Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - We're not allowed to speak in meetings
Transcript
- 0:06AV Super Friends Off the Rails,
- 0:07an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:09discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:11education.
- 0:12We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:14ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:15and everything in between.
- 0:17And because this conversation will almost
- 0:19certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:21we'll end up covering just about
- 0:22everything else.
- 0:23And now, the AV Super Friends.
- 0:31for october eight twenty twenty five it's
- 0:33the best sounding begrudgingly scheduled
- 0:36podcast in higher ed this is the av
- 0:38super friends off the rails episode number
- 0:40one hundred and twenty five that's a lot
- 0:42of them that's a nice brown number one
- 0:45twenty five it's kind of round sort of
- 0:47roundish it's in the quarters so uh well
- 0:49good morning good afternoon and whatever
- 0:51time it is when you realize wait a
- 0:54second
- 0:55We're recording and streaming this on the
- 0:57wrong day.
- 0:59Think about it.
- 1:00The weather's changing.
- 1:01Schedules are shifting.
- 1:02And just like the leaves,
- 1:03our guests keep blowing in from completely
- 1:05different directions.
- 1:07So scheduling people is difficult.
- 1:10There is.
- 1:11Falls here.
- 1:12The calendar is confused.
- 1:14My coffee has been reheated at least
- 1:17twice.
- 1:17So grab your pumpkin spice patch cable,
- 1:22plug into your nearest network switch,
- 1:24and hold on to your butts because you're
- 1:26tuned in for another Friday afternoon
- 1:28podcast adventure.
- 1:29Wednesday.
- 1:30On a Wednesday.
- 1:31Wednesday afternoon.
- 1:33Put ice in the coffee.
- 1:34It's now iced coffee.
- 1:36And then it gets watery coffee.
- 1:37Well, it's worth more.
- 1:39You can now sell it.
- 1:40You have more coffee that is worth more.
- 1:41And eventually it becomes room temperature
- 1:44watered down coffee that you find in like
- 1:46three hours.
- 1:46It all ends up being the same.
- 1:47It all goes down the drain.
- 1:48It all goes into the drain.
- 1:49Exactly.
- 1:49Making its way to the drain.
- 1:52Anyway,
- 1:52so let's say hello to today's panel.
- 1:54Our first panelist manages the art and
- 1:58science of hanging TVs in ways that
- 2:00inspire learning outcomes.
- 2:03He's an associate director of Pedagogical
- 2:05Display Solutions from Kansas City.
- 2:08Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 2:10I have found the best way is just
- 2:13put a flat on the tabletop so when
- 2:15they lay their head down for a nap,
- 2:16they're soaking it all in.
- 2:19That was a lot.
- 2:20That was a lot of words.
- 2:22That's like word salad.
- 2:27Jamie doesn't know.
- 2:27Don't need to.
- 2:30Our next panelist leads initiatives to
- 2:32replace legacy experiences with newer
- 2:35legacy experiences.
- 2:37He's a director of experiential
- 2:39infrastructure modernization.
- 2:41We're going to be amazed when we look
- 2:44back on how we're doing this today.
- 2:45It's going to seem exactly the same as
- 2:47it was when we did it yesterday.
- 2:49No, but it has to be newer.
- 2:52Yeah, soon to be old.
- 2:56Our next panelist has been making
- 2:57PowerPoint look like innovations since two
- 3:00thousand eleven.
- 3:00He's a senior specialist for institutional
- 3:03enablement systems.
- 3:04Greensboro, North Carolina, Mr.
- 3:06PowerPoint has no pilot.
- 3:09That is innovation.
- 3:10That was very forceful, Larry.
- 3:12That's great.
- 3:13I'm just saying it is.
- 3:15Well, no, we don't do that.
- 3:16We don't actually use it.
- 3:17But it's there.
- 3:18That's an extra two hundred dollars.
- 3:22Create me a slide.
- 3:23Would you like it to be four or
- 3:25three?
- 3:25Of course.
- 3:29Our next panelist measures productivity in
- 3:32vibes.
- 3:32Meetings attended and dashboard created.
- 3:36He is a vice president for integrated user
- 3:38success outcomes from Bowling Green,
- 3:40Kentucky.
- 3:40Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 3:41Yeah, our users lose success.
- 3:45Among other things, apparently.
- 3:47Yeah, they're just full of success.
- 3:50And finally,
- 3:51we're joined by a special guest panelist
- 3:53who ensures that meetings fail equally
- 3:56across all platforms.
- 3:58He's a coordinator of distributed
- 3:59collaboration environments from Dallas,
- 4:00Texas.
- 4:00Say hello to Mr. Chris Scott.
- 4:02Equal opportunity.
- 4:06Chris,
- 4:06you sure you want to hang out with
- 4:08us?
- 4:08Absolutely.
- 4:09It's this for the next hour and a
- 4:13half.
- 4:14So on today's show,
- 4:19we're going to discuss what to do when
- 4:20everything on a project just seems to go
- 4:22wrong.
- 4:22And we're going to discuss mixed use rooms
- 4:24that seem to need surrounding sound.
- 4:26But first,
- 4:27let's do a little bit of housekeeping.
- 4:29If you are catching us live as a
- 4:31recorded MP,
- 4:31remember we do stream live most Fridays.
- 4:33And I say most Fridays because today's
- 4:35Wednesday.
- 4:35But usually most Fridays at about three
- 4:38fifteen Eastern,
- 4:39twelve fifteen Pacific or whenever we get
- 4:41together.
- 4:42Yeah,
- 4:42you can join us for that on Twitter,
- 4:43LinkedIn, YouTube.
- 4:44And we can and you can't join us
- 4:46for that live on Blue Sky because they
- 4:47don't even follow us.
- 4:49Is that going on still?
- 4:51There's three people in Blue Sky for the
- 4:52three of you on Blue Sky.
- 4:54If you can't make it live,
- 4:56please do follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 4:58YouTube, Skype, and all that fun stuff.
- 4:59So there you go.
- 5:01If you have a topic that you want
- 5:02us to tackle,
- 5:03if you want us to look into something
- 5:04or you want to just yell about things,
- 5:06please send us an email at mailbag at
- 5:07avsuperfriends.com or hit us up on the
- 5:09aforementioned socials.
- 5:11While you're at it,
- 5:12please rate and review this nonsense on
- 5:14YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts,
- 5:16wherever you're listening to this.
- 5:17Please go in and leave a rating,
- 5:19preferably a positive one, but be honest.
- 5:23That helps because the more activity that
- 5:25ratings see,
- 5:26it moves it up in the algorithm,
- 5:27and more people who didn't mean to will
- 5:29inadvertently click on the link,
- 5:31and then they will...
- 5:32download and listen if we were just so
- 5:35terrible i think that's like that would be
- 5:37shocking too there's a comment have you
- 5:39heard the worst check this out that's
- 5:45Sound good, but worse content.
- 5:48Horrible.
- 5:49And finally,
- 5:50please go ahead and spread the word about
- 5:52this.
- 5:53Share with your friends, colleagues,
- 5:54enemies, AV consultants, integrators,
- 5:56manufacturer representatives,
- 5:57anyone who might have anything to do with
- 5:59this.
- 5:59Or maybe just not share with the
- 6:00consultants.
- 6:01Just lie.
- 6:01No, they need to hear it.
- 6:02That could be useful.
- 6:06The more people listen,
- 6:07the more likely we'll keep doing this
- 6:08nonsense,
- 6:09and eventually we'll do something
- 6:10worthwhile.
- 6:10But for now,
- 6:11it's just more of this stuff.
- 6:12All right, so there you go.
- 6:15And now that you've waited for it all
- 6:16week, you get to hear Justin sing along.
- 6:19Wait a minute.
- 6:19Hold on.
- 6:19I screwed up.
- 6:20Let's take a quick break.
- 6:22Jamie's freaking out over there.
- 6:27Hold your horses, Justin.
- 6:28We're going to take a quick break.
- 6:29We're going to do some Halloween-themed
- 6:30stuff here so Jamie doesn't murder me out
- 6:34of order here.
- 6:34All right.
- 6:36Back in thirty-eight seconds.
- 6:41He waits in the shadows of network
- 6:43closets.
- 6:44He stalks the hallways and forgotten
- 6:46classrooms.
- 6:48And he has only one target.
- 6:51Obsolete electronics.
- 6:55They call him the Ether Killmines.
- 6:59One jolt,
- 7:00and the zombie Blu-ray player finally
- 7:02stays down.
- 7:04No mercy for mixers.
- 7:06No parole for three sixty cameras.
- 7:10Etherkiller doesn't just end life cycles.
- 7:14He leaves nothing.
- 7:16But he wastes corpses.
- 7:19The Etherkiller.
- 7:22Old hearted amalgam.
- 7:31So there you go.
- 7:32You're a killer out there.
- 7:35So many.
- 7:37Yeah, there's lots of drops.
- 7:39Really?
- 7:40From me or from everybody?
- 7:41From everybody.
- 7:42So it's an equal opportunity drop.
- 7:44Well, all right.
- 7:45Thank you, StreamYard,
- 7:46for your inability to actually create a
- 7:47stream.
- 7:47It's in your name.
- 7:49Well,
- 7:49Wednesday is a known heavy hotbed of
- 7:51streaming activity.
- 7:52Mm-hmm.
- 7:53Is it?
- 7:54Allegedly.
- 7:55I thought you were being serious.
- 7:56I make shit up all the time.
- 7:57I think you're full of shit.
- 7:59Yep, full of shit.
- 8:00All right,
- 8:01so now you get to wait a little
- 8:03bit before you get to hear Justin sing
- 8:04along with our theme song here.
- 8:06Do-do-do-do-do.
- 8:16Yeah.
- 8:16By the way, Larry, interestingly enough,
- 8:17neither of the two computers I'm on right
- 8:18now have that little, like,
- 8:20your StreamYard link is poor.
- 8:22No.
- 8:23None of us are claiming on this side
- 8:25that things are bad.
- 8:26It's post.
- 8:27Apparently it's just Larry.
- 8:29I don't know because you guys don't let
- 8:31me in the back end.
- 8:32Don't worry about what's going on back
- 8:33here.
- 8:33Don't worry about it, man.
- 8:34You have to see the outboard stream.
- 8:36I'm like the outsider.
- 8:37Like, I'm not allowed in.
- 8:38You're just like,
- 8:39they've got all these buttons and gadgets
- 8:40and tools.
- 8:41It's just not the back end.
- 8:43Somebody let me in.
- 8:44It's like this whole thing.
- 8:46Y'all are really missing out.
- 8:48You were not given consent to come in
- 8:50the back end.
- 8:52Am I paying for the bill out of
- 8:54my account that I'm not allowed in?
- 8:56Is that right?
- 8:57It's not your account.
- 8:59It is now.
- 9:00Because you're not here on Fridays.
- 9:04All right.
- 9:04Moving on.
- 9:05And the news.
- 9:06So the news, it's not a news story,
- 9:10and I couldn't find the news story.
- 9:11There was no news.
- 9:12It was just like, by the way.
- 9:13It's a product announcement,
- 9:14and we're not covering it from the
- 9:15standpoint of this is a cool product sort
- 9:17of thing as much as,
- 9:17because we don't generally do that sort of
- 9:19a news story,
- 9:21but the ramifications of said product
- 9:23announcement.
- 9:24So this is the Zoom announcement.
- 9:27This is the Zoom video management
- 9:29platform.
- 9:30Okay, that sounds fine.
- 9:30Zoom can do video.
- 9:31Yeah, we get that.
- 9:31No, no, no.
- 9:33Panopto, Kaltura, Yuja.
- 9:35This is a shot right across the bow
- 9:37of every one of those.
- 9:38It is full feature.
- 9:39It brings all the Zoom stuff that comes
- 9:42with your Zoom rooms,
- 9:43and it works with non-Zoom rooms as well.
- 9:46It has big editing.
- 9:47All the stuff that you get in the
- 9:48other ones,
- 9:49but obviously very tight integration with
- 9:51Zoom.
- 9:51And best part,
- 9:52FTI integration across the board for all
- 9:54of your learning management systems,
- 9:55Sakai, Canvas, DTUL,
- 9:57whatever you're doing with Blackboard.
- 9:59So there are permissions things with that.
- 10:01I was on a webinar for this the
- 10:02other day.
- 10:03They spent a huge amount of time covering
- 10:05the LMS and LPI permissions.
- 10:06So Mark,
- 10:06I'm going to make sure we can figure
- 10:07out because I hear Raul in the other
- 10:08room shouting about that's not what it
- 10:11means.
- 10:11But no, it does.
- 10:12As a one point product,
- 10:14this will grow into it.
- 10:17I think the real interesting thing about
- 10:18this is I think clearly Zoom was leaving
- 10:21money on the table by immediately shipping
- 10:24all this stuff to some other platform and
- 10:28still integrate with your learning
- 10:30management system.
- 10:31Seems like a win-win to me.
- 10:33Thoughts?
- 10:35I think that's the baseline, like,
- 10:40welcome, Matt.
- 10:42I don't know if that's...
- 10:45really,
- 10:46I think this is more of an AI
- 10:47play, and you all can plug your ears,
- 10:49but from what I'm seeing in this marketing
- 10:50material,
- 10:52this is really showcasing the transcript
- 10:55pieces, the summaries,
- 10:57all the other search engagement,
- 10:59the tagging, all of that additional stuff,
- 11:01I think is really what this is.
- 11:04And they spent a huge amount of time,
- 11:05so if you get a chance to sit
- 11:06in on this,
- 11:07They spend a huge amount of time on
- 11:08that style of stuff.
- 11:09So all those, to your point,
- 11:10all the ancillary stuff that comes with
- 11:11Zoom meetings, calls, and all that,
- 11:13apply that to your entire learning
- 11:15management system video library.
- 11:19And all of the quizzes,
- 11:20all of that stuff dumps right in.
- 11:22So they're basically building on top of
- 11:24the platform and then integrating with
- 11:27your- Because I think that's the whole
- 11:30secret sauce here is that you need all
- 11:32that data context.
- 11:33No?
- 11:33Okay, I will be wrong.
- 11:35Go ahead, Bill.
- 11:35You said no.
- 11:36I was curious because- No, you said no.
- 11:38You said no.
- 11:39I was saying, why are you saying no?
- 11:40Because I was going to say as a
- 11:43campus that's moving off of Panopto,
- 11:47that had all those features because of the
- 11:49cost.
- 11:51I think the ease that this integrates and
- 11:54the way that they're handling the cost of
- 11:55their storage is going to be enticing to
- 11:58a lot of schools out there.
- 12:02I agree.
- 12:02I think the hardest part of this right
- 12:03now are those who've already made
- 12:06decisions and have one of these other
- 12:09service providers.
- 12:10Like jumping into team's room too fast
- 12:12because you're in the Northwest?
- 12:13No, no, maybe.
- 12:13But even if you're anywhere.
- 12:14I think this is perfect for the schools
- 12:16that maybe couldn't go out and do the
- 12:19Caljara thing or the Panopto thing.
- 12:21Yeah.
- 12:22But they've been using Zoom.
- 12:25Now this gives them a whole bunch of
- 12:27additional features that, from what I see,
- 12:31is every bit as good and as powerful.
- 12:33It gives them that AI strategy,
- 12:35all that piece baked in.
- 12:37Or maybe once before they weren't tall
- 12:38enough to ride that ride.
- 12:39Maybe this is now their gateway to
- 12:41actually start making use of that.
- 12:43I don't know.
- 12:45It's super cool and super intriguing to
- 12:46me.
- 12:49I think Mark's talking about us.
- 12:54We would be easy.
- 12:55We're right in the middle of trying to
- 12:57figure out what our lecture capture system
- 12:59is going to be because we've had a
- 13:00site and we're trying to figure out how
- 13:02to not do that anymore.
- 13:05This isn't being positioned as a lecture
- 13:06capture.
- 13:07It will do that.
- 13:08That's what I'm saying is maybe we can
- 13:11explore...
- 13:12leveraging this and not go into a full...
- 13:17Well, yeah,
- 13:19but that's a little bit of a training
- 13:22and adoption thing.
- 13:24That's what we do.
- 13:24I would say most of our Zooms that
- 13:28are happening in classrooms are
- 13:29single-person Zooms with just the
- 13:31instructor, the camera...
- 13:35See, that's smart.
- 13:36That's what we want.
- 13:38People, I think,
- 13:39overlook and automatically assume, well,
- 13:40I'm doing Zoom.
- 13:41Not necessarily.
- 13:42It's like, no.
- 13:44You need the camera and microphone just to
- 13:46capture what's going on.
- 13:48All that summary and stuff to feed that
- 13:50AI monster.
- 13:52That's the play of this to me.
- 13:54Yeah.
- 13:55And you might have distance students.
- 13:57It just might not be asynchronous,
- 14:00of course.
- 14:00When I say asynchronous, I mean,
- 14:02it might not be asynchronous.
- 14:02Exactly.
- 14:03But like, yeah.
- 14:05I got you.
- 14:05We're with you.
- 14:12This is like the consolidation of service,
- 14:15right?
- 14:16And yeah,
- 14:16I think if I was a counterproductive or
- 14:18one of those other like ancillary
- 14:20providers of media storage, now, arguably,
- 14:22they're doing the same kind of stuff.
- 14:24But I think we're all looking for more
- 14:26elegant approaches and where we can kind
- 14:28of collapse down some of that piece.
- 14:29And this is hard to not look at.
- 14:33Well, so my question is,
- 14:35what about the flip side?
- 14:36Do you, I mean,
- 14:37so we're using the Panopto integration.
- 14:40At some point,
- 14:41do you think Zoom will start turning off
- 14:45the tap users towards their video
- 14:48management platform?
- 14:50Do you know something we don't?
- 14:51Who do you know?
- 14:54I could see them taking a Microsoft
- 14:56approach.
- 14:57We're saying, hey,
- 14:57we're going to give you this,
- 14:58but this many queries per year,
- 15:00you're good for this point,
- 15:01but if you go over that,
- 15:02it's going to be a different cost model.
- 15:04We're not just going to let you do
- 15:05it for free anymore on the API.
- 15:07As you said, if they're, number one,
- 15:11trying to bring the small schools,
- 15:13pardon me, those who...
- 15:16you hit the nail on the head who
- 15:16weren't big enough to ride the ride.
- 15:18They're going to get some early adopters,
- 15:21right?
- 15:22But how, you know,
- 15:24what are they going to do in relation?
- 15:26And I'm sure your users are just like
- 15:28my users.
- 15:29They don't like change.
- 15:30They don't like learning new things,
- 15:32right?
- 15:33This is how I get out of my
- 15:35way.
- 15:37So yeah,
- 15:38how is Zoom going to change my users
- 15:41and push them to that platform?
- 15:43And I think that's the secret of the
- 15:46LTI.
- 15:47We're all looking at our LMS as the
- 15:49gateway to access our media and all of
- 15:51our course materials.
- 15:53It needs to align with those workflows
- 15:55very clean right now so that there's very
- 15:58little hiccups.
- 15:59I don't think the users care where the
- 16:01storage of their media sits.
- 16:03All they want to know is that when
- 16:04I go to my class, my page,
- 16:06it's there as the link works, right?
- 16:09And so they're addressing that, like, hey,
- 16:14here it is.
- 16:15It works very clean with these things,
- 16:17so you should see minimal disruption in
- 16:20your workflow.
- 16:21I think they've done a lot of due
- 16:23diligence.
- 16:24And those that have been close enough to
- 16:26know about Zoom have kind of sensed that
- 16:28this was coming over the last couple
- 16:30months.
- 16:31It just wasn't the big announcement they
- 16:33ever made.
- 16:33I don't know if there really was a
- 16:34big announcement.
- 16:35This might be one of those secret things
- 16:37that are just going to come.
- 16:41Jamie, you're all in, right?
- 16:43I got nothing.
- 16:47So, y'all remember... I mean, we have...
- 16:50Way to contribute, Jamie.
- 16:52It takes a person out of the steps
- 16:54here.
- 16:55I mean, for us,
- 16:58they're already using Zoom or Panoptic to
- 17:01record lectures and or calls of some sort,
- 17:06right?
- 17:07And it gets so much storage in Zoom,
- 17:10and then it pumps over to Panopto,
- 17:11and then automatically,
- 17:12so we're just taking out a middleman.
- 17:14Now, what's it suck for?
- 17:16Anybody that's signed a contract within
- 17:18the last six months with one of these
- 17:21other providers.
- 17:23It pays off to delay those decisions.
- 17:26Just keep delaying,
- 17:27and then something comes along,
- 17:29and you're like, hey, look at this.
- 17:31Never make a decision.
- 17:32I actually see some benefits in it as
- 17:34far as, you know, folks,
- 17:36one of the things that we consistently
- 17:38battle,
- 17:40my department really doesn't deal with the
- 17:43Zoom and licensing and everything else.
- 17:45It's there, it's provided,
- 17:46we need to not use it.
- 17:47Provide video and audio and let's just go.
- 17:50but um i think one of the things
- 17:53we continuously have to train people on is
- 17:56if they want to use a panopto for
- 17:58their classroom capture it's a different
- 18:00software a different step and and every
- 18:05zoom is ubiquitous now everybody knows how
- 18:08to use it and if you're on a
- 18:09different computer than the one that's
- 18:10provided how can you still so or your
- 18:12ipad how can you get
- 18:13an opt-in on your iPad to connect to
- 18:15your... This is done.
- 18:17It's federated.
- 18:18It's on the SS.
- 18:19I think Zoom's got some interesting things
- 18:21going on with it.
- 18:22They had their Zoom-topia not too long
- 18:24ago.
- 18:24And they technically announced it there,
- 18:27but it was...
- 18:29They're kind of sandbagging the
- 18:30announcement, in my opinion.
- 18:32They didn't come out guns blazing.
- 18:35So for me, it came out,
- 18:38and we'll see how it impacts.
- 18:41But in these...
- 18:43Going forward,
- 18:44we all know that our schools,
- 18:46our universities, businesses,
- 18:48everybody's going to be looking at
- 18:50contracts.
- 18:52They're going to be looking at budgetary
- 18:57impacts.
- 18:57I don't know the cost at the scale.
- 19:00I'm really intrigued on what that storage
- 19:01costs and that usage.
- 19:04I think the AI part is absolutely right
- 19:07on.
- 19:08I think now they can leverage their own
- 19:10algorithms inside their own little thing,
- 19:12and you're not
- 19:13parsing that out to another server,
- 19:16it's easier for them to sell the word
- 19:21security.
- 19:22It's easier for them to sell that.
- 19:24Anybody else pick up on that?
- 19:26I'm not going to say anything.
- 19:27You said something positive about AI.
- 19:29I was going to say that.
- 19:30That's how it starts.
- 19:31It's like that scene in Star Trek II.
- 19:33It's not that I don't have anything
- 19:33positive about AI.
- 19:34It's just I'm not using it very much.
- 19:36But I think you're going to see...
- 19:39a lot of universities,
- 19:40they're going to have to come out and
- 19:41say, well,
- 19:42what's your AI strategy and how are you
- 19:43addressing AI in the learning space?
- 19:45this is almost a way to get out
- 19:47of jail free here for folks say, Oh,
- 19:49we're just using we have her here, right?
- 19:51Bang, here's transcripts,
- 19:52we're using and we're bringing to the
- 19:53forefront.
- 19:53And my my guess is,
- 19:55you will see the model grow,
- 19:57you will see more capability,
- 19:58you'll see integrations with the big
- 20:00model, whether it be Claude or GPT,
- 20:01or whatever, you're gonna see it in this,
- 20:04right?
- 20:04Yeah, whatever, right?
- 20:05It's gonna be in there.
- 20:06Or maybe they'll give you the option to
- 20:07use your federated one of choice as an
- 20:09API MC people.
- 20:10I don't know.
- 20:11But it's gonna grow.
- 20:12This is setting the stage for that,
- 20:14I think,
- 20:15It's a slight tweak of what they've
- 20:17already had and just kind of refined it
- 20:21and rolled it out.
- 20:21So I think it's good on them for
- 20:24being able to rethink what they currently
- 20:25have and kind of redress it and spruce
- 20:28it up a little bit.
- 20:30Yeah, and so I guess,
- 20:32and I didn't bring this up at the
- 20:33outset, but like the...
- 20:35My interest in this, and Chris,
- 20:36you brought it up,
- 20:37like faculty don't like change.
- 20:38They'll figure out their workflows.
- 20:39They're experts in their field.
- 20:41They begrudgingly deal with the IT stuff
- 20:44because they have to,
- 20:45but they don't want to focus on that.
- 20:48Get that out of my way.
- 20:48Let me do my teaching.
- 20:49And everyone's comfortable with- Yeah,
- 20:51these slides,
- 20:51maybe these slides in seventy-six.
- 20:52I'm not updating them right now.
- 20:53Well,
- 20:54everyone got comfortable with Zoom a
- 20:57couple of years ago.
- 20:57They were legally required to get
- 20:59comfortable with Zoom.
- 20:59So everyone knows, oh,
- 21:00there's a red button and click record.
- 21:01Or if I'm in a Zoom room,
- 21:02it can automatically start recording.
- 21:04But it's like that delivery side where it
- 21:06shows up in my Canvas shell,
- 21:07in my Blackboard course.
- 21:09It shows up in my Sakai instance,
- 21:10wherever that is.
- 21:11As long as I can go to the
- 21:12thing that says videos and I can find
- 21:13my video.
- 21:14Oh, there's my video from this morning.
- 21:15Post.
- 21:16Let me write up some questions for it.
- 21:17Done.
- 21:17If that's there and that workflow is,
- 21:20let's say, ninety percent the same,
- 21:22I think we'll be OK.
- 21:23If that workflow is dramatically
- 21:24different,
- 21:25then there's going to be major problems
- 21:26with it.
- 21:26And I think Zoom is well aware of
- 21:28that and working on it.
- 21:29So I'm cautiously optimistic that that
- 21:33workflow will.
- 21:34streamline and right now it will save us
- 21:37a step because for us it's you click
- 21:39in zoom it goes to the temporary zoom
- 21:42storage it gets moved over to um to
- 21:45yuja there's like that extra intermediary
- 21:48step if this removes one of those even
- 21:52if that process is a little bit different
- 21:53but it removes one of those steps then
- 21:55i think everybody's happy
- 21:58Simplify it.
- 21:59And then you get all the Zoom stuff,
- 22:01the AI summaries, the whiteboarding.
- 22:05All the stuff you get in Zoom is
- 22:06now part of your course materials,
- 22:09which is kind of interesting.
- 22:10Sounds like we need to buy Zoom stuff.
- 22:13You keep saying that.
- 22:15Does AVSF have a stock?
- 22:17We don't have that.
- 22:19No, no, no, no, no.
- 22:20No, we're not going public.
- 22:23All right.
- 22:23You just ring the bell.
- 22:25This is escalating way too quickly.
- 22:28Simmer down a little bit.
- 22:29We're over time.
- 22:30Moving on.
- 22:31Yeah.
- 22:32All right.
- 22:33Any other thoughts on video forms,
- 22:36delivery, electric capture?
- 22:38I will say they did bring up,
- 22:39because a question came up,
- 22:40does it work with my appliances,
- 22:43my Epifans, my Panoptos?
- 22:45No.
- 22:46Not Panopto.
- 22:49extron and what's the other one that
- 22:50starts the nest i'll think of a minute
- 22:51anyway the answer is yes it does you
- 22:53can you can say as long as you
- 22:54set up those permissions it can still
- 22:55deliver to that so you know i think
- 22:57they're aware of all the boxes they need
- 22:59to tick so at least they come out
- 23:01with a one point oh that's full featured
- 23:03or or stop using boxes kind of seems
- 23:06like this industry is going to where
- 23:09universities are going to be like
- 23:11microsoft or zoom
- 23:13campus we already are everybody uses
- 23:15microsoft to some degree like our first
- 23:19like season shows we did like now this
- 23:23is well i thought zoom was kind of
- 23:24going away it's like they haven't really
- 23:26done anything in a while their stock has
- 23:28been going down we haven't talked a lot
- 23:29about them they haven't released any new
- 23:31stuff and then here they are kind of
- 23:33like oh now it's
- 23:35Pretty big news.
- 23:36So kind of forecasting the future.
- 23:40Ten minutes ago, Justin said,
- 23:41should we buy Zoom stock?
- 23:43Now he goes on saying it's been going
- 23:45down.
- 23:45Well, I was asking you,
- 23:46so you've been saying it's been going
- 23:48down.
- 23:49He's driving it down so he can buy
- 23:52early in the month.
- 23:52Buy low, sell high, projecting forward.
- 23:55Is that what I've been doing wrong?
- 23:57Oh.
- 23:59It's not hard.
- 24:01It's easy.
- 24:02All right.
- 24:02Let's take a quick break.
- 24:04We'll take a quick break.
- 24:05We'll come back.
- 24:05We're going to talk about projects going
- 24:07awry and all that fun stuff.
- 24:09Oh, great.
- 24:12The AV Super Friends are sponsored by
- 24:14Computer Comforts Incorporated.
- 24:16CCI has been building tech furniture for
- 24:18the education market since nineteen eighty
- 24:20seven.
- 24:22Instructor lecterns, computer lab tables,
- 24:24collaborative tables and active learning
- 24:26clusters are just a few of the many
- 24:28innovative products made by CCI.
- 24:31Speaking of lecterns,
- 24:32Computer Comforts has just released
- 24:34Evolve.
- 24:35If you're looking to future-proof your
- 24:36classroom,
- 24:37Evolve is the Swiss Army knife of
- 24:39lecterns.
- 24:40Seriously,
- 24:40this flexible lectern does it all.
- 24:43Not only is Evolve sit-to-stand and
- 24:45ADA-compliant,
- 24:46it's also packed with tech-friendly
- 24:49features.
- 24:50And the best part?
- 24:51It ships fully assembled and ready for
- 24:53action.
- 24:54Check out the ninety-second video to see
- 24:57all the options.
- 24:58Visit ComputerComforts.com slash Evolve.
- 25:06Oy, oy, oy.
- 25:07Let's see this one, right?
- 25:07Topic.
- 25:07Topic.
- 25:07Topics.
- 25:08Topic one starts now.
- 25:14So topic one.
- 25:17What happens when projects don't go well?
- 25:19What happens when we get handed a project
- 25:21that's in flight?
- 25:23Things haven't been fully well thought
- 25:27out.
- 25:27Over there.
- 25:28What the heck is this thing?
- 25:30Why is that over here in this spot?
- 25:31This is a pretty broad discussion.
- 25:33Justin,
- 25:33do you want to maybe give us a...
- 25:36No.
- 25:38I prepped him this morning.
- 25:39Justin,
- 25:39can you give us a five-minute version?
- 25:43Two minutes.
- 25:44No, he's been muted.
- 25:45Sixty seconds.
- 25:47this is what i mean by them you
- 25:49know gaslighting me and keeping me out of
- 25:51the admin panel so part of this and
- 25:55and i don't think everybody on this call
- 25:58thinks that this is important based on
- 26:00prior conversations maybe chris does
- 26:02dinner wait chris but you other i don't
- 26:05know what it is yet one two three
- 26:07four the other four just listen
- 26:15When we're talking about what happens when
- 26:16a project goes bad, what are we doing?
- 26:21Yeah, let's see what happens.
- 26:24People normally have some kind of control.
- 26:26So there's a big difference here where you
- 26:29know about the project,
- 26:31maybe you don't have input in it,
- 26:34whatever it is,
- 26:35versus having a project where you do care
- 26:38about it, that you want input,
- 26:41but you're told, no,
- 26:42we don't want your input.
- 26:44We don't need you for this project.
- 26:47So that's kind of setting the expectations
- 26:50of, okay, well,
- 26:53the people running this project and the
- 26:54project managers think that they can do
- 26:57this without us and do a better job
- 27:00because we're always last ones in,
- 27:02so we always get blamed for it.
- 27:04We all know how construction projects
- 27:06work,
- 27:07whether it's really
- 27:08they be people's fault or not, whatever.
- 27:12So here we are with a building on
- 27:15our campus where we were basically told
- 27:17that we don't need IT.
- 27:20And so time goes on.
- 27:22This has been the course of two years.
- 27:25And
- 27:27Here we are,
- 27:28and we've had a lot of debates behind
- 27:29the scenes about it,
- 27:30especially Mark and I,
- 27:32about why don't you just go fix it?
- 27:33It's like, well, when you have contracts,
- 27:37let's say school starts and the project's
- 27:39not done,
- 27:40and there's contracts saying that this
- 27:42company has to finish before you can even
- 27:44help.
- 27:45You're not even allowed to self-perform on
- 27:47the job.
- 27:48You are instructed not to go into the
- 27:51building and do any work.
- 27:53So there's not really anything you can do.
- 27:55You have to watch it crumble.
- 27:57Even though you know how to fix it,
- 27:58you could probably fix it one day with
- 28:01you and your team.
- 28:02Then there's the other projects where you
- 28:05are involved, things go awry,
- 28:06and you jump in because you have a
- 28:08stake in the game because you are a
- 28:10true stakeholder.
- 28:11So there's a lot of differences in how
- 28:13you handle those two scenarios and those
- 28:15two projects.
- 28:16How much ownership do you have?
- 28:18Because if you're told the whole time,
- 28:20we don't need you,
- 28:21and then things blow up at the end,
- 28:23and they're still telling you,
- 28:25we don't need you,
- 28:27there's nothing you can do.
- 28:28You just have to watch your partner.
- 28:30You're talking about process, really.
- 28:33It's all about process.
- 28:35This is so wide.
- 28:36Because I think if the public had access
- 28:39to the back channel, AVSF,
- 28:42Drama that it has been unfolding around
- 28:46this project Here we are classes start
- 28:59tomorrow Whatever you just rattled off for
- 29:03the last three minutes may be true may
- 29:04not be true.
- 29:05I
- 29:06What actions do you take,
- 29:08whether legal or not?
- 29:12Because I agree with you.
- 29:13Yes, we may have been told in contracts.
- 29:16I don't really give a shit.
- 29:18the instructor is going to show up there
- 29:20tomorrow morning and expect that to turn
- 29:23on or it's not pretty and it won't
- 29:27be perfect.
- 29:27And it's going to require people running
- 29:31and jumping through hoops and all these
- 29:32things and just to accommodate.
- 29:35But I think we navigate that differently.
- 29:37And I think.
- 29:39I completely agree.
- 29:42Like, I think it's,
- 29:43because me and mark come from the
- 29:45production back way to make that event
- 29:48happen it's let me ask you then these
- 29:52two questions so if you're in that
- 29:53production and you see the fire happening
- 29:57on stage and your boss says if you
- 30:00touch that you're fired what do you do
- 30:03I'm going to save people's lives.
- 30:05So you're going to go up there.
- 30:07I'm not literal fire,
- 30:08just an AV nightmare.
- 30:10I'm going to do what I can to
- 30:11make it work.
- 30:11You're not saving lives.
- 30:13So you go make it work,
- 30:14and then you lose your job the next
- 30:15day.
- 30:15And you're okay with that.
- 30:17I don't think you would have lost your
- 30:18job.
- 30:18But that's a story for a different time.
- 30:21I think the moment that the classes
- 30:25begin...
- 30:28We've taken ownership.
- 30:29The campus is now liable for that whole
- 30:31experience.
- 30:32Whether, whatever or not, don't care.
- 30:34Whatever project fumbling happened,
- 30:36and we've been in the exact same boat
- 30:37you've been in, Justin.
- 30:39And we have come in.
- 30:40So you've been told that we don't want
- 30:42your help or knowledge or expertise on
- 30:44this?
- 30:44We've been told this is not your scope
- 30:46at all.
- 30:47And you're not doing anything.
- 30:50But we know at the end of the
- 30:51day,
- 30:52the Monday classes begin when the deadline
- 30:54has met that time.
- 30:54So let me ask you this question.
- 30:56We have to do something.
- 30:57Do you literally like...
- 31:00Do you literally hold the integrator's
- 31:02hand and pull them out of the room
- 31:03and say,
- 31:04get out of my way so I can
- 31:06finish?
- 31:07They're not going to be there at that
- 31:08point anyway.
- 31:08And I can put a system together that
- 31:11bypasses their stuff.
- 31:12And that's what we're talking about.
- 31:15We need to run cap cables and extenders
- 31:18and taping them down and providing things.
- 31:20I mean, I get that.
- 31:22But we can't do that because the
- 31:23electrical inspector said that we can't by
- 31:25state law.
- 31:26Like we were not able to do that.
- 31:27Can't and won't are not the same thing.
- 31:30You won't do that because somebody told
- 31:32you you shouldn't.
- 31:33We all like our jobs.
- 31:34That's not necessarily true.
- 31:37We were told we weren't needed.
- 31:39And I think this speaks to the internal
- 31:42minutia.
- 31:43And I think Larry and I may be
- 31:45on the same page.
- 31:47It happens.
- 31:49Just keep talking.
- 31:52It's interesting because I think your
- 31:55point's a hundred percent valid, Justin,
- 31:56is that there are legal issues that we
- 31:59often will have to confront.
- 32:01And that is contract.
- 32:03And yes,
- 32:04if you go in and you change something,
- 32:05yes, you're giving that integrator an out.
- 32:07I get it.
- 32:08So you have to do what you can
- 32:09to not address what they have done and
- 32:11leave that intact.
- 32:12Now, if the WKU and the client said...
- 32:17We are tired.
- 32:18The client being the school that I'm
- 32:19talking about, right?
- 32:20The college, if you will.
- 32:22We are tired of this integration,
- 32:24this whatever's happening.
- 32:26Why is all my stuff not working?
- 32:28Please come help us.
- 32:30We would be the first ones in there
- 32:31helping because now you get out of our
- 32:35way so we can come save the day.
- 32:38I'll do my best now to come over
- 32:39to your side, Justin,
- 32:40is that sometimes in higher ed,
- 32:43you have to make a very definitive
- 32:45problem.
- 32:47And IT needs a problem so that a
- 32:50project can begin.
- 32:52And so sometimes we have to get through
- 32:54very elaborate things.
- 32:55We've taken ownership of the building and
- 32:57contractually the systems.
- 32:58And we've been consulted and told people,
- 33:00what you're going to do will not work.
- 33:02And we've had to take ownership of broken
- 33:04systems.
- 33:05Chris, you lived it with us.
- 33:08And we'll eventually do that.
- 33:09It only took like a year.
- 33:10Right.
- 33:11And so whenever that's the one that goes
- 33:12out or not.
- 33:12You're going to be able to sense of
- 33:14it.
- 33:14I don't know.
- 33:15But at the end of the day,
- 33:17leadership often knows.
- 33:18It's a threshold for your leadership to
- 33:20say, I understand the contract,
- 33:24and I understand that that language is
- 33:25there.
- 33:26However,
- 33:26the impact on student and teaching and
- 33:29experience
- 33:30that is being compromised way too much
- 33:33right now.
- 33:34We have to do something.
- 33:35And they still went after the contractor
- 33:36and said, contractor, you must finish.
- 33:39And it gave them a deadline and the
- 33:40deadline passed and nothing happened.
- 33:42I think there was an overstep and you
- 33:44couldn't do anything.
- 33:45I think that's a misstep.
- 33:47There's things you could have done.
- 33:49Oh, I agree with that.
- 33:50The jurisdiction of actions were not
- 33:52correct.
- 33:52We could have fixed it in one day.
- 33:55I know that.
- 33:56One hundred percent fact.
- 33:58We mentioned that.
- 34:00You get them out of our way,
- 34:02we'll go in there and fix it.
- 34:03But we can't have two people working on
- 34:05the same system while they're trying.
- 34:08They're getting yelled at by people.
- 34:09They're trying to get paid.
- 34:11We're in their way,
- 34:12two people in one rack.
- 34:13I just don't understand.
- 34:15Temporary measures are one thing.
- 34:16Oh, that works.
- 34:17Adjusting other people's work is a
- 34:19different thing.
- 34:20That's not what I'm saying.
- 34:22That's what I was going to get into.
- 34:24I have been in this situation, and I...
- 34:28We'll typically let it burn for a few
- 34:31days, maybe the first week,
- 34:33just to kind of prove the point of...
- 34:34I told you.
- 34:38Yeah, I told you so.
- 34:40I mean, sometimes we have to say,
- 34:42I told you so.
- 34:43Like, you employ me to be here.
- 34:46to be an expert of this.
- 34:47To not let this happen.
- 34:49To not let this happen.
- 34:51And so there are, but in that time,
- 34:55let's say the display's already hung.
- 34:57I've been known to put, like,
- 35:01give them a remote control and an HDMI
- 35:03cable to the second input.
- 35:06And it's just,
- 35:07it literally is hanging from the ceiling.
- 35:09That way, we're not programming,
- 35:10we're not screwing with shape.
- 35:12Oh, I did it.
- 35:13They can still do something.
- 35:16And now I'm quasi-hero,
- 35:19but I've still kind of let it die.
- 35:22I want some pain to be felt a
- 35:26little bit.
- 35:28But then again, we have to...
- 35:32In your case,
- 35:33some administrator somewhere said, by God,
- 35:36we're going to have courses no matter
- 35:38what, hell or high water,
- 35:39this is going to happen.
- 35:41And somebody in your case went so far
- 35:44as to say, stay out of it.
- 35:48You know, you said,
- 35:49and this is where the I told you
- 35:50so comes in, like, well...
- 35:54Are you sure?
- 35:55Because I can do this and we can
- 35:57still hold their feet to the fire.
- 35:59But most of the time when it gets
- 36:01up to that final date,
- 36:02they've already got three quarters of the
- 36:04payment.
- 36:05So they're walking away from a quarter of
- 36:07their fee.
- 36:07I don't really care if they get paid
- 36:08or not.
- 36:09It's not really what I care about.
- 36:10It's about the faculty and students.
- 36:14And we're all on the same page with
- 36:15that because you have too many guardrails
- 36:18put up by administration.
- 36:20Yeah.
- 36:21And it just... Did you ever...
- 36:24You start asking them, like,
- 36:27we want them to be financially punished.
- 36:29We want to push back on integrated.
- 36:30We want to do this,
- 36:31but it's just not feasible.
- 36:32Sometimes, I've even said that.
- 36:34It's like, look,
- 36:35how much do you owe them?
- 36:36Well, like, ten grand?
- 36:37Screw it!
- 36:38I have no idea what those numbers look
- 36:41like.
- 36:42We're ruining courses right now.
- 36:44But in a conversation... Three years.
- 36:48Yeah.
- 36:50it's one thing to point out the problems
- 36:54and that's great and then you can seem
- 36:55like the bad guy right yeah this is
- 36:58why it never gets involved all they do
- 37:01is and you've you've voiced a lot of
- 37:03that through this journey
- 37:06But do we all come to the table
- 37:09with solutions?
- 37:11So I wrote five thousand five hundred
- 37:13words when the design review came through.
- 37:16Five thousand five hundred and seventy
- 37:18three.
- 37:18I'll never forget that number.
- 37:19That's how many words was in my write
- 37:21up.
- 37:22Problem.
- 37:23Solution.
- 37:24Problem.
- 37:25Solution.
- 37:25So what they did.
- 37:27But that's addressing like wholesale
- 37:29design.
- 37:29Everywhere that added scope and added
- 37:31cost.
- 37:33Guess what?
- 37:34Chris knows.
- 37:36They, yes, we'll do that.
- 37:38Anything that reduced cost and added
- 37:41efficiency and reduced profit.
- 37:43Right.
- 37:44I don't want to do that.
- 37:48And I was like, no,
- 37:48you can't just this, not that.
- 37:50Because now you've got to do more
- 37:52problems.
- 37:53I'll take one.
- 37:54It was just so many problems with that
- 37:56many solutions.
- 37:58One solution per problem.
- 38:00But I'm talking about after the fact.
- 38:02So you saw this a long time ago.
- 38:05You saw a light coming in this dark
- 38:06tunnel.
- 38:07So the problem was,
- 38:08I don't think everybody understands the
- 38:09problem.
- 38:10But when it got closer, did you,
- 38:11but did you come to the table?
- 38:12Like,
- 38:12here's how we can remediate to make things
- 38:13functioning right now.
- 38:15Not,
- 38:15not addressing the programmatic things and
- 38:16all the installations,
- 38:17but we can come in the room and
- 38:18the cloak of darkness and middle of the
- 38:20night and lay down in a couple of
- 38:21extenders and get things functioning.
- 38:22Oh,
- 38:22people know that we've done that before.
- 38:24Right.
- 38:24That's what I'm saying.
- 38:25Were you turned down on that before?
- 38:26But did you come to the table and
- 38:27express that?
- 38:28No, any solution,
- 38:29we don't step foot in the building.
- 38:30It's under contract.
- 38:32It's construction.
- 38:32It's not even TCO.
- 38:35And there's, I think,
- 38:35where we get a little bit sore.
- 38:37We're not allowed.
- 38:38If you're not allowed,
- 38:39then how the hell are the students in
- 38:40there?
- 38:41So how would you...
- 38:44Aha, now we're asking correct questions,
- 38:46Mark.
- 38:46They're not.
- 38:47Now we're asking correct questions, Mark.
- 38:50Because they were in there.
- 38:52Do they have networks and computers?
- 38:54So everybody but AVs?
- 38:56I'm curious of how,
- 38:57if you don't have TCO,
- 38:58how anybody's in the space.
- 39:00Full stop.
- 39:01I don't care what trade you are.
- 39:02Great question.
- 39:03I don't know when the TCO happened.
- 39:06I don't know because we were not part
- 39:08of the process.
- 39:09We were kept out.
- 39:10We're just hearing things from the
- 39:12inspector because the inspector knows us
- 39:14because they inspect our jobs too.
- 39:16Is this a Good Old Boys Club thing?
- 39:18No, not for us.
- 39:22We're just being told.
- 39:24No, we just went down to the diner,
- 39:26had a cup of coffee and Danish.
- 39:28We just heard all this stuff.
- 39:30Passed a hundred dollar bill across the
- 39:31table.
- 39:31No problem.
- 39:32So the fallout was the fallout of this
- 39:35was semester started in mid-August and
- 39:39every room that was a classroom was
- 39:43was blinking the entire time up until
- 39:47Monday.
- 39:48It's fall break.
- 39:50And the manufacturer,
- 39:53every display flashing.
- 39:55For content, you know, HDCP stuff,
- 39:59network issues, things like that.
- 40:00And these are all network islands.
- 40:01It's not like IT was integrating and doing
- 40:03all this fancy.
- 40:03It's just network islands, right?
- 40:06And so, no, they're on Netgear switches.
- 40:10something so uh well ended up being hdcp
- 40:15stuff but they flew the uh manufacturer
- 40:17out who you know who we know well
- 40:21who fixed the issue in a day or
- 40:24so which is basically yeah that's like
- 40:29just log in push this button push this
- 40:30button and you're done
- 40:33Right, Mark?
- 40:34Why is that so hard for the integrator
- 40:37to do?
- 40:40But you know what happened?
- 40:41The integrator consultant for the synopsis
- 40:44was of the situation.
- 40:46It has to be the PCs that were
- 40:49given to us by WKU IT.
- 40:51So it's IT's problem.
- 40:53Let's just all agree it's never our fault.
- 40:55It's always somebody else's fault when it
- 40:57comes to construction.
- 40:58No, no, no.
- 40:59It's like, wow.
- 41:00And so it's like, okay,
- 41:01so if I plug in this other laptop
- 41:02that doesn't have a WQ image on it
- 41:04and it still blinks,
- 41:05how is that an IT problem?
- 41:07Owner furnished, buddy.
- 41:09Owner furnished.
- 41:09But it wasn't owner furnished.
- 41:11It was just a random laptop.
- 41:13It was their laptop.
- 41:14It was their laptop.
- 41:16Yeah,
- 41:17I think there's wholesale construction
- 41:20process here.
- 41:23Let's shift a little bit.
- 41:27How about go into turnover?
- 41:29Here's the end of the story.
- 41:30Yeah.
- 41:31Is that it resulted in patient...
- 41:36That's going to get met out.
- 41:37We oversee the AV project process.
- 41:42We sign off on the basic programming,
- 41:44turn display on and off, hear sound,
- 41:46all that great stuff, cable labels.
- 41:48Then our team comes in and configures and
- 41:50programs everything after the building's
- 41:53turned over to us.
- 41:54We're going to need to know the date
- 41:55when your team goes in there.
- 41:57This is the new project, Cherry Hall.
- 41:59This is not the other one.
- 42:04So this project aside, Justin,
- 42:07Have you ever rappelled down from the
- 42:08rafters with an extender and a cat five
- 42:10reel and an adapter with a computer and
- 42:12a projector to make it work?
- 42:14Yeah.
- 42:14Yeah.
- 42:14Okay.
- 42:15And I think that's the story is why
- 42:16I think we,
- 42:16when the time comes and we're allowed to
- 42:18roll up our sleeves, we're allowed to,
- 42:20they allowed you to think I'm not going
- 42:21to knowledge.
- 42:21That's the problem with this.
- 42:23That's the whole problem with this
- 42:25project.
- 42:25And so, but I think,
- 42:27is that normal for us to say, yes,
- 42:29push comes to shove,
- 42:30whether the night before or early in the
- 42:33morning before classes is, is,
- 42:34normal for us to roll out there and
- 42:38get out there and put in temporary
- 42:40solutions.
- 42:40I've got a system right now that needs
- 42:43a touch panel and we're putting the old
- 42:45button panel back in just because just to
- 42:47get it working because we're not done yet.
- 42:50I mean, they'll be fine.
- 42:51They'll have class on Monday.
- 42:53I have an extender.
- 42:55We do that all the time.
- 42:57So to Mark's point, about a decade ago,
- 42:59we had a new academic event.
- 43:02Someone wanted to buy one
- 43:05giant HD-based eSwitch for the whole
- 43:09thing.
- 43:09Good for you.
- 43:13We're doing that again on YouTube right
- 43:15now.
- 43:20We fought so hard to get Apple TVs.
- 43:23The projector only has the DVI input left.
- 43:29So you're never going to get audio.
- 43:31And I was like, what?
- 43:33And they go, yeah,
- 43:33it only had one HDMI input.
- 43:35And we used it for the system.
- 43:38And so my boss and my office mate,
- 43:46they met every class.
- 43:49every hour from January to spring break.
- 43:53And they were completely out of the
- 43:55rotation for half a semester.
- 43:57They took no other calls.
- 43:59They took on no additional work.
- 44:01And that's all they did was just shuffle
- 44:04up and down.
- 44:04How was it coming in late at night
- 44:05to actually change the program?
- 44:06The integrator.
- 44:08No,
- 44:08the integrator came in at spring break
- 44:10with a parachute and bought the correct
- 44:14parts.
- 44:17So, I mean, yeah, to your point,
- 44:19that's what we do.
- 44:20We come in.
- 44:22I can't imagine the story that Justin's
- 44:24telling.
- 44:25There's a lot of backstory.
- 44:26Like, here's the thing.
- 44:27At the very beginning,
- 44:28if they would have said, hey,
- 44:29we want your input, and they said that,
- 44:32but they wanted us to just be a
- 44:33fly on the wall in meetings and not
- 44:34speak.
- 44:34Like,
- 44:35we're not allowed to speak at meetings,
- 44:37right?
- 44:38So, okay.
- 44:39My personal favorite is when you get
- 44:41invited to the meeting and then they take
- 44:42your notes,
- 44:43but every week you have the same five
- 44:46items.
- 44:46And you're like,
- 44:47but what happened last time?
- 44:48They're like, no, we're moving on.
- 44:50We've addressed that when we met with the
- 44:51stakeholders early on,
- 44:53so we're not going to go back.
- 44:55Why aren't we even here?
- 44:57We didn't have any control or sign off.
- 44:58There's no control over the process.
- 45:00No idea of schedule.
- 45:02No idea if they were even late.
- 45:04How do we know if they're even behind?
- 45:06We're just seeing vans show up and they're
- 45:10working late and we're adding one and one
- 45:12together.
- 45:13We see boxes open in the windows.
- 45:15Like we're looking in windows going,
- 45:17there's all these boxes there.
- 45:18Tomorrow's class.
- 45:20What are you doing?
- 45:20I don't know.
- 45:21Are they done?
- 45:22I don't know.
- 45:22That's...
- 45:23That was our point.
- 45:25He is telling the truth.
- 45:27We have pictures of him looking in the
- 45:29window.
- 45:29Because the police took a picture of him
- 45:32looking in the window.
- 45:33Oh, I don't care about that.
- 45:34The police are very familiar with Justin.
- 45:36It's a story for another day, Chris.
- 45:39It's a story for another day.
- 45:45so but if we were involved and we
- 45:48knew the integrators and it was like some
- 45:51kind of relationship just some even ten
- 45:54percent of a relationship and they said
- 45:56hey we need your help like yeah all
- 45:58right we'll we'll jump in that's fine it's
- 46:01not like oh we don't want to work
- 46:03you've mentioned that some of your
- 46:05leadership is very concerned about the
- 46:07public perception
- 46:10Like when we had some crazy spaces,
- 46:13we've had faculty that wrote into the
- 46:15newspaper about how wasteful these things
- 46:17had been.
- 46:17You're kind of dealing with one now
- 46:19anyway.
- 46:22That's where I think our leadership is
- 46:23like, well,
- 46:23what can we do to address these things?
- 46:25We don't want to have bad press out
- 46:27there around these things.
- 46:28And so I think coming from that
- 46:30production,
- 46:30like the show must go on mentality,
- 46:33we want to make sure that we are
- 46:35not subjected to negativity in the press
- 46:38or whatever it is.
- 46:38So we want to make sure the teaching
- 46:39owners
- 46:41And I believe that students and faculty
- 46:45are appreciative of that when they see us
- 46:48making sure it's working and going through
- 46:50there.
- 46:50So your whole process that you've gone
- 46:52through was just gross failure at all
- 46:56different project management.
- 46:58Why would you not want our help?
- 47:01Yeah.
- 47:02from the delivering of the service,
- 47:03which is kind of crazy.
- 47:04Like, why would you not want our help?
- 47:05Right.
- 47:06I just don't,
- 47:06I think that because we've done all the
- 47:09work.
- 47:10Yeah, like,
- 47:11we've done all the work for so many
- 47:13years.
- 47:13He flew in here from somewhere else,
- 47:15so he must have had a plan.
- 47:17But I do.
- 47:17So because they're from somewhere else,
- 47:19they have to know more than us.
- 47:21They're more experienced than us.
- 47:25But they don't really,
- 47:26Western doesn't know the team that they
- 47:28have.
- 47:29Like our teams can run circles around most
- 47:32integrators.
- 47:32Like they're A-team integrators.
- 47:33What's your service catalog look like,
- 47:34sir?
- 47:34I think every so often,
- 47:36because I go through it through here too.
- 47:40Every so often,
- 47:41it's like they have to test the waters
- 47:43again.
- 47:44Mm-hmm.
- 47:45Like, oh,
- 47:45maybe these guys don't know what they're
- 47:47doing.
- 47:47Well, they're like,
- 47:48or the last couple of things.
- 47:50It's like, man, every time.
- 47:53And usually it's a project management
- 47:56process problem where we're not brought in
- 47:59during discovery.
- 48:00So we don't hear what the needs are.
- 48:02And I get that.
- 48:02That happens a lot.
- 48:04And it does.
- 48:04And it does.
- 48:05But then when we do get involved,
- 48:06what happens?
- 48:07Change order money, change order money,
- 48:09change order money.
- 48:10You guys, every time you get involved,
- 48:12it's change order money.
- 48:13And we say things like, well.
- 48:15It wouldn't have been if we were included
- 48:17five months earlier.
- 48:19And it's, I do,
- 48:21it's like every five or six years,
- 48:23I have one of these,
- 48:25not quite this extreme,
- 48:28where it's like they test the waters,
- 48:30they go solo,
- 48:31the campus project management,
- 48:35and then they find out after the fact
- 48:38that, well,
- 48:39this is costing us a lot of money
- 48:41because nobody told us.
- 48:43Okay.
- 48:44Please get involved earlier.
- 48:46It really helps us go...
- 48:50We do know what we're talking about.
- 48:52They ask you all the things you told
- 48:54them years ago.
- 48:55You know, the polite ways to say,
- 48:59I told you so.
- 49:00Yeah.
- 49:00So...
- 49:03So Jamie, I got two things on that.
- 49:05So one, and absolutely,
- 49:07and it seems for us every five years
- 49:09we get a project manager who decides low
- 49:11bid is best bid.
- 49:12And then about two years later we go,
- 49:14huh, we're never doing that again.
- 49:16And it's just, it's a cycle, right?
- 49:18But I had two jobs,
- 49:20one during COVID time,
- 49:22one immediately after.
- 49:23And it was a rush job,
- 49:25as they all are.
- 49:26And someone said, well,
- 49:27we're going to use the same architect and
- 49:28the same construction management company
- 49:30and the same design consultants,
- 49:32and we're going to do it again across
- 49:33the street.
- 49:34And the GCs took IT out of the
- 49:39submittal process because, quote,
- 49:42that Chris guy,
- 49:43all he does is cause problems and cause
- 49:45change orders.
- 49:46And so we're building the second building
- 49:49and we're not getting any documentation.
- 49:53My network team doesn't know how many
- 49:55switches.
- 49:57When are we going to get submittals?
- 49:59And the GC goes, oh, well,
- 50:02to add you to the submittal process this
- 50:04late in the game,
- 50:06that would be a change order.
- 50:09And my colleague in networking,
- 50:10he knows the game and he goes,
- 50:13Great.
- 50:14Okay, fine.
- 50:15Write it up.
- 50:15See ya.
- 50:16And it goes all the way up to,
- 50:18what is this?
- 50:19They go, oh,
- 50:19that's the change order to make IT a
- 50:22part of the submittal workflow.
- 50:23Well, he shut that down incredibly fast.
- 50:28But it was one of those things where,
- 50:29all right, we'll play the game.
- 50:30We have to make it go up.
- 50:31It's going to come down even faster than
- 50:34it went up.
- 50:34It's crazy.
- 50:35That's kind of what I was going to
- 50:37say.
- 50:37There's always these official problems.
- 50:41In my experience, honestly,
- 50:42it's construction management buy-in to our
- 50:45services.
- 50:47That's the level of success, right?
- 50:51And part of that, that's a good point,
- 50:53Chris,
- 50:53and part of it comes from the direction
- 50:56of leadership because guess who they're,
- 50:59right?
- 51:00Yes.
- 51:01I think...
- 51:02But their direction is coming from
- 51:03somewhere else.
- 51:04Don't allow these people in.
- 51:05They cause problems.
- 51:06Right.
- 51:07But...
- 51:08Like,
- 51:08so a PM who's maybe going through a
- 51:10bumpy divorce and is sitting in the
- 51:13passenger seat and the construction
- 51:17company is driving that bus off the cliff
- 51:19with the wheel back to center, right?
- 51:23And that's hypothetical.
- 51:25That would never happen to my kid.
- 51:28Sure.
- 51:29Far-fetched.
- 51:30So, but, and, you know,
- 51:35how the hell does IT know about that,
- 51:36right?
- 51:40A way that I have to deal with
- 51:42frequently is that because we do our own
- 51:46integrations,
- 51:47we're not actually part of the
- 51:48contractor's contract.
- 51:51So we do technically save them money,
- 51:52but we're outside of their sphere of
- 51:54control, right?
- 51:57And there are many times,
- 51:59and maybe I don't think I'm the only
- 52:01one,
- 52:02that we in our departments and our
- 52:05services thrive in the gray area.
- 52:08So your schedule ran long.
- 52:10Okay.
- 52:12We'll be here on Monday, right?
- 52:15We can clean up a lot.
- 52:18Yes,
- 52:19if we're not done on the first day
- 52:21of class,
- 52:22we know what the minimum base level of
- 52:25use is,
- 52:25and then we improve on it because we
- 52:27own it for the rest of its life.
- 52:29And your contractor doesn't have,
- 52:33typically.
- 52:35Yeah,
- 52:35contractors don't survive in that area.
- 52:37They need things to be very bought.
- 52:39We're not on a schedule.
- 52:41We are not always in the sub meetings.
- 52:46We're not getting.
- 52:48And so I think that the construction
- 52:50phase,
- 52:52I've also been where the GC didn't have
- 52:55any idea that we were even included.
- 52:58They knew there was electrical.
- 53:00There's a T-shaped set inside of the
- 53:04building plan.
- 53:06But they didn't have to know it existed.
- 53:10So they just assumed magic was going to
- 53:13happen.
- 53:13It's like your mom complains all the time.
- 53:15Who's going to do these dishes?
- 53:17The magic shore elf?
- 53:19Well, yeah.
- 53:20Of course.
- 53:21We're the elf.
- 53:23And so I think that convolutes the issue
- 53:28a little bit.
- 53:29And I love living in that gray area,
- 53:31but man,
- 53:31sometimes I think that also causes our
- 53:33problems.
- 53:33And I try to recognize that with
- 53:35administration because...
- 53:37I think they like the gray area too,
- 53:40but they hate it.
- 53:41You have a lot of new folks that
- 53:45are to the game project managers.
- 53:46I think we've seen a lot of turnover,
- 53:48like a lot of folks.
- 53:50And then you get folks that are coming
- 53:51in.
- 53:52Hey, I'm the new cowboy here.
- 53:53I'm going to save so much money on
- 53:55this project.
- 53:55I'm going to cut all kinds of shit.
- 53:57So they go into it and they know
- 53:59if they can just say, hey,
- 54:00you know what?
- 54:00We're going to be working with this
- 54:01architectural firm.
- 54:02They have this in-house and blah, blah,
- 54:03blah, blah.
- 54:04And they're just going to say, hey,
- 54:05we're trying to do this for the least
- 54:06amount of money as possible.
- 54:07Right?
- 54:07Bang.
- 54:09Architect hears that.
- 54:10We're going to not involve anybody we
- 54:12don't need to involve.
- 54:13We've already set the stage.
- 54:19Right down the middle,
- 54:20we want this building to be the same
- 54:21price as everything else we've ever done.
- 54:23Never.
- 54:24It's always, we're doing it on a budget.
- 54:27We don't have a budget.
- 54:28It never is that we're spending more than
- 54:30we should.
- 54:30But it's got to be the best building
- 54:31ever made by man.
- 54:32It's got to be the best ever,
- 54:32but we have no money.
- 54:33And those are happening well before any of
- 54:37these coordinated meetings have even
- 54:38kicked off.
- 54:39They are in the courtship of this whole
- 54:41thing between these firms and their...
- 54:44If you have a PM who doesn't even
- 54:45know who they should be talking to on
- 54:46campus,
- 54:47they're talking to architectural firms who
- 54:48have all these embedded contracts with
- 54:50designers, integration firms,
- 54:52and they all have heard is we're doing
- 54:54it the cheapest possible.
- 54:56Cool,
- 54:56that just gave them carte blanche to just
- 54:58run and do whatever the hell they want.
- 54:59And then they're not going to include and
- 55:01they know if I stop and ask a
- 55:03question,
- 55:05change order.
- 55:06It's going to come in.
- 55:07So yeah,
- 55:08we love change orders because guess what?
- 55:11Ring a bell.
- 55:12We'll do it all day long.
- 55:13However, I can also just not say anything,
- 55:16continue to do what I'm going to do
- 55:17and just keep the lion's share of this
- 55:18money.
- 55:18So it's not in anybody's best interest to
- 55:20involve any of y'all because you've all
- 55:21experienced it already and said, oh,
- 55:22we're just getting more expensive.
- 55:23Actually,
- 55:23it's now the opposite based on our project
- 55:26because of how inflated
- 55:28building is and I'm doing the same I'm
- 55:33doing it though and not the consultant but
- 55:36it's the same
- 55:38People, they learn their lesson.
- 55:42But they're not doing what they're doing
- 55:45to spite any of you all or any
- 55:47of us.
- 55:48They're doing it because they think
- 55:49they're being a champion.
- 55:51They think they're doing it fast and
- 55:52cheap.
- 55:53And we're like screaming and waving red
- 55:57flags.
- 55:57And they're like,
- 55:58you don't know what you're talking about.
- 55:59Just be quiet over there.
- 56:00Because they know if they stop and involve
- 56:02you, it's going to be a change.
- 56:03It's going to bring all these different
- 56:04things.
- 56:04But we could have saved money.
- 56:05Right.
- 56:06That shit's already sailed.
- 56:08You weren't there at the onset of the
- 56:09courtship when they were out to dinner
- 56:10doing their thing and having their- No,
- 56:11it was.
- 56:13It was.
- 56:14I told them.
- 56:16You weren't there.
- 56:17In a meeting, in a design review meeting,
- 56:19I said,
- 56:19I can bring a booth to two thousand
- 56:21and know the difference.
- 56:23What do you mean?
- 56:26That's just Justin's crazy-ass hairbring.
- 56:30He doesn't know when you're having
- 56:32hurricane drinks.
- 56:33Yeah.
- 56:35And he wouldn't be working at Western.
- 56:37He'd be making more money.
- 56:42Oh, I don't.
- 56:43Okay.
- 56:43Anyways.
- 56:44Oh yeah.
- 56:45I don't know.
- 56:45Maybe that's a different show.
- 56:48Maybe.
- 56:48Okay.
- 56:49Yeah.
- 56:49I don't know.
- 56:50How do you feel?
- 56:50You seem upset.
- 56:51I just,
- 56:52we're here to help and you push us
- 56:55away and we could have saved you and
- 56:58you won't allow us to save you.
- 57:00So I don't know what else to do
- 57:02for you.
- 57:05So we're coming down from the rafters.
- 57:06We're parachuting in.
- 57:07Cat five reel.
- 57:08Adapters.
- 57:09Maybe a projector.
- 57:10We can make all that stuff happen
- 57:12overnight.
- 57:13Love it.
- 57:14Like easily in a building full of
- 57:16classrooms.
- 57:16But only if you have DCO and you're
- 57:19allowed to get on-prem.
- 57:21Otherwise,
- 57:22you're outside the window with a bag of
- 57:24popcorn.
- 57:25I see boxes.
- 57:27That box isn't open.
- 57:29Oh, that's not good.
- 57:33we had a job very recently and I'm
- 57:38moving in to their offices,
- 57:41wearing yellow vests and hard hats.
- 57:45Yeah.
- 57:48What?
- 57:49And they've,
- 57:51they're a very powerful group of people on
- 57:53campus with a very firm deadline and be
- 57:57his office.
- 57:58And they go, Oh,
- 57:59he's wearing a hard hat.
- 58:00It's cool.
- 58:01I was like, I,
- 58:03TCOs are very political.
- 58:06We didn't know.
- 58:08Very political.
- 58:09We were on a TCO for a year
- 58:11and we didn't know because the building
- 58:14manager got let go during a restructuring
- 58:19and he was on permanent.
- 58:20They were like,
- 58:21what are you talking about?
- 58:22Oh,
- 58:23you were on a temporary for a year
- 58:25and nobody knew.
- 58:27Oh, wow.
- 58:30That was a little bit wild.
- 58:34Obviously,
- 58:34that was an addition by subtraction with
- 58:37that person no longer being around.
- 58:42My favorite quote of that guy is,
- 58:43we don't need no fancy lighting control
- 58:45system.
- 58:46Just give me twenty light switches in a
- 58:47row.
- 58:47I like that guy.
- 58:49Let's do that.
- 58:49It's not wrong.
- 58:51It's not wrong.
- 58:53No labels.
- 58:54Which one's the front?
- 58:55God damn it.
- 58:58We had an electrician on campus who went
- 59:00and dutifully labeled things,
- 59:02but based on cardinal direction.
- 59:03So it said like,
- 59:04there was like seven switches.
- 59:05It was like, it was like northeast bank.
- 59:07Like, I gotta have a compass to...
- 59:11Turn the damn lights on in this building.
- 59:15We have a very large building that was
- 59:18opened that has a commercial lighting
- 59:20system.
- 59:20But the lighting control programmer,
- 59:24who will not be named,
- 59:27didn't want to use scenes.
- 59:29And so everything is the alphanumeric
- 59:31designator from their plans.
- 59:33And so the instructors don't know how to
- 59:36turn on the lights.
- 59:37Dude, that's malicious compliance.
- 59:40jbox.o one d means yes and that's
- 59:44hilarious i said can you imagine if my
- 59:46av system just said hdmi input two to
- 59:49hdmi output one and i didn't say projector
- 59:52or laptop or pc yeah people would riot
- 59:55but for some reason described like half of
- 59:57higher end yeah
- 59:59That guy just got yelled at by their
- 1:00:04boss and was like, oh yeah,
- 1:00:07I'll get the job done.
- 1:00:08I asked him,
- 1:00:10there's no submittals for lighting
- 1:00:15control.
- 1:00:16I was like, what?
- 1:00:19There's no crying in baseball right now.
- 1:00:24It's too late in the game.
- 1:00:25Who needs submittals, right?
- 1:00:26That was catharsis.
- 1:00:27Oh, no, that's a custom program.
- 1:00:28That's a change order.
- 1:00:30Love it.
- 1:00:31So let me ask this high-level question of
- 1:00:32everybody for everyone on the panel here.
- 1:00:33Oh, boy.
- 1:00:35let's say you know new construction
- 1:00:36whatever it may be big remodel whatever
- 1:00:38but it's not a classroom space so you
- 1:00:41don't have that like classes start a week
- 1:00:43from monday sort of thing let it burn
- 1:00:46that's my question like it's an event
- 1:00:48space it's a dorm it's a research building
- 1:00:50it's lab spaces whatever it is with the
- 1:00:53same challenges we've just discussed for
- 1:00:55the last forty minutes can't do that
- 1:00:59It's the same thing.
- 1:01:01No, it's different.
- 1:01:03How is it different?
- 1:01:05What if it's more money?
- 1:01:06What if it's more money?
- 1:01:07What if a classroom has six A's?
- 1:01:15Now it matters.
- 1:01:17Now it matters, Larry.
- 1:01:18I'm just saying.
- 1:01:19It's an office or something like that.
- 1:01:23I think the reality is that if you
- 1:01:26have an event,
- 1:01:27It's probably not a good example.
- 1:01:30If you had an event space,
- 1:01:32my guess is that event space was also
- 1:01:34going to be higher.
- 1:01:35Which was scheduled two years ago.
- 1:01:37Than the classrooms.
- 1:01:39Yeah.
- 1:01:40Right.
- 1:01:40It's a bad example.
- 1:01:41So we've done staged deliveries where
- 1:01:44we've focused on prioritizing learning
- 1:01:46spaces, lab spaces,
- 1:01:47and then collaborative spaces.
- 1:01:49That's kind of the hierarchy of which we
- 1:01:50will deliver them.
- 1:01:52And if they're not all done day one,
- 1:01:54then guess who's going to be in there
- 1:01:55working during the term?
- 1:01:57Yep, we will.
- 1:01:57Well, I remember in our student union,
- 1:02:00we were, you know,
- 1:02:01the integrator wasn't done.
- 1:02:03We were kind of helping them because we
- 1:02:05were involved in all of that good stuff.
- 1:02:07And, you know,
- 1:02:08the event for opening the building,
- 1:02:10I remember myself and Matt were there that
- 1:02:12night running the event forum to make sure
- 1:02:15nothing, no screens blinked,
- 1:02:18no audio dropped out.
- 1:02:20We were there.
- 1:02:21We were bought in.
- 1:02:23You tell us, we don't want you here.
- 1:02:26Okay.
- 1:02:27Just compliance.
- 1:02:28We got what you asked for.
- 1:02:31Malicious compliance.
- 1:02:33In the back closet,
- 1:02:34pushing buttons on the rack.
- 1:02:35And I was out there with a laptop.
- 1:02:37Remote routing system.
- 1:02:41Yeah, we were.
- 1:02:43Call it in, text it.
- 1:02:44We were texting each other.
- 1:02:50Change over to the other input now.
- 1:02:52Give me a slow fade, star wipe.
- 1:02:55What the hell's going on back there?
- 1:02:56Problems happen that were perceived.
- 1:02:59All good.
- 1:03:02There we go.
- 1:03:03So anyways.
- 1:03:07Sounds like...
- 1:03:11Depends what we do.
- 1:03:13So... We've got down to,
- 1:03:17if you're legally allowed and you have
- 1:03:19occupancy... And you have buy-in.
- 1:03:20Go ahead.
- 1:03:21And you have buy-in.
- 1:03:22If not, no one's looking.
- 1:03:23No one's looking if you have buy-in.
- 1:03:25Other than that,
- 1:03:25dress in black and rappel down from the
- 1:03:27ceiling and plan accordingly.
- 1:03:29Or carry a briefcase and a clipboard.
- 1:03:33To make all this not happen,
- 1:03:35fly in with a briefcase and a clipboard
- 1:03:38and convince people you know what you're
- 1:03:40talking about.
- 1:03:41Meet them in Key Largo.
- 1:03:43Like as a different person.
- 1:03:46I'd be like, oh.
- 1:03:47A briefcase carries a lot of weight.
- 1:03:49Mustache.
- 1:03:52This is my cousin.
- 1:03:53It would be easier to have a mustache
- 1:03:56shirt.
- 1:03:56Just come in with, you know, a consultant.
- 1:04:00You look like the guy from IT.
- 1:04:02No, not me.
- 1:04:03I'm the consultant.
- 1:04:06That is, Jamie,
- 1:04:07that would be the only way that we
- 1:04:08could have helped.
- 1:04:09If we would have jumped the integrator and
- 1:04:13stole their jerseys,
- 1:04:15did the laundry first,
- 1:04:16and then we'd jump in.
- 1:04:17Coming on off the bench,
- 1:04:18number twenty-two, get in there.
- 1:04:20We're coming on off the bench.
- 1:04:23You look familiar.
- 1:04:23I'm the other integrator.
- 1:04:25We're the A-team from Atlanta.
- 1:04:27The integrator's probably looking at you
- 1:04:28like, dude, here's my tools,
- 1:04:31here's my shirt, I'll be at the diner.
- 1:04:34I'm sure they were probably looking for
- 1:04:35help.
- 1:04:35Tell me when you clock out so that
- 1:04:37I can turn it in.
- 1:04:38I guarantee you they wanted our help.
- 1:04:40Guarantee you they wanted our help.
- 1:04:43Oh, man.
- 1:04:44I'm picturing Justin in tearaway cargo
- 1:04:46pants so he can just click change.
- 1:04:47Let's go!
- 1:04:50It's the skinny jeans under that that's
- 1:04:52kind of gross.
- 1:04:53We're not scared to work now.
- 1:04:54We just can't be, you know, disrespected.
- 1:05:01Oh, I'm talking about ethics now.
- 1:05:03Come on.
- 1:05:03We've all got a line.
- 1:05:05Yeah.
- 1:05:05All right.
- 1:05:09Feel good about that, Chris?
- 1:05:10You got your summary?
- 1:05:11Yeah, summary.
- 1:05:12Yeah, we'll say a summary.
- 1:05:15I'll pump that into Zoom.
- 1:05:17We'll get a summary.
- 1:05:17It's diapers.
- 1:05:18It depends.
- 1:05:20Okay.
- 1:05:21All right.
- 1:05:21Well,
- 1:05:22we're going to take a quick break since
- 1:05:23we saw that one.
- 1:05:24We're going to take a quick break.
- 1:05:28Seasonal sponsor.
- 1:05:29And then we're going to come back.
- 1:05:35We're going to talk about some
- 1:05:36multipurpose spaces and some nonsense
- 1:05:37going on there.
- 1:05:43This fall,
- 1:05:43your AV system has got a whole lot
- 1:05:46cozier.
- 1:05:47Introducing the independent, amalgamated,
- 1:05:50limited edition Pumpkin Spice AV
- 1:05:53collection.
- 1:05:56Rich amber LEDs,
- 1:05:58cinnamon-tinted cable jackets,
- 1:06:00and the unmistakable aroma of nutmeg
- 1:06:03walking from your lavalier mic every time
- 1:06:06you clip it on.
- 1:06:07From presentation switchers that crunch
- 1:06:10like piles of fallen leaves,
- 1:06:13change sources to cameras that auto-focus
- 1:06:17only on flannel.
- 1:06:18This season,
- 1:06:19your classroom and meeting rooms aren't
- 1:06:21just smart, they're deliciously festive.
- 1:06:25But act fast.
- 1:06:27This pumpkin spice gear is available
- 1:06:29through November or until the first
- 1:06:31snowfall.
- 1:06:32Pumpkin spice AV.
- 1:06:35Fall into better conferences.
- 1:06:39From Independent Amalgamated.
- 1:06:42Not compatible with summer firmware.
- 1:06:44May cause sudden cravings for pie.
- 1:06:46Use in moderation, please.
- 1:06:52Now, hold on.
- 1:06:53Flannel Conan's so stupid.
- 1:06:54Didn't it already snow there?
- 1:06:58Yeah, I was watching your football game.
- 1:06:59I was like, is this last year's game?
- 1:07:02Is that...
- 1:07:11Chris is like, no, what?
- 1:07:16We get it once a year and it
- 1:07:17shuts the entire city down because no one
- 1:07:19can drive.
- 1:07:20They can't drive in the summer.
- 1:07:23So for our short, short closer topic here,
- 1:07:26put a timer on this one.
- 1:07:27What are we talking about?
- 1:07:30Where's my notes?
- 1:07:32Your most recent project headache.
- 1:07:34What?
- 1:07:35I thought that was just the thing that
- 1:07:36we just did.
- 1:07:37No, we're not doing that again.
- 1:07:40So the question is,
- 1:07:41what do we do about those fun kind
- 1:07:44of multi-use spaces?
- 1:07:46Not a multi-purpose space in the
- 1:07:47traditional sense,
- 1:07:48but like a multi-use space where you're
- 1:07:49like, you know what?
- 1:07:50This is a nice big auditorium.
- 1:07:52They got comfortable seating here.
- 1:07:53Let's do some surround sound.
- 1:07:56Or maybe you get it the other direction
- 1:07:57where somebody says, hey,
- 1:07:59since this is our nice big auditorium,
- 1:08:01we want to do movie nights.
- 1:08:02We want...
- 1:08:03We want movie audio in here.
- 1:08:05Let's get some cinema experience in here.
- 1:08:08Never mind you're just using a regular
- 1:08:10projector and all that fun stuff.
- 1:08:11But we've all done it.
- 1:08:13We've all done it different ways.
- 1:08:14Sometimes it's our idea.
- 1:08:15Sometimes it's not our idea.
- 1:08:17It's never our idea.
- 1:08:22Sometimes we have to fix stuff to kind
- 1:08:25of make it work better or whatever.
- 1:08:26So what's our approach on this?
- 1:08:29Easy.
- 1:08:30So unless you are a film nerd,
- 1:08:34film studies,
- 1:08:35or use one of those keywords,
- 1:08:37and you actually come from that department
- 1:08:39that I know you do that shit,
- 1:08:42and you say you want surround sound,
- 1:08:43you're getting speakers everywhere,
- 1:08:45and you're not going to know the
- 1:08:46difference.
- 1:08:46We call that surround sound.
- 1:08:47Yeah.
- 1:08:47Okay.
- 1:08:48It's like you just want surround sound.
- 1:08:51You want speakers around you.
- 1:08:54But I need it to be surround sound.
- 1:08:56Okay.
- 1:08:57where's the other one how many of y'all
- 1:08:59like raise on trying to get the thing
- 1:09:02on the surround sound decoded system and
- 1:09:05whatever point whatever it is and
- 1:09:10technically it all works and then what
- 1:09:13shows up the very first day that is
- 1:09:16expected to be in every one of those
- 1:09:18speakers
- 1:09:20I just want an eighth-inch connector.
- 1:09:22Why is it not coming out with all
- 1:09:23these things?
- 1:09:25That's why you do everywhere.
- 1:09:26I haven't had this conversation about
- 1:09:28encoding and decoding,
- 1:09:29and they're all just like,
- 1:09:31you guys make things way complicated
- 1:09:33again.
- 1:09:34But I just buy my five-hundred-dollar
- 1:09:35receiver, and that works at home.
- 1:09:37Right,
- 1:09:37I put it in straight or pass-through mode,
- 1:09:38and it all just comes out everywhere.
- 1:09:40PCM, Mark, PCM.
- 1:09:42And then you talk to your programmer,
- 1:09:46and your designer's like...
- 1:09:47it's doing what it's supposed to be doing
- 1:09:49it decodes the surround sound and it
- 1:09:51passes everything sounds not there then it
- 1:09:53does what it does exactly but clients have
- 1:09:56zero awareness of that and they expect
- 1:09:58everything to be everywhere all the time
- 1:10:00because if they can see it it better
- 1:10:01be on and working and that's what we
- 1:10:03give them just they don't care if they
- 1:10:05hear the elephant out of this speaker and
- 1:10:07the giraffe out of that one they just
- 1:10:08want to hear it out of all of
- 1:10:09them everywhere so that's easy
- 1:10:12Mark,
- 1:10:13we have this exact situation and it was
- 1:10:17the art history department and the film
- 1:10:19department need to share a space because
- 1:10:22they both like high quality projection,
- 1:10:24not my words.
- 1:10:26And
- 1:10:27We had that exact situation you described
- 1:10:29about where's my laptop, where's this,
- 1:10:31and it was in the design criteria that
- 1:10:35the users have the ability to change the
- 1:10:39decoding mode,
- 1:10:39and there were this many presets.
- 1:10:41Whoa!
- 1:10:43The creator just said, not doing it.
- 1:10:45Take the money.
- 1:10:46F you.
- 1:10:49Correct.
- 1:10:50That feature does not exist to this day.
- 1:10:53But are the buttons there?
- 1:10:55No, they never run them.
- 1:10:57It doesn't do anything.
- 1:10:58That's like the monitor thing.
- 1:10:59Oh, you need more in your drip.
- 1:11:00How's that sound?
- 1:11:00Oh, good.
- 1:11:00Yeah, it didn't do anything.
- 1:11:02So this winter,
- 1:11:04we're ripping the whole thing out.
- 1:11:06And the film department is buying their
- 1:11:08own surround sound processor,
- 1:11:10a consumer level unit.
- 1:11:12Perfect.
- 1:11:13And I said,
- 1:11:14I'm not going to try to control it
- 1:11:15because I'm not going to do it right.
- 1:11:17My responsibility ends at this HDMI cable.
- 1:11:20Like, y'all choose your own adventure.
- 1:11:25Do you ever go down the accessibility road
- 1:11:31in these round sound rooms?
- 1:11:34Why would we want to have one space
- 1:11:35have access to a certain content and
- 1:11:37another space not?
- 1:11:38No, because I lied to him.
- 1:11:40Now we know why they don't want you
- 1:11:41there.
- 1:11:42Do we want this side to have a
- 1:11:43different experience than that side of the
- 1:11:44auditorium?
- 1:11:45Is that a thing?
- 1:11:46No, you're right.
- 1:11:46It is a thing, Mark.
- 1:11:48But I mean, that gets into audio coverage,
- 1:11:51uniformity standards, throw in ADA stuff.
- 1:11:55You can mitigate that because of hearing
- 1:11:57assistance.
- 1:11:58I mean, that's mono.
- 1:12:00I mean, it doesn't matter.
- 1:12:01It's just I've never had that argument
- 1:12:03because if somebody brings it up,
- 1:12:05it's usually in a higher end space.
- 1:12:07It's been brought up.
- 1:12:08three or four times on our campus.
- 1:12:10We've done it three times.
- 1:12:13And each space,
- 1:12:14and we have one actual surround sound out
- 1:12:16of the three.
- 1:12:17The other is just...
- 1:12:18Speakers blowing out sound everywhere.
- 1:12:20Yeah,
- 1:12:21and they're all happy with everything they
- 1:12:22got.
- 1:12:23Because to them, they're like, oh, cool.
- 1:12:25they're here but we force we force mono
- 1:12:28on certain sources the only one that does
- 1:12:31have true sound is like yeah i think
- 1:12:32we've all done even if you tried to
- 1:12:35do it with every source the the pcs
- 1:12:38don't all yeah the yeah we have to
- 1:12:40force reliably output um multi-channel um
- 1:12:45transmission systems hd based avl repeat
- 1:12:47don't all reliably output multi-channel
- 1:12:49they're
- 1:12:49capable of it some are on the source
- 1:12:53depends on how it's done for those you
- 1:12:56do that you are doing it where does
- 1:12:58that decoder sit in your chain
- 1:13:02But this is an important question.
- 1:13:04Under the hood,
- 1:13:05where you have that decoder,
- 1:13:07you're doing it right before the amp?
- 1:13:08Before the DSP.
- 1:13:10I do mine before the DSP and not
- 1:13:12at the last link.
- 1:13:13I think that's important because if you do
- 1:13:14that, it gets all wacky.
- 1:13:16Go ahead, Chris.
- 1:13:16DSP, most, most, most.
- 1:13:20pretty much across the board too dsps do
- 1:13:22not maintain the surround sound timing if
- 1:13:24you're doing that right and that's where
- 1:13:26you get into cheating it and this is
- 1:13:27this is like what i'm talking about like
- 1:13:28this is like unless you're gonna do a
- 1:13:30full certified thing which is i'm not
- 1:13:32going down that route we don't have time
- 1:13:33so i did one room that way with
- 1:13:35a cinema processor with the cinema
- 1:13:36amplifiers with the cinema um uh speaker
- 1:13:40cabinets but only and they know this that
- 1:13:45comes from the
- 1:13:46the blue ray player so that chain is
- 1:13:49certified anything else you're doing there
- 1:13:51because most i'm just going to run mad
- 1:13:53together chris you were asking that was
- 1:13:55like last year i remember that shit three
- 1:13:58years ago god time flies um this is
- 1:14:01so chris i want to ask you though
- 1:14:03if in that scenario
- 1:14:06The number one part of this question was
- 1:14:08multi-purpose space.
- 1:14:10For us,
- 1:14:10a multi-purpose space has a microphone.
- 1:14:13I don't mix surround sound with
- 1:14:14multi-purpose.
- 1:14:15So I take that back.
- 1:14:17That was the whole start of this
- 1:14:19conversation.
- 1:14:20I forgot that surround sound is a theater.
- 1:14:26It's very...
- 1:14:31They sure do.
- 1:14:32Not this one.
- 1:14:33So, Chris, to your point.
- 1:14:35So I have two spaces where we've
- 1:14:36deliberately in recent years done some
- 1:14:40limitations here.
- 1:14:41So it will work this way in this
- 1:14:43sort of scenario.
- 1:14:44The other one, which is a big auditorium,
- 1:14:46and this was, you know, hey,
- 1:14:48the plumbing was there.
- 1:14:50We put the speakers in.
- 1:14:52We did it.
- 1:14:54You have to deliberately switch to...
- 1:14:58movie mode to get surround so to your
- 1:15:00question when you're in movie mode you get
- 1:15:03no microphones because you're making that
- 1:15:05call like we're going to movie mode a
- 1:15:07lot of stuff turns off um when you're
- 1:15:10in class mode it's you get you know
- 1:15:12the more traditional you get two channels
- 1:15:14up front your microphones your assistant
- 1:15:16thing all that stuff so actually assistant
- 1:15:17listening doesn't work during the mode
- 1:15:18because it just takes just put in regular
- 1:15:20voice yes and that was what we found
- 1:15:23though
- 1:15:24Well, what we found, though,
- 1:15:24interestingly enough,
- 1:15:25is a lot of the processors,
- 1:15:26even when you're looping through, like,
- 1:15:28I'll turn all the processing off and
- 1:15:29you're still going through there,
- 1:15:31there's that slight amount of latency
- 1:15:36that's induced.
- 1:15:37Like, you know,
- 1:15:38you're doing any sort of production, like,
- 1:15:40you can see the iMac screen,
- 1:15:42but you can see the person with the
- 1:15:43mic, and you're like, there's, like,
- 1:15:44this weird, like, what is it, like a...
- 1:15:46an eighth of a second difference and my
- 1:15:48brain's going weird because I can see it.
- 1:15:50Anyone farther back doesn't care.
- 1:15:51But if you're close enough and you can
- 1:15:53see, what's happening?
- 1:15:54That happens all the time if you can
- 1:15:55see the person on the screen because of
- 1:15:57that induced latency with the processing.
- 1:15:58And that calls out that differentiation of
- 1:16:02where you sit in that environment.
- 1:16:04It's not equal.
- 1:16:05You have these
- 1:16:06varying experiences based on where you
- 1:16:08chose to sit in a space because they're
- 1:16:10all, oh, but that's also a classroom.
- 1:16:13It's multipurpose,
- 1:16:14but it's also a classroom.
- 1:16:16And so it never, I don't know,
- 1:16:19we've dumbed them down more often than
- 1:16:20not.
- 1:16:21Okay.
- 1:16:21So, you know,
- 1:16:22I'm coming to you guys from my theater
- 1:16:24here in my house.
- 1:16:26You know,
- 1:16:27we've all done the surround sound.
- 1:16:28Am I in every one of your speakers
- 1:16:29right now?
- 1:16:30I bet.
- 1:16:30Please.
- 1:16:31Yeah.
- 1:16:32He's stereo.
- 1:16:34Yeah, multi-mono.
- 1:16:36Right here and right here, buddy.
- 1:16:37Exactly.
- 1:16:38That's all audio is.
- 1:16:39He's going to start flexing in a minute.
- 1:16:41Right here and right here.
- 1:16:44Like Justin said, middle-middle, right?
- 1:16:46Middle-middle.
- 1:16:47Odyssey, Dirac,
- 1:16:48whatever calibration you do,
- 1:16:50it only works for one scene.
- 1:16:53right it'll average out the others but
- 1:16:56there is one perfect seat where everything
- 1:16:58is like a group of four in the
- 1:17:00movie theaters that i've tested i've got
- 1:17:03my four seats right in the middle it
- 1:17:09goes over hold this over here from we
- 1:17:10only have three seats justin so i'm
- 1:17:12obviously three nice but that's so your
- 1:17:14sample size is low so you're for what
- 1:17:17i get it yeah that makes sense
- 1:17:20D-I-N-K, baby.
- 1:17:21It's the only way to live.
- 1:17:22Oh, man.
- 1:17:27That's Justin's method?
- 1:17:31Yeah.
- 1:17:31And twenty-seven dogs.
- 1:17:32You brought up that monophonic thing
- 1:17:35before.
- 1:17:36monophonic who all of it stereo mono
- 1:17:41monoroll it depends on the space i've
- 1:17:44you've been in our surrounding spaces mono
- 1:17:46everywhere mono mono mono here like are we
- 1:17:49we've successfully in a couple of uh yes
- 1:17:53we have stereo true stereo true stereo on
- 1:18:00a teaching learning space depends on this
- 1:18:02space
- 1:18:03Oh, man.
- 1:18:04Almost a ton of them.
- 1:18:05Ninety percent of my classrooms are
- 1:18:06eight-ohm stereo.
- 1:18:09Really?
- 1:18:10Oh, you work at Oregon State.
- 1:18:12Got that Pacific money going there.
- 1:18:13I think we do it because I think
- 1:18:14that's an easy deployment.
- 1:18:16I don't think it's designed for left,
- 1:18:18right, making sure.
- 1:18:18And we're not listening to the Beatles and
- 1:18:20these things.
- 1:18:22Which was recorded in mono, by the way.
- 1:18:24Right, exactly.
- 1:18:24And then...
- 1:18:26We have asbestos in the ceiling,
- 1:18:29so we can only put speakers in the
- 1:18:32sheetrock walls.
- 1:18:33So we just don't do something.
- 1:18:34Yeah, it's easy to do that.
- 1:18:37But are you intentional?
- 1:18:39We're going to make sure we're designing
- 1:18:40around the stereo to preserve the stereo
- 1:18:44space.
- 1:18:45Yeah.
- 1:18:46No,
- 1:18:47it was absolutely path of least
- 1:18:49resistance.
- 1:18:49Quite frankly,
- 1:18:50there were serial speakers haunting the
- 1:18:53rooms when I got the job.
- 1:18:55So when we're upgrading, we're like,
- 1:18:57what are we doing?
- 1:18:58Well, they're JBLs.
- 1:18:59They still work.
- 1:18:59Keep going.
- 1:19:00They'll live forever.
- 1:19:03Once a year,
- 1:19:03I'll get a bee in my bonnet and
- 1:19:05go check out both channels.
- 1:19:07I go,
- 1:19:07that's why I don't do these tests.
- 1:19:09And I just walk away.
- 1:19:14No, it's interesting.
- 1:19:16Are there people who are adamantly like,
- 1:19:17no,
- 1:19:18we have got to have stereo because my
- 1:19:21content is going to be stereo and I
- 1:19:23want to watch half the class.
- 1:19:24I care more about...
- 1:19:26We have a master's in video game design
- 1:19:31and programming.
- 1:19:32and no, no, no, it's a school.
- 1:19:35It's its own thing.
- 1:19:38But they're in their own secured
- 1:19:39environment.
- 1:19:40Do not let those people out of there.
- 1:19:41These people are so crazy.
- 1:19:42They once told me that they can see
- 1:19:45the latency
- 1:19:47on the screen from too long of an
- 1:19:49HDMI cable.
- 1:19:51I said, you're wasting your superpowers.
- 1:19:55But like all modern audio systems,
- 1:19:59every classroom,
- 1:20:02they were in that system for two years.
- 1:20:04They go, Chris, this Crestron...
- 1:20:08NVX thing is programmed wrong.
- 1:20:10Everything is mono.
- 1:20:12And I was like, nope,
- 1:20:13it's doing exactly what it should.
- 1:20:15We had to rip it all out and
- 1:20:17give them full range stereo with two
- 1:20:22subwoofers in every classroom in the
- 1:20:25ceiling so that they could have...
- 1:20:28Stereo quality to program the game by not
- 1:20:32being able to program stereo stuff.
- 1:20:33Ooh,
- 1:20:34I would have went down that physics road
- 1:20:35and battled that fight.
- 1:20:36Yeah, you can't tell me that subwoofer.
- 1:20:39I wasn't going to win this.
- 1:20:41I would have mapped that out.
- 1:20:44I would have mathed that out.
- 1:20:45It doesn't work like that, no.
- 1:20:46Look, look, look, look.
- 1:20:49Physics, bro.
- 1:20:50Physics.
- 1:20:51At some point, just give it to me.
- 1:20:54Right now.
- 1:20:56They're paying for it?
- 1:20:56Yeah, you gotta choose your back.
- 1:20:58Like, they asked for it.
- 1:20:59It's the principle of the day.
- 1:21:01If they pay for it,
- 1:21:02I'll give it to them,
- 1:21:03but I'm still gonna...
- 1:21:04I've told lots of people, like,
- 1:21:06this is a terrible idea.
- 1:21:07That's not really how it works,
- 1:21:09but I'll...
- 1:21:10Jamie, why wouldn't you do that before?
- 1:21:11I normally do.
- 1:21:12See, that's the thing.
- 1:21:15And roll it off like a hundred.
- 1:21:21We had a physical media deck,
- 1:21:25and we were running analog audio out of
- 1:21:27the computers.
- 1:21:29And there was real left and right when
- 1:21:31you watched YouTube videos.
- 1:21:32There was really left and right.
- 1:21:35I did have a set of stereo speakers
- 1:21:36up front and a voice lift monitor up,
- 1:21:38USB,
- 1:21:39and then the speakerphone in and out of
- 1:21:42the computers in order to do conferencing.
- 1:21:47We don't let them switch from one USB
- 1:21:50stream to the other.
- 1:21:51They get speakerphone one so that they can
- 1:21:55use it in Teams, Zoom, whatever.
- 1:21:57That's all mono all the time.
- 1:21:59So having that separation with no physical
- 1:22:02media player doesn't matter anymore.
- 1:22:04And so that's where it really starts
- 1:22:06getting goofy.
- 1:22:06It's like, well, that's great.
- 1:22:08You want stereo,
- 1:22:09except it only comes out of your computer
- 1:22:10mono anyway.
- 1:22:11So whatever.
- 1:22:13And we go back, put on headphones.
- 1:22:16you want that put on headphones aren't
- 1:22:18headphones dual mono did not read that
- 1:22:20somewhere they're not actually stereo
- 1:22:23depends depends on what they're plugged
- 1:22:24into the entire world is mono yeah
- 1:22:26everything so uh yeah i used to be
- 1:22:32just make it up in stereo well i
- 1:22:33actually have a set of stereo headphones
- 1:22:35back here and it sometimes it's weird just
- 1:22:38listening to music when it's true stereo
- 1:22:40you're like
- 1:22:42oh my where the oh okay the song
- 1:22:44all right i got it yeah i'm good
- 1:22:46now my headphone oh we're good yeah okay
- 1:22:51dirty little thing it's all mono there it
- 1:22:53is we fixed that too got the end
- 1:22:55of it chris we did it nice short
- 1:22:57show
- 1:22:58That's right.
- 1:22:59So we answered all the questions,
- 1:23:00solved all the problems.
- 1:23:01Got to the bottom of it.
- 1:23:01Got to the root of all these problems.
- 1:23:04I think this is a good opportunity for
- 1:23:06us to shut the heck up and get
- 1:23:07out of here.
- 1:23:07Yep.
- 1:23:07Go back.
- 1:23:08Get out of here.
- 1:23:09See you.
- 1:23:09Bye.
- 1:23:11You can sleep right now.
- 1:23:16Everybody's staring at each other
- 1:23:17awkwardly.
- 1:23:17No, next week we're at ETC.
- 1:23:19We don't know what we're doing next week.
- 1:23:20We'll figure it out.
- 1:23:21I know exactly what we're doing next week.
- 1:23:22Oh, Chris, I'm driving.
- 1:23:23I'm not flying, by the way.
- 1:23:27Well,
- 1:23:28we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:23:30of AV Superfriends Off the Rails.
- 1:23:32You can contact us with questions,
- 1:23:33topic ideas,
- 1:23:34or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:23:36avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:23:38If you complain loud enough,
- 1:23:39we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:23:44Nice work, everyone.
- 1:23:45Sharp broadcast.
- 1:23:47Really good.
- 1:23:47Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:23:49Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:23:50I liked it.
- 1:23:51The opinions expressed by the AV
- 1:23:53Superfriends are solely those of the
- 1:23:54individuals and do not represent their
- 1:23:56respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:23:58companies, or clients.