Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The United States Governments Brief In Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's Appeal Request (Part 7)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04In this episode, we're getting right back to the United
- 0:06States Government's brief in response to Glenn Maxwell's attempt to
- 0:10appeal her sentence point number three, the District Court did
- 0:15not abuse its discretion in concluding that jur fifty could
- 0:18be fair and impartial, notwithstanding his inadvertent mistakes on his
- 0:23jur questionnaire. Maxwell contends that she was denied her right
- 0:26to affair and impartial jury because a juror failed to
- 0:30disclose during vor Dyer that he was sexually abused as
- 0:33a child, and therefore incorrectly answered this question on his
- 0:37written questionnaire. After an extensive hearing, Judge Nathan concluded that
- 0:42the juror's error was inadvertent and in any event, she
- 0:45would not obstruct the juror for cause had he answered
- 0:48those questions accurately because he was not biased in any
- 0:51way against Maxwell and was qualified to serve as a
- 0:54jur Judge Nathan therefore found that Maxwell failed to meet
- 0:58the high bar for a new tribe and denied or motion.
- 1:01This Court should affirm that careful determination a relevant facts
- 1:06one the jury selection process. In November twenty twenty one.
- 1:11In advance of trial, six hundred and ninety four jurors
- 1:14completed a jury questionnaire approved by the District Court. The
- 1:18juror questionnaire was twenty nine pages and consisted of fifty
- 1:22one questions, many of which contained subparts. After the party's
- 1:26review the questionnaires, two hundred and thirty one of the
- 1:29six hundred and ninety four proceeded to vordier. The District
- 1:34Court then examined prospective jurors, asking them about questions in
- 1:37the jury questionnaire that prospective jurors had answered affirmatively. The
- 1:42District Court asked the prospective jurors whether the information or
- 1:45experiences resulting in the affirmative answer would interfere with their
- 1:49ability to be fair and impartial. At the conclusion of
- 1:53the vordire, the District Court qualified fifty eight jurors. Of
- 1:57the fifty eight individuals who were qualified to serve as jurors,
- 2:01eight individuals responded to question forty eight of the juror
- 2:04questionnaire that they themselves had been a victim of sexual harassment,
- 2:08sexual abuse, or sexual assault, and that this experience would
- 2:12not affect their ability to serve fairly end impartially as
- 2:16a jur in the case each confirm that he or
- 2:19she could be fair and impartial, and defense counsel did
- 2:23not move to strike any of these jurors for cause
- 2:25based on their answers to question forty eight. For instance,
- 2:29one juror said that she was sexually molested by an
- 2:32uncle when she was twelve or thirteen, but that would
- 2:35not affect her ability to be fair and impartial in
- 2:38the case. Another jur indicated that she had recently reported
- 2:42that a friend was being coerced and sexually abused by
- 2:45a professor, but confirmed that the experience would not in
- 2:49any way interfere with her ability to be fair and impartial.
- 2:54Neither the government nor the Defense council challenged those jurors
- 2:57for cause. The parties then exercised the peremptory strikes and
- 3:01the jury was seated two jur number fifty jurf fifty
- 3:06completed the questionnaire and was questioned by Judge Nathan during vordre.
- 3:11In his questionnaire, jur fifty repeatedly made clear that he
- 3:14could be fair and impartial. In response to question number thirteen,
- 3:18he indicated that he could decide the case based solely
- 3:21on the evidence or lack of evidence presented in court
- 3:24and not on the basis of conjecture, suspicion, bias, sympathy,
- 3:29or prejudice. He also accepted the principle that the law
- 3:32provides that a defendant in a criminal case is presumed
- 3:36innocent and the government is required to prove guilt beyond
- 3:39a reasonable doubt. Jur fifty indicated that there was nothing
- 3:44about the nature of the case and the accusations as
- 3:47summarized in the questionnaire that might make it difficult for
- 3:50him to be fair and impartial. He repeated these assurances
- 3:54at Oral Vor Dire. Jur fifty checked the no box
- 3:59in response to question forty eight, which asked whether he
- 4:03or a friend or family member had ever been the
- 4:05victim of sexual harassment, sexual abuse, or a sexual assault.
- 4:10He also checked the NOE box in response to the
- 4:12question of whether he or any of his relatives or
- 4:15close friends had ever been the victim of a crime.
- 4:18Jury Number fifty was seated following the verdict. He discussed
- 4:22his experience as a jur during interviews with multiple journalists.
- 4:26During these interviews, Juror fifty stated that he was a
- 4:29survivor of childhood sexual abuse, which he did not disclose
- 4:33until high school, and that his experience of sexual abuse
- 4:36did not affect his ability to view Maxwell as innocent
- 4:39until proven guilty. He also stated that he did not
- 4:43recall the details of the jury questionnaire which he flew through,
- 4:46but he believed he answered the questions honestly three the hearing.
- 4:51Following these reports, the government filed a letter highlighting Jur
- 4:54of fifty's public statements and requesting that the district Court
- 4:58conduct a hearing or briefing. Judge Nathan ordered a limited
- 5:02hearing focused on Jur fifty's potential failure to respond truthfully
- 5:06to the questions during the jury selection process that asked
- 5:10for the material information. Judge Nathan denied Maxwell's request to
- 5:14directly question Jur fifty, which was committed to her sound discretion,
- 5:18but permitted the parties to propose questions in advance of
- 5:21the hearing. The parties did so, and Maxwell submitted a
- 5:25letter renewing her request to question Jur fifty directly and
- 5:29proposing twenty one pages of questions on topics including the
- 5:33nature and length of the jur fifties sexual abuse, the
- 5:37nature of the sexual abuse experienced by any of Jure
- 5:40fifty's family or friends, his own employment responsibilities, the impact
- 5:46of his sexual abuse on his life and personal relationships,
- 5:49whether jur fifty ever sought mental health counseling or spoke
- 5:52with the therapist, how he came to give media interviews,
- 5:56and whether he was attempting to be viewed as a
- 5:58champion of victims of sexual abuse. The District Court held
- 6:03the hearing on March eighth, twenty twenty two, at which
- 6:06jerv fifty testified under a grant of immunity. Jerf fifty
- 6:10testified that his answers to three questions were not accurate.
- 6:14Questions twenty five whether he or a close associate had
- 6:17been a victim of a crime, forty eight whether he
- 6:20or a friend or a family member had ever been
- 6:23a victim of sexual harassment or abuse, and forty nine
- 6:26whether he or a family member had been accused of
- 6:29sexual harassment or abuse. He explained that when he was
- 6:32nine or ten years old, he was sexually abused by
- 6:35a stepbrother who he no longer considered part of the family,
- 6:39and the stepbrother's friend. He explained that he answered question
- 6:42forty nine no because he no longer considered the stepbrother
- 6:46part of his family, although he should have answered yes.
- 6:49He also acknowledged that he should have answered yes to
- 6:51question twenty five because he was a crime victim, although
- 6:55he read the question at the time to inquire about robbery, mugging,
- 6:59or similar crimes. Jur fifty also testified that his failure
- 7:04to disclose his experience was an inadvertent mistake. He explained
- 7:08that he completely skimmed way too fast when completing the questionnaire.
- 7:12He did so, he explained in light of the context.
- 7:15He started the questionnaire after several hours waiting in security
- 7:19lines and after technical issues with the instructions. He was
- 7:23preoccupied with his own recent romantic breakup and with disruptions
- 7:27in the jury room, and he rushed to complete the
- 7:29questionnaire because he thought it virtually impossible that he would
- 7:32be selected as a jur given the number of people
- 7:35completing the questionnaire. He did not generally think about his
- 7:38personal history of sexual abuse, and it did not occur
- 7:41to him while carelessly speeding through the questionnaire. At oral
- 7:45vor Dyer, Jur fifty had not been asked the questions
- 7:48Judge Nathan pose to prospective jurors who answered affirmatively to
- 7:52questions twenty five forty eight or forty nine, and therefore
- 7:56was not asked questions about sexual abuse. At the hearing.
- 7:59Judge Nathan examined jur fifty in detail, and Juror fifty
- 8:03emphasized that his experiences did not affect his ability to
- 8:07be fair and impartial, or his ability to fairly assess
- 8:11the credibility of victim witnesses, or his ability to impartially
- 8:14judge Maxwell's guilt. For the District Court's decision, Judge Nathan
- 8:20denied Maxwell's motion for a new trial in a detailed
- 8:22written opinion. First Judge Nathan concluded that jur of fifty's
- 8:26answers were not deliberately inaccurate, crediting jurf fifty's testimony in
- 8:30light of his demeanor and consistent logical answers to her questions.
- 8:35Second Judge Nathan concluded that she would not have granted
- 8:39a four cause challenge to Juror fifty had he provided
- 8:42accurate information at the hearing. Judge Nathan asked Juru fifty
- 8:46the questions she asked other jurors who indicated a personal
- 8:50experience with sexual assault or abuse. She concluded that Juror
- 8:54fifty's credible responses to those questions under oath at the
- 8:58hearing established that he would not have been struck for
- 9:01cause if he had provided accurate responses to the questionnaire.
- 9:05As Judge Nathan explained, other jurors who answered the questions
- 9:08similarly were not even challenged for cause, and she would
- 9:12not have granted a challenge had one been made. She
- 9:15also rejected the notion that these similarities between Juror fifty's
- 9:18life experiences and the issues at trial required her to
- 9:22excuse Juror fifty for cause. B Applicable law Federal rule
- 9:26a criminal Procedure thirty three permits a district court to
- 9:29vacate any judgment and grant a new trial if the
- 9:32interest of justice so requires. As this Court has explained,
- 9:36the defendant bears the burden of proving that he is
- 9:39entitled to a new trial under rule thirty three, and
- 9:42before ordering a new trial pursuant to Rule thirty three,
- 9:45a district court must find that there is a real
- 9:48concern that an innocent person may have been convicted. United
- 9:52States vers. Mccorty, five sixty two Ft three d four
- 9:55to fifty eight, four to seventy five, Second Circuit two
- 9:58thousand and nine verdict. Inquiries into jury conduct are strongly disfavored.
- 10:03Such inquiries seriously disrupt the finality of the process. Tanner
- 10:08versus United States for eighty three US one oh seven,
- 10:11one twenty one, twenty one, nineteen eighty seven. Permitting post
- 10:15verdicts scrutiny of jury conduct would undermine pillars that undergird
- 10:19the jury trial right, including full and frank discussions in
- 10:23the jury room, juror's willingness to return an unpopular verdict,
- 10:27and the community's trust in a system that relies on
- 10:30the decision of lay people. Such inquiries may instead lead
- 10:34to evil consequences, subjecting juries to harassment, inhibiting jury room deliberation,
- 10:40burdening courts with meritless applications, increasing temptation for jury tampering,
- 10:45and creating uncertainty in jury verdicts. United States versus Ionello,
- 10:50eight sixty six f dot two D five forty five
- 10:53forty three, Second Circuit, nineteen eighty nine. Accordingly, a defendant
- 10:58seeking Rule thirty three relief based on alleged juror misrepresentations
- 11:02during vorddire must satisfy a stringent two part test. First,
- 11:07a party must demonstrate that a djur failed to answer
- 11:10honestly a material question. On vor Dyre McDonough Power Equipment Incorporated.
- 11:15Versus Greenwood for sixty four US five forty eight five
- 11:19point fifty six, nineteen eighty four. Second, the party must
- 11:23show that a correct response would have provided a valid
- 11:26basis for a challenge for cause. To satisfy this prong,
- 11:30a court must determine whether if the juror had answered truthfully,
- 11:34it would have granted a hypothetical strike for cause United
- 11:37States vers. Stuart, four to thirty three F. Dot three,
- 11:40D two seventy three three zero four, Second Circuit, two
- 11:43thousand and six. A party may challenge a juror for
- 11:47cause based only on narrowly specified, provable, and legally cognizable
- 11:52basis United States versus Torres, one twenty eight F. Dot
- 11:56three D thirty eight forty three, Second circuitnineteen ninety seven.
- 12:01In the context of oor dire, challenges for cause generally
- 12:04fall into one of three limited categories. Actual bias, implied bias,
- 12:09and inferable bias. Actual bias is bias, in fact, the
- 12:14existence of a state of mind that leads to an
- 12:16inference that the person will not act with entire impartiality.
- 12:21Implied bias, also called presumed bias, is a bias conclusively
- 12:25presumed as a matter of law. This Court has emphasized
- 12:28that this category is narrow and reserved for exceptional situations,
- 12:33generally meaning circumstances in which jurors are related to the
- 12:36parties or were victims of the alleged crime itself Idea at.
- 12:40Forty five and forty six. Finally, bias may be inferred
- 12:44when a jur discloses a fact that bespeaks a risk
- 12:48partiality sufficiently significant a warrant granting the trial judge discretion
- 12:53to excuse the jur for cause, but not so great
- 12:56as to make mandatory a presumption of bias. Where there
- 13:00are concrete allegations of duram misconduct, a court may conduct
- 13:04a post verdict hearing see United States versus Baker, eight
- 13:07ninety nine F. Dot three D one twenty three one
- 13:10thirty Second Circuit twenty eighteen. The inquiry should be limited
- 13:14to only what is absolutely necessary to determine the facts
- 13:18with precision. Ianello eight sixty six f. Dot two d
- 13:22at five forty four. The proper functioning of the jury
- 13:25system requires that the courts protect jurors from being harassed
- 13:29and beset by defeated party in an effort to secure
- 13:33from them evidence of fact which might establish misconducts sufficient
- 13:37to set aside a verdict Moten five eighty two f
- 13:41Dot two d at six sixty four. Accordingly, the district
- 13:45court has the power and the duty to supervise and
- 13:48closely control such inquiries United States vers. Calbus, eight twenty
- 13:52one f dot two d. Eight eighty seven, eight ninety six,
- 13:56Second Circuit. Nineteen eighty seven. For example, the disc court
- 14:00may choose to personally conduct the questioning of a jur
- 14:03in order to avoid intruding on the jury's deliberations ce Gcalbus,
- 14:09eight twenty one f Dot two d at. Eight ninety six.
- 14:12At such a hearing, and with limited exceptions, the jur
- 14:15may not testify about any statement made or incident that
- 14:19occurred during the jury's deliberations, the effect of anything on
- 14:23that jur or another jurors vote, or any jurors mental
- 14:27processes concerning the verdict or indictment. The court may not
- 14:31receive a jurors aff david or evidence of a juris statement.
- 14:34On these matters fed are evidence six oh six B one.
- 14:39This Court reviews the denial of a rule thirty three
- 14:41motion for abuse of discretion United States verus. Archer, nine
- 14:45seventy seven f Dot three D one eighty one one
- 14:48eighty seven, Second Circuit, twenty twenty. A district court only
- 14:52abuses its discretion if its decision rests on an error
- 14:56of law, such as application of the wrong legal principle
- 14:59or a clearly erroneous factual finding, or its decision cannot
- 15:03be located within the range of permissible decisions. This Court
- 15:08has only, on rare occasions, overturned a verdict or remanded
- 15:12for an evidentiary hearing based on the failure of a
- 15:15jur to disclose information during jury selection. United States versus Temen,
- 15:21four to sixty five F. Dot s upp Dot three
- 15:25D two seventy seven three point thirty sdn Y, twenty twenty.
- 15:29All Right, we're gonna wrap up this episode here and
- 15:32then the next episode dealing with the topic, We're gonna
- 15:34pick up where we left off, and that's with Part C,
- 15:38the discussion. All of the information that goes with this
- 15:41episode can be found in the description box