Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Part Two: Appellate Oral Argument from the Decisionmaker's Perspective
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everybody and welcome to part two of Appellate
- 0:07Oral Arguments from the Decision -Makers Perspective.
- 0:10I'd just like to note this is part two of a two
- 0:12-part series and so if you haven't watched part
- 0:16one, I do recommend that you reach out to us
- 0:19and we can send it to you or you can find it
- 0:21on the website. The first part was about brief
- 0:25writing. The second part is about oral argument.
- 0:27So they are very different. And we hope that
- 0:29you will get a lot out of today, even if you
- 0:32hadn't watched part one. But we do suggest that
- 0:36you go take a look at part one as well. My name
- 0:38is Connor Tucker. I'm the chair of the appellate
- 0:41law section here at the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:44And I'm delighted to reintroduce our speakers,
- 0:47MC Sungayla and Melanie Gold. Ms. Sangela is
- 0:52a partner at the Complex Appellate Litigation
- 0:54Group, where she has briefed or argued more than
- 0:57170 appeals in areas including employment, class
- 1:01action, products, liability, and constitutional
- 1:04law. She's handled appeals before the U .S. Supreme
- 1:07Court, several state supreme courts, and numerous
- 1:09federal and state appellate courts. Early in
- 1:12her career, she clerked for Judge Fernandez on
- 1:15the Ninth Circuit, and she has taught appellate
- 1:17law at UC Irvine, Loyola, and Whittier. She's
- 1:21written widely on appellate practice for the
- 1:23ABA and the CEB. She's also the creator and host
- 1:27of the award -winning podcast, The Porsche Project,
- 1:30which features conversations with leading women
- 1:32judges and lawyers. Twice named California Lawyer
- 1:36of the Year, she's earned dozens of honors for
- 1:39her advocacy and for her pro bono and community
- 1:42service. Melanie Gold is a partner at Complex
- 1:45Appellate Litigation Group who spent more than
- 1:47three decades as a research attorney for California's
- 1:50appellate courts. She worked primarily with the
- 1:53justices of the 4th District Court of Appeal
- 1:55in San Diego and also with the 6th District and
- 1:58the California Supreme Court. Over those years,
- 2:01she's analyzed thousands of briefs and petitions,
- 2:04advised justices on hundreds of appeals, and
- 2:06helped draft nearly 1 ,000 opinions across areas
- 2:09including anti -SLAP, real property, employment,
- 2:12arbitration, and class action law. That work
- 2:15gave her a close view of the appellate courts
- 2:17and how they actually decide cases. She has taught
- 2:20appellate advocacy at the University of San Diego
- 2:23and California Western, and she founded and chairs
- 2:26the San Diego County Bar Association's access
- 2:28to appellate justice program. So with no further
- 2:32ado, take it off MC and Melanie. All right. Thank
- 2:37you so much for the introduction and thank you
- 2:39to everyone who is joining us. Twice yesterday
- 2:44and today for this program, which together is,
- 2:49you know, really just concise symposium on both
- 2:54brief writing and oral argument and the art of
- 2:56those two things. So next slide, please. I wanted
- 3:03to start or we want to start with a little clip.
- 3:07Supreme Court of Justice in the can of worms
- 3:11argument. But each country is different and poses
- 3:14different conditions. Unlike, say, Cuba, in Austria's
- 3:16case, there's a treaty, so there's no dispute
- 3:18as to what type of law could apply. We recommend
- 3:22opening the can and extracting just the one little
- 3:26worm with a pair of tweezers and then quickly
- 3:29closing it shut again. The defendants in this
- 3:33case have continuously tried to frustrate our
- 3:35attempts, raising every possible objection, threatening
- 3:37an Armageddon in international relations, but
- 3:39let's put things into perspective here. This
- 3:42is a case of one woman wanting back what is rightfully
- 3:46hers. Mrs. Altman came to America as a young
- 3:50woman in search of peace. Let's give her justice
- 3:54too. All right, next slide please. I think we
- 4:03all hope that we would have a cinema -worthy
- 4:06oral argument like Ryan Reynolds and his client
- 4:10Helen Marin there. That was a reenactment with
- 4:16some license, I think, in the Woman in Gold movie
- 4:20of Randy Schoenberg's argument before the US
- 4:24Supreme Court. where he was successful in getting
- 4:28the return of the Klimt paintings from Austria
- 4:31to Mrs. Altman. So there is one good, I think,
- 4:36example from that clip, which is have a theme.
- 4:38He clearly had a theme and a little David and
- 4:42Goliath theme there. So today, I want to just
- 4:47give a quick intro and overview of where we're
- 4:50going. We've framed both of these presentations
- 4:53in terms of the decision -maker's perspective.
- 4:56So we're looking at both oral argument and appellate
- 4:59briefs as persuasive tools for the audience that
- 5:03you want to persuade, for the judges, for their
- 5:05staff and research attorneys. and looking at
- 5:09them through that lens. And so that's what we'll
- 5:11be doing here again today with oral argument,
- 5:13just as we did with appellate briefing. And looking
- 5:16at them really together as a whole as well, because
- 5:20it's really a continuum of persuasion from the
- 5:24brief to oral argument. And what things would
- 5:27you do in oral argument that you might not do
- 5:28in an appellate brief? And how does all of that
- 5:31fit together to be effective with the court?
- 5:36The other thing is to think about oral argument
- 5:38from the perspective of the decision maker. For
- 5:41you as the advocate, that's the last input you
- 5:44can have into the case. So for you, that's sort
- 5:46of the end of the case. But for the court and
- 5:49for the judges you're talking to and having a
- 5:52conversation with, that is not the end. That's
- 5:55really the beginning of a lot of their work in
- 5:58drafting an opinion and conferring with justices
- 6:00and things like that, especially in the federal
- 6:02courts. you know, aware of that. So, Melanie,
- 6:11do you want to say something too about this in
- 6:13terms of the perspective in the process? Yes,
- 6:17and I know the state I'm more focused on the
- 6:19state and you'll see emcees more focused on the
- 6:21federal. They are different in in a moral argument.
- 6:25So thank you all for coming and we want to try
- 6:27to give you some of these inside tips in part
- 6:30one discussion. We talked about a written brief
- 6:33central importance in appeals, particularly in
- 6:36the California appellate courts that generally
- 6:40the justices have a fully formed opinion before
- 6:43the oral argument. So That is certainly important.
- 6:49But oral argument also plays a crucial role in
- 6:52the decision -making process. And most justices
- 6:55see it that way. And most really look forward
- 6:58to oral argument. They're stuck in their chamber
- 7:00all day. They're used to all the activity in
- 7:04the trial courts. They get to the court of appeals
- 7:05very quiet. So they do like the interaction.
- 7:09But before we get into the details, I wanted
- 7:11to make one quick foundational point. Oral argument
- 7:15is really miss named it should be called oral
- 7:19conversation not oral argument a conversation
- 7:23requires not only listening but not only talking.
- 7:29But also listening. And that's a key feature
- 7:31of oral argument. To do this, your core goal,
- 7:35and we'll talk in many different ways about this,
- 7:37is to draw out the panel's views and directly
- 7:40address them or support them. The court really
- 7:43wants to get it right, and they want information
- 7:45from you about what's right. So similar to the
- 7:49role of an appellate brief writer, the role of
- 7:52an appellate advocate at oral argument is to
- 7:54be a helper to the court, to be a partner, and
- 7:57to provide information that will help the justices
- 8:00reach the correct decision. So we'll be talking
- 8:03about details, but be thinking about that theme
- 8:05as we go along. MC? Okay. Yeah. Next slide, please.
- 8:12All right. So we're going to walk through the
- 8:15oral argument process just as we did with the
- 8:17appellate brief writing process. And sort of
- 8:19the first question is Should you, if you have
- 8:22the ability to, which you can in the California
- 8:25Court of Appeal, but not in the Federal Court
- 8:27of Appeals, if you have the ability to ask for
- 8:29argument, should you, and my answer to that is
- 8:36yes, always. I think that it is your very last
- 8:42opportunity to have a conversation with the justices
- 8:46to see what is. bothering them, what is concerning
- 8:49them to see if there is something, maybe a misapprehension
- 8:53of something in the record. It's really your
- 8:59last chance to make the pitch on your client's
- 9:01behalf. And so I would never give up an opportunity
- 9:04to do that. Folks could debate if you have a
- 9:12tentative opinion against you or in your favor,
- 9:16whether you would ask for that. But I think you
- 9:19can count on the other side who's on the losing
- 9:21end to ask for arguments. So you will be showing
- 9:24up there in any event. Also with the advent of
- 9:28COVID, of course, we have choices. During COVID,
- 9:32all of our arguments were remote, either telephonically
- 9:35or over Zoom, like this presentation. And at
- 9:39least the Zoom presentations have carried over
- 9:42in many courts as an accommodation to the parties
- 9:46to appear remotely, but also in the federal courts
- 9:51in particular, the judges are all over the circuit
- 9:55and they may not be able to travel in person.
- 9:57So when we're talking about remote versus live
- 10:00appearances, sometimes We're talking about a
- 10:03hybrid in -person and remote appearance by the
- 10:07judges themselves. And that certainly changes
- 10:11the dynamic when you have some members on the
- 10:15bench in front of you physically and the other
- 10:18one in a video beside that. That's a little different
- 10:23dynamic and less of an ability to read. And I
- 10:26would say that's the one thing about remote versus
- 10:29live, whether you're remote or one of the justices
- 10:32is remote. One of the things from being in person
- 10:35is that you can see the body language and the
- 10:39discussions between the various members of the
- 10:42panel very differently when everyone's in person
- 10:45as opposed to one person being remote. You can
- 10:48get a sense from the body language and the cues.
- 10:51whether judges are friendly to each other's positions,
- 10:55whether they're kind of playing off each other
- 10:59to get the answers that they want from counsel.
- 11:02It's just generally preferable to have everybody
- 11:05in person in one place, but we cannot always
- 11:07have that. So even if your only option is remote,
- 11:11either you, the judges, or both, it's better
- 11:14to have an argument than no argument or argument
- 11:18at all. Melanie did you want to say something
- 11:20about this and just a quick just with a two quick
- 11:23points when just what you're saying i happen
- 11:25to be in the audience for another world recently
- 11:27and i. It was the other person in the argument
- 11:31before me was remote and these two justices were
- 11:34almost like. They were hitting each other, but
- 11:37they were not happy with each other's positions,
- 11:40their body language, and they were feeling, you
- 11:42know, and their questions. And I feel that the
- 11:45person who was on the phone, actually, there
- 11:47was no video at the time that he was not getting
- 11:51the dynamic of it. And it really hurt his oral
- 11:54argument as to what. What one person was trying
- 11:57to dry out so if you can sometimes you can't
- 12:00be live but if you can it is recommended the
- 12:04other thing is just in terms of whether to ask
- 12:06for oral argument i'm a little bit on the minority
- 12:09in terms of whether you should always ask for
- 12:12oral argument because. The process of the court,
- 12:15it's a different kind of avenue if you've waived
- 12:20oral argument or not. If you are an appellant
- 12:24and you want oral argument, the case is going
- 12:26to get more attention. If a case is waived, the
- 12:32justices are really probably never going to talk
- 12:36in person about the case. It's just electronically
- 12:39they draft the opinion and then they said it
- 12:43electronically and generally speaking they don't
- 12:45talk so not having that conversation is not as
- 12:48good for you and also when a case is or going
- 12:51to be early argued you they put more attention
- 12:55on it because they're going to be up there on
- 12:56the bench so they want it they want to make sure
- 12:59that they are they're prepared for it that they're
- 13:01confident. And the research attorneys maybe make
- 13:04their opinions, the draft opinions, more complete
- 13:06because they don't want to be missing any issues.
- 13:09And so it's a little bit different process. They
- 13:12all get full attention. So the one thing on this
- 13:16one is if you are a respondent and the appellant's
- 13:20brief is really poor and your brief was very
- 13:23good, do you really want more attention given
- 13:27to the case and to an oral argument to allow
- 13:31More time on this case, rather than just going
- 13:35on the briefs. So I would just say, and I know
- 13:38most experienced appellate attorneys don't agree.
- 13:40They say always ask for oral argument. But I
- 13:43think it's a consideration. And I think you should
- 13:45just think about it, especially if the other
- 13:47side does not ask for oral argument. So it's
- 13:50just a little footnote in the requesting oral
- 13:53argument. So MC. Okay. Yeah. Next slide, please.
- 14:04I think Melanie, were you going to cover this
- 14:06one, Melanie? Oh, yeah. Okay. And I have a little,
- 14:09I'm going to, okay. So if you were here for,
- 14:12I'm going to talk about the general practice
- 14:14of the California Court of Appeal and oral argument.
- 14:16I kind of mentioned it before and the Supreme
- 14:18Court and talk a little bit about some approaches,
- 14:21but we'll. cover some of those later. And then
- 14:24MC is going to talk about the federal courts,
- 14:26how that's different. So if you were here for
- 14:29our part one session, we discussed that one chambers
- 14:32is assigned to prepare a draft opinion on a case.
- 14:35And once approved by the justice, if the case
- 14:38is set for oral argument, draft is then circulated
- 14:41to the other panel members who have a week or
- 14:43two to prepare. So by the time of oral argument,
- 14:47sitting on the bench, they have something that
- 14:49looks exactly like an opinion. It's not a bench
- 14:51memorandum. It doesn't have two sides. It has
- 14:54the opinion. The only difference is it has citations
- 14:57to the record because research attorneys are
- 14:59required to cite to the internal record, which
- 15:02will come out before the case is filed. So it
- 15:05looks like an opinion. And the authoring justice
- 15:08has already spent a lot of time on the case and
- 15:11in collaboration with the research attorney.
- 15:17Generally, you don't know what's in that draft,
- 15:19but as MC was saying, the courts of appeal, notably
- 15:21the 4th District Division 2 and sometimes the
- 15:242nd District Division 5, distributes tentative
- 15:27opinions. And then after the oral argument, the
- 15:30justices meet in a little room and decide whether
- 15:34to sign off or whether someone wants to delve
- 15:36in more. So based on this process, what can we
- 15:40learn from oral arguments? First, institutionally,
- 15:44there is some incentive for the other justices
- 15:47to sign off right after oral argument and not
- 15:50to change after your oral argument. In the past
- 15:54several years, there's been a real push to get
- 15:56cases out as soon as possible. And I won't talk
- 15:59about the reasons for that. And so not signing
- 16:03off on an opinion prepared for oral argument
- 16:05creates a lot more work. and delay within the
- 16:08court. So it's a consideration you should be
- 16:11thinking about. Also, there's a tendency, of
- 16:13course, psychologically, to want to sign off
- 16:15so that other justices will sign off on your
- 16:18opinion. But that's not to say that oral argument
- 16:22does not change minds. It's just that there's
- 16:25some institutional weight against changing based
- 16:30on oral argument. Although not frequent, I did
- 16:35see changes happen. And based on anecdotal information,
- 16:39this is really happening a lot more with the
- 16:42new justices. There's been many new, I talked
- 16:44about this yesterday, but there's been a whole
- 16:48slew of new justices appointed throughout the
- 16:50state. And those justices have brought fresh
- 16:53energy and new perspective. And there seems to
- 16:56be a more of a willingness to move from a position
- 16:58after oral argument. Also, after oral argument,
- 17:03and we'll talk about this later, it's common
- 17:04for justices to make modifications rather than
- 17:07to change the actual disposition. So what can
- 17:12you do in oral argument beyond what was already
- 17:16in your brief? And then what do the justices
- 17:19want to accomplish in the Court of Appeal? I'll
- 17:22just go over this quickly, because we're going
- 17:23to talk about this some more later. They have
- 17:28the opinion. They want to test the conclusions
- 17:31and rationale of the draft to see if they're
- 17:33missing anything. Second, they want to ask questions
- 17:37if they don't understand something in the record.
- 17:39It was not uncommon after an oral argument for
- 17:43me to hear a justice say, I finally understand
- 17:46what the attorney was trying to say in the briefs.
- 17:51So to compliment that to understand what was
- 17:54saying and then 3rd allows the justices to communicate
- 17:57with each other and like in the California Supreme
- 17:59Court, the justices have not communicated ahead
- 18:02of time in the Court of Appeal and oral argument
- 18:05is often the 1st chance when they get to do that.
- 18:09Okay, I'm just going to give you 2 or 3. Quick
- 18:12things and I'll be done with the Court of Appeal
- 18:13part. of the process. So what is the purpose
- 18:18knowing all of this? What's the purpose of oral
- 18:21argument for the parties? What are you trying
- 18:23to do different from the brief in the California
- 18:26Court of Appeal? You want to draw questions.
- 18:30You want questions. You welcome questions to
- 18:33figure out what the court is thinking. And we'll
- 18:37talk about how to do that. But two approaches.
- 18:39Two thoughts on approaches that might work to
- 18:42change the justices from the draft opinion. And
- 18:46this requires that you're familiar with both
- 18:48the micro, the micro facts and the macro themes
- 18:53of your case. On the micro, if the justices are
- 18:56basing their questions on inaccurate factual
- 18:59assumptions, you really need to clarify. You
- 19:02need to know the record backward and forward.
- 19:04It's certainly possible, although not infrequent,
- 19:08that Not frequent that the research attorney
- 19:11who prepared the draft missed something or got
- 19:15the facts wrong and so you you need this is your
- 19:19time when you can correct that and this is really
- 19:21one of the most fertile grounds for changing
- 19:23the court's mind they will they will be open
- 19:26to reconsidering if they think that the basis
- 19:29of their decision is based on the wrong facts
- 19:31secondly another potential focus is on the macro
- 19:35to create a. a paradigm shift in the justice's
- 19:39thinking. If you're feeling the panel's not in
- 19:42your favor, focus on the big picture and try
- 19:45to change the foundation of the judge's thinking.
- 19:49Try to say it in a different way or from a different
- 19:52angle. I've seen this where the light goes on
- 19:56in the justice's head and suddenly they see the
- 19:59issue in a different way and then they're open
- 20:01to revise. thing they're thinking on the issue.
- 20:04So I can give you some examples later, but I
- 20:07just wanted to point that out in terms of the
- 20:09process. And then let me just quickly go over
- 20:12the California Supreme Court process, how that
- 20:15changes that's different. The Supreme Court oral
- 20:18argument preparation is different. It's also
- 20:21front loading. Where a draft opinion is prepared,
- 20:24but it's really different because the court has
- 20:27gone through rigorous exchange of memos called
- 20:31preliminary responses, and they've discussed
- 20:33every detail of a proposed draft and they have.
- 20:36They're everybody is much more engaged in the
- 20:39process. So there's many different views are
- 20:43expressed. And unlike the Court of Appeal, the
- 20:45High Court doesn't necessarily have a solid draft
- 20:49at the time of the oral argument, meaning some
- 20:51justices views are not set. They tentatively
- 20:55said they'll agree, but with some reservations.
- 20:58But so the court does change its mind in the
- 21:02California Supreme Court. I've seen it and or
- 21:04they'll change some of the the opinion. And of
- 21:09course, the focus of oral argument at the California
- 21:11Supreme Court is different. It's not on the facts
- 21:13of the case. The court is focused on broader
- 21:16policy implications. So be prepared to answer
- 21:19questions such as what is the rule you're looking
- 21:21at? What's the practical result? Expect lots
- 21:25of hypotheticals. What are the implications of
- 21:27what you're asking for? We'll see if we can talk
- 21:30more about that. So finally, I've given you an
- 21:34overview of the Court of Appeal based on my experience
- 21:37and based on talking to other research attorneys
- 21:40at other courts, but every court is different.
- 21:42So if you are once you get the notice for your
- 21:45case. Do investigation on what the process is
- 21:50at that court. Find out how they're scheduled,
- 21:54whether they meet before and after. Do they have
- 21:55draft opinions? Mostly they do. I've said it
- 21:58for the majority, but there may be differences.
- 22:00Call or consult with an appellate specialist.
- 22:02Talk to somebody with experience with the court
- 22:05and panel. In our appellate firm, we regularly
- 22:08have emails, people asking, I just got assigned
- 22:11this panel. Anybody know about it? Even though
- 22:14we're all very experienced appellate. practitioners,
- 22:17we get advice from each other as to the appellate
- 22:19panel. Watch videos of oral argument from the
- 22:22panel. Join your local appellate bar section.
- 22:28So yes, so I'm going to let you, I think I've
- 22:33covered most of what's on this slide. And MC,
- 22:35do you want to? So there's a couple of things
- 22:37that I wanted to kind of amplify. One of them
- 22:44is, of course, knowing the procedure of the court.
- 22:51The federal courts are different. In the Ninth
- 22:55Circuit, for example, there's a bench memo that
- 23:00one member of the panel's chambers has prepared,
- 23:04which may or may not have been substantively
- 23:07reviewed and approved by the judge. whose chambers
- 23:11it was sent from. So you need somewhat of a grain
- 23:15of salt depending on how that chambers operates.
- 23:18There is no draft opinion because in the federal
- 23:21courts there is no conferring prior to oral argument.
- 23:24It is frowned upon. It is inappropriate. It is
- 23:28not done. So the first time that the panel actually
- 23:32discusses your particular case will be in the
- 23:35room right next to where oral argument was held,
- 23:39where they will all sit together and have a sense
- 23:42of where things will go. So it is a little bit
- 23:46different in that regard. And then with regard
- 23:52to the point that Melanie had made, about presenting
- 23:59arguments a little bit differently. I think this
- 24:01is something we hear all the time that when you
- 24:04stand up for argument, the court will say, thank
- 24:06you, counsel. We received your briefs. Please
- 24:09don't repeat them. We know them. Now go ahead
- 24:13and argue. And when you hear that, you think,
- 24:16well, I can't raise anything new. And I'm not
- 24:19supposed to repeat what was in my brief. So what
- 24:21the heck am I doing here? Like, what am I supposed
- 24:23to be telling you? It seems a little confusing.
- 24:28And I think by that reference, the judges are
- 24:32signaling, you know, explain it differently,
- 24:35tell us something in a different way than you
- 24:39provided in your brief, particularly I think
- 24:42at the Supreme Court level. They're very interested
- 24:45in that at oral argument. Tell us something new
- 24:49or a different framing of something or a different
- 24:53way of looking at the problem, especially the
- 24:56macro of the problem, not just the impact on
- 24:59your client, but the impact on the law in California
- 25:01and others within the state of California. So
- 25:06I think that is a really key factor and a key
- 25:10element of what what you're doing at argument
- 25:13and what the court expects to receive. And so
- 25:18that takes a lot of work. So that's why we're
- 25:19going to talk about the prep part. And in fact,
- 25:23I think you have in your materials, I think,
- 25:25this article of mine with some. oral argument
- 25:30tips from the nearly 100 appellate judges that
- 25:34I interviewed in the Portia Project podcast.
- 25:37Sort of the same, like the top five things that
- 25:40come up as being please do this or don't do this
- 25:43oral argument. And this point of making your
- 25:46argument a little bit differently and giving
- 25:49us something to chew on that we haven't already
- 25:52read has come up repeatedly. So it's not just
- 25:56Melanie and I saying this, even though we've
- 25:58both been involved in many arguments ourselves.
- 26:02But it's a common thread across jurisdictions.
- 26:07So next slide, please. So I always wish the argument
- 26:16is usually quite short. At most in the Ninth
- 26:19Circuit, you're going to have 20 minutes. Generally,
- 26:21it's 10 or 15 minutes. And I don't think it's
- 26:24much different in the Court of Appeal. In the
- 26:26Supreme Court, you'll have 30 minutes, but it's
- 26:28just not a long time. So you have to work really
- 26:34hard to concentrate and prepare so that you are
- 26:38ready to deliver things concisely and the most
- 26:41important things in this very short period of
- 26:43time. So I always wish that I could. enjoy the
- 26:47oral argument itself with a much less preparation,
- 26:51but it wouldn't be enjoyable without the preparation.
- 26:54So you have to go through the pain to, you know,
- 26:57to kind of enjoy the conversation. So the first
- 27:03thing, let's say you get your oral argument notice
- 27:06and you're like, oh my gosh, okay, what do I
- 27:07do now? And there's a few things sort of right
- 27:10away that you would do. And this is usually,
- 27:13you know, maybe six weeks, maybe a couple of
- 27:16months at the most before the actual argument
- 27:19date is when you get your notice. So the very
- 27:23first thing that I do, because it's been a long
- 27:26time, usually several months since you filed
- 27:28your last brief in the case, you really need
- 27:30to get like reacquainted with the case. But there's
- 27:33a benefit to that because you do have a little
- 27:35bit of objectivity. You know, if you had argument,
- 27:38think about it's more like the trial court. You
- 27:40write your brief and then soon thereafter you
- 27:42have oral argument and you're still like passionately
- 27:44engaged in what you argued in your brief and
- 27:46it's really hard to have objectivity. One of
- 27:49the benefits of this delay is that you can have
- 27:52a little objectivity because it's kind of new
- 27:54to you too. You've done a lot of other cases
- 27:56in the meantime and you're coming back to this
- 27:59one. So the first thing at least I'll just say
- 28:02what I do and there's some variation of this
- 28:05part. that I hear many other experienced appellate
- 28:09lawyers also do. But each of the things that
- 28:12we're talking about here in terms of process
- 28:13are just ideas. Everybody has particular ways
- 28:17that they do things, but I can best describe
- 28:20my way. So the first thing that I would do is
- 28:23review the appellate briefs and the record, the
- 28:28record itself, my record notes that I've prepared
- 28:31or someone on my team has prepared, and then
- 28:33also the literal get your hands on the record
- 28:37and read it all again. And then from that, I
- 28:45try to read each brief with a critical eye or
- 28:50an eye towards the other side's brief where I'm
- 28:53more generous. I wanna say, where are the problems
- 28:58from these arguments for me? If I am a judge
- 29:02trying to write an opinion, Where are the questions?
- 29:05Where would I have discomfort? And I just write
- 29:07all those questions alongside the margins of
- 29:10the briefs that I'm reading or get a running
- 29:13list of the questions. And from doing that, you
- 29:17can start to see themes or problem areas. And
- 29:22then in reading the record, sometimes strangely
- 29:26enough, you sometimes will see things a little
- 29:29bit differently. You'll see connections between
- 29:32things. that you didn't see in the same way when
- 29:35you were crafting the brief or a certain timeline
- 29:37or other things that now seem important that
- 29:41didn't seem as important when you were crafting
- 29:43the brief. And that's part of how you get to
- 29:45a little bit different explanation of things
- 29:47to the court than the brief said. And so the
- 29:50purpose of this is to test your position and
- 29:55start working out responses. And the other thing
- 30:01that I do is I'll circulate the briefs to smart
- 30:05people in my firm or otherwise that you're able
- 30:09to do within privilege to say, hey, read the
- 30:13briefs and tell me what are your questions? Just
- 30:16give me a list of questions that if you were
- 30:19on the panel, you would ask. Because my job is
- 30:23to anticipate as many questions as possible and
- 30:26have worked out what those answers are. And I
- 30:29do the questions first before putting together
- 30:32my statement or what I want to say if I'm uninterrupted
- 30:35by the court, because the questions are the most
- 30:37important thing. The judges have questions. They're
- 30:40making the decision in your case. If they have
- 30:43a question, you want to answer it. And you want
- 30:45to be prepared to answer it. And so by contemplating
- 30:48all of these different questions, you will be
- 30:51prepared. And that's the process. And then the
- 30:58most important thing immediately in terms of
- 31:00deliverables is to update the research. You know,
- 31:03since the parties briefed the case, which may
- 31:06have been nine months ago or even more in the
- 31:08Ninth Circuit, Are there any new cases that came
- 31:12up in between time that the court needs to know
- 31:15about that's directly relevant to a point in
- 31:17your case? If you're in federal court, this is
- 31:19called the 28 J letter for 28 J and you will
- 31:23do a brief non argumentative letter alerting
- 31:26the court to this so that. And you would do a
- 31:30similar thing in the state courts also to make
- 31:33sure that everything's updated. And you're not
- 31:36presenting some newly decided case for the very
- 31:38first time at argument. It's not good to surprise
- 31:42the judges with things you could have told them
- 31:45about in advance. Yeah, in state court it's a
- 31:48rule 8 .254 and the same thing where no argument,
- 31:52but if you really feel that there's a really
- 31:55important decision, you can ask for supplemental
- 31:57briefing and at some point they'll let you, but
- 32:01definitely before citing anything, send it to
- 32:04the court without any argument. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 32:08OK, next slide. So this I call sort of like.
- 32:16You know, like you're going to a game, right?
- 32:18You're participating in, let's say, a football
- 32:20match or rugby match or whatever you want to
- 32:22call it. The courtroom is your theater. It's
- 32:25your it's your stadium and you want to be prepared
- 32:30for that. And so you also want to minimize your,
- 32:34you know, just jitters and discomfort or whatever.
- 32:38So. You want to get familiar with the judges
- 32:42as Melanie had mentioned, you know. One of the
- 32:45things I do early on too is I look for the panel,
- 32:49any member of the panel, but particularly portions
- 32:52of the panel who may be sitting together again,
- 32:55which in the federal court can vary. It doesn't
- 32:59vary as much in the California Courts of Appeal,
- 33:01but I'll pull their decisions in the particular
- 33:05areas that are relevant to my case, and then
- 33:09I'll see what have they written before. Something
- 33:14that I. Would like to remind them of from that
- 33:18now some people do this very obsequiously well
- 33:20as judge so and so you wrote in blah blah case
- 33:23the answer is this you know there are ways to
- 33:27do it that are a little more subtle than that
- 33:29but basically resonating with something they've
- 33:33already signed on to or wrote before. It's familiar.
- 33:37It makes them feel comfortable and warm and fuzzy.
- 33:40So if you can do that and be aware of that, it's
- 33:44helpful. So pulling decisions in the key areas
- 33:48in your case by this panel is something I do
- 33:51very early also. Watching the judges in oral
- 33:55argument, watching the videos of prior arguments
- 33:58involving this panel or different members of
- 34:01the panel to see how they are at argument. Are
- 34:04they kind of crotchety so that if they're crotchety
- 34:06with you, they're just crotchety that they don't
- 34:08have anything to do with you or your particular
- 34:10case or your presentation? What kinds of questions
- 34:13do they ask? You know, in the California Supreme
- 34:15Court, I can think of, you know, Justice Corrigan
- 34:18will always almost always ask. We're not just
- 34:22concerned with your parties in your case. We're
- 34:24concerned with, you know, the rule of law and
- 34:27how it applies to others in the state and whether
- 34:30we're doing something. inadvertent and untoward
- 34:33that we didn't intend. So tell me how this does
- 34:37or doesn't create headaches down the line for
- 34:42the law or for certain members of the California
- 34:46society. So you can always count on that Justice
- 34:50Corrigan type of question. And Justice Groban
- 34:54asks hypotheticals, which are always confusing.
- 34:57Yes, yes, exactly. So there's some things like
- 35:02that where you're like, that's just such a really
- 35:07easy pitch. You know those are going to come
- 35:09because they just come like the sun rising and
- 35:12the sun setting. So you need to be prepared for
- 35:14that. And you also want to watch, if you can,
- 35:18videos of arguments with two or three members
- 35:22of your panel together because you want to see
- 35:24how they interact with each other. so that when
- 35:27they're interacting on your case, is that just
- 35:32how they are with each other or are they like
- 35:35friendly ribbing with each other or they really
- 35:39have very different views about how particular
- 35:43types of cases should be decided and so they're
- 35:45a little bristly with each other. All of that
- 35:47is just information for you to take in with you.
- 35:51The other thing I would, I would notice, of course,
- 35:53I mentioned getting background on the judges
- 35:55themselves, their biographies, you know, the
- 35:57Daily Journal has all of these biographies on
- 36:00judges. Of course, you would, you would find
- 36:02those. But now you're also able to see videos
- 36:06and podcasts and interviews with judges. And
- 36:11I would highly recommend doing that. I mean,
- 36:13a lot of people listen to the Porsche Project
- 36:17so that they can see Their particular judge or
- 36:21justice who's going to be on their panel they're
- 36:25really getting background on them. From them
- 36:29not filtered through a writer editor you know
- 36:32the daily journal or elsewhere so so that's another
- 36:36video source for you and then just like like
- 36:41I said checking the field out you know what which
- 36:44courtroom are you in you know what does it look
- 36:46like. Most experienced lawyers, appellate lawyers
- 36:52will go, if they can, to court the day before
- 36:56their argument. They will go to see what that
- 36:59panel, especially if it's the same panel, maybe
- 37:01different than the Ninth Circuit, but if it's
- 37:02the same panel has argument before you, you either
- 37:04watch the videos or if you're able to, you go
- 37:08to argument to get the feel of the room, to get
- 37:11the feel of the panel, how are they interacting
- 37:13with each other. What's the vibe this week with
- 37:16everyone on that panel? And just getting comfortable
- 37:19with the courtroom you're going to and all of
- 37:21that. What's the layout? How does it work? And
- 37:25then, of course, the day of argument. Get there
- 37:27as early as you can in case there's any unexpected
- 37:31traffic, but also so that you can just sort of
- 37:35calm yourself down before you actually get to
- 37:37argument. And then, of course, figuring out just
- 37:40all of the logistics. There's usually room for
- 37:45one person to sit with you at the council table
- 37:48before going out to the lectern. Who is that
- 37:50person going to be? Is it going to be the client?
- 37:51Is it going to be trial counsel? Is it going
- 37:53to be your co -counsel on appeal who worked with
- 37:57you on the brief? Just kind of figure that out
- 38:01both with the client and amongst your team beforehand.
- 38:06In most cases, it's going to be the person who
- 38:08can help you the most, and that would be the
- 38:10person Who helped on the brief because you want
- 38:14to be able to respond in real time to the questions
- 38:18and, you know, have the full weight of the team
- 38:21working together. So, I'll turn it over to Melanie
- 38:24now for more record prep. Okay, I think this
- 38:35was yours, but I will do it and we'll see advance.
- 38:39Okay. So yes, just as I said, you need to know
- 38:42the record inside and out. You need to know where
- 38:45to find things you need to know. I mean, usually
- 38:49that doesn't come up in your in the oral argument
- 38:52because as we talked about, they're talking macro
- 38:54talking themes, but sometimes it will and sometimes
- 38:57it really matters. Bring the record to the to
- 39:00the oral argument and have it. Just organized
- 39:05and be able to find things quickly. I mean, that's
- 39:07it's not just a procedural thing. It's substantive
- 39:10in terms of the argument is goes so quickly.
- 39:14You've worked on this case for as MC said for
- 39:18years and you have 15 minutes, 20, you know,
- 39:21maybe 20 and you have to be able to do things
- 39:24really quickly. Yeah, and I'll say something
- 39:28about bringing the record to oral argument. Sometimes
- 39:30people will come in with six bankers boxes of
- 39:33this massive record from a one -month trial.
- 39:38That is not realistic, right? You're not going
- 39:40to be able to, oh, Your Honor, you had a question.
- 39:42I'm going to be able to dig through all these
- 39:43bankers boxes and find the answer for you. No,
- 39:47that's not exactly what we mean when we say bring
- 39:49the record to oral argument. It's basically bring
- 39:51the key parts of the record that you think you
- 39:53will need. um and whatever it is you need to
- 39:58get into that record so you've taken record notes
- 40:01you've reviewed the the transcript and the court
- 40:04filings you know in preparing the brief but sometimes
- 40:09it's easy it's good to create charts or to digest
- 40:13it or you know, have particular things that you
- 40:17know the court's going to ask or that you think
- 40:19were important during your preparation. So if
- 40:22there's actually an importance to a timeline,
- 40:25you could chart out the timeline with exact pages
- 40:29to the record where that appears so that you
- 40:32can make assertions and provide a record site
- 40:35to the court on the spot for those assertions.
- 40:38You can bring key portions of the Reporters Transcript
- 40:43itself that you just kind of know are going to
- 40:45come up or are important to illustrate a point
- 40:48that you want to make that you just want to have
- 40:53on hand to be able to point to. I saw this Supreme
- 40:58Court argument recently. It was a huge case.
- 41:02Advocate brought one page, one single page with
- 41:05him, and it was so impressive because that's,
- 41:07especially at the Supreme Court, you're just,
- 41:08you're talking big things. And it's very, you
- 41:11know, if you have all these little details, you
- 41:13want to have them have access to it. But having
- 41:17the main points, being able to digest them on
- 41:18one page, that's, I think that's really what
- 41:21your goal should be. Yeah, everybody does that
- 41:26differently. So, um, I'm always amazed at the
- 41:29people who are, you know, who can do that or
- 41:32bring no notes at all or bring just in it, you
- 41:34know, their. Their legal pad up something like
- 41:38that. Everybody has a different way of of proceeding
- 41:40and it, you know, it is. That's certainly an
- 41:43impressive look. But it's basically whatever
- 41:46works for you. It can look impressive, but it
- 41:49does not matter if it looks impressive. Your
- 41:52presentation is what's going to matter. So if
- 41:54you cannot live with one page like that, don't
- 41:58do it because it looked cool because somebody
- 42:00else did it. You have to do what works for you.
- 42:02So that's just another caveat for everything
- 42:04we're talking about here is like, general principles,
- 42:07general concerns of the decision maker all apply.
- 42:11But how you satisfy those concerns, how you uh
- 42:15you know how you do it um is something that is
- 42:18really unique to you and in many cases and don't
- 42:22don't yeah and i think the point of this the
- 42:26last few slides are prepare prepare be prepared
- 42:30that's the best way to not be nervous and to
- 42:34be able to i mean it's you know there you only
- 42:36have 15 minutes but you just have to be prepared
- 42:38and that's however you do it Be prepared. Yeah,
- 42:42exactly. Yeah, this is like a lot of work. I
- 42:45mean, I, so I teach in clinics, non circuit clinics
- 42:50and California clinics at Loyola Law School in
- 42:54Los Angeles. And the students are always surprised,
- 42:58like how much work it takes them to prepare for
- 43:02oral argument, you know, even For us who are
- 43:05experienced, we spend a lot of time, you know,
- 43:09and then in the two weeks beforehand, maybe three
- 43:11weeks, if it's really a big case. This is what
- 43:14we're doing, you know, preparing and doing all
- 43:17of this. That is what we're doing very well.
- 43:22So right and yeah and that's why I think there's
- 43:25a big push for tenants of opinions because then
- 43:30you would know what's really not going to really
- 43:32you don't have to prepare for it's would save
- 43:34the client so much money and I think from what
- 43:36I've heard is that younger justices the new justices
- 43:39are much more. Interested in pursuing that and
- 43:44I think in the next 10 years that I mean I think
- 43:47it would be really helpful but I the courts all.
- 43:52really also are doing more focus letters. So
- 43:56they will say, please be prepared to add oral
- 43:58argument to draft. They still have to be prepared
- 44:00for everything. But I think that helps a lot.
- 44:03Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, about those things,
- 44:06I have very different views. I think tentative
- 44:09opinions are not good for advocates. I know it
- 44:11saves the client money in the short run. But
- 44:14once a panel has committed, as they do in riverside
- 44:18to the world sharing their draft opinion with
- 44:21the parties it's a very hard to move them off
- 44:25that because they committed themselves publicly.
- 44:28And i think that it it makes oral argument very
- 44:32different. and it has a very different role and
- 44:36less of an impact just because it's just human
- 44:40nature. It's hard to get off that. Focus letters
- 44:43on the other hand, I think are helpful because
- 44:45they say, here's what we're thinking about. Please
- 44:47be prepared to answer questions on X or we're
- 44:50interested in issue Y. That is helpful because
- 44:53you're like, it's kind of like the Corrigan -Grobin
- 44:56question we're talking about. Will we know we're
- 44:58getting this one? So we can definitely prepare
- 45:00for that. We might need to be prepared for other
- 45:03things, but not that one. So I think focus letters
- 45:08are important. I, as an arbitrator, ask focus
- 45:13letter type questions all the time to people
- 45:15before I have argument on emotion. I say, hey,
- 45:18here's what I'm interested in. You could talk
- 45:20about whatever you want, but be prepared to answer
- 45:22A, B, C, and D. Very helpful. It's helpful to
- 45:26the decision maker to do that and to get that
- 45:28response. And then the next slide is going to
- 45:31also one more thing about advanced preparation,
- 45:34I believe. Yeah. Yeah, we're talking about moot
- 45:37court. Right. Kind of a number of components
- 45:41to prep. I mentioned the doing your own questions
- 45:45on your own, being an objective reader of the
- 45:48briefs and of the cases and things like that.
- 45:50So getting your own list of cases, also ascertaining
- 45:54in that process, as well as getting questions
- 45:57from other colleagues to add to your list of
- 46:00questions. You're also trying to discern what
- 46:04is the key issue upon which this entire decision
- 46:08will pivot. Because it always turns out that
- 46:11way. You might brief three or four issues in
- 46:14your brief, but really, the only one either worth
- 46:17discussing further or which is the core of the
- 46:20case, there's usually just one or two. And so
- 46:23discerning what that is and being able to explain
- 46:27that to the court is part of this process as
- 46:31well. And beyond getting the questions in writing
- 46:36independently from your colleagues is the next
- 46:39step, which is moot court preparation. So having
- 46:42a moot panel of members of your firm or members
- 46:47of the various firms that may have been consulting
- 46:49on the case or retired judges who do this and
- 46:54assist with moot court preparation, we have a
- 46:59retired justice in our firm and she often is
- 47:02invaluable in moot courts for us, providing her
- 47:05judicial perspective. And so if you can, and
- 47:11the budget permits, I would recommend doing one
- 47:18or two moot courts if you can. And there's a
- 47:22couple different ways of doing them. You know,
- 47:23one of them is more informal, just having them
- 47:30sort of bounce questions back and forth and their
- 47:33impressions of the case, more of a talking back
- 47:36and forth and formal moot. And then the formal
- 47:39moot where you're really testing your statement
- 47:42to the court that you would make if you were
- 47:44asked no questions, you're testing out responses
- 47:48to questions and interactions with the justices.
- 47:52Some people, I find the more experience people
- 47:56get, the more they prefer the informal. But I
- 48:00personally prefer informal first and then a formal
- 48:04second. So there's at least one that is more
- 48:07formal. Or you can combine them, like start out
- 48:10informal in the same session and then say, OK,
- 48:13I want to test out my overview statement and
- 48:17get some real -time questions. Can we do that?
- 48:21In terms of budget and money, of course, it costs
- 48:25to have people provide their time for this. And
- 48:29your client might not be able to pay for that
- 48:32or be interested in paying for that. But there
- 48:36are options to that. Sometimes people will basically
- 48:42donate their time to do that, to assist each
- 48:44other as a courtesy. And so you can call on friends
- 48:51of the appellate bar to help you with that. There's
- 48:54also other places to do that for free. Loyola
- 49:00Law School has a practitioners mute program where
- 49:05they will have professors from Loyola and from
- 49:07other places. who are, let's say, experts in
- 49:12the particular subject matter that you're working
- 49:14on or clerked on the Ninth Circuit or clerked,
- 49:17you know, or worked as a research attorney in
- 49:19the Court of Appeal or in the Supreme Court,
- 49:23and they will be your bench. And they will do
- 49:27it for free as a service to the public if you
- 49:30give them enough notice and they haven't already
- 49:33been asked to do it for your opponent in the
- 49:35case. So you see San Francisco has a fantastic
- 49:39for the California Supreme Court. If you get
- 49:41if you have a case, free opportunity, and they
- 49:43have great moot questioners. So take advantage
- 49:47of that. Once you get notice from the California
- 49:48Supreme Court, go to them quickly because they
- 49:50only take one one from each side. So. Yeah, do
- 49:57you want to talk about the AI? Yeah, I'll talk
- 50:00about the AI. And I saw there are a couple of
- 50:01interesting questions too, which we can get to
- 50:03towards the end, or I could answer a couple of
- 50:05them. But yeah, so the one thing I wanted to
- 50:08say is I think it's so interesting. People use
- 50:10outside people to prepare for their oral arguments.
- 50:13And oral argument, as we've seen, is sometimes
- 50:16not important as the brief. So I'm always wondering,
- 50:18why don't you think about having an outside person
- 50:21read your brief? And see what it's missing, you
- 50:24know, or having somebody from the firm who's
- 50:27not an appellate attorney read the brief and
- 50:30have that input at that time. I feel like that's
- 50:33not that would be really helpful because sometimes
- 50:37there's a missing a big thing which you don't
- 50:39figure out until the oral argument in terms of
- 50:42AI for moods. I think definitely it's available
- 50:48and you know. Why not use it? But I wouldn't
- 50:51use it as your primary preparation, because what
- 50:55I have found is the questions are more kind of
- 50:58law school questions, the questions that a professor
- 51:00would write. And so those are not actually the
- 51:04real world questions that you're going to get
- 51:06from an actual court of appeal panel. You could
- 51:11ask AI to give you real world questions, but
- 51:16somehow, It I have kind of worked with that and
- 51:20I don't think it's that helpful, but use it to
- 51:22make sure you've hit every possible issue. But
- 51:26I wouldn't use it as the primary. So that's.
- 51:31Yeah, we can move on, or do you want to? I mean,
- 51:33you can also use it to. See what it finds in
- 51:38terms of patterns across cases or something like
- 51:41feed all of the cases in on a particular topic,
- 51:44because that's actually something I haven't.
- 51:48Mentioned directly when I say in the preparation.
- 51:51I also what I will do is I will gather not just
- 51:54the record in the breeze, but I gather all of
- 51:57the key cases. So all of the key cases that were
- 52:00cited in the briefs on each topic. And then anything
- 52:04subject to the 20 J letter or anything new that
- 52:06needs to be included. I put those cases together
- 52:12in notebooks. Physically or digitally or whatever.
- 52:18And all of those cases from the beginning of
- 52:22time in order until 2026, on one topic, on one
- 52:27of the issues, I put them together and I read
- 52:30them. The first case to the end, to the latest.
- 52:34And I read them in that order because I want
- 52:37to see if there's something about the development
- 52:40of the law that I can see from that that I missed.
- 52:45Because sometimes you're looking at them, you're
- 52:48pulling them for different reasons for your brief,
- 52:50but you didn't really sit down and read them
- 52:52all in order. And that's really what, as I mentioned
- 52:55in the brief writing class yesterday, what you're
- 52:58really doing is what the judges are doing is
- 53:01setting this case in the stream of the law. So
- 53:03you're setting yourself in the stream by reading
- 53:06this and saying, well, where is the law going?
- 53:09How have each of those cases informed each other
- 53:11along the way? And did maybe some later cases
- 53:17basically misapprehended what some of the earlier
- 53:19cases were saying. Sometimes you see that people
- 53:22start repeating and citing cases for principles
- 53:25and you read that original case and you say,
- 53:28well that. actually wasn't the original reasoning
- 53:31in that case. So everyone sort of misapprehended
- 53:34that and that has a different implication for
- 53:37where the law should go now. And so this is part
- 53:40of the process too. You're not just becoming
- 53:41familiar with your record. You're becoming familiar
- 53:44with the area of the law in your particular case.
- 53:48using that to argue for different outcomes in
- 53:51your particular. And I think that same thing,
- 53:54of course, is in brief writing. You need to have
- 53:56done that already to have gone through that.
- 53:58So I think that's critical. Yeah, but it's a
- 54:03different reason why you're doing it now. And
- 54:08for that purpose is what I'm saying. If you're
- 54:09looking for patterns, AI does patterns really
- 54:13well. So if you want to feed in all of those
- 54:16cases from the beginning of time to the end and
- 54:18say, hey, basically, did I miss something? Tell
- 54:23me about this particular part of it. It may find
- 54:26a pattern that will help you discern what to
- 54:32say. All right, next slide. So again, this is
- 54:40personal preference, sort of day of argument,
- 54:42what do you bring up? Melanie mentioned the people
- 54:46who bring the one page or the folder with things
- 54:51stapled in on each side or nothing at all, which
- 54:54is the most impressive. I am not one of those
- 54:57people. I personally will bring up a three -ring
- 55:02binder. I have tabs. I have the key cases that
- 55:06I think I might need to refer to. You know, with
- 55:10the key pages tabbed or highlighted, I have my
- 55:14one to two page argument that I would make if
- 55:17I were totally uninterrupted by the court. I
- 55:21have all of the questions and all of the answers
- 55:24that we got during the courts or from my colleagues
- 55:28or whatnot. I have those there in case. you know,
- 55:32I just completely miss something and I know it's
- 55:35there and I can find that question and that answer,
- 55:40but usually you've internalized it. And then,
- 55:43yeah, just key parts of the record as well. If
- 55:46there's something you want to refer to, you know
- 55:49you're going to cite and you want the exact page
- 55:52so that you can read from it directly, you can
- 55:55do that as well. And then, of course, a general
- 55:59outline of the argument. So if you've got your
- 56:01statement, and then these are the key points
- 56:03I want to cover. And this is the result I want
- 56:06to ask for. This is my disposition that I want.
- 56:09This is what I want to ask the court to do, as
- 56:11we mentioned in the brief writing. Don't forget
- 56:13to ask for exactly what you want the court to
- 56:15do. That's what I bring up. And staying calm
- 56:22and focused, for me, it's the preparation. So
- 56:25having done all the prep before, it gives you
- 56:27a little bit of calm, hopefully, just before
- 56:32argument. Because the less surprises you have,
- 56:35the less sort of Perry Mason moments you have
- 56:38or whatever the better in an appellate argument.
- 56:41I wanted to address a couple of things before
- 56:43we move on in terms of, there were a couple of
- 56:46questions about video footage. Video footage
- 56:51is available on YouTube for the Ninth Circuit
- 56:53for forever. For the courts of appeal, I think
- 56:57each one has different... Some of them only go
- 57:06back six months, but each of them does have some
- 57:10video preservation now, but they don't go back
- 57:13forever. so you can find them. Some of them are
- 57:16not as easy searchable. Yeah, it's harder. It's
- 57:19harder in the Court of Appeal. It used to be
- 57:20that it wasn't available online at all. And if
- 57:22you wanted an argument, you had to order, pay
- 57:27like $10 and order a CD from the clerk. So yeah.
- 57:33And I can answer the next question. I also want
- 57:35to say, I know we're kind of up on the time,
- 57:37but if people can stay, we'll go a few more minutes
- 57:40extra to finish or outline our slides. But on
- 57:43the pro -per, because I spent a lot of time on
- 57:46these access issues, the justices are very aware
- 57:51that these people are not attorneys. So I would
- 57:54say the majority of the justices, they let them.
- 57:59Talk and they they just listen and they don't
- 58:02ask them very many questions because they they
- 58:05just want to give them the opportunity and sometimes
- 58:08they have something really helpful to say but
- 58:10they don't. They don't challenge them very much
- 58:14and they you know and they are encouraged to
- 58:18come in and argue but most of the time those
- 58:20people will if they're not represented they will
- 58:22read and they will read their statement that's
- 58:26maybe somebody else wrote for them but it's.
- 58:28They are encouraged to come and but also the
- 58:32court generally puts them last so that they can
- 58:35see how professional people are arguing so they
- 58:38can kind of get a sense of it. Yeah, yeah, as
- 58:42an arbitrator when I have self represented people
- 58:45also I am I am. Conscious that they are not lawyers.
- 58:49I want to allow them to have an opportunity to
- 58:52say their piece to present their case as they,
- 58:54you know, as they wish to present it without
- 58:57going too far a field and. And, but, but I will
- 59:03still ask questions to make sure. you know, if
- 59:07there's something that they can share that would
- 59:09be important to their case, I want to give them
- 59:11the opportunity for that. So yeah, there's a
- 59:14little gentler aspect to them, but also, you
- 59:19know, you want to give them their opportunity
- 59:22to present as they wish to, but also try to ask
- 59:27them questions and get information. And different
- 59:30justices have different styles. Some of them
- 59:32get impatient and others are very, very kind.
- 59:35And so it just it depends. Yeah. OK, so the next
- 59:40slide. OK, so we have a bunch of in the next
- 59:48few slides that we have tips, and I'm not going
- 59:51to go through each one of these because you'll
- 59:53get these slides and you basically you've heard
- 59:56of them. I'll just give you some. some overview,
- 1:00:00and then next slides, we'll have them too. Just
- 1:00:03again, remember oral argument is short. You've
- 1:00:06spent years, but you have 15 minutes to cover.
- 1:00:09So be aware of that and be prepared for that.
- 1:00:13Listen, listen, listen. Listen to what the justices
- 1:00:16are saying. And particularly if you're a respondent,
- 1:00:20we'll do that. There's a slide coming up on respondents.
- 1:00:25Sometimes you get asked a question that's where
- 1:00:28something's not in the record and and generally
- 1:00:32it shouldn't be in your argument but if but there
- 1:00:34are particular judges throughout the state that
- 1:00:36often ask you for questions because they're just
- 1:00:38they're curious or they just want to get this
- 1:00:41fit into the practical sense of it and not at
- 1:00:44the California Supreme Court they do ask. You
- 1:00:46know more policy questions but it's just single
- 1:00:48justice asking questions and you're always put
- 1:00:50in the spot because it's not the record so what
- 1:00:52you would say is generally you say well it's
- 1:00:55not in there you answer by saying it's not in
- 1:00:57the record but. Here's the answer to your question
- 1:01:00and or you don't know. And many times you want
- 1:01:04to say you don't know because you don't want
- 1:01:05to. It may be a fact that's not helpful to you,
- 1:01:08but you but if you can answer the question, it
- 1:01:11is helpful for them because they they want to
- 1:01:13know the practical implications or the practical
- 1:01:16background. Things that are not super relevant
- 1:01:19to the legal issue, but it's things that the
- 1:01:21justices talk about and want to know. Also, don't
- 1:01:26assume the draft is written against you, even
- 1:01:28though they're asking you all these hard questions.
- 1:01:32Whether you're an appellant or respondent, a
- 1:01:33lot of justices like the sparring and testing.
- 1:01:38And there are certain justices. That's one of
- 1:01:40the things that MC was talking about, that you
- 1:01:44get to know which justices do that, so you're
- 1:01:46not surprised. But don't assume that and push
- 1:01:49back. or give up anything because they may just
- 1:01:51be pushing and things seem to be going your way.
- 1:01:55Don't assume that don't assume they're going
- 1:01:57your way either. I mean, I have walked out of
- 1:01:58so many arguments where, you know, oh, we got
- 1:02:01this or we didn't get this and it turned out
- 1:02:03to be another way. And so you but you you want
- 1:02:07to give if the if the court seems to be going
- 1:02:09your way, you want to give them the confidence.
- 1:02:11They have a draft opinion. They want to know
- 1:02:13on my right. You want to give them confidence,
- 1:02:15especially if they're asking helpful questions.
- 1:02:19And be prepared to answer irrelevant questions
- 1:02:22when when i'm doing moods or anything like that
- 1:02:26ask the people to ask to ask you or to prepare.
- 1:02:30Off the wall questions because you want to be
- 1:02:32prepared for that something that's completely
- 1:02:34irrelevant but you know but something that that
- 1:02:37somebody might want to know about also style
- 1:02:41matters substance is of course important but
- 1:02:44style from my viewing so many arguments the judges
- 1:02:49are much more likely to be hearing you when you're
- 1:02:53confident. You're respectful your tone is professional
- 1:02:57but conversational not not reading not stilted
- 1:03:01not the language of you know kind of here after
- 1:03:05this kind of thing just be conversational but
- 1:03:08professional and really believe in your case
- 1:03:11now if the justices are pushing back at you.
- 1:03:16And you keep making that argument there is a
- 1:03:18point where you need to back off you don't have
- 1:03:21to necessarily concede. But you need to move
- 1:03:24on, because otherwise you're going to really
- 1:03:27lose the panel and your credibility. But you
- 1:03:31might decide to argue a related point that might
- 1:03:33shape a better opinion for you. It's critical
- 1:03:36for your reputation. Justices remember who's
- 1:03:41making arguments. They talk about it after. So
- 1:03:44just at some point you have to be aware that
- 1:03:46you've got to just kind of stop and think, well,
- 1:03:49it's not going to work. This is our disagreeing,
- 1:03:54because as I said, they communicate with each
- 1:03:55other. Don't get in the middle of it. Really
- 1:03:57try to just make your point and let them do that.
- 1:04:00It's easy to try to curry favor on one, but really
- 1:04:06try to stay away from that. I think we can get
- 1:04:11to the next tips. Next slide. OK, this one's
- 1:04:17yours. Yeah. I was going to just touch on this
- 1:04:21a little bit. Sometimes, as Melanie said, you're
- 1:04:24oppressed and you're like, oh, what do I do if
- 1:04:27my back's up against the wall? Do I say, oh,
- 1:04:31you're right, Your Honor, or do I not? And what
- 1:04:35do I do with a question that I did not expect?
- 1:04:39I'll handle the second one, which would be there
- 1:04:41should be very few that you don't expect if you
- 1:04:43follow the preparation that we have. Um, mentioned,
- 1:04:48but there can be on occasion things that are
- 1:04:50just like, wow, that was just left field or that
- 1:04:53the court wants to know something about some
- 1:04:55something in the record that you, um, you know,
- 1:04:58just don't have, um, right at your fingertips
- 1:05:01because you didn't anticipate that question,
- 1:05:03but you know, it's in the record. And so typically
- 1:05:06the way to handle that, especially if it's something
- 1:05:09that. You know, you. Someone would not say, well,
- 1:05:13of course, you should have expected that question
- 1:05:15is to say, well, your honor, may I submit a supplemental
- 1:05:18brief on that particular point and find that
- 1:05:23particular record site for you on that question
- 1:05:26or whatever it is that they're asking about.
- 1:05:28And by asking that way, the court will either
- 1:05:32say yes or no. And maybe they'll say no because
- 1:05:34it actually was just. Something they were mildly
- 1:05:38interested in, but really doesn't determine anything.
- 1:05:41So you'll get kind of a read. Like, was that
- 1:05:43really an important question to the disposition?
- 1:05:46Or was it just, you know, sort of like a interested
- 1:05:50to know, but not essential to the decision? If
- 1:05:52it is something important, they will almost always
- 1:05:55allow you to submit, you know, a short brief,
- 1:05:59unless it's something that they think, well,
- 1:06:01you should have known that, like, you know, counsel,
- 1:06:03you know, I was going to ask about. you know,
- 1:06:05something very fundamental. And then I just want
- 1:06:09to go on. Are you still on the slide? OK, so
- 1:06:11go ahead. Oh, I was just going to answer a question
- 1:06:13because I want it has to do with what I was just
- 1:06:15saying. The question was, does the judge hold
- 1:06:17it against you if you read your oral argument?
- 1:06:19And absolutely not, especially if you're if you're
- 1:06:22either less experienced or if you are a self
- 1:06:25-represented party, it's fine to read. So I don't
- 1:06:29the judge will the justices. will not rule against
- 1:06:32you or hold it against you. It's just to be more
- 1:06:35persuasive. It's better to kind of to have what
- 1:06:39you want to say. And it doesn't have to be complicated
- 1:06:41because they've already read the brief. Just
- 1:06:44say it as you were talking to somebody and make
- 1:06:47it small. Make it. You don't have to address
- 1:06:49every point. Address the main point of your.
- 1:06:54of what you want to say after reading all the
- 1:06:56briefs, just what MC was saying about how she
- 1:06:58prepares. And then once you've said, OK, this
- 1:07:02is the issue I want to tell the justices, just
- 1:07:04tell them that instead of reading. But if you
- 1:07:06read it, it's completely fine. They'll understand.
- 1:07:11Yeah, I mean, I mean, I see in that question
- 1:07:13like, well, they hold it against you. No, I don't
- 1:07:15think they I mean, this was sort of the way that's
- 1:07:18phrased. It's not I think when we're talking
- 1:07:21about oral argument, we're not we're not Here
- 1:07:24talking about like what will will there be like
- 1:07:27a black mark on your you know particular side
- 1:07:31of the case or anything if you don't do something
- 1:07:33a certain way it's more like. This is your only
- 1:07:39opportunity actually to speak directly to the
- 1:07:42people who are deciding your case. So you want
- 1:07:45to be as helpful as possible to them and in that
- 1:07:49process. And by being helpful, you may well help
- 1:07:53yourself in terms of the decision. So I think
- 1:07:56thinking about argument in that frame instead
- 1:07:59of holding it against someone is probably a better
- 1:08:04mental framing. for it and not a little more
- 1:08:09positive thinking. And then whether when and
- 1:08:13whether to concede, yes, there might be some
- 1:08:15circumstances where you're like, yeah, you might
- 1:08:18have to agree with the court on a point of the
- 1:08:22record that is unfortunate for you or a case
- 1:08:26that does go against you. And you need to be
- 1:08:29honest and to maintain your credibility about
- 1:08:32that. You shouldn't suggest that the sky is gray
- 1:08:35when it's blue, because you're going to lose
- 1:08:39credibility with the court in that regard. But
- 1:08:42there are ways to answer those, just to say,
- 1:08:46yes, that's correct, or yes, that case did decide
- 1:08:49that, or yes, that is part of the record. And
- 1:08:53or but, here's why that doesn't. mean that I
- 1:08:58lose or here's why together with this other case,
- 1:09:01it actually means that we should prevail or something
- 1:09:04like that. Trying to turn a quick yes or no answer
- 1:09:09into something that could be positive for you
- 1:09:13instead of negative. I think that's the best
- 1:09:16way of thinking about that. And that is what
- 1:09:20you should do at your moots, because often we'll
- 1:09:23say, OK, let's workshop that question. You know
- 1:09:25what? You're going to get that question. People
- 1:09:27should be asking you, are you going to concede
- 1:09:29this or that? And MC just said a great way, and
- 1:09:32you should be prepared for that. And so whether
- 1:09:35to concede or not and talk to the client, it
- 1:09:37might be a big deal for them. Yeah. So you have
- 1:09:40to be careful with that. Another point, for sure,
- 1:09:42yeah, is to make sure if there is something that
- 1:09:47you think you might need to concede at some point
- 1:09:49that you sort of clear that with the client in
- 1:09:53advance before you get that. If there's something
- 1:09:56sensitive that the client might be sensitive
- 1:09:59to, you don't want to bind them to particular
- 1:10:03positions that they don't want to be bound to,
- 1:10:05things like that. This may be more relevant to
- 1:10:07a corporate client than to others, but it may
- 1:10:11also be relevant to trial counsel, for example.
- 1:10:13If you're arguing for a reversal and for a new
- 1:10:17trial under what terms and maybe they would have
- 1:10:22something to say about what you might say about
- 1:10:24that too. So it might mean that you need to vet
- 1:10:26things prior to argument and that's why you need
- 1:10:29to also prepare. Okay, so this one has, okay,
- 1:10:36the next slide has additional tips. I'm going
- 1:10:38to take some and see it's going to take others.
- 1:10:40Okay, so things not to do, I'll just go over
- 1:10:42a few. Don't split time, meaning if you have
- 1:10:45a co -counsel, you know, don't, they say not
- 1:10:51to split time. And so why, why not split time
- 1:10:53with them? First of all, it places artificial
- 1:10:56limits on the argument. It's impeding, as we
- 1:10:59talked about, art. Oral argument is a conversation
- 1:11:03and it's impeding your conversation the justices
- 1:11:06may want to go there and they and they can't
- 1:11:08get there because there's somebody else it's
- 1:11:10gonna be doing i've seen those arguments and
- 1:11:11they usually don't work. And the other reason
- 1:11:15why not to split time is because the justices
- 1:11:18don't like it. I've heard Justice Cantil -Sakue
- 1:11:21and also the former Chief Justice and also Justice
- 1:11:24Guerrero both talk about how they really strongly
- 1:11:27discourage splitting time because it interferes
- 1:11:31with their freedom to ask questions on a particular
- 1:11:34subject. Secondly, fighting hypotheticals don't.
- 1:11:39Enjoy them and think through them. Encourage
- 1:11:43your moot people to ask hypotheticals. I know
- 1:11:47there are some justices at the 4th District Division
- 1:11:491 that love them and will ask them all the time.
- 1:11:53And I think that it's, you know, you got to be
- 1:11:55careful because you're saying this is a hypothetical.
- 1:11:57I'm assuming what you're saying. But if you fight
- 1:12:00them, you're not helping because they really
- 1:12:01want to think through something. And sometimes
- 1:12:04hypotheticals are the way they can do it. Of
- 1:12:07course, don't interrupt anybody. Summarizing
- 1:12:11the facts you don't want to summarize the facts
- 1:12:14why because the justices know the facts they
- 1:12:16have that they have the opinion and they have
- 1:12:19that the statement of facts in both of your briefs
- 1:12:22but also the draft opinion that has gone through
- 1:12:26those facts but of course don't hesitate to correct
- 1:12:31factual inaccuracies. Using sat words big words
- 1:12:38generally. I would say no it's not very effective
- 1:12:43because why because again as i said yesterday
- 1:12:46you're not there to convince the justice is how
- 1:12:50smart you are how well you did on your sat that
- 1:12:52you took latin that you want to convince the
- 1:12:55judges that are you want the judges to feel really
- 1:12:58smart about what they're doing and so if you
- 1:13:00did a lot of these just says might not know those
- 1:13:03words so don't. Talking plain, just like I talked
- 1:13:07about introductions and briefs, it's plain language,
- 1:13:10simple language. Get across your point really
- 1:13:12in a simple, but effective way. And that doesn't
- 1:13:17mean that's not, you don't convey complex ideas,
- 1:13:20but your language should be simple. Mispronouncing
- 1:13:24the justice's name, never be very careful about
- 1:13:27that. And don't say like, When a council said
- 1:13:31to the three women panel three justice you guys
- 1:13:35they got really irritated that but I don't call
- 1:13:38them you know call them your honor or justice
- 1:13:41so and so and and ask people how to pronounce
- 1:13:45somebody's name just like you wouldn't want your
- 1:13:47name to be pronounced. Do you want to do the
- 1:13:53rest, Pepsi? Yeah, yeah. And to that, we have
- 1:13:56a few things, sort of things not to say, which
- 1:13:58is the first one. I wasn't trial counsel. It's
- 1:14:02sort of a deflection to a question about the
- 1:14:06record or something that isn't in the record
- 1:14:09that happened at trial or something like that.
- 1:14:14And the court, OK, fine. You weren't trial counsel.
- 1:14:18But you are appellate counsel. And you're the
- 1:14:19counsel standing in front of the court answering,
- 1:14:22You know nominated to answer questions so that
- 1:14:25that doesn't work. If it's something that was
- 1:14:29in the in the record that the Court of Appeal
- 1:14:31has, then you can refer to that. Whether your
- 1:14:34trial counsel or appellate counsel, you should
- 1:14:35be prepared for that. If it isn't in the record,
- 1:14:38then you know the answer isn't. I wasn't trial
- 1:14:41counsel. It's well your honor. That's not in
- 1:14:43the record, but I happen to know ABC happened
- 1:14:48or you know. That's not in the record and I don't
- 1:14:52know what happened or something like that. Whatever
- 1:14:54it is, but I wasn't talking. So isn't the way
- 1:14:57to do it with all due respect. We all know what
- 1:15:00that generally means. That means no respect at
- 1:15:03all. So don't use that phrase personal attacks
- 1:15:06on the judge. You know the trial judge or opposing
- 1:15:10counsel or whatnot that doesn't work. I would
- 1:15:14say particularly in some courts where. Many of
- 1:15:17the Court of Appeal justices were on the trial
- 1:15:19court with many of the judges who are being reviewed.
- 1:15:23And you could have just attacked their bestie,
- 1:15:27their lunch friend, whoever they knew quite well
- 1:15:30on the trial court. And not only that, but no
- 1:15:34judge likes to see that. And the present counsel
- 1:15:39is the same thing. Most judges don't like to
- 1:15:43see fighting or unnecessary aggression or bad
- 1:15:51words or whatever it is between counsel. We'd
- 1:15:54like to believe we're more civilized than that,
- 1:15:57even if it might not be that way outside of the
- 1:15:59courtroom. And then humor is really tough. You
- 1:16:03know, some advocates are really good at it. Some
- 1:16:07experienced advocates are able to express points
- 1:16:11of humor because of their relationships with
- 1:16:13the particular judges, but no one else would
- 1:16:16be able to do that. So sometimes you will see
- 1:16:18that in US Supreme Court arguments or otherwise.
- 1:16:22It seems so nice, everyone's jovial and understanding,
- 1:16:26but it's because of a longstanding relationship
- 1:16:29that they're able to do that. And so you want
- 1:16:32to be cautious in doing that. It almost always
- 1:16:37falls flat unless you know exactly what you're
- 1:16:39doing. OK, next slide. There's a lot more we
- 1:16:45could say, but we need to. OK, so. During the
- 1:16:48response okay so this respondent's role argument
- 1:16:50some special issues if you're the respondent
- 1:16:53you've got to be nimble on your feet and it's
- 1:16:56best not to add memorize an opening because that
- 1:17:00gets you I want to say this. But the argument
- 1:17:04already has gone in a different direction and
- 1:17:07you're in your thinking of it you're thinking
- 1:17:09of what you had prepared before so. What you
- 1:17:12need to do and write it down as soon as you sit
- 1:17:15down for the respondent listen listen listen
- 1:17:17listen support a justice's expressed point during
- 1:17:21the opponent's argument so the. That relates
- 1:17:24to the biggest mistake that I see for respondents,
- 1:17:28and I've seen them lose arguments. When the justices
- 1:17:31are asking the appellant about something, a weakness
- 1:17:34of their case, pick up on that. Don't just start
- 1:17:37talking about something else. The justice will
- 1:17:40think, well, and they'll talk about it later.
- 1:17:42Why didn't the respondent talk about that different
- 1:17:44issue? Was I wrong in that? Doesn't he or she
- 1:17:48believe it's an important dispositive issue?
- 1:17:50Maybe we need to look into this a little bit
- 1:17:52more. For example, I once saw an oral argument
- 1:17:55where the justice was saying to the pellet, well,
- 1:17:58I agree with you on all these elements, but I
- 1:18:00still don't think that you show that there's
- 1:18:02any support for your justifiable reliance element.
- 1:18:06And then when the respondent got up, instead
- 1:18:09of talking about the kind of like echoing what
- 1:18:13the court said about there's no evidence of justifiable
- 1:18:15reliance, they went on all the other elements.
- 1:18:18And that really Put a pause on the panel like
- 1:18:23maybe we're wrong maybe we need to look at that
- 1:18:25and ended up going the other way so be. Listen
- 1:18:30to what the justice are saying and if you're
- 1:18:33the respondent pick up on that the same for the
- 1:18:36appellant to you you need to listen during the
- 1:18:38respondents arguments and so. Yeah and be comfortable
- 1:18:42the other thing is is i know your clients paying
- 1:18:44you big bucks you go there and use and you feel
- 1:18:48like well. You still want to stand up and make
- 1:18:51an argument, but it's going your way. You don't
- 1:18:54need to stand up there forever. The justices
- 1:18:56are, um, and don't say, I'm just there to answer
- 1:18:59questions, either if you're the appellant or
- 1:19:02the respondent, the justices hate that. You want,
- 1:19:05you want to prepare something and say something.
- 1:19:07If you're the appellant and the respondent, you
- 1:19:09respond. Or if you feel you think about it, you're
- 1:19:12listening in real time. I don't think there's
- 1:19:15anything I need to add. stay seated because the
- 1:19:18more you, you know, sometimes I've seen respondents
- 1:19:20lose their case through saying, like talking
- 1:19:23too much. Yeah. Don't, don't snatch a defeat
- 1:19:27from the jaws of victory. Yeah. And I think this
- 1:19:31was a common, this was sort of a common thread
- 1:19:33between this slide about respondents arguments
- 1:19:36and the rebuttal. In both cases, you're being,
- 1:19:39you have to be particularly nimble and paying
- 1:19:43pay attention to the whole playing field, not
- 1:19:46just the play that's happening at the time. So
- 1:19:49you need to be, if you're the respondent, it's
- 1:19:51really hard to... You know, produce your what
- 1:19:54your sort of your opening statement or your theme
- 1:19:57in advance because you want to read not only
- 1:20:00what the your friend on the other side is arguing,
- 1:20:04but also how the court is reacting to that. What
- 1:20:07kinds of signals the court is giving like Melanie
- 1:20:10said, oh, they seem really interested in this
- 1:20:12particular element. I should start with that
- 1:20:15because they're interested in that. I'm not just
- 1:20:18going to go through all the elements of the claim
- 1:20:20in a rote way. I'm going to show that I listen
- 1:20:23to the court, and I listen to that interaction.
- 1:20:26And this is something that I would say, besides
- 1:20:31just listening to the questions and answering
- 1:20:34the questions, which is sort of a top. best practice
- 1:20:41that a lot of judges will talk about in terms
- 1:20:43of oral argument is this one is listen to the
- 1:20:47arguments being made by opposing counsel and
- 1:20:50to the court's response to them and to the court's
- 1:20:53interaction about that, because this is where
- 1:20:56there's a lot more art, I think, in real time
- 1:20:59to preparing the argument as respondent, because
- 1:21:02you have to do all the preparation we talked
- 1:21:04about before, but you also need to be super nimble
- 1:21:08during the other side's argument to adjust and
- 1:21:11to say, ah, the court seems to be going this
- 1:21:13way. I just need to nudge them a little bit on
- 1:21:15this point. So I'm going to start with that,
- 1:21:18then maybe address a couple of other things,
- 1:21:20or maybe just do that and sit down. So you need
- 1:21:25to have that kind of ability to read the room
- 1:21:30and to react and respond to it. So I'm next.
- 1:21:33Yeah, I think one of the I'm just going to because
- 1:21:35that was one of the response. One of the worst
- 1:21:38oral arguments, even though it may not feel that
- 1:21:39way, is when they don't ask you any questions.
- 1:21:41So just just what you're saying and kind of going
- 1:21:44back to why you want to be conversational. You
- 1:21:47want it to if you just if you read or you memorize
- 1:21:51something, you don't give the judges a chance
- 1:21:54to interact with you in a way you kind of put
- 1:21:57up a block. And so. That's what you really you
- 1:22:01want. And we said this before. I'm going to say
- 1:22:03it again. I'm both the respondents. You want
- 1:22:05to draw the questions out. You want the judges
- 1:22:08to ask you questions and you don't want to get
- 1:22:11irritated. You've prepared this wonderful opening
- 1:22:13or respondents. And then they start asking you
- 1:22:16questions. You have this look on your face like,
- 1:22:18don't bother me. I want to get my points across.
- 1:22:21It's not about you and your soliloquy. You want
- 1:22:24to be in a position. You want it. make yourself
- 1:22:27conversational and comfortable, not using big
- 1:22:30words, just talking so that they'll they will
- 1:22:32respond to you and talk to you. That's what that's
- 1:22:35what your goal is. And it takes practice and
- 1:22:37moots are good for that. And if they have questions,
- 1:22:41you want to know what they are. So you can answer
- 1:22:44them. You know, you can you can dispel notions
- 1:22:47that they might have that are not correct. And
- 1:22:50even if they're really hard, like if there's
- 1:22:52really hard questions. you should be prepared
- 1:22:56for those. You know, like the court is gonna
- 1:22:58focus on the key points that will decide the
- 1:23:02case. And that key point may have some, you know,
- 1:23:05warts and all that you need to address and you
- 1:23:09need to be prepared for those. So in your preparation,
- 1:23:11you do not shy away from the hard questions.
- 1:23:14You don't try away from the hard issues because
- 1:23:16those invariably are going to be the issues you
- 1:23:18are going to be asked about and that will determine
- 1:23:21the case. So if you're happy to talk about other
- 1:23:24things, it's just not going to matter. Exactly.
- 1:23:28We did the next slide. I think that's the reply.
- 1:23:32Yeah, rebuttal is the same. I think it has a
- 1:23:35lot of the same principles as the respondents.
- 1:23:38You need to be really nimble. You need to be
- 1:23:41listening to the interactions and the overall
- 1:23:44interactions of the court and the questions between
- 1:23:48the opening and the response. until you're doing
- 1:23:51a lot of the same things, but harkening back
- 1:23:57to your opening, if you can, if you've anticipated
- 1:23:59things of saying, well, you know, and this just
- 1:24:01reinforces what I said in the opening about why
- 1:24:03we need to win, you know, for the following reason.
- 1:24:06Right. And you reinforce what the court said.
- 1:24:09If the justice said something that was good for
- 1:24:11you, reinforce that. And if you have a good chart
- 1:24:13of the arguments you made in the opening, you
- 1:24:15can just be checking them as they're talking
- 1:24:17and seeing which ones they've addressed and which
- 1:24:20ones they haven't. So you can respond. And just
- 1:24:22like a reply brief, a rebuttal at oral argument
- 1:24:25is key because it gets you down to the actual
- 1:24:28nub of the issues. But I know we're kind of running
- 1:24:30close to it. Yeah. So we're just in the last.
- 1:24:34I want to cover just the next slide. in terms
- 1:24:38of the differences between oral argument and
- 1:24:42federal and state court. We talked about that,
- 1:24:44which is just, you know, being aware of that.
- 1:24:46Yeah, being aware of that and knowing the differences,
- 1:24:50that's part of your preparation. What part of
- 1:24:54the court you're at. I'm sorry, there's technical
- 1:24:56difficulties right now. No problem. No problem.
- 1:25:01So anyway, so. So again, knowing your court and
- 1:25:06knowing the judges you're arguing in front of,
- 1:25:08but also knowing what the role of that particular
- 1:25:12court is, how they conduct arguments, all of
- 1:25:14the things that we've talked about throughout
- 1:25:17the presentation. So let me just make sure we
- 1:25:21don't have it. No, we don't have any more questions.
- 1:25:23We answered the Q &A. I just want to say, oh,
- 1:25:27I was going to say on that last slide that this
- 1:25:28California Supreme Court, these people It is
- 1:25:32wonderful they are all that's a conversation
- 1:25:35if you want to see a good argument every single
- 1:25:37one of them because they ask good questions and
- 1:25:39they are open to discussion so if you have like
- 1:25:42you want some free time to have an enjoyable
- 1:25:45hour watch on video the spring court is kind
- 1:25:48of what i like to do yes so oh there it is yes
- 1:25:53i think we talked about the difference in the
- 1:25:56california court. Yeah, we did. I just want to
- 1:25:58make sure that we reminded everyone of that.
- 1:26:01So thank you so much, everyone who joined us
- 1:26:05today and also previously for brief writing.
- 1:26:08And as we mentioned in the brief writing session,
- 1:26:10if you have any questions, feel free to contact
- 1:26:13us and take a look at the materials we provided
- 1:26:18with the program as well. There's a lot of good
- 1:26:22nuggets in there for you and your oral argument.
- 1:26:26Good luck with your appellate arguments and thank
- 1:26:30you for joining us and thank you to the Beverly
- 1:26:32Hills Bar Association for doing the hard work
- 1:26:36to put these programs on. We appreciate you.
- 1:26:41Thank you.