Latest / StarQuest Media / What Are Demons?
Transcript
- 0:00Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is brought to you by the StarQuest
- 0:03Dom Bettinelli: Production Network and is made possible by our many generous patrons.
- 0:07Dom Bettinelli: If you'd like to support the podcast, please visit givemysterious.
- 0:11Dom Bettinelli: fm.
- 0:12Dom Bettinelli: You're listening to episode 442 of Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World, where we look at mysteries from the twin perspectives of faith and reason.
- 0:23Dom Bettinelli: In this episode, we're talking about what demons
- 0:26Dom Bettinelli: are.
- 0:27Dom Bettinelli: I'm Dom Bettinelli, and joining me as always is Jimmy Akin.
- 0:31Dom Bettinelli: Hey Jimmy!
- 0:31Dom Bettinelli: Howdy, Dom.
- 0:33Dom Bettinelli: And folks, be sure to stick around for the end of the episode.
- 0:35Dom Bettinelli: We'll have your feedback on our recent episode number 431
- 0:39Dom Bettinelli: on Auras.
- 0:41Dom Bettinelli: But first, we all think we know what a demon is.
- 0:45Dom Bettinelli: A fallen angel, a rebel spirit that turned against God, and that's what the Catholic Church means by the word
- 0:51Dom Bettinelli: in her documents today.
- 0:53Dom Bettinelli: But
- 0:53Dom Bettinelli: demon is a Greek term, and it's far older than the Christian idea of a fallen angel.
- 0:59Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:00Dom Bettinelli: what did it mean before?
- 1:02Dom Bettinelli: A fallen angel, a pagan god, or a spirit of the restless dead?
- 1:07Dom Bettinelli: And does the New Testament ever use the word
- 1:10Dom Bettinelli: way
- 1:10Dom Bettinelli: the way we use it now?
- 1:12Dom Bettinelli: Well, that's what we'll be talking about on this episode of Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World.
- 1:17Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:17Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, we've done a bunch of episodes that involve demons, but today we're asking a more basic question, what
- 1:25Dom Bettinelli: is a demon?
- 1:26Dom Bettinelli: So where do we even start?
- 1:28Jimmy Akin: Well, we've talked about demons a lot on this show.
- 1:31Jimmy Akin: For example, we looked at whether unexplained events should be assumed to be demonic in It's
- 1:36Jimmy Akin: Always Demons, which was episode 188.
- 1:39Jimmy Akin: We also talked about the idea that it's always alien demons in episode 281.
- 1:45Jimmy Akin: We helped a man sort out uh
- 1:47Jimmy Akin: who was worried about possession uh
- 1:50Jimmy Akin: in a Satanist
- 1:51Jimmy Akin: Ask for Help, which was episode 302.
- 1:54Jimmy Akin: We talked
- 1:55Jimmy Akin: about and went through the rites of exorcism in episode 342, and I did a whole Ask Me Anything
- 2:00Jimmy Akin: About Demons in episode 384.
- 2:03Jimmy Akin: But
- 2:03Jimmy Akin: today's episode isn't about what demons do.
- 2:07Jimmy Akin: It's about what a demon fundamentally is, and will be telling their secret origin
- 2:12Jimmy Akin: story
- 2:13Jimmy Akin: or stories
- 2:15Jimmy Akin: The question of what demons are
- 2:17Jimmy Akin: is something that people today
- 2:19Jimmy Akin: usually skip right over
- 2:21Jimmy Akin: because we assume we already know the answer.
- 2:24Jimmy Akin: But the standard answer today is only the last stop on a long road.
- 2:29Dom Bettinelli: Then let's start by casting a wide net and look for the broadest understanding of what
- 2:34Dom Bettinelli: of demons that we can find.
- 2:36Dom Bettinelli: Do other religions, besides Christianity, have a concept of demons?
- 2:41Jimmy Akin: They do, and this requires a little bit of nuance.
- 2:44Jimmy Akin: One of the reasons is the fact that people all over the world mm
- 2:48Jimmy Akin: speak different languages, and not every language has a word that's a direct equivalent of our term demon
- 2:54Jimmy Akin: However, there are spirits in the different world religions that are similar enough to what we think of as a demon
- 3:01Jimmy Akin: that scholars of world religions and anthropologists refer to them as demons, at least when they're translating or composing texts.
- 3:10Jimmy Akin: in English.
- 3:11Jimmy Akin: So
- 3:11Jimmy Akin: if you look
- 3:12Jimmy Akin: not just in modern Western religions like Judaism, Christianity, and Islam,
- 3:18Jimmy Akin: But also in other religions, you will find demons, uh
- 3:21Jimmy Akin: you will find spirits that scholars refer to as demons.
- 3:25Jimmy Akin: So
- 3:25Jimmy Akin: Hinduism has demons, Buddhism
- 3:28Jimmy Akin: has demons.
- 3:29Jimmy Akin: Shinto
- 3:30Jimmy Akin: has demons, Zoroastrianism does, Taoism
- 3:34Jimmy Akin: does, and various African religions have them.
- 3:38Jimmy Akin: And so do older ancient religions, including the folk
- 3:42Jimmy Akin: religions of Mesopotamia, Egypt, Greece, and Rome.
- 3:46Jimmy Akin: One of the things that these demons have in common is that they tend to be superior to humans in terms of power, but they're not supreme.
- 3:56Jimmy Akin: In other words, there are
- 3:58Jimmy Akin: intermediate spirits that have power somewhere between that of humans and gods
- 4:04Jimmy Akin: Another thing about demons in the different world religions is that they tend to be connected to misfortune of various kinds, like
- 4:12Jimmy Akin: they may cause disease
- 4:14Jimmy Akin: or mental illness, death, or bad luck.
- 4:18Jimmy Akin: That doesn't mean that they're always understood as evil beings, the way we think of demons.
- 4:23Jimmy Akin: In some cases, in these world religions, demons are evil.
- 4:28Jimmy Akin: But in other cases, they might be amoral, neither good nor bad, or they might be neutral, or they might even be good.
- 4:36Jimmy Akin: So
- 4:36Jimmy Akin: in some world religions, you might appeal to a good demon to protect you and your family, for example, by
- 4:44Jimmy Akin: scaring or inflicting harm.
- 4:47Jimmy Akin: on human beings who would harm you.
- 4:49Jimmy Akin: You know, if someone's
- 4:50Jimmy Akin: some human's trying to harm you, you might want a good demon to protect you from them.
- 4:56Jimmy Akin: Or
- 4:57Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 4:57Jimmy Akin: you
- 4:57Jimmy Akin: might want a good demon to scare away bad dreams
- 5:00Jimmy Akin: or scare away the truly evil spirits.
- 5:03Jimmy Akin: At least that's how people in some religions think about them.
- 5:06Jimmy Akin: So a key thing to remember is that in world religions, you don't automatically assume that the demons are always envisioned as evil.
- 5:15Jimmy Akin: In fact
- 5:16Jimmy Akin: Understanding that will be important for understanding how the term and the concept developed in Christianity.
- 5:24Jimmy Akin: A final thing to know about demons in world religions is that they
- 5:29Jimmy Akin: aren't tied
- 5:30Jimmy Akin: to the Christian concept of angels.
- 5:32Jimmy Akin: Most religions don't have a category of angels the way we do
- 5:37Jimmy Akin: They may have a category, you know, a minor category
- 5:41Jimmy Akin: of messengers of the God, which is the origin of the concept of angels.
- 5:47Jimmy Akin: In fact, in Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek, the term for angel means messenger.
- 5:53Jimmy Akin: So
- 5:54Jimmy Akin: angels are God's messengers.
- 5:56Jimmy Akin: And in Christianity, the term expanded to include spirits that aren't actually messengers, like Isaiah's Seraphim and Ezekiel's cherubim.
- 6:07Jimmy Akin: who
- 6:07Jimmy Akin: are actually guardians of God's throne.
- 6:10Jimmy Akin: So they're throne guardians rather than messengers.
- 6:13Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 6:14Jimmy Akin: today
- 6:15Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 6:16Jimmy Akin: Angel
- 6:17Jimmy Akin: is a major category that isn't strictly identical with the task of delivering messages
- 6:23Jimmy Akin: And
- 6:23Jimmy Akin: just as we're doing an episode on what demons are today, we'll do a future episode on what angels are, so we can talk about that then.
- 6:32Jimmy Akin: But other religions, even though they don't have a class of beings
- 6:36Jimmy Akin: they refer to as messengers, they they can
- 6:40Jimmy Akin: have the concept
- 6:41Jimmy Akin: of messengers of the gods, like Hermes
- 6:45Jimmy Akin: or Mercury
- 6:46Jimmy Akin: was the messenger of the Greco-Roman gods.
- 6:49Jimmy Akin: So
- 6:49Jimmy Akin: people
- 6:50Jimmy Akin: in the ancient Greek religion could well
- 6:52Jimmy Akin: think of him as an angel
- 6:55Jimmy Akin: you know, a messenger, even though he was also considered a god.
- 6:59Jimmy Akin: But, like I said, other religions don't have a big
- 7:02Jimmy Akin: generic angel category, and so what scholars call demons in different religions
- 7:09Jimmy Akin: aren't
- 7:09Jimmy Akin: thought of as fallen
- 7:11Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 7:12Jimmy Akin: They are often non-human spirits, but
- 7:16Jimmy Akin: they
- 7:16Jimmy Akin: are
- 7:17Jimmy Akin: also
- 7:17Jimmy Akin: sometimes the spirits of human beings.
- 7:20Jimmy Akin: For example, people who did bad things in life might become demons after their deaths, or in
- 7:27Jimmy Akin: religions that believe in reincarnation.
- 7:29Jimmy Akin: People who did bad things in this life might be reborn as demons in their next life.
- 7:36Jimmy Akin: Also, people who died violent deaths
- 7:38Jimmy Akin: or were unburied
- 7:40Jimmy Akin: or improperly buried or were neglected after their deaths.
- 7:45Jimmy Akin: Well, they might get mad for any one of those reasons and might become demons
- 7:49Jimmy Akin: in the next life or in their next life.
- 7:52Jimmy Akin: I point
- 7:53Jimmy Akin: all this out to show how there's not just a single concept of demons in the different religions.
- 7:59Jimmy Akin: There is generally
- 8:01Jimmy Akin: something that you can call demons.
- 8:03Jimmy Akin: in the different religions
- 8:05Jimmy Akin: and if I were to give a broad anthropological definition, trying to catch as many of 'em as possible
- 8:11Jimmy Akin: I would say
- 8:12Jimmy Akin: that a demon is an intermediate spirit between the level of humans and the God level.
- 8:19Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 8:20Jimmy Akin: that the demon may be evil, neutral, or good.
- 8:24Jimmy Akin: That
- 8:24Jimmy Akin: at least that's how it's understood.
- 8:26Jimmy Akin: uh
- 8:27Jimmy Akin: and that the demon is in some way connected with misfortune.
- 8:31Jimmy Akin: At least
- 8:31Jimmy Akin: that's how people in the different religions tend to understand them
- 8:35Jimmy Akin: And everyone has misfortune in life, so people
- 8:39Jimmy Akin: usually have a spirit category that they can call a demon.
- 8:44Dom Bettinelli: Okay, but in Christianity today, the term demon means something much more specific.
- 8:50Jimmy Akin: Yeah, uh
- 8:51Jimmy Akin: the way Christians use language today, a demon is a fallen angel.
- 8:56Jimmy Akin: Here's what the catechism of the Catholic Church has to say in paragraph 414.
- 9:01Voiceover: Satan or the devil and the other demons are fallen angels, who have freely refused to serve God and his
- 9:08Voiceover: plan.
- 9:09Voiceover: Their choice against God is definitive.
- 9:12Voiceover: They try to associate man in their revolt against God
- 9:17Jimmy Akin: So the modern definition is that demons
- 9:20Jimmy Akin: are fallen angels who have freely refused to serve God.
- 9:25Jimmy Akin: And
- 9:26Jimmy Akin: there are
- 9:27Jimmy Akin: fallen
- 9:27Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 9:28Jimmy Akin: So
- 9:29Jimmy Akin: demons in the modern sense definitely exist
- 9:33Jimmy Akin: Remember that
- 9:34Jimmy Akin: because it's going to be important as we go forward.
- 9:37Jimmy Akin: We're not saying that demons don't exist
- 9:39Jimmy Akin: or that they're not fallen
- 9:41Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 9:41Jimmy Akin: Fallen
- 9:42Jimmy Akin: angels are real, and so demonic fallen
- 9:45Jimmy Akin: angels are real.
- 9:47Jimmy Akin: They do possess people
- 9:49Jimmy Akin: and they do need to be exercised.
- 9:52Jimmy Akin: We're just going to be looking at additional senses
- 9:55Jimmy Akin: that the term has been used in
- 9:57Jimmy Akin: in history
- 9:59Jimmy Akin: Because here's the thing.
- 10:01Jimmy Akin: Demon is a word that comes to us from Greek.
- 10:05Jimmy Akin: Greek speakers were using it long before Christianity arose, and they didn't have the concept of fallen angels
- 10:12Jimmy Akin: So
- 10:13Jimmy Akin: they used the word to mean something else, and thus the word has changed meaning.
- 10:18Jimmy Akin: In other words, there's a history of how the word developed, from what it originally meant to what it means today.
- 10:25Jimmy Akin: And that's what this episode is about.
- 10:27Jimmy Akin: And the history of words is something that we can work out by reason
- 10:32Jimmy Akin: So
- 10:33Jimmy Akin: today the background and reason perspectives will be combined
- 10:36Jimmy Akin: and then we'll look at how what we learn affects or doesn't affect the faith.
- 10:41Dom Bettinelli: Before we go back to the Greeks, I know that there's something surprising hiding in the Bible itself.
- 10:47Dom Bettinelli: What is it?
- 10:48Jimmy Akin: It's something that most people never notice when they read the Bible, but the New Testament uses several different words for evil spiritual creatures.
- 10:56Jimmy Akin: In Greek it uses three main
- 10:59Jimmy Akin: ones.
- 11:00Jimmy Akin: One is the term
- 11:02Jimmy Akin: daimon, which means demon.
- 11:05Jimmy Akin: Another is pneuma
- 11:07Jimmy Akin: akatharton, which means an unclean spirit.
- 11:11Jimmy Akin: And another is Pneuma
- 11:13Jimmy Akin: Poneeron, which means an evil spirit.
- 11:17Jimmy Akin: The question is
- 11:18Jimmy Akin: whether those three
- 11:21Jimmy Akin: Terms
- 11:22Jimmy Akin: refer to three different things
- 11:23Jimmy Akin: or whether they're just three labels for one thing.
- 11:27Jimmy Akin: Because of how we use the terms today, readers just tend to assume they're all the same thing.
- 11:32Jimmy Akin: A demon is an unclean spirit, is an evil
- 11:36Jimmy Akin: evil spirit.
- 11:37Jimmy Akin: But from a scholarly perspective, that's not something you can just assume.
- 11:42Jimmy Akin: You have to prove it.
- 11:44Jimmy Akin: And the way you do that is by looking at how terms get used in the New Testament.
- 11:50Dom Bettinelli: So
- 11:50Dom Bettinelli: we've got a detective story on our hands, so how do we go about cracking it?
- 11:55Jimmy Akin: One way of solving it is by looking at how a single author
- 11:59Jimmy Akin: uses the terms.
- 12:01Jimmy Akin: For example, in a given story in the Gospels, does the author refer to something both as a demon and as an unclean spirit?
- 12:10Jimmy Akin: If he does, then that shows you that at least some of the time the two terms mean the same thing.
- 12:16Jimmy Akin: For example,
- 12:17Jimmy Akin: consider the Garrison demoniac in Mark V.
- 12:20Jimmy Akin: Here's how the story opens
- 12:23Voiceover: And when Jesus had stepped out of the boat, immediately there met him under the tombs
- 12:28Voiceover: a man with an unclean spirit.
- 12:30Voiceover: And when he saw Jesus from afar, he ran and fell down before him
- 12:35Voiceover: And, crying out with a loud voice, he said, What have you to do with me, Jesus, Son of the Most High God?
- 12:42Voiceover: I adjure you by God, do not torment me
- 12:45Voiceover: For he was saying to him, Come out of the man, you unclean spirit.
- 12:51Jimmy Akin: So
- 12:51Jimmy Akin: Mark calls the entity in the man an unclean spirit
- 12:55Jimmy Akin: twice
- 12:56Jimmy Akin: both in Mark's narration and in Jesus'
- 12:59Jimmy Akin: command
- 13:00Jimmy Akin: come out.
- 13:01Jimmy Akin: Only it turns out that there's a whole legion of unclean spirits in him
- 13:06Jimmy Akin: So
- 13:06Jimmy Akin: Jesus casts them out
- 13:08Jimmy Akin: and lets the unclean spirits that had possessed the man go into a herd of pigs.
- 13:12Jimmy Akin: Then
- 13:13Jimmy Akin: Mark says,
- 13:14Voiceover: And the people came to Jesus and saw the demon-possessed man, the one who had had the legion, sitting there, clothed and in his right mind, and they were afraid.
- 13:25Voiceover: And those who had seen it described to them what had happened to the demon-possessed man and to the pigs.
- 13:31Jimmy Akin: Mark now calls him the demon-possessed man, again, twice.
- 13:35Jimmy Akin: So
- 13:36Jimmy Akin: what Mark first calls an unclean spirit, he now calls a demon.
- 13:41Jimmy Akin: That means an unclean spirit can be regarded as a demon
- 13:45Jimmy Akin: too.
- 13:46Jimmy Akin: We can also add the term evil spirit to the mix.
- 13:49Jimmy Akin: Over in Luke chapter
- 13:50Jimmy Akin: eight
- 13:51Jimmy Akin: we read.
- 13:52Voiceover: Soon afterward, Jesus went on through cities and villages, proclaiming and bringing the good news of the kingdom of God.
- 14:00Voiceover: And the twelve were with him, and also some women who had been healed of evil spirits and infirmities.
- 14:06Voiceover: Mary called Magdalene, from whom seven demons had gone out
- 14:11Jimmy Akin: Here
- 14:11Jimmy Akin: the women are healed of evil spirits, including Mary, who had seven demons.
- 14:17Jimmy Akin: So
- 14:17Jimmy Akin: Luke calls them
- 14:19Jimmy Akin: evil spirits, and he specifically calls Mary Magdalene's s
- 14:23Jimmy Akin: spirits
- 14:24Jimmy Akin: demons.
- 14:25Jimmy Akin: That indicates that the term
- 14:27Jimmy Akin: evil spirit can also be used to mean demon.
- 14:31Jimmy Akin: Another way of approaching this is by looking at parallel passages in the Gospels, because
- 14:36Jimmy Akin: One writer may use one term for a possessing entity and another writer may use a different term.
- 14:43Jimmy Akin: For example, let's look at the exorcism in the synagogue at Capernaum.
- 14:48Jimmy Akin: Here's how Mark tells the story.
- 14:50Voiceover: And immediately there was in their synagogue a man with an unclean spirit, and he cried out,
- 14:56Voiceover: What have you to do with us, Jesus of Nazareth?
- 14:59Voiceover: Have you come to destroy us?
- 15:01Voiceover: I know who you are, the Holy One of God.
- 15:05Voiceover: But Jesus rebuked
- 15:06Voiceover: him, saying, Be
- 15:08Voiceover: silent
- 15:08Voiceover: and come out of him.
- 15:10Voiceover: And the unclean spirit, convulsing him and crying out with a loud voice, came out of him.
- 15:16Jimmy Akin: Mark calls the thing in the man an unclean spirit, but here
- 15:21Jimmy Akin: is Luke relating the same event.
- 15:25Voiceover: And in the synagogue there was a man who had the spirit of an unclean demon, and he cried out with a loud voice,
- 15:31Voiceover: Ha!
- 15:31Voiceover: What have you to do with us, Jesus of Nazareth?
- 15:34Voiceover: Have you come to destroy us?
- 15:36Voiceover: I know who you are, the Holy One of God.
- 15:39Voiceover: But Jesus rebuked
- 15:41Voiceover: him, saying, Be silent and come out of him.
- 15:44Voiceover: And when the demon had thrown him down in their midst, he came out of him, having done no harm
- 15:51Jimmy Akin: Luke calls the same entity
- 15:53Jimmy Akin: the spirit of an unclean demon, and then he calls it simply the demon.
- 15:59Jimmy Akin: So
- 15:59Jimmy Akin: again, we see what in one passage is called an unclean spirit
- 16:04Jimmy Akin: also being called a demon.
- 16:06Jimmy Akin: So far, we've looked at Mark and Luke, but now let's look at Matthew.
- 16:11Jimmy Akin: Here is what Matthew says about the Gentile woman whose daughter was possessed.
- 16:16Voiceover: And behold, a Canaanite woman from that region
- 16:18Voiceover: came out and was crying, Have mercy on me, O Lord, son of David.
- 16:23Voiceover: My daughter is severely oppressed by a demon.
- 16:26Jimmy Akin: So Matthew calls the possessing entity a demon.
- 16:30Jimmy Akin: Now
- 16:30Jimmy Akin: here's Mark telling the same story.
- 16:33Voiceover: But immediately a woman, whose little daughter had an unclean spirit, heard of him, and came and fell down at his feet.
- 16:40Voiceover: Now the woman was a gentile
- 16:42Voiceover: a
- 16:42Voiceover: Syrophoenician by birth, and she begged him to cast the demon out of her daughter.
- 16:48Jimmy Akin: So Mark calls the possessing entity both an unclean spirit and a demon
- 16:53Jimmy Akin: Thus, it's easy to show that demon, unclean spirit, and evil spirit can all mean the same thing.
- 17:00Jimmy Akin: They form a single cluster of words that you can map.
- 17:04Jimmy Akin: both by looking at what one author says in a single passage
- 17:09Jimmy Akin: and by comparing what he says to what another author says in parallel passages.
- 17:15Dom Bettinelli: Okay, so those three terms are one cluster.
- 17:18Dom Bettinelli: What's the surprising part?
- 17:20Jimmy Akin: The surprising part is what's not in that cluster.
- 17:24Jimmy Akin: Not one
- 17:26Jimmy Akin: of those passages ever
- 17:28Jimmy Akin: calls a demon
- 17:30Jimmy Akin: a fallen angel
- 17:32Jimmy Akin: The Gospels have Jesus casting demons out of people multiple times, and not once does the text ever say that those demons are fallen angels.
- 17:42Jimmy Akin: The New Testament certainly talks about evil
- 17:45Jimmy Akin: and it talks about fallen
- 17:46Jimmy Akin: angels, but it never uses the term angel
- 17:50Jimmy Akin: as part of what it means when it talks about the term demon.
- 17:54Jimmy Akin: the way it does, for terms like unclean spirit and evil spirit.
- 17:59Jimmy Akin: In the Gospels, the only
- 18:01Jimmy Akin: passage that explicitly uses the term angel
- 18:04Jimmy Akin: to refer to fallen
- 18:05Jimmy Akin: creatures
- 18:06Jimmy Akin: is in Matthew twenty
- 18:08Jimmy Akin: five.
- 18:08Jimmy Akin: It's in the parable of the sheep and the goats, where Jesus says.
- 18:13Voiceover: Then he will say to those on his left, Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.
- 18:21Jimmy Akin: So
- 18:21Jimmy Akin: here we have a reference to the devil and his angels, meaning that some angels have allied themselves with the devil and are therefore fallen
- 18:29Jimmy Akin: or evil.
- 18:30Jimmy Akin: We see similar references to fallen
- 18:33Jimmy Akin: angels elsewhere in the New Testament.
- 18:35Jimmy Akin: For example, in 2
- 18:37Jimmy Akin: Corinthians 12, 7, St.
- 18:39Jimmy Akin: Paul writes
- 18:41Voiceover: To keep me from becoming conceited, because of the surpassing greatness of the revelations I have received, a thorn was given me in the flesh, an angel of Satan to harass
- 18:51Voiceover: me, to keep me from becoming conceited
- 18:54Jimmy Akin: So
- 18:55Jimmy Akin: here, Paul was being tormented by an angel of Satan.
- 18:58Jimmy Akin: The fact that it was tormenting him means that it's an evil angel, as does the fact it's an angel of Satan.
- 19:04Jimmy Akin: So it's definitely an evil angel.
- 19:07Jimmy Akin: Similarly, in 2
- 19:08Jimmy Akin: Peter 2.
- 19:09Jimmy Akin: 4, Peter says,
- 19:11Voiceover: God did not spare the angels when they sinned, but cast them into hell and committed them to pits of deepest darkness.
- 19:18Voiceover: to be kept until the judgment.
- 19:21Jimmy Akin: So here we have a reference to angels who sinned and were cast into hell, or more literally
- 19:27Jimmy Akin: into Tartarus, which is what it says in Greek.
- 19:30Jimmy Akin: And in Jude 6, we read about
- 19:33Voiceover: The angels that did not keep their own position, but left their proper dwelling, have been kept by him
- 19:39Voiceover: in eternal chains.
- 19:40Voiceover: and the deepest darkness
- 19:42Voiceover: until the judgment of the great day.
- 19:45Jimmy Akin: So
- 19:46Jimmy Akin: once again we have angels who left their proper dwelling and are kept by God in eternal chains in the deepest darkness.
- 19:53Jimmy Akin: We also have a reference in Revelation 12
- 19:56Jimmy Akin: where it describes how
- 19:58Voiceover: war
- 19:58Voiceover: arose in heaven, Michael and his angels fighting against the dragon, and the dragon and his angels fought
- 20:05Voiceover: But they were defeated, and there was no longer any place for them in heaven.
- 20:10Voiceover: And the great dragon was thrown down, that ancient serpent, who is called the devil in Satan, the deceiver of the whole world
- 20:18Voiceover: He was thrown down to the earth, and his angels were thrown down with him.
- 20:23Jimmy Akin: Here we have a reference to the dragon and his angels, and we're told that the dragon is the devil and Satan.
- 20:30Jimmy Akin: And we're told that he and his
- 20:32Jimmy Akin: angels were thrown down to earth.
- 20:35Jimmy Akin: Finally, in Revelation 9.
- 20:37Jimmy Akin: 11, we read about the evil locusts that come out of the abyss.
- 20:41Jimmy Akin: And then we're told
- 20:43Voiceover: They have as king over
- 20:44Voiceover: them the angel of the bottomless pit.
- 20:47Voiceover: His name in Hebrew is Abadon, and in Greek he is called Apollyon
- 20:52Jimmy Akin: Here we're told that there is an angel in the bottomless pit
- 20:57Jimmy Akin: who is the king over the evil locust, and he
- 21:00Jimmy Akin: sure sounds like he's a fallen angel.
- 21:03Jimmy Akin: Since he's the king of these evil creatures, well that suggests he's on the same side that they are, so that would make him evil
- 21:10Jimmy Akin: too.
- 21:11Jimmy Akin: And his
- 21:11Jimmy Akin: name
- 21:12Jimmy Akin: Abadon
- 21:13Jimmy Akin: in Hebrew
- 21:14Jimmy Akin: and Apollyon in Greek
- 21:16Jimmy Akin: means destruction or destroyer.
- 21:18Jimmy Akin: So that's another hint
- 21:20Jimmy Akin: that this is an evil fallen
- 21:21Jimmy Akin: angel.
- 21:22Jimmy Akin: If we extend our search back into the Old Testament, we also find passages that link the sons of God, who are today identified as angelic beings, as fallen.
- 21:34Jimmy Akin: in Genesis six, where the sons of God take daughters of men as wives, you know, like we talked about in episode three hundred eighty
- 21:42Jimmy Akin: six, and that I also talked about in episode sixty of the Jimmy Akin podcast.
- 21:47Jimmy Akin: You know,
- 21:47Jimmy Akin: well
- 21:48Jimmy Akin: The sons of God weren't supposed to do this.
- 21:51Jimmy Akin: They weren't supposed to take human wives.
- 21:53Jimmy Akin: So that indicates that these sons of God were
- 21:56Jimmy Akin: fallen angels.
- 21:58Jimmy Akin: In fact, they were
- 22:00Jimmy Akin: the fallen angels that Jude referred to as having left their proper dwelling.
- 22:05Jimmy Akin: Angelicanides
- 22:07Jimmy Akin: are also called watchers in the book of Daniel
- 22:10Jimmy Akin: In Daniel, they aren't portrayed as fallen, but in Second
- 22:14Jimmy Akin: Temple Jewish literature outside the Bible, like in 1
- 22:17Jimmy Akin: Enoch and Jubilees, the term watcher
- 22:20Jimmy Akin: is used for the same angelic beings.
- 22:23Jimmy Akin: that mated
- 22:24Jimmy Akin: with the daughters of men.
- 22:25Jimmy Akin: So
- 22:25Jimmy Akin: that would be
- 22:26Jimmy Akin: fallen angels again.
- 22:29Jimmy Akin: We
- 22:29Jimmy Akin: thus have a second cluster of passages talking about fallen angels.
- 22:34Jimmy Akin: But if you review these passages, you find that none of them ever mentioned the term demon.
- 22:41Jimmy Akin: So
- 22:42Jimmy Akin: even though it would be surprising to a large number of people,
- 22:46Jimmy Akin: The modern definition of a demon as a fallen
- 22:49Jimmy Akin: angel
- 22:50Jimmy Akin: is actually not
- 22:52Jimmy Akin: supported by the biblical text.
- 22:54Jimmy Akin: There are two different clusters of terms.
- 22:58Jimmy Akin: And
- 22:59Jimmy Akin: they never overlap
- 23:01Jimmy Akin: in the biblical texts.
- 23:03Dom Bettinelli: Okay, so
- 23:04Dom Bettinelli: what implication does that have for the use of the term demon?
- 23:08Jimmy Akin: Well, it doesn't have any implications for how we use the term today.
- 23:13Jimmy Akin: Terms develop over time in every language community, and in the Christian community, the term has come to mean
- 23:20Jimmy Akin: a fallen angel.
- 23:21Jimmy Akin: So
- 23:22Jimmy Akin: when
- 23:23Jimmy Akin: you uh
- 23:24Jimmy Akin: today
- 23:24Jimmy Akin: hear Christians using the term, you can usually assume that that's what they're talking about.
- 23:29Jimmy Akin: But
- 23:30Jimmy Akin: this wasn't true in earlier ages.
- 23:33Jimmy Akin: So
- 23:34Jimmy Akin: that means that we need to read earlier documents without the fallen
- 23:38Jimmy Akin: angel
- 23:39Jimmy Akin: interpretation in mind.
- 23:40Jimmy Akin: At least we can't assume it
- 23:42Jimmy Akin: because
- 23:43Jimmy Akin: to project it into the text would be anachronistic, meaning reading a later meaning into an earlier text
- 23:51Jimmy Akin: And
- 23:51Jimmy Akin: anachronism is a form of exegesis
- 23:54Jimmy Akin: or reading meaning into
- 23:56Jimmy Akin: a text
- 23:57Jimmy Akin: rather than exegesis
- 24:00Jimmy Akin: or reading the meaning out of the text
- 24:03Jimmy Akin: So
- 24:03Jimmy Akin: we need to read the texts the way that they would have been understood when they were written.
- 24:09Dom Bettinelli: If we can't just assume that demons are fallen
- 24:11Dom Bettinelli: angels in these texts, then that raises a new question.
- 24:15Dom Bettinelli: What were demons understood to be?
- 24:17Dom Bettinelli: How did the original audience understand these texts?
- 24:21Jimmy Akin: That
- 24:21Jimmy Akin: is the key question we're going to be examining in this episode.
- 24:25Jimmy Akin: And the starting point is looking at how the Greek term for demon was originally used.
- 24:30Jimmy Akin: That's one of the standard things you do
- 24:32Jimmy Akin: when you want to find out how a biblical term is used.
- 24:34Jimmy Akin: You start with how it was normally used, you know, outside of the Bible, and then you look to see if the biblical authors
- 24:42Jimmy Akin: modified its usage in any way.
- 24:44Jimmy Akin: So
- 24:45Jimmy Akin: in this case, we need to look at what the Greek term for demon originally meant, and then we'll look to see how and if the biblical authors modified it.
- 24:55Dom Bettinelli: Then let's go back to the beginning.
- 24:57Dom Bettinelli: What did demon mean to the Greeks who invented the word?
- 25:01Jimmy Akin: The first thing to be aware of is that there are a few Greek terms that get translated
- 25:06Jimmy Akin: demon.
- 25:06Jimmy Akin: The first is daimon, and the second is the related term
- 25:11Jimmy Akin: daimonion.
- 25:13Jimmy Akin: Daimonion
- 25:14Jimmy Akin: can be understood as a diminutive
- 25:17Jimmy Akin: form of the older term daimon.
- 25:19Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 25:20Jimmy Akin: you know, kind of like the English word doggy
- 25:23Jimmy Akin: is derived from the original term
- 25:25Jimmy Akin: dog.
- 25:26Jimmy Akin: And
- 25:26Jimmy Akin: both terms for demon appear in the Bible, uh
- 25:29Jimmy Akin: both in the Greek Old Testament and in the Greek New
- 25:32Jimmy Akin: Testament.
- 25:33Jimmy Akin: though
- 25:34Jimmy Akin: daimonion
- 25:35Jimmy Akin: is by far the more common word.
- 25:38Jimmy Akin: It's always hard to trace the original meaning of a term when we're dealing with ancient texts, but
- 25:45Jimmy Akin: The first meaning we have on record for Daimon
- 25:49Jimmy Akin: or Daimonion
- 25:51Jimmy Akin: seems to be a reference to a god
- 25:54Jimmy Akin: We find this meaning in the writings of Homer, who lived in the eighth century
- 25:58Jimmy Akin: BC.
- 25:59Jimmy Akin: In the Iliad, Homer writes about how
- 26:02Voiceover: Athena returned to Olympus
- 26:04Voiceover: to the palace of protection
- 26:06Voiceover: bearing Zeus
- 26:07Voiceover: to join the company of the other Daimonus.
- 26:10Jimmy Akin: So
- 26:11Jimmy Akin: here
- 26:11Jimmy Akin: Homer refers to Zeus, the greatest of the Olympian gods, as one of the Daimones.
- 26:17Jimmy Akin: He's thus very clear
- 26:19Jimmy Akin: that one of the meanings of this term was simply
- 26:22Jimmy Akin: a god.
- 26:23Jimmy Akin: However, daimon
- 26:25Jimmy Akin: is not the normal Greek term for a god.
- 26:28Jimmy Akin: That term
- 26:29Jimmy Akin: is Thaos.
- 26:31Jimmy Akin: So the term daimon came to be distinguished from Thaos, and Daimon
- 26:37Jimmy Akin: came to refer to a kind
- 26:40Jimmy Akin: of
- 26:40Jimmy Akin: intermediate being that was higher than a man
- 26:44Jimmy Akin: but not as high as a true god.
- 26:46Jimmy Akin: We find this meaning in the fourth century BC
- 26:50Jimmy Akin: in Plato.
- 26:51Jimmy Akin: In his dialogue, the Symposium, the characters are debating whether Eros
- 26:56Jimmy Akin: is a god
- 26:57Jimmy Akin: or whether he's immortal.
- 26:59Jimmy Akin: a
- 27:00Jimmy Akin: mortal.
- 27:01Jimmy Akin: And one of the characters, a priestess named Diotima, says that he's between
- 27:08Jimmy Akin: a mortal and an immortal.
- 27:10Jimmy Akin: She says that he is
- 27:12Voiceover: a great daimon, Socrates, for the whole of the daimon
- 27:16Voiceover: is between divine and mortal.
- 27:19Jimmy Akin: So
- 27:19Jimmy Akin: here we see the term daimon
- 27:21Jimmy Akin: being used to indicate an intermediate being.
- 27:25Jimmy Akin: These intermediate beings, kind of like our angels, could be either good or bad, and there's one conception of the bad ones that I want to mention.
- 27:34Jimmy Akin: Now, this is from a
- 27:37Jimmy Akin: much
- 27:37Jimmy Akin: later
- 27:38Jimmy Akin: period, like 600 years later.
- 27:41Jimmy Akin: In fact, it's from after the time of Christ, so it is not the original use of the term.
- 27:47Jimmy Akin: but it does sound a good bit like the modern idea of a demon.
- 27:52Jimmy Akin: This conception is found in the Greek Neoplatonist philosopher
- 27:56Jimmy Akin: Porphyry.
- 27:57Jimmy Akin: He lived in the 3rd century A.
- 27:59Jimmy Akin: D.
- 28:00Jimmy Akin: and he was a vegetarian. He
- 28:02Jimmy Akin: didn't like the idea of killing and eating animals. He
- 28:05Jimmy Akin: thus wrote a book called On Abstinence from
- 28:08Jimmy Akin: Animal Food.
- 28:10Jimmy Akin: And in it
- 28:11Jimmy Akin: he argues against sacrificing
- 28:13Jimmy Akin: animals.
- 28:14Jimmy Akin: He says that there's one great God at the top of the heavenly hierarchy, and this ultimate God doesn't need sacrifices at all.
- 28:23Jimmy Akin: Under him
- 28:24Jimmy Akin: are the lesser gods, and they don't need sacrifices either.
- 28:28Jimmy Akin: But then we come to the demons that are intermediate beings between gods and men.
- 28:34Jimmy Akin: For porphyry, some of these
- 28:36Jimmy Akin: are good, but
- 28:39Jimmy Akin: others are
- 28:40Jimmy Akin: bad, and it's the bad ones that want animal sacrifice
- 28:45Jimmy Akin: Porphyry
- 28:46Jimmy Akin: says that it's these evil daimonas
- 28:49Jimmy Akin: that
- 28:50Jimmy Akin: crave smoke and the blood of the altar
- 28:53Jimmy Akin: They feed on the sacrifices
- 28:55Jimmy Akin: and they trick people into worshipping them.
- 28:58Jimmy Akin: He writes
- 28:59Voiceover: All
- 29:00Voiceover: intemperance and hope of possessing wealth and renown, and especially deception, exist
- 29:05Voiceover: through these
- 29:07Voiceover: since falsehood is allied to these malevolent beings.
- 29:11Voiceover: For they wish to be considered as gods, and the power which presides over them is ambitious to appear to be the greatest God.
- 29:19Voiceover: These are they that rejoice in libations
- 29:22Voiceover: and the savour
- 29:23Voiceover: of sacrifices.
- 29:24Voiceover: On this account, a wise and temperate man
- 29:28Voiceover: will be religiously afraid to use sacrifices of this kind
- 29:32Voiceover: Through which he will attract to himself
- 29:34Voiceover: such like demons, but he will endeavor in all possible ways to purify his
- 29:39Voiceover: soul
- 29:40Voiceover: For these malefic beings do not attack a pure soul
- 29:44Voiceover: because it is dissimilar to them.
- 29:46Jimmy Akin: So
- 29:47Jimmy Akin: this is sounding a lot like the modern Christian understanding of demons.
- 29:51Jimmy Akin: They are intermediate beings between God and man.
- 29:55Jimmy Akin: They pretend to be gods
- 29:57Jimmy Akin: or even the greatest God Himself.
- 30:00Jimmy Akin: They revel in animal sacrifices, and people who are pure
- 30:04Jimmy Akin: tend not to attract them.
- 30:06Jimmy Akin: That's a lot like the Christian concept of a demon.
- 30:10Jimmy Akin: But note
- 30:11Jimmy Akin: when
- 30:11Jimmy Akin: Porphyry is writing.
- 30:13Jimmy Akin: He's in the third century
- 30:16Jimmy Akin: after
- 30:16Jimmy Akin: Christ.
- 30:17Jimmy Akin: So
- 30:18Jimmy Akin: we can't just read his understanding of demons back onto earlier texts, and even Porphyry
- 30:25Jimmy Akin: thinks there were good demons, that is, good
- 30:28Jimmy Akin: intermediate beings between the divine and the human.
- 30:32Jimmy Akin: There's a problem
- 30:34Jimmy Akin: though
- 30:34Jimmy Akin: because
- 30:35Jimmy Akin: the idea of demons impersonating deities
- 30:39Jimmy Akin: That
- 30:40Jimmy Akin: was really just Porphyry's idea.
- 30:42Jimmy Akin: Other Greeks didn't hold this, and even other members of Porphyry's own school of philosophers didn't buy it.
- 30:49Jimmy Akin: So
- 30:49Jimmy Akin: it's basically this one
- 30:51Jimmy Akin: guy's proposal for what some of the demons are, and it's from centuries after Christ.
- 30:57Jimmy Akin: So
- 30:58Jimmy Akin: we can't use it to inform
- 31:00Jimmy Akin: our understanding of the New Testament.
- 31:02Jimmy Akin: What we can say is that the Greeks sometimes use the term demon to refer to intermediate beings between gods and men, and that these intermediate beings could sometimes be good or bad
- 31:14Jimmy Akin: in their conception
- 31:15Dom Bettinelli: Then let's take a look at another meaning of the term.
- 31:18Dom Bettinelli: If we've seen the term used for gods and for intermediate beings, what comes next?
- 31:24Jimmy Akin: Now we jump down to another class of beings that is
- 31:28Jimmy Akin: clearly human
- 31:30Jimmy Akin: in nature
- 31:32Jimmy Akin: We read about this kind of demon in the early Greek poet Hesiod, around 700 B.
- 31:38Jimmy Akin: C.
- 31:38Jimmy Akin: and we know a little about him because
- 31:40Jimmy Akin: he complains about his lazy brother in his poems
- 31:44Jimmy Akin: His poem
- 31:45Jimmy Akin: Works and Days
- 31:46Jimmy Akin: mixes farming advice with old stories about the gods, and one of those stories is the myth of the ages of humankind.
- 31:56Jimmy Akin: Hesiod
- 31:57Jimmy Akin: says that the human race has passed through ages of gold, silver, bronze, and iron.
- 32:03Jimmy Akin: He says
- 32:04Jimmy Akin: the people of the Golden Age lived like gods
- 32:07Jimmy Akin: without toil or sorrow, so it was kind of a Greek version of our Garden of Eden.
- 32:14Jimmy Akin: and when the Golden Age men died, they didn't simply vanish, they became guardian spirits, Daimones, who watch over the living
- 32:24Jimmy Akin: and hand out wealth.
- 32:25Jimmy Akin: Here is how Hesiod puts it.
- 32:28Voiceover: First of all, the deathless gods who dwell on Olympus
- 32:31Voiceover: made a golden race of mortal men
- 32:34Voiceover: who lived in the time of Kronos, when he was reigning in heaven.
- 32:38Voiceover: And they lived like gods without sorrow of heart, remote and free from toil and grief.
- 32:44Voiceover: Miserable age rested not on them
- 32:47Voiceover: But with legs and arms never failing, they made merry with feasting beyond the reach of all evils.
- 32:53Voiceover: When they died, it was as though they were overcome with sleep
- 32:58Voiceover: And they had all good things, for the fruitful earth unforced
- 33:02Voiceover: bore them fruit abundantly and without stent
- 33:05Voiceover: They dwelt in ease and peace upon their lands with many good things, rich in flocks and loved by the blessed gods
- 33:13Voiceover: But after earth had covered this generation, they are called pure daimonis, dwelling on the earth, and are kindly delivered from harm
- 33:22Voiceover: and guardians of mortal men, for they roam everywhere over the earth, clothed in mist, and they keep watch on judgments and cruel deeds, givers of wealth, for this royal right
- 33:34Voiceover: also they received.
- 33:36Jimmy Akin: So
- 33:36Jimmy Akin: Hesiod
- 33:37Jimmy Akin: says that the ghosts of the golden race of humans function kind of like our guardian angels.
- 33:44Jimmy Akin: They also
- 33:45Jimmy Akin: aren't just guardian spirits in a general way for mankind.
- 33:49Jimmy Akin: They were also understood as guarding each person
- 33:53Jimmy Akin: specifically.
- 33:54Jimmy Akin: Again, just like our guardian angels
- 33:57Jimmy Akin: In Plato's dialogue
- 33:59Jimmy Akin: The
- 33:59Jimmy Akin: Phaedo, one of the characters speaks of
- 34:02Voiceover: It is said that after death, the daimon of each person to whom he had been allotted in life, leads him to a place where the dead are gathered together.
- 34:11Voiceover: then
- 34:12Voiceover: they are judged
- 34:13Voiceover: and depart to the other
- 34:14Voiceover: world.
- 34:15Jimmy Akin: So
- 34:16Jimmy Akin: each person is allotted a daimon to guard him in life, and then this daimone
- 34:22Jimmy Akin: guides him to the place of judgment for the dead in the afterlife.
- 34:26Jimmy Akin: But it wasn't just the ghosts of the golden race of men that could be called daimones, like Hessiod did
- 34:33Jimmy Akin: In Plato's dialogue
- 34:35Jimmy Akin: Cratolus, the character Socrates expands this to cover anyone
- 34:40Jimmy Akin: who's good.
- 34:42Jimmy Akin: Hayes says
- 34:43Voiceover: This, then, I think, is what Hesiod
- 34:45Voiceover: certainly means to say of the Daimonus, because
- 34:49Voiceover: they are wise, and knowing he called them Daimonus
- 34:52Voiceover: Now
- 34:53Voiceover: he and all the other poets are right, who say that when a good man dies, he has a great portion and honor among the dead, and becomes a daimon.
- 35:03Jimmy Akin: So
- 35:03Jimmy Akin: here the term daimon
- 35:05Jimmy Akin: can be used to refer to the ghost of any
- 35:09Jimmy Akin: good man, you know, who is a member of our race, which Hesiod
- 35:14Jimmy Akin: considered the
- 35:15Jimmy Akin: iron race of men.
- 35:17Jimmy Akin: In other usages, a daimon
- 35:20Jimmy Akin: didn't have to even be an especially good person.
- 35:23Jimmy Akin: They could also be someone who was much more ordinary.
- 35:26Jimmy Akin: So
- 35:26Jimmy Akin: the third idea is that the demon is just a regular ghost, the surviving soul of a dead person.
- 35:34Jimmy Akin: The Roman writer Apuleus lays out a whole classification of the human dead as demons.
- 35:40Jimmy Akin: Apulius lived in the 2nd century A.
- 35:43Jimmy Akin: D.
- 35:43Jimmy Akin: in the Roman provinces in North Africa
- 35:46Jimmy Akin: He was a public speaker and a follower of Plato, and he was even put on trial once for supposed magic.
- 35:53Jimmy Akin: He's remembered to
- 35:55Jimmy Akin: day
- 35:55Jimmy Akin: for a comic novel he wrote called The Golden Ass, about a man who was turned into a donkey.
- 36:01Jimmy Akin: But he also wrote a short lecture on the God of Socrates, which is all about
- 36:08Jimmy Akin: Daimonus.
- 36:09Jimmy Akin: He actually wrote this book in Latin, but he's mapping the Greek concept onto Latin vocabulary, and he takes the human soul itself to be a kind of daimon.
- 36:21Jimmy Akin: While you're alive, he says, your soul is a daimone housed in a body, and then after death
- 36:27Jimmy Akin: it goes on as a daimone of a different sort.
- 36:31Voiceover: There is also a class of demons in a second sense, the human soul that has renounced its body after doing its years of service and life.
- 36:40Voiceover: In early Latin, I find this called a lemor
- 36:45Voiceover: Well, in this class of lemours, the one who is assigned responsibility for his descendants and inhabits the home
- 36:51Voiceover: with his serene and untroubled influence
- 36:54Voiceover: is called the household law
- 36:57Voiceover: If, however, because his life has deserved the opposite, he has no fixed abode, and is doomed to aimless wandering in a kind of exile
- 37:06Voiceover: A bogeyman
- 37:07Voiceover: powerless against
- 37:08Voiceover: good people, but dangerous to wicked ones.
- 37:11Voiceover: The traditional name for his class is often larva
- 37:16Jimmy Akin: So according to Apuleus, a demon can
- 37:19Jimmy Akin: also
- 37:20Jimmy Akin: be a disembodied soul, or just an ordinary ghost, and he gives the equivalent Latin terms for these concepts, with the ghost itself being called a lemur.
- 37:31Jimmy Akin: in early Latin, and if a lemur
- 37:34Jimmy Akin: has been assigned the responsibility of caring for its descendants in a particular house, it's also called a household law
- 37:42Jimmy Akin: while
- 37:42Jimmy Akin: if it's wandering around and scaring people, it's called a larva.
- 37:47Jimmy Akin: Incidentally, uh
- 37:48Jimmy Akin: these terms are where we get the biological terms
- 37:52Jimmy Akin: lemur and larva
- 37:54Jimmy Akin: In the 1700s, Carl Linnaeus, the father of taxonomy, named the primates from Eastern Africa and Madagascar
- 38:02Jimmy Akin: lemurs
- 38:03Jimmy Akin: after the Roman ghosts, because
- 38:05Jimmy Akin: The animal lemurs
- 38:07Jimmy Akin: move
- 38:08Jimmy Akin: mostly at night and look kind of like humans and are slow.
- 38:13Jimmy Akin: And Linnaeus also decided to name the immature species of some insects
- 38:19Jimmy Akin: larvae, because the word larva
- 38:21Jimmy Akin: could not only mean ghost, it could also mean mask, and the immature form of an insect is
- 38:28Jimmy Akin: kind of like a mask for its adult form.
- 38:32Jimmy Akin: In any event
- 38:33Jimmy Akin: we see that the term demon was used to refer to several different things by the Greeks and Romans.
- 38:40Jimmy Akin: It could refer to a god,
- 38:42Jimmy Akin: An intermediate being?
- 38:45Jimmy Akin: A golden race ghost?
- 38:47Jimmy Akin: A good ghost?
- 38:48Jimmy Akin: Or an ordinary ghost that could be either good or bad
- 38:52Jimmy Akin: There are other
- 38:53Jimmy Akin: possible
- 38:54Jimmy Akin: debatable meanings
- 38:55Jimmy Akin: too, but this will do for our present purposes.
- 38:59Dom Bettinelli: So that's a basic look at how Greeks and Romans use the term demon.
- 39:04Dom Bettinelli: Now we need to step back and look at how the term was used in Judaism and Christianity.
- 39:08Dom Bettinelli: But first, I want to take a moment to thank our patrons who make this show possible, including
- 39:13Dom Bettinelli: Valonzo M, Chris R.
- 39:15Dom Bettinelli: Frederick H.
- 39:16Dom Bettinelli: Thomas P.
- 39:17Dom Bettinelli: and
- 39:17Dom Bettinelli: Roseanne
- 39:18Dom Bettinelli: M. Their
- 39:19Dom Bettinelli: generous donations that give mysterious.
- 39:22Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 39:23Dom Bettinelli: make it possible for us to continue Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World
- 39:27Dom Bettinelli: and all the shows at StarQuest.
- 39:29Dom Bettinelli: More than 90%
- 39:30Dom Bettinelli: of our financial support comes from individual donors like you, and you can join them by visiting givemysterious.
- 39:37Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 39:39Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is also brought to you by Father Dwight Longnecker.
- 39:44Dom Bettinelli: Father Longnecker reminds the Jimmy Akin's
- 39:47Dom Bettinelli: Mysterious World audience that one of the most mysterious of mysteries is coming up
- 39:51Dom Bettinelli: And that is the mystery of Christ's nativity, otherwise known as Christmas.
- 39:56Dom Bettinelli: The Magi, along with the shepherds, are the mysterious strangers who come to visit the stable
- 40:01Dom Bettinelli: boy of Bethlehem
- 40:02Dom Bettinelli: In his two Christmas books, Father Longnecker
- 40:05Dom Bettinelli: explores the mystery of the Magi
- 40:07Dom Bettinelli: and the secret of the Bethlehem Shepherds.
- 40:10Dom Bettinelli: These books will deepen your understanding of Christmas and are perfect to wrap up and put beneath the tree
- 40:16Dom Bettinelli: To cut through all the mystery and get down to the history, check out Father Longnecker's Substacked website.
- 40:22Dom Bettinelli: Go to dweltlongnecker.
- 40:25Dom Bettinelli: com to read his blog, browse his books, and be in touch
- 40:30Dom Bettinelli: And
- 40:30Dom Bettinelli: by
- 40:31Dom Bettinelli: Grave Tending Solutions.
- 40:33Dom Bettinelli: Gravetending is a professional service and apostolate that brings peace of mind to families
- 40:38Dom Bettinelli: By caring for established grave
- 40:40Dom Bettinelli: sites, distance and physical limitations can create barriers to maintaining a loved one's
- 40:46Dom Bettinelli: final
- 40:46Dom Bettinelli: resting place.
- 40:47Dom Bettinelli: From planting graveside gardens to cleaning headstones, a grave-tending professional provides a way for their clients to continue to care for
- 40:55Dom Bettinelli: and honor their loved ones.
- 40:57Dom Bettinelli: If you're interested in learning more about grave
- 40:59Dom Bettinelli: tending, either as a client or as someone who'd like to enter the profession, please visit gravetending solutions.
- 41:06Dom Bettinelli: com
- 41:11Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, now that we've looked at the meaning of the word demon in secular Greek and Roman society
- 41:17Dom Bettinelli: We need to look at how Jews and Christians modified the word.
- 41:20Dom Bettinelli: How do you want to begin?
- 41:22Jimmy Akin: We need to start by looking at how the word was used in the Greek version of the Old Testament, which is known as the Septuagint.
- 41:31Jimmy Akin: Then
- 41:31Jimmy Akin: we'll look at how it was used in other Second Temple
- 41:34Jimmy Akin: era
- 41:35Jimmy Akin: Jewish literature.
- 41:36Jimmy Akin: After that, we'll leap over the New Testament and look at how it was used in the early church.
- 41:42Jimmy Akin: The reason for doing that is so we can see what preceded the New Testament and what followed the New Testament, and that'll put us in a good position to examine the New Testament usage itself.
- 41:54Jimmy Akin: So
- 41:55Jimmy Akin: we'll then go back and look at the New Testament usage and how it connects to what came before and what came after.
- 42:02Jimmy Akin: What we'll want to do with each body of literature we look at
- 42:06Jimmy Akin: is to see which
- 42:07Jimmy Akin: of the term's established usages are repeated in that literature.
- 42:13Jimmy Akin: And
- 42:13Jimmy Akin: then see if there are any passages that don't fit, which means that we're looking at a new usage.
- 42:19Dom Bettinelli: Okay, then let's look at the Greek Septuagint translation of the Old Testament.
- 42:23Dom Bettinelli: How does it use the term demon?
- 42:26Jimmy Akin: Well, it doesn't use it that often.
- 42:28Jimmy Akin: The Septuagint contains only one usage of the word daimone
- 42:33Jimmy Akin: and about 18
- 42:34Jimmy Akin: uses of daimonion.
- 42:37Jimmy Akin: It uses them to translate several terms from the original Hebrew or Aramaic.
- 42:43Jimmy Akin: One of the main occurrences is in Deuteronomy 32.
- 42:48Jimmy Akin: 17, which describes how the Israelites behaved.
- 42:52Voiceover: They sacrificed to demons that were not God, to gods they had never known, to new gods that had come recently, whom your fathers had never dreaded.
- 43:03Jimmy Akin: Here, the Hebrew word translated demons
- 43:07Jimmy Akin: is Shadim.
- 43:08Jimmy Akin: It says that the Israelites sacrificed to Shadim
- 43:12Jimmy Akin: rather than to the true God.
- 43:14Jimmy Akin: It says that these were gods that were new to the Israelites, and their ancestors had never worshipped, and it's clear that they're definitely gods, since the Septuagint uses the Greek word Thaos
- 43:26Jimmy Akin: to refer to them.
- 43:28Jimmy Akin: So
- 43:28Jimmy Akin: here we have the first usage that we saw of the Greek word demon, where it refers to a god, or in this case, a foreign god.
- 43:38Jimmy Akin: We see
- 43:38Jimmy Akin: the same use in other passages like Psalm
- 43:42Voiceover: 95, where it says, Great is the Lord and exceedingly praiseworthy.
- 43:47Voiceover: He is more awesome than all the gods.
- 43:50Voiceover: For all the gods of the nations are demons, but the Lord made the heavens
- 43:55Jimmy Akin: Here again, the word demon is being used to refer to foreign gods.
- 43:59Jimmy Akin: We can also infer the same about other passages where people are said to worship demons in the Septuagint, like
- 44:06Jimmy Akin: offering sacrifice or incense to them rather than to God, because
- 44:12Jimmy Akin: these
- 44:13Jimmy Akin: are what people did for foreign gods.
- 44:15Jimmy Akin: So the same foreign god meaning is in focus.
- 44:19Jimmy Akin: And
- 44:19Jimmy Akin: this is the main meaning of the term demon in the Septuagint.
- 44:25Dom Bettinelli: Are there any passages where the term is used in another sense?
- 44:29Jimmy Akin: Well, possibly, but the question is more complex than you might think.
- 44:33Jimmy Akin: For example, you might think that Psalm 90 uses a different sense.
- 44:38Jimmy Akin: That passage says
- 44:40Jimmy Akin: of the righteous person
- 44:42Voiceover: That one will not be afraid from fear by night, from the arrow flying by day, from the deed carried out in darkness, from
- 44:50Voiceover: mishap and demon at midday.
- 44:53Jimmy Akin: So
- 44:54Jimmy Akin: here the term demon is something that could attack a person at midday, but God will protect him.
- 45:00Jimmy Akin: In Greek, the text doesn't tell us anything else about the nature of the midday demon.
- 45:06Jimmy Akin: But if we look at the Hebrew original and allow it to influence our understanding, the Hebrew word translated demon is
- 45:15Jimmy Akin: kateb.
- 45:16Jimmy Akin: Which means destruction.
- 45:18Jimmy Akin: So you could say, well, here the word is be
- 45:21Jimmy Akin: demon is being used to personify a destructive force
- 45:25Dom Bettinelli: Does that fit with any of the senses we've already seen for the Greek term demon?
- 45:30Jimmy Akin: Well, you wouldn't think so, but
- 45:34Jimmy Akin: This is going to be a little surprising because
- 45:36Jimmy Akin: of the way the verse gets translated in English Bibles.
- 45:40Jimmy Akin: And the answer
- 45:41Jimmy Akin: is
- 45:42Jimmy Akin: quite probably, yes, it does fit
- 45:44Jimmy Akin: with an existing usage of the term demon.
- 45:47Jimmy Akin: What's not often realized
- 45:49Jimmy Akin: is that the Hebrew terms for things like famine, pestilence, and destruction
- 45:55Jimmy Akin: were
- 45:55Jimmy Akin: actually the names of Canaanite gods.
- 46:00Jimmy Akin: Famine, or in Hebrew
- 46:01Jimmy Akin: Raab
- 46:03Jimmy Akin: ,
- 46:03Jimmy Akin: is another name for the god
- 46:05Jimmy Akin: Mot, the Canaanite god of death.
- 46:08Jimmy Akin: Pestilence, or in Hebrew
- 46:10Jimmy Akin: Reshef, was the Canaanite god of plague, and destruction, or Keteb, is placed in parallel with Raab
- 46:21Jimmy Akin: and Reshef.
- 46:22Jimmy Akin: Mm
- 46:23Jimmy Akin: ,
- 46:23Jimmy Akin: suggesting that he's God
- 46:25Jimmy Akin: too, and he is mentioned that way in some Ugaritic texts.
- 46:30Jimmy Akin: So
- 46:30Jimmy Akin: even though most Bibles
- 46:31Jimmy Akin: don't translate the passage this way,
- 46:34Jimmy Akin: It looks like the Septuagint translators understood the psalm
- 46:38Jimmy Akin: as referring to God
- 46:40Jimmy Akin: protecting the people from the Canaanite deity of destruction.
- 46:45Jimmy Akin: And so they translated the word for this deity
- 46:48Jimmy Akin: using the Greek word
- 46:50Jimmy Akin: demon.
- 46:51Jimmy Akin: That would mean that this passage
- 46:53Jimmy Akin: too.
- 46:54Jimmy Akin: fits with the usage we saw of demon as referring to a god, again a foreign god.
- 47:01Dom Bettinelli: Do we see other Hebrew terms being translated
- 47:04Dom Bettinelli: demon by the Septuagint translators?
- 47:07Jimmy Akin: There's one that shows up in passages like Isaiah 13, which prophecies what's going to happen to Babylon and says,
- 47:14Voiceover: And wild animals will rest there.
- 47:17Voiceover: and the houses will be filled with sound, and sirens will rest there, and demons will dance there.
- 47:24Jimmy Akin: Similarly, Isaiah 34
- 47:26Jimmy Akin: predicts God's judgment on the nations, and says
- 47:30Voiceover: Thorny trees will grow again in their cities and in its fortresses, and it will be a dwelling for sirens
- 47:36Voiceover: and a courtyard of sparrows.
- 47:38Voiceover: And demons will meet donkey centaurs, and one will cry out to the other.
- 47:43Voiceover: Their
- 47:44Voiceover: donkey centaurs
- 47:45Voiceover: will rest, since they have found a rest for themselves.
- 47:49Jimmy Akin: In both of these passages, the demons are something that lives out in the wilderness.
- 47:55Jimmy Akin: The Hebrew word translated demon is
- 47:57Jimmy Akin: Sair.
- 47:59Jimmy Akin: and it means something like
- 48:01Jimmy Akin: goat
- 48:02Jimmy Akin: or hairy one, and
- 48:04Jimmy Akin: these could just be references to normal
- 48:07Jimmy Akin: natural goats that were living in these areas.
- 48:10Jimmy Akin: And there have been scholars who've proposed that.
- 48:13Jimmy Akin: However, we know that
- 48:15Jimmy Akin: some in the ancient Near East, including some Israelites, worshipped goat idols as gods.
- 48:22Jimmy Akin: For example, in the book of Leviticus it gives regulations for worship, and the text says,
- 48:28Voiceover: They may no longer sacrifice their sacrifices to the goat idols after which they were prostituting.
- 48:35Voiceover: This is a lasting statute for them throughout their generations.
- 48:40Jimmy Akin: And later, after the division of the kingdom, we read that
- 48:43Voiceover: Jeroboam appointed his own priests for the high places, and for the goat idols, and for the calves
- 48:50Voiceover: that he had made
- 48:51Jimmy Akin: So
- 48:51Jimmy Akin: we know that Israelites were worshiping goat idols, and the Hebrew term used
- 48:58Jimmy Akin: here is the same one used in Isaiah.
- 49:01Jimmy Akin: So
- 49:01Jimmy Akin: it may well be that the demons the Septuagint envisions as living out in the wilderness
- 49:07Jimmy Akin: were the same beings, not
- 49:09Jimmy Akin: normal goats.
- 49:11Jimmy Akin: And if that's what's meant, then this would be another usage of the term demon to represent foreign gods.
- 49:19Jimmy Akin: But
- 49:19Jimmy Akin: this passage isn't fully clear, so we can't be fully confident about
- 49:24Jimmy Akin: that
- 49:24Dom Bettinelli: What about the book of Tobit?
- 49:26Dom Bettinelli: That contains an extensive story involving the demon Esmodeus.
- 49:30Dom Bettinelli: How does Tobit
- 49:32Dom Bettinelli: understand this demon?
- 49:33Jimmy Akin: Unfortunately, Tobit
- 49:35Jimmy Akin: doesn't give us an origin story for Asmodius, so the ultimate answer is that we can't be sure.
- 49:42Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 49:42Jimmy Akin: we can't determine exactly what kind of demon the author of Tobit
- 49:47Jimmy Akin: understood Asmodeus to be.
- 49:49Jimmy Akin: But
- 49:50Jimmy Akin: we can make a guess, and that guess is based on the name Asmodeus itself.
- 49:56Jimmy Akin: Unfortunately, the etymology or origin of this name isn't certain, but most scholars think that Asmodeus was based on the Zoroastrian words
- 50:07Jimmy Akin: Aishmah
- 50:08Jimmy Akin: Dewa, which would mean
- 50:10Jimmy Akin: demon of wrath.
- 50:12Jimmy Akin: And
- 50:12Jimmy Akin: that would make sense, because as Modius is tormenting a woman in Ekbatana
- 50:18Jimmy Akin: in media
- 50:19Jimmy Akin: in modern Iran
- 50:20Jimmy Akin: And the majority religion there at the time was Zoroastrianism
- 50:25Jimmy Akin: with a local community of Jewish exiles.
- 50:28Jimmy Akin: So
- 50:29Jimmy Akin: On this understanding, Asmodeus would be an evil demon that both Zoroastrians and Jews were aware of.
- 50:37Jimmy Akin: And we could look at the Zoroastrian understanding of what demons are for a clue about what the Jewish author may have understood about Asmodeus.
- 50:48Jimmy Akin: Well, the Zoroastrian word for day
- 50:51Jimmy Akin: for demon, Dewa, is related to the Sanskrit word
- 50:57Jimmy Akin: deva, which means God.
- 51:00Jimmy Akin: In
- 51:00Jimmy Akin: India, the Devas
- 51:02Jimmy Akin: continued to be worshipped as gods as part of Hinduism.
- 51:05Jimmy Akin: But in Iran, once Zoroastrianism got started, this changed.
- 51:10Jimmy Akin: because
- 51:10Jimmy Akin: Zoroastrianism, like Judaism, is a monotheistic religion.
- 51:15Jimmy Akin: The old Indo-Iranian
- 51:17Jimmy Akin: gods
- 51:18Jimmy Akin: or devas
- 51:19Jimmy Akin: got demoted
- 51:20Jimmy Akin: and portrayed as evil beings.
- 51:23Jimmy Akin: So that's what a demon is in Zoroastrianism.
- 51:27Jimmy Akin: And that may be
- 51:29Jimmy Akin: How the Jewish writer of Tobit understood Asmodeus as a lesser foreign god that should not be worshipped
- 51:37Jimmy Akin: And that goes along with the fact that we have an Aramaic fragment of Tobit
- 51:43Jimmy Akin: where the word translated demon
- 51:45Jimmy Akin: is the word
- 51:47Jimmy Akin: shed.
- 51:48Jimmy Akin: And we've already seen from Deuteronomy
- 51:51Jimmy Akin: that the gods of the nations were Shadim, so Asmodeus could be understood as a kind of foreign deity.
- 52:00Jimmy Akin: Although it's also possible
- 52:02Jimmy Akin: that he understood Asmodeus as an intermediate being between gods and men
- 52:08Jimmy Akin: So, like I said, the ultimate answer isn't fully clear, since Tobit doesn't give us an origin
- 52:14Jimmy Akin: story or other clarification on Asmodius.
- 52:17Jimmy Akin: In any event, the Septuagint doesn't mention demons that much.
- 52:22Jimmy Akin: The majority use of the term in the Septuagint is to refer to foreign gods.
- 52:27Jimmy Akin: We
- 52:28Jimmy Akin: might have a passage
- 52:30Jimmy Akin: that
- 52:30Jimmy Akin: r
- 52:31Jimmy Akin: refers to demons as intermediate beings that are lower than the gods.
- 52:36Jimmy Akin: than the foreign gods, but we don't have any clear references to any of the other Greek uses.
- 52:43Dom Bettinelli: Okay, then
- 52:44Dom Bettinelli: let's look at other Second Temple
- 52:46Dom Bettinelli: Era Jewish literature
- 52:48Dom Bettinelli: which is to say
- 52:49Dom Bettinelli: works written after the end of the Babylonian exile, and up to about the time of the destruction of the temple in A.
- 52:55Dom Bettinelli: D.
- 52:55Dom Bettinelli: seventy.
- 52:56Dom Bettinelli: So
- 52:57Dom Bettinelli: they are the period just before and after the ministry of Jesus.
- 53:01Dom Bettinelli: What can you tell us about demons in them?
- 53:04Jimmy Akin: Well, here we get a new meaning for the term
- 53:07Jimmy Akin: that is different from any of the Greek uses.
- 53:10Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 53:11Jimmy Akin: one
- 53:11Jimmy Akin: of the works we find in this period, and one of the places we find this usage
- 53:15Jimmy Akin: is in first
- 53:16Jimmy Akin: Enoch, and specifically
- 53:19Jimmy Akin: It's the part of First
- 53:20Jimmy Akin: Enoch
- 53:20Jimmy Akin: known as the Book of the Watchers.
- 53:22Jimmy Akin: We talked about First Enoch
- 53:24Jimmy Akin: in general and the Book of the Watchers
- 53:26Jimmy Akin: specifically in episodes 323 and 324.
- 53:30Jimmy Akin: And I went into some more detail on my other podcast in the Jimmy Akin Podcast episode 60.
- 53:37Jimmy Akin: The Book of the Watchers expands on the famous short passage in Genesis 6.
- 53:43Jimmy Akin: In that passage the sons of God, who first
- 53:46Jimmy Akin: Enoch calls watchers, marry the daughter
- 53:49Jimmy Akin: the daughters of men, and they give birth to children known as the Nephilim, or giants
- 53:56Jimmy Akin: First Enoch takes this and expands on it.
- 53:59Jimmy Akin: It says
- 54:00Jimmy Akin: the Angelic Sons of God, 200 rebel
- 54:04Jimmy Akin: watchers.
- 54:05Jimmy Akin: corrupted mankind by teaching the arts of warfare, seduction, and magic.
- 54:11Jimmy Akin: And First
- 54:11Jimmy Akin: Enoch
- 54:12Jimmy Akin: envisions this whole complex of events as leading up to the flood.
- 54:16Jimmy Akin: It
- 54:17Jimmy Akin: also fills in what became of these giants.
- 54:21Jimmy Akin: When these giants
- 54:23Jimmy Akin: finally die, their spirits don't rest.
- 54:26Jimmy Akin: They stay on as evil spirits.
- 54:29Jimmy Akin: Verse
- 54:29Jimmy Akin: Enoch
- 54:30Jimmy Akin: fifteen says,
- 54:31Voiceover: And now the giants who are produced from these spirits and flesh
- 54:36Voiceover: shall be called evil spirits upon the earth, and on the earth shall be their dwelling.
- 54:41Voiceover: Evil spirits have proceeded from their bodies, because they are born from men
- 54:46Voiceover: and from the holy watchers is their beginning and primal origin.
- 54:51Voiceover: They shall be evil spirits on earth, and evil spirits shall they be called.
- 54:57Voiceover: As for the spirits of heaven, in heaven shall be their dwelling
- 55:01Voiceover: But as for the spirits of the earth, which were born upon the earth, on the earth shall be their dwelling, and the spirits of the giants
- 55:09Voiceover: afflict, oppress, destroy, attack
- 55:13Voiceover: Do battle, and work destruction on the earth, and cause trouble.
- 55:17Voiceover: They take no food, but nevertheless hunger and thirst, and cause offences
- 55:24Jimmy Akin: So
- 55:24Jimmy Akin: this is the origin
- 55:26Jimmy Akin: story of what are called evil spirits, and the fact that the passage twice
- 55:31Jimmy Akin: says that they shall be called evil spirits.
- 55:35Jimmy Akin: Indicates that the passage is defining a commonly known term.
- 55:40Jimmy Akin: It's saying, you know, those things that you know as evil spirits, well, this is where they came from.
- 55:46Jimmy Akin: And
- 55:47Jimmy Akin: we already know that evil spirits was one of the terms in the New Testament for demons.
- 55:53Jimmy Akin: So
- 55:53Jimmy Akin: this is an origin
- 55:55Jimmy Akin: story for demons, which means.
- 55:57Jimmy Akin: that we have a new use of the term.
- 56:00Jimmy Akin: Here
- 56:00Jimmy Akin: it refers to angelic human hybrid
- 56:04Jimmy Akin: ghosts
- 56:05Jimmy Akin: That's
- 56:06Jimmy Akin: a little bit like the Greek idea that demons were the ghosts of the golden race of mankind, who were ancient and in some ways
- 56:15Jimmy Akin: better and stronger than us, but the Israelite authors see them as evil rather than good.
- 56:21Jimmy Akin: Now the Book of the Watchers, which is the part of 1
- 56:25Jimmy Akin: Enoch
- 56:26Jimmy Akin: where this occurs,
- 56:27Jimmy Akin: was written in the 3rd century
- 56:30Jimmy Akin: BC, and we see the same use in the Book of Jubilees, which was written in the 2nd century BC.
- 56:38Jimmy Akin: By the way, we talked about Jubilees in episode 319.
- 56:42Jimmy Akin: And in Jubilees
- 56:44Jimmy Akin: 10, we read
- 56:46Voiceover: In the third week of that Jubilee, the unclean demons began to lead astray the children of Noah's sons, and to lead them to folly and to destroy them.
- 56:55Voiceover: And the sons of Noah came to Noah, their father, and they told him about the demons who were leading astray
- 57:01Voiceover: and blinding and killing his grandchildren
- 57:05Voiceover: And Noah prayed to God, saying, You
- 57:08Voiceover: know that which your watchers, the fathers of these spirits, did in my days, and also these spirits who are alive.
- 57:15Voiceover: Shut them up, and take them to the place of judgment.
- 57:19Voiceover: And do not let them cause corruption among the sons of your servant, O my God, because
- 57:24Voiceover: they are cruel and were created to destroy
- 57:27Voiceover: And let them not rule over the spirits of the living, because you alone know their judgment, and do not let them have power over the children of the righteous
- 57:38Voiceover: henceforth and forever.
- 57:40Jimmy Akin: So
- 57:40Jimmy Akin: here again we're talking about the spirits of the giants.
- 57:44Jimmy Akin: Jubilees calls them unclean demons, which is what Luke called a demon in Luke four
- 57:50Jimmy Akin: thirty-three.
- 57:51Jimmy Akin: The text also here calls them spirits.
- 57:55Jimmy Akin: so
- 57:55Jimmy Akin: they're unclean spirits.
- 57:57Jimmy Akin: And we already know that that's one of the terms the New
- 58:00Jimmy Akin: Testament uses for demons.
- 58:03Jimmy Akin: The passage
- 58:04Jimmy Akin: also just flat
- 58:06Jimmy Akin: out calls them demons.
- 58:07Jimmy Akin: And in the Ethiopic language that Jubilee survives in.
- 58:11Jimmy Akin: It uses the standard Ethiopic word that's translated in Greek as daimon
- 58:17Jimmy Akin: or daimonion.
- 58:19Jimmy Akin: So
- 58:20Jimmy Akin: Here
- 58:20Jimmy Akin: we have the same origin
- 58:22Jimmy Akin: story of demons as angelic human hybrid ghosts.
- 58:27Jimmy Akin: Jubilees
- 58:28Jimmy Akin: also has an explanation regarding the current situation with demons.
- 58:32Jimmy Akin: Now, Noah has just prayed that the demons
- 58:36Jimmy Akin: be shut up in a place of judgment
- 58:39Jimmy Akin: so that they can't harm mankind.
- 58:41Jimmy Akin: So
- 58:42Jimmy Akin: why do demons still bother people here on earth?
- 58:46Jimmy Akin: Well, Jubilees
- 58:47Jimmy Akin: answers that question.
- 58:49Jimmy Akin: After Noah's Prayer, we read.
- 58:52Voiceover: The chief of the evil spirits, Mastama, came and he said, O
- 58:56Voiceover: Lord
- 58:56Voiceover: Creator, leave some of them before me
- 58:59Voiceover: and let them obey my voice, and let them do everything which I tell them.
- 59:04Voiceover: because
- 59:04Voiceover: if some of them are not left for me, I will not be able to exercise the authority of my will among the children of men, because they are intended to corrupt and lead astray before my judgment
- 59:16Voiceover: because
- 59:16Voiceover: the evil of the sons of men is great.
- 59:19Voiceover: And he said,
- 59:20Voiceover: Let a tenth of them remain before him, but let nine parts go down into the place of judgment
- 59:27Voiceover: And we, that is, the good angels, acted in accord with all his
- 59:32Voiceover: words.
- 59:33Voiceover: All of the evil ones
- 59:34Voiceover: who were cruel
- 59:35Voiceover: we bound in the place of judgment
- 59:38Voiceover: but a tenth of them we let remain, so that they might be subject to Satan upon the earth.
- 59:45Jimmy Akin: So
- 59:45Jimmy Akin: the devil, who is here given the name Mastema, asked God to allow ten per cent of the demons to still roam free.
- 59:52Jimmy Akin: And so the good angels can find 90% of the demons, but they let 10%
- 59:57Jimmy Akin: of them still run loose, which is why we still have problems with demons here in the world.
- 1:00:02Jimmy Akin: Just imagine if we had to deal with ten
- 1:00:05Jimmy Akin: times more demons than we do.
- 1:00:07Jimmy Akin: I mean
- 1:00:07Jimmy Akin: wow, that would be bad
- 1:00:10Jimmy Akin: In any event, Jubilees, like first
- 1:00:12Jimmy Akin: Enoch, understands demons to be hybrid ghosts.
- 1:00:16Jimmy Akin: Another second temple
- 1:00:17Jimmy Akin: source
- 1:00:18Jimmy Akin: from just before the time of Jesus
- 1:00:20Jimmy Akin: is the Jewish philosopher Philo
- 1:00:22Jimmy Akin: of Alexandria.
- 1:00:24Jimmy Akin: He lived from about twenty
- 1:00:26Jimmy Akin: BC
- 1:00:27Jimmy Akin: to about
- 1:00:28Jimmy Akin: A.
- 1:00:28Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:00:28Jimmy Akin: fifty.
- 1:00:29Jimmy Akin: He came from a wealthy family, and he once led an embassy to the Emperor Caligula
- 1:00:34Jimmy Akin: in Rome.
- 1:00:35Jimmy Akin: He spent his life trying to show that the faith of Moses
- 1:00:38Jimmy Akin: and the philosophy of Plato
- 1:00:40Jimmy Akin: fit together.
- 1:00:41Jimmy Akin: He wrote in Greek, and he wrote a whole book about the giants from Genesis 6
- 1:00:46Jimmy Akin: And he forms a kind of bridge with Greek thought about demons.
- 1:00:50Jimmy Akin: You'll recall that one of the Greek uses was the idea that demons are intermediate beings between gods and men.
- 1:00:59Jimmy Akin: Well, Philo
- 1:01:00Jimmy Akin: says
- 1:01:01Voiceover: Those beings whom other philosophers call demons, Moses
- 1:01:05Voiceover: usually calls angels, and they are souls hovering in the air.
- 1:01:10Voiceover: Philosophers in general are wont to call these demons, but the sacred scripture calls them angels.
- 1:01:17Voiceover: And as men in general speak of good and evil demons, and in like manner of good and evil souls,
- 1:01:24Voiceover: So also do they speak of good and evil angels.
- 1:01:28Jimmy Akin: And Philo
- 1:01:29Jimmy Akin: just swaps the words.
- 1:01:31Jimmy Akin: What others call demons, Moses
- 1:01:33Jimmy Akin: usually calls angels.
- 1:01:35Jimmy Akin: For philo, demon, angel, and soul
- 1:01:40Jimmy Akin: are three words for
- 1:01:42Jimmy Akin: one kind of in-between being.
- 1:01:44Jimmy Akin: For him, there's no contradiction.
- 1:01:46Jimmy Akin: The philosophers and Moses
- 1:01:48Jimmy Akin: are describing the same spirits.
- 1:01:50Jimmy Akin: In any event, this is one of the familiar uses of the term demon from Greek.
- 1:01:56Dom Bettinelli: Thus far, we've seen Second Temple Jewish sources using the term demon to refer to gods and intermediate beings, but we also saw that there were several ways the word
- 1:02:06Dom Bettinelli: could
- 1:02:06Dom Bettinelli: be used to refer to human spirits, either golden race ghosts, good ghosts, or ordinary ghosts.
- 1:02:13Dom Bettinelli: Do we see anything like that in the Jewish sources?
- 1:02:17Jimmy Akin: Yes, uh
- 1:02:18Jimmy Akin: the Jewish sources also
- 1:02:20Jimmy Akin: keep the old ghost idea alive, the
- 1:02:23Jimmy Akin: you know, ordinary human ghost
- 1:02:25Jimmy Akin: again.
- 1:02:26Jimmy Akin: The historian Josephus
- 1:02:28Jimmy Akin: is an example of that
- 1:02:29Jimmy Akin: Josephus was a Jewish historian who lived through the war with Rome in the AD
- 1:02:34Jimmy Akin: 60s and 70s.
- 1:02:36Jimmy Akin: He came from a priestly family and he commanded rebel forces in Galilee.
- 1:02:41Jimmy Akin: When the Romans captured him, he changed sides and wrote history under their patronage.
- 1:02:47Jimmy Akin: His account of the war is one of our main sources, in fact, for this whole period.
- 1:02:52Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:02:52Jimmy Akin: he reports a speech given to encourage soldiers
- 1:02:55Jimmy Akin: that said
- 1:02:57Voiceover: What man of virtue is there who does not know that those souls which are severed from their fleshly bodies in battle and by the sword
- 1:03:05Voiceover: are received by the ether, that purest of elements, and joined to that company which are placed among the stars, that they become good demons and propitious heroes
- 1:03:17Jimmy Akin: So in this passage
- 1:03:18Jimmy Akin: those killed in battle become good
- 1:03:21Jimmy Akin: demons.
- 1:03:22Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:03:22Jimmy Akin: from
- 1:03:22Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:03:23Jimmy Akin: you might suppose that we're dealing with the Greek usage of the term to refer to good
- 1:03:29Jimmy Akin: human ghosts again, but
- 1:03:31Jimmy Akin: Josephus has another passage that sheds additional light on the term.
- 1:03:36Jimmy Akin: He's describing a medicinal root in that passage
- 1:03:40Jimmy Akin: that's difficult and dangerous to obtain, and he says
- 1:03:44Voiceover: Yet
- 1:03:44Voiceover: after all this pains in getting, the root is only valuable on account of one virtue it has
- 1:03:51Voiceover: that if it be only brought to sick persons, it quickly drives away those called demons
- 1:03:57Voiceover: which are no other than the spirits of the wicked, that enter into men that are alive
- 1:04:02Voiceover: and kill them, unless they can obtain some help against them.
- 1:04:06Jimmy Akin: So here
- 1:04:07Jimmy Akin: Josephus
- 1:04:08Jimmy Akin: says that the demons are no other than the spirits of the wicked.
- 1:04:13Jimmy Akin: That's the same idea
- 1:04:14Jimmy Akin: later Judaism calls a dibock.
- 1:04:17Jimmy Akin: uh that is the soul of a dead person that possesses a living person.
- 1:04:21Jimmy Akin: The term comes from a word that means to cling, so a dibbuck is something that
- 1:04:27Jimmy Akin: clings, the soul of a dead sinner that grabs onto a living person.
- 1:04:32Jimmy Akin: And we'll talk about Dybbux in a future episode
- 1:04:36Jimmy Akin: In any event, Josephus has one passage where he talks about good demons
- 1:04:40Jimmy Akin: and another passage where he talks about bad demons.
- 1:04:44Jimmy Akin: And in both cases, he's talking about human spirits.
- 1:04:47Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:04:48Jimmy Akin: in
- 1:04:48Jimmy Akin: this, he's using the Greek term to just mean an ordinary ghost that could either be good or bad.
- 1:04:56Dom Bettinelli: The Second Temple Jewish sources that we've seen use the term demon to refer to hybrid ghosts, regular ghosts, and intermediate beings, specifically as a synonym for angels.
- 1:05:07Dom Bettinelli: But Judaism has a long history after the temple was destroyed in AD 70.
- 1:05:11Dom Bettinelli: How are demons understood in later Judaism?
- 1:05:15Jimmy Akin: Well, it's something that will surprise many Christian listeners and viewers, but Later Judaism does not have the idea
- 1:05:22Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:05:23Jimmy Akin: demons as fallen
- 1:05:24Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 1:05:25Jimmy Akin: The main understanding in later Judaism is that demons were specially created by God.
- 1:05:32Jimmy Akin: and that they were evil or destructive
- 1:05:35Jimmy Akin: from
- 1:05:36Jimmy Akin: the beginning.
- 1:05:37Jimmy Akin: They didn't fall.
- 1:05:39Jimmy Akin: We see this, for example, in the Tractate of the Mishnah
- 1:05:43Jimmy Akin: known as Perkay
- 1:05:45Jimmy Akin: Avot
- 1:05:46Jimmy Akin: The Mishnah
- 1:05:47Jimmy Akin: is a collection of Jewish legal opinions and lore
- 1:05:51Jimmy Akin: that was written down around A.
- 1:05:53Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:05:53Jimmy Akin: 200 by a sage known as Judah
- 1:05:55Jimmy Akin: Hanasi
- 1:05:56Jimmy Akin: or Judah the Prince.
- 1:05:58Jimmy Akin: And in one passage, the tractate
- 1:06:00Jimmy Akin: per key
- 1:06:01Jimmy Akin: a vote
- 1:06:02Jimmy Akin: is talking about the first week of creation, and it says
- 1:06:07Voiceover: Ten
- 1:06:07Voiceover: things were created on the eve of the Sabbath at twilight, and these are they
- 1:06:12Voiceover: the
- 1:06:12Voiceover: mouth of the earth, the mouth of the well, the mouth of the donkey, the rainbow, the manna, the staff.
- 1:06:21Voiceover: the Shamir, the letters, the writing and the tablets.
- 1:06:25Voiceover: And some say, also
- 1:06:27Voiceover: the demons, the grave of Moses, and the ram of Abraham our father
- 1:06:32Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:06:33Jimmy Akin: according to this tractate, some people say that the demons
- 1:06:37Jimmy Akin: were
- 1:06:38Jimmy Akin: created on the eve of the Sabbath
- 1:06:40Jimmy Akin: of the first week of creation, that is, right before the beginning of the Sabbath at twilight
- 1:06:46Jimmy Akin: In other words, at the very end of the day.
- 1:06:48Jimmy Akin: Later Jewish sources indicate that the timing was crucial to why they ended up as demons.
- 1:06:55Jimmy Akin: A commentary on Genesis known as the Genesis Rabbah, which was written in the early AD
- 1:07:01Jimmy Akin: four hundred, says,
- 1:07:03Voiceover: These are the demons.
- 1:07:05Voiceover: The Holy One, blessed be he, created their souls.
- 1:07:09Voiceover: And when he came to create their bodies, he sanctified the Sabbath
- 1:07:13Voiceover: and did not create them.
- 1:07:15Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:07:16Jimmy Akin: here it
- 1:07:16Jimmy Akin: says that when God created the demons, he created their souls, but did not create bodies for them in order to sanctify the Sabbath.
- 1:07:26Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:07:26Jimmy Akin: they're kind of
- 1:07:28Jimmy Akin: unfinished
- 1:07:30Jimmy Akin: spiritual beings that are evil
- 1:07:32Jimmy Akin: but distinct from humans and angels.
- 1:07:35Jimmy Akin: Now, this would conflict with the biblical idea that God created everything good, but many ancient Jews did not have a problem.
- 1:07:44Jimmy Akin: with the idea that both good and evil come from God, which can be interpreted as
- 1:07:49Jimmy Akin: a way of saying that, well, God's in control of everything, so
- 1:07:53Jimmy Akin: that even
- 1:07:54Jimmy Akin: evil things only happen because he allows them
- 1:07:58Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:07:58Jimmy Akin: in an older way of thinking, many Jews didn't have a problem with
- 1:08:02Jimmy Akin: speaking in a way that attributed evil directly to God.
- 1:08:07Jimmy Akin: So God
- 1:08:08Jimmy Akin: could just
- 1:08:09Jimmy Akin: directly create evil spirits.
- 1:08:12Jimmy Akin: In any event, this idea of demons as spiritual beings that were bad from the beginning
- 1:08:18Jimmy Akin: later became the standard one in post-Second
- 1:08:22Jimmy Akin: Temple Judaism.
- 1:08:23Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:08:24Jimmy Akin: Don't assume that Jews understand demons to be fallen
- 1:08:27Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 1:08:28Jimmy Akin: That's a Christian idea, not one we find in pre-Christian or post-Christian Jewish sources.
- 1:08:36Dom Bettinelli: We've seen that later Judaism didn't understand demons as fallen
- 1:08:40Dom Bettinelli: angels.
- 1:08:40Dom Bettinelli: What about the Christian writers who came after the New
- 1:08:43Dom Bettinelli: Testament?
- 1:08:44Dom Bettinelli: How did they use the term
- 1:08:46Jimmy Akin: The Church Fathers
- 1:08:47Jimmy Akin: inherited all of the earlier uses of the term, and the first few that we find among them is one that we've already met.
- 1:08:54Jimmy Akin: Many of the early church fathers had read First Enoch, and they took over its account of where demons came from.
- 1:09:01Jimmy Akin: In fact, the Book of Jude even quotes First Enoch as genuine prophecy, and some early Christians considered it scripture.
- 1:09:09Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:09:09Jimmy Akin: they understood demons as the offspring
- 1:09:13Jimmy Akin: of the angels who mated with the human women, that is, as hybrid ghosts.
- 1:09:18Jimmy Akin: We find this understanding, for example, in Saint Justin Martyr.
- 1:09:22Jimmy Akin: He was a philosopher who became a Christian and taught in Rome.
- 1:09:26Jimmy Akin: Uh he was martyred around A.
- 1:09:28Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:09:28Jimmy Akin: 165, which is how he got the name martyr, and he wrote two defenses of the faith addressed to the Roman authorities.
- 1:09:35Jimmy Akin: His first apology was written around A.
- 1:09:38Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:09:38Jimmy Akin: one
- 1:09:38Jimmy Akin: fifty five
- 1:09:39Jimmy Akin: And his second apology
- 1:09:41Jimmy Akin: shortly after that.
- 1:09:42Jimmy Akin: In the second apology, Justin describes how God arranged the world and what the angels did
- 1:09:49Jimmy Akin: next.
- 1:09:50Voiceover: God, when he had made the whole world, and subjected things earthly to man, and arranged the heavenly elements for the increase of fruits and rotation of the seasons, and appointed this divine law
- 1:10:03Voiceover: For these things also he evidently made for man, committed the care of men and of all things under heaven to angels, whom he appointed over them
- 1:10:12Voiceover: But the angels transgressed this appointment, and were captivated by love of women, and fathered children
- 1:10:19Voiceover: who are those that are called demons.
- 1:10:22Voiceover: And besides, they afterwards subdued the human race to themselves, partly by magical writings, and partly by fears and the punishments they occasioned
- 1:10:32Voiceover: and partly by teaching them to offer sacrifices
- 1:10:36Voiceover: and incense and libations, of which things they stood in need, after they were enslaved by lustful passions
- 1:10:44Voiceover: ,
- 1:10:44Voiceover: and among men they sowed murders, wars, adulteries, intemperate deeds, and all wickedness
- 1:10:52Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:10:53Jimmy Akin: the angels fathered children
- 1:10:56Jimmy Akin: who are
- 1:10:57Jimmy Akin: those that are called demons.
- 1:11:00Jimmy Akin: The Greek word there
- 1:11:02Jimmy Akin: is daimones, the plural of daimon
- 1:11:05Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:11:05Jimmy Akin: for Justin, the demons aren't the angels themselves, they're the angel's children.
- 1:11:12Jimmy Akin: Justin doesn't use the word giants
- 1:11:14Jimmy Akin: here, but in Genesis 6 and 1st Enoch,
- 1:11:17Jimmy Akin: That's who the children of the angels were.
- 1:11:19Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:11:20Jimmy Akin: Justin is just using the
- 1:11:22Jimmy Akin: term
- 1:11:23Jimmy Akin: for the angels' hybrid offspring, the idea behind a demon being a hybrid ghost.
- 1:11:30Jimmy Akin: About twenty years later we find the same idea in an author named Athenagoras.
- 1:11:36Jimmy Akin: He was a Christian philosopher in Athens, and around A.
- 1:11:39Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:11:39Jimmy Akin: 177
- 1:11:41Jimmy Akin: ,
- 1:11:41Jimmy Akin: He wrote a defense of the faith
- 1:11:42Jimmy Akin: addressed to the Emperor Marcus Aurelius and his son Commodus.
- 1:11:46Jimmy Akin: He describes how some of the angels sinned with women, and then he says
- 1:11:52Voiceover: Of these angelic lovers of virgins, therefore, were fathered
- 1:11:56Voiceover: those who were called giants.
- 1:11:59Voiceover: These angels, then, who have fallen from heaven, and haunt the air and the earth, and are no longer able to rise to heavenly things,
- 1:12:07Voiceover: And the souls of the giants, which are the demons who wander about the world, perform actions similar, the one
- 1:12:14Voiceover: that is of the demons, to the natures they have received
- 1:12:18Voiceover: the other, that is the angels, to the appetites they have indulged.
- 1:12:23Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:12:23Jimmy Akin: Athenagoras speaks of the souls of the giants, which are the demons who wander about the world
- 1:12:30Jimmy Akin: And he keeps the two groups separate.
- 1:12:33Jimmy Akin: The fallen
- 1:12:33Jimmy Akin: angels are one group, and the demons, the
- 1:12:37Jimmy Akin: the souls of the angels' giant children, are another group.
- 1:12:40Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:12:41Jimmy Akin: This
- 1:12:42Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:12:43Jimmy Akin: yet another clear use of the term for a hybrid ghost, just as in First
- 1:12:47Jimmy Akin: Enoch, the demons are the surviving spirits of the giants.
- 1:12:52Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:12:52Jimmy Akin: there were others in this period who used the term the same way.
- 1:12:56Jimmy Akin: In fact, before a certain point, this was the standard understanding in Christian circles.
- 1:13:02Dom Bettinelli: Did any of the fathers use the term for human ghosts?
- 1:13:06Jimmy Akin: The idea was certainly present at the time, and St.
- 1:13:10Jimmy Akin: Justin Martyr
- 1:13:11Jimmy Akin: seems to do this.
- 1:13:13Jimmy Akin: In his first apology, he's arguing that the soul survives death, and he points to things that his pagan readers already believed.
- 1:13:23Voiceover: For let
- 1:13:24Voiceover: even necromancy
- 1:13:25Voiceover: and the divinations you practice by immaculate children, and the evoking of departed human souls
- 1:13:32Voiceover: And those who are called among the magi, dreamsenders and assistant spirits, familiars, and all that is done by those who are skilled in such matters
- 1:13:42Voiceover: Let these persuade you that even after death
- 1:13:45Voiceover: souls are in a state of sensation, and those who are seized
- 1:13:50Voiceover: and cast about by the souls of the dead, whom all call demoniacs
- 1:13:55Voiceover: or madmen.
- 1:13:57Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:13:57Jimmy Akin: Justin mentions people who are seized and cast about by the souls of the dead, and he says that all
- 1:14:06Jimmy Akin: call the people they seize
- 1:14:08Jimmy Akin: demoniacs.
- 1:14:09Jimmy Akin: The Greek word is
- 1:14:11Jimmy Akin: daimoniolaptos.
- 1:14:13Jimmy Akin: Daimonio
- 1:14:14Jimmy Akin: laptos
- 1:14:15Jimmy Akin: means seized by a demon.
- 1:14:17Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:14:18Jimmy Akin: the people seized by the souls of the dead are called demon-seized, which indicates that the souls
- 1:14:24Jimmy Akin: due in
- 1:14:24Jimmy Akin: the seizing
- 1:14:25Jimmy Akin: were thought of as demons.
- 1:14:27Jimmy Akin: Now, Justin is reporting
- 1:14:30Jimmy Akin: a common belief here, but he's using it as evidence that the soul survives death, and it would undercut
- 1:14:36Jimmy Akin: his argument if
- 1:14:37Jimmy Akin: Souls of the Dead didn't really seize people.
- 1:14:40Jimmy Akin: So it looks like
- 1:14:41Jimmy Akin: in addition to using the term demon for hybrid ghosts, Justin also uses it for
- 1:14:48Jimmy Akin: just regular ghosts.
- 1:14:50Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:14:50Dom Bettinelli: who was the first Christian to identify demons as fallen angels?
- 1:14:55Jimmy Akin: The first we have a record of was named Tatian.
- 1:14:59Jimmy Akin: Tatian was a student of Saint Justin Martyr in Rome
- 1:15:04Jimmy Akin: He became a Christian around A.
- 1:15:06Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:15:06Jimmy Akin: 150, and he would end up being a kind of problematic individual
- 1:15:11Jimmy Akin: He wrote and addressed to the Greeks sometime between the A.
- 1:15:15Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:15:16Jimmy Akin: 160s and 170s, but around A.
- 1:15:19Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:15:19Jimmy Akin: 172, he left the church to found his own heretical sect.
- 1:15:25Jimmy Akin: In
- 1:15:25Jimmy Akin: the address
- 1:15:26Jimmy Akin: to the Greeks, he has a chapter on how evil came into the world.
- 1:15:31Jimmy Akin: He notes that it was through the Lagos
- 1:15:33Jimmy Akin: through Jesus that the angels were created, but then one of the angels, the
- 1:15:38Jimmy Akin: firstborn angel
- 1:15:40Jimmy Akin: fell and became a demon.
- 1:15:43Jimmy Akin: Tatian says.
- 1:15:44Voiceover: The Logos
- 1:15:45Voiceover: too, before the creation of men, was the framer of angels.
- 1:15:50Voiceover: And each of these two orders of creatures was made free to act as it pleased, not having the nature of good, which again is with God alone, but is brought to perfection in men through their freedom of choice.
- 1:16:04Voiceover: And when men attached themselves to one
- 1:16:06Voiceover: who was more subtle than the rest, having regard to his being the firstborn, and declared him to be God, though he was resisting the law of God
- 1:16:16Voiceover: Then the power of the Logos excluded the beginner of the folly
- 1:16:20Voiceover: and his adherents
- 1:16:21Voiceover: from all fellowship with himself
- 1:16:24Voiceover: And so
- 1:16:25Voiceover: he who was made in the likeness of God, since the more powerful spirit is separated from him, becomes mortal
- 1:16:32Voiceover: But
- 1:16:33Voiceover: that first begotten one through his transgression and ignorance
- 1:16:37Voiceover: becomes a demon, and those who imitated him, that is his illusions, have become a host of demons
- 1:16:44Voiceover: and through their freedom of choice
- 1:16:47Voiceover: have been given up to their own infatuation.
- 1:16:50Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:16:51Jimmy Akin: Tatian says that the first begotten one through his transgression in ignorance
- 1:16:55Jimmy Akin: becomes a demon.
- 1:16:57Jimmy Akin: The first begotten angel is the devil.
- 1:17:00Jimmy Akin: Tatian has just said that the Lagos
- 1:17:02Jimmy Akin: made two orders of creatures, angels and men.
- 1:17:05Jimmy Akin: And the firstborn isn't one of the men, since men attached themselves to him, so he's one of the angels.
- 1:17:12Jimmy Akin: And his followers have become a host of demons.
- 1:17:16Jimmy Akin: The Greek words are
- 1:17:18Jimmy Akin: daimon
- 1:17:19Jimmy Akin: for the devil
- 1:17:20Jimmy Akin: and daimones
- 1:17:22Jimmy Akin: for his followers.
- 1:17:23Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:17:23Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:17:24Jimmy Akin: Tatian, the demons aren't the angels' children, they're the angels who fell
- 1:17:29Jimmy Akin: This is the first time we find a Christian writer using the term demon for fallen
- 1:17:34Jimmy Akin: angel.
- 1:17:35Jimmy Akin: A little later we find the same idea in Theophilus of Antioch.
- 1:17:39Jimmy Akin: Theophilus
- 1:17:40Jimmy Akin: was the Bishop of Antioch
- 1:17:42Jimmy Akin: in Syria, and he wrote a work in three books called To Atolicus, defending the faith
- 1:17:49Jimmy Akin: to a pagan friend of his.
- 1:17:51Jimmy Akin: He wrote it around A.
- 1:17:52Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:17:52Jimmy Akin: one
- 1:17:53Jimmy Akin: eighty.
- 1:17:54Jimmy Akin: He's been uh
- 1:17:55Jimmy Akin: discussing Eve and the serpent in the Garden of Eden in the book, and then he says.
- 1:18:01Voiceover: This
- 1:18:01Voiceover: Eve, on account of her having been in the beginning, deceived by the serpent.
- 1:18:06Voiceover: and become the author of sin, the wicked demon, who also is called Satan, who
- 1:18:12Voiceover: then spoke to her through the serpent, and who works even to this day in those men who are possessed by him, invokes as Eve.
- 1:18:21Voiceover: And he is called Demon and Dragon, on account of his revolting from God.
- 1:18:27Voiceover: For at first
- 1:18:28Voiceover: he was an angel.
- 1:18:30Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:18:31Jimmy Akin: Theophilus says the devil is called the demon and dragon, and that at first
- 1:18:37Jimmy Akin: he was an angel.
- 1:18:39Jimmy Akin: The Greek word here for demon is daimon.
- 1:18:43Jimmy Akin: So around AD
- 1:18:44Jimmy Akin: 180, we have two Christian writers using the term demon for
- 1:18:49Jimmy Akin: fallen
- 1:18:49Jimmy Akin: angel.
- 1:18:50Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:18:51Dom Bettinelli: did the Fallen Angel idea
- 1:18:53Dom Bettinelli: take over at that point?
- 1:18:55Jimmy Akin: Not right away.
- 1:18:56Jimmy Akin: The church hadn't settled what these beings are.
- 1:19:00Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:19:00Jimmy Akin: Origen of Alexandria shows this.
- 1:19:02Jimmy Akin: Origen was a Christian scholar from Egypt who lived from about AD
- 1:19:07Jimmy Akin: 185
- 1:19:08Jimmy Akin: to 253.
- 1:19:10Jimmy Akin: Around 225, he wrote a book called On First Principles.
- 1:19:14Jimmy Akin: It sets out the main teachings of the faith
- 1:19:17Jimmy Akin: and the questions that
- 1:19:19Jimmy Akin: the faith leaves open.
- 1:19:21Jimmy Akin: Most of it survives only in a Latin translation that a man named Rufinus made in the late 390s
- 1:19:29Jimmy Akin: In the preface, Origen lists the points he regards as the church's teaching, and he says
- 1:19:35Voiceover: regarding the devil and his angels and the opposing influences, the teaching of the church has laid down
- 1:19:42Voiceover: That these beings exist indeed.
- 1:19:45Voiceover: But what they are, or how they exist, it has not explained with sufficient clearness
- 1:19:51Voiceover: This opinion, however, is held by most, that the devil was an angel, and that, having become an apostate, he induced as many of the angels as possible
- 1:20:02Voiceover: to fall away with himself
- 1:20:04Voiceover: and these up to the present time
- 1:20:06Voiceover: are called his
- 1:20:07Voiceover: angels.
- 1:20:08Jimmy Akin: So according to Origen, these beings exist, but what they are
- 1:20:12Jimmy Akin: or how they exist, it has not explained with sufficient clearness.
- 1:20:17Jimmy Akin: He reports that most
- 1:20:19Jimmy Akin: hold that the devil was an angel who led other angels to fall, but that's a widely held opinion, not subtle teaching.
- 1:20:27Jimmy Akin: Origen also doesn't use the word
- 1:20:30Jimmy Akin: demon
- 1:20:30Jimmy Akin: in this passage.
- 1:20:31Jimmy Akin: He's talking about the devil and his angels, but it shows that in the early two
- 1:20:37Jimmy Akin: hundreds the nature of these beings was still an open question
- 1:20:41Jimmy Akin: And the term
- 1:20:42Jimmy Akin: was still used in more than one way.
- 1:20:45Jimmy Akin: We find this about 80 years later in Lactantius.
- 1:20:49Jimmy Akin: He was a Christian teacher of rhetoric who lived from about A.
- 1:20:53Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:20:53Jimmy Akin: 250 to 325.
- 1:20:56Jimmy Akin: Late in life he tutored a son of the Emperor Constantine.
- 1:21:01Jimmy Akin: Between three hundred oh
- 1:21:02Jimmy Akin: three and three hundred
- 1:21:03Jimmy Akin: eleven he wrote a defense of the faith called the Divine Institutes.
- 1:21:07Jimmy Akin: In it
- 1:21:07Jimmy Akin: he says that God sent angels to protect the human race
- 1:21:11Jimmy Akin: and commanded them not to defile themselves with the earth.
- 1:21:15Jimmy Akin: Then he says,
- 1:21:17Voiceover: Therefore, while they, the angels, stayed among men, that most deceitful ruler of the earth, by his very association, gradually enticed them to vices
- 1:21:28Voiceover: and polluted them by intercourse with women.
- 1:21:31Voiceover: Then, not being admitted into heaven
- 1:21:34Voiceover: on account of the sins
- 1:21:35Voiceover: into which they had plunged themselves, they fell to the earth
- 1:21:40Voiceover: Thus
- 1:21:40Voiceover: from angels, the devil makes them to become his
- 1:21:43Voiceover: satellites and attendants.
- 1:21:45Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:21:46Jimmy Akin: the angels fell to the earth, and the devil made them his satellites
- 1:21:50Jimmy Akin: and attendants.
- 1:21:51Jimmy Akin: These are the fallen
- 1:21:53Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 1:21:53Jimmy Akin: But Lactantius doesn't stop there.
- 1:21:56Jimmy Akin: He goes on to describe their children
- 1:21:59Voiceover: But those who were born from these angels, because they were neither angels nor men, but bearing a kind of mixed nature, were not admitted into hell, as their fathers were not into heaven.
- 1:22:11Voiceover: Thus there came to be two kinds of demons, one of heaven, the other of the earth.
- 1:22:17Voiceover: The latter are the wicked spirits, the authors of all the evils which are done, and the same devil is their prince.
- 1:22:25Jimmy Akin: So for Lactantius there came to be two kinds of demons, one
- 1:22:31Jimmy Akin: of heaven and the other of earth.
- 1:22:34Jimmy Akin: The demons of heaven are the fallen angels.
- 1:22:37Jimmy Akin: Lactantius doesn't say that in so many words, but the two groups in his story are the angels and their children.
- 1:22:45Jimmy Akin: And the two kinds of demons match them.
- 1:22:47Jimmy Akin: And the demons of the earth, therefore, would be the angel's children, or hybrids.
- 1:22:53Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:22:54Jimmy Akin: neither angels nor men, but something in between.
- 1:22:57Jimmy Akin: So in the early three hundreds a Christian writer could still use the term demon for both.
- 1:23:02Jimmy Akin: We thus see two different uses of the term demon in the same author.
- 1:23:07Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:23:07Dom Bettinelli: when did the Fallen
- 1:23:09Dom Bettinelli: Angel View become the standard one?
- 1:23:12Jimmy Akin: Gradually
- 1:23:13Jimmy Akin: over the following centuries, and in the West the decisive figure was St.
- 1:23:17Jimmy Akin: Augustine.
- 1:23:18Jimmy Akin: Augustine was a bishop of Hippo
- 1:23:21Jimmy Akin: in North Africa, and he lived from A.
- 1:23:24Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:23:24Jimmy Akin: 354
- 1:23:25Jimmy Akin: to A.
- 1:23:26Jimmy Akin: D.
- 1:23:26Jimmy Akin: 430.
- 1:23:28Jimmy Akin: Between about 413 and 426 he wrote his massive
- 1:23:32Jimmy Akin: multi-volume work, The City of God, and later Western theologians relied heavily on his writings.
- 1:23:39Jimmy Akin: In the city of God, Augustine says,
- 1:23:42Voiceover: And when I speak of the wills of angels, I mean either the wills of good angels, whom we call the angels of God, or of the wicked angels
- 1:23:51Voiceover: whom we call the angels of the devil
- 1:23:54Voiceover: or demons.
- 1:23:55Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:23:55Jimmy Akin: Augustine speaks of the wicked angels
- 1:23:58Jimmy Akin: whom we call the angels of the devil
- 1:24:01Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:24:02Jimmy Akin: demons.
- 1:24:04Jimmy Akin: For
- 1:24:04Jimmy Akin: Augustine, angels of the devil and demons are two names for the same group.
- 1:24:10Jimmy Akin: That's the identification that became standard.
- 1:24:14Jimmy Akin: A demon is a fallen angel
- 1:24:16Jimmy Akin: It didn't happen overnight that it became standard, but Augustine's authority in the West
- 1:24:22Jimmy Akin: led to it becoming the normal Christian understanding in the Western Church.
- 1:24:27Jimmy Akin: It already had been supported by other figures in the East.
- 1:24:31Dom Bettinelli: So, with that as background, we've now seen how the term was used both before and after the New Testament.
- 1:24:38Dom Bettinelli: That lets us look at what the New Testament says with fresh eyes.
- 1:24:41Dom Bettinelli: What do we find when we do that
- 1:24:44Jimmy Akin: Well, the New Testament authors wrote in the middle of this history, after the Septuagint, First Enoch, and Jubilees, but before Justin Tatian and Augustine.
- 1:24:55Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:24:56Jimmy Akin: we can't assume
- 1:24:58Jimmy Akin: that they meant fallen angels.
- 1:25:00Jimmy Akin: That usage isn't present in the Old Testament or in Second Temple literature.
- 1:25:06Jimmy Akin: And it never caught on in Judaism.
- 1:25:08Jimmy Akin: It's a Christian usage
- 1:25:10Jimmy Akin: that first appears in the literary record in the second century.
- 1:25:15Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:25:15Jimmy Akin: we need to look at how each New Testament passage uses the term
- 1:25:20Jimmy Akin: without assuming
- 1:25:22Jimmy Akin: the fallen
- 1:25:23Jimmy Akin: angel idea to be the case.
- 1:25:25Jimmy Akin: I mean, if we find it, that's great, but we can't just assume it
- 1:25:29Jimmy Akin: One of the clearest cases for how the term demon is being used is found in the book of Acts.
- 1:25:36Jimmy Akin: Paul, who is in Athens, is debating the philosophers there, and Luke reports.
- 1:25:41Voiceover: Some of the Epicurean and Stoic philosophers also conversed with him, and some said, What does this babbler
- 1:25:49Voiceover: wish to say?
- 1:25:50Voiceover: Others said, he seems to be a preacher of foreign divinities, because he was preaching Jesus and the resurrection.
- 1:25:58Jimmy Akin: Here
- 1:25:59Jimmy Akin: the ESV says foreign divinities, but the Greek is
- 1:26:04Jimmy Akin: xenon
- 1:26:05Jimmy Akin: daimonion, literally
- 1:26:08Jimmy Akin: foreign demons.
- 1:26:10Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:26:10Jimmy Akin: these Athenians are using the term the way the pagan Greeks often did
- 1:26:15Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:26:16Jimmy Akin: as a reference for a god.
- 1:26:18Jimmy Akin: and they thought that Paul was introducing new gods.
- 1:26:22Jimmy Akin: Paul himself also
- 1:26:24Jimmy Akin: uses the term for pagan gods
- 1:26:27Jimmy Akin: when he's writing to Christians at Corinth about whether they can eat
- 1:26:32Jimmy Akin: Meat sacrificed to idols,
- 1:26:34Jimmy Akin: he says.
- 1:26:35Voiceover: What do I imply, then?
- 1:26:37Voiceover: That food offered to idols is anything, or that an idol is anything?
- 1:26:42Voiceover: No, I imply that what pagans sacrifice they offer to demons
- 1:26:46Voiceover: and not to God.
- 1:26:48Voiceover: I do not want you to be participants with demons.
- 1:26:51Voiceover: You cannot drink the cup of the Lord and the cup of demons.
- 1:26:55Voiceover: You cannot partake of the table of the Lord and the table of demons.
- 1:27:00Jimmy Akin: So Paul says that what pagan sacrifice they offer
- 1:27:03Jimmy Akin: to demons and not to God.
- 1:27:06Jimmy Akin: That echoes Deuteronomy 32, 17, which we looked at earlier, where the Israelites
- 1:27:12Jimmy Akin: sacrifice to demons that were not gods.
- 1:27:15Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:27:15Jimmy Akin: Paul is using the term for the beings behind the pagan cults, you know,
- 1:27:21Jimmy Akin: the different pagan gods.
- 1:27:23Jimmy Akin: For Paul, they aren't the true God, but they are real, and Christians must not take part in their worship.
- 1:27:30Jimmy Akin: The book of Revelation uses the term the same way.
- 1:27:33Jimmy Akin: In Revelation 9.
- 1:27:35Jimmy Akin: 20, people refuse to give up worshiping demons and idols of gold and silver
- 1:27:40Jimmy Akin: and bronze
- 1:27:41Jimmy Akin: and stone
- 1:27:42Jimmy Akin: and wood.
- 1:27:44Dom Bettinelli: What about the demons
- 1:27:45Dom Bettinelli: Jesus cast out in the Gospels?
- 1:27:54Jimmy Akin: two different clusters of words, a demon cluster and a fallen angel cluster, but they never link the two.
- 1:28:01Jimmy Akin: Demons are never identified as fallen
- 1:28:04Jimmy Akin: angels, and fallen angels are never identified as demons.
- 1:28:08Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:28:09Jimmy Akin: the fallen
- 1:28:09Jimmy Akin: angel interpretation is not found in the Septuagint or other Second Temple literature, and because it doesn't begin to appear
- 1:28:17Jimmy Akin: in the literary record until about 150 years after Jesus'
- 1:28:22Jimmy Akin: ministry.
- 1:28:23Jimmy Akin: We can't just assume that the gospels are talking about fallen
- 1:28:26Jimmy Akin: angels possessing people.
- 1:28:28Jimmy Akin: We need to read the texts and see if
- 1:28:31Jimmy Akin: they would make sense in terms of the uses that we already know existed in this period.
- 1:28:37Jimmy Akin: Now, we saw earlier that Luke speaks of a man with the spirit of an unclean demon
- 1:28:44Jimmy Akin: That's the same language Jubilees uses when it speaks of unclean demons.
- 1:28:49Jimmy Akin: And in Jubilees, those were the spirits of the giants.
- 1:28:53Jimmy Akin: First
- 1:28:54Jimmy Akin: Enoch
- 1:28:54Jimmy Akin: also used the term evil spirits,
- 1:28:57Jimmy Akin: which is another New Testament term for demons.
- 1:29:00Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:29:00Jimmy Akin: this vocabulary would
- 1:29:03Jimmy Akin: fit
- 1:29:03Jimmy Akin: the demon as a hybrid ghost.
- 1:29:06Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:29:06Jimmy Akin: the gospels never say
- 1:29:09Jimmy Akin: where the demons come from.
- 1:29:10Jimmy Akin: They use the vocabulary, but without giving us an origin
- 1:29:14Jimmy Akin: story.
- 1:29:15Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:29:16Jimmy Akin: there are
- 1:29:17Jimmy Akin: passages that may suggest where they
- 1:29:20Jimmy Akin: came from, such as
- 1:29:23Jimmy Akin: when Luke tells us the story of the Garrosene demoniac.
- 1:29:28Voiceover: When Jesus had stepped out on land, there met him a man from the city who had demons.
- 1:29:33Voiceover: For a long time he had worn no clothes, and he had not lived in a house
- 1:29:38Voiceover: but among the tombs
- 1:29:40Voiceover: When he saw Jesus, he cried out and fell down before him, and said with a loud voice, What have you to do with me, Jesus, Son of the Most High God?
- 1:29:50Voiceover: I beg you, do not torment me
- 1:29:53Voiceover: For he had commanded the unclean spirit to come out of the man, for many a time it had seized him
- 1:30:00Voiceover: He was kept under guard and bound with chains and shackles, but he would break the bonds
- 1:30:05Voiceover: and be driven by the demon into the desert.
- 1:30:08Voiceover: Jesus then asked him, What is your name?
- 1:30:12Voiceover: And he said, Legion, for many demons had entered him.
- 1:30:17Voiceover: And they begged him not to command them to depart into the abyss.
- 1:30:21Jimmy Akin: Luke uses several terms for the same beings in this passage.
- 1:30:26Jimmy Akin: He says the man had
- 1:30:28Jimmy Akin: demons, and then that Jesus had commanded the unclean spirit to come out.
- 1:30:34Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:30:34Jimmy Akin: for Luke, uh the demon and unclean spirit are two names for the same kind of being.
- 1:30:40Jimmy Akin: The passage also
- 1:30:41Jimmy Akin: has two details that bear on what these demons were.
- 1:30:46Jimmy Akin: The first detail is that the man had not lived in a house, but among the tombs.
- 1:30:53Jimmy Akin: tombs are where people expected to find the spirits of the dead.
- 1:30:58Jimmy Akin: And we saw in Josephus, the first
- 1:31:00Jimmy Akin: century Jewish writer, that demons
- 1:31:03Jimmy Akin: are no other
- 1:31:05Jimmy Akin: than the spirits of the wicked dead.
- 1:31:08Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:31:09Jimmy Akin: some
- 1:31:09Jimmy Akin: first century years
- 1:31:10Jimmy Akin: would have understood these demons that were possessing the Garrosene
- 1:31:14Jimmy Akin: Man
- 1:31:15Jimmy Akin: as ghosts.
- 1:31:16Jimmy Akin: In fact, they may have assumed that the demons possessing the man were the ghosts of the spirits of the people in the tombs.
- 1:31:25Jimmy Akin: And that's why he hung out in the tombs, because the ghosts wanted to be close to or were tied to their bodies in some way.
- 1:31:35Jimmy Akin: The second detail in the passage is that the demons beg
- 1:31:39Jimmy Akin: Jesus not to command them to depart into the abyss.
- 1:31:43Jimmy Akin: Now, they could still be ordinary human ghosts and not want to go into the abyss, but that also fits Jubilees, where nine out of the ten of the giants' spirits were bound in a
- 1:31:56Jimmy Akin: in a place of judgment.
- 1:31:58Jimmy Akin: The same story
- 1:32:00Jimmy Akin: could
- 1:32:00Jimmy Akin: also thus
- 1:32:01Jimmy Akin: be heard in terms of hybrid ghosts.
- 1:32:05Jimmy Akin: And Luke's account doesn't settle which reading is right.
- 1:32:07Jimmy Akin: It just calls them demons.
- 1:32:09Jimmy Akin: but it has evidence that could point either towards human ghosts or hybrid ghosts.
- 1:32:15Jimmy Akin: Then there's the question of how demons relate to Satan
- 1:32:19Jimmy Akin: When the scribes from Jerusalem object to Jesus performing exorcisms, Mark reports.
- 1:32:26Voiceover: And the scribes who came down from Jerusalem were saying, He is possessed by Beelzebubel.
- 1:32:32Voiceover: And by the prince of demons
- 1:32:34Voiceover: he casts out the demons.
- 1:32:36Voiceover: And he called them to him and said to them in parables, How can Satan cast out Satan?
- 1:32:43Voiceover: If a kingdom is divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand.
- 1:32:48Voiceover: And if a house is divided against itself, that house will not be able to stand.
- 1:32:53Voiceover: And if Satan has risen up against himself and is divided, he cannot stand, but is coming to an end
- 1:33:01Jimmy Akin: So the scribes call Beelzebal
- 1:33:03Jimmy Akin: the prince of demons, and Jesus answers in terms of Satan.
- 1:33:08Jimmy Akin: So the demons are under Satan's rule.
- 1:33:11Jimmy Akin: And as we saw earlier, Satan has angels, the devil and his angels, you know, in Matthew 25, 41
- 1:33:19Jimmy Akin: This
- 1:33:19Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:33:20Jimmy Akin: the closest the New
- 1:33:22Jimmy Akin: Testament ever comes to linking the two clusters, but it never calls the demons
- 1:33:29Jimmy Akin: angels
- 1:33:29Jimmy Akin: and it never calls the devil's angels demons.
- 1:33:34Jimmy Akin: The
- 1:33:34Jimmy Akin: idea of a prince
- 1:33:36Jimmy Akin: just means a commander or
- 1:33:39Jimmy Akin: leader.
- 1:33:40Jimmy Akin: In Greek, the term is archone.
- 1:33:43Jimmy Akin: which
- 1:33:43Jimmy Akin: means ruler.
- 1:33:45Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:33:45Jimmy Akin: ruling
- 1:33:46Jimmy Akin: a group and being part of that group are not the same thing
- 1:33:50Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:33:51Jimmy Akin: you can be
- 1:33:52Jimmy Akin: the Archon
- 1:33:54Jimmy Akin: of Dons without being a demon yourself, just like you could be the Roman commander of a platoon of Germans.
- 1:34:01Jimmy Akin: It
- 1:34:02Jimmy Akin: you
- 1:34:02Jimmy Akin: just because you're the commander of the Germans doesn't make you a German.
- 1:34:07Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:34:07Jimmy Akin: yes, the Roman army did have Germans in its employ.
- 1:34:11Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:34:12Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:34:13Jimmy Akin: you could be the Archon of Dem without being a demon yourself, just like the fallen angels would have been the leaders, you know, of their hybrid children.
- 1:34:22Jimmy Akin: In any event, the New Testament never identifies the fallen angels as demons.
- 1:34:27Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:34:27Jimmy Akin: when we read the New Testament, you know, with these fresh eyes.
- 1:34:31Jimmy Akin: It uses the term demons in ways that are already on our lists, you know, for
- 1:34:37Jimmy Akin: pagan gods in Acts, First Corinthians and Revelation.
- 1:34:41Jimmy Akin: And for the spirits that Jesus casts out, you know, in language that fits with
- 1:34:47Jimmy Akin: hybrid ghosts or regular ghost models.
- 1:34:51Jimmy Akin: The identification of demons with fallen
- 1:34:53Jimmy Akin: angels comes later, starting with Tatian.
- 1:34:57Jimmy Akin: You could propose
- 1:34:58Jimmy Akin: that the usage is earlier than Tatian, and that it stretches back over the hundred and fifty year gap
- 1:35:04Jimmy Akin: between him
- 1:35:05Jimmy Akin: and the ministry of Jesus, but we can't show that
- 1:35:09Jimmy Akin: from the literary record, so it's less certain
- 1:35:13Jimmy Akin: What we can show, and what is thus more certain, is that demons were understood to be hybrid ghosts and regular ghosts.
- 1:35:21Jimmy Akin: Do
- 1:35:22Dom Bettinelli: we have any evidence that sometimes the ghosts of the dead may possess the living?
- 1:35:27Jimmy Akin: We
- 1:35:28Jimmy Akin: have at least some evidence
- 1:35:29Jimmy Akin: in exorcism cases.
- 1:35:31Jimmy Akin: The possessing spirits often claim to be human dead.
- 1:35:34Jimmy Akin: We'll see examples of that in a few moments.
- 1:35:37Jimmy Akin: But the question is, you know, whether or not you can believe those spirits when they make this claim.
- 1:35:44Jimmy Akin: And on that question.
- 1:35:47Jimmy Akin: Opinions are divided.
- 1:35:49Jimmy Akin: Some exorcists think that any such spirits are lying, and that they're really fallen
- 1:35:54Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 1:35:55Jimmy Akin: Other exorcists think that the claim to be human may be credible, at least in some cases.
- 1:36:01Dom Bettinelli: And what's your opinion?
- 1:36:03Jimmy Akin: Well, I don't have one.
- 1:36:04Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:36:04Jimmy Akin: my inclination is to go with the evidence that presents itself in a given case rather than make dogmatic pronouncements
- 1:36:11Jimmy Akin: one way or the other, because
- 1:36:13Jimmy Akin: The church doesn't have a dogma or any
- 1:36:16Jimmy Akin: teaching on this question.
- 1:36:19Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:36:19Jimmy Akin: the only official statement pertaining to it is from the 1614 Rite of Exorcism
- 1:36:25Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:36:26Jimmy Akin: In that rite, Rule 14
- 1:36:28Jimmy Akin: contains this warning.
- 1:36:30Voiceover: The exorcist must not digress into
- 1:36:33Voiceover: senseless prattle.
- 1:36:34Voiceover: nor ask superfluous questions, or such as are prompted by curiosity, particularly if they pertain to future and hidden matters, all of which have nothing to do with his office
- 1:36:46Voiceover: Instead, he will bid the unclean spirit keep silence, and answer only when asked.
- 1:36:52Voiceover: Neither ought he to give any credence to the devil, if the latter maintains that he is the spirit of some saint
- 1:37:00Voiceover: or of a deceased party, or even claims to be a good angel.
- 1:37:05Jimmy Akin: So you can see that the context here is
- 1:37:08Jimmy Akin: about not straying
- 1:37:10Jimmy Akin: off into matters that don't have anything to do with the job of the exorcist, which is getting the spirit.
- 1:37:15Jimmy Akin: it out.
- 1:37:16Jimmy Akin: So don't ask it questions
- 1:37:18Jimmy Akin: and don't believe it if it claims to be a soul
- 1:37:21Jimmy Akin: or a saint
- 1:37:22Jimmy Akin: or an angel.
- 1:37:24Jimmy Akin: which
- 1:37:24Jimmy Akin: are deceptions it might try to use to keep from being cast out.
- 1:37:29Jimmy Akin: You know, oh, I'm your beloved grandmother, or
- 1:37:32Jimmy Akin: I'm the Virgin Mary, or I'm the Angel Michael, so you can let me stay.
- 1:37:39Jimmy Akin: Don't you want to have such a blessed visitation from someone like me?
- 1:37:44Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:37:45Jimmy Akin: if you have a spirit that is forcing itself on a person
- 1:37:50Jimmy Akin: so that you have to do an exorcism to get rid of it.
- 1:37:53Jimmy Akin: Don't believe dodges, it tries to use.
- 1:37:56Jimmy Akin: Just perform the exorcism to get it out.
- 1:38:00Jimmy Akin: In my view, that is a very sound rule.
- 1:38:04Jimmy Akin: Any spirit that's guilty of forcing itself on a person and possessing them
- 1:38:08Jimmy Akin: is a bad one and is not to be trusted.
- 1:38:11Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:38:12Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:38:13Jimmy Akin: rule against believing them when they claim to be, you know, a ghost or a saint or an angel.
- 1:38:20Jimmy Akin: doesn't mean that the dead are never involved.
- 1:38:24Jimmy Akin: And like I said, there are exorcists who think they are.
- 1:38:28Jimmy Akin: They are sometimes involved.
- 1:38:29Jimmy Akin: For example,
- 1:38:31Jimmy Akin: Perhaps the most famous exorcist of our times, or recent times, Father Gabriela Amorth
- 1:38:38Jimmy Akin: agreed.
- 1:38:39Jimmy Akin: In a catechesis he gave in 2010 in Italian, he said.
- 1:38:44Voiceover: Here we must take into account the warning contained by the Roman ritual, the introductory norm
- 1:38:50Voiceover: number fourteen, in which the exorcist is warned against the possible disguises
- 1:38:55Voiceover: of the devil.
- 1:38:56Voiceover: That is, the rule states
- 1:38:58Voiceover: one must not believe the devil when he wants to pass himself off as the soul of a saint
- 1:39:04Voiceover: or of a deceased
- 1:39:05Voiceover: or as an angel
- 1:39:07Voiceover: It is a precious warning, because the devil gladly tries to cheat the exorcist, but it is not an absolute rule.
- 1:39:15Voiceover: We finally come to the answers given by the exorcists, and with these answers I also conclude my initial speech.
- 1:39:23Voiceover: What is their experience regarding the problem of presences
- 1:39:28Voiceover: I asked more renowned exorcists, those who have more years of experience, and I have had the answers that I am now giving you.
- 1:39:37Voiceover: Now we hear from a Sicilian exorcist, with
- 1:39:40Voiceover: regard to the presences of the damned, my opinion, based on personal experience, is that
- 1:39:46Voiceover: the devil, to disturb living people
- 1:39:48Voiceover: ,
- 1:39:49Voiceover: can also make use of the damned, especially those he has already possessed in life.
- 1:39:54Voiceover: Nothing prevents God from allowing the devil to use the damned, who in hell below
- 1:40:00Voiceover: are under his
- 1:40:01Voiceover: dominion
- 1:40:01Voiceover: and who in a certain way are demonized.
- 1:40:04Voiceover: Therefore there could be a divine permission for the demons to use the damned to torment souls
- 1:40:11Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:40:12Jimmy Akin: Father Amorth
- 1:40:13Jimmy Akin: says that Rule 14 is a valuable warning, but it's not an absolute rule that possessing spirits can't
- 1:40:21Jimmy Akin: be departed human souls.
- 1:40:23Jimmy Akin: And he goes on to quote
- 1:40:24Jimmy Akin: highly experienced exorcists who he considers credible, including one who says, yes, the devil can use
- 1:40:31Jimmy Akin: the souls of damned people to possess others.
- 1:40:34Jimmy Akin: the magisterium has not
- 1:40:36Jimmy Akin: settled this matter, so this is an open question in theology.
- 1:40:41Dom Bettinelli: Now, eventually, especially after Saint Augustine, the fallen
- 1:40:45Dom Bettinelli: angel
- 1:40:45Dom Bettinelli: meaning became standard in church documents
- 1:40:48Dom Bettinelli: Does that mean that other uses disappeared outside of church documents?
- 1:40:53Jimmy Akin: No, um, other
- 1:40:54Jimmy Akin: uses of the term demon
- 1:40:56Jimmy Akin: have continued to be employed.
- 1:40:58Jimmy Akin: We saw that in episodes 412 and 413 on the Erling Exorcism,
- 1:41:04Jimmy Akin: where most of the voices claim to be the human dead.
- 1:41:07Jimmy Akin: As recorded in the book Begone Satan, one of the spirits in the possessed woman claimed to be her father
- 1:41:13Jimmy Akin: Jacob, or Jake.
- 1:41:15Jimmy Akin: And even though Jake had been human, the book still classified him as a demon.
- 1:41:20Jimmy Akin: For example, the booklet says
- 1:41:23Voiceover: When the prayer of exorcism was renewed, the demon Jacob made his appearance with a healthy, manly voice.
- 1:41:30Voiceover: As in the case of Judas, one could detect at once that he had been a human being
- 1:41:37Voiceover: Which Jacob are you?
- 1:41:39Voiceover: asked the Exorcist.
- 1:41:40Voiceover: It said
- 1:41:41Voiceover: ,
- 1:41:42Voiceover: The father of the possessed girl
- 1:41:44Jimmy Akin: So the book loot refers to the demon Jacob, even though Jacob was a human.
- 1:41:50Jimmy Akin: Now, as we heard in episode 413.
- 1:41:53Jimmy Akin: I think there are significant reasons to at least question whether this was a real case of possession, but that's not what
- 1:42:01Jimmy Akin: The issue is here.
- 1:42:03Jimmy Akin: I'm not evaluating whether the woman was really possessed.
- 1:42:06Jimmy Akin: I'm documenting the use of a term.
- 1:42:09Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:42:10Jimmy Akin: even though it was written in the 20th century, begone Satan uses the term demon
- 1:42:16Jimmy Akin: to refer to a human spirit.
- 1:42:18Jimmy Akin: It also
- 1:42:19Jimmy Akin: carries an imprimatur from the Bishop of St.
- 1:42:23Jimmy Akin: Cloud, Minnesota, granted in 1935.
- 1:42:26Jimmy Akin: So this is a pre-Vatican II imprimatur.
- 1:42:29Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:42:29Jimmy Akin: this
- 1:42:30Jimmy Akin: use of the term demon
- 1:42:32Jimmy Akin: was considered acceptable, and the pattern doesn't stop at Erling.
- 1:42:37Dom Bettinelli: Yeah, it also turns up in the case of Annalise Michel, the young German woman whose ordeal loosely inspired the film
- 1:42:44Dom Bettinelli: The Exorcism of Emily
- 1:42:46Dom Bettinelli: Rose.
- 1:42:46Dom Bettinelli: We'll do a future episode on that case, but what do we need to know for our present purposes?
- 1:42:52Jimmy Akin: In nineteen seventy-five and nineteen seventy-six, in the Bavarian town of Klingenberg
- 1:42:57Jimmy Akin: Two priests performed a long series of exorcisms on Annalisa Michelle.
- 1:43:02Jimmy Akin: They were Father Arnold Rentz and Father Ernst Alt.
- 1:43:07Jimmy Akin: Over those months, the spirits speaking through her gave their names, and there were six of them.
- 1:43:13Jimmy Akin: One was Lucifer, because you've always got to have a reference directly to the devil possessing someone
- 1:43:20Jimmy Akin: But the other five had
- 1:43:23Jimmy Akin: all once been living human beings.
- 1:43:25Jimmy Akin: They included Cain, Judas
- 1:43:27Jimmy Akin: Iscariot
- 1:43:28Jimmy Akin: the Emperor Nero, Adolf Hitler, and so and a disgraced parish priest named Valentin Fleischman.
- 1:43:35Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:43:37Jimmy Akin: Of the five, four of them are like the heaviest evil
- 1:43:41Jimmy Akin: hitters of all time of humanity.
- 1:43:43Jimmy Akin: And then there's this one priest.
- 1:43:45Dom Bettinelli: And so
- 1:43:46Dom Bettinelli: five of the six were human.
- 1:43:48Jimmy Akin: Yeah, and every one of them, human and angel alike, gets called a demon
- 1:43:54Jimmy Akin: in a booklet called The Exorcism of Annalisa Michelle.
- 1:43:57Jimmy Akin: Now, Father Alt
- 1:43:59Jimmy Akin: happened to be the pastor of Edelben, and
- 1:44:02Jimmy Akin: that's the very parish where the spirit that claimed to be Fleischmann had lived in the 16th century.
- 1:44:10Jimmy Akin: When the name surfaced during the exorcism, Father Alt went to his own parish archives and confirmed that a father
- 1:44:16Jimmy Akin: Fleischmann had been pastor there and had killed a man.
- 1:44:21Jimmy Akin: Father Alt
- 1:44:22Jimmy Akin: says.
- 1:44:23Voiceover: The sixth demon, by the name of Fleischman, announced himself, saying that he was the fallen priest of Edelben
- 1:44:30Voiceover: who had killed a man.
- 1:44:32Voiceover: He gave many details, none of which I had mentioned in her presence.
- 1:44:37Voiceover: Annelise was afraid of this particular demon
- 1:44:40Jimmy Akin: So the exorcist calls him, this human ghost, the sixth demon
- 1:44:47Jimmy Akin: by the name of Fleischmann.
- 1:44:49Jimmy Akin: There's also a Catholic booklet devoted to this case called Satan's Answers to the Exorcist, and that booklet regularly refers to these human souls as among the demons.
- 1:45:01Jimmy Akin: Its chapters are headed with things like
- 1:45:04Jimmy Akin: Judas speaks of himself and
- 1:45:07Jimmy Akin: the other
- 1:45:08Jimmy Akin: demons of hell.
- 1:45:09Jimmy Akin: And at one point, Lucifer says.
- 1:45:13Voiceover: In this century, there will be so many saints as never in the past.
- 1:45:17Voiceover: However, many also come down there with us, and people do not believe
- 1:45:23Voiceover: They all believe that all is well with them, and they provide every comfort for themselves.
- 1:45:29Voiceover: All of them are demons.
- 1:45:31Voiceover: If they knew
- 1:45:33Voiceover: But then, when they will realize it, it will be too late.
- 1:45:38Voiceover: Then, no one will ever come back.
- 1:45:41Jimmy Akin: So the booklet says that all of them are demons, meaning the damned who were once ordinary people.
- 1:45:49Jimmy Akin: So the booklet, like the book, refers to wicked humans as demons in the afterlife.
- 1:45:55Jimmy Akin: The Italian uh publisher of the booklet
- 1:45:58Jimmy Akin: refers to these entities as Uomini
- 1:46:01Jimmy Akin: Demoni, which would mean man
- 1:46:03Jimmy Akin: demons or human demons.
- 1:46:05Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:46:06Jimmy Akin: the usage of referring to evil human spirits
- 1:46:10Jimmy Akin: continues
- 1:46:11Jimmy Akin: in this setting.
- 1:46:12Jimmy Akin: As a result, even today
- 1:46:14Jimmy Akin: there are Catholic sources that use the term demon
- 1:46:17Jimmy Akin: more broadly than just for fallen
- 1:46:19Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 1:46:20Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:46:21Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, when we find out the word demon has meant all these different things, does that affect anything in our faith?
- 1:46:29Jimmy Akin: No, uh
- 1:46:30Jimmy Akin: nothing about what the church teaches about demons has changed.
- 1:46:33Jimmy Akin: There really are
- 1:46:35Jimmy Akin: fallen angels.
- 1:46:36Jimmy Akin: They really
- 1:46:37Jimmy Akin: are dangerous.
- 1:46:39Jimmy Akin: They really do
- 1:46:40Jimmy Akin: possess people, and they really do need to be fought and exercised.
- 1:46:45Jimmy Akin: What's different
- 1:46:46Jimmy Akin: isn't a matter of substance, but of terminology.
- 1:46:50Jimmy Akin: The term
- 1:46:51Jimmy Akin: demon
- 1:46:52Jimmy Akin: has been used to refer to more things than just the fallen
- 1:46:56Jimmy Akin: angels alone.
- 1:46:58Jimmy Akin: Words change their meaning over time, including theological words, and that happens constantly.
- 1:47:04Jimmy Akin: For example, the word saint
- 1:47:06Jimmy Akin: is used multiple ways in the Bible.
- 1:47:09Jimmy Akin: It got a new meaning referring to living Christians in the New Testament, and today it's often used for the souls of canonized saints in heaven
- 1:47:18Jimmy Akin: Charity
- 1:47:19Jimmy Akin: used to mean love itself, and now it often means giving money to the poor.
- 1:47:24Jimmy Akin: Hell used to simply mean the place of the dead.
- 1:47:27Jimmy Akin: It's where anybody who dead
- 1:47:28Jimmy Akin: who was dead went.
- 1:47:30Jimmy Akin: Which is why the Creed says Jesus descended into hell.
- 1:47:34Jimmy Akin: But today, in ordinary speech, hell means the place of the damned, which is why people get confused about what the creed is saying.
- 1:47:42Jimmy Akin: Even Angel
- 1:47:43Jimmy Akin: has shifted.
- 1:47:44Jimmy Akin: It originally just meant messenger, whether that messenger was human or not.
- 1:47:50Jimmy Akin: If it referred to non-human messengers, well, it referred to the lowest rank of the spiritual beings in the heavenly hierarchy, but it came to mean
- 1:48:00Jimmy Akin: any
- 1:48:02Jimmy Akin: superhuman, spiritual being except God himself.
- 1:48:04Jimmy Akin: It expanded up the hierarchy to everybody but God.
- 1:48:08Jimmy Akin: None of that's a problem.
- 1:48:10Jimmy Akin: We just need to recognize which sense a word is being used in when we read a text
- 1:48:15Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:48:16Jimmy Akin: when you're reading a church document today
- 1:48:18Jimmy Akin: and you encounter the word demon, it means a fallen
- 1:48:21Jimmy Akin: angel, and you need to take its teaching about fallen angels seriously.
- 1:48:26Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:48:27Jimmy Akin: if you're reading an older document, such as from the Bible or Second Temple literature, or a non-church
- 1:48:33Jimmy Akin: document today, like
- 1:48:35Jimmy Akin: begone
- 1:48:36Jimmy Akin: Satan or the works about Annalisa
- 1:48:38Jimmy Akin: Michelle
- 1:48:38Jimmy Akin: ,
- 1:48:39Jimmy Akin: it may
- 1:48:40Jimmy Akin: be being used in another sense.
- 1:48:42Dom Bettinelli: So Jimmy, what's your bottom line?
- 1:48:45Jimmy Akin: The word demon has a long history, and it's been used multiple ways over that history.
- 1:48:50Jimmy Akin: The Greek term was used to refer to gods, to intermediate beings between gods and men.
- 1:48:57Jimmy Akin: to ghosts of the golden
- 1:48:58Jimmy Akin: race, to ghosts of good men, and to the ghosts of ordinary men.
- 1:49:03Jimmy Akin: In Jewish circles it was used to refer to foreign gods,
- 1:49:07Jimmy Akin: to the hybrid offspring of angels and humans, to purely human
- 1:49:12Jimmy Akin: ghosts, and to spiritual beings that were created evil rather than falling
- 1:49:18Jimmy Akin: In
- 1:49:18Jimmy Akin: Christian circles, it was used to refer to foreign gods, to hybrid ghosts, to purely human ghosts, and after the time of Christ, we can show it was used to refer to fallen
- 1:49:30Jimmy Akin: angels.
- 1:49:30Jimmy Akin: That
- 1:49:31Jimmy Akin: last usage became the standard one in official church documents, so
- 1:49:36Jimmy Akin: that's how you need to understand them when you read them.
- 1:49:40Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:49:40Jimmy Akin: the term had other uses in history
- 1:49:43Jimmy Akin: and it continues to refer to things like wicked human spirits outside of church documents.
- 1:49:49Dom Bettinelli: And what further resources can we offer to the listeners and viewers?
- 1:49:53Jimmy Akin: We'll have links to the catechism, the passage we quoted from in this episode, also to the various Greek authors.
- 1:50:00Jimmy Akin: that we referred to, um
- 1:50:02Jimmy Akin: the Book of Enoch
- 1:50:04Jimmy Akin: and the different church fathers we talked to, as well as the catechesis that Father Gabriela Amorth
- 1:50:12Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:50:12Jimmy Akin: gave
- 1:50:13Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:50:13Jimmy Akin: he originally did it in italian
- 1:50:15Jimmy Akin: but on youtube
- 1:50:16Jimmy Akin: there seems to be an auto
- 1:50:18Jimmy Akin: translation into english
- 1:50:20Jimmy Akin: so you can actually listen to it in english if you want
- 1:50:25Spidermail bumper: Look out!
- 1:50:26Spidermail bumper: Here comes the spider
- 1:50:29Spidermail bumper: ghost
- 1:50:35Dom Bettinelli: Now we turn to our mysterious feedback
- 1:50:37Dom Bettinelli: brought to us by our feedback coordinator, Rob Leonardi, and this feedback comes from episode 431, are
- 1:50:44Dom Bettinelli: Auras
- 1:50:45Dom Bettinelli: Real?
- 1:50:45Dom Bettinelli: And our first feedback comes from Bridget
- 1:50:48Dom Bettinelli: on Patreon, who writes, So disappointed.
- 1:50:51Dom Bettinelli: Before this episode I didn't know anything about auras beyond the basics.
- 1:50:55Dom Bettinelli: Some people claim to see colors around others that reveal something about them.
- 1:50:59Dom Bettinelli: And it was hoping they would turn out to be ESP.
- 1:51:02Dom Bettinelli: Nope, they're too new of a phenomenon to be credible.
- 1:51:05Dom Bettinelli: Great episode as usual.
- 1:51:07Jimmy Akin: Well, I wouldn't rule out ESP just on the recency of the reports of this phenomenon.
- 1:51:15Jimmy Akin: What rules it out for me
- 1:51:18Jimmy Akin: as commonly understood
- 1:51:20Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:51:21Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:51:22Jimmy Akin: the fact that when you do the barrier tests and you put a person behind certain barriers
- 1:51:28Jimmy Akin: there
- 1:51:29Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:51:30Jimmy Akin: the aura perceivers
- 1:51:31Jimmy Akin: can't tell which barrier the person is standing behind.
- 1:51:35Jimmy Akin: They don't see their aura spilling out over the top of the barrier.
- 1:51:40Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:51:41Jimmy Akin: Or they don't do so better than chance.
- 1:51:44Jimmy Akin: So that's what rules out aura
- 1:51:46Jimmy Akin: perception
- 1:51:46Jimmy Akin: as commonly understood
- 1:51:48Jimmy Akin: for me, though I think there is likely a form of it in that
- 1:51:53Jimmy Akin: synesthesia.
- 1:51:54Dom Bettinelli: The next feedback comes from James the
- 1:51:57Dom Bettinelli: Ken
- 1:51:58Dom Bettinelli: on Spotify
- 1:51:59Dom Bettinelli: who writes, thank you, Jimmy and Dom, especially for making t episodes on topics like this.
- 1:52:04Dom Bettinelli: It makes it much easier to connect with people.
- 1:52:07Dom Bettinelli: Most people's interaction with Christianity in America is the it's always demons
- 1:52:11Dom Bettinelli: crowd
- 1:52:12Dom Bettinelli: I love that you show the Catholic faith isn't afraid to ask questions and explore everything God created in our universe with open minds, all while remembering Christ as Lord.
- 1:52:22Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:52:23Jimmy Akin: Christ is Lord, and I just love discovering the world that he made and all of its different aspects
- 1:52:30Dom Bettinelli: Ender Wiggin, 3638, writes on YouTube, I think it's plausible given electrical currents produce magnetic waves.
- 1:52:39Dom Bettinelli: Given we are a sack of mostly water, which has biochemical reactions and electropositions.
- 1:52:49Jimmy Akin: Just want to be clear on that.
- 1:52:50Dom Bettinelli: Okay.
- 1:52:51Dom Bettinelli: So uh given that we are ugly bags of mostly water, which is biochemical reactions and electrical signals going through our body
- 1:52:58Dom Bettinelli: It's possible there is an affected area around our body that is influenced by the energy within the body.
- 1:53:04Dom Bettinelli: Whether that's actually visible or not, and if there's a color to it, I don't know.
- 1:53:08Dom Bettinelli: I wouldn't call it a mystical aura the way these people think, but they would definitely have a normal field versus a difference when your body is stressed or diseased.
- 1:53:18Jimmy Akin: Well, and that's true.
- 1:53:19Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:53:20Jimmy Akin: we do produce an electrical field, and you could
- 1:53:23Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:53:23Jimmy Akin: map it onto a
- 1:53:25Jimmy Akin: color
- 1:53:26Jimmy Akin: a false
- 1:53:26Jimmy Akin: color display, you know, as
- 1:53:29Jimmy Akin: Scientists frequently do when they're mapping things that fall outside the visual range.
- 1:53:33Jimmy Akin: We just don't have any evidence of humans being able to detect this field.
- 1:53:39Dom Bettinelli: Jane Sager, 3049 on YouTube
- 1:53:41Dom Bettinelli: writes, I thought I was seeing auras, but all of them were the same color.
- 1:53:46Dom Bettinelli: I think it was the sensitivity to the intense fluorescent lighting of the classrooms
- 1:53:51Dom Bettinelli: I also began experiencing retinal migraines, which were a bit colorful.
- 1:53:56Jimmy Akin: Yeah, and that's something that
- 1:53:59Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:54:00Jimmy Akin: that uh people
- 1:54:01Jimmy Akin: who
- 1:54:01Jimmy Akin: experience migraines, even if they don't have pain,
- 1:54:05Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:54:06Jimmy Akin: can
- 1:54:06Jimmy Akin: experience.
- 1:54:07Jimmy Akin: I know of people who have had what are called migraine auras, which is uh
- 1:54:12Jimmy Akin: really it's an electrical impulse that expands across the visual center of the brain.
- 1:54:17Jimmy Akin: they'll
- 1:54:18Jimmy Akin: see it like in the it
- 1:54:19Jimmy Akin: 'll be a a kind of jaggedy
- 1:54:21Jimmy Akin: arch
- 1:54:22Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:54:23Jimmy Akin: arc that appears in the um
- 1:54:26Jimmy Akin: near the center of their vision and then over about 20 minutes it expands
- 1:54:30Jimmy Akin: and just
- 1:54:31Jimmy Akin: goes away.
- 1:54:33Jimmy Akin: And that's the
- 1:54:34Jimmy Akin: the electrical wave passing
- 1:54:36Jimmy Akin: over the
- 1:54:37Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:54:38Jimmy Akin: it's a result of the electrical wave passing over the visual center in the brain
- 1:54:42Jimmy Akin: And fortunately, uh
- 1:54:44Jimmy Akin: the people that I know that have had these
- 1:54:46Jimmy Akin: haven't had the
- 1:54:47Jimmy Akin: the painful form of migraines.
- 1:54:50Jimmy Akin: But um
- 1:54:51Jimmy Akin: but this that is a real phenomenon
- 1:54:54Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:54:55Jimmy Akin: I'm
- 1:54:56Jimmy Akin: I hope that
- 1:54:58Jimmy Akin: I hope that
- 1:54:59Jimmy Akin: yours
- 1:55:00Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:55:01Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:55:01Jimmy Akin: and it could be triggered by things like intense fluorescent light.
- 1:55:04Jimmy Akin: I hope that yours
- 1:55:06Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:55:07Jimmy Akin: haven't
- 1:55:08Jimmy Akin: resulted in pain.
- 1:55:09Jimmy Akin: That
- 1:55:10Jimmy Akin: you know, I appreciate the experience.
- 1:55:12Jimmy Akin: I just
- 1:55:13Jimmy Akin: I hope I hope you don't have to suffer.
- 1:55:16Jimmy Akin: from
- 1:55:16Jimmy Akin: migraine pain and if you have had to suffer, I hope they find an effective treatment.
- 1:55:22Dom Bettinelli: Then
- 1:55:22Dom Bettinelli: J.
- 1:55:23Dom Bettinelli: Oz
- 1:55:24Dom Bettinelli: on YouTube
- 1:55:24Dom Bettinelli: writes
- 1:55:25Dom Bettinelli: I'm not going in for this explanation at all, but in principle the discrepancy in color reporting could be the result of arbitrary pseudo-color choice, like we do with IR and UV imagery.
- 1:55:37Dom Bettinelli: Just as we choose to represent certain non-visible frequency bands with an arbitrary color, or perhaps a color that helps us use the imagery better for a particular case.
- 1:55:46Dom Bettinelli: It seems possible that a person seeing an aura
- 1:55:49Dom Bettinelli: could be consciously or unconsciously
- 1:55:51Dom Bettinelli: choosing to see certain bands of whatever the aura spectrum is
- 1:55:55Dom Bettinelli: as particular visible colors.
- 1:55:57Jimmy Akin: Well, if aura
- 1:55:59Jimmy Akin: perception
- 1:56:00Jimmy Akin: in the parapsychological sense were real, I would assume that is what's happening.
- 1:56:05Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:56:07Jimmy Akin: I just don't have any evidence that
- 1:56:10Jimmy Akin: classic aura
- 1:56:12Jimmy Akin: perception
- 1:56:13Jimmy Akin: occurs.
- 1:56:14Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:56:15Jimmy Akin: but if it were occurring, I would assume it's an it's a subconsciously chosen selection of false color imagery
- 1:56:23Jimmy Akin: representing what the person's perceiving.
- 1:56:25Jimmy Akin: And I assume that is what's happening in synesthetic aura perception
- 1:56:30Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:56:31Jimmy Akin: Subconsciously the person is picking up on clues and interpreting those clues
- 1:56:36Jimmy Akin: in terms of certain images
- 1:56:39Jimmy Akin: ,
- 1:56:40Jimmy Akin: just
- 1:56:40Jimmy Akin: like other forms of synesthesia.
- 1:56:43Dom Bettinelli: Very good.
- 1:56:44Dom Bettinelli: And that's all our feedback.
- 1:56:45Dom Bettinelli: And I want to thank everyone for your feedback.
- 1:56:48Dom Bettinelli: And now it's time to hear from you.
- 1:56:50Dom Bettinelli: What are your theories about what a demon is?
- 1:56:53Dom Bettinelli: Let us know by visiting sqpn.
- 1:56:55Dom Bettinelli: com or the Jimmy Akin's
- 1:56:57Dom Bettinelli: Mysterious World Facebook page, sending us an email to feedback at mysterious.
- 1:57:02Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 1:57:03Dom Bettinelli: Sending a tweet to at
- 1:57:04Dom Bettinelli: MYS underscore world, visiting the StarQuest
- 1:57:08Dom Bettinelli: Discord community at sqpn.
- 1:57:10Dom Bettinelli: com slash Discord
- 1:57:12Dom Bettinelli: Or calling our mysterious feedback line at 619-738-4515.
- 1:57:17Dom Bettinelli: That's 619-738-4515.
- 1:57:22Jimmy Akin: And thanks to Oasis
- 1:57:24Jimmy Akin: Studio 7 for the video and animation work on the episode, check it out by going to my YouTube
- 1:57:29Jimmy Akin: channel
- 1:57:30Jimmy Akin: youtube.
- 1:57:31Jimmy Akin: com slash Jimmy
- 1:57:32Jimmy Akin: Akin.
- 1:57:33Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:57:34Jimmy Akin: I need your help in fighting the algorithm
- 1:57:37Jimmy Akin: because the algorithm is
- 1:57:39Jimmy Akin: many people tell me they don't think the algorithm is showing enough people the all the quality work on the videos we do.
- 1:57:47Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:57:47Jimmy Akin: I've had lots of people say they can't believe how few
- 1:57:51Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:57:52Jimmy Akin: views my videos have compared to the quality when
- 1:57:55Jimmy Akin: other people's videos that are
- 1:57:58Jimmy Akin: much less in quality, have much higher views.
- 1:58:01Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:58:01Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:58:02Jimmy Akin: please uh
- 1:58:03Jimmy Akin: help me in the cause of fighting the algorithm and delivering quality content to people.
- 1:58:09Jimmy Akin: You can do that by liking, commenting.
- 1:58:12Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:58:12Jimmy Akin: writing reviews, sharing the podcast with others, hyping
- 1:58:16Jimmy Akin: it and subscribing.
- 1:58:17Jimmy Akin: And when you subscribe, tell the bell notification that it will
- 1:58:23Jimmy Akin: be tormented by demons, however they're interpreted.
- 1:58:26Jimmy Akin: unless it agrees to notify you every time I post a new video.
- 1:58:33Dom Bettinelli: And I'd like to thank Craig Hart for his voiceover work in today's episode.
- 1:58:38Jimmy Akin: Next week we're going to be looking at a letter written by former Pope Benedict, and we're going to be looking at controversial things he said
- 1:58:47Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:58:48Jimmy Akin: Adam.
- 1:58:49Jimmy Akin: original sin
- 1:58:51Jimmy Akin: and aliens
- 1:58:53Jimmy Akin: things that will make some folks
- 1:58:56Jimmy Akin: very
- 1:58:56Jimmy Akin: angry
- 1:58:58Dom Bettinelli: Folks should
- 1:58:59Dom Bettinelli: be sure to share the podcast with your friends
- 1:59:00Dom Bettinelli: and write a review in Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcast from to help us
- 1:59:05Dom Bettinelli: Grow our community and reach more listeners.
- 1:59:07Dom Bettinelli: Check out our new designs for Mysterious World t-shirts, mugs, and more in our merchandise shop at sqpn.
- 1:59:14Dom Bettinelli: com slash merch.
- 1:59:15Dom Bettinelli: You'll find links to Jimmy's resources from our discussion on our show notes at mysterious.
- 1:59:20Dom Bettinelli: fm slash
- 1:59:21Dom Bettinelli: four four
- 1:59:21Dom Bettinelli: two.
- 1:59:22Dom Bettinelli: And remember to help us continue to produce the podcast, please visit givemysterious.
- 1:59:28Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 1:59:30Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin
- 1:59:31Dom Bettinelli: 's Mysterious World is also brought to you in part by Rosary Army, featuring award-winning Catholic podcasts, Rosary Resources, Videos.
- 1:59:40Dom Bettinelli: And the School of
- 1:59:41Dom Bettinelli: Mary online
- 1:59:42Dom Bettinelli: community prayer
- 1:59:43Dom Bettinelli: and learning platform.
- 1:59:44Dom Bettinelli: Learn how to make them, pray them, and give them away while growing in your faith at rosaryarmy.
- 1:59:50Dom Bettinelli: com and schoolofmary.
- 1:59:52Dom Bettinelli: com.
- 1:59:53Dom Bettinelli: A special feature this month from our sponsor, the Grady
- 1:59:56Dom Bettinelli: Group, who wants to share with you some music from Petersbark, Catholic Music for the Curious.
- 2:00:02Dom Bettinelli: Here's
- 2:00:02Dom Bettinelli: Ancient Scandal
- 2:00:04Spidermail bumper: Body and blood under
- 2:00:06Spidermail bumper: bread and wine
- 2:00:09Peter's Barque: More than symbol, more than
- 2:00:11Peter's Barque: sign, not
- 2:00:12Peter's Barque: torn
- 2:00:13Peter's Barque: flesh laid upon a plate, but the living
- 2:00:17Peter's Barque: Christ in sacramental
- 2:00:19Peter's Barque: stay, an ancient scandal, holy feast given by the Prince of Peace.
- 2:00:25Peter's Barque: And when the crowd said
- 2:00:26Peter's Barque: this is hard, he did
- 2:00:27Peter's Barque: not say
- 2:00:30Peter's Barque: they
- 2:00:30Peter's Barque: 've gone too far.
- 2:00:32Peter's Barque: You've lost the plot, but you're closer than not.
- 2:00:35Peter's Barque: This is his
- 2:00:36Peter's Barque: flesh, but it's not how you thought.
- 2:00:39Peter's Barque: Because when
- 2:00:40Peter's Barque: the word
- 2:00:40Peter's Barque: be
- 2:00:41Dom Bettinelli: Petersbark, streaming everywhere.
- 2:00:44Dom Bettinelli: Find more at mysterious.
- 2:00:46Dom Bettinelli: fm slash
- 2:00:47Dom Bettinelli: music.
- 2:00:50Dom Bettinelli: Until next time, Jimmy Akin, thank you for exploring with us our mysterious world.
- 2:00:55Jimmy Akin: Thanks, Dom.
- 2:00:56Dom Bettinelli: And once again, I'm Dom Bettinelli.
- 2:00:58Dom Bettinelli: Thank you for listening to Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World on StarQu.