DON'T KNOW HOW IT REACTS TO
- 45:36EMERGENCIES.
- 45:37WE DON'T KNOW WHO IS IN CHARGE
- 45:38OF REGULATING THAT.
- 45:40ARE THESE PRIVATE COMPANIES THAT
- 45:42HAVE FLEETS OF THE VEHICLES IS
- 45:45THERE ANY GOVERNMENT REGULATION
- 45:46AND SAFETY AND OVERSIGHT FOR
- 45:48INDIVIDUALS?
- 45:48AND THOSE ARE THE CONCERNS THAT
- 45:51WERE BROUGHT UP IN ADDITION TO
- 45:52THE JOB DISPLACEMENT ASPECT OF
- 45:54IT IS THE LIABILITY PIECE WHO
- 45:56ACTUALLY IS GOING TO BE
- 45:57RESPONSIBLE FOR SOMEBODY GETTING
- 45:59HURT?
- 45:59WE DON'T KNOW HOW AI RESPONDS IN
- 46:02A SITUATION WHERE THEY MIGHT BE
- 46:05HAVING TO HIT A PEDESTRIAN OR
- 46:08AVOID HITTING MORE PEDESTRIANS
- 46:09ON THE SIDE.
- 46:10DO THEY HAVE TO SWERVE?
- 46:11HOW DO THEY AVOID HOW DO THEY
- 46:14DEAL WITH A RAINY ROAD?
- 46:18INCLEMENT WEATHER AND THE HILLY
- 46:20CURVEY ROADS IN EASTERN
- 46:21KENTUCKY.
- 46:22THERE'S JUST A LOT OF
- 46:25UNCERTAINTY SURROUNDING THIS
- 46:26TECHNOLOGY AS THERE IS WITH ANY
- 46:28NEW TECHNOLOGY.
- 46:28AND ALL OF THIS WAS BROUGHT UP.
- 46:31AND THERE IS A LOT OF REASONS
- 46:33WHY WE NEED TO NOT NECESSARILY
- 46:36JUST START LOOKING AT IT FROM A
- 46:38LIABILITY PERSPECTIVE AND
- 46:40ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PERSPECTIVE
- 46:41BECAUSE THIS TECHNOLOGY WITH AI,
- 46:44WE USE THAT ALREADY.
- 46:45WE HAVE THE ASSIST ACTIVE
- 46:48TECHNOLOGY IN CARS RIGHT NOW.
- 46:51AND AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES WILL USE
- 46:52A COMBINATION OF SENSORS AND
- 46:54CAMERAS AND RADAR AND SATELLITE
- 46:57AND AI TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
- 46:59VEHICLE ITSELF IS EN ROUTE ON
- 47:02THE SAFEST ROUTE THERE'S NOT
- 47:04OBSTACLES.
- 47:05BUT WE HAVE TO UNDERSTAND HOW IT
- 47:07REACTS TO A SITUATION.
- 47:10IT'S NOT GOING TO DO IT THE SAME
- 47:11WAY THAT A HUMAN DOES.
- 47:12AND I ALSO AGREE THAT THERE IS A
- 47:14LOT OF HUMAN ERROR WHEN WE ARE
- 47:16ON THE ROADS TODAY.
- 47:17I DON'T THINK I NEED TO TELL
- 47:20ANYBODY ABOUT PEOPLE BEING
- 47:24INATTENTIVE DRIVERS NOT PAYING
- 47:25ATTENTION.
- 47:26BUT I THINK WE HAVE TO STUDY THE
- 47:28ISSUE.
- 47:29WE NEED TO NOT ONLY STUDY THE
- 47:30ISSUE FROM A JOB DISPLACEMENT
- 47:32STANDPOINT BUT WE NEED TO STUDY
- 47:34THE ISSUE IN TERMS OF WHO OWNS
- 47:37THIS TECHNOLOGY HOW ARE THEY
- 47:39DEPLOYING THIS TECHNOLOGY AND
- 47:41WHERE ARE THEY DOING IT.
- 47:42BECAUSE I THINK WE NEED TO
- 47:43REALLY UNDERSTAND THE
- 47:46IMPLICATIONS OF THE BROADER
- 47:47PICTURE HERE.
- 47:47WE CANNOT SIMPLY LOOK AT ONE
- 47:49SMALL PIECE AND SAY THIS LOOKS
- 47:51GREAT AND IT'S GOING TO SAVE
- 47:53SOME MONEY FOR SOMEBODY.
- 47:55I THINK THAT WE HAVE TO LOOK AT
- 47:56THE BROADER IMPLICATIONS OF ALL
- 47:59OF THIS TECHNOLOGY AND I THINK
- 48:01THAT'S WHY STATES LIKE NEW YORK
- 48:02AND NEW JERSEY HAVE CREATED TASK
- 48:04FORCES AND PILOT PROGRAMS AND
- 48:07MONITORING PROGRAMS WHERE A
- 48:09HUMAN IS INVOLVED.
- 48:10BECAUSE UNTIL WE GET TO THAT
- 48:12POINT, I DON'T KNOW THAT WE AS
- 48:15POLICYMAKERS HAVE ENOUGH OF AN
- 48:17UNDERSTANDING OR ENOUGH
- 48:19INFORMATION ENOUGH DATA FOR
- 48:21OURSELVES ON THIS TECHNOLOGY TO
- 48:24UNDERSTAND HOW TO USE IT SAFELY
- 48:25AND HOW TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
- 48:29TRANSITION INTO USING THIS ON A
- 48:31BROAD SCOPE TO THE BEST WAY THAT
- 48:33WE CAN FOR OUR COMMUNITIES.
- 48:35>> Renee: I WANT TO GO TO THE
- 48:37DOCTOR ABOUT THIS TO ASK YOUR
- 48:39OPINION ABOUT AUTONOMOUS OR
- 48:41SELF-DRIVING VEHICLES AS AN
- 48:43EXAMPLE OF ARTIFICIAL
- 48:44INTELLIGENCE?
- 48:45>> WE HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO SAVE
- 48:47MANY LIVES.
- 48:48THEY OBVIOUSLY PAY ATTENTION.
- 48:49AND THEY DON'T GET DRUNK SO
- 48:52THERE IS A LOT TO BE SAID.
- 48:53THEY CAN COORDINATE WITH OTHER
- 48:55VEHICLES.
- 48:56THEY CAN HAVE ENOUGH ON THE ROAD
- 48:57IT WOULD BE A GREAT IMPROVEMENT.
- 48:59THEY ARE NOT GOOD IN NOVEL
- 49:02SITUATIONS.
- 49:03THEY ARE GOOD ON A HIGHWAY GOING
- 49:05STRAIGHT KEEPING THE LANE.
- 49:08IF SOMETHING UNUSUAL HAPPENS A
- 49:10LOT OF TIMES THEY GET LOST AND
- 49:12IT WOULD BE AN ILLUSION THE SUN
- 49:14HITS A SURFACE AT A CERTAIN
- 49:17ANGLE, THEY GET CONFUSED.
- 49:20YOU STILL NEED HUMANS IN THE
- 49:21LOOP FOR NOW.
- 49:23LONG-TERM OBVIOUSLY THAT IS
- 49:24GOING TO BE ONE OF A GREAT
- 49:26SUCCESS STORIES FOR AI WHERE WE
- 49:27CAN FULLY AUTOMATE
- 49:30TRANSPORTATION.
- 49:32EVENTUALLY, WE WILL AUTOMATE
- 49:33MOST JOBS.
- 49:34SHORT-TERM TERM WE WILL CREATE
- 49:36NOVEL JOBS AND THAT IS WHAT
- 49:39UNIVERSITIES ARE THERE FOR TO
- 49:40FIGURE OUT WHAT MAJORS WILL BE
- 49:42USEFUL IN A COUPLE YEARS AND
- 49:44GUIDING STUDENTS TOWARDS THOSE
- 49:46MAJORS AND AWAY FROM THE
- 49:48DEAD-END OCCUPATIONS WHICH WILL
- 49:50BE AUTOMATED BEFORE THEY
- 49:52GRADUATE.
- 49:53BUT LONG-TERM, ALL JOBS WILL BE
- 49:56REPLACED.
- 49:57IF YOU HAVE A SUPER INTELLIGENCE
- 49:59SYSTEM THERE IS NOTHING YOU CAN
- 50:01CONTRIBUTE AS I SAID BEFORE.
- 50:02>> Renee: I DO WANT AS WE I ONLY
- 50:04HAVE A FEW MINUTES LEFT IN OUR
- 50:06PROGRAM EARLIER THIS AFTERNOON I
- 50:09TALKED WITH COLLEGE PROFESSOR
- 50:11Dr. THACKER WHO TEACHES
- 50:13PHILOSOPHY AND ETHICS AND WORLD
- 50:15VIEW AND WRITTEN A BOOK ABOUT
- 50:17AI.
- 50:17AND HERE IS WHAT HE HAD TO SAY
- 50:19TODAY.
- 50:20>> PROFESSOR THACKER, THANK YOU
- 50:22FOR JOINING US.
- 50:23YOU ARE ALSO AN AUTHOR.
- 50:25YOUR BOOK THE AGE OF AI IS
- 50:27SOMETHING WE WANT TO TALK ABOUT.
- 50:29BECAUSE THAT IS OUR TOPIC ON KEN
- 50:34"KENTUCKY TONIGHT" THIS EVENING.
- 50:37>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
- 50:38>> Renee: TALK TO TO US ABOUT
- 50:41HOW THE AI, ARTIFICIAL
- 50:43INTELLIGENCE EXPANSION AND WHAT
- 50:44IT MEANS COULD DISRUPT HUMANITY
- 50:46AS YOU SEE IT?
- 50:47DO YOU SEE IT AS A DISRUPTION TO
- 50:50HUMANITY AND WHAT ARE YOUR
- 50:51CONCERNS ABOUT IT?
- 50:53>> YEAH, IT'S INTERESTING WHAT
- 50:55THE CONVERSATION SURROUNDING AI
- 50:57FOR MANY YEARS WE KEEP THIS
- 50:59TECHNOLOGY AT ARM'S LENGTH WE
- 51:01THOUGHT IT WAS SOMETHING ONE DAY
- 51:02WE MIGHT HAVE TO ADDRESS AND
- 51:03THINK THROUGH BUT REALITY IS
- 51:05IT'S ALL OF US HAVE BEEN
- 51:08UTILIZING ARTIFICIAL
- 51:09INTELLIGENCE EVERYDAY FROM
- 51:11COMMUNICATION PLATFORMS TO
- 51:11THINGS WE PURCHASE AND SHOP
- 51:13ON-LINE TO A HOST OF TOOLS AND
- 51:15TECHNOLOGIES.
- 51:17BUT WITH THE AI WE SAW RELEASED
- 51:1910 AND 12 MONTHS AGO,
- 51:23POPULARIZED IS RAISING REALLY
- 51:24INTERESTING QUESTIONS THAT IT'S
- 51:26PRESSING AND HELPFUL FOR ALL OF
- 51:27US TO STEP IN ON AND THINK
- 51:29DEEPLY ABOUT THE BIG QUESTION
- 51:32FUNDAMENTAL QUESTIONS THAT AI IS
- 51:34CAUSING US TO ASK.
- 51:35>> Renee: AND WHAT ARE THOSE
- 51:36QUESTIONS THAT YOU ARE ASKING
- 51:38WHEN IT COMES TO AI?
- 51:40>> THERE IS A HOST OF ISSUES THE
- 51:43CORE ESPECIALLY WITH JEN ACTIVE
- 51:46AI WE ARE HAVING THE DEEP
- 51:48QUESTIONS WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO
- 51:49BE HUMAN.
- 51:50A LOT OF THE FUNDAMENTAL
- 51:51QUESTIONS THAT WE'RE ASKING NOW
- 51:52ABOUT AI ARE NOT NOVEL OR NEW
- 51:55QUESTIONS AT ALL.
- 51:56THEY ARE QUESTIONS WE'VE ALWAYS
- 51:58ASKED AS HUMANITY WE ARE ASKING
- 52:00THEM IN LIGHT OF THE NEW
- 52:02OPPORTUNITIES THE NEW CHALLENGES
- 52:03AND OPPORTUNITIES BEFORE US.
- 52:04SO WITH AI I THINK WE ARE ASKING
- 52:07QUESTIONS WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO
- 52:08BE HUMAN.
- 52:09AND ONE OF THE THINGS THROUGH MY
- 52:10WORK AND THE WORK THAT I DO IN
- 52:12THE CLASSROOM AND WRITING AND
- 52:13DIFFERENT THINGS, IS JUST
- 52:15REMINDING FOLKS WHERE HUMAN
- 52:16DIGNITY LIES.
- 52:17IT ISN'T RELIANT ON THE THING WE
- 52:20DO.
- 52:20IT ISN'T THAT OUR VALUE OR WORK
- 52:22OR DIGNITY IS BASED ON WHAT WE
- 52:25DO BUT WHO WE ARE.
- 52:26FROM MY FAITH AS IMAGE BEARERS
- 52:28OF THE ALMIGHTY GOD THAT IS THE
- 52:31CORE OF HUMAN DIGNITY THAT NEEDS
- 52:33TO BE CENTER AND CENTER STAGE ON
- 52:34ANY TYPE OF REGULATION THAT WE
- 52:36CONSIDER, ANY TYPE OF USES WE
- 52:38CONSIDER, TO MAKE SURE WE KEEP
- 52:40WHAT IT MEANS TO BE HUMAN AT THE
- 52:42CENTER OF THESE CONVERSATIONS.
- 52:43>> Renee: AS YOU MENTIONED, AI
- 52:45HAS BEEN AROUND FOR A LONGTIME
- 52:47AND SOME SHAPE FORM OR FASHION.
- 52:49PARTICULARLY IN MEDICAL FIELDS
- 52:51FROM IMPLANTS TO OTHER DEVICES
- 52:53THAT HELP WITH MOBILITY.
- 52:55SO IS NOW A PARTICULAR
- 52:57CONCERNING TIME AS WE SEE THIS
- 53:01BURGEONING TECHNOLOGY REALLY
- 53:01TAKE ROOT AND WE'RE
- 53:03UNDERSTANDING MORE AND MORE OR
- 53:05PERHAPS TRYING TO UNDERSTAND
- 53:06MORE AND MORE EACH DAY, WHY IS
- 53:09IT A THREAT NOW MORE SO THAN
- 53:11PERHAPS IT WOULD HAVE BEEN 10
- 53:13YEARS AGO?
- 53:15>> I THINK A LOT OF IT COMES
- 53:17DOWN TO THE ESPECIALLY WITH JEN
- 53:21ACTIVE AI WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO
- 53:23BE HUMAN GET THRUST INTO THE
- 53:25CENTER OF THE CONVERSATION.
- 53:26BECAUSE WE HAVE LONG ASSUMED
- 53:27WHAT IT MEANT TO BE HUMAN WAS
- 53:29BASED ON THE THINGS WE DO IN
- 53:31CREATIVITY OR WRITING OR
- 53:32THINKING AND PROCESSING.
- 53:34AND NOW WE'RE STARTING TO SEE
- 53:35THESE JEN ACTIVE AI SYSTEMS TO
- 53:39CREATE THINGS AND WRITE TEXT AND
- 53:41MAKE VIDEO AND AUDIO.
- 53:42AND I THINK THAT'S FUNDAMENTALLY
- 53:44CHALLENGING A LOT OF THE
- 53:46ASSUMPTIONS WHAT WE THOUGHT IT
- 53:47MEANT TO BE HUMAN.
- 53:48BUT WHEN WE STEP BACK AND
- 53:50REALIZE THESE TOOLS THEY ARE NOT
- 53:51NEUTRAL.
- 53:52THEY HAVE DEEP VALUES THEY HAVE
- 53:54DESIGNS THEY HAVE PURPOSES.
- 53:55SO WHEN WE START TO THINK HOW
- 53:57TECHNOLOGY IS FORMING AND
- 53:58SHAPING US, AI PRESENTS AN
- 54:01OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO STEP INTO
- 54:03EXAMINE THE NATURE OF
- 54:04TECHNOLOGY, WHAT IS IT, HOW IS
- 54:05IT FORMING AND SHAPING US AS
- 54:08PEOPLE AND WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT
- 54:09IT.
- 54:10FROM MY FAITH PERSPECTIVE OF
- 54:12UNDERSTANDING THE CENTRALITY
- 54:14OFRIES CRAN ETHICS IS LOVING OUR
- 54:16GOD AND LOVING OUR NEIGHBOR AS
- 54:17OURSELF AND THAT IS CENTERED ON
- 54:20THE CONCEPT OF HUMAN DIGNITY AND
- 54:22THAT HAS TO BE THE CENTER OF ALL
- 54:25CONVERSATIONS WHETHER WE ARE
- 54:26TALKING ABOUT REGULATION OR THE
- 54:27INDUSTRY OR AS USERS ENGAGING IN
- 54:29THESE TECHNOLOGIES TO BE
- 54:31THOUGHTFUL AND SLOW DOWN AND ASK
- 54:32SOME OF THE FUNDAMENTAL AND AT
- 54:34TIMES VERY DIFFICULT QUESTIONS
- 54:36TO ADDRESS REALLY A LOT OF THE
- 54:39CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES
- 54:40BEFORE US.
- 54:41>> Renee: WELL, PROFESSOR
- 54:42THACKER, THE AGE OF AI IS YOUR
- 54:45BOOK.
- 54:45AND WE APPRECIATE YOUR JOINING
- 54:47US.
- 54:48ARE A PRO FOISER AT BOYS COLLEGE
- 54:51IN LOUISVILLE AND WE APPRECIATE
- 54:53THESE FEW MINUTES TO GET YOUR
- 54:56PERSPECTIVE ON THIS.
- 54:57AND WE HOPE TO SPEAK TO YOU
- 54:58AGAIN.
- 54:59THANK YOU SO MUCH.
- 54:59>> THANK YOU SO MUCH, RENEE.
- 55:01>> Renee: AS WE WRAP UP WITH 90
- 55:03SECONDS REMAINING I GO TO YOU
- 55:06DOCTOR YOU MADE SIMILAR POINTS
- 55:08AS Mr. THACKER ABOUT THE HUMAN
- 55:10ELEMENTS OF THIS AS WELL.
- 55:12I WILL LET YOU HAVE FINAL
- 55:13THOUGHTS ON THAT.
- 55:14>> I WOULD LIKE TO ECHO A LITTLE
- 55:16BIT THAT LANGUAGE AND MY CONTEXT
- 55:19THIS IS FOR ME AND FOR LOTS OF
- 55:21US WHO WORK IN EDUCATION A
- 55:24SEARCH FOR INQUIRY INTO WHERE
- 55:26THE DIGNITY OF EDUCATION IS AND
- 55:28THE CONTEXT OF ALL OF THESE NEW
- 55:30DEVELOPMENTS THAT MAY BE AT
- 55:33FACE-VALUE SEEM TO BE A
- 55:35REPUTATION OF WHAT WE HAVE DONE
- 55:36IN THE CLASSROOM.
- 55:37BUT WE'RE TRYING TO REFRAME IT
- 55:39AS AN INVITATION AS A WAY TO
- 55:42PROCEED WITH INFORMED CAUTION
- 55:44BUT CURIOSITY TO INQUIRE INTO
- 55:46HOW THIS COULD BE LEVERAGED AND
- 55:48HOW WE COULD INNOVATE WHAT WE
- 55:50ARE DOING THAT IS RESPONSIBLE IN
- 55:52A WAY THAT IS PRODUCTIVE AND
- 55:55AGAIN, PRESERVES THIS ENTERPRISE
- 55:56OF EDUCATING THAT WE'RE STILL
- 55:58INVESTED IN AT EYE HUMAN LEVEL.
- 56:01>> Renee: WELL, WE'LL HAVE TO
- 56:02LEAVE IT THERE.
- 56:05GENTLEMEN AND REPRESENTATIVE
- 56:06NIMS KULKSRNI WE THANK YOU FOR
- 56:07BEING WITH US.
- 56:09REPRESENTATIVE BRAY THANK YOU
- 56:10FOR JOINING US.
- 56:10WE WILL BE FOLLOWING THIS TOPIC
- 56:12MORE AS WE GO ALONG AND
- 56:14PARTICULARLY AS THE LEGISLATURE
- 56:15TAKES UP THIS ISSUE AND MORE.
- 56:17NEXT WEEK ON "KENTUCKY TONIGHT"
- 56:19WE'LL TALK ABOUT KENTUCKY'S
- 56:21ENERGY NEEDS AND JOIN US EACH
- 56:24WEEKNIGHT AT 6 EASTERN FOR
- 56:26KENTUCKY EDITION AND BILL BRYANT
- 56:28WILL BE HERE FRIDAY NIGHT TO
- 56:30DISCUSS THE WEEK'S NEWS.
- 56:31I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 56:32THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
- 56:33GOOD NIGHT.