Latest / Columbus' Morning News / Man disciplines his son by doing push-ups and squats...Is this ok?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: All right. This video that has gone viral now, it's
- 0:05got a lot of people conflicted on whether it's okay
- 0:08to use exercise as punishment. I'll just set it up
- 0:14and i'll play you the audio. The kid is kind
- 0:19of pestering his mom. She's on a work email. She's
- 0:22trying to do some work. She tells him, hey, stop
- 0:27interrupting me. I'm doing some work on the phone. The
- 0:30kid snaps at her. Kid's probably nine or ten. Little
- 0:34boy tells mom to chill, which that probably happens every
- 0:41day in this country. You get a snotty little kid
- 0:43telling mom chill nowadays. Anyway, Oh for sure. So the father,
- 0:50and at one point it was stepdad, but I don't
- 0:52think it is. I think it's the biological father. Overhears
- 0:56this and takes some action, and here's the audio. Listen carefully.
- 1:02Speaker 2: I said, O, did you That was the question?
- 1:06Speaker 3: Did you just come here? Push ups? Count on?
- 1:11Speaker 1: Kids doing push ups? Three? Yeah? Count Now he's doing squats.
- 1:29Chill out, No, absolutely not. I'm not talk to me.
- 1:34Absolutely I let anybody else talk to me like that.
- 1:36So you don't get okay, I love you, all right.
- 1:41So at the very end there in the video, the
- 1:45dad tells the kid to come here, gives him a
- 1:47hugs as I love you. He doesn't raise his voice,
- 1:50he doesn't yell, he's not screaming, he's not sending the
- 1:52kid off to his room, brings the kid over. Hey,
- 1:56you know, basically drop and give me fifty. It has
- 1:59a couple of push ups, does a couple of squats,
- 2:02and he's coaching the kid up. He's parenting the kid
- 2:06while he's doing the squad, saying, I don't let anybody
- 2:09talk to your mom like that. I'm not going to
- 2:11let you talk to your mom like that. She's doing work.
- 2:14You can't tell her to chill, all right, So the
- 2:16kid gets it, does the exercise, does the work. Dad says,
- 2:21now come over and give me a hug. You know,
- 2:23we're all good here. Yeah. So, as you would imagine,
- 2:27the video has got over forty million views, and it's
- 2:31so why is this on video? To start with Jack,
- 2:34the couple is a they're on Instagram together, Katie and Dustin,
- 2:38and they've got an Instagram account. It's it's a parenting account.
- 2:42So that's why it's on Instagram. That's why it was
- 2:45being recorded. They have a ring like a security cam
- 2:49and they're inside their house, which whatever. Okay, the question comes,
- 2:54do you use punishment? Do you use exercise as a punishment?
- 2:59I mean, you see some of these comments and people
- 3:02are accusing this guy of abuse, that that's physical abuse,
- 3:07but what he did it's not only physical abuse. It's
- 3:09humiliating to the child to then post it on Instagram
- 3:13on video. You're the kid who had to do push
- 3:15up because you told your mom to chill. The mom
- 3:19posted and she said, I will never stop being grateful
- 3:22to my husband for raising kids to be real men,
- 3:26and he knows how to be a father, especially to
- 3:28his boys. This is what masculinity that looks like. I
- 3:31was trying to send a work email while making breakfast
- 3:33for my family, and my son kept asking me to
- 3:35use the phone, and you know, we heard everything anything
- 3:38my kid says, chill. So mom is supportive of how
- 3:42dad handled this. So my question to you is using
- 3:47exercise as a punishment. Okay, I don't have any problem
- 3:52with what the dad did. Back in our day, it
- 3:55was a lot worse than that.
- 3:56Speaker 3: To tell you what now, I find it if you
- 3:57know what if I if dad would have done the
- 4:00punishment like that for me, for stupid stuff that when
- 4:03I was a kid, I'd have been a triathlete by
- 4:05the time I was like eleven. I mean, I'm just saying, look,
- 4:09there's nothing there's there was nothing brutal about it. He
- 4:13did a couple of push ups, he did a couple
- 4:15of squats, got up and walked away. He wasn't sore.
- 4:17He was It's not like he made him do burpies
- 4:20until the kid couldn't stand up.
- 4:22Speaker 2: Then you're talking about something different. All he did was
- 4:24he made it.
- 4:25Speaker 3: He created effort that the kid had to do well,
- 4:28drilling into his head you don't talk to your mother
- 4:30like that because guess what.
- 4:31Speaker 1: Guess what, the kid's not going to do anymore. The
- 4:33kid's not going to talk back to his mom, which
- 4:35is the whole point of all of this, right is
- 4:37to is to disincentivize the bad behavior. You know, pain,
- 4:43an avoidance of pain is a great motivator.
- 4:46Speaker 3: Yeah, my dad could yell me into submission. He wouldn't
- 4:49even have to raise a hand. He ever had the
- 4:51finger poke. Oh yeah, the one right in the chest, right, Yeah,
- 4:55that's the that's that was enough for me and for
- 4:59this kid.
- 4:59Speaker 2: It'll probably be enough because.
- 5:01Speaker 1: You didn't want to know what was going to happen
- 5:02next if you kept it up.
- 5:04Speaker 3: Would you rather have forty million views of him smacking
- 5:06the kid around forty million views of him doing sit
- 5:09ups and squats or push ups and squads?
- 5:12Speaker 1: Twell said, my only, my only concern, And again I
- 5:15was curious as to why this even got posted and
- 5:18and how it got posted. Well, they they are I
- 5:21guess influenced and influencer couple, so they do they do
- 5:26apparently parenting videos and and all of this. So that
- 5:30explains that the only thing. Would you probably don't want
- 5:34your kid to grow up resenting exercise because they associate
- 5:38it with punishment, and that that's something that maybe happens
- 5:42down the line.
- 5:43Speaker 3: I think as you get older you understand the difference
- 5:46at that point, you know what I mean, Like, I
- 5:48don't I think that that would grow out of it,
- 5:50Like if you're still associating that with I mean, they
- 5:53do do it in the military if you disobey order,
- 5:56you get that.
- 5:57Speaker 2: Wrong, you're on you're on the ground doing twenty.
- 5:59Speaker 1: It happens in sports all the time too, all the time.
- 6:01If you're at practice and you're screwing around with one
- 6:03of your teammates and coach tells you to stop, and
- 6:05you don't, and coach doesn't like it. And guess what,
- 6:08everybody on the line, yeah or whatever it is, we're running, Yeah,
- 6:12we need to do I needed to do five laps.
- 6:15Speaker 2: Yeah, I don't.
- 6:15Speaker 3: I don't see this being a I just don't see
- 6:18this as being a weird way of punishing anybody.
- 6:21Speaker 1: I don't think so either. Again, he didn't raise his voice,
- 6:24he didn't call the kid names. He just said, Look,
- 6:27no one talks to your mom like that, including you.
- 6:29Speaker 2: Yeah, he didn't sound like a drill serge, and he
- 6:31could have been.
- 6:32Speaker 3: I mean, like I said, if the kid had like
- 6:34bloody knuckles or he'd been down there for doing it,
- 6:36then you're talking about something entirely different.
- 6:38Speaker 2: This was a simple lesson that got.
- 6:40Speaker 3: Into the kid's head. He told him he loved him.
- 6:42After that, the kid responded, gave.
- 6:43Speaker 1: Him a hug, and walked away, and they went out
- 6:45with her their morning. But yeah, you know, there are
- 6:48a lot of parents in the comment section, you know,
- 6:51calling this guy abusive, calling this an uncomfortable video to watch,
- 6:54and a lot of these you know, sort of softer
- 6:57parenting styles, which is prominent today, the gentle parenting.
- 7:01Speaker 2: Which I don't necessarily have a problem with either, that's your.
- 7:03Speaker 1: Well, I actually know people who adopt this gentle parenting style,
- 7:09and you know, the whole notion of never telling your
- 7:12kid no. See, and that's and that's what it is.
- 7:16And I've witnessed it firsthand where the kid is kind
- 7:19of getting away with murder and in some you know,
- 7:22this snotty, unwelcome behavior. Yeah, and it's like, you know,
- 7:28let let's not do that. You never tell the kid,
- 7:31hey stop, Yeah you want to stop stop the behavior,
- 7:35but you know, hey, let's is that a good choice?
- 7:38Like you hear this gentle never say no parenting, and
- 7:43guess what you have? You have seven eight nine year
- 7:45olds running the house. Well, and there's what you have.
- 7:48Speaker 3: Yeah. I now, look, I'm not a parent, so I
- 7:50maybe I don't have the right to chime in and I
- 7:52can just speak as a child in the way I
- 7:54was raised.
- 7:55Speaker 2: What you do.
- 7:56Speaker 3: Learn is when you hear no, and you you do
- 7:59learn that life is hard and you have to persevere
- 8:02and that things are not going to be given to you.
- 8:04In fact, that is a rare when that happens, that's awesome.
- 8:08That's why it's called a gift.
- 8:09Speaker 1: Well, and it's not always going to be your parents
- 8:11telling you no, because at some point you're going to
- 8:14leave the house and you have been raised in a bubble,
- 8:17and then you're gonna have a boss or a coworker
- 8:20or somebody else in your life. You'll be shocked tell
- 8:22you no, and you're gonna be I don't understand what.
- 8:26I don't understand What do you mean?
- 8:27Speaker 3: No?
- 8:27Speaker 1: Yeah, what do you mean? I have to follow rules
- 8:30and have to follow a certain way of doing things.
- 8:32This is not how that's gonna be a that's a
- 8:35lesson that you're going to learn at some point.
- 8:37Speaker 2: You made me do burpies before I walked
- 8:39Speaker 1: In here this morning, and you're a better man.