Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Sam Altman invested in this new Bitcoin Private Credit Fund, Legitimizing BTC | BC Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashton Addison from the Cryptic Coin Show and today i'm Blockchain Interviews with Zach
- 0:04Townsend, CEO and co founder of Meanwhile. Zach, welcome to the show
- 0:08and thanks for taking the time, Thanks for having me. Ashton, very
- 0:12welcome. Excited to dive into the Bitcoin Credit Fund, Bitcoin Life Insurance,
- 0:17bitcoins and nominated everything hopefully in the future, yess it. Yeah, and
- 0:23I know that you're deep in this as well, and that you know this
- 0:26is a long time coming, but we're still very early on in what this
- 0:30will become in bitcoins and nominated everything. I would love to start off our
- 0:34conversation by just first of all, hearing a little bit about yourself, your
- 0:38history and how that led up to forming Meanwhile, and then we'll dive into
- 0:42all the latest updates with Meanwhile. Great. Yeah, I'm primarily a fintech
- 0:48entrepreneur by background, so I was moved out to the San Francisco Bay area
- 0:54in twenty thirteen. I was an early employee of Stripe and then pretty quickly
- 1:00decided I wanted to start my own company. So, uh, you know,
- 1:03with this support of the Compson's, got into y Combinator and started a
- 1:07company called Standard Treasury, which was really the first like banking as a service
- 1:11company. So we did like bank accounts as a service for stripe at lists
- 1:17and a bunch of other fintech companies, and that was backed by in Treess
- 1:22and Horowitz and Index Ventures and y Combinator and UH. In a long and
- 1:26funny story, I eventually sold that company to Silicon Valley Bank, but we
- 1:33we had built a lot of like cool infrastructure, We had built a lot
- 1:37of expertise around any money wandering and KYC and things like that. So actually
- 1:42my first introduction to crypto UH and bitcoin in particular was when I was selling
- 1:48that company. Coinbase wanted to buy it, and obviously it'd be a lot
- 1:53richer and a lot happier, but I sold at the coin Base but we
- 1:57we we thought it was pretty special, the idea of selling it to a
- 2:00bank, and that was pretty unusual at the time. So but you know,
- 2:06the first bitcoin I ever received was actually like literally in a meeting with
- 2:12Brian Armstrong and he sent me a bitcoin, you know, like through Coinbase.
- 2:19So that that really began what I guess for me was like a an
- 2:23avocation, like a side project. Something I was like paying attention to through
- 2:30the ico boom and all of that. And I was just sitting there,
- 2:36like buying one hundred dollars a bitcoin a week and doing like dollar cost averaging
- 2:42and uh, but you know, I did a bunch of other things.
- 2:49My wife started a company. I need to have a real job because we
- 2:52have young kids. I like worked at McKenzie company. And my co founder
- 2:57and I or my now co frinder and I we sat down in late twenty
- 3:00twenty one, so almost like two years exactly ago now, and we really
- 3:07had this firm belief that there will be a bitcoin economy, just as you
- 3:13say, like you look out twenty thirty forty years, we think there will
- 3:15absolutely one be an economy denominated in bitcoin. And the second thing we really
- 3:22believe is that we're really comfortable with a particular type of pain, and that
- 3:28pain is like regulatory pain and really dealing with that. So we think that
- 3:34there needs like if you thought of I call it like bitcoin Land. So
- 3:38imagine there's this country, it's called bitcoin Land. It exists, it happens
- 3:43to be decentralized, but it's there's going to be an economy. There's going
- 3:47to be what I jokingly called gross decentralized product, and then that economy is
- 3:55going to have every financial institution that like quote unquote normal economy does or traditional
- 4:01economy does. And we basically went through the list of like, well,
- 4:05what are the big financial institutions that need to exist for bitcoin land? And
- 4:12we knew a decent amount about life insurance. I mean, now, I
- 4:14know I didn't know anything about life insurance, but the time we thought we
- 4:17knew something about it. And that's really how meanwhile I was born. We
- 4:23we you know, think that the bitcoin economy will you know, they it
- 4:28needs rating, and it needs banks, and it needs I don't know,
- 4:34payments rails, and it also needs a life insurance company. Even though that
- 4:38sounds really boring, I can talk about why it is not boring. Yeah,
- 4:43very interesting backstory, Zach. And that's really cool that Brian Armstrong is
- 4:46orange pilling people in meetings and I think sometimes or at least he wasn't twenty
- 4:50fifteen. I don't know what he is now anymore. Yeah, Well,
- 4:54it's it's good for those people that like you, that understood, you know,
- 4:58sometimes when there's a new asset class, you have to have, you
- 5:01know, even just a couple of dollars in it. You know, once
- 5:03you own a little bit of it, then sort of ingrains the understanding more
- 5:09and hey, there there is actually value in this and this is money,
- 5:13and then that vision starts to become reality on hey if other what other things
- 5:17will be denominated in bitcoin as this continues to grow and exactly although life insurance
- 5:23is is not that exciting, I'm sure it is a very big business.
- 5:27You probably know the numbers and and it's like two or three percent of global
- 5:32GDP every year is life insurance per means, so like pretty big numbers.
- 5:39And look, I you know, I think it is made somewhat boring.
- 5:44I mean, it is a boring product in some ways. But I also
- 5:46think that it's a product that's, like in tradfin made needlessly complicated, and
- 5:51that it uh it, it's often made needlessly complicated, and then like it
- 5:57doesn't feel great. It doesn't feel great to have it. It's old.
- 6:00So one of the nice things that we see in crypto and bitcoin is you
- 6:04get to like reinvent these things from scratch, and that oft also means you
- 6:09get to really think about customer needs and actually, like the oldest savings product
- 6:15in the world was burial insurance. You know, sailors would like leave them
- 6:19as and they'd buy insurance in case they died their family could afford uh to
- 6:27uh you know, have a burial And so we really think about, like,
- 6:31you know, life insurance is this really core thing of like what happens
- 6:35is your family? How do you save for them, like, you know,
- 6:40if you in some ways like die before you're supposed to or yeah,
- 6:46and then annuity is also like big word that sounds really boring, but in
- 6:49some ways annuity is like what what happens to your loved ones or yourself if
- 6:54you live longer than you're supposed to And that's when a nuity is supposed to
- 6:58be is like lifetime and come anyway, Yeah, No, it's it's great
- 7:04that introducing bitcoin into something like life insurance can hopefully spice it up and it'll
- 7:10probably make the industry grow even bigger when when people realize that, you know,
- 7:15I, personally being a bitcoin fanatic, I would rather have it being
- 7:20paid out in bitcoin rather than a currency that might be experiencing inflation where the
- 7:25value is going to go down. Hopefully my family's getting something that's that is
- 7:30not so far the top all time returning asset of all time. Sounds like
- 7:34that they would be better off so well, And that's really the cool benefit
- 7:40about the product is like, is one exactly what you just said, Like
- 7:43we think that bitcoin is not just an appreciating asset, but as you said,
- 7:48back to my country analogy. By the way, I don't like to
- 7:50say the price of bitcoin. I like to say the exchange rate of bitcoin.
- 7:54Right, you know, if it is a currency, we shouldn't think
- 7:56of it as like this thing you just buy, but it's a medium of
- 8:00exchange, so you're exchanging. So every time bitcoin goes up in value,
- 8:05maybe we should be thinking about the dollar going down on value. But anyway,
- 8:09so like one is that, like, yes, I think for a
- 8:13ton of people, this is an appreciate, appreciating asset, so it like
- 8:18makes sense if you're a bitcoiner to like buy life insurance in this asset.
- 8:24The second is, and this has nothing to do with the fact that like
- 8:26we started this company, but life insurance in the United States, life insurance
- 8:31and many other jurisdictions like has a pretty privileged like tax position. So it
- 8:39exactly because you're like trying to provide production for your family, and like,
- 8:43you know, the state wants to incentivize, you know, in a generational
- 8:46savings so I can describe the product that we have in detail, but like
- 8:52ultimately there are all these like tax privileges. And then the third thing that
- 8:56we think a lot about doesn't I think matter as much for you and me,
- 8:58but it is something that like we we work on a lot is you
- 9:03know, there are fifty seven countries in the world with inflation rates right now
- 9:05over ten percent. And the whole company in some ways is predicated on the
- 9:11belief that there are these like two revolutions happening right now. One is digital
- 9:16money, is bitcoin, and like we see that as a way to reach
- 9:20many, many more people than have ever been reached by a life insurance company.
- 9:26And then on the other hand, we we think the only way you
- 9:31can serve like hundreds of millions of people profitably at scale is to like figure
- 9:37out like new ways of doing things. And that's why we've ended up with
- 9:43like some of the biggest names in AI on our cap table is exactly because
- 9:48you know, we're currently running a life insurance company with seven people, which
- 9:50is a little crazy and that's like on the back of a lot of software
- 9:56and automation and artificial intelligence, so they're not like generated AI, which is
- 10:03what people think AI is right now. But yeah, that's very cool and
- 10:09it's amazing to see bitcoin denominated companies, AI companies, you know, crypto
- 10:15exchanges and the like having not needing thousands of employees like they do in traditional
- 10:20banks. The overhead is insane in traditional banks having tens of thousands or hundreds
- 10:24of thousands of employees. So that's really cool to hear. I would love
- 10:28to get sort of a better explanation on what is the difference from you know,
- 10:33the traditional boring life insurance to this bitcoin life insurance. Is it everything
- 10:39is the same except for you're getting paid on in bitcoin or all the payments
- 10:43are in bitcoin. Yeah, and obviously the AI has some additional value there
- 10:46as well. Yeah. Look, I think the big difference is right now
- 10:54that that's in bitcoin, and in some ways that's how we pitched it to
- 10:56the regulator. So we're regulated by themmunam Ontaria Authority. Bermuda is a completely
- 11:03legit place to have a life insurance company. Like seventy percent of the economy
- 11:07of Bermuda is insurance. It's an island full of actuaries, accountant, some
- 11:11lawyers, not a victorist destination. You walk around the Hamilton Bermuda and it's
- 11:18all like Chubb and Munichree and Swiss read there. It's just huge buildings.
- 11:22And we picked that jurisdiction one because they are like a serious regulator who like
- 11:31puts serious requirements on us. And on the other hand, they were willing
- 11:35to do something innovative. And one of the ways we talk to them about
- 11:37this company is imagine a boring life insurance company that does everything in like relatively
- 11:45typical ways, so we're not trying to innovate on underwriting or claims or whatever.
- 11:50But instead of the company being nominated in dollars or euros or the end
- 11:56or Swiss francs, it's nominated in bitcoin. So what that means in practice
- 12:00is we take all premiums in bitcoin, so all our customers pay us in
- 12:05bitcoin, and we pay all our claims in bitcoin, and then there's all
- 12:09this stuff an insurance company does in between. So our financials are in bitcoin,
- 12:13our solvency calculations are bitcoin, our reserves are in bitcoin. Everything's in
- 12:18bitcoin. And what's nice about that fundamentally as a company is we're not just
- 12:26saying we're building for the bitcoin economy. We're like have literally built the company
- 12:31like in the bitcoin you know, gunmery. And what that leads to back
- 12:37to the exchange rate comment is like, we're somewhat ambivalent to the price,
- 12:43the like exchange rate of bitcoin to dollars because all our assets and all our
- 12:48liabilities are denominated in bitcoin. So we like, over the course of this
- 12:54company, you know, it's been at sixty thousand, and you know,
- 12:58sixteen thousand, and you know, thirty thousand, now forty five thousand.
- 13:03But you could sort of think if you were getting a balance sheet from us
- 13:07every quarter, you would have just seen you know, assets and liabilities like
- 13:11subtle a rising in bitcoin terms. Now, So that's what the company,
- 13:18how the company works. And then what our first product is is it's called
- 13:22a Whole Life. So it lashed your whole life. It's well named.
- 13:28So because I hope I'm not the bearer of bad news your action. You
- 13:31will eventually die, you know, you know, hopefully that will be forty
- 13:37fifty sixty years from now. But so because the product lash your whole life.
- 13:43That means there will eventually be a payout, right, So it is
- 13:46much more of like an intergenerational wealth transfer Hoddle product. And the way the
- 13:50product works is you pay let's say one bitcoin a year for ten years,
- 13:56and so it's called it's limited pay. You don't pay forever, You just
- 14:00pay for ten years. You can pay up front if you want. Different
- 14:03people make different trises, and then we promise you some fixed payout, so
- 14:09that might be like fifteen or twenty. You know, it depends how howthy
- 14:13you are and stuff like that. And so the product is really simple,
- 14:16like you give us ten and we promise you fifteen, or you promise your
- 14:20beneficiaries fifteen. And that comes with like three key benefits. One is we
- 14:28there's like real protection, so that from the moment we received the first premium,
- 14:31if you die, you know your your beneficiaries get fifteen. The second
- 14:37is there is a savings rate that may be uncomfortable. We can talk about
- 14:41like what that means, but there's a savings rate. And even if you
- 14:46thought you could get the same savings rate as us, that is, you
- 14:48thought you could try to turn ten into fifteen, we are compounding that savings
- 14:54rate tax free, so you know, if you were getting earning interest your
- 15:00bitcoin, then you'll be baying taxes every year. And then the third thing
- 15:05is, and this is just true of all whole life products, it just
- 15:07ours happens to be denominated in bitcoin, is you can borrow against the policy
- 15:11tax free, and that's denominated in bitcoin. So imagine you put ten bitcoin
- 15:16in. We're now fifteen years from now, bitcoin's at a million dollars a
- 15:22token a coin. You could borrow a million dollar bitcoin out from us,
- 15:28and you it's like you're getting a new bitcoin. So it's a new capital
- 15:30gains tax basis, you wouldn't owe any taxes on like when you put it
- 15:35in till the million dollars. And so we sort of talk about the product
- 15:39as a a like it's a product for hoddling, and then it has this
- 15:46like tax advantage liquidity if you need it. Wow, that's very cool.
- 15:50And I think a lot of the smartest investors are long term investors. I've
- 15:58seen many of the visionaries. They have a ten year minimum investment horizon on
- 16:03bitcoin, but just based on you know, the havings and how far we
- 16:07are since inception around fourteen years. Even just the circulating supply of bitcoin is
- 16:14not going to stop for another one hundred and twenty years. Hopefully it is
- 16:18for hundreds of years beyond that, so you know, we I think,
- 16:22thinking long term, it seems like a smart idea to be able to optimize
- 16:27the tax for it and pass on that generational wealth with Yeah. I mean,
- 16:32obviously there are some bitcoiners who don't think that bitcoin will last longer than
- 16:36the United States tax regime. But if you believe that the United States tax
- 16:40regime will survive, then yeah, I think it makes sense to take a
- 16:44portion of your stack and put it in a product like this one. Very
- 16:48cool. Well, thank you for explaining all that, and now I want
- 16:49to dive into some more recent news on the latest pr that I saw for
- 16:55Meanwhile, which is very cool as well. You were talking about the AI
- 16:59founders are in. I saw Sam Altman is invested from Opening Eye, which
- 17:03is very cool. Is this private credit fund that meanwhile started? Maybe could
- 17:07explain a little bit about that. Yeah, Well, fundamentally, what we
- 17:11do in the insurance company, as I said, is like you give us
- 17:15ten, we promise you fifteen, And between those two things is us essentially
- 17:19already running a private credit task. I think this is uncomfortable for a lot
- 17:23of bitcoiners. Like, look, we do everything that's uncomfortable in bitcoin,
- 17:27right, So you send us to your bitcoin, we take custody of it,
- 17:33we hypothecate it with all the other premiums we received from everyone else,
- 17:37and then we lend it to other people. And we've been doing that lending
- 17:41for about two years and we've had no credit losses and we've gotten you know,
- 17:47a conservative yield. I think that's the key distinction we're trying to make,
- 17:51is like we're long term, we're conservative, we are boring, and
- 17:56that's something that hasn't existed in bitcoin, and certainly has an existed in crypto,
- 18:02which is like there's a lot of like and there's a we understand like
- 18:07I'm this way too. Like there's a real pride in liquidity, there's a
- 18:10real pride in like short term nous. There's a real interest in like high
- 18:15returns, and we're trying to be like the exact opposite, right, So
- 18:18we are like long duration, low risk, low yield, and that isn't
- 18:25where maybe your entire portfolio should be, but that is where like a portion
- 18:27of your portfolio should be. So we realized that this is a product that
- 18:33we needed for ourselves, right, like if someone else was doing this like
- 18:37a really conservative like deep credit analysis like low ltv H low yield long duration
- 18:47fund, we would invest ourselves in it. And then so we had to
- 18:51build this capability out right. So I have an investment committee, I have
- 18:53a chief risk officer, I have a board, I have a target IRR.
- 18:57I have a due diligence checklist of all this stuff already for the insurance
- 19:00company. And we realize, like, okay, if we're going to do
- 19:04this for ourselves, we should do it for other people too, because we
- 19:07think that there should be other people who are interested. And you know,
- 19:15there's just a core thesis we have as I said that, like you look
- 19:18out twenty thirty, forty fifty years, there's going to be a bitcoin economy.
- 19:22And for us, that means that bitcoin has to be more than gold
- 19:25in the ground. It has to be money, it has to be capital
- 19:27markets, it has to be debt, it has to be like used in
- 19:33economic activity. And we see our insurance company as not just solving like a
- 19:37financial need for individual users, but also like as a longer term vehicle,
- 19:45like permanent capital vehicle to create that economy and to create a yield curve and
- 19:49bitcoin, and this credit fund is an extension of that, like we're going
- 19:53to institutional well institutional we in the US. This this is this technical term
- 20:00of like we can have qualified purchasers, so it's like people who have more
- 20:04than like five million dollars, so it can be like individuals and family offices,
- 20:08but like you know, people who have We're not trying like block Fi
- 20:12or Celsius or whatever, to get millions of people to give us small amounts
- 20:18and a big portion in our stack and make extravagant provinces that we can't keep.
- 20:23We're trying to do is go to sophisticated investors, talk to them about
- 20:27this long term ecosystem, have them invest in this fund, and then the
- 20:32idea is like, you know, we raise whatever a thousand bitcoin or two
- 20:37thousand bitcoin, and our target returns are five percent, So that means that
- 20:41every year, let's just have a thousand bitcoin because it matters easier that we
- 20:47would be trying to distribute fifty new bitcoin to our user, to our investors,
- 20:52and then at the end we'll you know, return back to one thousand
- 20:57bitcoin. So this is it's really the same story as the insurance company.
- 21:00In some way, we've taken this boring structure of private credit, you know
- 21:07that KKR or Apollo or those folks are doing every single day, and we're
- 21:11trying to bring that longer term, more conservative perspective to bitcoin land. Very
- 21:19interesting, Zach, and I feel like maybe it's the younger generation, more
- 21:25like myself and younger that they weren't really involved in traditional finance before they sort
- 21:30of saw bitcoin and what it can become and got involved, and this is
- 21:34their first step, and this is like all they know is that you know
- 21:37bitcoin, you know, the assets are volatile and the returns are high,
- 21:41and they don't have maybe as long term investment horizon as somebody who's already been
- 21:48involved in traditional investments for thirty forty years. So maybe this isn't as exciting
- 21:53to them, But I feel like it is the kind of products that they
- 21:57actually bring more stability to that other side that they're involved in with bitcoin.
- 22:03Without this boring, long term, small yield investment side, bitcoin wouldn't be
- 22:08as legit as it would be without it. One hundred percent agree, And
- 22:15I think what's fascinating to me is that there is this culture of hoddling.
- 22:22So there is already this like element of long termness, but that's not reflected
- 22:27in like, well, I don't know, it's not reflected in in partially
- 22:36how people think, but also how the space is comfored Like there's a lot
- 22:40more coin desk articles and Crypto Telegraph articles about like what's going to happen to
- 22:47the price of bitcoin this week? And obviously the Wall Street Journal covers like
- 22:53what is going to happen to the price of the S and P five hundred
- 22:56this week? But it is not that is not the whole of of what
- 23:00the Wall Street Journal covers. It's not the whole of what finance is.
- 23:03And I don't think it is going to be or should be what the whole
- 23:08of bitcoin is, right So, and that that may sound less exciting,
- 23:15because yeah, I think that there's a whole world of people who like they
- 23:18want to grade every day and like I don't know duvall plays, but like
- 23:23there's another world of people, no matter of their age, I think,
- 23:26who are like, this is a durable store of value and we should start
- 23:33talking about it. That way, and we should start thinking about it that
- 23:36way, and we should start building products that facilitate that. And that's,
- 23:40uh, that's what we're trying to do. And you know, maybe it
- 23:44won't be as exciting or sexy as I don't know what what the price action
- 23:49is, but I think, as you said, it's I guess i'd argue
- 23:55it's even more important. Well, I'm glad that you and your team are
- 23:59working on this, and I like the approach of focusing on the big money,
- 24:04the smart money, not you know, the Celsius spray and prey to
- 24:08everybody and offer gields that obviously was unsustainable in what they were doing. But
- 24:15you know, I have seen a lot of discussions from even you know,
- 24:18the Blackrock CEO or billionaire investors that they're starting to up their allocation of bitcoin
- 24:25of their portfolio from one percent to five percent or maybe even ten percent or
- 24:29more. Where do you think sort of that's at and how much of their
- 24:33appetite will be geared towards this kind of private credit fund. Yeah, I
- 24:40think you're absolutely right that people it's not just billionaires. I think it's like
- 24:44financial advisors and general high networth individuals are you know, they're moving from zero
- 24:49to two or two to five, and yeah, we have this core belief
- 24:56that when you look out even five years, that bitcoin itself will be I
- 25:06don't know the the the simplest product you can buy in the bitcoin economy,
- 25:12but that there is going. The way that these act allocators should start thinking
- 25:18about Crypto is not or bitcoin isn't. Like they have a portfolio, right,
- 25:25and you know they have like a stocks box, and they have a
- 25:29bonds box, and they have a private credit box, and they have a
- 25:30hedge fund box, and they have a venture capital box. And I think
- 25:33that what they're doing right now is they're like, oh, let's have a
- 25:37new box called the bitcoin box, and we'll put two percent of our portfolio
- 25:41in that. And I actually think the right way to start thinking about it
- 25:45is that for every single one of those boxes that they already have, those
- 25:49are strategies, and then a certain percentage of the allocation in those strategies should
- 25:56be crypto or should be bitcoin. Right, So if they already have a
- 26:00private credit box, they should invest in our fund. They already have a
- 26:03hedge fund box, they should invest in edge fund X. They already have
- 26:07a venture Capital Fund, they should invest in Paradigm er andresen or still Mark
- 26:14who's one of my investors and is really amazing, And and I think that's
- 26:18what we'll see as a maturation that instead of it being this like new thing
- 26:22off to the side that's two percent of the portfolio, rather let's have it
- 26:26be two percent of every part of our portfolio. And that will require not
- 26:33just what we're doing, it will require like all sorts of new the creation
- 26:37of new products. But that's the like fundamentally when you mentioned black Rock,
- 26:41Like when black when he's talking about it, he's talking about like the future
- 26:48of capitalism and the like Bitcoin as this like new global decentralized financial system.
- 26:53And to me that speaks to it being not just a commodity that's two percent
- 27:00of your portfolio, but that it is a range of portfolio strategies dedicated to
- 27:07that economy. Wow. That I love that perspective showing it like that,
- 27:14that you know, it's not just one box on the side to allocate two
- 27:18percent to it's revolutionizing all of the different asset classes, which it just goes
- 27:22to show how incredible, uh, the potential for bitcoin will become when bitcoin
- 27:27land becomes more of a reality to the mainstream. So I appreciate your insights,
- 27:33Zach. It's incredible. And what is the best way for people to
- 27:37learn more about the life insurance product or the private credit fund? Uh,
- 27:42well, the life insurance product they can people can just go to Meanwhile dot
- 27:45bm, which is their website. The private credit fund, I guess a
- 27:51little more hand to hand, so it's uh, hello at meanwhile dot BM.
- 27:57I'm happy to share information with folks. Great. Thank you so much,
- 28:02Zach. I really appreciate it. All the best with everything moving forward
- 28:04in Meanwhile and to help build the future for bitcoin and bitcoin land, and
- 28:10let's definitely follow up in the near future. Great, thanks so much,
- 28:12Ashton, love being here.