Latest / Yaron Brook Show / Religion in the 21st Century -- A Conversation With Ben Bayer | Yaron Brook Show
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: A lot of them, funds of Leado, little cell interest
- 0:09Speaker 1: and an individual lots. This is the show, all right, everybody,
- 0:21Speaker 1: welcome to you on Book Show on this Monday, February
- 0:25Speaker 1: twenty fourth, our second show today. I hope everybody's having
- 0:29Speaker 1: a fantastic start your week, and uh yeah, I'm excited.
- 0:34Speaker 1: Today we're going to be talking to Ben Bear. We're
- 0:36Speaker 1: going to be talking about one of my favorite subjects,
- 0:40Speaker 1: religion and and what's up with everybody becoming religious. So
- 0:46Speaker 1: we'll talk about that. We'll talk about Jadie Vance's comments.
- 0:50Speaker 1: We'll talk about a controversy with which you guys probably
- 0:52Speaker 1: haven't heard much about within the kind of atheist movement.
- 0:57Speaker 1: I don't think it made a lot of waves out
- 1:00Speaker 1: side of outside of that movement. But we'll talk about that,
- 1:05Speaker 1: and then of course, you guys get to do someone
- 1:08Speaker 1: what we talk about. You guys ask questions. We'll talk
- 1:12Speaker 1: about anything. Remember Ben's a philosopher, so any philosophical questions
- 1:16Speaker 1: that you've asked me, and I said, ah, ask a philosopher,
- 1:19Speaker 1: now's your chance. We'll have Greg Gonn in a couple
- 1:22Speaker 1: of weeks. You can add ask him some philosopher questions
- 1:25Speaker 1: as well. But ask whatever you want to ask. We're here.
- 1:30Speaker 1: We're here. If we can't answer something, we'll tell you. Yeah, Ben,
- 1:35Speaker 1: thanks for joining me.
- 1:37Speaker 2: Thanks very I love I love coming on the show.
- 1:39Speaker 1: Good Good. So, as you all know, Ben is a
- 1:43Speaker 1: fellow fellow at the Ironman Institute and a philosopher. I've
- 1:49Speaker 1: known Ben since you ran a compass club years and
- 1:52Speaker 1: years and years ago at the University of Illinois in Champagne.
- 1:57Speaker 1: And uh yeah, let's let's jump into it. So and
- 2:04Speaker 1: and Ben has a particularly interest and has written quite
- 2:06Speaker 1: a bit and and tweets a lot about kind of
- 2:10Speaker 1: these issues regarding religion. And he's he did a really
- 2:12Speaker 1: good talk which I highly recommend on Augustine's and Augustine
- 2:18Speaker 1: that's uh on the institute YouTube channel, so you can
- 2:23Speaker 1: catch it there. Uh So, yeah, So there's been this phenomena,
- 2:31Speaker 1: you know it. It probably started before this, but it
- 2:34Speaker 1: really hit home with iron Her Cyli kind of uh,
- 2:40Speaker 1: I don't know if becoming Christian is even right, but
- 2:43Speaker 1: it is even the right terminology, but kind of acknowledging
- 2:46Speaker 1: that there was a hole in her life that Christianity
- 2:49Speaker 1: could fill. And then it's it's uh, people talking about
- 2:53Speaker 1: being Christian culturally Christian and uh, and then I talked
- 3:00Speaker 1: on the show A Week of Togo about this, you know,
- 3:05Speaker 1: Christianity's rise and so like in value the last place
- 3:07Speaker 1: on oath I thought Christianity would would would find a foothold.
- 3:13Speaker 1: So how do we explain this phenomena?
- 3:18Speaker 3: Well, part of it, I think is suggested by the
- 3:20Speaker 3: way you described the eye on hersile hersy a lee
- 3:23Speaker 3: problem she describes she and others describe it as having
- 3:28Speaker 3: a God shaped hole in their lives. There's been a
- 3:31Speaker 3: retreat of religion from Western culture, and what that brings
- 3:39Speaker 3: with it is a retreat of any kind of explicit,
- 3:46Speaker 3: semi philosophical source of moral guidance in a lot of
- 3:50Speaker 3: people's mind at least.
- 3:51Speaker 2: And you know.
- 3:53Speaker 3: I've written about how the number of thinkers have noticed
- 3:58Speaker 3: that with the retreat of really and you also then
- 4:00Speaker 3: get this h onslaught of irrational ideologies, woke egalitarianism, so forth, which.
- 4:08Speaker 2: Are really just kind of quasi religions.
- 4:11Speaker 3: They have all the same kind of altruistic, self sacrificial
- 4:14Speaker 3: moral fervor, calls for humility, et cetera. And so somebody, Uh,
- 4:20Speaker 3: there are different ways that this whole gets filled. You know,
- 4:23Speaker 3: the leftist to galitarianism is one way, but it's it's
- 4:27Speaker 3: true that people need guidance in life. Uh, and when
- 4:31Speaker 3: our culture has failed to provide a rational, philosophical, alternative
- 4:38Speaker 3: source of moral guidance, then people will default back into
- 4:41Speaker 3: the only thing they know. And you know, iin Hearsiaele
- 4:44Speaker 3: is an interesting example, of course, because she was she
- 4:46Speaker 3: was raised religious of course, with Islam, and that did
- 4:49Speaker 3: something for her that her many her many years.
- 4:52Speaker 2: In the wilderness as an atheist didn't get her.
- 4:55Speaker 3: And there's some kind of code of meaning and value,
- 4:57Speaker 3: and it's it's, uh, you know, it's a it's a
- 5:00Speaker 3: terrible mistake to think that you're actually going to get good,
- 5:03Speaker 3: meaningful guidance from any of these irrational codes, religious or otherwise.
- 5:08Speaker 3: But I mean, I think that's the basic factor, the
- 5:12Speaker 3: basic issue, that there is a whole in our culture and.
- 5:15Speaker 2: Something's got to fill it. I only wish it were
- 5:17Speaker 2: something better than what they're taking.
- 5:19Speaker 1: Do you think that kind of the secular philosophers thinkers
- 5:23Speaker 1: out there, does this challenge them? Are they are they
- 5:28Speaker 1: interested in this? Are they like, Okay, we need we
- 5:30Speaker 1: need to do better, we need to fill this hole.
- 5:34Speaker 1: Or are they so sin called it?
- 5:37Speaker 3: You know, it's a great question, and I think this
- 5:42Speaker 3: is a question that a few of them are thinking about,
- 5:46Speaker 3: not nearly enough, you know, Like I think Sam Harris
- 5:49Speaker 3: gets this.
- 5:49Speaker 2: I gets that this is a problem.
- 5:51Speaker 3: It's why he wrote a whole book some years ago
- 5:54Speaker 3: on kind of atheistic moral theory, which I don't think
- 5:56Speaker 3: is very good. But he's at least trying, you know,
- 5:58Speaker 3: Michael Shermer to some extent. But I'll tell you I
- 6:02Speaker 3: went to this event a few months ago in October.
- 6:06Speaker 3: It was it was one of Richard Dawkins's last, final,
- 6:10Speaker 3: last public events, and he was being interviewed by Shermer
- 6:14Speaker 3: about this new book of his, the Genetic Book of
- 6:17Speaker 3: the Dead. And I, I said, this is one of
- 6:20Speaker 3: dawkins last events. I got to go and ask him
- 6:22Speaker 3: a question. And I got up, you know, in the audience,
- 6:25Speaker 3: and they taped this. There's tapes of this somewhere. And
- 6:27Speaker 3: I asked him about this. I asked him about Ian Hercile,
- 6:30Speaker 3: and I said, you know, isn't it kind of a
- 6:32Speaker 3: scandal for atheism that of all people, this this this
- 6:36Speaker 3: heroic woman that we all really admired.
- 6:38Speaker 2: Who was you know, a major asset to the atheist.
- 6:41Speaker 3: Movement has come out in favor of Christianity, and and
- 6:45Speaker 3: what are we going to do about it? And like,
- 6:47Speaker 3: how can atheists offer some kind of rational secud of
- 6:49Speaker 3: moral alternative? And Dawkins just had nothing to say and
- 6:55Speaker 3: thought that it was a kind of silly question and
- 6:58Speaker 3: and and said something like, well, it's not true that
- 7:01Speaker 3: science has nothing to offer.
- 7:03Speaker 2: Science offers you truth and progress.
- 7:05Speaker 3: And he's right about that, but he didn't even really
- 7:08Speaker 3: want to venture into the question of how are we
- 7:11Speaker 3: going to as atheists propose a scientific morality. It's no
- 7:17Speaker 3: surprise to me because he's even though he's great on
- 7:21Speaker 3: so many issues and I love him, he's just not
- 7:24Speaker 3: very philosophical. And you see this whenever he bothers to
- 7:30Speaker 3: talk about the issue of morality, it's always And I
- 7:33Speaker 3: recently wrote a piece called how Christianity Polluted the Moral
- 7:37Speaker 3: Atmosphere of the West, where I use the beginning at
- 7:40Speaker 3: the beginning, I use his example because like in his
- 7:42Speaker 3: book The God Delusion, when he has a chapter on ethics,
- 7:48Speaker 3: and you know where do atheists get their ethics?
- 7:50Speaker 2: And the first thing he talks about is, well, we
- 7:53Speaker 2: all feel this urge to help other people.
- 7:55Speaker 3: This good Samartian urge. Where does it come from? And
- 7:57Speaker 3: then he tries to give some kind of evolutionary explanation
- 7:59Speaker 3: of it, but like that's his starting point. Just take
- 8:01Speaker 3: for granted that the Christian view of morality is equivalent
- 8:05Speaker 3: to identical with morality as such, and then you know,
- 8:08Speaker 3: offer some kind of scientific spin on it. So he's
- 8:11Speaker 3: just very curious about that kind of question, and Shermer's
- 8:16Speaker 3: a little bit more curious. But E didn't want to
- 8:18Speaker 3: push Dawkins too hard on it, and he said something like.
- 8:21Speaker 2: Well, look up secular humanism.
- 8:23Speaker 3: They offer some alternatives, and that's just a kind of generic,
- 8:26Speaker 3: you know, recycling of various Christian bromides.
- 8:31Speaker 1: Yeah, and it's it's interesting because I know Cli, you know,
- 8:35Speaker 1: she read a lot of philosophy, I know, as part
- 8:38Speaker 1: of her kind of uh, you know, growing up intellectually.
- 8:43Speaker 1: And when I met her once and we talked about
- 8:48Speaker 1: and and she was clearly enamored with human skepticism and
- 8:55Speaker 1: and you know the atheism, So does a kind of
- 9:00Speaker 1: religion was certainty. Atheism was skepticism, and that Showman's view
- 9:05Speaker 1: as well in some respects, and they view I rand
- 9:10Speaker 1: as almost to similar to religion or and and then
- 9:16Speaker 1: by the time they get tired of the skepticism, like
- 9:19Speaker 1: kay and I think it's too late for them to
- 9:21Speaker 1: find iron Man, I should mention.
- 9:24Speaker 3: I'm going later this week there's a debate happening in Austin,
- 9:27Speaker 3: hosted by the Free Press and Iron Hersilian Ross doubt it.
- 9:31Speaker 2: Are going to debate Michael Shermer and Adam Carolla.
- 9:35Speaker 1: I don't know how he got but coolest too.
- 9:38Speaker 2: I'll be live tweeting it.
- 9:40Speaker 1: So what are they debating?
- 9:42Speaker 2: What the role of religion should be in the modern West?
- 9:45Speaker 1: Really?
- 9:46Speaker 2: Yeah, so I'll be live tweeting what I think the
- 9:49Speaker 2: responses should have been that. I don't think we'll get
- 9:51Speaker 2: from the atheist side.
- 9:53Speaker 1: Yeah, And I don't know what Adam Coola has to
- 9:54Speaker 1: add to that. And he's such a he's such a wacko.
- 9:59Speaker 3: I guess he's an atheist. I've never seen anything serious
- 10:01Speaker 3: from him.
- 10:02Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, I mean it does seem like the good
- 10:07Speaker 1: thing is that it's it's it's out in the opening.
- 10:09Speaker 1: People are debating it and discussing it. Partially, I think
- 10:12Speaker 1: the Free Past has some responsibility for that, because they're
- 10:14Speaker 1: kind of they were in the middle of it. There.
- 10:17Speaker 1: There's some atheists there and there's some not. There's some
- 10:20Speaker 1: Jews and some Christians, and it's all and they don't know.
- 10:23Speaker 1: I mean, clearly Barry is Barry Wie is religious, but
- 10:27Speaker 1: she's not, you know, fanatical about it, and you know,
- 10:32Speaker 1: I think it's something that's up top of mind for them.
- 10:34Speaker 1: So I think I think it's good. It's it's It
- 10:36Speaker 1: would be great if there was a way to get
- 10:38Speaker 1: objectivism into that discussion, into the general discussion. Yep. So
- 10:45Speaker 1: you know, one of the things I read, Kissing had
- 10:49Speaker 1: a Constantine. Kissing had a essay about this too, where
- 10:53Speaker 1: he basically said everything's religion. So you know, once they
- 10:59Speaker 1: once you abandon Christian danity, all you have are these
- 11:01Speaker 1: leftist religions and Christianity is better than them. I'm still
- 11:06Speaker 1: not sure. I'm not an atheist anymore, but the Christians
- 11:09Speaker 1: are better than the woke sign on that side up,
- 11:15Speaker 1: how do we how do we again, how do we
- 11:17Speaker 1: penetrate that? I think he's familiar again with objectivism, so
- 11:21Speaker 1: it's not like they completely ignorant, but they have no.
- 11:29Speaker 3: I think some of it is, and I think I
- 11:34Speaker 3: read that essay of his when it came out, so
- 11:37Speaker 3: and I certainly heard others say the kind of thing
- 11:40Speaker 3: you just mentioned.
- 11:41Speaker 2: And part of it is also there's a tribalistic element where.
- 11:47Speaker 3: There's a class of people who've been aggrieved by the
- 11:51Speaker 3: Left in various ways of grievances against the Left, they
- 11:55Speaker 3: see them as the main and only evil enemy to
- 11:59Speaker 3: be apart, and just anybody who is fighting them then
- 12:04Speaker 3: counts as an ally. I mean this attitude includes I
- 12:08Speaker 3: think even some fans of mine Rand, and in our
- 12:12Speaker 3: culture the way things are right now, it's not too
- 12:16Speaker 3: surprising that this is the way it should work. That
- 12:20Speaker 3: we see the religion as an enemy of the left,
- 12:22Speaker 3: and therefore will be more sympathetic to them, And the
- 12:27Speaker 3: more they curry favor with us, the more we'll listen
- 12:29Speaker 3: to what they have to say and start to think
- 12:31Speaker 3: of them not just as allies of convenience but friends.
- 12:36Speaker 3: One of the things that I talk about in that
- 12:39Speaker 3: same article, how Christianity plued to the moral atmosphere of
- 12:42Speaker 3: the West, is how I mean, ultimately, this is a
- 12:45Speaker 3: this is a delusion.
- 12:46Speaker 2: Because the Left is just the cultural.
- 12:53Speaker 3: Descendant of religion in so many way and that's why
- 12:57Speaker 3: these various woke egalitarian movements seems so religious. They're drawing
- 13:01Speaker 3: on the same old ideas and so it's it's and
- 13:07Speaker 3: I think you see this too in the in the
- 13:09Speaker 3: current direction of the American right, it's become successful, it's
- 13:13Speaker 3: one elections by becoming more left wing. And the fact
- 13:16Speaker 3: that there are elements of Christianity that support them in doing.
- 13:20Speaker 2: That is not an accident.
- 13:24Speaker 1: So let's let's talk maybe a little bit about what
- 13:26Speaker 1: those elements of Christianity they find appealing. You know, obviously
- 13:31Speaker 1: they it gives them a quote of ethics, it gives
- 13:33Speaker 1: them some morality, though it's vague interus of what that
- 13:36Speaker 1: morality is other than kind of a general call for altruism.
- 13:40Speaker 1: But but what is it about the morality and what
- 13:43Speaker 1: is what are the other features of Christianity that uh,
- 13:47Speaker 1: you know, the the left is adopted and interpreted in
- 13:50Speaker 1: its own way.
- 13:54Speaker 2: Well, I like to illustrate this with the.
- 13:58Speaker 3: With the issue the woke movement, in particular, John mcwadour
- 14:05Speaker 3: wrote this really great book, Woke Racism, and one of
- 14:08Speaker 3: his themes in the book, one of his central themes
- 14:11Speaker 3: is how so called wokeism, which it's a bad name
- 14:15Speaker 3: for it's egalitarianism is really just a version of a
- 14:19Speaker 3: kind of Abrahamic religion.
- 14:20Speaker 2: And he brings out how so.
- 14:23Speaker 3: Much of one of the practices and attitudes of uh
- 14:28Speaker 3: woke activists.
- 14:31Speaker 2: Are about a kind of humility. They're about they're about,
- 14:36Speaker 2: you know.
- 14:36Speaker 3: Taking the knee in effect to some kind of totem.
- 14:41Speaker 3: And it might not be God, it might not be Jesus,
- 14:43Speaker 3: but it's whatever their stand in is for the you know,
- 14:47Speaker 3: oppressed uh oppressed, downtrodden people that someone needs to sacrifice
- 14:52Speaker 3: for the sake of And totem is a good way
- 14:56Speaker 3: to think about it, because it's totemizing somebody is also
- 14:59Speaker 3: very de hum very dehumanizing, So you're treating them as
- 15:03Speaker 3: this object of sacrifice but not really giving them any agency.
- 15:06Speaker 3: That's a whole separate conversation.
- 15:08Speaker 2: But the need to.
- 15:13Speaker 3: Prove that you're holier than thou by showing just how
- 15:18Speaker 3: much you can give up, how much of your white
- 15:20Speaker 3: privilege you can confess to. There's a kind of original
- 15:24Speaker 3: sin view that goes with that. This is all just
- 15:27Speaker 3: kind of chapter and verse from Christian religion.
- 15:31Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, we've talked about I think that generally
- 15:34Speaker 1: in the objectives movement we've talked about, the environmental movement
- 15:38Speaker 1: is being very kind of CAUSI religious also with original
- 15:42Speaker 1: sin and in a sacrifice and psychoist mother Earth. And
- 15:46Speaker 1: it seems like really all the movement is a sense
- 15:48Speaker 1: of which Marxism, communism is religious in that sense. It
- 15:53Speaker 1: seems like all the movements of the left of religious
- 15:56Speaker 1: in that sense. It really is. It's interesting, And what's
- 16:02Speaker 1: interesting to me is that other than Man, there's so
- 16:06Speaker 1: few thinkers that have challenged that that, you know, that
- 16:09Speaker 1: have stood up and said no. Since the Enlightenment, you know,
- 16:14Speaker 1: they basically embraced Christianity, whether from the left or from
- 16:17Speaker 1: the right.
- 16:19Speaker 2: And this is the major failure of the Enlightenment.
- 16:22Speaker 3: As much as I love the Enlightenment, they the major
- 16:26Speaker 3: Enlightenment thinkers did there's great service showing the power of science,
- 16:32Speaker 3: the power of reason for understanding the world around us
- 16:35Speaker 3: in one form or another. They didn't get time to
- 16:40Speaker 3: extend that explanation to the topic of morality. There's just
- 16:46Speaker 3: there were glimmers here and there among different Enlightenment figures
- 16:49Speaker 3: of attempts to reconcile morality with self interest, but that's
- 16:55Speaker 3: about as far as it goes as a kind of reconciliation.
- 16:58Speaker 3: It was never a systematic reworking and rejection of the
- 17:03Speaker 3: old Judeo Christian frames against something else I talk about
- 17:05Speaker 3: in that moral Atmosphere piece, I list some of the
- 17:10Speaker 3: examples of Enlightenment figures who who as religion was starting
- 17:14Speaker 3: to retreat from the West, became a little more tolerant.
- 17:18Speaker 2: Of self interest.
- 17:19Speaker 3: But none of them, not even the best of them,
- 17:23Speaker 3: subjected Christian morality to a comprehensive kind of critique.
- 17:26Speaker 2: I mean, a good example here is is Hume.
- 17:29Speaker 3: It was a very systematic philosopher, and he even has
- 17:31Speaker 3: very good and critical things to say about Christianity, Like
- 17:35Speaker 3: he has a whole section critiquing the Monkish virtues he
- 17:39Speaker 3: called humility and meekness and so forth. So like when
- 17:42Speaker 3: it's you know, when the rubber meets the road, he's
- 17:44Speaker 3: opposed to their kind of most radical views. But at
- 17:48Speaker 3: the same time, when his when he's doing systematic what
- 17:52Speaker 3: philosopher's called meta ethics an in theory of value in
- 17:55Speaker 3: his ranth where do we get.
- 17:56Speaker 2: Moral principles from? For him, it's well, you know, you introspect,
- 18:00Speaker 2: you look inside and what are the things that we
- 18:02Speaker 2: feel a calm and detached passion about. And I have
- 18:05Speaker 2: to be detached. You can't have anything to do with
- 18:07Speaker 2: self interest.
- 18:08Speaker 3: And that's just something he takes as an axiom because
- 18:11Speaker 3: his radical as humans, he's not radical enough to kind
- 18:13Speaker 3: of break out of the moral framework of Christianity that
- 18:17Speaker 3: he's grown up. Then, even in the Enlightenment period, Isssume.
- 18:20Speaker 1: Taking them from Madam Smith is a'am Smith taking from Hume.
- 18:24Speaker 1: They're contemporary, so I think they're they're working on it
- 18:27Speaker 1: together and they're friends, They contemporaries and friends. Yeah, what
- 18:32Speaker 1: about the French, I mean, didrou goes to jail because
- 18:36Speaker 1: he's an atheist and has to suppress. He really doesn't
- 18:40Speaker 1: write about it anymore because he's afraid. And there's some
- 18:44Speaker 1: others who kind of are working on a on morality.
- 18:47Speaker 1: It's it's pretty flawed, but they're at least attempting. Yeah.
- 18:51Speaker 2: I don't know as much about the French Enlightenment as
- 18:53Speaker 2: I do, but the English and I haven't read as
- 18:54Speaker 2: much of the philosoph's.
- 18:58Speaker 1: But they're much more He sate.
- 19:00Speaker 3: I've just never come across any any French Enlightenment moral
- 19:03Speaker 3: theory to speak of, even I mean, I guess Rousseau
- 19:07Speaker 3: maybe is the closest that they get.
- 19:10Speaker 2: He's pretty far from the enlightenmental right.
- 19:13Speaker 3: But it's one of the complicating factors in that period
- 19:16Speaker 3: is to the extent they're talking about egoism at all,
- 19:19Speaker 3: it's often psychological egoism, where they assume everybody is selfish
- 19:22Speaker 3: and they don't need any guidance in that regard, and
- 19:26Speaker 3: that leads to certain kinds of reconciliation between self interest
- 19:32Speaker 3: in morality. Is why are people doing these things that
- 19:34Speaker 3: look moral even.
- 19:35Speaker 2: Though they're all self interested?
- 19:36Speaker 3: And so they try to combine those together, but it's
- 19:39Speaker 3: not a real normative theory. Mandeville is a French thinker,
- 19:43Speaker 3: and he's interesting because you know, he's got the fable
- 19:48Speaker 3: of the bees, talking about how when people pursue selfish interests,
- 19:52Speaker 3: there's it somehow serves the common good. I haven't read
- 19:56Speaker 3: him recently enough to be sure I'm getting his thesis right,
- 19:58Speaker 3: but he's this is the thesis he's famous for. But
- 20:02Speaker 3: he's also horrified by the thesis, like he's in Augustinian says,
- 20:06Speaker 3: look at all these people pursuing their self interest like,
- 20:08Speaker 3: you know, like bumbling bees, and what are we to
- 20:11Speaker 3: do with ourselves?
- 20:11Speaker 2: Since now this means this is kind of this is good. Yeah,
- 20:15Speaker 2: his view of original sin is inevitable.
- 20:18Speaker 1: Yeah, no, I mean I think that the French more
- 20:23Speaker 1: explicitly atheistic, and therefore the at least trying. But they're
- 20:28Speaker 1: so far away, they're so far off, and they also
- 20:32Speaker 1: have to repress themselves because they're in danger. I mean,
- 20:35Speaker 1: that's the other thing we have to remember. The Enlightenment
- 20:37Speaker 1: is in the in the context of religion is still
- 20:40Speaker 1: dominant in Europe, and and and they'll go to jail
- 20:44Speaker 1: or the oh wus. I mean, Voltai has to run away,
- 20:47Speaker 1: and he's not an atheist, and he still has to
- 20:49Speaker 1: run away.
- 20:50Speaker 3: So Hume was denied a job at neuro because he
- 20:54Speaker 3: was an atheist. And before that, Locke was not persecuted
- 20:58Speaker 3: for his religion, but persecuted because of his political views
- 21:01Speaker 3: and had to flee to Holland because.
- 21:03Speaker 1: Well it was Catholic king coming and he was afraid. Yeah.
- 21:07Speaker 1: So yeah, yeah, no, it was a different eraror Luckily
- 21:11Speaker 1: for now at least I don't know how long this
- 21:13Speaker 1: will last. We don't have to flee anyway we can
- 21:15Speaker 1: we can we can work. We can work here. So JD.
- 21:23Speaker 1: Vance the other day made this argument that that sounds
- 21:33Speaker 1: almost but but far from but it sounds in the
- 21:37Speaker 1: name of of of Catholicism. Although I'morris, and the idea
- 21:41Speaker 1: is that what's closest to you is more important, and
- 21:45Speaker 1: the further goes from you, the less important it is,
- 21:48Speaker 1: unless you should sacrifice for it. You know, the close
- 21:52Speaker 1: is good, the far is bad. It sounds almost, you know,
- 21:57Speaker 1: a perversion of of of of any Ghoistic argument, but
- 22:02Speaker 1: it's not. And so what do you make of that?
- 22:05Speaker 1: And what do you make of the controversy? Because God,
- 22:07Speaker 1: I mean, the number of people who who wrote about
- 22:10Speaker 1: it was quite astounding.
- 22:12Speaker 2: It's so interesting.
- 22:13Speaker 3: It's one of these rare occasions where a semi obscure
- 22:18Speaker 3: issue and philosophy and the history of philosophy, it breaks
- 22:22Speaker 3: out into the open into a social media flame war.
- 22:27Speaker 3: And you people on Twitter, you know, citing Augustine and
- 22:31Speaker 3: Aquinas and trying to justify Vance's view on the basis
- 22:36Speaker 3: of that, and other people say, no.
- 22:37Speaker 2: This is not Christianity at all. And so I follow
- 22:41Speaker 2: this very closely when it came out and.
- 22:45Speaker 3: Then I also went and read many of the relevant
- 22:48Speaker 3: texts from Augustine and Aquinas to see what this was
- 22:52Speaker 3: all about. And what I found was not too surprising,
- 22:55Speaker 3: but still super interesting. I mean, it's I should mention,
- 23:00Speaker 3: by the way, this comes up originally because of questions
- 23:02Speaker 3: about Trump's immigration policy, and he's trying to justify the
- 23:07Speaker 3: deepportations and various things like that.
- 23:10Speaker 2: Later it turns into.
- 23:11Speaker 3: A wider debate about usaid and aid to Catholic charities
- 23:16Speaker 3: and things like this. You have to make that disclaimer
- 23:22Speaker 3: because I don't want to concede even his premise that
- 23:28Speaker 3: a immigrant closing our immigration policy from the world, kicking
- 23:34Speaker 3: people out with mass deportations is anything like an egoistic
- 23:38Speaker 3: policy that actually serves our self interest. I think the
- 23:41Speaker 3: fact that they have for such a long time seen
- 23:45Speaker 3: an opposition between morality and practicality makes it easier for
- 23:50Speaker 3: them to think that because they've lost all principled conception
- 23:52Speaker 3: of what is required for actual self interest.
- 23:55Speaker 2: Leave that aside for the moment. Maybe we come back
- 23:58Speaker 2: to if you want to. But it's yeah, it sounds
- 24:02Speaker 2: kind of like an egoistic proposal. And the texts that
- 24:07Speaker 2: he cites. He didn't cite text.
- 24:08Speaker 3: He cites this concept ordo amorus, which is a term
- 24:13Speaker 3: that originally comes from a certain doctrine in Augustine, and
- 24:19Speaker 3: it it then also there's also a text in Aquinas.
- 24:23Speaker 3: And the first thing to say about the text from Augustine,
- 24:25Speaker 3: these are the older ones, these are going back to
- 24:27Speaker 3: the fourth century.
- 24:28Speaker 1: Is that.
- 24:31Speaker 3: The few passages that you can find from him saying
- 24:35Speaker 3: anything like what Vance is saying. It is such a
- 24:40Speaker 3: stretch to think that Augustine would favor anything like the
- 24:47Speaker 3: kind of family values, family first, bourgeois attitude.
- 24:54Speaker 2: That the conservatives are trying to justify it.
- 24:56Speaker 3: Most what Augustine says is we should all be selfless
- 25:01Speaker 3: all the time. We can't be selfless to everybody all
- 25:04Speaker 3: the time. It's just impossible, because after all, we're all sinners, right,
- 25:07Speaker 3: that's original sin, and so you know, we have to
- 25:09Speaker 3: be selective about.
- 25:10Speaker 2: Who we're going to do our sacrifices to, and it's
- 25:13Speaker 2: just easier to do them to the people who are
- 25:15Speaker 2: right in front of us. Now. He doesn't say to
- 25:18Speaker 2: our loved ones, to our family.
- 25:20Speaker 3: Remember, he's the one who says we should all be
- 25:22Speaker 3: monks if we can and you know, condescends to the
- 25:27Speaker 3: weakness of other people who have to get married going
- 25:28Speaker 3: to Saint Paul. But you know, so if it's our
- 25:32Speaker 3: family weapons need this because they're right in front of us,
- 25:34Speaker 3: yes of course we should help them first. But then
- 25:35Speaker 3: if there's a stranger who's in front of us, who
- 25:38Speaker 3: who's who's who's dying or whatever, or if there's a
- 25:42Speaker 3: mendicant priests who's begging for good, we should help them
- 25:45Speaker 3: because they're right in front of it. So it's the
- 25:47Speaker 3: fact that people in front of us are asking for something.
- 25:52Speaker 2: For him.
- 25:53Speaker 3: It's this is an accident, and it's just it's a
- 25:56Speaker 3: it's an easy way to decide how to discharge your
- 25:58Speaker 3: selfless obligation. But this is nothing like, oh, I have
- 26:03Speaker 3: loved ones who I think are actually more important than
- 26:05Speaker 3: strangers around the world or strangers.
- 26:07Speaker 2: Next door for that matter. So it's the association.
- 26:12Speaker 3: The similarity between what Vance would like to justify and
- 26:14Speaker 3: what august Augustine's trying to actually justifying is just stark.
- 26:18Speaker 2: It's a stark disparity there.
- 26:21Speaker 3: It gets more interesting is when you look at the
- 26:24Speaker 3: Aquinas texts that are cited by.
- 26:27Speaker 2: Many of the people who've been talking about order of Morris.
- 26:30Speaker 3: And there's a number of them, number of places, lengthy
- 26:33Speaker 3: texts where Aquinas talks about that. And one thing is
- 26:40Speaker 3: he is trying harder to justify some kind of preferential
- 26:45Speaker 3: social relationships. The other thing that you notice is that
- 26:51Speaker 3: this is happening in chapters in the Suma, where Aquinas
- 26:57Speaker 3: is invoking Aristotle all the time. The Philosopher, if you
- 27:01Speaker 3: look at the text's that's that's who he's talking about.
- 27:03Speaker 2: And so he's quoting Aristotle.
- 27:05Speaker 3: About how love for others is a reflection of our
- 27:10Speaker 3: love for ourselves, you know, the famous passages in nick
- 27:12Speaker 3: Nickuin Ethics where he talks about how others friends are
- 27:15Speaker 3: just another self and so forth. And so this is
- 27:19Speaker 3: characteristic a Quinness trying to somehow possibly reconcile his reverence
- 27:27Speaker 3: for the Philosopher with Christianity, and it's it's very difficult
- 27:31Speaker 3: thing to do. I mean, it's actually impossible, yep. But
- 27:35Speaker 3: he has this reverence to this torn loyalty between both
- 27:37Speaker 3: of them, and so as a result he he appeals
- 27:39Speaker 3: to all kinds of really tortured distinctions, of various kinds
- 27:43Speaker 3: to reconcile them and say that, well, they're both right
- 27:45Speaker 3: in different respects, and he'll say things like, yeah, of
- 27:51Speaker 3: course you shouldn't really love yourself or your friends more
- 27:57Speaker 3: than God, but it just so happens that, you know,
- 28:02Speaker 3: God kind of channels him felf through your friends and
- 28:05Speaker 3: your loved ones, and it's just it's a way of
- 28:07Speaker 3: expressing that, and it's just trying so hard to reconcile
- 28:11Speaker 3: something that can't actually be reconciled, and in the.
- 28:14Speaker 2: End it can't be done.
- 28:17Speaker 3: And the sign of that is that there are various
- 28:18Speaker 3: places where where Aquinas basically gives in and and and
- 28:22Speaker 3: sids the same things that Augustin says, because he also
- 28:24Speaker 3: revers Augustine.
- 28:26Speaker 2: And so he said, yeah, really, you know, if if
- 28:28Speaker 2: if it's a stranger who's you know, who you don't
- 28:31Speaker 2: even care about, who comes in front of you, and
- 28:33Speaker 2: he's starting, yeah, you got to sacrifice to him too.
- 28:36Speaker 3: So it's the same story as Augustine and many of
- 28:41Speaker 3: the left wing critics of Vance and the Trump administration
- 28:46Speaker 3: the site, you know, make this point, and they and
- 28:50Speaker 3: they of course make the point that there's all kinds
- 28:51Speaker 3: of other stuff in the Bible that Vance is just
- 28:55Speaker 3: kind of blissfully ignoring.
- 28:57Speaker 2: That makes it very.
- 28:58Speaker 3: Clear that the Christian message here is not just you know,
- 29:02Speaker 3: love your family and and your your bourgeois life. I mean,
- 29:06Speaker 3: the good Samaritan is the is the most obvious example
- 29:08Speaker 3: to go back to the example we talked about from Dawkins,
- 29:10Speaker 3: because I mean.
- 29:11Speaker 2: That's that's a story explicitly where.
- 29:15Speaker 3: All of the all of the uh, all these people
- 29:20Speaker 3: pass the good Samaritan by, sorry, they passed the wounded
- 29:24Speaker 3: man by. And then the Samaritan comes along, the Samaritans
- 29:26Speaker 3: an outsider. He's he's not from the you know, the
- 29:28Speaker 3: tribe of Judea.
- 29:30Speaker 1: He's even hostile. There is hostility between the Jews and
- 29:33Speaker 1: the Samaritans, right, so.
- 29:35Speaker 3: Even he's able to look across tribal lines and sacrifice
- 29:38Speaker 3: for the sake of you know, this, of this victim.
- 29:41Speaker 3: And and it comes up in the context where Christ
- 29:45Speaker 3: says love thy neighbor as thyself, and someone asks them.
- 29:48Speaker 2: Who is thy neighbor? And this is this is the
- 29:50Speaker 2: explicit answer to this.
- 29:51Speaker 3: Your neighbor is somebody who's who's who's not necessarily uh,
- 29:55Speaker 3: you your friend, not necessarily someone from the same tribe.
- 29:58Speaker 3: And of course Christ is a similar nearby passage says,
- 30:01Speaker 3: if you really want to love God, give up everything
- 30:04Speaker 3: you have, leave your family and go and you know,
- 30:08Speaker 3: and be with me, and you know there's worship God and.
- 30:10Speaker 2: Try to live for the afterlife. So it's it's the
- 30:12Speaker 2: idea that you can somehow, Jerry rig you can shoehorn
- 30:20Speaker 2: something like the contemporary American values into into Christianity. Is
- 30:25Speaker 2: such an.
- 30:25Speaker 3: Evasion, and it's it's it's it's it's a coping mechanism.
- 30:31Speaker 3: I think that the modern consertives are having to resort
- 30:35Speaker 3: to when whatever small elements of the remaining political ideology
- 30:40Speaker 3: do actually favor self interest and property rights and capitalism,
- 30:45Speaker 3: and it's an increasingly diminishing portion of it, whatever is
- 30:48Speaker 3: left of that, they have to try to reconcile with
- 30:50Speaker 3: the morality that they know on some level doesn't really
- 30:53Speaker 3: allow for this. And they're particularly disturbed by the fact
- 30:56Speaker 3: that the left is the one that's the more consistent
- 30:59Speaker 3: advocate of that, and so they have to come up
- 31:01Speaker 3: with these sort of you know, just so story rationalizations
- 31:06Speaker 3: to make sense of it, and then they get really
- 31:07Speaker 3: defensive about it.
- 31:08Speaker 2: Online when someone challenges them, and they like, I'll pull
- 31:11Speaker 2: out these medieval texts to show that I've got real
- 31:16Speaker 2: Christian thinking, often to the exclusion of the actual Bible.
- 31:21Speaker 1: And they do this on a lot of topics. I mean,
- 31:23Speaker 1: you've got now all these evangelical churches that are prosperity Christianity.
- 31:27Speaker 1: God wants you to be rich, God wants you to
- 31:29Speaker 1: be successful. I tell some of my Christian audiences that
- 31:35Speaker 1: they they really love Thomas Jefferson more than Jesus. And
- 31:39Speaker 1: then they and what they do is they try to
- 31:41Speaker 1: make Jesus into Thomas Jefferson. And they love the Constitution
- 31:44Speaker 1: more than the Bible, and therefore they try to massage
- 31:48Speaker 1: the Bible into being the Constitution. They don't take it
- 31:52Speaker 1: very well, but because they don't want to believe that,
- 31:55Speaker 1: but that's what they're doing. They have a sudden American
- 31:57Speaker 1: sense of life and in all to and they adapted
- 32:02Speaker 1: Christianity to it, and they have to evade huge amounts
- 32:06Speaker 1: in order to do that.
- 32:08Speaker 3: The point of a sense of life is important because
- 32:12Speaker 3: I think what's left right now in large swaths of
- 32:17Speaker 3: the right is nothing but American sense of life. And
- 32:21Speaker 3: there's there's if that even if that, yeah, so little
- 32:25Speaker 3: actual ideology left. And you know that essay of An
- 32:28Speaker 3: Rand's Don't Let It Go, where she talks about the
- 32:32Speaker 3: American sense of life. One of the qualifiers that she
- 32:34Speaker 3: makes is that you know, a sense of life can
- 32:36Speaker 3: only get you so far if you don't translate into
- 32:38Speaker 3: an explicit philosophy. And at this point, all the explicit
- 32:41Speaker 3: philosophy is pulling them in the opposite direction.
- 32:43Speaker 2: And so that's one of the reasons why.
- 32:48Speaker 3: What's left of the American sense of life, I think
- 32:50Speaker 3: gets translated into something that's so explicitly at odds.
- 32:56Speaker 2: With the founding principles of America. That is, this is
- 33:01Speaker 2: what I was referencing before.
- 33:02Speaker 3: If if you, if your model for morality is Christian selflessness,
- 33:05Speaker 3: and you spend your whole life and your child and
- 33:07Speaker 3: everybody tells you rally has nothing to do with self interest,
- 33:11Speaker 3: and you associate principle with selflessness, and and you think
- 33:17Speaker 3: of that as that's for suckers.
- 33:18Speaker 2: And so I don't want to be a sucker.
- 33:19Speaker 3: In my American sense of life tells me I'm not
- 33:21Speaker 3: going to nobody should push me around. But to not
- 33:24Speaker 3: be pushed around, and not to not be a sucker
- 33:26Speaker 3: then means to be not means to be unprincipled, and
- 33:29Speaker 3: it means when it comes to trying to figure out
- 33:32Speaker 3: how we should actually.
- 33:33Speaker 2: Live in this world, it's then range of the moment expediency.
- 33:37Speaker 3: And so if that means kick out all the immigrants
- 33:39Speaker 3: because they're challenging us in various ways and I can't
- 33:43Speaker 3: quite compete with them economically, or if it means, let's uh,
- 33:48Speaker 3: Vladimir Putin is the powerful guy in Eastern Europe right now,
- 33:51Speaker 3: and we got to make a deal with him because.
- 33:55Speaker 2: It looks like our side is losing and.
- 33:58Speaker 1: Well, which a Christian puts into Christian and his enemy
- 34:03Speaker 1: is not that too. So what do you make of
- 34:06Speaker 1: jd Vance. I mean, here's a guy who's obviously really smart.
- 34:10Speaker 1: I mean he's he's I think he's proven that he's
- 34:15Speaker 1: comes from a background that's evangelical. Uh in In in
- 34:19Speaker 1: Apalachi's he's uh went through an atheist phase. He went
- 34:24Speaker 1: to an iron Ran phase, or at least somewhat. Who
- 34:28Speaker 1: knows how how how how much iron Ran he consumed,
- 34:30Speaker 1: but he went through an iron Ran phase. And then
- 34:33Speaker 1: he converts to Catholicism, which almost everybody on the kind
- 34:40Speaker 1: of the what I consider the New Right the intellectuals
- 34:44Speaker 1: of the New Right are all Catholics, but they're all
- 34:47Speaker 1: converts to Catholicism.
- 34:49Speaker 2: Uh.
- 34:50Speaker 1: You know of a mule in Harvard, Patrick Deneeni. Uh,
- 34:58Speaker 1: they're all converts to Catholicism, and something's going on there.
- 35:05Speaker 1: What do you make of it all? What do you
- 35:06Speaker 1: make of the d e Vans and then the phenomena
- 35:08Speaker 1: of Catholic convots.
- 35:11Speaker 3: It's fascinating. We talked I think a little bit about
- 35:15Speaker 3: this on our last interview. And you know, there's this
- 35:18Speaker 3: essay that Vance wrote talking about his conversion how I
- 35:25Speaker 3: joined the resistance in religious Catholic journal called The Lamp,
- 35:30Speaker 3: and the things that he says in there about why
- 35:34Speaker 3: he wanted to leave eroin Rand.
- 35:36Speaker 2: And go to religion are really revealing.
- 35:41Speaker 3: I comfort I comforted myself with an appeal to a
- 35:44Speaker 3: philosopher's atheism Kumli returnism and told me everything I wanted
- 35:46Speaker 3: to hear. Ein Rand great smart men were only arrogant
- 35:49Speaker 3: if they were wrong, and I was anything but that.
- 35:51Speaker 3: And what he goes on to say that in that
- 35:54Speaker 3: article is to basically paint himself as having been arrogant
- 35:59Speaker 3: for thinking he could discover some kind of rational alternative
- 36:03Speaker 3: to religion and how I'd have to look at the
- 36:12Speaker 3: details of it again. But it strikes me as just
- 36:17Speaker 3: the perfect exemplear an embodiment of a kind of intellectual appeasement.
- 36:23Speaker 2: He goes to school, he's been kind of a contrarian,
- 36:29Speaker 2: but then he meets up with Peter Thiel, who introduces
- 36:32Speaker 2: into nin Gerard, and they he realizes, Hey, I'm a
- 36:39Speaker 2: smart kid.
- 36:40Speaker 3: It's the same phenomenon Rans talking about that essay Altruism, aspieasement,
- 36:43Speaker 3: I'm a smart kid.
- 36:44Speaker 2: I'd like to be able to do my own thing.
- 36:46Speaker 3: I've tried doing it, but when I did, I encountered
- 36:48Speaker 3: this opposition from people who thought I was arrogant. And
- 36:51Speaker 3: so please give me permission to be my own smart person,
- 36:57Speaker 3: and I will show you that I have the right
- 36:59Speaker 3: to do that because I'm going to advocate for alchemistic causes.
- 37:02Speaker 3: I'm going to advocate for the little guy. I'm going
- 37:03Speaker 3: to add advocate for the people. And he's like a
- 37:10Speaker 3: perfect embodiment of what she's talking about in that essay.
- 37:14Speaker 3: The Renee Girard connection is also fascinating because I saw
- 37:17Speaker 3: that the Peter tele story. You want to talk about
- 37:20Speaker 3: he's a common denominator here, and I haven't studied much
- 37:23Speaker 3: Gerard closely. I haven't read any primary texts I really
- 37:28Speaker 3: want to. I've read a bunch of articles about him.
- 37:30Speaker 3: But one of the things that's fascinating this is going
- 37:32Speaker 3: to connect to the thing you want to talk about
- 37:34Speaker 3: with Teal is essential to Gerard's worldview, and this comes
- 37:39Speaker 3: up in that New York Times article, is the idea
- 37:41Speaker 3: that everybody out there is pursuing this mimetic form of life,
- 37:45Speaker 3: which means they're all trying to copy each other.
- 37:47Speaker 2: And Gerard sees in this view, this is the reason.
- 37:51Speaker 3: This is the source of suffering, This is the source
- 37:52Speaker 3: of pain and meaninglessness in everyday life. And if there
- 37:54Speaker 3: are only some way to break out of this cycle,
- 37:57Speaker 3: you know, by using Christ as an example, who's who
- 38:00Speaker 3: doesn't care about any of that.
- 38:01Speaker 2: Will all be better.
- 38:02Speaker 3: And it's such a striking worldview for someone like advanced
- 38:07Speaker 3: to glom Onto and for Teal to glom Onto, because
- 38:11Speaker 3: it's it's it's like the view that the world consists
- 38:14Speaker 3: of Peter Keating's and therefore the only solution is to
- 38:18Speaker 3: become a two or the equivalent and completely missing the
- 38:24Speaker 3: possibility of living an independent existence where you know you
- 38:27Speaker 3: you live for yourself, by your own means, you don't
- 38:31Speaker 3: just think we should copy everybody else and absorb our
- 38:35Speaker 3: values from them. And it's especially interesting because in that
- 38:41Speaker 3: article about Teal and about his growing influence in Silicon Valley,
- 38:47Speaker 3: and I think that Time is even subtly poking fun
- 38:50Speaker 3: at this. You know, on the one hand, they're interested
- 38:53Speaker 3: in Teal and Girard, who complain about everybody being a
- 38:56Speaker 3: Peter Keating.
- 38:57Speaker 2: On the on the other hand, boy to want to
- 39:00Speaker 2: be like Peter Teele. And if Peter Tele says Christianity's
- 39:03Speaker 2: great in Silicon Valley, well that's good enough for me
- 39:06Speaker 2: and my friends are now going to these meeting groups.
- 39:08Speaker 2: ACT seventeen. And I think I think, you know, Vance
- 39:12Speaker 2: was part of the early advancing guard of that. It's
- 39:16Speaker 2: it's so yeah, but so much social metaphysics that's playing
- 39:21Speaker 2: itself out.
- 39:22Speaker 1: But so much of that. I mean, it's so tragic
- 39:24Speaker 1: because he's Peter Tele, who's, you know, one of the
- 39:28Speaker 1: great entrepreneurs and solely venture capitalists of our time. An
- 39:33Speaker 1: independent mind. He couldn't otherwise, I mean, in his business,
- 39:37Speaker 1: there's no way he'd be this successful if he wasn't
- 39:40Speaker 1: a great independent mind latching onto philosophy that tells him
- 39:43Speaker 1: that he has to avoid being a second handed, which
- 39:46Speaker 1: is he's not primarily at least not in that realm
- 39:50Speaker 1: of his life, has to glam onto religion and to
- 39:53Speaker 1: avoid it. It just seems so bizarre, the whole.
- 39:57Speaker 3: Thing's it's bizarrely tragic. But if you see, and I
- 40:01Speaker 3: really encourage people to go out and read that Altruism
- 40:04Speaker 3: is Appeasement article because I think it's the one of
- 40:08Speaker 3: the underappreciated gems of Iran's nonfiction where she goes into
- 40:12Speaker 3: the psychology of this and.
- 40:15Speaker 2: It's so it's tragic, but it's also kind of to
- 40:17Speaker 2: be expected.
- 40:17Speaker 3: Because somebody who is precisely bright and innovative and wants
- 40:22Speaker 3: to go against the grain, who has all these ideas,
- 40:26Speaker 3: and then you know, goes to college, goes to Stanford,
- 40:28Speaker 3: as you know in Teel's case, or or in Vance's case,
- 40:32Speaker 3: goes to ill law school having come out of Appalachia.
- 40:35Speaker 2: Uh. And then it meets with this reception of people
- 40:39Speaker 2: don't agree with you, and.
- 40:40Speaker 3: They think that your iin randy and ideas or are
- 40:43Speaker 3: so arrogant, and you know, you, on the one hand,
- 40:46Speaker 3: you're a rebel, but on the other hand, you kind
- 40:48Speaker 3: of want to be in the in crowd, and you
- 40:50Speaker 3: don't like the fact that everybody is making fun of
- 40:53Speaker 3: you and criticizing you know, like, I've been there, right,
- 40:55Speaker 3: I've been in academia. I know what it's like to
- 40:58Speaker 3: to meet with that kind of crowd and that kind
- 41:00Speaker 3: of glares and those kind of eyebrow raises, and uh,
- 41:03Speaker 3: you know somebody who is you know, kind of fashions
- 41:06Speaker 3: themselves as a rebel, but who still you know, deep.
- 41:10Speaker 2: Down and kind of wants to get along.
- 41:12Speaker 3: Is is gonna They're gonna give up on that, and
- 41:15Speaker 3: they're gonna look for ways of rationalizing their independence and
- 41:19Speaker 3: rationalizing you know, their intelligence that kind of give them
- 41:23Speaker 3: for a mission. And it might not be what the
- 41:25Speaker 3: people at academia like, it might not be something that's
- 41:28Speaker 3: popular with them. But wow, if you can get into
- 41:30Speaker 3: this other tribe of people, the Christians, who they love
- 41:32Speaker 3: to have you, that's another thing.
- 41:35Speaker 1: It's interesting. It's interesting how they can stay rebels in
- 41:38Speaker 1: a sense and dependent in the you know, in their
- 41:41Speaker 1: business life, and yet be like this. But yeah, but
- 41:47Speaker 1: Peter Teel seems to have a because because he's been
- 41:51Speaker 1: so successful and because he is in some way very intellectual.
- 41:56Speaker 1: In another way, he's very pseudo intelligent. I mean, he's
- 41:58Speaker 1: he mumbles and rumbles a lot, you know, kind of
- 42:02Speaker 1: often in a meaningless way. But he's he's he's always
- 42:07Speaker 1: seems to be saying something that's different and interesting to
- 42:10Speaker 1: at least some audience. He's had an enormous impact both
- 42:13Speaker 1: in Silicon Valley in politics. He's brought a lot of
- 42:17Speaker 1: these guys from the from Silicon Valley to the right
- 42:21Speaker 1: to Trump to Mega to Mega. It's amazing how much
- 42:25Speaker 1: influence he really has had.
- 42:29Speaker 2: Yeah, no doubt, I want to I want to learn
- 42:31Speaker 2: more about Gerard so I can speak more territatively. On one.
- 42:34Speaker 1: Yeah, it would be interesting. It will definitely be interesting.
- 42:38Speaker 1: Uh So you know the other thing that you know, JD.
- 42:43Speaker 1: Vans I had the quote, I mean, because the thing
- 42:49Speaker 1: you wrote about was you love your family, and then
- 42:51Speaker 1: you love your neighbor, and then you love your community,
- 42:53Speaker 1: and then you love your fellow citizen. And the thing
- 42:56Speaker 1: he's he's leveraging here is the fact that nobody's going
- 43:00Speaker 1: to question any of those statements, right, not that maybe
- 43:03Speaker 1: that question that then you love, maybe that question the order.
- 43:07Speaker 1: But you know, as I think I said on the
- 43:09Speaker 1: show that I don't love my neighbor, I don't love
- 43:12Speaker 1: my community. I mean it's but nobody questions that you
- 43:16Speaker 1: can't question that you're not allowed to question that with
- 43:19Speaker 1: with altruism. Yeah, and.
- 43:24Speaker 3: Usually the way that so when I used to teach
- 43:28Speaker 3: college philosophy classes, I would I would talk about related issues,
- 43:31Speaker 3: and what I would often get from my students when
- 43:35Speaker 3: we talk about questions about self interest versus altruism is
- 43:40Speaker 3: they'd say, oh, yeah, it's just like the air mask
- 43:45Speaker 3: on the plane when it pops down, you got to
- 43:47Speaker 3: put your own on first creation.
- 43:51Speaker 2: And I'm saying, oh, so that is the idea there
- 43:53Speaker 2: that you your own breathing is actually more important than
- 43:58Speaker 2: other people's or is it that you are just a
- 44:00Speaker 2: means to their end and you know you've got to
- 44:02Speaker 2: put it on before you help the other person, because
- 44:04Speaker 2: then you can't help them if you if you die first.
- 44:07Speaker 3: And when pressed on that, they always oh, yeah, it's
- 44:09Speaker 3: the second one. It's uh, it's not because it can't
- 44:14Speaker 3: be that that my own life is actually the ultimate value,
- 44:18Speaker 3: and so there's that equivocation between the two kinds of
- 44:22Speaker 3: before you love your yourself before your family, your family
- 44:26Speaker 3: before your country, et cetera, that allows them to get
- 44:28Speaker 3: away with that. On the one hand, it kind of
- 44:29Speaker 3: rationalizes a sort of egoism, but it's put in just
- 44:33Speaker 3: ambiguous enough of a way that it's still formally consistent
- 44:36Speaker 3: with the idea that our obligations are owed to somebody else.
- 44:42Speaker 1: So, well, this is happening kind of in the in
- 44:46Speaker 1: the people debating Christian theology. There's there's be now a
- 44:51Speaker 1: controversy within the atheist movement, uh, the atheist movement of
- 44:56Speaker 1: Dawkins and Pinco and Sam Houise, and I guess all
- 44:59Speaker 1: of those tell us a little bit about this, because
- 45:01Speaker 1: this certainly didn't make the big headlines that jd. Vance makes.
- 45:06Speaker 3: Yeah, it didn't, and I'm writing an article about it,
- 45:08Speaker 3: so there'll be more from me on this soon. But
- 45:12Speaker 3: just for framing, I think it's worth pointing out that
- 45:14Speaker 3: this is another example of I think, the same thing
- 45:18Speaker 3: we talked about before, of the way in which even
- 45:24Speaker 3: the heirs to the Enlightenment, the best of secular kind
- 45:28Speaker 3: of rationalist culture is still in one way or another
- 45:34Speaker 3: completely under the spell of Christian morality and there's just
- 45:36Speaker 3: really nobody sees an alternative. And it's it comes up
- 45:41Speaker 3: because there's a recent recent scandal controversy raw among atheists
- 45:46Speaker 3: about transgender ideology and it it's actually been long in
- 45:51Speaker 3: the making, but the latest flare up of it really
- 45:55Speaker 3: kind of formalized a break, a split, kind of schism
- 45:58Speaker 3: in the in the eighth movement. It started with is
- 46:01Speaker 3: an organization called Freedom from Religion Foundation. They're the ones
- 46:05Speaker 3: who are often firing filing a lot of lawsuits on
- 46:08Speaker 3: issues of church state separation. And they have a blog
- 46:12Speaker 3: and where you know, people who are affiliated with the
- 46:15Speaker 3: organization one way or another post their opinions on things
- 46:19Speaker 3: that they think are related to the secular movement. There
- 46:20Speaker 3: was there was a post put up by a person
- 46:23Speaker 3: named Kat Grant, what is a woman? And the essence
- 46:28Speaker 3: of this person's answer is a woman is whoever says
- 46:30Speaker 3: she is.
- 46:32Speaker 2: And there's a member of the honorary.
- 46:36Speaker 3: Board of Directors of Freedom From Religion Foundation, Jerry Coy,
- 46:40Speaker 3: who's a very well respected established evolutionary biologist from University
- 46:46Speaker 3: of Chicago and Coin has has long had a problem
- 46:52Speaker 3: with the denial among the transgender activists of the sexual
- 46:58Speaker 3: binary and so he object to the idea that it's
- 47:00Speaker 3: just whoever says whoever she says she is. And he
- 47:04Speaker 3: writes an article, has it, asks for it to be
- 47:07Speaker 3: posted to the f FRF blog because he's a he's
- 47:10Speaker 3: a member of their honorary Board directors, where he basically
- 47:13Speaker 3: tries to rebut this idea, and he says, you know,
- 47:15Speaker 3: there's there's a fundamental difference in biology between the member
- 47:20Speaker 3: of the species that produces the large gam meets and
- 47:22Speaker 3: the small gam meets, and it makes a big difference
- 47:24Speaker 3: for how natural selection works, et cetera. Uh, and yes,
- 47:28Speaker 3: there's parent exceptions to this, there's intersex individuals, but in effect,
- 47:31Speaker 3: it's kind of borderline case and it doesn't really deny
- 47:33Speaker 3: it still doesn't deny the fact that there are binaries,
- 47:36Speaker 3: that it's on the borderline between and you know, I
- 47:38Speaker 3: should I should also say, in defense of what quin
- 47:42Speaker 3: is saying in this in this piece, that he is
- 47:46Speaker 3: very far, very very far from like calling for the
- 47:49Speaker 3: persecution of trans individuals.
- 47:53Speaker 2: And he's like he's even using the they.
- 47:55Speaker 3: Them pronouns to describe cat Grant, and he's just hesinguishes
- 48:00Speaker 3: between sex and gender, and he says, you know, gender
- 48:03Speaker 3: is the kind of cultural associations with biological sex role
- 48:06Speaker 3: and that comes on a spectrum, and we should be
- 48:08Speaker 3: very tolerant of all kinds of different lifestyles that people have.
- 48:11Speaker 3: But if you're talking about biological sex, that's still a
- 48:15Speaker 3: biological binary. And I'll tell you you're an I'm no biologist,
- 48:20Speaker 3: So like, I haven't studied the biology of ge meat
- 48:23Speaker 3: size close enough to with certainty that that Coin, who's
- 48:27Speaker 3: a really you know, well established biologies is right about this.
- 48:30Speaker 3: But like that would be a reason for there to
- 48:33Speaker 3: be a good, open scientific debate on the question that
- 48:36Speaker 3: I could then follow.
- 48:36Speaker 2: But that's then not what happens.
- 48:40Speaker 3: What happens is there's a social media mob that comes
- 48:45Speaker 3: for Coin, pressures the Freedom From Foundation Freedom From Revision
- 48:50Speaker 3: Foundation to take down his post, to delete it from
- 48:52Speaker 3: their blog, and they put up a small post of
- 48:57Speaker 3: their own saying why they did it, but not take
- 49:00Speaker 3: any issue with any of his scientific arguments or claims.
- 49:03Speaker 3: And so as a result, he steps down from their board,
- 49:06Speaker 3: and so do Richard Dawkins, and so does Stephen Pinker.
- 49:10Speaker 3: Others come forward to defend what FFRF did, uh and
- 49:16Speaker 3: what they focus on. They basically ignore the whole scientific
- 49:20Speaker 3: debate that most of which is what was motivating coin
- 49:23Speaker 3: and they focused instead.
- 49:24Speaker 2: On there's some things he says about what he thinks the.
- 49:27Speaker 3: Policy implications of the sex biner should be, having to
- 49:30Speaker 3: do with bathrooms and women in sports and things like that,
- 49:33Speaker 3: And they take issue with his use of statistics and
- 49:36Speaker 3: whether or not trans people are overrepresented in prison populations.
- 49:40Speaker 3: I think there are some real serious questions about whether
- 49:42Speaker 3: he was using the statistics properly. But then like that's
- 49:44Speaker 3: a debate you should have, uh, And instead it's he
- 49:48Speaker 3: must be a bigot.
- 49:49Speaker 2: He must be he must be prejudiced, you know, good
- 49:52Speaker 2: riddance that he.
- 49:53Speaker 3: Was kicked out of the movement, And so they really
- 49:57Speaker 3: they what what what's happening there on that side of
- 49:59Speaker 3: the atheist movement to me, really does look like religious
- 50:04Speaker 3: dogmatism on behalf of you know, this new quasi religion
- 50:07Speaker 3: of the woke, which has now you know, infiltrated the
- 50:10Speaker 3: major element of the atheist movement. And Dawkins and Pinker
- 50:14Speaker 3: and others have you know, long been critics of that,
- 50:16Speaker 3: and so it's no surprise that they're now formalizing that break.
- 50:21Speaker 3: So on the one hand, here are in fact left
- 50:24Speaker 3: wing atheists who are they're supposed to be the scientific rationalists, right,
- 50:29Speaker 3: They're supposed to be the ones who are immune to
- 50:32Speaker 3: all the irrationality religion, And yet here they are, you know,
- 50:36Speaker 3: having their own little inquisition kicking out the heretics, who
- 50:40Speaker 3: are you unwilling to speak the sacred words? Although with
- 50:44Speaker 3: some of them they are willing to speak, but that
- 50:46Speaker 3: they don't even want to have the scientific debate.
- 50:49Speaker 2: And so.
- 50:51Speaker 3: The religion's influence even among the atheists is really quite ubiquitous.
- 50:59Speaker 2: And there's one last little twist.
- 51:00Speaker 3: On this, which is that even among those who are
- 51:05Speaker 3: speaking up on behalf of coin, like Richard Dawkins and
- 51:08Speaker 3: Pinker and I, you know, I applaud them for doing it,
- 51:14Speaker 3: there's a there's a there's a kind of inconsistency looming
- 51:17Speaker 3: in the background with their overall position, which is, on
- 51:20Speaker 3: the one hand, wow, you know, to to come out
- 51:23Speaker 3: in defense of scientific truth, or at least what you
- 51:26Speaker 3: argue is scientific truth, even when everybody opposes you, Even
- 51:31Speaker 3: when there's this populous, vulnerable population of people who are
- 51:34Speaker 3: going to be offended and you know in some way
- 51:37Speaker 3: affected by what you say. Well, that's that that takes
- 51:40Speaker 3: some guts, right, that takes some that takes some pride
- 51:44Speaker 3: to be able to do that.
- 51:45Speaker 2: And yet there's this trend on the atheist and the
- 51:49Speaker 2: atheist movement.
- 51:49Speaker 3: It's been it's been bullied and promoted by people like
- 51:52Speaker 3: Dawkins and Pinker that we should really practice intellectual humility,
- 51:56Speaker 3: and it just doesn't fit, like, this is not the
- 51:59Speaker 3: act of someone who's being intellectually humble to be able
- 52:02Speaker 3: to defend science even when it's this pop, when it's
- 52:04Speaker 3: this unpopular, that takes pride. And so yeah, I wrote
- 52:09Speaker 3: an article about this, and I sent it to all
- 52:11Speaker 3: the different atheist magazines and nobody wanted to publish it.
- 52:15Speaker 2: And it's it's telling because like.
- 52:19Speaker 3: Even among the better parts of the atheist movement, they
- 52:24Speaker 3: want to apologize for their reverence for science by framing
- 52:28Speaker 3: it in terms of humility.
- 52:30Speaker 2: And they say science is.
- 52:31Speaker 3: Humble because scientists have to be willing to admit when
- 52:35Speaker 3: they've made mistakes and then they don't know everything and all.
- 52:38Speaker 3: This is of course true, but it's not humility, it's objectivity,
- 52:41Speaker 3: it's intellectual honesty and nothing to do with the Christian
- 52:45Speaker 3: virtue of humility, which says, you know, you should not
- 52:49Speaker 3: think so well of yourself to think you can ever
- 52:51Speaker 3: discover any truth.
- 52:52Speaker 2: You should, you know, bow down before the authorities.
- 52:55Speaker 1: And so it really just is everywhere, how much is
- 52:58Speaker 1: this is the way so many of these intellectuals presented
- 53:01Speaker 1: as dogmatism visus skepticism, and those are the two options.
- 53:05Speaker 3: Oh, it's it's completely related to that. It's it's those
- 53:09Speaker 3: are the two alternatives that they can that they can envision.
- 53:12Speaker 3: And I guess my point is, you know, if.
- 53:15Speaker 2: You want to distinguish what you're doing in a controversy
- 53:18Speaker 2: like this, where you are taking a real principal stand
- 53:21Speaker 2: in favor of science against all the naysayers, h but
- 53:25Speaker 2: you don't want to you don't want to see that
- 53:27Speaker 2: as dogmatic.
- 53:28Speaker 3: You've got to see there's a third possibility here. It's
- 53:30Speaker 3: neither skepticism nor dogmatism is being objective.
- 53:35Speaker 1: Why do you think that's so hard?
- 53:39Speaker 2: You got me, Yeah, I mean it's it's hard.
- 53:44Speaker 3: What's hard is is pushing back against so many automatized
- 53:51Speaker 3: categories that you've been taught from you know, day one,
- 53:56Speaker 3: that you're either dogmatic or you're a skeptic. You're either
- 54:01Speaker 3: you know, arrogant or you're humble, and it's those are
- 54:06Speaker 3: just automatized in a lot of people's minds.
- 54:08Speaker 2: And being able to see a third alternative it does
- 54:11Speaker 2: take work. It does take, you know, it really takes.
- 54:15Speaker 3: Having a whole alternate worldview as a possibility that you
- 54:18Speaker 3: can consult to attach that third alternative too.
- 54:22Speaker 2: It's not it's not enough that it's just like kind
- 54:24Speaker 2: of logical possibility. It has to have some you know,
- 54:26Speaker 2: flesh to it.
- 54:28Speaker 3: And they what they don't have is and this goes
- 54:31Speaker 3: back to earlier conversation, they just they don't have a systematic,
- 54:34Speaker 3: worked out theory of morality that that they see as scientific,
- 54:38Speaker 3: they see.
- 54:39Speaker 2: As a real alternative of the Christian worldview. It's there.
- 54:43Speaker 3: They still equate like the Christian view of morality as
- 54:46Speaker 3: the stereotype of what morality is and just can't see
- 54:48Speaker 3: past it.
- 54:49Speaker 1: How much is this also pistemological in terms of how
- 54:52Speaker 1: they view what the truth is?
- 54:57Speaker 2: I mean, sure, that's that's part of it.
- 54:58Speaker 3: It's it's part of what And you know, Mike Mas
- 55:02Speaker 3: has done some good work lately on Carl Popper, Mike
- 55:05Speaker 3: is my.
- 55:05Speaker 2: Colleague Ari And the paparian view is that a.
- 55:12Speaker 3: Certainty is the certainty is is a form of it's
- 55:17Speaker 3: a form of dogmatism, and it's conducive to authoritarianism. And yeah,
- 55:22Speaker 3: it's it's it's true that baseless confidence is a kind
- 55:27Speaker 3: of authoritarianism and conducive to that and is a kind
- 55:30Speaker 3: of dogmatism. But you have to be able to distinguish
- 55:33Speaker 3: between certainty that's earned, confidence that's earned in the kind
- 55:36Speaker 3: that's unearned. And there's a lot more to say about that,
- 55:41Speaker 3: but there's definitely an epistemological view coming from Popper and
- 55:45Speaker 3: many many others that make that possibility difficult to see.
- 55:51Speaker 1: All right, let's uh, we've got a bunch of questions,
- 55:53Speaker 1: so let's let's turns out questions. I think we covered
- 55:58Speaker 1: everything we plan to. Yep, let's see right. John puts
- 56:05Speaker 1: one hundred dollars in. He says, love Ben, take my money.
- 56:08Speaker 1: Happy to take your money, John, And I'm glad you
- 56:10Speaker 1: love Ben. That's great. Wes also one hundred dollars, says
- 56:13Speaker 1: how you Ben. I'm a big fan the old Check
- 56:17Speaker 1: your Premises blog. You and Greg worked on years ago
- 56:21Speaker 1: helped me learn a lot about objectivism.
- 56:25Speaker 3: That was the old blog of the Iran Society, which
- 56:29Speaker 3: was the which is the academic society affility with the
- 56:33Speaker 3: American Philosophical Association. I yeah, we don't do that anymore,
- 56:37Speaker 3: but I should mention that Greg recently transferred all of
- 56:41Speaker 3: the old contents of that to a substack. Oh, you
- 56:44Speaker 3: can subscribe to that substack and support the Iran Society
- 56:47Speaker 3: and get the papers that they put out every year
- 56:51Speaker 3: at their sessions.
- 56:52Speaker 1: So that's a substack of the Ironman Society. Yeah, okay,
- 56:56Speaker 1: do you know how they would find it?
- 56:58Speaker 2: I think probably just look up bin Ran Society.
- 57:02Speaker 1: I think it's Society substack.
- 57:05Speaker 2: Yeah, I think it's Iran Society dot org. Yes, that
- 57:11Speaker 2: is the substack.
- 57:13Speaker 1: All right. Ian says this is partially for Ben's work
- 57:18Speaker 1: on religion and partially for him holding Trump to product
- 57:22Speaker 1: standards on social media. I appreciate all his posts and
- 57:26Speaker 1: good to see some objectivists on blue Sky now that
- 57:30Speaker 1: I'm off Twitter.
- 57:31Speaker 2: Okay, mirror everything on blue Sky?
- 57:34Speaker 1: What's that you mirror everything?
- 57:35Speaker 2: Is that easy to do? Because the left has left
- 57:39Speaker 2: a lot of the left has left X and yeah,
- 57:43Speaker 2: some of them might want to hear what I have
- 57:45Speaker 2: to say show them might need to hear what I
- 57:47Speaker 2: have to say.
- 57:49Speaker 1: Is is it easy to mirror? Not?
- 57:52Speaker 2: There are probably.
- 57:52Speaker 3: Programs you could do that use that would make it
- 57:54Speaker 3: easier than what I'm doing right now. Right now, I'm
- 57:56Speaker 3: just copying and.
- 57:56Speaker 1: Ping pasting our programs. Yeah, ex is becoming I don't know.
- 58:02Speaker 1: I've created my own little uh inchu l a babble.
- 58:07Speaker 1: I think so I get I get certain I get
- 58:11Speaker 1: the same people over and over again. It's getting boring
- 58:14Speaker 1: because I pretty much know what they're going to say
- 58:16Speaker 1: about any particulation. Uh, let's see Schasbat asks if God
- 58:23Speaker 1: is omnipotent, why are so many people worried that he
- 58:27Speaker 1: will somehow lose his grip on the world. He could
- 58:30Speaker 1: make a whole galaxy become purple in an instant if
- 58:33Speaker 1: you wanted to.
- 58:37Speaker 2: That's that's actually a very interesting question, and I think
- 58:42Speaker 2: to really answer it, you'd have to you have to
- 58:44Speaker 2: think a little bit more about the psychology of religious belief,
- 58:47Speaker 2: because people who believe.
- 58:52Speaker 3: Things on faith, it's not they don't always believe the
- 58:57Speaker 3: thing that they say that they believe, And there there's
- 59:05Speaker 3: a lot of stuff in Gault's speech that speaks to
- 59:07Speaker 3: this which people don't appreciate when she talks about the
- 59:10Speaker 3: psychology of the mystic and I mean her view is
- 59:13Speaker 3: that the kind of attitude that pushes someone.
- 59:17Speaker 2: Toward religious belief, in the belief in a higher power is.
- 59:23Speaker 3: Ultimately it's a kind of social pressure, a kind of
- 59:25Speaker 3: fear of the consciousness.
- 59:26Speaker 2: Of other people.
- 59:28Speaker 3: And so, yeah, the idea of God being omnipotent, that's
- 59:32Speaker 3: a that's a theologian's innovation that's developed to solve one
- 59:37Speaker 3: another one or another puzzle about the.
- 59:39Speaker 2: Idea of God.
- 59:41Speaker 3: But at the end of the day, what believing in
- 59:43Speaker 3: God really is about is is I fear other people.
- 59:48Speaker 2: I want to be able to.
- 59:53Speaker 3: Especially if you're a preacher of religion, you want to
- 59:56Speaker 3: be able to put something over on them. If I
- 59:58Speaker 3: can get them to believe this cre thing, then I'll
- 1:00:02Speaker 3: have something on them and they'll have surrendered their consciousness
- 1:00:04Speaker 3: to me, and they'll they'll help me to fake the
- 1:00:08Speaker 3: kind of person that I am. And so there's very
- 1:00:10Speaker 3: much a concern about what other people are going to
- 1:00:13Speaker 3: do that's baked into the whole religious worldview, and that
- 1:00:18Speaker 3: has to explain you know, the.
- 1:00:22Speaker 2: The push to try to convert people.
- 1:00:24Speaker 3: It explains the loss of confidence that religious people have
- 1:00:28Speaker 3: when religion erodes from the culture. Yeah, because they can't
- 1:00:33Speaker 3: just say, oh, you know, well, the price is going
- 1:00:36Speaker 3: to come again, and the second Coming will happen and
- 1:00:38Speaker 3: we'll all be raptured away.
- 1:00:40Speaker 2: It doesn't really matter what we do on earth. If
- 1:00:42Speaker 2: you took that.
- 1:00:42Speaker 3: Really, really seriously, then you would, you know, go live
- 1:00:45Speaker 3: in a monastery and and not really care what happens
- 1:00:48Speaker 3: in the world. And a few people are like that,
- 1:00:50Speaker 3: but most of them very much care about what other
- 1:00:53Speaker 3: people think of them.
- 1:00:54Speaker 1: And it shows yep, and says I'm I was intrigued
- 1:01:02Speaker 1: by Ben's observation from Augustine's biography of his second handedness.
- 1:01:08Speaker 1: How does second handedness and or the need to belong
- 1:01:11Speaker 1: connect to religion?
- 1:01:13Speaker 2: And this is related?
- 1:01:16Speaker 3: Yeah, this is the I talk about this in that
- 1:01:17Speaker 3: in that Okon talk from two years ago, and uh,
- 1:01:21Speaker 3: it's it comes from a famous part of the Confessions
- 1:01:25Speaker 3: where Augustine talks about stealing a bunch of pairs.
- 1:01:29Speaker 2: With some friends of his.
- 1:01:31Speaker 3: And the main thing he tries to stress in this
- 1:01:35Speaker 3: story is see it's it's it's just an example of
- 1:01:39Speaker 3: the arrogance of of being a pagan to think that
- 1:01:43Speaker 3: I could, you know, steal these parents that even I
- 1:01:45Speaker 3: didn't really need.
- 1:01:46Speaker 2: I just wanted to prove that I could do it. Uh.
- 1:01:48Speaker 2: And so he uses it as this.
- 1:01:51Speaker 3: Is another reason why we should all be humble, uh
- 1:01:55Speaker 3: and and further confirmation of the ubiquity of original sin.
- 1:01:59Speaker 2: But there's another aspect of the story that he mentions.
- 1:02:03Speaker 3: It kind of goes by and passing, but it's significant
- 1:02:06Speaker 3: that it's there. I think that a big part of
- 1:02:09Speaker 3: the story is my friends were kind of peer pressuring me.
- 1:02:12Speaker 2: Into stealing these pairs. I didn't really want to do it,
- 1:02:15Speaker 2: but they were all going along with it.
- 1:02:16Speaker 3: Come on, Augustine, let's steal those pairs. And it's not
- 1:02:20Speaker 3: the only example in his life where he goes along
- 1:02:24Speaker 3: with what the crowd is doing.
- 1:02:26Speaker 1: You know.
- 1:02:26Speaker 2: Another big example of it is when he becomes a priest.
- 1:02:32Speaker 3: He shows up at a church service in his hometown
- 1:02:37Speaker 3: in North Africa after having traveled in Italy trying to
- 1:02:40Speaker 3: get away from his mother and so forth. I mean,
- 1:02:43Speaker 3: he has these brief periods of time, but he's really rebellious,
- 1:02:45Speaker 3: trying to break away from all of that, trying to
- 1:02:47Speaker 3: find himself, but she eventually gets her claws back in him,
- 1:02:52Speaker 3: pulls him back to North Africa. And then he's sitting
- 1:02:54Speaker 3: in church one day and this mob beasaults him and
- 1:02:57Speaker 3: forces him to take holy orders and become a priest.
- 1:02:59Speaker 2: They literally forced him to become a priest. And you know,
- 1:03:03Speaker 2: somebody does that to me like, you know, gun to
- 1:03:07Speaker 2: my head, okay, yeah, I'm a priest, and then run away.
- 1:03:09Speaker 2: But no, he goes with it. He runs with it.
- 1:03:11Speaker 2: He's like, Okay, I guess I'm a priest now. And
- 1:03:13Speaker 2: so there's this real streak of.
- 1:03:16Speaker 3: Having to give in to other people and you know,
- 1:03:19Speaker 3: not really having the courage of your own rebelliousness. That
- 1:03:25Speaker 3: is a theme and throughout his life not really fully
- 1:03:28Speaker 3: acknowledged theme, but it made me. I raised the point
- 1:03:32Speaker 3: in the lecture, Gee, Augusty, do you think may, just maybe,
- 1:03:37Speaker 3: just maybe that that same habit of yours could also
- 1:03:42Speaker 3: account for your acceptance of all of these ideas, all
- 1:03:44Speaker 3: of these religious ideas.
- 1:03:45Speaker 2: And so it goes back to the idea this is
- 1:03:47Speaker 2: this fear of the fear of the of others.
- 1:03:51Speaker 3: Disagreement, fear of others approval in one way or another
- 1:03:54Speaker 3: that transmutes into into religious belief.
- 1:04:02Speaker 1: Let's see Richard Cunningham's asks, what's the difference between the
- 1:04:06Speaker 1: soul and consciousness?
- 1:04:11Speaker 3: You know, I think somebody actually asked Iran this very
- 1:04:13Speaker 3: question in a Fourhall Forum session.
- 1:04:17Speaker 2: I might be mistaken, but I have a vague.
- 1:04:20Speaker 3: Memory that's in the Iron Answers book, and what I
- 1:04:23Speaker 3: remember her saying, something to the effect of which makes
- 1:04:26Speaker 3: sense to me, is.
- 1:04:29Speaker 2: They're basically the same thing.
- 1:04:31Speaker 3: But when you talk about the soul, you're putting emphasis
- 1:04:34Speaker 3: on the emotional aspects of consciousness.
- 1:04:37Speaker 2: Consciousness is a very inclusive concept. It refers to.
- 1:04:43Speaker 3: Thoughts and feelings and decisions and memories and like everything
- 1:04:48Speaker 3: that you would count as a state of consciousness. And
- 1:04:51Speaker 3: when you talk about the soul, it's that, you know,
- 1:04:53Speaker 3: with special emphasis on kind of the agency and the
- 1:04:56Speaker 3: feelings aspect of it. It's not just a purely cognitive thing.
- 1:04:59Speaker 3: It's not just sitting back apprehending the world. It's it's
- 1:05:02Speaker 3: it's it's that plus feeling something about it and maybe
- 1:05:05Speaker 3: doing something.
- 1:05:05Speaker 2: So it's the kind of passionate aspect of consciousness.
- 1:05:08Speaker 3: When you're when you're writing about consciousness and you in
- 1:05:13Speaker 3: certain context, it makes more sense to talk about the soul.
- 1:05:15Speaker 3: It's the thing that has values, It's the the thing
- 1:05:17Speaker 3: that chooses. That's the way she puts in the fountain head.
- 1:05:20Speaker 3: That's the way that Dominique puts it in the fountain head.
- 1:05:22Speaker 3: What is the soul, Peter, It's the thing that thinks,
- 1:05:24Speaker 3: it chooses and makes decisions.
- 1:05:27Speaker 1: Yeah, that makes sense. All right, Let's see hupa Campbell
- 1:05:35Speaker 1: Atlas truck does been out for a while. Now, why
- 1:05:38Speaker 1: are we still going backwards?
- 1:05:43Speaker 3: I mean, part of the whole topic of our conversation
- 1:05:48Speaker 3: today is I think the answer, and I mean you
- 1:05:52Speaker 3: you you raised this in a recent episode of your show,
- 1:05:54Speaker 3: Your Own There's and I really agreed with you that
- 1:05:59Speaker 3: this is a reason why religion has to be fought.
- 1:06:01Speaker 3: You can't just sit back and offer your alternative. Although
- 1:06:06Speaker 3: that is obviously a really big part of it. Religion
- 1:06:09Speaker 3: maintains this grip on our culture that is so destructive
- 1:06:14Speaker 3: in so many ways. And you know the fact that
- 1:06:17Speaker 3: Atlas has been out for what sixty five years, sixty
- 1:06:22Speaker 3: three years now or something, is.
- 1:06:25Speaker 2: Is a sign of that.
- 1:06:28Speaker 3: Who was the audience that was going to be captured
- 1:06:31Speaker 3: by it? When it came out. I mean, iron Rand
- 1:06:33Speaker 3: at the time was still hopeful that the non leftist
- 1:06:38Speaker 3: conservative types, could you know, see this alternative. But instead
- 1:06:42Speaker 3: what happens, you know, National Review Unleash's Whittaker Chambers the
- 1:06:46Speaker 3: Catholic Convert on her and writes his famous Catholic.
- 1:06:50Speaker 1: View vote to all the Catholic converts.
- 1:06:52Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, and eviscerates it. And you know, William F.
- 1:06:56Speaker 3: Buckley is another example of you know, where these very influential,
- 1:07:00Speaker 3: very influential conservative Catholics and they try to read her
- 1:07:04Speaker 3: out of the movement because they know, they know her
- 1:07:06Speaker 3: ideas are a threat to they're cherished so called values
- 1:07:10Speaker 3: and so and.
- 1:07:11Speaker 2: There's a lot of people like that still today. Who
- 1:07:16Speaker 2: they are fighting.
- 1:07:17Speaker 3: They are fighting to keep religion real and relevant and
- 1:07:21Speaker 3: to silence the people who provide the most rational, most
- 1:07:26Speaker 3: comprehensive alternatives to it.
- 1:07:28Speaker 2: So they hate iron Rant.
- 1:07:29Speaker 3: They hate that to the extent that they know who
- 1:07:32Speaker 3: she is, they know she's a threat, and so they
- 1:07:35Speaker 3: work to oppose her. And I mean, that's not the
- 1:07:37Speaker 3: only reason we're still going backwards, but that is that
- 1:07:39Speaker 3: is a big part of it.
- 1:07:43Speaker 1: Yeah, And they's just not enough of us, and they're
- 1:07:45Speaker 1: not enough intellectuals to take on all the different battles,
- 1:07:49Speaker 1: because we're battling everybody really, and maybe at the heart
- 1:07:52Speaker 1: of it is religion, but it's it's the entire culture.
- 1:07:59Speaker 1: Let's see, Michael Ben, how were you able to break
- 1:08:04Speaker 1: free from your Catholic upbringing? What was the hottest part
- 1:08:07Speaker 1: of going from Catholicism to objectivism?
- 1:08:11Speaker 2: It's the farm question. What to say? Well, one thing
- 1:08:18Speaker 2: to say is that even though yes, I was raised Catholic,
- 1:08:23Speaker 2: and even though it was.
- 1:08:26Speaker 3: You know, sixteen seventeen years of it, I do want
- 1:08:30Speaker 3: to give credit to my parents if they happened to
- 1:08:32Speaker 3: be listening, just because they they're Catholic, but they're not
- 1:08:38Speaker 3: crazy Catholic. They're they're the kind of more liberal Catholic types,
- 1:08:42Speaker 3: and so they were willing to tolerate my break with
- 1:08:48Speaker 3: them on the subjects of religion. And we still have
- 1:08:50Speaker 3: a relationship to this day. And yeah, here's a funny story.
- 1:08:56Speaker 3: My own mother was a nun for fourteen years before
- 1:08:59Speaker 3: she met my fe She was very Catholic, but the
- 1:09:02Speaker 3: liberal Catholic variety. And she was even the one who
- 1:09:04Speaker 3: was in charge of running my obviously after she left comment.
- 1:09:08Speaker 3: She was the one who's in charge of running the
- 1:09:10Speaker 3: confirmation program that I was in high school. So I
- 1:09:13Speaker 3: was in confirmation junior year high school. I was supposed
- 1:09:17Speaker 3: to you know, you know, formally announce my confirmation as
- 1:09:19Speaker 3: a Catholic. That was the year that I started acquiring
- 1:09:23Speaker 3: doubts about religion. And even though I'm in the program
- 1:09:26Speaker 3: she's running, I drop out and it must have embarrassing
- 1:09:30Speaker 3: to her.
- 1:09:31Speaker 2: But you know, I knew.
- 1:09:32Speaker 3: I knew other people in the program whose parents were
- 1:09:35Speaker 3: atheists who just wanted them to get converted, so that
- 1:09:38Speaker 3: because it looked respectful and it made them go through
- 1:09:41Speaker 3: with it. But my mom, the former nun you know,
- 1:09:45Speaker 3: still accepted me for you know, even after I dropped out.
- 1:09:50Speaker 3: So that's one point I didn't. It wasn't like an
- 1:09:53Speaker 3: intolerantly Catholic upbring. But if you want to ask about, like,
- 1:09:59Speaker 3: what's the intellectual process by which I broke free from it,
- 1:10:04Speaker 3: the thing to say there is I did it by
- 1:10:09Speaker 3: encountering people from different religions. I went to high school
- 1:10:13Speaker 3: where I had Jewish friends, I had Muslim friends, I
- 1:10:15Speaker 3: had atheist friends, and we'd get in arguments about this
- 1:10:18Speaker 3: kind of stuff. And I could not really reconcile this fact,
- 1:10:26Speaker 3: the fact that I had friends from these different religions
- 1:10:28Speaker 3: with it like mine's the one true religions. Had a
- 1:10:31Speaker 3: Muslim friend, I read the Koran, or I read a
- 1:10:34Speaker 3: big chunk of the Qoran, and like, Okay, here's a
- 1:10:36Speaker 3: whole faith tradition of people who have a completely different
- 1:10:39Speaker 3: view of the world. They know about Jesus, they don't
- 1:10:41Speaker 3: think he's the son of God, though, and like, there's
- 1:10:45Speaker 3: millions of them all around the world.
- 1:10:47Speaker 2: Why is it that my view is the right one
- 1:10:49Speaker 2: and their book is wrong. I didn't have an answer
- 1:10:52Speaker 2: to that question.
- 1:10:54Speaker 3: And then, especially at meeting people who are coming from
- 1:10:57Speaker 3: these different views, I just couldn't bring myself to think, oh, yeah,
- 1:11:02Speaker 3: mine's the right one. I don't have any arguments for it.
- 1:11:04Speaker 3: It's just the one that I was raised with. That's
- 1:11:06Speaker 3: the only reason that I hold it is my view.
- 1:11:09Speaker 3: And you know, once you make that identification, if you're
- 1:11:13Speaker 3: being honest with yourself, you really can't rationalize why yours
- 1:11:17Speaker 3: is the one right view.
- 1:11:19Speaker 1: Well, if if you're intellectually honest, that assumes an honesty
- 1:11:22Speaker 1: that a lot of people do not have for whatever reason.
- 1:11:25Speaker 3: Yeah, and you know, so I spent maybe a year
- 1:11:28Speaker 3: as a kind of agnostic or I didn't know what
- 1:11:29Speaker 3: to do with myself, and I was reading all kinds
- 1:11:32Speaker 3: of different philosophers, different coming from different perspectives, and I
- 1:11:36Speaker 3: read the Fountainhead and you know, for about a year there,
- 1:11:40Speaker 3: I was just kind of depressed and didn't know what
- 1:11:43Speaker 3: to do.
- 1:11:43Speaker 2: With myself intellectually.
- 1:11:45Speaker 3: But the fountain Heads, you know, gave me this vision
- 1:11:48Speaker 3: of a real positive set of values that could be
- 1:11:51Speaker 3: defended on rational grounds.
- 1:11:52Speaker 2: And the rest was history. There's a warm story there.
- 1:11:55Speaker 3: But the hardest part of going from Catholicism to objectivism
- 1:12:05Speaker 3: from the biggest perspective, I would say, giving up on
- 1:12:07Speaker 3: Catholic guilt, which is really entrenched in you on so
- 1:12:11Speaker 3: many in so many ways, you can have to formally
- 1:12:13Speaker 3: reject all of his propositions.
- 1:12:15Speaker 2: And my wife will testify to this.
- 1:12:20Speaker 1: Yep. We all carry some some of the baggage from
- 1:12:24Speaker 1: growing up in crazy environments. All right, and says, can
- 1:12:31Speaker 1: you talk of the atheist movement creating an unintended sanction
- 1:12:36Speaker 1: of woke and can blaming woke and Christianity become a
- 1:12:40Speaker 1: way to not have to face it?
- 1:12:46Speaker 2: I'm not sure if I get the question.
- 1:12:48Speaker 3: So, can talk of an atheist movement create an unintended
- 1:12:54Speaker 3: sanction of woke?
- 1:12:56Speaker 1: Well, just well, because part of the atheist movement is woke.
- 1:13:03Speaker 1: So if you're part of that movement, you're sanctioning the woke.
- 1:13:06Speaker 1: I see, Well, like we don't want to be part
- 1:13:09Speaker 1: of the movement because yeah, I.
- 1:13:12Speaker 2: Mean, I use the phrase atheist movement very very loosely.
- 1:13:15Speaker 2: It's it's it's it's not much of a movement, as
- 1:13:17Speaker 2: I think the schism shows, you know, the atheist community
- 1:13:21Speaker 2: maybe is a better.
- 1:13:22Speaker 1: And part of any atheist movement.
- 1:13:25Speaker 3: I mean, I certainly don't think I am part of
- 1:13:26Speaker 3: any of these movements. It's it's and I they won't
- 1:13:30Speaker 3: have me for one thing, So it's it's I'd love to,
- 1:13:33Speaker 3: you know, get an audience with some of them, but
- 1:13:35Speaker 3: it's it's uh to the extent that there's a movement
- 1:13:38Speaker 3: there at all, Yeah, I'm not.
- 1:13:39Speaker 2: I'm not part of it. So I don't think you
- 1:13:41Speaker 2: can take it as a sanction. But then what was
- 1:13:45Speaker 2: the other part of but blame.
- 1:13:46Speaker 1: If we blame woke the existence of woke on Christianity,
- 1:13:50Speaker 1: is that a way we don't have to face it,
- 1:13:54Speaker 1: like we're not recognizing the true evil or the true
- 1:13:57Speaker 1: nature of.
- 1:13:57Speaker 2: It, the true nature of wocism.
- 1:14:00Speaker 1: Yes, I think it's will Yeah, So I don't know.
- 1:14:04Speaker 2: I don't think that's what it is.
- 1:14:07Speaker 3: Because if that's what they mean by the question, assumes
- 1:14:13Speaker 3: that blaming Wocism on Christianity is saying something nice about it.
- 1:14:18Speaker 3: I mean, I'm I'm I'm saying this makes it really
- 1:14:21Speaker 3: really bad, and it helps understand where the power of
- 1:14:25Speaker 3: the movement comes from. It's true that there have been,
- 1:14:28Speaker 3: you know, twists. Uh, there's a there's a secular twist
- 1:14:33Speaker 3: on wocism that you know that wasn't there in the
- 1:14:37Speaker 3: religious version of it. I don't think it makes that
- 1:14:40Speaker 3: much difference. And again I said before, wocism is not
- 1:14:46Speaker 3: a really great word. It's it doesn't really describe what
- 1:14:49Speaker 3: we're talking about. And what what what the real what
- 1:14:52Speaker 3: the leftist movement is is egalitarianism. It's the idea that
- 1:14:57Speaker 3: we have to break down all all concepts of the good,
- 1:15:03Speaker 3: all concepts of ability, lower it all to the ground
- 1:15:07Speaker 3: in deference to people.
- 1:15:09Speaker 2: Who lack ability.
- 1:15:11Speaker 3: So there's ways in which it's maybe more logically pristine
- 1:15:17Speaker 3: in its application.
- 1:15:19Speaker 2: Certainly more so than like the JD. Vance's who.
- 1:15:22Speaker 3: As we've discussed, you don't want to try to have
- 1:15:24Speaker 3: it both ways, and so in that respect you could
- 1:15:27Speaker 3: argue it's, you know, the kind of the more logical
- 1:15:30Speaker 3: expression of this concept of Christian humility, more logical than
- 1:15:35Speaker 3: today is Christians. But if you go back to what
- 1:15:40Speaker 3: the original Christian idea is, this is not any kind
- 1:15:44Speaker 3: of whitewashing. This is not any kind of apologizing because
- 1:15:47Speaker 3: the original Christian idea, like the kind that you see
- 1:15:49Speaker 3: in Augustine, the kind you see in the medieval Saints,
- 1:15:52Speaker 3: it's just as neilistic and just as anti value, if
- 1:15:56Speaker 3: not more so, than what you see contemporary egalitarianism.
- 1:16:02Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, I suspect what she's trying to say
- 1:16:05Speaker 1: is by associating wokeism with Christianity, it leaves us just
- 1:16:12Speaker 1: free to criticize wocism, and we don't spend enough time
- 1:16:15Speaker 1: analyzing and dissecting and criticizing the woke the egalitarians.
- 1:16:21Speaker 3: I mean, there's there's a there's a somebody should be
- 1:16:24Speaker 3: doing the job of criticizing contemporary egalitarianism.
- 1:16:29Speaker 2: I do it to the extent I can, But I
- 1:16:31Speaker 2: think the one of the problems with the.
- 1:16:39Speaker 3: Knee jerk reaction to everything evil about the woke movement
- 1:16:43Speaker 3: is it really misses how this is just one expression
- 1:16:48Speaker 3: of a larger cultural neihilism that we see all over
- 1:16:52Speaker 3: the place. And if you don't, if you don't understand
- 1:16:54Speaker 3: the root of where it's coming from, you'll you'll just
- 1:16:57Speaker 3: not be able to fight it. And I'll give you
- 1:17:00Speaker 3: one more example of this, which is this is some
- 1:17:02Speaker 3: point I make in the article I wrote about John
- 1:17:06Speaker 3: mcwater's views on this issue, which I think are pretty good.
- 1:17:10Speaker 3: You know, he's the one who says this wokeism is
- 1:17:12Speaker 3: a kind of religion like but even mcwarter, I think
- 1:17:16Speaker 3: in part because he's not fully coming to terms with
- 1:17:19Speaker 3: the religious origin of this. What is his criticism of
- 1:17:25Speaker 3: the woke movement? You know, they're not humble enough. They
- 1:17:27Speaker 3: should really realize that they're not right about everything.
- 1:17:31Speaker 2: Which is a major concession to the very idea that that.
- 1:17:35Speaker 3: That they are trying to promote. And so if that's
- 1:17:39Speaker 3: your way of trying to combat them, you're you're lost.
- 1:17:42Speaker 1: Yep, all right, Liam, asks do you put in some
- 1:17:48Speaker 1: form of Christian fascism for Europe in the United States?
- 1:17:52Speaker 1: I don't see any forces with large enough numbers to
- 1:17:54Speaker 1: reverse it.
- 1:17:59Speaker 2: I don't know.
- 1:18:03Speaker 3: Yeh, certainly closer to that right now than than we
- 1:18:07Speaker 3: have been any since anytime in my memory.
- 1:18:11Speaker 1: Ah.
- 1:18:12Speaker 2: I like to take consolation in the in the American system,
- 1:18:19Speaker 2: in in the Constitution, the system the.
- 1:18:21Speaker 3: Founders created knowing that the tyrants would rise someday, and
- 1:18:26Speaker 3: system of checks and balances that are there to protect
- 1:18:29Speaker 3: against it.
- 1:18:29Speaker 2: And you know, to some extent, I think it's worked. Ah,
- 1:18:33Speaker 2: It's going to be a very interesting four years to
- 1:18:35Speaker 2: see how it holds. The Uh, I have to say, Uh.
- 1:18:42Speaker 3: You know, for those who think I'm knee jerk anti
- 1:18:45Speaker 3: Trump on everything, I think that the left's rhetoric so
- 1:18:51Speaker 3: far last two weeks, especially on legal questions, has been
- 1:18:55Speaker 3: hysterical and exaggerated. That many, not all, but many or
- 1:19:00Speaker 3: most of the accusations of ways in which Trump is
- 1:19:05Speaker 3: supposed to be violating the Constitution are are very far fetched.
- 1:19:09Speaker 3: Like when you when you look at the text of
- 1:19:11Speaker 3: the executive orders and you look at the allegations of
- 1:19:15Speaker 3: why they're supposed to be unconstitutional, it's not obvious like
- 1:19:20Speaker 3: there are in many cases at least there are you know,
- 1:19:24Speaker 3: pretty credible legal theories that conservatives have.
- 1:19:27Speaker 2: Had a long time for why what Trump is doing
- 1:19:30Speaker 2: is challenging some unconstitutional law, and it's going to be
- 1:19:32Speaker 2: a test case. It's going to be brought to the
- 1:19:34Speaker 2: Supreme Court.
- 1:19:35Speaker 3: And I'm not a legal scholar, so I'm not in
- 1:19:36Speaker 3: a position to weigh those I think it'll be interesting
- 1:19:38Speaker 3: to see what happens when these cases go to Supreme Court.
- 1:19:42Speaker 3: I suspect he's going to lose on some of them,
- 1:19:44Speaker 3: he's going to win on others, And the big question
- 1:19:46Speaker 3: will be what does he do when he loses, Like
- 1:19:48Speaker 3: is he gonna is he going to comply with this,
- 1:19:50Speaker 3: with the Court's orders and that happens. If that happens,
- 1:19:53Speaker 3: if you disobeys the Supreme Court, then I think we
- 1:19:55Speaker 3: can start talking about a constitutional crisis.
- 1:19:57Speaker 2: I don't think we're there quite yet. No.
- 1:19:59Speaker 1: I think we' phone constitutional crisis is the courts actually
- 1:20:03Speaker 1: make a ruling, and it's going to be a while
- 1:20:05Speaker 1: because it takes a while for the Supreme Court to
- 1:20:07Speaker 1: get these crisis. There's so many of them, it's like
- 1:20:11Speaker 1: they're probably they're probably six big ones right right now
- 1:20:15Speaker 1: that are heading towards the Supreme Court they're probably more
- 1:20:18Speaker 1: so it's it's gonna be. I think this is gonna
- 1:20:20Speaker 1: be maybe the next couple of years, the most interesting
- 1:20:23Speaker 1: Supreme Court period, maybe since the nineteen thirties, because they
- 1:20:27Speaker 1: will either confirm a lot of the you know, the
- 1:20:32Speaker 1: changes made over the last hundred years, or turn them
- 1:20:36Speaker 1: overturn them. Either way, it's going to be momentous, and.
- 1:20:40Speaker 2: Some of the stuff needs to be over Like, there
- 1:20:41Speaker 2: are absolutely a lot of unconstitutional stuff in the existing
- 1:20:44Speaker 2: body of the law. Whether the Court's reasons for thinking
- 1:20:48Speaker 2: it will be yeah, it's unconstitution will be the best reasons.
- 1:20:51Speaker 2: It is an interesting question.
- 1:20:52Speaker 1: But all right, James asked, is Kant's dream of overthrowing
- 1:20:58Speaker 1: the Enlightenment about to occur in our lifetime? Trump a
- 1:21:01Speaker 1: fd putin all fascist forces that are winning power.
- 1:21:06Speaker 3: I mean this is kind of the same question, Yeah,
- 1:21:12Speaker 3: except this, I mean, Kant's dream of overthrowing the Enlightenment
- 1:21:16Speaker 3: came true with Kant if you're talking about in our
- 1:21:19Speaker 3: intellectual culture, the nineteenth century was the embodiment of Kant's
- 1:21:23Speaker 3: dream in so many different ways.
- 1:21:26Speaker 2: He successfully.
- 1:21:28Speaker 1: But they never fully manifested itself in the world. Well,
- 1:21:31Speaker 1: I mean, you could argue communism and fascism maybe in
- 1:21:35Speaker 1: the twentieth century, but somehow the Enlightenment held on right
- 1:21:38Speaker 1: and it still does. And that's the amazing thing is
- 1:21:42Speaker 1: how well the Enlightenment is done in spite of Kant
- 1:21:45Speaker 1: and you know all these anti Enlightenment forces.
- 1:21:50Speaker 2: Yeah, and there are segments of our culture.
- 1:21:56Speaker 3: Not nearly big or influential or vocal enough, but there
- 1:21:59Speaker 3: are segments of our culture that have become radicalized in
- 1:22:02Speaker 3: favor of the Enlightenment in the last ten years when
- 1:22:07Speaker 3: they've seen the way things are going. And so to
- 1:22:11Speaker 3: go back to the question of associating with people in
- 1:22:14Speaker 3: the atheist movement, I mean some of them are there,
- 1:22:16Speaker 3: not nearly enough of them, but a few of them
- 1:22:18Speaker 3: are there, And why would be great to get an
- 1:22:21Speaker 3: audience with them, and it'd be great to be able
- 1:22:24Speaker 3: to give them the tools that they need from a
- 1:22:28Speaker 3: philosophy like objectivism, especially on the subject of morality, where
- 1:22:32Speaker 3: they most desperately need the tools.
- 1:22:35Speaker 2: And you know, some of them may be.
- 1:22:37Speaker 1: Open to yep, let's see, I like numbers. As Ben said,
- 1:22:46Speaker 1: he doubts Musk would interview with him.
- 1:22:50Speaker 2: Why somebody asked me about this on X today. Well,
- 1:22:55Speaker 2: I think Musk is busy with a lot of other things.
- 1:23:00Speaker 1: Yeah, and even even if he wasn't, I mean.
- 1:23:02Speaker 3: Even if he wasn't yeah, I mean, so it's part
- 1:23:04Speaker 3: of the context. Is he tweeted out a quote from
- 1:23:06Speaker 3: iin Ran today about about the businessmen can't force you
- 1:23:12Speaker 3: to buy their products, only bureaucrats can, you know, which
- 1:23:15Speaker 3: is a good quote to tweet out. No comment on
- 1:23:19Speaker 3: whether Muski is trying to force anyone to buy his
- 1:23:22Speaker 3: products when he sues advertisers for boycotting him. But it's,
- 1:23:26Speaker 3: you know, he's a really mixed guy, and you've you've
- 1:23:28Speaker 3: done some really good shows on him lately. It's he's
- 1:23:31Speaker 3: a brilliant business innovator, but he seems to have no
- 1:23:35Speaker 3: clue what he's doing with politics, even when he's trying
- 1:23:37Speaker 3: to do good things with politics.
- 1:23:39Speaker 2: Some of that's because there's only so much he can do.
- 1:23:42Speaker 3: And and like I think, as you've discussed with connection
- 1:23:45Speaker 3: with the doge phenomenon, it's it's it's such a drop
- 1:23:49Speaker 3: in the bucket compared to the big budgetary issues that
- 1:23:54Speaker 3: nobody wants to touch. Nobody can touch legally, nobody wants
- 1:23:57Speaker 3: to touch morally, because the morale of altruism just rules
- 1:24:01Speaker 3: out doing any kind of entitlement reform, and he doesn't
- 1:24:05Speaker 3: want to talk about that. He wants to talk about
- 1:24:07Speaker 3: taking a chain sawts of the you know, really small stuff,
- 1:24:10Speaker 3: which is good pr.
- 1:24:13Speaker 2: And but I think that's about all it is.
- 1:24:18Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean it's it's some of it is an
- 1:24:22Speaker 1: entrepreneur's frustration at the inability to actually get stuff done
- 1:24:25Speaker 1: and wanting to do something. It's it's the primacy of action.
- 1:24:31Speaker 2: Yeap.
- 1:24:32Speaker 1: Have you have you read Russ What dude I can't
- 1:24:37Speaker 1: pronounce his name, do o U.
- 1:24:39Speaker 3: T h Stalt Delta a New New York Times columnist
- 1:24:44Speaker 3: who's religious conservative.
- 1:24:46Speaker 2: And yeah, he has this new book out. Believe I
- 1:24:49Speaker 2: have not read his book. It just came out. I've
- 1:24:52Speaker 2: read a bunch of reviews of it. I want to
- 1:24:54Speaker 2: read it. I've read some excerpts that he's published. I'm
- 1:24:59Speaker 2: not too impressed.
- 1:24:59Speaker 1: Off.
- 1:25:01Speaker 3: I tweeted about one excerpt that he published recently, which
- 1:25:04Speaker 3: I thought was so bizarre it's worth sharing because it
- 1:25:09Speaker 3: shows you kind of the level of thinking that these
- 1:25:12Speaker 3: religious apologists are operating at these days. So he it
- 1:25:16Speaker 3: was a New York Times one of his columns an
- 1:25:19Speaker 3: excerpt from his book and he was I think he
- 1:25:21Speaker 3: was the one the best reason to believe in God,
- 1:25:23Speaker 3: or something like that, And he he gives a he
- 1:25:28Speaker 3: references an argument from a contemporary philosopher, Thomas Nagel. Nagel
- 1:25:35Speaker 3: is a famous, as among other reasons, as a critic
- 1:25:39Speaker 3: of certain Darwinian arguments.
- 1:25:42Speaker 2: And I don't think.
- 1:25:44Speaker 3: I'm not sure if Nagel himself is religious, but at
- 1:25:46Speaker 3: least a lot of his criticism gets used.
- 1:25:48Speaker 2: By religious philosophers. And one of the arguments he makes
- 1:25:51Speaker 2: is the following and doubted approves of it. The argument is,
- 1:25:58Speaker 2: even if you.
- 1:25:58Speaker 3: Can account for the evolution of various biological phenomena to
- 1:26:05Speaker 3: some extent using evolution by natural selection, here's something you
- 1:26:11Speaker 3: can't account for.
- 1:26:13Speaker 1: Uh.
- 1:26:13Speaker 3: The extreme complexity of advanced human intelligence is while we
- 1:26:17Speaker 3: can make sense of how you know, maybe, uh, I
- 1:26:22Speaker 3: don't know.
- 1:26:22Speaker 2: Dogs dogs develop the ability to bite with their teeth
- 1:26:27Speaker 2: on evolutionary grounds, Wow, how can you how can you
- 1:26:29Speaker 2: account for the fact that not only the human beings
- 1:26:32Speaker 2: you know, know how to do basic math, but they
- 1:26:35Speaker 2: can do advanced physics, and they can they can build cyclotrons,
- 1:26:38Speaker 2: and and there's not a single little mental module that
- 1:26:41Speaker 2: accounts for all. This is just so much, so many unpredictable,
- 1:26:45Speaker 2: complex things we can do with our minds. There's got
- 1:26:48Speaker 2: to be a god that accounts for this, says doubt Fit.
- 1:26:52Speaker 3: And my thought on this is, well, first of all,
- 1:26:57Speaker 3: there's just all kinds of problems with your standard every
- 1:27:00Speaker 3: day argument from design, which is which this is a
- 1:27:03Speaker 3: part of. You know, there's some kind of complex functionality.
- 1:27:07Speaker 3: We don't understand how it evolved, therefore it must be
- 1:27:09Speaker 3: a god.
- 1:27:11Speaker 2: You know.
- 1:27:12Speaker 3: Ordinary response to that is like, even if you don't
- 1:27:14Speaker 3: understand how it's possible, that doesn't prove that it was
- 1:27:17Speaker 3: a god that had to do It doesn't prove anything.
- 1:27:19Speaker 3: It's just something you don't understand. It doesn't prove something
- 1:27:22Speaker 3: else that you then do. But what's especially galling about
- 1:27:25Speaker 3: this version of the argument from design, this special version
- 1:27:30Speaker 3: of it from the complex functionality of human intelligence, is
- 1:27:34Speaker 3: the whole argument from design in the first place, gets
- 1:27:38Speaker 3: whatever degree of plausibility it has from the fact that, oh,
- 1:27:42Speaker 3: there's a difference between the things that we see that
- 1:27:45Speaker 3: we think are just the product of random chance. First,
- 1:27:47Speaker 3: just the things that we see that are the products
- 1:27:49Speaker 3: of design. You see a stone on a beach, nobody
- 1:27:53Speaker 3: would think that had to be made by anybody.
- 1:27:54Speaker 2: But oh, you see a watch, a clock, It's got
- 1:27:56Speaker 2: all this intricate mechanism that must have been designed by
- 1:27:58Speaker 2: something with what with? What with intelligence?
- 1:28:01Speaker 3: And so like, the whole idea of the argument from
- 1:28:04Speaker 3: design gets off the ground in the first place only
- 1:28:06Speaker 3: because you think human intelligence has some kind of power
- 1:28:09Speaker 3: to it.
- 1:28:10Speaker 2: If you're not using the argument from design and say
- 1:28:12Speaker 2: we can't account for human intelligence, it must have been
- 1:28:14Speaker 2: designed by some miner, it's just completely cuts itself off
- 1:28:17Speaker 2: at its own branch.
- 1:28:19Speaker 3: And it's it's it really shows just the fear and
- 1:28:26Speaker 3: resentment of intelligence. I think that that is that it
- 1:28:30Speaker 3: so much of religious faith is imbibed with. So it's
- 1:28:36Speaker 3: a real confession on doubt. It's part that this is
- 1:28:39Speaker 3: the argument that he thinks is so compelling, you know,
- 1:28:42Speaker 3: in spite of its just intellectual incoherence. This is like
- 1:28:46Speaker 3: the fact that people are smart. That's why you think
- 1:28:49Speaker 3: we should hollow out our brains and and just go
- 1:28:53Speaker 3: by faith.
- 1:28:54Speaker 2: It's galling, and.
- 1:28:58Speaker 1: He asks any thought any slam in the twenty first century,
- 1:29:01Speaker 1: Are there any glimmers of rationality the Middle East that
- 1:29:05Speaker 1: get lost in the headlines or is it really close
- 1:29:07Speaker 1: to hopeless?
- 1:29:13Speaker 2: You know more about this one than I do around
- 1:29:15Speaker 2: I nothing comes to mind except the You know, if
- 1:29:21Speaker 2: it were five if it were five years ago, i'd
- 1:29:23Speaker 2: have said people like Ironhurst Cyli.
- 1:29:26Speaker 3: Who've managed to escape it and find find a refuge
- 1:29:33Speaker 3: in the West and do activism on behalf of the West.
- 1:29:37Speaker 3: And there are still others like her that are still
- 1:29:40Speaker 3: sticking to that. They just they don't have the notoriety
- 1:29:43Speaker 3: that she did. Some of them are, you know, feel
- 1:29:45Speaker 3: really betrayed by what she did rightly, So.
- 1:29:50Speaker 1: I mean, you need people. The Gold Revolution, I think
- 1:29:54Speaker 1: is the best thing coming out of the Muslim worlds,
- 1:29:57Speaker 1: the rising up against the Iranian regime, showing unbelievably courage
- 1:30:05Speaker 1: and rejecting kind of at least their interpretation of Islam.
- 1:30:08Speaker 1: Whether they whether they have anything positive to offer is
- 1:30:11Speaker 1: not clear, but at least they want the West and
- 1:30:14Speaker 1: they're rejecting their version. You know, there's a certain element
- 1:30:20Speaker 1: of Saudi and the Gulf States. There's still authoritarian there's
- 1:30:25Speaker 1: still horrible but it seems like islam ka religion is
- 1:30:29Speaker 1: playing a smaller role in their cultures than it did
- 1:30:32Speaker 1: ten years ago. And I don't know if that continues.
- 1:30:36Speaker 1: I don't know if that's permanent. I don't know exactly
- 1:30:38Speaker 1: if that's a trend, but it might be, and we'll
- 1:30:42Speaker 1: have to wait and see and see where it goes.
- 1:30:45Speaker 1: And as long as the authoritarian it had, you know,
- 1:30:49Speaker 1: they're problematic no matter what.
- 1:30:51Speaker 2: So and one thing I will say is that.
- 1:30:57Speaker 3: This is a question we shouldn't even have to be
- 1:31:00Speaker 3: worrying about, because you know, we for twenty four years now,
- 1:31:08Speaker 3: we've had the chance to strike a blow, you know,
- 1:31:13Speaker 3: in response to the attacks of September eleventh, and Iran
- 1:31:17Speaker 3: would be a good candidate for it, but we just
- 1:31:22Speaker 3: America's really lost its self esteem after nine to eleven.
- 1:31:27Speaker 3: And I'm actually go maybe be talking about this in
- 1:31:29Speaker 3: part at my Ocon talk this summer, theme of which
- 1:31:35Speaker 3: is why we need to declare independence from altruism. And
- 1:31:39Speaker 3: there's there's this phenomenon where when we we don't do
- 1:31:45Speaker 3: what we know we need to do on egoistic moral grounds,
- 1:31:50Speaker 3: it's it's quite depressing. On some level, we know we've
- 1:31:54Speaker 3: failed ourselves, and so we have to come up with rationalizations.
- 1:32:00Speaker 3: We have to, like we're not actually such suckers as
- 1:32:04Speaker 3: that it's really somebody else's fault. It's the immigrant's fault,
- 1:32:10Speaker 3: it's it's the fault of you know, the big tech.
- 1:32:14Speaker 3: And there's so many different ways in which we've resorted
- 1:32:17Speaker 3: to blaming others for our own failures to mask that
- 1:32:21Speaker 3: underlying lack of self esteem that comes from such a
- 1:32:25Speaker 3: failure as failing to respond properly to nine to eleven.
- 1:32:28Speaker 2: I think we're talking about JD. Vance. He's an interesting
- 1:32:32Speaker 2: example of this as well.
- 1:32:34Speaker 3: And there's a whole cohort of his his peers who
- 1:32:38Speaker 3: are now in power, who him and Tulsea Gabbert and
- 1:32:42Speaker 3: Pete Hegseth, who are all veterans of you know, the
- 1:32:46Speaker 3: various wars on terrorism so called, and who went into
- 1:32:49Speaker 3: those wars gung ho patriotic Americans who came out of
- 1:32:53Speaker 3: them completely demoralized by our obvious failure. And they each
- 1:33:01Speaker 3: responded in different ways, but common to all three of
- 1:33:04Speaker 3: them is this real skepticism about the possibility of actually
- 1:33:09Speaker 3: exerting American values on.
- 1:33:11Speaker 2: The world stage.
- 1:33:12Speaker 3: And it's just this, it's this retrenchment and defensiveness. And
- 1:33:17Speaker 3: they each come up with different and defense values as
- 1:33:21Speaker 3: a result.
- 1:33:21Speaker 2: Of it, But it's the root is the same.
- 1:33:24Speaker 3: And I mean, you're seeing this generation of people who
- 1:33:28Speaker 3: who were in the military in that period now assuming
- 1:33:30Speaker 3: roles of leadership, and you see the kind of response
- 1:33:33Speaker 3: that it's engendering and absolutely, one way or another, this
- 1:33:36Speaker 3: retrenchment from the world rather than asserting ourselves properly.
- 1:33:41Speaker 2: And in all cases it's because.
- 1:33:42Speaker 3: They are all They all lack any kind of real
- 1:33:46Speaker 3: alternatives with the Christian values they've been taught.
- 1:33:48Speaker 2: That they don't want to challenge that. That's not why
- 1:33:51Speaker 2: we refuse to fight. It's not because we're supposed to
- 1:33:54Speaker 2: be peacemakers. That wasn't our failure. It was something else.
- 1:33:56Speaker 2: It had to be something else. So please don't make
- 1:33:59Speaker 2: me admit that is that?
- 1:34:01Speaker 1: Yep? All right, rich it asks I'm taking objectivism through
- 1:34:07Speaker 1: Ironman's fiction and speculated uesed that's an AARU and speculated
- 1:34:13Speaker 1: about Anthem being a sequel to Atlas Shrugged set in
- 1:34:17Speaker 1: a dystopian world far from Atlantis.
- 1:34:20Speaker 2: What do you think, Well, first thumbs up on taking
- 1:34:25Speaker 2: the objectives and through Ironman. Of course, that's of course.
- 1:34:27Speaker 3: I'm helping to teach at the Iman University. I think
- 1:34:31Speaker 3: one of the sponsors of this program and the Areus
- 1:34:35Speaker 3: educational program offered by Aari that anybody here should should
- 1:34:39Speaker 3: consider enrolling in, either as a graded student or as
- 1:34:42Speaker 3: an auditor constantly growing program which we were all very
- 1:34:47Speaker 3: excited about it. ARII Anthem has sequeled out the Shrugg.
- 1:34:52Speaker 3: It might be fun to think about it. Obviously, she
- 1:34:55Speaker 3: wrote it well before Out the Shrugged. I don't think
- 1:34:58Speaker 3: she had anything of atlass in her in her mind
- 1:35:03Speaker 3: yet when she wrote it. But you know, just if
- 1:35:07Speaker 3: you're kind of thinking of things in fan fiction fan
- 1:35:10Speaker 3: fiction universe, he.
- 1:35:11Speaker 2: Might he might think of it that way. Although then
- 1:35:15Speaker 2: at the Shrugged.
- 1:35:19Speaker 3: That would be very unfortunate, right, because it suggests that
- 1:35:22Speaker 3: when Gold goes back to the world at the end
- 1:35:24Speaker 3: of Outlast, that he fails, and then Anthem is the
- 1:35:26Speaker 3: sequel to it. So I'd rather think of if I'm
- 1:35:29Speaker 3: gonna write fan fiction to Atlas, it's it's the it's the.
- 1:35:32Speaker 2: One where you know he succeeds, and not where it
- 1:35:35Speaker 2: turns into the world of Anthem.
- 1:35:39Speaker 1: Justin has thoughts on Ian's conversion to Christianity. We've talked
- 1:35:42Speaker 1: a little bit about that already. Anything else you want
- 1:35:45Speaker 1: to say about that, justin it's in the beginning of
- 1:35:49Speaker 1: the show. You probably came late.
- 1:35:51Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, one thing I get add is that
- 1:35:53Speaker 2: she did this.
- 1:35:55Speaker 3: She did this event with Dawkins, a dissident Dialogue UGGS
- 1:36:00Speaker 3: event in New York back in spring, and it was
- 1:36:04Speaker 3: one of the places where you saw Dawkins where the
- 1:36:10Speaker 3: chickens were coming home to roost for him. He's been
- 1:36:12Speaker 3: advocating for intellectual humility all this time. And now Ian
- 1:36:16Speaker 3: hers Is asked, why did you convert to Christianity? And
- 1:36:20Speaker 3: she says, you know, I was one of these atheists.
- 1:36:22Speaker 3: I was really arrogant, and now I've had to get
- 1:36:25Speaker 3: down on my knees and be humble and accept as the.
- 1:36:29Speaker 2: Lord is my God.
- 1:36:31Speaker 3: And Dawkins says nothing to say to that. He can't
- 1:36:35Speaker 3: how can he respond to that everything he said? So
- 1:36:37Speaker 3: it's a case where these ideas that even the best
- 1:36:40Speaker 3: of the atheists have accepted are really kind of neutering
- 1:36:43Speaker 3: their ability to respond to these kinds of criticisms. And
- 1:36:49Speaker 3: so I'm going to see her debate on Thursday in Austin,
- 1:36:55Speaker 3: and it'll be interesting to see what people like Shermer
- 1:36:58Speaker 3: and Corolla can say against her. I'm not hopeful that
- 1:37:01Speaker 3: they're gonna be able to challenge her at any kind
- 1:37:02Speaker 3: of fundamental level.
- 1:37:03Speaker 1: No, unfortunately, not justin asks Ben, what are your thoughts
- 1:37:09Speaker 1: on Peter Teal's justification for Christianity. He's a smart person.
- 1:37:15Speaker 3: I mean, beyond what we already talked about with regard
- 1:37:17Speaker 3: to Girard and his invocation of Girard. I don't have
- 1:37:21Speaker 3: much more to say. I haven't read enough of what
- 1:37:24Speaker 3: Teal said to justify it. I mean, do you know
- 1:37:28Speaker 3: do you know any more of it about it?
- 1:37:29Speaker 1: No? But I mean I know Peter, I know Teal.
- 1:37:32Speaker 1: I mean, he's been a Christian forever. It's just that
- 1:37:35Speaker 1: it's bubbled up into the soface the last few years.
- 1:37:37Speaker 1: But I've known him since two thousand and eight, two
- 1:37:41Speaker 1: thousand and eight, about two thousand and eight and nine,
- 1:37:44Speaker 1: and he's always been a Christian. He's always been known
- 1:37:46Speaker 1: to be a Christian, at least in certain circles. I
- 1:37:49Speaker 1: don't think this is new. I don't think he suddenly
- 1:37:51Speaker 1: discovered Christianity. I think it's been part of who he
- 1:37:53Speaker 1: is for a very long time. He maybe discovered Gerard
- 1:37:56Speaker 1: when he was a Stanford and has been since he
- 1:37:58Speaker 1: was a student at Stanford. Maybe that's the source he was.
- 1:38:01Speaker 1: Also he's also gay and very promiscuous, at least was
- 1:38:05Speaker 1: very promiscuse for a while, the famous parties that he'd
- 1:38:08Speaker 1: have and yet still a Catholic, and there was always
- 1:38:11Speaker 1: whispering about that and how that worked. But you know,
- 1:38:16Speaker 1: but this is there's a bigause. There's another confusion he adjusted,
- 1:38:19Speaker 1: which I think is very revealing because I see it
- 1:38:21Speaker 1: all the time on the chat here. He's very smart.
- 1:38:26Speaker 1: So was Augustine. I'm sure Augustine was super smart. So
- 1:38:30Speaker 1: is so a lot of I mean, Hitler is probably smart.
- 1:38:34Speaker 1: Uh Stalin was probably smart. Lenin certainly was the fact
- 1:38:39Speaker 1: that you're smart means nothing in in terms of morality
- 1:38:44Speaker 1: and even in terms of the ideology you hold. People
- 1:38:47Speaker 1: can hold really evil ideologies and be incredibly smart. And
- 1:38:51Speaker 1: in terms of IQ or however you want to measure smart,
- 1:38:53Speaker 1: So don't confuse people seem to be how could he
- 1:38:57Speaker 1: do this? He's smart? I mean, this is the all
- 1:38:59Speaker 1: of ideas ideas of what man are not you IQ.
- 1:39:03Speaker 2: That does give me something to add, which is Augustine's
- 1:39:07Speaker 2: an interesting case here.
- 1:39:08Speaker 3: He's absolutely super smart. I mean, if you look at
- 1:39:12Speaker 3: his collected works, you couldn't even begin to broach them.
- 1:39:16Speaker 3: They are multiple shelves of volumes. And so I read
- 1:39:24Speaker 3: The City of God, and one thing I found particularly
- 1:39:28Speaker 3: impressive about it just from a pure smart perspective. So
- 1:39:33Speaker 3: here's a guy who really knows his Bible. Plus he
- 1:39:36Speaker 3: knows all the contradictions in the Bible. He knows all
- 1:39:38Speaker 3: the kind of standard arguments that pagans make about the
- 1:39:41Speaker 3: various contradictions between various passages. He knows them all, and he's.
- 1:39:44Speaker 2: Got answers to each and every one of them. And
- 1:39:46Speaker 2: you know, they're all rationalizations, they're all you know, invoking
- 1:39:50Speaker 2: faulty distinctions and methods of interpretation, but you know they're clever.
- 1:39:55Speaker 3: And so yeah, he's absolutely smart. And what that means
- 1:39:59Speaker 3: is is smart people who have irrational ideas that they
- 1:40:02Speaker 3: want to defend and rationalize are then able to, you know,
- 1:40:05Speaker 3: resort to all kinds of tricky techniques to engage in
- 1:40:08Speaker 3: that rationalization.
- 1:40:10Speaker 2: And that's that's the that's.
- 1:40:12Speaker 3: The story of the history of philosophy, is that people
- 1:40:17Speaker 3: who have some free occupation, some kind of you know,
- 1:40:20Speaker 3: irrational supposition that they really want to stick with for
- 1:40:22Speaker 3: whatever reason they were raised with it. It serves some
- 1:40:26Speaker 3: insecurity of theirs, and they build up this whole system
- 1:40:30Speaker 3: to accommodate it. And read Iran's essay Philosophical Detection. The
- 1:40:34Speaker 3: major one of the major themes in that essay is
- 1:40:38Speaker 3: systems of sorry. Irrational philosophies are systems of rationalization. And
- 1:40:42Speaker 3: so if you've got something you want to rationalize, you're
- 1:40:44Speaker 3: smarts are going to help you. They're going to help
- 1:40:46Speaker 3: you assemble that irrational system to make sense of it.
- 1:40:50Speaker 3: I mean, someone like Kant, because he wants to preserve
- 1:40:54Speaker 3: Christian morality in the face of the of the Enlightenment,
- 1:40:57Speaker 3: because you know he's raised by this in this Pietist
- 1:40:59Speaker 3: luth In track where he just can't.
- 1:41:02Speaker 2: Quite give it all up, assembles this whole system to
- 1:41:05Speaker 2: the point of, you.
- 1:41:06Speaker 3: Know, positing whole new dimensions of reality to make sense
- 1:41:10Speaker 3: of how you can reconcile a Christian categorical imperative morality
- 1:41:15Speaker 3: with an Enlightenment worldview. You've got to have a nouminal
- 1:41:18Speaker 3: realm that makes you know that that categorical imperative comes
- 1:41:21Speaker 3: from because you can't reconcile it with the phenomenal world
- 1:41:24Speaker 3: where only hypothetical imperatives exists. So like the whole dimension
- 1:41:28Speaker 3: of reality has to posit using his brain, very good brain.
- 1:41:31Speaker 2: To do that. Rationalization knows no boundaries in the mental sphere.
- 1:41:39Speaker 1: All right, we still have a lot of questions. I'll
- 1:41:41Speaker 1: be all right with that. Yeah, all right. Collectivists can
- 1:41:45Speaker 1: conceive of individual purpose and thus turned to a meaning
- 1:41:49Speaker 1: of life that is dependent oriented. The rejection of Rand
- 1:41:54Speaker 1: is that of individualism, which creates a spiritual void that
- 1:41:58Speaker 1: needs filling. Thoughts.
- 1:42:03Speaker 3: I'm not sure it's the rejection of Rand that creates
- 1:42:06Speaker 3: the spiritual void. I mean, there's a void that a
- 1:42:10Speaker 3: rational philosophy could have filled. The question is why do
- 1:42:15Speaker 3: they reject that way to fill it? And I don't
- 1:42:21Speaker 3: think it's that they can't conceive of individual purpose or
- 1:42:26Speaker 3: a meaning of life that's dependent on it. It's a
- 1:42:30Speaker 3: very easy thing to conceive of, and you offer it
- 1:42:32Speaker 3: to people all the time who make this argument you
- 1:42:36Speaker 3: can't have a meaning of life without God. They're just
- 1:42:39Speaker 3: not impressed, or at least not impressed enough to give
- 1:42:42Speaker 3: up the preoccupations that they've been raised with. There is
- 1:42:49Speaker 3: a and this goes back to the conversation about you
- 1:42:51Speaker 3: know what to what degree intellectual honesty is involved in
- 1:42:56Speaker 3: rejecting religion. You know, you do have to reject a
- 1:42:58Speaker 3: lot of things you've been raised to believe, and that
- 1:43:01Speaker 3: implies rejecting a lot of people who've told you to
- 1:43:06Speaker 3: believe these things. You have to say to them that
- 1:43:09Speaker 3: you think that they're wrong, and that takes some honesty.
- 1:43:12Speaker 3: It takes not like the most courage in the world,
- 1:43:15Speaker 3: but it takes it takes a little bit of courage.
- 1:43:17Speaker 3: And so the question is why didn't reject man in
- 1:43:21Speaker 3: the first place? And there might be a few cases
- 1:43:23Speaker 3: where she's too sophisticated for them, they don't quite get it.
- 1:43:27Speaker 3: I don't think that's usually the case. It's usually the
- 1:43:30Speaker 3: case that there's they don't want to if they understand
- 1:43:33Speaker 3: what she's saying. I think they just they don't want
- 1:43:37Speaker 3: to take that extra step that does involve, you know,
- 1:43:41Speaker 3: breaking with the world to some extent.
- 1:43:43Speaker 2: And so, you know, this is in a way the
- 1:43:46Speaker 2: lesson about the shrugged. The lesson is not you should.
- 1:43:49Speaker 3: You should you know, get your buddies and go live
- 1:43:52Speaker 3: in a mountain valley somewhere where you're gonna escape from
- 1:43:55Speaker 3: the world. But the lesson is, yeah, you have to
- 1:43:57Speaker 3: go on strike against the culture to some extent. And
- 1:43:59Speaker 3: that doesn't mean that you are constantly denouncing everybody that
- 1:44:02Speaker 3: you meet, but it does mean that you're you're going
- 1:44:04Speaker 3: to break with them on key issues.
- 1:44:06Speaker 2: You're going to go on strike culturally against them.
- 1:44:08Speaker 3: And that that means, uh, you know, living with some
- 1:44:12Speaker 3: distance from the rest of society on certain key issues,
- 1:44:15Speaker 3: and that takes some it takes some bravery.
- 1:44:19Speaker 1: Kok asks do you guys know of any good books
- 1:44:22Speaker 1: or resources and the impact that religion has had on
- 1:44:25Speaker 1: politics and the conservative movement?
- 1:44:29Speaker 2: Oh, I don't know. If you need a book to
- 1:44:37Speaker 2: know about it, it's it's there.
- 1:44:42Speaker 3: I mean, there probably are books on this, but it's
- 1:44:44Speaker 3: I don't know of them. It's you'd want to study
- 1:44:52Speaker 3: mid to late twentieth century Republican politics and just see
- 1:44:57Speaker 3: how there's a you know, temporary alliance between the free
- 1:45:04Speaker 3: market types and the religious types. They see a common
- 1:45:08Speaker 3: enemy in the Soviet Union because the Soviet Unions both
- 1:45:11Speaker 3: communists and atheist, and so there's this accidental fact of
- 1:45:16Speaker 3: history that puts them into a temporary alliance together. And
- 1:45:19Speaker 3: then well, what happens when the Soviets disappear. There's no
- 1:45:25Speaker 3: longer a reason for that alliance, and that's the point
- 1:45:28Speaker 3: at which it starts to break down. And then free
- 1:45:30Speaker 3: market types get kicked out. Religious ones are left. They
- 1:45:35Speaker 3: can't distinguish themselves from the left wing anymore on the
- 1:45:42Speaker 3: grounds of free markets then, because they've kicked the free
- 1:45:44Speaker 3: market types out.
- 1:45:45Speaker 2: So yeah, I don't. I can't think of a good book.
- 1:45:49Speaker 2: But maybe.
- 1:45:53Speaker 1: Justin Elon Muskus frequently articulated the importance of splace exploration
- 1:45:58Speaker 1: in preserving and expanding human consciousness. Is that a rational pursuit?
- 1:46:05Speaker 3: Well, first, i'd have to know what he means by
- 1:46:07Speaker 3: that to be able to what Musk means by it,
- 1:46:10Speaker 3: to be able to comment on it. I'm not sure
- 1:46:13Speaker 3: what he means. To the extent that I've been able
- 1:46:16Speaker 3: to make any sense of it. I think that Musk
- 1:46:20Speaker 3: is coming from I mean, he's been influenced by the
- 1:46:22Speaker 3: effective altruists. He's been influenced by the long term mist
- 1:46:26Speaker 3: effective altruists who are utilitarians, who think that the imperative
- 1:46:34Speaker 3: of all of our moral action needs to be not
- 1:46:38Speaker 3: to save people who are starving, you know, in other
- 1:46:41Speaker 3: countries right now, but to maximize the greatest happiness the
- 1:46:46Speaker 3: greatest number of conscious beings who are alive a million
- 1:46:50Speaker 3: years from now, probably living on other planets. Many of
- 1:46:53Speaker 3: them are artificial intelligence, and we need to build rockets
- 1:46:58Speaker 3: so that we can get consciousness into outer space so
- 1:47:00Speaker 3: that this greatest quantity will be maximized. This is the
- 1:47:04Speaker 3: Nick Bostrom idea in this book Superintelligence, and Musk is
- 1:47:08Speaker 3: influenced by that, and so to the extent that I
- 1:47:12Speaker 3: can make any sense of what he's talking about, it's
- 1:47:14Speaker 3: this wacky long termists effective altruist idea, which is I've
- 1:47:21Speaker 3: written articles about it. You know itself has a kind
- 1:47:23Speaker 3: of religious motivation to it at base. You know, Roone,
- 1:47:29Speaker 3: we were talking about religion in Silicon Valley, and you know,
- 1:47:34Speaker 3: in the specific form of Christianity.
- 1:47:35Speaker 2: But there are all these other versions of it that
- 1:47:38Speaker 2: have been come up in the Bay Area.
- 1:47:41Speaker 3: I don't know if you heard the latest about the
- 1:47:43Speaker 3: latest offshoot of the rationalist effective altruist movement, the Zizians
- 1:47:48Speaker 3: who are A who are A They've been kicked out
- 1:47:52Speaker 3: because they advocate violence in pursuit of their vegan objectives,
- 1:47:58Speaker 3: and a bunch of them just got arrested from.
- 1:48:00Speaker 2: Order in Western Maryland.
- 1:48:01Speaker 3: Really on this Wall Street Journal article about this, so,
- 1:48:04Speaker 3: I mean they're kind of an offshoot of the Eliazier Yeddkowski.
- 1:48:09Speaker 2: Aspect of the rational movement.
- 1:48:10Speaker 3: He's the one who says around of times saying we
- 1:48:13Speaker 3: should bomb GPUs because because they're going to give rise
- 1:48:17Speaker 3: to this artificial intelligence that's going to kill us all.
- 1:48:19Speaker 3: And I guess some people are starting to act on that,
- 1:48:22Speaker 3: on this, you know, in further imitation of their religious
- 1:48:26Speaker 3: four bears.
- 1:48:30Speaker 1: H Let's see, Gail, it seems picking a belief is
- 1:48:34Speaker 1: like picking a dessert off a menu. It has nothing
- 1:48:37Speaker 1: to do with reality. But it's almost like you, most
- 1:48:41Speaker 1: of these people are born with it, with exception of
- 1:48:43Speaker 1: these convoted Catholics, almost all of them.
- 1:48:45Speaker 3: Yeah, that's important, and that was something I want to
- 1:48:47Speaker 3: say about the one of the earlier questions about what why,
- 1:48:50Speaker 3: How does Teal justify it? Justify suggests he's made this
- 1:48:57Speaker 3: conscious decision to you, He's surveyed all the iff items
- 1:49:00Speaker 3: on the menu. How do I justify this one? Why
- 1:49:04Speaker 3: this and not all the others? And it's just so
- 1:49:07Speaker 3: rarely the case that that's the way it works. It
- 1:49:10Speaker 3: is so much more often they're raised in a certain
- 1:49:12Speaker 3: religious tradition, and they'll give they'll come up with reasons
- 1:49:17Speaker 3: to justify it, you know, ex post facto, retroactively justify it.
- 1:49:22Speaker 3: I'm in this religion because such and such argument for
- 1:49:25Speaker 3: the existence of God. It wasn't these arguments that led
- 1:49:27Speaker 3: them to believe in God in the first place. These
- 1:49:29Speaker 3: are after the fact rationalizations that they tell themselves to
- 1:49:34Speaker 3: try to excuse the fact that they know that they're
- 1:49:36Speaker 3: believing in for irrational reasons. Please, please don't let me
- 1:49:40Speaker 3: realize that that's why I'm believing it. I'm only believing
- 1:49:43Speaker 3: it because I was raising a certain tribe. This is
- 1:49:44Speaker 3: what my parents believe. I was afraid to challenge them,
- 1:49:47Speaker 3: and so here's my official justification. And so yeah, it's
- 1:49:52Speaker 3: not usually that they're picking something off of menu. They
- 1:49:54Speaker 3: usually they haven't shopped around at all. And that was like,
- 1:49:57Speaker 3: that was the thing that I realized when I was seventeen, Like,
- 1:50:00Speaker 3: I haven't shopped around for this religion. I haven't done
- 1:50:03Speaker 3: any comparison to comparative shopping. This is I'm just taking
- 1:50:06Speaker 3: what it's been given to me.
- 1:50:07Speaker 2: And that's not a good enough reason I should I
- 1:50:09Speaker 2: should drop it.
- 1:50:10Speaker 1: Yep, Nrik's valuable conversation. Thank you, Thanks Enric Michael. Amazing
- 1:50:18Speaker 1: how doctor Peacock was able to make such an accurate prediction.
- 1:50:22Speaker 1: DIM is unfolding by a new front of US. I
- 1:50:25Speaker 1: don't know if you want to comments on that.
- 1:50:30Speaker 3: There's certainly persuasive arguments in DIM about how the left
- 1:50:38Speaker 3: is in so far as the left represents his category
- 1:50:42Speaker 3: of his d category, the disintegrated category, they're they're intimate,
- 1:50:47Speaker 3: they're they're impotent because they lack any kind of ideological
- 1:50:52Speaker 3: principles that would that would help give people guidance in life.
- 1:50:56Speaker 3: And you know, to some extent they do have those
- 1:50:58Speaker 3: those principles, and then they turn into you know, leftist
- 1:51:02Speaker 3: secular kinds of religion. But otherwise, yeah, it's it's secular
- 1:51:06Speaker 3: culture is generally bereft of any kind of integrating principles,
- 1:51:10Speaker 3: and then people end up defaulting.
- 1:51:11Speaker 2: Back into religion.
- 1:51:12Speaker 3: And his point there, which I found very plausible, was,
- 1:51:16Speaker 3: you know, religion rules Western culture for thousands of years.
- 1:51:20Speaker 3: When the Communists come into power, they get seventy and
- 1:51:22Speaker 3: then they're out because you know, they make promises for
- 1:51:26Speaker 3: what's going to be delivered on earth, and they can't.
- 1:51:27Speaker 2: The promises are not delivered.
- 1:51:29Speaker 3: But religious thinkers can promise the afterlife, and nobody's ever
- 1:51:34Speaker 3: going to be able to falsify that. And they can
- 1:51:36Speaker 3: keep making that promise and keep holding on to power
- 1:51:38Speaker 3: and and and so that's why it's it's a it's
- 1:51:42Speaker 3: a really convenient form of default.
- 1:51:48Speaker 1: It's so analytic, synthetic, the economy. He asks, well, it's
- 1:51:52Speaker 1: not a questions. I don't know what it is. You
- 1:51:55Speaker 1: can't refute the two best arguments for religion. The first
- 1:52:00Speaker 1: is the theological political problem, and the second is the
- 1:52:06Speaker 1: noble lie.
- 1:52:08Speaker 2: I don't know what he means by the theological political argument.
- 1:52:13Speaker 3: Ah, the noble lie. What he might be referring to
- 1:52:19Speaker 3: there is something like and you do you do hear
- 1:52:23Speaker 3: a lot of I mean, this is it's more or
- 1:52:28Speaker 3: less what Jordan Peterson says, we've we've maybe there's not
- 1:52:32Speaker 3: a literal truths religion, but people have to believe something.
- 1:52:36Speaker 3: They need some kind of values if they if they
- 1:52:39Speaker 3: don't have religion, they'll turn into nehilistic animals. And so
- 1:52:45Speaker 3: people need religion. And it's that's kind of a noble lie.
- 1:52:50Speaker 3: And there's a core of truth to it. Which is
- 1:52:53Speaker 3: people need guidance. But the idea that atheism is only
- 1:52:59Speaker 3: for smart people and everybody else will turn into an
- 1:53:01Speaker 3: animal is uh, it's.
- 1:53:05Speaker 2: So insulting to human nature.
- 1:53:07Speaker 3: I mean, yeah, if you believe in some secular version
- 1:53:10Speaker 3: of original sin where you have to be smart enough
- 1:53:13Speaker 3: to be honest about the world, and nobody nobody is
- 1:53:17Speaker 3: Nobody is that smarter, nobody is that honest by default. Okay,
- 1:53:20Speaker 3: but I think I think honest people don't need to
- 1:53:23Speaker 3: be super smart to reject delusions, and they don't need
- 1:53:27Speaker 3: to be super smart to live an honest life. Uh
- 1:53:32Speaker 3: so they don't need delusions to do that either.
- 1:53:39Speaker 1: Tracticus Theological Politicus liberate the individual man from bondage to superstition.
- 1:53:46Speaker 2: I don't know.
- 1:53:49Speaker 1: The debate about the relationship between religion and politics.
- 1:53:54Speaker 2: Is follow up.
- 1:53:55Speaker 1: He knows it has to do with spin and I'm
- 1:53:56Speaker 1: just reading. I just put it into Google to see
- 1:53:59Speaker 1: what will come.
- 1:54:00Speaker 3: I mean, Spinoza's major treatise is the Theological Political tract
- 1:54:05Speaker 3: But I don't know what argument in Spinoza he could
- 1:54:07Speaker 3: be referring to that would be an argument for religion,
- 1:54:11Speaker 3: especially since Spinoza himself is such a critic of so
- 1:54:15Speaker 3: much about conventional religion. I mean, he's he formally believes
- 1:54:20Speaker 3: in God, but he's a pantheist, so you know, it's
- 1:54:24Speaker 3: equates God with nature, that that kind of God he
- 1:54:27Speaker 3: believes in. But you know, he was condemned as a
- 1:54:30Speaker 3: heretic for that because most people read it as a
- 1:54:32Speaker 3: kind of atheism.
- 1:54:33Speaker 1: Oh, he's actually referencing, he says, Heah, he's referencing Leo Strauss.
- 1:54:38Speaker 2: Ah. Well, yeah, Strauss has various versions of noble eye.
- 1:54:44Speaker 2: I don't know what specific No.
- 1:54:47Speaker 1: Even the Theodore theological political.
- 1:54:51Speaker 3: Yeah, I don't know what he means by that in Straus,
- 1:54:52Speaker 3: and I don't know Strauss well enough to the comments. Yeah,
- 1:55:00Speaker 3: tell us what theological political problem from Strauss is, we
- 1:55:02Speaker 3: could comment on.
- 1:55:03Speaker 1: The theological political problem is a concept that Leo Strauss
- 1:55:06Speaker 1: used to describe the tension between politics and theology. Strous
- 1:55:10Speaker 1: believed that this tension was a key theme of his
- 1:55:13Speaker 1: intellectual work. That's what AI tells us. This is I
- 1:55:18Speaker 1: guess Google's aa. Yeah, I still don't know enough of
- 1:55:24Speaker 1: really modern attempt to separate theology and politics at devastating consequences,
- 1:55:29Speaker 1: crisis of modernity arose and anyway for another.
- 1:55:33Speaker 2: Time sposed to be an argument for religion.
- 1:55:35Speaker 1: Yeah, it doesn't. See it seems that like a pragmatic again,
- 1:55:39Speaker 1: one of these pragmatic arguments that we need it in
- 1:55:41Speaker 1: order to politically control people. All right, Uh, Andrew, do
- 1:55:54Speaker 1: people really want harmony among men? It seems that people
- 1:55:57Speaker 1: want social conflict because of issues of self stem in
- 1:56:00Speaker 1: addition to conflicting philosophical premises thoughts.
- 1:56:06Speaker 2: Some people want harmony among men, but a lot of
- 1:56:08Speaker 2: them don't. A lot of them want the conflict. I mean,
- 1:56:12Speaker 2: not everybody wants to live. Not everybody, Not everybody is selfish.
- 1:56:16Speaker 2: Is why psychological egoism isn't true. It's one of the
- 1:56:20Speaker 2: major themes about the shrugged. You know, if you wanted to.
- 1:56:28Speaker 3: Push back against what I just said, against the noble,
- 1:56:30Speaker 3: why you could say, uh, yeah, atheism works for honest people,
- 1:56:38Speaker 3: but not for dishonest people. And there's a whole lot
- 1:56:41Speaker 3: of dishonest people in the world who don't really want
- 1:56:43Speaker 3: to live. And yeah, that part's true. It's like, you
- 1:56:46Speaker 3: can't can this dishonest people to believe in rational ideas.
- 1:56:50Speaker 3: I don't think that really matters ultimately historically, because so
- 1:56:53Speaker 3: much history is made by minorities. And if if a
- 1:56:57Speaker 3: minority intellectual leadership has some rational principles, then the dishonest
- 1:57:03Speaker 3: people will follow because they follow whoever's in charge.
- 1:57:07Speaker 2: But that's not an issue of intelligence. That's an issue
- 1:57:09Speaker 2: of honesty.
- 1:57:10Speaker 3: And there's honest people throughout every sector of the culture
- 1:57:13Speaker 3: who could lead it if they wanted to.
- 1:57:17Speaker 1: See he has analytics synthetic Economy's explanation, right, So this
- 1:57:21Speaker 1: is one sentence theological political problem. Theological political problem. Religion
- 1:57:26Speaker 1: can't refute philosophy. Philosophy can't refute religion because both deal
- 1:57:31Speaker 1: with different species of truth, absolute truth versus universal truth.
- 1:57:37Speaker 1: Where do you even want to start.
- 1:57:40Speaker 3: I mean, I'll say the simple thing, which is that
- 1:57:44Speaker 3: on some level that's absolutely true that religion can't refute. Sorry,
- 1:57:53Speaker 3: philosophy can't refute religion. There's a different species of something there.
- 1:57:59Speaker 3: It's called the arbitrary. What religious apologists call a different
- 1:58:07Speaker 3: species of truth is actually stuff that's just made up,
- 1:58:13Speaker 3: stuff that has no actual cognitive value with regard to
- 1:58:17Speaker 3: the only species of reality that there is.
- 1:58:21Speaker 2: There's just one reality.
- 1:58:23Speaker 3: And yeah, you can make stuff up that doesn't fit
- 1:58:25Speaker 3: in any way because it doesn't relate in any way
- 1:58:27Speaker 3: to evidence in this world and say, oh, it's really
- 1:58:30Speaker 3: about some other dimension of reality, and then you can't
- 1:58:32Speaker 3: refute it because it's you can't refute what has no
- 1:58:36Speaker 3: cognitive identity, that's nothing in its favor though.
- 1:58:41Speaker 1: No, and it certainly doesn't make it true. It just
- 1:58:44Speaker 1: makes it makes it just, you know, an arbitrary statement
- 1:58:48Speaker 1: that has no relationship to truth. Why you do intellectuals
- 1:58:55Speaker 1: as justin why do intellectuals choose Catholicism over Protestantism Orthodoxy?
- 1:59:03Speaker 2: I can't comment so much in orthodoxy.
- 1:59:04Speaker 3: I suspect that in the Eastern world they do choose
- 1:59:07Speaker 3: Orthodoxy in that way, even a few in the Western world.
- 1:59:11Speaker 3: But you know, probably it's because of there's a whole
- 1:59:16Speaker 3: intellectual tradition that the Catholics have created, uh, you know,
- 1:59:21Speaker 3: since since the medieval period. And it's so it's a
- 1:59:25Speaker 3: it's just a whole body of work that somebody can
- 1:59:28Speaker 3: you know, grab onto to to rationalize their choice. The
- 1:59:33Speaker 3: Protestants have a body of intellectual work too, it's not
- 1:59:35Speaker 3: as vast, you know, some of them do, like there's
- 1:59:39Speaker 3: there's I've definitely met Protestant converts who dig deep into
- 1:59:47Speaker 3: Protestant theology and are able to make something of it,
- 1:59:50Speaker 3: but it's it's uh yeah, I mean if you're looking
- 1:59:55Speaker 3: to try to sound intellectually respectable, and that is part
- 1:59:59Speaker 3: of what you need.
- 2:00:00Speaker 2: You want to try to.
- 2:00:00Speaker 3: Rationalize this to yourself, like I'm not a dishonest Yahoo,
- 2:00:04Speaker 3: I've got all these centuries of philosophers behind me.
- 2:00:07Speaker 2: I think Catholicism is a good option for that purpose because.
- 2:00:10Speaker 3: It gives you so many different sources of quote unquote
- 2:00:13Speaker 3: intellectually respectable justifications.
- 2:00:16Speaker 1: Do you think Catholicism against the fact that it's, you know,
- 2:00:20Speaker 1: because of a quitness, it has this element of they
- 2:00:27Speaker 1: don't reject reason that you know, everything's based on reason.
- 2:00:30Speaker 1: Why Protestantism is much more emotional based and emotionally argued.
- 2:00:37Speaker 2: Yeah, I think there's really something to that. A Quinas.
- 2:00:44Speaker 3: Is an excellent historical example of an intellectual version of
- 2:00:49Speaker 3: the sanction of the victim, a better person who uses
- 2:00:55Speaker 3: his intellect to excuse the the very people who are
- 2:01:02Speaker 3: victimizing him. And there's like dramatic examples of this in
- 2:01:07Speaker 3: his life story and thereby empowers them for centuries, gives.
- 2:01:15Speaker 2: Them something that if they if there were no quients
- 2:01:18Speaker 2: that nobody had tried. You can't do it.
- 2:01:20Speaker 3: But if nobody had tried to reconcile Christianity with Aristotle
- 2:01:23Speaker 3: and with the achievements of the Greeks, they never would
- 2:01:26Speaker 3: have had the lasting intellectual power that they do. There's
- 2:01:29Speaker 3: many other examples of people like him, and so yeah,
- 2:01:34Speaker 3: there's there's a I'll give you an analogous point. Some
- 2:01:39Speaker 3: friends and I in Austin we recently went to go
- 2:01:42Speaker 3: see a performance of the Austin Opera's rendition of Veriti's Requiem,
- 2:01:48Speaker 3: which is amazing.
- 2:01:50Speaker 2: Piece of music, one of the greatest, and you know,
- 2:01:54Speaker 2: it's great musically, it's you know, high high Italian romanticism,
- 2:02:03Speaker 2: but it's a requie a math and you know, we
- 2:02:07Speaker 2: were watching this as the translations would go across the
- 2:02:11Speaker 2: top of the screen, and you know, it's all the
- 2:02:13Speaker 2: usual text of the Requi a mass, you know, like
- 2:02:16Speaker 2: and so Verdi's most famous piece from that work is
- 2:02:20Speaker 2: the Diazira, just this rousing, energetic piece. But the translation,
- 2:02:25Speaker 2: of course is day.
- 2:02:26Speaker 3: Of Judgment, day of wrath, and it's all like God
- 2:02:29Speaker 3: is going to come punish you all. And you know,
- 2:02:31Speaker 3: one thing to observe as well, That's that's why so
- 2:02:34Speaker 3: many people have a negative view of moral judgment, because
- 2:02:36Speaker 3: they equate it with vengeful God sending you to hell.
- 2:02:40Speaker 3: But on top of that, like, here's one of the
- 2:02:42Speaker 3: greatest Romantic composers of the nineteenth century, and he is
- 2:02:49Speaker 3: lending his talent and his virtue and his art and
- 2:02:52Speaker 3: his beauty to making awe inspiring this.
- 2:02:57Speaker 2: Totally irrational, primitive idea.
- 2:03:00Speaker 3: And there's so many examples of that, not just in
- 2:03:03Speaker 3: the history philosophy, but in the history of art, of
- 2:03:05Speaker 3: really talented, great thinkers and innovators lending their sanction to
- 2:03:12Speaker 3: these ideas that are ultimately at odds with all the
- 2:03:14Speaker 3: beautiful things they create.
- 2:03:16Speaker 1: And with Verdi, it's likely a was an atheist. So yeah,
- 2:03:21Speaker 1: I mean, he's certainly not a religious man. You know, Michaelangelo.
- 2:03:25Speaker 1: You can say it was religious and torn by religions,
- 2:03:27Speaker 1: so but I don't think Verdi was religious at all.
- 2:03:32Speaker 2: That's very interesting, true, Yeah, I mean, but Michaelangel is
- 2:03:34Speaker 2: another great example of that.
- 2:03:39Speaker 1: Jackson says, have you seen the movie Family Man with
- 2:03:44Speaker 1: Nicholas Cage. He rejects his dream job in New York
- 2:03:47Speaker 1: City for his wife and kids in New Jersey, is
- 2:03:51Speaker 1: this Christian view of purpose. Is the differentiation between family
- 2:03:55Speaker 1: man and Korea man a package deal.
- 2:03:58Speaker 2: I haven't seen the movie. The way it's described, it
- 2:04:04Speaker 2: could be.
- 2:04:05Speaker 3: A kind of quasi Christian view, although you know, we
- 2:04:08Speaker 3: had the conversation at the beginning about whether actually carrying
- 2:04:11Speaker 3: about your family even that's something that could be ultimately
- 2:04:15Speaker 3: consistent with the kind of Christian selfless ethic.
- 2:04:18Speaker 2: You know, there is.
- 2:04:20Speaker 3: There is a move in among conservative Christians to take
- 2:04:26Speaker 3: less seriously the values of career and productiveness and regress
- 2:04:31Speaker 3: into medieval collectivism of the family. If that's really what
- 2:04:39Speaker 3: it's going for. There might be an influence there. But
- 2:04:41Speaker 3: you know, i'd have to see the movie, you know,
- 2:04:43Speaker 3: for sure.
- 2:04:46Speaker 1: Rob says hood of Leveyan Satanism, Oh god, yeah, atheist
- 2:04:53Speaker 1: religion copying aspects of Wan mixed with Nietzsche, Spencer Freud
- 2:04:57Speaker 1: and more with a cult psycho drama. Weird.
- 2:05:01Speaker 2: That is, that is a real thing.
- 2:05:03Speaker 3: Anthony Levy is the one who wrote the Satanic Bible
- 2:05:06Speaker 3: in the sixties, and he had a whole cult in
- 2:05:08Speaker 3: San Francisco.
- 2:05:09Speaker 2: And oh yeah, yeah, well the Lave and Satanist did.
- 2:05:14Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, and and there's some you know, attempt
- 2:05:18Speaker 3: to integrate iron Rand in with all that, because she
- 2:05:20Speaker 3: believed in selfishness.
- 2:05:21Speaker 2: But as the question suggests, you know, mixed with Nietzsche
- 2:05:24Speaker 2: and Froud and all this stuff.
- 2:05:25Speaker 3: And so it's taking you know, the bits of Rand
- 2:05:30Speaker 3: that suggest to the incurious reader hedonism and irrationalism and
- 2:05:39Speaker 3: trying to mix it all together. But it's just it's
- 2:05:41Speaker 3: obviously ridiculous because she would have I mean, so LaVey
- 2:05:45Speaker 3: and most Satanists don't actually believe in Satan.
- 2:05:48Speaker 2: They're they're just kind of early trolls where they like to.
- 2:05:55Speaker 3: They're contrarians who like to piss people off for the
- 2:05:58Speaker 3: sake of pissing them off. And so what's a better
- 2:06:00Speaker 3: way is there to you know, piss off your family
- 2:06:03Speaker 3: and say you worship Satan.
- 2:06:05Speaker 2: And this is their way of doing that.
- 2:06:07Speaker 3: And so they take all the contrarian stuff and Rand
- 2:06:09Speaker 3: and the contrarian stuff in nature or whatever, combine it
- 2:06:11Speaker 3: with Satan, and wow, I'll really piss I'll really piss
- 2:06:13Speaker 3: off some people who are Christians. And you know the
- 2:06:17Speaker 3: funny thing is that most Christians take the bait and
- 2:06:19Speaker 3: assume that they really do believe.
- 2:06:20Speaker 2: In Satan, and they don't, but it's I doubt too
- 2:06:24Speaker 2: many of them really do.
- 2:06:27Speaker 1: So Bix and Cole asks, how do we stop our
- 2:06:29Speaker 1: institutions from being ideologically captured by left right extremists.
- 2:06:41Speaker 2: That's a tough one. I mean, one simple thing to
- 2:06:46Speaker 2: say is what is it that causes an institution to
- 2:06:51Speaker 2: be captured by anything? If you if that means anything,
- 2:06:56Speaker 2: if it means like the institution is can permanently captured
- 2:07:03Speaker 2: institutional lead, it's become institutional lies, it's become a matter
- 2:07:07Speaker 2: of legal policy. Well, so many of our institutions where
- 2:07:10Speaker 2: that applies, if it means anything, are ones where there's
- 2:07:13Speaker 2: no free market in alternatives to that institution.
- 2:07:17Speaker 3: I mean, ideologies get entrenched in government universities because there's
- 2:07:24Speaker 3: an establishment that's been established. We read that essay by
- 2:07:28Speaker 3: iron N the establishing of an establishment where you know,
- 2:07:30Speaker 3: once there's a bureaucracy that's enforced by law, then yeah,
- 2:07:34Speaker 3: there's going to be some ideology that dominates it.
- 2:07:38Speaker 2: And so we need freedom to.
- 2:07:41Speaker 3: Disestablish entrenched ideologies. Where we still have it, we should
- 2:07:46Speaker 3: use it. And you know, so it gets entrenched in
- 2:07:49Speaker 3: the universities that are currently running.
- 2:07:51Speaker 2: You can still open up alternative universities. People are doing it.
- 2:07:55Speaker 2: You know, we're setting up the are you at the
- 2:07:57Speaker 2: Iron Institute right now?
- 2:08:00Speaker 3: And so that that's one way to think about it.
- 2:08:03Speaker 3: But you know, obviously that only works to the extent
- 2:08:09Speaker 3: that there's a cultural moment for a better ideology, and
- 2:08:17Speaker 3: so institutions get captured ideologically because a culture has really
- 2:08:21Speaker 3: been captured by an ideology, and our culture is captured.
- 2:08:25Speaker 2: By one or another form of altruism and.
- 2:08:28Speaker 3: Collectivism, and so of course the legal institutions that they
- 2:08:32Speaker 3: set up are going to be doubly captured by that.
- 2:08:35Speaker 3: So that's ultimately why we need to have We need
- 2:08:37Speaker 3: to have ideological change at the level of culture, and
- 2:08:40Speaker 3: to do that you need new institutions where they're still possible.
- 2:08:42Speaker 3: And they are, so let's step them up.
- 2:08:47Speaker 1: Eric says, can you econcile the Department of Justice dropping
- 2:08:52Speaker 1: charges against the corrupt mayor so he will play ball,
- 2:08:56Speaker 1: versus dropping charges against the small time criminal, so he
- 2:09:00Speaker 1: will cooperate. I guess in getting a bigger criminal. I
- 2:09:03Speaker 1: think there's a distinction of it. It's hard to articulate.
- 2:09:07Speaker 2: I assume this is with reference to Eric Adams.
- 2:09:11Speaker 3: H and you to a segment on your show about
- 2:09:15Speaker 3: this recently, your own, which I thought it was pretty good.
- 2:09:18Speaker 3: And you know, what I know about the case is
- 2:09:20Speaker 3: that there's a very there's a big difference in the
- 2:09:22Speaker 3: kind of playing ball that we're talking about here. If
- 2:09:25Speaker 3: it's it's the playing ball of going along with the
- 2:09:29Speaker 3: regime's policy versus cooperating of the small time criminal to
- 2:09:36Speaker 3: do what like to get a criminal criminal, I mean, that's.
- 2:09:40Speaker 2: A legitimate thing if you if you if there's a
- 2:09:42Speaker 2: bigger criminal that you're trying to get him to.
- 2:09:48Speaker 3: Confess about so that we can charge the bigger criminal
- 2:09:51Speaker 3: who poses an actual threat to people's rights, that could
- 2:09:55Speaker 3: be a legitimate strategy. But if it's just I've got
- 2:09:58Speaker 3: a policy that I want to implement, uh, and it's
- 2:10:01Speaker 3: in this case to round up immigrants who are not
- 2:10:03Speaker 3: actually the criminals, that's quite a different thing.
- 2:10:06Speaker 1: Yep, Ben, I think you referenced this to whole ideas
- 2:10:12Speaker 1: against reality, willing time destroy you to continue getting others
- 2:10:17Speaker 1: to believe mysticism shield you from confronting reality.
- 2:10:23Speaker 2: That's the point I did reference that.
- 2:10:25Speaker 3: It's it's it's all over Gault's speech and Outlas Shrugged.
- 2:10:30Speaker 3: You know, the whole second half or last third of
- 2:10:35Speaker 3: that speech. Most objectivists don't read very carefully, if at all.
- 2:10:40Speaker 3: They remember the stuff at the beginning, you know, And
- 2:10:42Speaker 3: in part it is because it's a very long speech,
- 2:10:43Speaker 3: so yep, there's a lot to digest in there. But
- 2:10:47Speaker 3: they people remember the stuff from the beginning where he's
- 2:10:50Speaker 3: laying out kind of the positives of the objectivist ethics
- 2:10:55Speaker 3: and metaphysics, but they kind of get maybe they get
- 2:10:59Speaker 3: tired by the time they get halfway in. And halfway
- 2:11:02Speaker 3: in is the stuff on the psychology of the mystic?
- 2:11:11Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, I think that's part why.
- 2:11:15Speaker 2: There's so much.
- 2:11:16Speaker 3: Juicy stuff in there about why do people adopt altruism,
- 2:11:20Speaker 3: why do they adopt the morality of death? What psychology
- 2:11:23Speaker 3: leads them to that? And you've got to have some
- 2:11:25Speaker 3: theory of that, because they're not adopting it because of
- 2:11:28Speaker 3: any rational arguments, So it's it's because of some kind
- 2:11:33Speaker 3: of psychological corruptions, some kind of irrational do they want
- 2:11:37Speaker 3: to rationalize. And there's there's really amazing stuff in that
- 2:11:41Speaker 3: second half of gold speech about that that more people
- 2:11:43Speaker 3: should really look at. And that's that's one of the points.
- 2:11:48Speaker 1: Hook masked. Ben have you read Paradise Lost? Do you recommend.
- 2:11:52Speaker 2: I've not read much, if any, of Milton. I've heard
- 2:11:57Speaker 2: good things about it.
- 2:12:01Speaker 3: Just you know, the thing, one interesting thing about Milton is,
- 2:12:04Speaker 3: just to connect with our current conversation, is everything I've
- 2:12:09Speaker 3: read about Milton suggests that Satan in Paradise Lost is
- 2:12:15Speaker 3: the more interesting and well developed character. And it says
- 2:12:21Speaker 3: something about the the literary dynamics of heroism that yeah,
- 2:12:29Speaker 3: you can never really project a convincing Christian hero, and
- 2:12:36Speaker 3: so even in a work like Milton. You know, Milton
- 2:12:39Speaker 3: is heavily influenced by the Enlightenment. So that's that's part
- 2:12:42Speaker 3: of what accounts for it, I'm sure, but uh, it's
- 2:12:47Speaker 3: it's you gotta appeal to the guy who's rebelling against
- 2:12:52Speaker 3: Christian dogma if you want to have a convincing kind
- 2:12:55Speaker 3: of hero. And you know, this goes along with Einran's
- 2:12:57Speaker 3: observation that, you know, the best literature that's been written
- 2:13:03Speaker 3: by Christians like Dostoevsky.
- 2:13:06Speaker 2: Even with Dostoyevsky, his heroes are not convincing.
- 2:13:10Speaker 3: Alyosha and Brothers Karamazov, who's supposed to be the embodiment
- 2:13:13Speaker 3: of Christian virtue, he's kind of a flat, unconvincing character.
- 2:13:17Speaker 2: That the villains is are the brothers are the are
- 2:13:20Speaker 2: the better ones, They're.
- 2:13:21Speaker 3: They're more interesting as characters, and she says similar things
- 2:13:24Speaker 3: about the characters in Huko.
- 2:13:28Speaker 1: Justin asked, have you thought, what are your thoughts on
- 2:13:32Speaker 1: race realism?
- 2:13:37Speaker 3: If I understand what that view is, I think it's
- 2:13:42Speaker 3: false and probably just another fancy name for racism. And
- 2:13:50Speaker 3: I know you've done shows on this your own that,
- 2:13:54Speaker 3: like I, I do not think race is a biological
- 2:14:00Speaker 3: category in the way that a species is. It's and
- 2:14:05Speaker 3: you don't need to know too much about the science
- 2:14:07Speaker 3: to see why this is the case. People inherit characteristics
- 2:14:14Speaker 3: from their parents because their parents make a choice to mate,
- 2:14:18Speaker 3: and that's a human choice, who you're going to mate with,
- 2:14:23Speaker 3: and that's a choice. It can be influenced by geographic isolation,
- 2:14:26Speaker 3: it can be influenced by prejudice, it can be influenced
- 2:14:29Speaker 3: by the view that there are biological categories of race.
- 2:14:32Speaker 3: It's like, if you think that this person of this
- 2:14:35Speaker 3: different skin color is a different species than you are
- 2:14:38Speaker 3: because you're a racist, well that will self perpetuate the category.
- 2:14:42Speaker 2: But it's because of an irrational viewpoint.
- 2:14:44Speaker 3: And so the way that leftist theorists talk about this
- 2:14:49Speaker 3: that they say race is social construction. And usually when
- 2:14:53Speaker 3: they talk about social constructions, they're flat out wrong and
- 2:14:57Speaker 3: there's no basis to what they're saying. Well, this is
- 2:14:59Speaker 3: one where you can kind of makes sense of what
- 2:15:00Speaker 3: they're talking about, because the categories of race that exist
- 2:15:04Speaker 3: exist because people have literally constructed them through their reproductive choices.
- 2:15:09Speaker 3: And any time people from different quote unquote races make
- 2:15:12Speaker 3: you get a mix and it is you've destroyed that category.
- 2:15:16Speaker 2: And there's no reason that it has to exist.
- 2:15:19Speaker 1: And so.
- 2:15:22Speaker 3: If I understand race realism to me, and race is
- 2:15:24Speaker 3: a biological category like species, it's just not there's obviously
- 2:15:28Speaker 3: biological dimensions to the there's a biological basis for the
- 2:15:35Speaker 3: white people have the theenotypic characteristics that they do, like
- 2:15:39Speaker 3: you have a certain skin color, because there's some genetic
- 2:15:41Speaker 3: basis to that, but it's not linked to many many
- 2:15:46Speaker 3: other inherited characteristics. There's nothing special about it that forms
- 2:15:51Speaker 3: some kind of natural kind.
- 2:15:54Speaker 1: Yeah, and well, matter is in medicine, for example, in
- 2:15:56Speaker 1: these things, is you know you're link your heritage your
- 2:16:01Speaker 1: DNA heritage, What DNA have you inhabited, not the race
- 2:16:04Speaker 1: that you belong to, because there is no such thing.
- 2:16:08Speaker 1: And and and the doctor can't tell what your races.
- 2:16:10Speaker 1: You can't tell if you mixed and how mixed you
- 2:16:12Speaker 1: are just by looking at you.
- 2:16:15Speaker 2: I remember you did a show once where you talked
- 2:16:16Speaker 2: about the results of your twenty three and mets. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 2:16:22Speaker 2: and lots of lots of different parts of the world
- 2:16:24Speaker 2: coming together.
- 2:16:25Speaker 1: Yeah. And my kids are complete much. I mean, the
- 2:16:27Speaker 1: kids are even more ridiculously all over the place. So yeah,
- 2:16:32Speaker 1: it's it's and and the more the geneticists look at this,
- 2:16:40Speaker 1: the more it turns out that even populations that think
- 2:16:43Speaker 1: that they are pure and untouched, how how mixed they
- 2:16:50Speaker 1: all are. You know, the the South Americans who think
- 2:16:55Speaker 1: they're all you know, they're all originally from Spain, and
- 2:17:00Speaker 1: they've got a big chunk of Native Native American DNA
- 2:17:05Speaker 1: and some black DNA from the slaves, and you know,
- 2:17:09Speaker 1: And it's meaningless. That's the point.
- 2:17:11Speaker 2: The point is it's meaningless, and it's and the whole
- 2:17:13Speaker 2: concept of racial categories.
- 2:17:17Speaker 3: Is very recent. It comes out of the nineteenth century.
- 2:17:22Speaker 3: As all the people who all the theorists who originally
- 2:17:28Speaker 3: devised sets of racial categories that they took to be
- 2:17:31Speaker 3: immutable were all racists.
- 2:17:33Speaker 2: By the kind of standard understanding of the term of racism.
- 2:17:37Speaker 3: That they were devising these categories to try to, you know,
- 2:17:40Speaker 3: justify something special about the tribe they happened to belong to.
- 2:17:44Speaker 3: And this is this is one of the unfortunate outcomes
- 2:17:48Speaker 3: of the Enlightenment, is kind of misunderstanding the nature of
- 2:17:51Speaker 3: science and how to use it properly, and then you
- 2:17:54Speaker 3: kind of try to come up with category systems for
- 2:17:57Speaker 3: things where they don't even apply. In part again, it's
- 2:17:59Speaker 3: because of failure to grapple with the fact of human
- 2:18:01Speaker 3: free will, which the Enlightenment also kind of defaults on.
- 2:18:07Speaker 1: Mark says, welcome back, Ben, looking forward to iron ran
- 2:18:11Speaker 1: Con in Texas this month. Would like he says, you
- 2:18:15Speaker 1: would like to reach out regarding AARI and inviting you
- 2:18:18Speaker 1: as a podcast guest. What's the best way to reach you?
- 2:18:24Speaker 2: I think just send an email to New Ideal at
- 2:18:27Speaker 2: inran dot org, where we where we look at all
- 2:18:30Speaker 2: the email about our podcasting.
- 2:18:32Speaker 1: New Ideal at iran dot oag Matt says, what is
- 2:18:36Speaker 1: the value? What is the value? In philosophical edge cases.
- 2:18:43Speaker 2: H not usually very much. It's it's uh just it's
- 2:18:54Speaker 2: not just philosophical education.
- 2:18:56Speaker 3: And edge case, by its nature is something where it's
- 2:19:00Speaker 3: hard to classify.
- 2:19:02Speaker 2: In any category.
- 2:19:03Speaker 3: If I understand what you mean by an edge case,
- 2:19:06Speaker 3: and so you can think about edge cases, you can think,
- 2:19:10Speaker 3: you can think about how to classify them, and sometimes
- 2:19:12Speaker 3: you just have to make a choice, is what Ironran
- 2:19:14Speaker 3: talks about when she talks about borderline cases and introduction
- 2:19:16Speaker 3: to objectives to pistemology.
- 2:19:19Speaker 2: But if there's anything that.
- 2:19:21Speaker 3: You can learn from them, from the very fact of
- 2:19:24Speaker 3: their existence, well there's the thing, for example, that iron
- 2:19:27Speaker 3: Rand concludes about them in that book, which is that
- 2:19:31Speaker 3: the fact that edu cases exist, the fact that borderline
- 2:19:33Speaker 3: cases exist where it's not obvious which category it goes
- 2:19:36Speaker 3: into it Does it go into category A or does
- 2:19:38Speaker 3: it in the category B?
- 2:19:39Speaker 2: Is it a plant? Is it an animal?
- 2:19:41Speaker 3: Is this red or is this yellow? Somewhere in between
- 2:19:45Speaker 3: you can't really tell is this a male or a female.
- 2:19:47Speaker 3: There's another case of edge cases when you're talking about
- 2:19:49Speaker 3: intersex phenomena. Nature doesn't draw these lines for us. That's
- 2:19:53Speaker 3: why it's an edge case, and so is there a
- 2:19:57Speaker 3: lesson from the fact that nature doesn't draw the lines
- 2:19:59Speaker 3: for us.
- 2:20:00Speaker 2: Well, yes, it's that Plato is wrong.
- 2:20:01Speaker 3: It's that intrinsicism is a false theory of concepts, and
- 2:20:05Speaker 3: we have to draw the lines.
- 2:20:07Speaker 1: Now.
- 2:20:08Speaker 3: The part that that doesn't give you the lesson for
- 2:20:10Speaker 3: us is how to then draw the lines. And you
- 2:20:12Speaker 3: can end up in a kind of subjectivism or a
- 2:20:14Speaker 3: kind of nominalism, or you think, well, there's no lines
- 2:20:16Speaker 3: drawn by nature, so it's just all arbitrary and everything goes.
- 2:20:19Speaker 2: But of course if you then have, you know, do
- 2:20:21Speaker 2: more work like Heinrhan did, and you.
- 2:20:23Speaker 3: Realize, well, okay, nature doesn't draw the lines for us,
- 2:20:26Speaker 3: but we human beings are the line drawers. And there
- 2:20:29Speaker 3: are actually facts about us that are relevant to how
- 2:20:32Speaker 3: we draw them, facts about how much we can take
- 2:20:35Speaker 3: into our consciousness at a given time. And so we
- 2:20:37Speaker 3: need to condense things. We need to reduce the number
- 2:20:39Speaker 3: of units we need unit economy. That's why we need
- 2:20:42Speaker 3: some categories, and so we've got to make we've definitely
- 2:20:44Speaker 3: got to draw some lines, and so we'll use the.
- 2:20:47Speaker 2: Facts that are observable to us.
- 2:20:49Speaker 3: We'll use the biggest, most obvious similarities and differences, and
- 2:20:52Speaker 3: sometimes those won't settle everything for us, at which point
- 2:20:55Speaker 3: we just have to make a choice.
- 2:20:56Speaker 2: But that's not a bug, it's a feature. It's a
- 2:20:59Speaker 2: feature the fact.
- 2:21:00Speaker 3: That our our minds are not ruled by some kind
- 2:21:03Speaker 3: of platonic intrinsic essences that were autonomous beings. And there's
- 2:21:07Speaker 3: facts about us that we have to respect us along
- 2:21:09Speaker 3: with facts in reality. But I strongly recommend looking up
- 2:21:14Speaker 3: Iinran's book Introduction to Objectives to Pistemology and seeing what
- 2:21:16Speaker 3: she says about borderline cases. If if there's ever a
- 2:21:19Speaker 3: lesson to draw from them, it's it's this whole point
- 2:21:22Speaker 3: about theory of concepts and what's what's a good solution
- 2:21:25Speaker 3: to the problem of universals.
- 2:21:30Speaker 1: Let's see why do many Christians refuse to morally judge Trump?
- 2:21:42Speaker 2: Uh?
- 2:21:44Speaker 1: Well, so.
- 2:21:47Speaker 2: There could be lots of reasons.
- 2:21:49Speaker 3: The most you know, the best example of this lately
- 2:21:51Speaker 3: is that is the controversy about Putin and how he
- 2:21:55Speaker 3: wants to call Zelensky a dictator but not Putin. Uh
- 2:21:59Speaker 3: and them is next back to something I raised earlier
- 2:22:01Speaker 3: in the episode that you know, if you've been taught
- 2:22:06Speaker 3: Christian selflessness as your model of morality and Christian selflessness
- 2:22:11Speaker 3: has nothing to do with real life. And so you
- 2:22:13Speaker 3: associate principle with something that's irrelevant to life, you'll not
- 2:22:16Speaker 3: have any principles for dealing with real life. This is
- 2:22:19Speaker 3: the point I get from that section late in golf speech.
- 2:22:22Speaker 3: By the way, we're talking about before, and so you'll
- 2:22:28Speaker 3: think moralities for suckers, and I just need to live,
- 2:22:31Speaker 3: I need to get by. I need to be realistic.
- 2:22:33Speaker 3: Don't judge him, don't make this a matter of principle.
- 2:22:36Speaker 3: And yeah, I'll actually I have it in front of me.
- 2:22:39Speaker 3: I'll read a relevant portion which I tweeted out recently
- 2:22:43Speaker 3: from later in golf speech.
- 2:22:45Speaker 2: It touches on this exactly.
- 2:22:46Speaker 3: You grew up to believe that moral laws bear no
- 2:22:49Speaker 3: relation to the job of living except as an impediment
- 2:22:51Speaker 3: and threat. That man's existence is an amoral jungle where
- 2:22:54Speaker 3: anything goes and anything works in that fog of switching
- 2:22:57Speaker 3: definitions which descends upon a frozen mind. Forgotten that evils
- 2:23:01Speaker 3: damned by your creed were the virtues required for a living,
- 2:23:04Speaker 3: and you've come to believe that actual evils aren't.
- 2:23:06Speaker 2: The practical means of existence. And skipping a little you.
- 2:23:09Speaker 3: Pity the men you admire. You believe they are doomed
- 2:23:11Speaker 3: to fail. You envy them, and you hate. You believe
- 2:23:14Speaker 3: they are the masters of the existence. You feel disarmed
- 2:23:16Speaker 3: when you come up against a scoundrel. You believe that
- 2:23:18Speaker 3: evil's bound to win, since the moral.
- 2:23:20Speaker 2: Is the impotent, the impractical.
- 2:23:22Speaker 3: If that doesn't describe yeah, a lot of conservatives attitude
- 2:23:25Speaker 3: toward Putin these days, including Trump's attitude toward Putin.
- 2:23:30Speaker 2: I don't know what does.
- 2:23:30Speaker 1: Yeah, No, that's brilliant. Stephen Happis says Alma Deutsche's twenty
- 2:23:37Speaker 1: twenty three opera, The Empra's New Waltz satirizes modern, non
- 2:23:42Speaker 1: tonal serious music and failed did box office f to
- 2:23:46Speaker 1: mixed reviews. I was at sellspoke Prima. The audience mostly
- 2:23:50Speaker 1: loved it. I thought it was a big hit. Cool heard.
- 2:23:55Speaker 2: I've heard about Alma Deutscher. I know Stephen's a big fan.
- 2:23:58Speaker 3: I've listened to a little of her ivan listen enough
- 2:24:00Speaker 3: to judge, But it makes sense to me that that's
- 2:24:04Speaker 3: the kind of reception that something like that would get.
- 2:24:09Speaker 3: Any kind of tonality in symphonic music these days is
- 2:24:14Speaker 3: usually greeted with skepticism by realistic critics.
- 2:24:18Speaker 2: And I all know.
- 2:24:20Speaker 3: We go to the symphony a lot here in Austin.
- 2:24:22Speaker 3: We've got a pretty good one, and they One thing
- 2:24:25Speaker 3: I've noticed is they've they've stopped they've stopped doing as
- 2:24:32Speaker 3: much of what symphonies used to do, which is you've
- 2:24:34Speaker 3: got like two or three nice romantic pieces and you
- 2:24:36Speaker 3: can throw in some kind of modern atonalism.
- 2:24:39Speaker 2: They just don't do that as much anymore. It's mostly
- 2:24:41Speaker 2: good music and more people come go.
- 2:24:43Speaker 1: Figure finances speak. Maybe here in Puerto Rico they do
- 2:24:48Speaker 1: better twenty twentieth century. You know, some of the I
- 2:24:52Speaker 1: think South American composes we actually pretty good. So it's
- 2:24:55Speaker 1: not a tonal. It's kind of modern but not etonal.
- 2:24:58Speaker 1: So they feel like they do their piece. We have
- 2:25:02Speaker 1: a decent symphony here in San Juan. Let's see. Desilek
- 2:25:09Speaker 1: says you on you should do an episode with Adam Corola,
- 2:25:13Speaker 1: and then he follows that up with bring Adam Colea on.
- 2:25:18Speaker 1: You have a lot in comments. So Adam Cola had
- 2:25:22Speaker 1: me on his podcast years ago, so a long time ago. Maybe,
- 2:25:27Speaker 1: I don't know, twenty sixteen, twenty seventeen, I don't know,
- 2:25:30Speaker 1: maybe even before that. It was on a show that
- 2:25:34Speaker 1: he did that was behind his firewall, so only paid
- 2:25:36Speaker 1: subscribers could listen to it, and we really didn't hit
- 2:25:41Speaker 1: it off. He was I don't know what it was.
- 2:25:44Speaker 1: He was not funny, but he was like a cynic.
- 2:25:48Speaker 1: He was very cynical. I don't know why he invited
- 2:25:52Speaker 1: me on. I don't think he liked it. I think
- 2:25:56Speaker 1: his staff probably invited me, but he was very cautious.
- 2:26:02Speaker 1: On the one hand, it's like, who is this not
- 2:26:05Speaker 1: the sign man stuff, and very cynical. And I really didn't,
- 2:26:09Speaker 1: you know, really didn't enjoy it, and he didn't and
- 2:26:12Speaker 1: he never had me on again, which is unusual because
- 2:26:15Speaker 1: usually when they're doing interviews they go really well and
- 2:26:19Speaker 1: the host usually has a good time. But it was
- 2:26:22Speaker 1: one of the one of the worst interviews I did,
- 2:26:25Speaker 1: just because of the interaction between us, and then I
- 2:26:27Speaker 1: don't think he'd ever come on my show. I mean,
- 2:26:29Speaker 1: who am I I mean he's He's got millions and
- 2:26:32Speaker 1: millions and millions of followers. It's the same point about
- 2:26:34Speaker 1: interviewing your alone, musk. It's not even an issue of busy,
- 2:26:37Speaker 1: it's just an issue of what do they have to gain,
- 2:26:40Speaker 1: you know, they don't have much to gain by it.
- 2:26:43Speaker 1: So yeah, he would never come on my show.
- 2:26:46Speaker 3: I don't I haven't followed him. I remember back when
- 2:26:49Speaker 3: he was on Love Line. I remember him being the
- 2:26:51Speaker 3: kind of cynic that you mentioned. It doesn't shock me
- 2:26:56Speaker 3: that they asked him to be in this debate about religion, because, yeah,
- 2:27:01Speaker 3: if you want to make atheists look like a bunch
- 2:27:03Speaker 3: of kind of neealistic cynics, why not bringing Adam Carolla
- 2:27:06Speaker 3: and then the other guys will look earnest and principled
- 2:27:10Speaker 3: by comparison.
- 2:27:11Speaker 1: Yep, Justin says is they have a non egalitarian reason
- 2:27:16Speaker 1: to prefer women's sports over men's. I prefer women tennis,
- 2:27:20Speaker 1: even though I know the men tennis players are better.
- 2:27:26Speaker 2: Oh gosh, I don't have much to say on on
- 2:27:29Speaker 2: sports or on philosophy of sports. I don't have myself.
- 2:27:37Speaker 2: I don't prefer women's sports. I don't know.
- 2:27:41Speaker 3: Well, I mean, I like gymnastics, and I much prefer
- 2:27:45Speaker 3: to watch women do gymnastics. And I don't think that's
- 2:27:48Speaker 3: just because I'm a man, So there might be some
- 2:27:52Speaker 3: reasons there.
- 2:27:53Speaker 1: Well, but there's a big difference between women's gymnastic and
- 2:27:55Speaker 1: male gymnastics. Male gymnastics, I mean there's a in the moves,
- 2:27:59Speaker 1: and they in the elegance in the and plus to
- 2:28:03Speaker 1: see these little little right, but these these little goals
- 2:28:09Speaker 1: sometimes do these amazing things versus to see a big
- 2:28:13Speaker 1: hulk of a guy do them. It's like, okay, yeah,
- 2:28:16Speaker 1: you kind of expect.
- 2:28:17Speaker 2: That systhetic issues there that connect to the differences in biology.
- 2:28:20Speaker 1: I'm sure.
- 2:28:22Speaker 3: I do think generally, without commenting on women's sports, that
- 2:28:25Speaker 3: there's there's a whole esthetic dimension to sports.
- 2:28:27Speaker 2: Appreciation that's usually underappreciated.
- 2:28:30Speaker 1: Yep. Uh.
- 2:28:31Speaker 2: And it's you know, what made me realize this was.
- 2:28:39Speaker 3: The controversy over doping in sports, because if you if
- 2:28:44Speaker 3: you just make that contra if it's just a question
- 2:28:46Speaker 3: of like the morality of doping, well, okay, so what
- 2:28:51Speaker 3: if somebody has rules where they say it's fine to
- 2:28:53Speaker 3: use all the drugs that you want in sports?
- 2:28:56Speaker 2: You could do that. That would be uh, that would
- 2:28:58Speaker 2: be legal.
- 2:28:59Speaker 3: It might have self destructive consequences on the athletes, but
- 2:29:04Speaker 3: then against so it does a lot of athletics, right,
- 2:29:06Speaker 3: So what is it about the doped competition versus the
- 2:29:13Speaker 3: non dope competition that we find, you know, disgusting or
- 2:29:18Speaker 3: not appealing.
- 2:29:19Speaker 2: I think it has something to do with the aesthetics
- 2:29:20Speaker 2: of it.
- 2:29:20Speaker 3: It's something to do with the knowledge of what's possible
- 2:29:24Speaker 3: to the human form, you know, through a kind of
- 2:29:29Speaker 3: virtuous practice, as opposed to as opposed to some kind
- 2:29:33Speaker 3: of artificial inducement.
- 2:29:35Speaker 1: I don't know, yep. I definitely think there's an a
- 2:29:40Speaker 1: psthechic aspect to it. So, but it needs more thought
- 2:29:43Speaker 1: and somebody needs to work on that. Nick is outraged.
- 2:29:49Speaker 1: You haven't read Paradise Lost. Sorry Nick, Yeah, Mary Eline says,
- 2:29:55Speaker 1: Satan rocks in Paradise Lost. Yeah. So Aunt Sam says,
- 2:30:02Speaker 1: thank you, Ben, and you on analytics Synthetic economy is back.
- 2:30:06Speaker 1: I think Ben has yet to read Nietzsche's Genealogy of Maraels.
- 2:30:12Speaker 2: I've read it twice.
- 2:30:14Speaker 1: There you go, analytic synthetic diconomy wrong again.
- 2:30:18Speaker 3: And you can see the evidence of this in the
- 2:30:22Speaker 3: talk I gave a few years ago Iran's Genealogy of Altruism,
- 2:30:25Speaker 3: where I compare and contrast her view of the genealogy
- 2:30:29Speaker 3: of altruistic morality to niches.
- 2:30:32Speaker 1: Cool and last question, we have what are your thoughts
- 2:30:36Speaker 1: on Chinas Civil War. Jacob's going to Chunki Schech's memorial today.
- 2:30:43Speaker 1: Tomorrow he's visiting Taiwan. Seems like he lost the war
- 2:30:47Speaker 1: that rather than Mao winning. Do you know anything about
- 2:30:52Speaker 1: Chinese Civil War?
- 2:30:53Speaker 2: I mean the one in the nineteen forties. I know
- 2:30:56Speaker 2: what happened. I'm sorry that the Communists won.
- 2:31:00Speaker 3: I wish that America were more supportive of what became
- 2:31:06Speaker 3: of Shang Kaishek's descendants, which is Taiwan, of course. And
- 2:31:10Speaker 3: I'm afraid about what's going to happen in Taiwan because
- 2:31:14Speaker 3: of what's happening in Ukraine right now, that China is
- 2:31:17Speaker 3: gonna look at that and see, well, this could be
- 2:31:20Speaker 3: a way that we successfully rationalize some kind of aggressive
- 2:31:24Speaker 3: action against Taiwan because the world's not coming to Ukraine's defense.
- 2:31:28Speaker 3: And I don't think that the United States should be
- 2:31:29Speaker 3: fighting on behalf of Ukraine, just to make things clear,
- 2:31:31Speaker 3: but we sure as heck should be morally supporting them.
- 2:31:35Speaker 2: And selling them weapons.
- 2:31:37Speaker 1: Yeah right, uh, okay, one more stuve. The debate is
- 2:31:43Speaker 1: about proving that philosophy can be objective. That is the
- 2:31:47Speaker 1: central point that these religious types fail to see. Do
- 2:31:53Speaker 1: you agree with that it's a.
- 2:31:58Speaker 2: Yeah, that is that is a big part of what
- 2:32:02Speaker 2: they fail to see. They think that.
- 2:32:05Speaker 3: The common refrain is that is that atheists are just
- 2:32:10Speaker 3: religious in their own way, that they're they have faith.
- 2:32:13Speaker 2: And reason or or something like that. And so when
- 2:32:16Speaker 2: you when you stand.
- 2:32:18Speaker 3: On principle in favor of atheism against religion, that's just
- 2:32:23Speaker 3: your own particular kind of faith.
- 2:32:25Speaker 1: Uh.
- 2:32:25Speaker 3: And it's a it's a it's a kind of adolescent,
- 2:32:29Speaker 3: infantile equivocation between faith, which is belief without evidence, and confidence,
- 2:32:39Speaker 3: which is something that you can believe on the.
- 2:32:41Speaker 2: Basis of evidence. And and the better atheists have the
- 2:32:46Speaker 2: latter and not the former.
- 2:32:48Speaker 3: And you can dismiss somebody who alleges something without evidence,
- 2:32:52Speaker 3: but that's because you you have reverence for the work
- 2:32:55Speaker 3: that it takes to do to get knowledge, which which
- 2:32:58Speaker 3: scientists know about.
- 2:33:01Speaker 1: Excellent, Thank you, Ben, We've gone two and a half hours.
- 2:33:07Speaker 1: Always fun.
- 2:33:08Speaker 2: I'll see some of your audience in Austin.
- 2:33:10Speaker 1: Excellent.
- 2:33:11Speaker 3: On Friday, We're we're having the regional conference here and yeah,
- 2:33:16Speaker 3: check me out on Twitter Thursday night when I live
- 2:33:18Speaker 3: tweet the debate about religion also.
- 2:33:21Speaker 2: Here in Austin, Oh, excellent. Good good versus Michael Schumer.
- 2:33:25Speaker 1: All right, well, thanks man, have a good night, bye everybody.
- 2:33:28Speaker 1: I will see you guys tomorrow for another show and
- 2:33:35Speaker 1: uh yeah bye right all right, Where am I going