Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration: Employment Arbitration
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration, Employment
- 0:06Arbitration. I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive
- 0:09Director and CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:12And I'm delighted to be here today to introduce
- 0:14our speakers, Stephanie Cabacha and Christine
- 0:17Kwong. Stephanie is the Vice President of Employment
- 0:21of... the American Arbitration Association International
- 0:24Center for Dispute Resolution, based in the Los
- 0:27Angeles regional office. She administers large
- 0:30complex cases, assists with recruiting panelists,
- 0:33and promotes the AAA ICDR's mission and vision
- 0:38through outreach and education. Prior to joining
- 0:41AAA, Stephanie practiced family and immigration
- 0:44law in the Chicago area. Christine Kwong is a
- 0:49senior partner at Music Peeler and Garrett LLP
- 0:52in Los Angeles, where she specializes in employment
- 0:55and labor law. With more than 30 years of experience,
- 0:57Christine advises and represents clients in matters
- 1:00involving discrimination, harassment, retaliation,
- 1:03disability accommodation, wage and hour, and
- 1:05executive employment contracts. She is also an
- 1:08experienced neutral. investigator, mediator,
- 1:11and hearing officer in workplace and civil disputes
- 1:13and serves as an arbitrator for the employment
- 1:16and consumer panel with AAA. Prior to joining
- 1:19her firm, Christine held positions at several
- 1:22prominent other firms and has served as an expert
- 1:24witness in HR and accommodation cases. And now
- 1:27let's get started learning from these experts.
- 1:31All right. Well, thank you so much, Valinda.
- 1:34Thank you all for joining. My name is Stephanie.
- 1:37As Valinda had stated earlier, I'm going to go
- 1:39ahead and share my screen to get started on our
- 1:48presentation. OK. So what is arbitration? Briefly,
- 2:01it is a form of alternative dispute resolution.
- 2:04So it is similar to court in that there is a
- 2:07binding decision made by a neutral fact finder,
- 2:10but it differs in a lot of ways from court. Arbitration
- 2:14is a creature of contract for the most part,
- 2:18and it is a party -driven process. So here, If
- 2:26a party, if two parties sign a contract and in
- 2:29an employment case, it's some, an employee signs
- 2:32an employee employment agreement with an employer
- 2:36or, you know, their handbook and arbitration
- 2:40is listed as where disputes are going to be heard.
- 2:44Then this would be where they would come to us
- 2:46or a different provider or, or ad hoc, which
- 2:48I will define later. And the parties get to choose
- 2:52the arbitrator. and work with that arbitrator
- 2:56to set the hearing and the discovery schedule
- 2:58and motion practice, what that could look like.
- 3:05And for arbitration, for employment arbitration,
- 3:08you will generally, as I stated, get into arbitration
- 3:12through either an employment... agreement which
- 3:14has an arbitration clause or if you are an executive
- 3:18and you signed an individually negotiated contract,
- 3:22which does vary from just a general employee
- 3:24handbook. And then Christine, can you talk to
- 3:28us about the types of claims that are commonly
- 3:30brought in employment arbitration? Sure. Thank
- 3:33you, Stephanie. So when you file a claim and
- 3:36you start a claim in the employment process,
- 3:38there are a lot of common claims that are typically
- 3:41raised. One are wage and hour claims and single
- 3:46plaintiff paga claims. So you might have cases
- 3:50where a plaintiff brought a representative and
- 3:54a single paga action in a court of law and the
- 3:58defendant filed a petition to compel arbitration
- 4:04of just the single plaintiff aspect of the Paga
- 4:07claim and the Superior Court will stay the representative
- 4:11aspect of it. So you might get a single plaintiff
- 4:14wage and hour actions with the Paga claim and
- 4:18also your typical employment discrimination claim.
- 4:22So things such as discrimination. retaliation,
- 4:27and harassment, those types of whistleblower
- 4:30claims. And sometimes you might even get a trade
- 4:33secret confidentiality breach of confidentiality
- 4:37trade secret theft case. It really depends on
- 4:41what is listed in the arbitration agreement and
- 4:44what the parties agree to as to what types of
- 4:48claims would be subject to arbitration, but those
- 4:50are the general ones. So here we have laid out
- 4:57a typical employment case arbitration roadmap.
- 5:02So from day one to potentially day 420. And just
- 5:07so everyone knows, one of the hallmarks of arbitration
- 5:10is that it is supposed to be and usually is faster
- 5:15than going to a state or federal court for a
- 5:19case. But as you'll see, some of these timelines
- 5:22can vary, especially when we get into information
- 5:25exchange or discovery. So at the beginning stage,
- 5:29you have the filing and initiation. That's where
- 5:31you file your demand with the ADR provider. And
- 5:36that's when the fees first start to be billed
- 5:43by the ADR provider. So in California, there's
- 5:49a small fee paid by the employee, and then a
- 5:52larger fee paid by the business. And pursuant
- 5:55to statute, the business has 30 days to pay that.
- 5:59And so we'll move on. Let's, you know, from day
- 6:03one to 15, that's what that beginning stage looks
- 6:05like. We assume everybody pays, that we're not
- 6:08gonna yet talk about. the kind of objections
- 6:11you receive at the beginning of a case or if
- 6:14somebody doesn't feel like they've agreed to
- 6:16arbitration. We will discuss that later, but
- 6:19this is just assuming that everybody is on board.
- 6:22And then approximately at day 15, the parties
- 6:26will engage in the arbitrator selection process.
- 6:29And as we'll discuss later, that can vary based
- 6:33on the contract, how well the parties and the
- 6:36council are getting along, and whether there's
- 6:39any disagreement as to where the arbitration
- 6:41hearing is going to take place. Assuming that
- 6:45we are able to get a mutually agreeable arbitrator
- 6:48pretty quickly, or within at least the first,
- 6:52generally under the AAA rules, it's about 14
- 6:54days once we send an arbitrator selection list.
- 6:57Then we get into scheduling and holding the management
- 7:01conference or preliminary hearing. So at the
- 7:04preliminary hearing, which Christine will go
- 7:06into detail about later, this is where you meet
- 7:09your arbitrator and the party is really kind
- 7:12of flesh out the timeline for the remainder of
- 7:14the case. One of the things that they'll discuss
- 7:18at that management conference or preliminary
- 7:20hearing is information exchange and preparation,
- 7:24also known as discovery. So this is where the
- 7:29case can either really this is where the rubber
- 7:37meets the road in terms of how quickly are the
- 7:40parties going to be able to get this done. consistently
- 7:45one of the biggest complaint state providers
- 7:48or anybody who works in arbitration hears is
- 7:52it arbitration takes almost as long as core or
- 7:56there's a lot of discovery and it's supposed
- 7:59to be efficient and that really is going to depend
- 8:01on how how well council is working together to
- 8:05get that information exchanged and what the contract
- 8:11or the arbitration clause looks like before you
- 8:14get in there. And we'll talk about that more,
- 8:17but it can be, you know, if it's a smaller or
- 8:22less complex case and there isn't as much discovery
- 8:26needed, you know, the employee only worked for
- 8:29the employer a couple of months, then hopefully
- 8:33this stage goes a lot quicker. But if we're talking
- 8:37about a 30 year employee, or an employee who
- 8:41was a senior executive for some time, then this
- 8:45part can take longer. Let's say we have everybody's
- 8:52pleased with the amount of discovery that each
- 8:55side has given, and they're ready to proceed
- 8:58to the hearing. Then we have the evidentiary
- 9:00hearing, which is akin to a trial in state or
- 9:03federal court. And that's where the parties present
- 9:07evidence to the arbitrator. after the hearing,
- 9:12then we go into post hearing submissions. Not
- 9:15all cases will have them. So again, when you're
- 9:17talking to your arbitrator at your management
- 9:20conference, that's when usually it's determined.
- 9:24But if. What or if any post hearing briefs will
- 9:30be filed at the conclusion of the hearing? and
- 9:33then you'll usually talk you can talk about it
- 9:35at the hearing or during the management conference
- 9:38about how many days you'll need to file your
- 9:42post hearing brief and are there going to be
- 9:45page limits and and usually there are because
- 9:47that really does help condense everything and
- 9:50then At least under the AAA rules, the arbitrator
- 9:55will have 30 days from after the last submission
- 9:59for the post hearing briefs, or if they've determined
- 10:01they have everything that they need, they'll
- 10:03have 30 days to render an award. At the bottom
- 10:07of the roadmap, it does talk about the expected
- 10:12costs. Those, again, will vary depending on the
- 10:16complexity of the case and how much discovery
- 10:21is needed, and if there will be, you know, dispositive
- 10:25motions filed, and if there are a lot of discovery
- 10:30disputes. Discovery disputes tend to help or
- 10:35have arbitration become very costly, very fast.
- 10:41Okay. And so Christine, if you can talk to us
- 10:47a little bit. both in your background as an arbitrator
- 10:52and advocate, how arbitration is different than
- 10:55litigation. Yes. Thank you, Stephanie. So one
- 10:59of the things for those of you that litigate
- 11:01in federal and state court is that there are
- 11:06rules to litigation. So in superior court, everybody
- 11:11follows the code of civil procedure or the civil
- 11:14code. There are rules with respect to the discovery
- 11:18that you are able to propound, which is very
- 11:21open. subject to any type of protective order.
- 11:26And the same is true in the federal court as
- 11:29well. You're governed by the federal rules of
- 11:31civil procedure. And in arbitration, it's a little
- 11:35bit less formal. And the parties have actually
- 11:38more say on how they want to litigate their case,
- 11:42subject to the arbitrator making a decision.
- 11:45on areas of disagreement. But one of the key
- 11:48aspects that is different is that the parties
- 11:51actually get to select their decision maker.
- 11:54So in comparison to federal and state court,
- 11:57once you file that complaint inside the judicial
- 12:00system, it will be assigned to a judge. For example,
- 12:05complex wage and hour class action cases, there's
- 12:08a group of judges in superior court. that are
- 12:11designated to handle those complex cases, but
- 12:14you don't get to choose who the person is that
- 12:17will be deciding and managing your case. But
- 12:20in arbitration, depending on your arbitration
- 12:22agreement and how it's written, the parties have
- 12:25some say in who they get to select. So the more
- 12:30exposure and experience you have in arbitrating
- 12:33cases, you will get to know the available arbitrators
- 12:38that are in your community that will be deciding
- 12:40your case. The other issue is that arbitration
- 12:44is confidential. So your arbitrator does not
- 12:48disclose the proceedings, the award is confidential,
- 12:52and especially things like remote, it's all confidential.
- 12:57Third is there's reduced discovery and motion
- 13:01practice. And what I mean by that is One of the
- 13:05key tenants of arbitration is the actual arbitration
- 13:09agreement. And the actual arbitration agreement
- 13:13can actually set forth the amount of discovery
- 13:18that a party can engage in subject to the restriction
- 13:24being held unenforceable by the arbitrator because
- 13:28it is unconscionable. But unless your arbitrator
- 13:32holds that the discovery provision is unconscionable,
- 13:36you are bound by that reduced discovery. So for
- 13:39example, there are arbitration agreements where
- 13:43inside the contract, there is a discovery provision
- 13:46that might limit the number of depositions that
- 13:51can be taken. So for example, in superior court,
- 13:55you have unlimited depots subject to a motion
- 13:58for a protective order. In arbitration, the contract
- 14:02can limit it to three depositions or even one
- 14:06deposition. On some employment arbitration rules,
- 14:11depending on who your provider is, there might
- 14:15be a limit on motion practice. So for example,
- 14:18in court, everybody has a right to file a summary
- 14:22judgment adjudication motion, but some rules
- 14:27based on who your neutral arbitration platform
- 14:30is, might require you to ask permission from
- 14:34the arbitrator in order to file a dispositive
- 14:37motion. Why do these rules exist? They exist
- 14:41because the whole purpose of arbitration is to
- 14:45streamline the proceedings and to make it less
- 14:48expensive. One of the ways we make it less expensive
- 14:52is by reducing the amount of law of motion practice
- 14:56and reducing the amount of discovery short of
- 15:01a party challenging that provision as being unconscionable.
- 15:05So in some ways, the arbitration process is more
- 15:09informal. You can control somewhat the procedures
- 15:14and you can even negotiate with the parties on
- 15:19the setting of the hearing dates. And so the
- 15:22parties actually have a little bit more control
- 15:24because there's less formality. And some arbitration
- 15:29rules require the arbitrator to issue an award
- 15:32under a certain deadline. For example, subject
- 15:36to a continuance arbitrator should be issuing
- 15:40the award within 30 days after the arbitration
- 15:43has closed. And then finally, it is the judicial
- 15:48review of the Arbitrator's Award. And under the
- 15:53California Arbitration Act, there are very, very
- 15:56limited bases upon which a party can go to the
- 15:59Superior Court and ask that you vacate the Arbitration
- 16:03Award. Misapplication of the law is not a basis.
- 16:08You basically have to show fraud or misconduct
- 16:13or some degree of bias. And the same is with
- 16:17the Federal Arbitration Act as well. You have
- 16:19to show fraud, bias, misconduct. The FAA does
- 16:23have a section called Manifest Disregard of the
- 16:26Law, but even the case law says that that manifest
- 16:29disregard of the law must be very obvious, so
- 16:34a slight misinterpretation of the law may not
- 16:37be enough. And with that said, however, if your
- 16:41arbitration agreement indicates that you can
- 16:44seek judicial review based on a misapplication
- 16:48of the law, then one can make the argument that
- 16:51you can actually seek judicial relief because
- 16:54your arbitrator did not apply the law correctly
- 16:57or did not cite the correct body of law. All
- 17:02right. So before we take a deep dive into the
- 17:07process of starting an arbitration, This is just
- 17:10a little bit about what the general arbitration
- 17:12framework looks like. When you are in arbitration,
- 17:16you do have a couple of options. You can either
- 17:18choose an ADR provider or your contract will
- 17:22have an ADR provider listed, the agreement or
- 17:25the language or a stipulation, which we'll talk
- 17:27about later. We'll have an ADR provider listed
- 17:30such as AAA, JAMS, Signature, Judicate West,
- 17:35ADR services, among others. Or the parties can
- 17:40agree to an arbitrator and ask that arbitrator
- 17:44or person to conduct the arbitration ad hoc.
- 17:48That means they generally don't have to abide
- 17:50by a provider's rules. And most of your providers
- 17:55provide some level of case management services.
- 17:58Typically, when you are reaching out to an arbitrator
- 18:01directly, they do not have necessarily a case
- 18:05manager. They may have some legal support staff,
- 18:08but you will be working with that arbitrator
- 18:11on your own. Generally, that can create some
- 18:16issues. Providers within the state of California
- 18:19especially are very concerned about making sure
- 18:23the parties have the proper disclosures. There
- 18:26are very strict statutes and timelines within
- 18:31California under the CCP, which requires the
- 18:35arbitrators to make from especially as compared
- 18:40to other states very lengthy disclosures about
- 18:43their relationships with the parties or the attorneys
- 18:46or any interactions with either of them and it
- 18:51is as Christine said earlier one of the ways
- 18:54in which a party can get an award vacated and
- 18:57if you are doing it ad hoc, you may not have
- 18:59that same level of an arbitrator really making
- 19:03sure that those disclosures are accurate and
- 19:05always updated if necessary, if new counsel come
- 19:08in or anything like that or a new party is added
- 19:12to the case. And then Christina, you talked briefly
- 19:16a little bit about the FAA and CAA, but if you
- 19:19want to talk a little bit more about that and
- 19:21then FIHA. Sure. Yes. Yes. So. Under the laws
- 19:28of arbitration, there are basically two bodies
- 19:30of law that govern the arbitration process. The
- 19:33first is the federal law, which is the Federal
- 19:36Arbitration Act. But California also has its
- 19:39own California Arbitration Act with its whole
- 19:43list of reported cases that have interpreted
- 19:45the California Arbitration Act. And the first
- 19:49thing you look at, well, one of the first things
- 19:50you look at There are many things you look at
- 19:53when you look at the arbitration agreement, but
- 19:55if you're looking at the substance as to what
- 19:57area of law applies to your arbitration agreement,
- 20:00you look to see if the drafter indicated in there
- 20:04whether or not the FAA will apply with respect
- 20:08to the enforceability of the arbitration agreement
- 20:12itself. So in general, the FAA favors arbitration
- 20:17and makes arbitration agreements enforceable.
- 20:21The California Arbitration Act also governs arbitration,
- 20:26but it also has a whole body of law with respect
- 20:29to discovery and a whole body of law on substantive
- 20:33unconscionability as well as procedural unconscionability.
- 20:38And then as I indicated, the two areas of law
- 20:42differ with respect to the grounds by which you
- 20:46can ask a court to vacate the arbitration award
- 20:51issued by the arbitrator. So, for example, under
- 20:54the CAA, you need to show fraud, misconduct,
- 20:57bias. But under the FAA, in addition to fraud,
- 21:01misconduct, and bias, you can also use a manifest
- 21:05disregard of the law, which is an additional
- 21:07element. However, that is a very, very high standard.
- 21:12So one of the things that one should consider
- 21:15when you're looking at the arbitration agreement
- 21:17is number one, is the agreement actually enforceable?
- 21:23Is this a valid arbitration agreement? And to
- 21:27answer that question, you have to ask what area
- 21:31of law governs this agreement? Is it the federal?
- 21:35Arbitration Act or is it the California Arbitration
- 21:39Act? Because if it's the CAA, you would go to
- 21:43California law. If it's the FAA, you could go
- 21:47to the federal law. And if it is a claim under
- 21:51the Fair Employment and Housing Act, FIHA, one
- 21:55of the principal aspects of an agreement is that
- 21:59the agreement as a whole needs to be fair. So
- 22:04both the FAA and the CAA require the arbitration
- 22:07agreement to be fair, and that basically boils
- 22:10down to two types of fairness. There's something
- 22:13called procedural unconscionability, and the
- 22:17second is substantive unconscionability. And
- 22:22procedural unconscionability deals with the process
- 22:24by which the worker and the employer entered
- 22:29into the agreement. So the question you ask is,
- 22:33are the procedures or the process by which the
- 22:36worker signed the agreement, was it fair? Or
- 22:38in other words, was it unconscionable? So an
- 22:42example would be the employer knew that the employee
- 22:47did not speak, understand, or read English and
- 22:52was given an arbitration agreement and it was
- 22:55only in English. It was never translated. The
- 22:58employer knew the worker did not understand the
- 23:02agreement and told the employee, you have to
- 23:05sign this as a condition of employment. And they
- 23:09weren't given an opportunity to have it translated.
- 23:12So they signed a document and they were bound
- 23:14by a document that they did not understand. That
- 23:17would be an example of procedural unconscionability.
- 23:20In one way, you can argue this agreement is so
- 23:24unfair that it should not be enforced. The second
- 23:27aspect is substantive unconscionability. So you
- 23:30look at the actual substance of this document
- 23:34and you ask yourself, is the substance so unfair,
- 23:38meaning it shocks your conscience that it should
- 23:40not be enforced? So I'll give an extreme example.
- 23:44And maybe it's not extreme, it could be in some
- 23:46agreements. There's a discovery provision and
- 23:48the discovery provision basically says that neither
- 23:51party can take any depositions and they're not
- 23:53allowed to send any interrogatories and they're
- 23:57not allowed to send any requests for production
- 23:59of documents. Basically no discovery. That may
- 24:02be considered substantively unconscionable because
- 24:05you are forcing the opposing party to go prosecute
- 24:10a hearing without obtaining any discovery. And
- 24:13so if you bring a wrongful term claim, a discrimination,
- 24:17harassment, or retaliation claim, at a minimum,
- 24:22the process and the substance of the agreement
- 24:25needs to be fair. So those are some of the general
- 24:28preliminary issues that you would look at before
- 24:31you even start the arbitration process, you look
- 24:34at these procedural steps first. All right. So
- 24:41we are going to assume that at this point, we
- 24:44are going to assume that the arbitration clause
- 24:47or stipulation to arbitration is both procedurally
- 24:51and substantively non -inconscionable. and that
- 24:54we are ready to proceed. So in the event you
- 24:57find yourself having to file an employment claim
- 24:59or if you know that an employee of a company
- 25:06you represent will be filing an employment claim,
- 25:09this is how it gets started. So as we discussed
- 25:13earlier, arbitration is a creature of contract.
- 25:16So one way to get to arbitration is that there
- 25:18is a clause in the employment agreement that
- 25:22requires the arbitration of whatever the dispute
- 25:25is. Because it is some, like we said earlier,
- 25:28there are some disputes that you're just not
- 25:29going to get into arbitration or that the parties
- 25:32have agreed will go to court. Or you can, if
- 25:38you don't have a contract that requires arbitration
- 25:40and both parties agree to go to arbitration instead
- 25:44of going to court, you can stipulate post -dispute
- 25:48to arbitration. and then you would just submit,
- 25:53most ADR providers, AAA included, have a submission
- 25:56form and we have a demand form when there's a
- 25:58contract. The other part is that there is a court
- 26:02order. For whatever reason, a court has said,
- 26:06you know, this dispute needs to go to court.
- 26:10Usually there is, maybe there was a discussion
- 26:12about an old contract and we don't have copies
- 26:16of it or something like that, the court can require
- 26:18the parties to arbitrate their dispute. So once
- 26:24you know that you have to go to arbitration,
- 26:27you would fill out a simple demand form. They're
- 26:30usually located online at the ADR providers website
- 26:34pursuant to the different rule sets. So for us,
- 26:37it would be the employment rules. You would include
- 26:42either a copy of the arbitration clause from
- 26:45the contract, the stipulation where both parties
- 26:49have signed, yes, we want to arbitrate this matter,
- 26:51or a court order that requires the parties to
- 26:54arbitrate. And then you would also have to pay
- 26:57the appropriate fees to the provider. As we discussed
- 27:01earlier for employees, it's a small fee and then
- 27:05a larger fee that needs to be paid to the administrator
- 27:09or ADR provider within 30 days. Or else then
- 27:14the claimant or the employee can... Employee
- 27:20will be deemed to have waived that, and the party
- 27:23can go back to court and ask the court to hear
- 27:26instead of having to go to arbitration. And then
- 27:34once the ADR provider has received the filing,
- 27:38we do tend to get a few initial issues. Not in
- 27:42every case. but we'll talk briefly about what
- 27:45some of the common initial issues that we get
- 27:47when we first have a case presented to us. So
- 27:52there are parallel court filings, ambiguous arbitration
- 27:56clauses, there's issues of confidentiality, and
- 27:59then there's the cost allocation. So. Christina
- 28:04is going to talk about the first three briefly,
- 28:06but for cost allocation, just know that the case
- 28:10law in this continues to change. So if you're
- 28:12an employment practitioner, you just want to
- 28:14make sure that you're up to date on all of the
- 28:16case law. OK, very good. So there could be instances
- 28:21in which there are parallel court filings. What
- 28:24that basically means is there was a filing. So
- 28:28you have one set of facts. claimant, one respondent,
- 28:34or maybe more, and there are dual filings. So
- 28:38there could be a filing in arbitration, there
- 28:40could be a filing in superior court. And depending
- 28:43on the type of claim that exists, the parallel
- 28:47filings could be completely appropriate. or it
- 28:51could be not appropriate and one needs to close
- 28:55or one needs to be stayed to allow one to happen.
- 28:58But it would be very difficult to have a proceeding
- 29:01proceed on one set of claims in arbitration and
- 29:05then the same set in a court of law. And so at
- 29:08that point, one cannot begin the arbitration
- 29:11until the parties resolve these parallel court
- 29:14filings. So how could this possibly exist? It's
- 29:18basically an issue of law. So for example, like
- 29:23I indicated, you might have a plaintiff that
- 29:26files a representative Paga action along with
- 29:29their own individual Paga claim. So there are
- 29:35a lot of cases such as Viking River and all the
- 29:40court cases after Viking River that have held
- 29:42that you may compel arbitration of the plaintiff's
- 29:46own single Paga claim for himself or herself,
- 29:50but those same Supreme Court cases do not allow
- 29:55arbitration of the representative claim or the
- 29:59class action claim. Therefore, a respondent,
- 30:03a defendant, might petition the Superior Court
- 30:06to compel the plaintiff to litigate his or her
- 30:11own single Paga and wage an hour claim. and then
- 30:16stay the representative claim. Why are they staying
- 30:19it? Because the outcome of the arbitration might
- 30:24affect the representative Paga claim. So it would
- 30:29not be appropriate to have both cases proceeding
- 30:33at the same time. So one of those cases might
- 30:36be stayed. Or you have a case where a matter
- 30:40was filed in Superior Court and one party filed
- 30:44a petition to compel arbitration, and the other
- 30:47party is objecting to it, and then somehow the
- 30:51arbitration, which moves at a faster timeline,
- 30:54is moving more quickly than, let's say, the Superior
- 30:58Court, which is now engaged in civil law and
- 31:02motion proceedings, and based on the court's
- 31:04calendar, you're not getting a hearing date to
- 31:06resolve some issues. So if you have these parallel
- 31:09filings, it is important to bring it up with
- 31:13the arbitrator at the first instance so that
- 31:17these issues can be resolved as quickly as possible
- 31:21so that both legal proceedings can go in the
- 31:25right timeline. So you want to address the parallel
- 31:28court filings quickly. You also at the preliminary
- 31:31stage want to address ambiguous arbitration clauses
- 31:35and as I'll defer some of it when you start talking
- 31:38about the preliminary hearing. but it's at the
- 31:41preliminary hearing where ambiguous arbitration
- 31:45clauses might become an issue and it really deals
- 31:49with discovery, the scope of discovery, dispositive
- 31:54motions, for example, or even the choice of law.
- 31:59And so those are issues that you're going to
- 32:01have to bring up in the preliminary hearing.
- 32:08So we have a demand that has been filed, and
- 32:12it is now in front of the case manager. At this
- 32:16point, we are assuming that you chose an ADR
- 32:17provider and you're not doing ad hoc. The ADR
- 32:22provider's case manager will have received your
- 32:27contract, your demand, and any subsequent or...
- 32:31court orders attached or pleadings or anything
- 32:34like that at the beginning stages and the case
- 32:37manager will review the case file and look to
- 32:42see if there is something laid out in the clause
- 32:47about how to select the arbitrator. So sometimes
- 32:51a contract clause calls for three arbitrators.
- 32:55Sometimes it calls for a single arbitrator. That
- 32:58will be, you know, something the parties can
- 33:01agree if the parties agree to have a single arbitrator
- 33:04hear the case and the contract clause calls for
- 33:08three arbitrators, then you can certainly let
- 33:10your case manager know and we would just appoint
- 33:12a single arbitrator. And it does tend to be much
- 33:16cheaper. I believe it's five times more expensive
- 33:19to have a panel hear a case than it is to have
- 33:22a single arbitrator hear a case. If the arbitration
- 33:27clause is silent, If it doesn't lay out a process
- 33:31for the provider to follow in terms of how the
- 33:34parties are supposed to select an arbitrator,
- 33:36or it defers to that ADR providers rules, then
- 33:41we will follow our rules. And for AAA, there's
- 33:48a couple of things you can do. We generally will
- 33:51send out a rank and strike list. The arbitrators
- 33:55on our panel In order to be on our panel, they
- 33:58have to have 50 % of their practice before they
- 34:05join the panel, or even during, be devoted to
- 34:09employment matters. these are arbitrators who
- 34:13have the necessary expertise to hear an employment
- 34:17case because it is a different type of law and
- 34:20it's very nuanced and we want the arbitrators
- 34:24to continually be up to date on the newest case
- 34:28law because they're going to have to apply it.
- 34:33We will send out a list of 14 arbitrators. I'm
- 34:37sorry, a list of about 10 arbitrators or more,
- 34:41depending on how many arbitrators we need to
- 34:43select. And generally, it will be arbitrators
- 34:48from the location the hearing is supposed to
- 34:50be in. So let's say. your contract says that
- 34:53any hearings that will take place will take place
- 34:55in Los Angeles, then the arbitrators, at least
- 34:59on the very first list, will generally be from
- 35:01the Los Angeles area. They will be on the employment
- 35:04panel and the parties will have two weeks, pursuant
- 35:09to our rules, to either mutually agree on an
- 35:13arbitrator, which we always think is best, but
- 35:15we know is not something that can happen in every
- 35:18case. So they can either by mutually, mutually
- 35:22agreeing on an arbitrator. and then letting the
- 35:25case manager know this is the person that we
- 35:27want. Or if you know that you're just not going
- 35:30to get mutual agreement or you can't, then you
- 35:32rank and strike. So you strike the arbitrators
- 35:35you don't want, and you rank the rest. And then
- 35:37the provider chooses or we invite the most mutually
- 35:43agreeable arbitrator based on those two lists,
- 35:46each side giving us their feedback. What we try
- 35:51not to do is select an arbitrator for you. The
- 35:56selection of the arbitrator is probably the most
- 35:59important decision you're making early on in
- 36:02your case and it's one of the things that sets
- 36:06arbitration apart from going to court. So we
- 36:10try not to and it's usually It's usually a very
- 36:15last resort, you know, we've sent multiple lists.
- 36:18I'm not talking just one or two, I'm talking
- 36:20three or four lists. We've had to maybe even
- 36:23move outside of Southern California and now we're
- 36:26in the Bay Area or sometimes we're out of California
- 36:28altogether because we cannot get you a list of
- 36:32arbitrators that you can agree on. In order to
- 36:36make sure that the case continues to proceed,
- 36:39we will select an arbitrator, but nobody wants
- 36:41to do that for you. We want the parties to have
- 36:44a say in this really important decision. So that's
- 36:50what arbitrator selection. can look like and
- 36:53then we did discuss the kinds of disclosures
- 36:56that will need to be sent to the parties prior
- 36:59to the arbitrator doing any work on your case
- 37:01and it's I want to say in California like 20s.
- 37:0628 or 30 questions about your, have you ever
- 37:10worked for any of the parties? Have you ever
- 37:14worked with them? Do you have any relationship
- 37:16with them? And then the same for all of the representatives,
- 37:20for the attorneys. Or have you ever arbitrated
- 37:24a case of, were you an arbitrator for anybody
- 37:28in this matter? And then the arbitrator has to
- 37:30disclose that as well. All right. Now, Christine,
- 37:38we've selected an arbitrator and you're at the
- 37:41preliminary hearing. So Christine is an arbitrator
- 37:44on our panel. So I'm going to let you discuss
- 37:47what the preliminary hearing looks like and any
- 37:51tips or tricks at this stage that you want to
- 37:54give the attorneys on the web. Great. Yes. Thank
- 37:59you. Thank you, Stephanie. So you're at that
- 38:01stage now. You selected your arbitrator. And
- 38:04the next step is that the case manager will coordinate
- 38:08a date and time that is available for all parties,
- 38:11meaning the claimant, the respondent, as well
- 38:13as the arbitrator to set up the first preliminary
- 38:15hearing. And once you secure that date and time,
- 38:20the arbitrator might have a template proposed,
- 38:24let's say, status conference form, the same type
- 38:27of status conference form that you might see
- 38:29in a court of law that you need to file a few
- 38:31days before your first status conference, except
- 38:34in arbitration, the form is a little bit more
- 38:37detailed because the parties have opportunities
- 38:40to really negotiate and agree. to a lot of the
- 38:45process. And so for example, prior to the preliminary
- 38:49hearing, when the two parties meet and confer
- 38:52to fill out their joint status conference report,
- 38:55they get to decide when would you like this hearing?
- 38:58And actually sometimes I see parties disagree
- 39:00as to when they want this hearing, they actually
- 39:03disagree as to the length of the hearing, and
- 39:05then they disagree as to the location of the
- 39:08hearing. In which case that is. At the preliminary
- 39:12hearing conference, I will listen to the relative
- 39:15concerns and issues of both sides. And then I
- 39:19would need to decide on the hearing date, the
- 39:23length of the hearing, and the location. And
- 39:26sometimes there's a dispute between whether or
- 39:28not they want it done remotely, or they want
- 39:31a hybrid, or they want all of it in live. So
- 39:35those are issues that your arbitrator will have
- 39:37to resolve if the parties cannot agree amongst
- 39:40themselves. Another issue that the parties can
- 39:43agree to that is really important is the extent
- 39:47of discovery. So unlike a court of law where
- 39:51you just follow the code of civil procedure or
- 39:53the federal rules of civil procedure, the parties,
- 39:56the first thing they should look at is the arbitration
- 39:58agreement. And you're looking to see if there's
- 40:02a limitation on discovery. So I gave you the
- 40:05example of an arbitration provision that basically
- 40:09said you can't do any discovery. at all. Well,
- 40:14if that were the case, the unhappy party might
- 40:18put in the Joint Status Conference Report that
- 40:22they're going to challenge that provision right
- 40:24away. So you really can't even set a hearing
- 40:27date if one of the parties is already challenging
- 40:31something that affects the process itself. Or
- 40:36an arbitration contract might have a limitation
- 40:39of discovery. Let's say they're limited to two
- 40:43depositions, but one party feels that they need
- 40:47to take 15 depositions. And they might tell me
- 40:51that. They said, look, we will agree to a limitation
- 40:54on discovery, but The limit is 15 depositions
- 40:58plus an expert witness. And if there's a dispute
- 41:02on that, I would need to resolve that issue.
- 41:05There might be. issues about dispositive motions.
- 41:11They might limit the ability to do a dispositive
- 41:14motion. Once again, you look at your arbitration
- 41:17agreement. Does it indicate that you have a right
- 41:20to file a dispositive motion? And so you want
- 41:23to consider your arbitration agreement as your
- 41:25scheduling order in terms of your discovery and
- 41:29your motion. You're also looking at your pre
- 41:33-hearing briefs. and whether or not the parties
- 41:36intend to engage in mediation or have settlement
- 41:40discussions, you might want to let the arbitrator
- 41:42know because they will be setting your hearing
- 41:45date. Another issue that's really important is
- 41:48the type of an award you want the arbitrator
- 41:51to render. So in employment cases, the rules
- 41:56of your arbitration provider might indicate that
- 42:00the arbitrator has to grant a reasoned award,
- 42:05meaning there are reasons behind the decision.
- 42:08But if the parties do not want a reason behind
- 42:11the decision, what you'll get is an award but
- 42:14with no explanation, which means it will be harder
- 42:18to challenge that award decision if you don't
- 42:22even understand the reasoning, especially under
- 42:25the FAA, where the basis for vacature is a manifest
- 42:31disregard of the law. The parties will also agree
- 42:35on whether or not they want a court reporter.
- 42:38Some arbitrations, the parties don't want a court
- 42:41reporter. They don't believe that the amount
- 42:42at issue is enough to justify a court reporter.
- 42:47And then you'll have to have a meet and confer
- 42:50as to how you would like to present your exhibits
- 42:53and your binders. So I've had cases where the
- 42:58respondents council and the claimants council
- 43:00have worked with each other sufficiently before
- 43:03they even appeared before me that they've already
- 43:06said we already have an exhibit binder and we've
- 43:10already stipulated to it and here it is and I
- 43:14open it up and it's you know 1 ,000 exhibits
- 43:16and they've already stipulated to it and they're
- 43:18already pre -marked which is great and you might
- 43:21have parties where they disagree in which case
- 43:24we need to talk about how we're going to lay
- 43:28out our exhibits. And then finally, of course,
- 43:30some housekeeping matters, the formality. So
- 43:33this is an interesting issue because arbitration
- 43:35is actually a very informal process, but it's
- 43:38not so informal that The way we address people
- 43:43is relaxed. So you want to address your arbitrator
- 43:47and your opposing counsel with the respective
- 43:50titles because you do want a certain amount of
- 43:53decorum and respect. I've seen instances where
- 43:57the attorneys, they start engaging in a lot of
- 44:01bickering and fighting in front of me and part
- 44:05of managing that is to really manage the formality
- 44:09of the process that even though it's less formal,
- 44:13it is a litigation forum and that all council
- 44:17and the parties, your respective clients need
- 44:20to respect that this is a formal litigation process
- 44:24to a certain degree. All right, so I think we
- 44:29covered a lot of the discovery and scheduling
- 44:31issues. in the previous slide but um if there's
- 44:35anything on here uh that you want to go over
- 44:39um Christine let me know but just um some ADR
- 44:42just very briefly um some ADR providers do have
- 44:46discovery protocols um I know ours are listed
- 44:49on the AAA's website um for uh FLSA and then
- 44:53non -FLSA cases um Fair Labor Standards Act uh
- 44:57but um Let me know if there's anything else on
- 45:00here that you want to point out because I do
- 45:03have a question for you Christine Okay. Sure.
- 45:06I think this is a pretty significant because
- 45:08your arbitrator provider platform whatever it
- 45:12is there's a lot of different providers out there
- 45:15they all have their own rules and And they might
- 45:19have rules on discovery. So some arbitration
- 45:22platform provider has something called an initial
- 45:25disclosure, which is similar to Rule 26 and now
- 45:28the Code of Civil Procedure, where the parties
- 45:31engage in an initial disclosure of documents.
- 45:35And I asked the parties if they would like to
- 45:37agree to the discovery rules of the arbitration
- 45:41provider platform. And if they do, I set a deadline
- 45:44for that initial disclosure of documents. The
- 45:48purpose for that is to streamline your discovery
- 45:51such that the parties will disclose documents
- 45:53that are relevant. And I'll just give an example.
- 45:56In a wage and hour case, if you're doing an initial
- 46:00disclosure, most attorneys know what you are
- 46:03supposed to be disclosing and you disclose it
- 46:05and you save time. And what I do is I set a deadline.
- 46:09So I give time for the parties to get their claims
- 46:11settled and to give them time to compile their
- 46:15documents, debate stamp them, and then get them
- 46:17to the other side. And once I set that deadline,
- 46:20they can then review it and then they can follow
- 46:22up with traditional discovery. But once you get
- 46:25everything, you might not need as much formal
- 46:28discovery. If you're not willing to agree to
- 46:30it, and your arbitration agreement is silent,
- 46:33then the default would be the Code of Civil Procedure
- 46:36absent an agreement by the parties. So the first
- 46:40thing you want to consider before your first
- 46:42preliminary conference with the arbitrator is
- 46:45to read the rules of the provider organization
- 46:50and see if they have any process for discovery.
- 46:54And if it's something that you believe is helpful
- 46:56for your case, then during your meet and confer,
- 46:59you can propose to the opposing counsel that
- 47:02you would like to follow the provider organization
- 47:05discovery tools. And then the last of course
- 47:09is will the arbitration agreement limit discovery?
- 47:12Absolutely. There are many provisions where the
- 47:15drafter has limited discovery. Just be careful
- 47:19that if it's too limited, it can be considered
- 47:22substantively unconscionable in which case the
- 47:27party that is not happy or challenging that provision
- 47:30will inform the arbitrator that they need to
- 47:34address this issue first. And then that would
- 47:37trigger a law and motion briefing schedule and
- 47:42a hearing to address the preliminary aspects
- 47:46of arbitration before you get started. All right.
- 47:53So Christine. Can you talk to us about the alternative
- 47:57methods for presenting evidence in arbitration
- 48:00and how it differs from court? We're at the stage
- 48:05now where everybody has gotten the discovery
- 48:09that they've needed or were ready to at least
- 48:11proceed to the evidentiary hearing, which is
- 48:15akin to a trial. So Christine, as an arbitrator,
- 48:19can you talk to us about that? Yes, yes. Thank
- 48:21you, Stephanie. So the great thing about arbitration
- 48:24is because the parties have a little bit more
- 48:26control of the process, they can actually decide
- 48:29how they would like to litigate their case. That's
- 48:31very different from a court of law where you
- 48:34have to follow very strict deadlines and timelines
- 48:38set forth under the Code of Civil Procedure.
- 48:41So for example, I've had cases where the parties
- 48:46want a desk arbitration. So what's a desk arbitration?
- 48:50They want to save time and they want to conserve
- 48:54their financial resources. So they have waived
- 48:57oral arguments. They don't want a hearing. They'd
- 49:00rather just submit briefs with exhibits and declaration.
- 49:06And they want an award or a decision based on
- 49:11a briefing schedule. And what's interesting about
- 49:14that is they might not they might even agree
- 49:18that we don't even need to lay the foundation
- 49:20for admissibility. The parties agree that these
- 49:23documents are the actual genuine documents. We're
- 49:27not going to lay the foundation that this section
- 49:29of the depot transcript. assume that it's true,
- 49:33there's no contrary testimony, and ask the arbitrator
- 49:36render an award based on this. The other thing
- 49:38that's interesting about arbitration is the arbitrator
- 49:42can rely on case law outside of your jurisdiction.
- 49:48So it's very frequent that The parties are citing
- 49:53cases, not only outside of our jurisdiction,
- 49:57but they're also relying on previous awards,
- 50:01opinion letters, etc. to use as persuasive authority,
- 50:06and they're asking the arbitrator to consider
- 50:09that. If you do decide to have a physical hearing,
- 50:13it could be anywhere. It could be in the law
- 50:16office conference room. It could be at your arbitrator
- 50:20provider organization. And when you show up,
- 50:23you're going to get a conference room at a conference
- 50:26table. So it's not going to look like a courtroom.
- 50:28But for all intents and purposes, you do need
- 50:31to set forth. testimony and you will have a court
- 50:34reporter if the parties agree to it. And the
- 50:37conduct of the proceedings are a little bit more
- 50:39informal, but the burdens of proof are still
- 50:42the same. The claimant has the burden of proof
- 50:44based on the type of claim that they're proceeding
- 50:47with and the respondent can still move forward
- 50:51with their alternative defenses. The other great
- 50:55aspect of it is the parties can agree to a fully
- 50:59remote hearing, or they can agree to a hybrid,
- 51:03and oftentimes the parties might disagree. One
- 51:06side might want a fully remote hearing, the other
- 51:10side might want a in -person hearing. In which
- 51:14case, the parties might agree to a hybrid hearing
- 51:17where it's physical in person, but any witness,
- 51:21they have the option of appearing remotely. So
- 51:25there's very, very different ways and you can
- 51:27be very creative as to how you would like to
- 51:29have that hearing. And part of it is you go back
- 51:32to the philosophy of arbitrations, which is efficiency.
- 51:36And it's basically your case. This is your contract.
- 51:39and the arbitrator will give some deference and
- 51:43will consider alternative methods of putting
- 51:45on that evidence. All right, so now we've had
- 51:51our hearing and the arbitrator is we're in the
- 51:55post hearing phase of the case. We have, as I
- 51:59stated earlier, this is not something every case
- 52:01will have. It really is case dependent and arbitrator
- 52:04and party dependent. But in the event there are
- 52:07post hearing briefs, a deadline will be set.
- 52:11Very rarely is additional hearing or argument
- 52:14needed. And the post -hering briefing is not
- 52:17a time to raise new arguments. It's not a time
- 52:20to present new evidence. It usually is just more
- 52:23a rehashing and pointing out to the arbitrator
- 52:27or panel of arbitrators the highlights of your
- 52:30case, why your claim is correct, why the law
- 52:36is in your favor. And once that is all done and
- 52:41the arbitrator or arbitrator feel she has the
- 52:45all of the information she needs to make her
- 52:47decision, she will close the hearings. That's
- 52:51usually just done either in an email to the case
- 52:53manager or to the parties to let them know I'm
- 52:56no longer taking any more information. The hearings
- 52:58are closed and I will be issuing my award within.
- 53:0230 days. Very rarely do arbitrators need longer.
- 53:07Sometimes I'll have to reopen it if there is
- 53:10something in the record that doesn't make sense
- 53:14or if they'll wait too close to hearings until
- 53:16all the transcripts are in if there was a court
- 53:18reporter that was present at the hearing because
- 53:21you want to make sure all the transcripts are
- 53:22in and generally the parties want those transcripts
- 53:25as well so they can write their post hearing
- 53:26briefs. In arbitration there are generally deadlines
- 53:33for awards so like I said the AAA has a 30 -day
- 53:35deadline after the hearings have closed. The
- 53:38award will address or should address every single
- 53:42claim that was made by either party so sometimes
- 53:45in arbitration you will in employment arbitration
- 53:48you will have counterclaims but all of those
- 53:52need to be addressed within the award and if
- 53:57there is an interim award which is when the arbitrator
- 54:01lets everyone know who the prevailing party is,
- 54:04and then we go through the attorney's fees, which
- 54:07we didn't go into here because that could probably
- 54:08be its own hour long CLE. Then the final award
- 54:14will be rendered to the parties. A common question
- 54:18is, can you appeal to the arbitrator? No. The
- 54:20arbitrator under the AAA's employment rules can,
- 54:23a party can. ask for a modification of the award
- 54:28to clarify if there's a typographical error or
- 54:30a numerical you know the numbers aren't adding
- 54:32up but it doesn't change who who the prevailing
- 54:36party was, you can do that within a short amount
- 54:40of time after the hearing or after the award
- 54:42has been rendered. But once the arbitrator has
- 54:45rendered their final award, she no longer has
- 54:48jurisdiction over that case or the parties. Enforcement
- 54:52and appeal of any award will have to go to state
- 54:55or federal court depending on if it's under the
- 54:59CAA or the FAA. And then really quickly, because
- 55:03I know we're running out of time, just wanted
- 55:07to give Christine a chance to talk about pitfalls
- 55:11to avoid from her perspective as an arbitrator.
- 55:15Okay. Thank you, Stephanie. So one of the things
- 55:17you're going to look at, of course, is the arbitration
- 55:20agreements itself. And if it's vague, And it's
- 55:23vague on a particular issue. That's when you
- 55:27raise it during your preliminary hearing if you
- 55:29need resolution by the arbitrator, if you can't
- 55:32get an agreement by counsel. The other issue
- 55:36is poor communication and cooperation between
- 55:39counsel. If the attorneys are not getting along,
- 55:43then it's going to result in more law in motion
- 55:46and more discovery disputes and that really just
- 55:49results in a more expensive arbitration. And
- 55:52so you want to be able to streamline that process.
- 55:56If there are discovery disputes, you have to
- 55:58look at proportionality. So unlike maybe a court
- 56:02of law, an arbitrator might put on a fairness
- 56:06hat to say, well, based on the discovery that
- 56:08you're seeking, let's look at the types of claims
- 56:12that you are trying to prosecute. So for example,
- 56:16if a discovery provision has a limitation on
- 56:21depositions and one side is challenging that,
- 56:24I might look at the type of claim that's involved
- 56:27and ask, well, is it sufficient or is the case
- 56:30so complex that that discovery provision is unconscionable
- 56:35because it really limits the party's ability
- 56:38to prepare the case and to secure the information
- 56:40that they need. It's really important that once
- 56:44the deadlines are set by the arbitrator that
- 56:47you respect the deadlines and to follow the process.
- 56:50Even though it's an informal process, The whole
- 56:56goal is to process it efficiently and you don't
- 56:59want to wait on doing your discovery because
- 57:02that will affect the ability to have a hearing.
- 57:06So really the overarching principle is to allow
- 57:11this process to go smoothly, to make it as efficient
- 57:14as possible. And the way we do that is we have
- 57:20more discretion. And we're not necessarily bound
- 57:23by the code of civil procedure or the federal
- 57:26rules of civil procedure. And we can streamline
- 57:29the case more easily than if you were not in
- 57:32arbitration. And then finally, of course, it's
- 57:35always more pleasant when everybody is professional
- 57:38throughout the entire process. Your representative
- 57:41parties, it's a more pleasant process for them.
- 57:44It's a more pleasant process for the attorneys,
- 57:46of course. And it really helps the whole process
- 57:51in terms of being able to maintain fairness and
- 57:54efficiency. All right. So that's it for the presentation.
- 58:01I know we're at time. So it looks like we have
- 58:09a few questions. I don't know if we'll be able
- 58:12to get through all of them. It looks like there
- 58:18are some for you, Christine. So the first one
- 58:19is, has discovery is the bait of litigation,
- 58:23sometimes leveraged to compel settlement? Do
- 58:25you have proposed limits that have sustained
- 58:27liberal discovery scrutiny? So that's a thank
- 58:31you for that question. If one of the parties
- 58:34believes that the discovery process is being
- 58:37abused, and let me back up. You look at your
- 58:40arbitration agreement, if there are no limits
- 58:42on discovery, and the parties never agree to
- 58:46a limitation on discovery, you would default
- 58:48to the CCP. The great thing about arbitration
- 58:51is if a party believes that discovery is being
- 58:54exploited or being utilized for some other means
- 58:59other than to obtain the information, you have
- 59:03the ability to ask for a discovery conference
- 59:06with the arbitrator. and ask the arbitrator,
- 59:10can you please limit the discovery because it
- 59:13is not, what do you call it? It does not lead
- 59:16to the discovery of admissible evidence and it's
- 59:20not relevant. And it doesn't even relate to the
- 59:23claims that are being litigated. And the arbitrator
- 59:26can consider that. And that's the beauty, is
- 59:29that they can put a limit on discovery. It may
- 59:31not even be harassing. It is simply too much.
- 59:34for the type of claims that you are prosecuting,
- 59:37and you can ask the arbitrator to put a limit
- 59:40on that. The next question is, in case an award
- 59:44is without reason, but there is some substantive
- 59:47unconscionable element in it, can it still be
- 59:50challenged? Yes, thanks for that question, Ms.
- 59:54Rana. So the whole concept of substantive unconscionability
- 59:57goes back to the arbitration contract, and that
- 1:00:02leads to lack of enforceability, and there's
- 1:00:06a whole body of case law on what is considered
- 1:00:09unconscionable. And when you're looking, even
- 1:00:12before your first preliminary hearing, when you
- 1:00:17look at the agreement and if you believe that
- 1:00:20the agreement should not be enforced because
- 1:00:22it's unconscionable, that's one of the first
- 1:00:24things you raise with the arbitrator. so that
- 1:00:27you can discuss the lack of enforcement if you
- 1:00:30believe it is the case, such that the arbitrator
- 1:00:33will have to make a decision as to whether or
- 1:00:35not to set a briefing schedule or to take some
- 1:00:38other action. But once the award is written,
- 1:00:44that assumes that you've agreed to the entire
- 1:00:46discovery process, you've agreed to the litigation
- 1:00:49process. Substantive unconscionability is not
- 1:00:53a basis for vacating an arbitration award under
- 1:00:56the FAA or the CAA. And so I'm going to go to
- 1:01:01another question about that. And then we'll get
- 1:01:03back to Seth's question. But if the plaintiff
- 1:01:06files in court because she believes the arbitration
- 1:01:09was unconscionable, why can't they have the court
- 1:01:11decide the issue instead of an arbitrator? So
- 1:01:14that is thank you for the question. This Fujiwara.
- 1:01:20There's a whole body of case law right on that
- 1:01:24very, very issue. And the issue that you've just
- 1:01:28addressed is a legal issue. And the legal issue
- 1:01:31is who decides the enforceability of the arbitration
- 1:01:36agreement? Is it a judge or is it the arbitrator?
- 1:01:40And it really depends on the language of the
- 1:01:42arbitration agreement. And so you always go back
- 1:01:45to what was written. in the arbitration agreement
- 1:01:49with respect to jurisdiction and deciding enforceability.
- 1:01:53But it is a very complex area of law. But either
- 1:01:59outcome is actually feasible. It could either
- 1:02:02be the arbitrator or the judge depending on how
- 1:02:06the agreement was written. So I think the overarching
- 1:02:09theme you've been hearing is the drafter of the
- 1:02:13arbitration agreement when they draft it needs
- 1:02:16to be very clear, very unambiguous, and very
- 1:02:20thorough and comprehensive in order for it helps
- 1:02:23with enforceability. And then Ms. Spiewak asked,
- 1:02:28what is the typical use of additional initial,
- 1:02:31excuse me, discovery protocols for employment
- 1:02:33arbitration cases? Are they presumptively applicable
- 1:02:36and effective to make the parties exchange basic
- 1:02:39discovery barely on without requests like the
- 1:02:41initial disclosures in federal court? What actually
- 1:02:44typically happens? So what do you see in your
- 1:02:47cases actually happen? Yes, thank you, Mr. Spiewak.
- 1:02:52So first of all, The parties need to agree to
- 1:02:57the initial discovery disclosures and the employment
- 1:03:00arbitration rules. So number one, look at your
- 1:03:04arbitration agreement and then look for a section
- 1:03:06on discovery and ask yourself, does this agreement
- 1:03:10limit my discovery in any way? And if the answer
- 1:03:14is yes, then you can ask yourself, well, is it
- 1:03:17a reasonable limitation or is it an unreasonable
- 1:03:20limitation? If it's unreasonable, you could challenge
- 1:03:25that. If it's reasonable, like if it says either
- 1:03:28side can take up to 20 depositions and it's a
- 1:03:30small five employee coffee shop, 20 is reasonable
- 1:03:35because there's only five employees. So there
- 1:03:39would be no reason to challenge it. That should
- 1:03:42govern. And then in addition to that, during
- 1:03:45your meet and confer with the attorney, you can
- 1:03:48agree to the discovery protocols and the arbitration
- 1:03:52rules. And if both lawyers agree to the discovery
- 1:03:54protocols, then you would do an initial disclosure.
- 1:03:58What's the advantage of an initial disclosure?
- 1:04:00The advantage is you get the documents right
- 1:04:02away, or at least based on the timeline that
- 1:04:05the arbitrator sets, and you don't have to do
- 1:04:07a request for production of documents. So it
- 1:04:09saves you time in checking off the boxes, in
- 1:04:13drafting the RTP, and it saves the other side
- 1:04:17time in responding to an RTP. Either side or
- 1:04:20both sides just look at what they believe is
- 1:04:23relevant. They collect the documents, they bait
- 1:04:27stamp it, and they can email it to the other
- 1:04:31side. So you save both sides a lot of time. Now
- 1:04:34at that point, if you still believe that there's
- 1:04:37additional discovery that you want, you can then
- 1:04:40send out a request for production of documents
- 1:04:42if your arbitration agreement allows it to. If
- 1:04:45it doesn't, and you feel the need for it, you
- 1:04:48have the option of asking the arbitrator for
- 1:04:50intervention. All right. It looks like Seth sent
- 1:04:57a link. Thank you for that. So Sandra, if you
- 1:05:06want to email me directly, I can try and help
- 1:05:11you with that. I'm not sure. There might be procedural
- 1:05:16issues that haven't taken place yet. I couldn't.
- 1:05:19answer that directly yet but please email me
- 1:05:22and I can I'm more than happy to help and if
- 1:05:25anybody else has any questions either you know
- 1:05:28live or if you're watching this recorded please
- 1:05:31email me if they're for Christine I can direct
- 1:05:33them to her but we really appreciate everyone's
- 1:05:37time here today thank you so much. Yes thank
- 1:05:41you.