Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: TikTok Ban, Protecting a Wildlife Refuge & Boeing
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: Is time ticking away for TikTok or is it just
- 0:13Speaker 2: another stage in a year's long tech drama. The wildly
- 0:18Speaker 2: popular video app used by one hundred and seventy million
- 0:21Speaker 2: Americans is facing its most serious threat to date. A
- 0:25Speaker 2: bill that would ban TikTok from operating in the US
- 0:29Speaker 2: or force a sale by its Chinese parent, passed overwhelmingly
- 0:33Speaker 2: in the House on Wednesday. Lawmakers cite privacy risks and
- 0:37Speaker 2: national security fears over the Chinese Communist Party's perceived ability
- 0:43Speaker 2: to use data from Americans for political gains. Here's North
- 0:47Speaker 2: Carolina Republican Senator Tom Tillis, We have.
- 0:50Speaker 3: To recognize that information on any of these platforms are
- 0:54Speaker 3: at risk of going to the Chinese Communist Party. So
- 0:57Speaker 3: this is one step in one. I think's a long
- 0:59Speaker 3: journey to hold Hi accountable.
- 1:01Speaker 2: But others like California Republican Congressman Tom McClintock, have raised
- 1:06Speaker 2: free speech concerns and fear the US is going down
- 1:10Speaker 2: a dangerous path.
- 1:12Speaker 4: The answer to CCPA style propaganda is not CCPA style oppression.
- 1:18Speaker 4: Let us slow down before we blunder down this very
- 1:22Speaker 4: steep and slippery slope.
- 1:24Speaker 2: The Chinese government has said it would oppose any forced
- 1:27Speaker 2: sale and its approval is needed, and TikTok CEOs showed too,
- 1:31Speaker 2: promised to fight back in a very American way.
- 1:35Speaker 5: We will continue to do all we can, including exercising
- 1:38Speaker 5: all legal.
- 1:39Speaker 2: Rights, and that's something the company did successfully when then
- 1:43Speaker 2: President Donald Trump ordered its Chinese parent, Byte Dance to
- 1:47Speaker 2: sell TikTok back in twenty twenty. My guest is Eric Goleman,
- 1:51Speaker 2: a professor at Santa Clara University Law School and co
- 1:55Speaker 2: director of its High Tech Law Institute. Eric explained why
- 1:59Speaker 2: so many lawmakers are concerned about TikTok and it's Chinese parent.
- 2:05Speaker 5: A lot of the legislature is object to TikTok principally
- 2:08Speaker 5: because of the fact that it's related to China, and
- 2:13Speaker 5: there's such senophobia that it becomes a very politically popular
- 2:18Speaker 5: move to tweak China. So it's not so much that
- 2:22Speaker 5: the representatives care about the privacy issues. They care about
- 2:28Speaker 5: China and they're signaling that to their voters.
- 2:31Speaker 2: Lawmakers often point to a Chinese security law that forces
- 2:36Speaker 2: companies to turn over information when requested, but TikTok CEO
- 2:41Speaker 2: says the company has never been asked to share US
- 2:44Speaker 2: user data with Chinese authorities and won't do so if asked,
- 2:48Speaker 2: and also that American data is now on servers in
- 2:52Speaker 2: Texas run by Oracle.
- 2:54Speaker 4: The bottom line is this American data stort on American soil,
- 3:00Speaker 4: American company overseen by American personnel.
- 3:03Speaker 2: So are those lawmakers concerns something we should take seriously?
- 3:09Speaker 5: In general? I think we should be concerned about government
- 3:12Speaker 5: access to our private information online. But I don't restrict
- 3:16Speaker 5: my concern to China. I feel that way about all
- 3:18Speaker 5: governments across the globe, including here in the United States,
- 3:21Speaker 5: where government agencies have a variety of ways about hating
- 3:25Speaker 5: private online communications that in fact we would prefer that
- 3:29Speaker 5: they don't have access to. Indeed, Europe cut off data
- 3:33Speaker 5: flows with the United States because of the concern in
- 3:36Speaker 5: Europe that the US government had access to European private
- 3:40Speaker 5: information online. So if that's the concern, then trying to
- 3:44Speaker 5: target China and doing it in this way is really
- 3:47Speaker 5: an indirect solution. We really ought to have a broad,
- 3:50Speaker 5: society wide conversation about when governments have access to private
- 3:54Speaker 5: citizen data and what we're going to do to protect
- 3:56Speaker 5: the interest of private citizens.
- 3:58Speaker 2: So tell us about the spill what it would do.
- 4:01Speaker 5: The bill is styled as a divestiture law. The idea
- 4:05Speaker 5: is to get the ownership of TikTok out of the
- 4:08Speaker 5: hands of people related to China. In practice, it's almost
- 4:13Speaker 5: certainly going to turn into a TikTok ban. It would
- 4:16Speaker 5: ban TikTok in the United States and require app stores
- 4:20Speaker 5: not to allow the installation of TikTok. So it's trying
- 4:24Speaker 5: to just kick TikTok out of the US market.
- 4:27Speaker 2: So what the lawmakers are saying is that by dance,
- 4:30Speaker 2: the Chinese parent would have six months to divest TikTok.
- 4:36Speaker 5: Yeah, just to be clear, nobody expects that to really
- 4:38Speaker 5: be the outcome. There's a limited number of people who
- 4:42Speaker 5: might be interested in buying TikTok, and the forced sale
- 4:46Speaker 5: would almost certainly depress the prices. But I want to
- 4:48Speaker 5: analogize this to what happened after the Ukrainian War, where
- 4:52Speaker 5: Russia put the squeeze on US owned enterprises and force
- 4:57Speaker 5: them to sell to Russian owners, and in so doing
- 5:01Speaker 5: they transferred billions of dollars of wealth from the US
- 5:05Speaker 5: owners to new Russian owners who bought up pennies on
- 5:08Speaker 5: the dollar, and so essentially the Congress is doing what
- 5:12Speaker 5: Russia did to our companies, and that really seems like
- 5:16Speaker 5: the wrong inspiration for US to be drawn from.
- 5:19Speaker 2: China's Foreign Ministry also said that there was a failure
- 5:23Speaker 2: to provide evidence that TikTok is a threat to the
- 5:26Speaker 2: US national security. I've heard a lot of blanket statements
- 5:31Speaker 2: that TikTok is a national security threat, but has the
- 5:35Speaker 2: US government provided any actual evidence of that.
- 5:39Speaker 5: So one of the big questions is exactly how is
- 5:44Speaker 5: TikTok a threat to national security? And there's been some
- 5:48Speaker 5: seculation about this, but the best evidence of this has
- 5:51Speaker 5: not been revealed to the public. It's only been disclosed privately,
- 5:54Speaker 5: with the justification that because it's in national security interests,
- 5:58Speaker 5: we couldn't tell the public or we would jeopardize national security.
- 6:01Speaker 5: But that kind of rationale makes it impossible for us
- 6:05Speaker 5: to actually scrutinize credibly the evidence, and as a result,
- 6:09Speaker 5: it's possible that that evidence is not credible. And in fact,
- 6:12Speaker 5: the efforts to ban TikTok were initiated in the Trump
- 6:15Speaker 5: administration and some of the judges got to see that
- 6:19Speaker 5: evidence and they did not find a persuasive Now, maybe
- 6:22Speaker 5: there's new evidence that we haven't seen yet, but the
- 6:24Speaker 5: most likely scenario is that national security is being invoked
- 6:29Speaker 5: as a concept, not actually as pieces of specific credible
- 6:33Speaker 5: evidence to try and justify the ban.
- 6:35Speaker 2: The company TikTok has warned about the potential economic impact
- 6:40Speaker 2: on small business owners who depend on the app. It's
- 6:44Speaker 2: urged it's one hundred and seventy million US users to
- 6:47Speaker 2: speak out against it, and they have been influencers. Took
- 6:51Speaker 2: to Capital Hill on Wednesday. Members of Congress were flooded
- 6:55Speaker 2: with calls from angry constituents and small businesses are saying
- 7:00Speaker 2: ban would crush their business.
- 7:02Speaker 5: It's not just the economic impact, although I think that's
- 7:05Speaker 5: a helpful way of establishing a measuring stick, but so
- 7:08Speaker 5: many communities rely upon TikTok to communicate with each other,
- 7:13Speaker 5: and that can create new stars, celebrities, influencers who wouldn't
- 7:18Speaker 5: have had a voice any other way that are actually
- 7:20Speaker 5: quite helpful to the communities that they're speaking to. It
- 7:23Speaker 5: also has created a variety of different small business opportunities
- 7:28Speaker 5: where new entrants to a market can use social media,
- 7:31Speaker 5: including TikTok, in order to gain traction against incumbents who
- 7:34Speaker 5: otherwise would rather not give them any opportunity to grow.
- 7:38Speaker 5: So when Congress says that we want to ban TikTok,
- 7:41Speaker 5: what they're really saying is we don't want people talking
- 7:44Speaker 5: to each other in that way, and we don't care
- 7:46Speaker 5: that sometimes that's the very best way for those people
- 7:49Speaker 5: to help self actualize, or the very best way for
- 7:52Speaker 5: those entrepreneurs to help build their business. So Congress is
- 7:55Speaker 5: just saying, we'll care about any of that, all of
- 7:57Speaker 5: that we're willing to forego in this fibulous chasing of
- 8:02Speaker 5: quote national security interest.
- 8:04Speaker 2: TikTok is banned on federal devices, and Biden administration officials
- 8:09Speaker 2: help with the bill's technical language, but Biden's re election
- 8:13Speaker 2: campaign joined TikTok last month. I mean talk about irony.
- 8:18Speaker 5: Biden's presence on TikTok is a reminder that even if
- 8:22Speaker 5: Biden could reach audiences through other channels, there's value to
- 8:25Speaker 5: reach them through TikTok. And it is that exact political
- 8:29Speaker 5: speech benefit that shows how corrupt it is to try
- 8:33Speaker 5: and ban TikTok. It literally would suppress valuable political speech
- 8:38Speaker 5: coming from the President who would potentially sign the build
- 8:40Speaker 5: a bandit.
- 8:41Speaker 2: So now it's up to the Senate. Does it seem
- 8:43Speaker 2: like senators are not quite as enthralled with the bill
- 8:47Speaker 2: as the House was.
- 8:49Speaker 5: We don't know what's going to happen to the bill
- 8:51Speaker 5: in the Senate. The Senate leaders have created equivocation about
- 8:56Speaker 5: the bill, but the political calculus that got the bill
- 8:59Speaker 5: through the House is the same for the Senate. In
- 9:02Speaker 5: all cases, there's political goal for beating up on China
- 9:06Speaker 5: legitimately or not. So I don't think that the bill
- 9:09Speaker 5: will die in the Senate easily. It will be given
- 9:13Speaker 5: a fair amount of push I think forward. But number
- 9:16Speaker 5: of senators I think understand both the ridiculousness of the
- 9:19Speaker 5: justifications of the bill as well as the fact that
- 9:22Speaker 5: in the end, the bill is a censorship bill, and
- 9:24Speaker 5: I think there are some centers who just can't support that.
- 9:27Speaker 2: And TikTok says it plans to exhaust all legal challenges
- 9:32Speaker 2: before it considers divestiture. What kind of legal challenges could
- 9:36Speaker 2: TikTok bring?
- 9:37Speaker 5: No doubt that if the bill is enacted, it will
- 9:40Speaker 5: be challenged in court, and it will be challenged by
- 9:42Speaker 5: TikTok sometimes there's been discussion that TikTok doesn't have its
- 9:46Speaker 5: own First Amendment interest, it's just a vessel for other communications.
- 9:51Speaker 5: But TikTok publishes content in the form of the software
- 9:54Speaker 5: that it offers to its users, and it curates users
- 9:58Speaker 5: speech in a way that communicates its editorial Priorities and
- 10:01Speaker 5: courts have recognized that TikTok has a speech interest in
- 10:06Speaker 5: the publication of the software and in the way in
- 10:08Speaker 5: which it curates its content for its users. It's also
- 10:12Speaker 5: probable that it would be challenged by users of TikTok
- 10:15Speaker 5: expressing their own free speech concerns independent of the concerns
- 10:19Speaker 5: that TikTok has, and the bill will also impact the
- 10:22Speaker 5: app stores. The app stores have not previously taken the
- 10:25Speaker 5: leadership on challenging the constitutionality of TikTok bands or bands
- 10:30Speaker 5: of social media, but they're actually harmed as well. The
- 10:33Speaker 5: ban is kind of like telling a bookstore that they
- 10:38Speaker 5: can't carry a particular book. They can still run a bookstore,
- 10:41Speaker 5: but they just can't carry a book. And so for
- 10:44Speaker 5: the app store, they're being told you have to pull
- 10:46Speaker 5: an app off of your shelves. And by forcing the
- 10:50Speaker 5: bookstore or in this case, the app store to change
- 10:53Speaker 5: what it wants to offer to its users that encroaches
- 10:57Speaker 5: on the app speech interests as well. So there are
- 11:00Speaker 5: three different feach interests to play here tiktoks, TikTok users,
- 11:05Speaker 5: and the app stores, and we actually have some indication
- 11:09Speaker 5: of how those legal challenges might look. This is not
- 11:11Speaker 5: the first time that efforts to ban social media apps
- 11:15Speaker 5: have been attempted and have been challenged in court. Both
- 11:19Speaker 5: in the Trump administration, there was a ban on TikTok
- 11:22Speaker 5: and we chat, and then states have been enacting bands,
- 11:25Speaker 5: including an illegal challenge was filed against one in Montana.
- 11:28Speaker 5: And all of those efforts to ban in the past
- 11:31Speaker 5: have failed, including on First Amendment grounds those bands were unconstitutional.
- 11:37Speaker 5: And so it seems to me that TikTok and its
- 11:39Speaker 5: users and maybe the appsers have pretty good reasons to
- 11:42Speaker 5: think that they might win a First Amendment challenge.
- 11:45Speaker 2: So many lawsuits ahead if this bill is enacted. Thanks
- 11:49Speaker 2: so much, Eric, that's Professor Eric Goleman of Santa Clara
- 11:52Speaker 2: University Law School coming up. Accident investigators called Boeing's failure
- 11:57Speaker 2: to cooperate upsurd I'm June and Grosso when you're listening
- 12:01Speaker 2: to Bloomberg.
- 12:02Speaker 6: That was really praying.
- 12:03Speaker 2: I was asking God to put angels under the wings
- 12:06Speaker 2: to hold us up. It was January fifth when Alaska
- 12:09Speaker 2: Airlines Flight twelve andty two had a mid air emergency.
- 12:13Speaker 2: A door plug blowout left a gaping hole in the
- 12:16Speaker 2: side of the Boeing seven thirty seven Max, causing an
- 12:19Speaker 2: explosive decompression of the cabin, with terrified passengers exposed to
- 12:24Speaker 2: the freezing air at sixteen thousand feet as cell phones,
- 12:28Speaker 2: plane manuals, papers, and clothing were sucked out of the plane.
- 12:33Speaker 6: There was the loudest explosion. It was horrible. People were
- 12:40Speaker 6: very afraid. They were kind of crying and moaning.
- 12:44Speaker 2: It's been two months and officials with the National Transportation
- 12:48Speaker 2: Safety Board say they're still in the dark about who
- 12:51Speaker 2: performed the work on the fuselage panel that failed, despite
- 12:56Speaker 2: repeatedly asking Boeing for the information. NTSB share Jennifer Hammandy
- 13:01Speaker 2: told a Senate hearing last week that Boeing has withheld
- 13:05Speaker 2: documents and information, including the list of people who are
- 13:09Speaker 2: on the team that handles doors and door plugs.
- 13:12Speaker 7: We don't have the records, We don't have the names
- 13:15Speaker 7: of the twenty five people that is in charge of
- 13:19Speaker 7: doing that work in that facility. It's absurd that two
- 13:23Speaker 7: months later we don't have that.
- 13:26Speaker 2: The FAA has stepped up oversight of Boeing after several
- 13:30Speaker 2: recent incidents and questions about its quality assurance at its factories.
- 13:35Speaker 2: FAA Administrator Michael Whittaker says its inspectors are in Boeing's
- 13:39Speaker 2: factories demanding answers from the company and making sure their
- 13:44Speaker 2: airplanes are safe to fly on.
- 13:46Speaker 3: Right now, with our oversight, we're certifying them as safe.
- 13:49Speaker 2: Yes, and the US Department of Justice has opened a
- 13:52Speaker 2: criminal investigation into the mid air blowout and specifically whether
- 13:56Speaker 2: Boeing violated its twenty twenty one defer prosecution agreement over
- 14:02Speaker 2: two deadly crashes of its seven thirty seven Max aircraft.
- 14:06Speaker 2: Joining me is Alan levin Bloomberg Aviation safety reporter. Alan
- 14:10Speaker 2: start by telling us what is known about the Alaska
- 14:14Speaker 2: Airlines mid air emergency.
- 14:16Speaker 8: This plane took off from Portland in the evening of
- 14:20Speaker 8: January fifth, and when it reached about fourteen fifteen thousand feet,
- 14:26Speaker 8: the cabin pressure suddenly dropped. And what happened was there's
- 14:32Speaker 8: what is known as a door plug, which is basically
- 14:35Speaker 8: just a beefed up panel that covers an unused exit door,
- 14:41Speaker 8: and it blew off the side of the plane and
- 14:44Speaker 8: then there's like a river if you will pressurized air
- 14:48Speaker 8: flowing out through this, it can be quite powerful. Luckily,
- 14:53Speaker 8: they were not at you know, thirty five thousand feet
- 14:55Speaker 8: where it would have been even more intense. And also
- 14:57Speaker 8: luckily nobody was seated next to where the door plug
- 15:01Speaker 8: was or in the middle seat, so the two closest
- 15:04Speaker 8: seats were empty on a very full plane. It's kind
- 15:07Speaker 8: of lucky. As dramatic as this was, nobody was injured,
- 15:11Speaker 8: amazing no damage to the aircraft structure, and the pilots
- 15:17Speaker 8: were able to return and make an emergency landing.
- 15:21Speaker 2: The NTSB has determined that those missing bolts caused.
- 15:26Speaker 8: The incident, so it's a little early to say the cause,
- 15:30Speaker 8: but the NTSB did put out a preliminary report and
- 15:33Speaker 8: they said there's very strong indications that this plug or
- 15:37Speaker 8: this panel over the unused door was not attached properly
- 15:42Speaker 8: in the factory. It's in rent in Washington that Boeing
- 15:46Speaker 8: uses to complete the construction of these seven thirty seven
- 15:51Speaker 8: mac jets. In particular, there's an extensive mechanism to hold
- 15:56Speaker 8: the pressure on the door, about a dozen points of
- 16:00Speaker 8: these pins, but they don't ensure the door will never
- 16:04Speaker 8: come off. So Boeing adds four bolts in there so
- 16:08Speaker 8: the door can never move, and if installed correctly, they
- 16:12Speaker 8: work pretty well because this has never happened before. But
- 16:16Speaker 8: in this case, all the evidence suggests that the bolts
- 16:20Speaker 8: were not installed, and so the plane think it was
- 16:23Speaker 8: delivered in October, it went into service in November, and
- 16:27Speaker 8: it bumped around enough that it came loose on this flight.
- 16:31Speaker 2: So the NTSB accident investigators still don't know who performed
- 16:36Speaker 2: the work on that panel that failed.
- 16:39Speaker 8: That's correct. It's quite extraordinary actually how this investigation has evolved,
- 16:46Speaker 8: if you will, so any factory, you know, you theoretically
- 16:50Speaker 8: have records of the construction of whatever widgets they're making,
- 16:54Speaker 8: But in the aviation industry, the record keeping is on steroids.
- 16:58Speaker 8: Anytime you do a safety critical thing, you're supposed to
- 17:02Speaker 8: memorialize it, you know, in this case it's a computer system.
- 17:05Speaker 8: When that happens for a critical item like this, there's
- 17:09Speaker 8: supposed to be a second set of eyes who comes
- 17:12Speaker 8: in afterward and certifies that it was done properly. Now,
- 17:16Speaker 8: in this case, Boeing has said that they do not
- 17:20Speaker 8: have a record of this work being performed, and in fact,
- 17:25Speaker 8: they an extraordinary mission last week in a letter to
- 17:28Speaker 8: the Senate they said that it was a violation of
- 17:31Speaker 8: their processes and so as you say, as a part
- 17:35Speaker 8: of that, they do not know who performed the work,
- 17:40Speaker 8: and the NTSB has been asking Boeing for information. The
- 17:45Speaker 8: NTSB is frustrated because they can't get the names of
- 17:49Speaker 8: the key people to interview, so instead they had to
- 17:52Speaker 8: ask for the names of every person who might have
- 17:56Speaker 8: done work on a door assembly in the plan at
- 18:00Speaker 8: the time this plane was moving through. We're told it's
- 18:03Speaker 8: twenty five people. They were in rent in Washington at
- 18:07Speaker 8: this plant doing interviews last week. But the head of
- 18:10Speaker 8: the NTSB, Jennifer Hammandy, this week told senators that they
- 18:15Speaker 8: still have been unable to determine who did it.
- 18:18Speaker 2: So now, you also had a Federal Aviation Administration audit
- 18:23Speaker 2: of Boeing seven thirty seven MAX that found a plethora
- 18:28Speaker 2: of issues with the production process.
- 18:31Speaker 8: That's correct. We understand there were dozens of violations, but
- 18:36Speaker 8: we still don't know the detail. I would add that
- 18:40Speaker 8: the fa also audited a second company called Spirit Aerospace,
- 18:45Speaker 8: which builds the raw fuselage parts for the seven thirty
- 18:49Speaker 8: seven and then ships them to Washington State where Boeing
- 18:53Speaker 8: does the final assembly, and they found violations at Spirit
- 18:57Speaker 8: as well. It's relevant because the reason this door plug
- 19:02Speaker 8: got removed in the first place at the factory is
- 19:05Speaker 8: that there were improperly done rivets by the Spirit folks,
- 19:09Speaker 8: and so they had to go in and fix those.
- 19:12Speaker 8: But the bottom line is we don't know the precise
- 19:14Speaker 8: details of how bad the violations were, but they did
- 19:17Speaker 8: find dozens of cases where there were shortfalls in the
- 19:22Speaker 8: safety processes and record keeping, etc. That FAA expects.
- 19:26Speaker 2: So we've seen several mishaps with Boeing aircraft recently, flaming engines,
- 19:33Speaker 2: tires falling from the sky, engine failures over the Pacific,
- 19:37Speaker 2: malfunctioning rudders, issues with wiring gears and hydraulic systems. It
- 19:43Speaker 2: strikes me as really concerning. Well.
- 19:45Speaker 8: I have two almost contradictory points here. One is that
- 19:49Speaker 8: in the case of the tire falling off, it was
- 19:52Speaker 8: quite dramatic. Somebody video taped it and the tire came
- 19:56Speaker 8: down and hit a car in a parking lot. It
- 19:58Speaker 8: was in San Francisco. You know that's not a good look,
- 20:02Speaker 8: but it was a twenty plus year old plane. That
- 20:06Speaker 8: failure had absolutely nothing to do with Boeing. We don't
- 20:09Speaker 8: know what happened, but you think it would be related
- 20:11Speaker 8: to maintenance somehow. Quite frankly, if you keep an eye
- 20:16Speaker 8: on incidents on a daily basis, as I've done many years,
- 20:21Speaker 8: these things happen all the time. I think it's fair
- 20:25Speaker 8: to say the accident rates are remarkable. They'd never been better,
- 20:29Speaker 8: and these incidents, I think demonstrate that the safety net
- 20:33Speaker 8: is pretty robust. But I would also say that one
- 20:37Speaker 8: of those incidents that you mentioned does speak to broader
- 20:41Speaker 8: issues with Boeing. There was a notice by the federal
- 20:45Speaker 8: government last week that seven thirty seven MAX wiring had
- 20:49Speaker 8: been improperly installed, and what happened was a flight control
- 20:54Speaker 8: device known as a spoiler was activating without a pilot
- 20:59Speaker 8: intending for it to activate. That speaks to some of
- 21:03Speaker 8: these very same issues with quality that we've seen with
- 21:07Speaker 8: Boeing in this door plug.
- 21:09Speaker 2: The Department of Justice has opened a criminal investigation into
- 21:13Speaker 2: the Alaska Airlines incident examining whether it falls under the
- 21:19Speaker 2: government's twenty twenty one deferred prosecution agreement with Boeing. And
- 21:23Speaker 2: by the way, the accident took place just two days
- 21:26Speaker 2: before that agreement was to expire. Tell us about that.
- 21:30Speaker 8: Several years ago, after these two fatal accidents in twenty
- 21:35Speaker 8: eighteen and twenty nineteen involving seven thirty seven Max aircraft.
- 21:40Speaker 8: If you recall, the accidents were caused at least in
- 21:44Speaker 8: part by a bad design that Boeing had put into
- 21:48Speaker 8: the plane, and afterward the Justice Department reached an agreement
- 21:54Speaker 8: not to prosecute Boeing, and in exchange, Boeing admitted to
- 21:59Speaker 8: a violation and agreed to pay a large civil penalty
- 22:04Speaker 8: and then also agreed to essentially clean up attact over
- 22:09Speaker 8: a three year period. That period, as you say, was
- 22:12Speaker 8: about to expire. The Justice Department has six months to
- 22:17Speaker 8: decide whether Boeing has violated is this earlier agreement. We
- 22:23Speaker 8: understand that they've convened a grand jury to look at
- 22:27Speaker 8: whether there are criminal charges to be brought. There are
- 22:30Speaker 8: two possibilities. We understand it's possible they could say that
- 22:34Speaker 8: Boeing violated the earlier agreements and then they would bring
- 22:39Speaker 8: the charges on that, or they are also potentially looking
- 22:44Speaker 8: at bringing charges related to the actual January fifth failure. Now,
- 22:49Speaker 8: I would note some countries France, for example, almost always
- 22:54Speaker 8: files a criminal charge after an airline accident, but it's
- 22:59Speaker 8: very unusual in the US and quite controversial. The National
- 23:04Speaker 8: Transportation Safety Board can't stop the DOJ and never would
- 23:09Speaker 8: try to do that, but they operate an environment in
- 23:12Speaker 8: which they never bring criminal charges or even civil violations
- 23:16Speaker 8: against entities that have accidents, and they encourage people to
- 23:20Speaker 8: speak freely about how a failure occurred so that they
- 23:23Speaker 8: can try to prevent it from happening in the future.
- 23:26Speaker 8: And you can imagine a case like this where the
- 23:29Speaker 8: Department of Justice is panneling a grand jury and all
- 23:33Speaker 8: the workers on the shop floor are going to hire
- 23:37Speaker 8: lawyers and perhaps decline to speak to the NTSB. It's
- 23:41Speaker 8: happened on other non aviation accidents, but some pretty high
- 23:45Speaker 8: profile fatal accidents that NTSP has looked at in recent
- 23:50Speaker 8: years where they weren't able to interview key participants because
- 23:54Speaker 8: of ongoing criminal investigation. So anyway, we're very early on.
- 23:58Speaker 8: It's unclear how it's going to play, but It's a
- 24:00Speaker 8: very sticky, complicated situation.
- 24:03Speaker 2: We should learn more, but it may not be until August.
- 24:06Speaker 2: That's when the NTSB has scheduled an investigative public hearing
- 24:11Speaker 2: into the Boeing door plug blowout. Thanks so much, Alan.
- 24:14Speaker 2: That's Alan Levin, Bloomberg Aviation Safety Reporter. Coming up next
- 24:19Speaker 2: on the Bloomberg Lawn Show. The federal government is trying
- 24:22Speaker 2: an unprecedented legal move to protect a world renowned national
- 24:27Speaker 2: wildlife refuge in Georgia. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 24:31Speaker 2: to Bloomberg.
- 24:33Speaker 1: There is a softness to the Okefinoke, a welcome that
- 24:37Speaker 1: somehow seems to contradict the very notion of swamp. The
- 24:44Speaker 1: ok finoch a blackwater swamp, is one of the largest
- 24:49Speaker 1: and most significant wetland complexes in the United States.
- 24:54Speaker 2: The Oke Finoke National Wildlife Refuge is a pristine six
- 24:59Speaker 2: hundred and eighty si square mile wilderness in Georgia, an
- 25:02Speaker 2: ecological wonder that's a haven for threatened and endangered species
- 25:07Speaker 2: and world renowned for its amphibian populations. It's one of
- 25:10Speaker 2: the world's largest intact freshwater ecosystems. Designated a Wetland of
- 25:16Speaker 2: International importance by the United Nations in nineteen seventy one.
- 25:20Speaker 2: But there's a long running battle over the Okefinoke, and
- 25:23Speaker 2: the federal government is making an unprecedented claim to protect it,
- 25:28Speaker 2: asserting federal reserved water rights to prevent a mining company
- 25:32Speaker 2: from pumping so much groundwater for a proposed titanium dioxide
- 25:36Speaker 2: mine that it could cut off part of the swamp's
- 25:39Speaker 2: water source, imperiling its biodiversity and original purpose as a
- 25:44Speaker 2: refuge from migratory birds. Joining me is water rights expert
- 25:48Speaker 2: Ryan Roeberry, a professor at the Georgia State University College
- 25:52Speaker 2: of Law. Ryan tell us about this battle over the Okefenoke.
- 25:56Speaker 9: Sure. I mean, the facts are quite simple.
- 25:58Speaker 5: There is the.
- 26:00Speaker 9: Swamp, part of which is a national wildlife refuge, obviously
- 26:05Speaker 9: a very large swamp in southern Georgia. About three miles
- 26:08Speaker 9: away from that, in the southeast section of the Oke
- 26:11Speaker 9: Pinochi Swamp. Mining company will apply for some groundwater pumping
- 26:15Speaker 9: permit to mine titanium dioxide, and that process of sort
- 26:20Speaker 9: of using the groundwater and pumping the groundwater would affect
- 26:24Speaker 9: the water flow going through the Oke Pinochi National Wildlife Refuge.
- 26:27Speaker 9: So that is the challenge right now. It's the water
- 26:30Speaker 9: quantity issue that may happen because of these permits, and would.
- 26:35Speaker 2: That lack of water be a hazard to the species
- 26:38Speaker 2: there that have been protected absolutely.
- 26:40Speaker 9: If it's Some hydrologists have studied this and they say
- 26:43Speaker 9: that they could cause a diminution of water about sixteen
- 26:45Speaker 9: percent of the recharge of the aquifer that sort of
- 26:49Speaker 9: naturally feeds the oke Pinochi National Wildlife Refuge. If that happens,
- 26:53Speaker 9: that has a very big negative impact on some endangered species,
- 26:57Speaker 9: the ability of the swamp, and it's the creatures inside
- 27:00Speaker 9: and swamp, some of the trees, grasses, some of the animals.
- 27:03Speaker 9: It would negatively impact them if there's a sixteen percent
- 27:06Speaker 9: diminution And that is what's an issue here is what
- 27:10Speaker 9: kind of damage, if any, would be groundwater permits posed
- 27:14Speaker 9: to the National Wildlife Refuge. And that's when you get
- 27:17Speaker 9: into the hydrology of it.
- 27:19Speaker 2: And the Georgia Environmental Protection Division issued a draft permit
- 27:24Speaker 2: to the mining company and held a public hearing.
- 27:27Speaker 9: So this has been going on for a couple of
- 27:28Speaker 9: years now. This has not just come out of the blue,
- 27:31Speaker 9: and now they are in the midst of the draft
- 27:34Speaker 9: permit is sort of thing. This is the permit we
- 27:36Speaker 9: want to give the mining company. They're accepting public comment
- 27:39Speaker 9: on it, I believe, up until the early part of April,
- 27:43Speaker 9: at which time they will make a decision on whether
- 27:45Speaker 9: to grant the permit to the mining company or not.
- 27:49Speaker 2: I've read some of the comments on the website for
- 27:52Speaker 2: the Okefinoke, with people talking about its pristine beauty, its
- 27:57Speaker 2: other worldliness, how unique it is is the public in
- 28:01Speaker 2: favor of allowing mining that might imperil that most people that.
- 28:06Speaker 9: I saw, who are far more concerned about the national
- 28:09Speaker 9: wildlife refuge. We don't have many spots like this in
- 28:12Speaker 9: the East, particularly the Eastern United States. I'm sure there
- 28:15Speaker 9: are people on the other side that would say, you know,
- 28:17Speaker 9: of course the mine would provide jobs, the economy, those
- 28:20Speaker 9: kinds of things, and so there's always going to be
- 28:22Speaker 9: a built intention between sort of preservation or economic development.
- 28:26Speaker 2: So the US Fish and Wildlife Service made a claim
- 28:29Speaker 2: in January asserting its federal reserved water rights at Okafenoke.
- 28:35Speaker 2: Is that unusual?
- 28:37Speaker 9: Absolutely, this is highly unusual. In fact, I think it's
- 28:40Speaker 9: the first time that federal or reserve water rights have
- 28:43Speaker 9: been asserted east of the Mississippi River. And the reason
- 28:47Speaker 9: for that is in the United States, we generally speaking
- 28:50Speaker 9: have two different water systems, one for the West, one
- 28:52Speaker 9: for the East. In the West, where it's very arid
- 28:55Speaker 9: and dry where I grew up in Idaho and Colorado,
- 28:58Speaker 9: you have prior appropriation first, in time first, and right
- 29:02Speaker 9: there's sort of the pecking order of who gets the water.
- 29:04Speaker 9: The federal the government has asserted its better reserve water rights,
- 29:08Speaker 9: which is simply a claim that when the federal government
- 29:10Speaker 9: reserves some land, that it also implicitly reserves the water
- 29:14Speaker 9: necessary for that lands to function as a reservation. That
- 29:17Speaker 9: has been asserted in the West. In the East we
- 29:20Speaker 9: have a regulated riparian system. Riparian system is predicated on
- 29:25Speaker 9: the premise that there's enough water for everybody, you just
- 29:28Speaker 9: have to share it reasonably. And I think one of
- 29:31Speaker 9: the challenges is is that with climate change, with increased
- 29:34Speaker 9: industrial use, we are seeing that there might not be
- 29:37Speaker 9: enough water for everybody anymore in the riparian states. And
- 29:41Speaker 9: so in this case, the US Fish and Wildlife Service
- 29:44Speaker 9: has asserted its cetter reserve water rights, which again in
- 29:47Speaker 9: a riparian state. I believe this is the first time
- 29:49Speaker 9: this has happened. So yes, it is a big deal.
- 29:52Speaker 2: The mining company claims a that the mind won't harm
- 29:56Speaker 2: the reserve and that federal reserve water rights is exclusive
- 30:01Speaker 2: to Western water law. Where do you stand on this.
- 30:04Speaker 9: I don't think it's exclusive to Western water law at all.
- 30:07Speaker 9: I mean, there is some argument that says, well, it
- 30:10Speaker 9: has to be land that was reserved in the public domain,
- 30:13Speaker 9: of which Georgia was not part of that because it's
- 30:15Speaker 9: part of the original thirteen colonies. But to me, the
- 30:18Speaker 9: doctrine of federal reserve water rights, it doesn't depend on
- 30:21Speaker 9: the status of the land that the government reserved. It
- 30:24Speaker 9: simply depends upon the reason for which the federal government
- 30:27Speaker 9: reserved the land. In the case of the Oki Sanoki,
- 30:30Speaker 9: it reserved the land to protect the water, the wildlife,
- 30:33Speaker 9: the tree, et cetera. And therefore the intent would have
- 30:36Speaker 9: been to preserve enough water for the congressionally recognized intent
- 30:40Speaker 9: to take place. So I am not of the opinion
- 30:43Speaker 9: it's just a Western issue. I think that the facts
- 30:46Speaker 9: on the ground have changed and that there's not enough
- 30:49Speaker 9: water in the East for everybody anymore, and this is
- 30:52Speaker 9: a right that the federal government can assert. There's no
- 30:55Speaker 9: problems in my opinion.
- 30:56Speaker 2: So the acting Regional Director of Fish and Wildlife Service
- 30:59Speaker 2: Might Volker said that federal reserve water rights include all
- 31:03Speaker 2: the water needed to maintain the purpose of the Okefinocchi Refuge,
- 31:07Speaker 2: which President Franklin Roosevelt created to protect migratory birds in
- 31:11Speaker 2: nineteen thirty seven with an executive order under the Migratory
- 31:15Speaker 2: Bird Conservation Act. Shouldn't that be enough that it's a
- 31:18Speaker 2: federal reserve and it has to be protected.
- 31:21Speaker 9: Yeah, I mean the challengerial again is the groundwater pumping permit.
- 31:25Speaker 9: The permits are not on the federal reserve right, they
- 31:29Speaker 9: are outside of it by about three miles. And so
- 31:31Speaker 9: the issue then is what kinds of things can the
- 31:35Speaker 9: federal government regulate that don't actually take place on federal
- 31:40Speaker 9: land but could impact federal lands. And so that's I
- 31:44Speaker 9: think the real nub of the issue here. And the
- 31:47Speaker 9: simple fact that cedera reserve water rights has not been
- 31:50Speaker 9: asserted in the East has led some people to believe
- 31:52Speaker 9: that well, they aren't applicable in a rip Aerian jurisdiction,
- 31:55Speaker 9: which again I think is wrong. It's just the fact
- 31:58Speaker 9: that probably we've had enough water the past to handle
- 32:01Speaker 9: everything and now that seems to be changing.
- 32:04Speaker 2: So tell us about this unanimous nineteen seventy six Supreme
- 32:08Speaker 2: Court opinion that the Fish and Wildlife Service is relying on.
- 32:14Speaker 9: Sure, that's the case of USB. Caffert, and that was
- 32:18Speaker 9: an assertion of a federal reserve water right for the
- 32:21Speaker 9: Devil's Hole to protect a small type of fish, So
- 32:24Speaker 9: that would be in the Western United States. Again, but
- 32:27Speaker 9: this also expanded the notion of federal reserve water rights
- 32:31Speaker 9: not just do Native American reservations or national parks, but
- 32:35Speaker 9: to all federal reservations, that includes national wildlife refuges, et cetera.
- 32:40Speaker 9: And simply stated, Caffert says, the primary purpose of a
- 32:44Speaker 9: federal reservation, that primary purpose needs to be served by
- 32:48Speaker 9: the water that is allotted to it. So it's really
- 32:50Speaker 9: the protection of the primary purpose for which a reservation
- 32:54Speaker 9: was made. And in the case of the Okifinoki Swamp,
- 32:57Speaker 9: clearly water is part of a swamp and part of
- 33:00Speaker 9: the national wildlife refuge and so fulfilling that primary purpose.
- 33:04Speaker 9: It's whatever that minimum amount is needed to fulfill the
- 33:07Speaker 9: primary purpose, and that minimum amount nobody knows. Nobody knows
- 33:11Speaker 9: what is the minimum amount needed, and so that would
- 33:13Speaker 9: require hydrologists to sort of get active and get involved,
- 33:17Speaker 9: and I'm sure there will be disputes over what is
- 33:19Speaker 9: the minimum amount necessary.
- 33:20Speaker 2: Do most water rights experts think that federal water rights
- 33:25Speaker 2: take precedence over state groundwater rights?
- 33:28Speaker 9: Absolutely? Absolutely, the federal claim would take precedence. That's pretty clear.
- 33:33Speaker 9: If the federal reserve water rights this, it supersedes state
- 33:37Speaker 9: water right.
- 33:37Speaker 2: So what do experts disagree on?
- 33:40Speaker 9: Well, I think some experts disagree on whether federal reserve
- 33:43Speaker 9: water rights exist in riparian states like Georgia and regulated
- 33:47Speaker 9: riparian states. And then the question is is how do
- 33:50Speaker 9: you make it fit. You're essentially saying we should privilege
- 33:54Speaker 9: the water usage of the National Wildlife Refuge in the Okefinoke,
- 33:59Speaker 9: oh for other competing claims from mining companies or municipal
- 34:04Speaker 9: industrial use. How are you going to fit that in
- 34:07Speaker 9: through a system that for many years has not really
- 34:10Speaker 9: looked at who gets it first, who gets the second,
- 34:13Speaker 9: But it's been based off of are you using the
- 34:16Speaker 9: water reasonably? And that's a very different question than in
- 34:19Speaker 9: the West, where you have a pecking order that is
- 34:22Speaker 9: clearly established on who gets the first amount and how
- 34:24Speaker 9: much they get who gets the second? We don't have
- 34:27Speaker 9: those same systems set up in the East, So how
- 34:29Speaker 9: it fits in to a sort of a reasonable use
- 34:32Speaker 9: standard system, which is very sort of ambiguous and opaque,
- 34:36Speaker 9: is still to be determined.
- 34:38Speaker 2: Wut this end with the Georgia Environmental Protection Division saying no,
- 34:43Speaker 2: we're not going to give you a permit.
- 34:45Speaker 9: It's possible, It's possible. I think what's going to happen
- 34:48Speaker 9: and what should happen is that Georgia EPD and the
- 34:51Speaker 9: US Fish and Wildlife Service need to sit down and
- 34:54Speaker 9: talk about this at are reserved water right? And more importantly,
- 34:57Speaker 9: how much water is necessary for the oke finoke to
- 35:01Speaker 9: actually fulfill its mandated purpose. I think that should be
- 35:05Speaker 9: the next step. I don't think it has to be
- 35:07Speaker 9: yes or no on the permit. I think it should
- 35:09Speaker 9: be We're going to have to wait until we figure
- 35:11Speaker 9: out these conversations with the US fishion Wildlife Service.
- 35:14Speaker 2: This has been going on for quite a while. I'm
- 35:16Speaker 2: surprised there's been no lawsuit filed yet.
- 35:20Speaker 9: Well, the question about whether they were going to get
- 35:22Speaker 9: a permit, how much water would they be pumping out
- 35:25Speaker 9: of the ground, et cetera. And then once you find
- 35:28Speaker 9: out all that information, well, does that harm or could
- 35:31Speaker 9: it harm the Oke Finoke Swamp or not? All of
- 35:35Speaker 9: those questions. That's what's been going on over the several years.
- 35:37Speaker 9: There's been a lot of fact finding and a lot
- 35:40Speaker 9: of documents being put together so that Georgia EPD would
- 35:43Speaker 9: be able to assess whether or not a permit should
- 35:46Speaker 9: be granted. So that's what's been going on. And it
- 35:49Speaker 9: takes years for mining permits to happen, so this is
- 35:51Speaker 9: not abnormal. This is part of the process of any
- 35:54Speaker 9: sort of large mining operation, whether in the Western US
- 35:57Speaker 9: or the East. So it takes a lot of ground wars,
- 36:00Speaker 9: gets your permits in order so that you can bring
- 36:02Speaker 9: a mine online.
- 36:03Speaker 2: And if this isn't settled, could this turn out to
- 36:06Speaker 2: be a groundbreaking case.
- 36:08Speaker 9: If the federal government starts asserting set to reserve water
- 36:10Speaker 9: rights in the East, which I believe they can, those
- 36:13Speaker 9: rights don't go away just because they have not asserted
- 36:16Speaker 9: them before. If they do that for the Oke Pinochi,
- 36:19Speaker 9: well you have to then look at all of the
- 36:20Speaker 9: other federal reservations in the East and the potential that
- 36:24Speaker 9: they could assert water rights or let's say, you know, Swampson,
- 36:28Speaker 9: South Carolina, or places in West Virginia that are federal reservations.
- 36:33Speaker 9: So this is much broader than the ok Pinocchi. This
- 36:36Speaker 9: is the federal government I think saying, you know, we
- 36:39Speaker 9: do have water rights. That is a tool in our toolbox,
- 36:42Speaker 9: and if we decide to use them anywhere that there
- 36:45Speaker 9: is a federal reservation whose primary purpose involves water, that
- 36:49Speaker 9: gives a hook for the federal government to have a
- 36:51Speaker 9: seat at the table. Essentially, if the federal government is
- 36:54Speaker 9: taking a stronger stance saying if you are going to
- 36:57Speaker 9: issue groundwater permit and we have a problem with that,
- 37:00Speaker 9: this legal doctrine is PEO will compel parties to have
- 37:02Speaker 9: to talk to them.
- 37:04Speaker 2: I find this such a fascinating topic. Thanks so much. Ryan.
- 37:07Speaker 2: That's Professor Ryan Roberry of the Georgia State University College
- 37:11Speaker 2: of Law. And that's it for this edition of the
- 37:13Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can always get the latest
- 37:16Speaker 2: legal news by subscribing and listening to the show on
- 37:19Speaker 2: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com Slash podcast
- 37:24Speaker 2: Slash Law. I'm June Grosso and this is Bloomberg