Latest / Deconstructing Horror / Trick 'r Treat (2007): The Ultimate Love Letter to Halloween
Transcript
- Ryan Does: Everyone on this episode of Deconstructing Horror, we are going to be getting in the Halloween spirit with the film Trick or Treat. This was a film I was just introduced to By our guest, and I am I'm a ready to be an evangelist for this movie.Anywhere I go, everywhere I go, even not in October. I'm ready to talk about this movie. So it is my privilege and my honor and my pleasure to introduce Josh Link, who introduced this movie to me. Josh, how were you introduced to Trick or Treat? Josh Link: well, first off, thanks for having me. Really appreciate it. But I Ryan Does: I could not have done a project like this without you being a part of it at some point and I'm sorry that it took this long to get here. Josh Link: no, no worries. No, I'm happy to be here. Yeah, so Trick or Treat now you said two thousand nine. What others may Ryan Does: Right. Josh Link: say is two thousand seven. And the reason is Ryan Does: Correct. Josh Link: because in the early days of the way I would follow internet stories when it comes to like horror movies and things that are on the horizon. This was pre-Twitter, pre-social media, so not something that you had, but I was aware of a movie that was made by Michael Doherty. Who had written X-Men 2. So I knew him from that. Ryan Does: Right. Josh Link: and he had apparently directed this Halloween anthology film that had a lot of the cast from X-Men 2 in it, that screened at some film festivals in 2007 and people were going crazy over it. Like, Ryan Does: Yeah. Josh Link: one of the best horror anthologies we've seen in years, like the best since creep show, stuff like that. And then it just sat on a shelf for two years because no distributor thought it was worth. picking up. And so it wasn't until 2009. So I was aware of this for two years, waiting Ryan Does: Okay. Josh Link: for it to come out. And finally in 2009, I think it was a legendary, picked it up, put it out, and just direct to DVD. Didn't even get a theatrical release at all. And it immediately became the cult classic that everyone knew it was going to be. Because anybody who was Ryan Does: Right. Josh Link: a horror fan was like champing at the bit to get their hands on this thing. So of course as soon as it came out, I I bought a copy. I didn't even rent or anything, just went out and bought a DVD of it. watched it like that night, was like this is everything I hoped it could be. I love this so much and I've been watching it every Halloween since. Ryan Does: I so I has is the t shirt just as old as your as your copy? Josh Link: No, no. The t shirt's a little more a little more recent. but w Ryan Does: Yeah, I gotta get Josh Link: within the last like five, six years, probably something like that. But yeah. Ryan Does: Well, I I'm excited to dig into like Michael Doherty's like vision for this because I know like it's basically a love letter to the holiday. Josh Link: Yes. Ryan Does: and we kind of I I I wanted to put this discussion together with Josh because Josh is a massive Halloween fan. He's a massive horror movie fan. And we'll put links for your substack in the episode description, Josh, because I want people to go check out your fantastic writing. Josh is also a really great writer. So you should just check it out if you're a fan of, people putting together coherent, passionate sentences. but Josh Link: You're too kind. Ryan Does: it's and and I honestly I've been introduced to a few different horror movies and horror franchises just by following your sub stack. So I I'm I'm just excited for other people to to come across that. I I want to give a little bit of a breakdown of Trick or Treat, and we will figure out where we're where we're starting out what the foundation is and then I hope that our conversation from there will in and of itself be a love letter to Halloween as this will be coming out just a few days before the holiday. So Josh Link: Perfect. Ryan Does: here we go. Is based on, like Josh said, a Michael Daugherty story, an animated short that he did called Seasons Greetings, which is much, much older. did it in the mid-90s. This is directed by Michael Daugherty and it stars Dylan Baker, Anna Packwin. Brian Cox and Rochelle Aids, just to name a few the cast members there. It was released on October 6, 2009. Whatever that means in the grand timeline of this movie coming into people's hands, I'm sure Josh can explain and make sense of that. The budget was twelve million dollars and through DVD releases, rentals, blu-rays, it did make back its budget, but I think Josh hit on a really important point. With this movie specifically, the box office and the money that it made back doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of how the life that this movie has taken on beyond it being released. And the cult status that it inherited a lot after it was finally released, but a little bit before, too, because it had such a weird production story. the plot of this movie, the Plot of the overall film will say that. because the it contains it contains multitudes. the this anthology film weaves together non-linear interconnected horror stories taking place on Halloween night in the same small town. So this is it's the same setting, but all these stories are happening somewhat independent of each other. This is in the town of Warren Valley, Ohio, a fictional town in a sadly not fictional state. Josh calls home. The the narratives follow Josh Link: Yes. The great Buckeye State. Ryan Does: I'm still sore about the Iowa Ohio State game. Josh Link: Ha ha. Ryan Does: the narratives follow various different residents, including a murderous school principal, a young whoop a young woman looking to enjoy her first time, a group of cruel pranksters, and a grumpy hermit played to perfection by Brian Cox. They Cross each other's paths, but there's one constant in these stories, and that is Sam, a mysterious, sack-headed, tr seeming child, trick-or-treater, who interacts with all of them to varying degrees, especially the culmination with Brian Cox. he is there to enforce the traditions of the holiday. So, Josh, to start off our conversation, since we are just a matter of days away from Halloween. It is one of the most important nights of the year for adults and kids where they're willing to follow some unwritten rules. And a lot of this movie is is following the rules of Halloween. They wear costumes, there's certain times you can, you know, actually l un take out the light in your jack-o'-lantern. How do you think this movie captures that specific thrill of participating in this scared, spooky atmosphere? as all these things do take place in the same town with a lot of the same people. Josh Link: Yeah, y you said the unwritten rules of the holiday. What this kinda does is turn them into written rules. it it codifies Ryan Does: Right. Josh Link: the the rules of Halloween and how you're supposed to behave on that night. Not so much in terms of like going back to the pagan roots of the holiday or anything like that, but more like in Midwest small town America, this is what you're supposed to be doing. You're supposed to be trick-or-treating. You keep your jack-o' lanterns lit all night. You don't blow them out until the night is over. you you you enforce the spirit of the holiday throughout the holiday and you don't you know stray from that path until the holiday is over. Ryan Does: You and I are both Midwest kids, and I think we we have said this before that the Midwest is by far the b small town Midwest is the best setting for a horror movie. Cause like so many things can happen and you there's so much possibility there. Doherty kind of does this movie as like an homage to I mean, n not just kind of the obvious like Halloween, the nineteen seventy eight film, but to John Carpenter movies. And so like he he infuses Hall this Halloween atmosphere with a lot of different carpenter elements. What about the spirit of Halloween and the spirit of these rules kind of jumped out to you when you're watching it and you're like, you know what? That is mmm, that is perfect Halloween right there. That captures the spirit of Halloween. Josh Link: Yeah. Yeah. My favorite is the recurring motif of keeping your jack lantern lit. that's important in multiple different of these anthology stories. and beyond that, it's also like, you know, check your candy. Don't don't be smashing pumpkins, for example, like one kid does that and it goes very poorly for him. yeah, it's just like don't be cruel to people. while celebrating the holiday. it's trick or treat, but keep it fun. And if you're gonna be cruel or even murderous in one instance, it's gonna come back to bite ya, quite literally. Ryan Does: Quite yes. so Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: that kind of brings me to the to to the gosh. I couldn't even decide my answer to this question. So I'm I'm just kind of stumbling over this. We kind of have four storylines here. Five if you kind of count Sam's journey through the night as a as a runner. Which one of the stories is your favorite and why does it resonate with you? Personally and why is that the thing where it's like Halloween is this story the most to me? Josh Link: Man, it's really, really hard for me to pick a favorite, as you might imagine, Ryan Does: It is it is very different. Josh Link: because these are all really, really good. and they have great twists throughout. Yeah. Ryan Does: That's why I'm asking you first while I have time to come up with that. Josh Link: But I I was torn between the Anna Paquin story and the Ryan Does: Yeah. Josh Link: Pranksters. those are my two favorites, I would say. And I think I'm gonna go with the Pranksters because Ryan Does: Okay. Josh Link: it's I think the scariest of them. they're all very fun stories, but the Pranksters is a little bit unnerving in a way that the rest aren't, because it involves special needs kids being murdered, which is really horrific. of all the things Ryan Does: Yes. Josh Link: that happened in this movie, that's the darkest thing by far. And then basically seeing their their vengeance be wrought upon, some prankster kids, and maybe someone else e too. So it it's just it it just really is creepy. And great use of like fog and like the the the river or the lake, whatever it is that the the bank it's on and the school bus and just everything about it just kinda oozes that like creepy Halloween feeling to me. Ryan Does: So, listener, viewer, Josh has recommended many different movies to me throughout the times time that we've known each other. And this was one of those movies where I I I Josh is one of those friends where I kind of implicitly trust his taste because I I don't know, I feel like we're on a similar wavelength. But in the flashback scene where the bus driver's going around making sure that the chains are locked on the on these on these special needs students, I was like, my. God, what am I about to watch? Because I already watched a rather tubby kid get razor bladed in the throat and start puking up chocolate and blood. That was like the moment in the beginning of the movie where I was like, okay, this is gonna be kind of nuts. But that flashback with the bus, I was like, no, am I gonna be really sad at the end of this movie? Like, is this gonna be like traumatizing to me? But that that whole storyline. It leads to one of my favorite Carpenter homages in the entire movie where it basically becomes a like five ten minute episode of the fog. Like whittled down into one scene. And I was like, my gosh, this is Carpenter's the Fog so hard right now. Josh Link: Yeah. Yeah, it's so well executed. Like it it's it's like genuinely thrilling. I like it like it we we've talked about this as a very fun movie, but man, but that is a really creepy sequence. where like you already know they're not afraid to kill kids in this movie, which Ryan Does: No. Josh Link: a lot of time that that's you know like the third rail, you don't touch it, but no, that that is not a problem here. They are going to kill those kids. Ryan Does: Yeah. And and I I you mentioned the Anna Pacquin story. I think that would be mine. N it it like the the the principle it Dylan Baker's character is so like it's kinda like if you took if you took Patrick Bateman less serious. Like he's kinda like he's he's Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: American psycho who was like American principle goes crazy. Like that kind of Josh Link: Yeah, if he's nerdier. Ryan Does: The irony, yeah, the irony of that story is so funny. And it leads to the culmination of the Anna Packwin story. And I I I will admit the twist ending of this story was spoiled for me. But Josh Link: that's a bummer. Ryan Does: but Josh, I didn't care. It got so good. And I love I love the double entendre of, you know, like, it's my first time, so bear with me. And I was like, Josh Link: Ha ha ha. Ryan Does: my gosh. This werewolf design is so cool. I I I liked I liked the design of the werewolves right before they fully transformed because it reminded Josh Link: Yes, yes. Ryan Does: me of another of probably a top three werewolf movie for me, Ginger Snaps. Josh Link: No, great movie. Ryan Does: And the design was like, it was so creepy. It was like also full of transparency. I'm gonna overshare here. It was maybe the only time I was physically attracted to Anna Pacquin. Which is alarming to me. That she's about to rip this guy's throat out, and I'm like, my gosh. I d I need to reconcile that feeling later. But Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: but the werewolf story was so, so good. and well executed if you didn't know the ending of it, like it even better. Because you kinda think like, Is she a vampire? Like but then you're like, She's wearing little red riding hood's cape the entire time. Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: So once you see it, you can't unsee it. And there's and Brian Cox's story. Like and Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: it interweaves with the other one as they all kind of interweave with each other. I should have said this. Anna Paquin ends up her first time, ends up being the murderous principal, and she kills him. and that Dylan Baker gives a great performance in that reveal scene. is not menacing Josh Link: He's great. He's great in this movie. Ryan Does: at all anymore. but the Josh, speak to the the Brian Cox the the end cap of this. There is he is so good in such a limited amount of time. And he's a great actor anyway. Like, but what did you think Josh Link: Yeah, yeah. Yes, yes. Ryan Does: about him and being the the the the end segment? Josh Link: Yeah. Yeah, he's great. So he's he's like the the Scrooge, the Ebenezer Scrooge of this movie where he does not like the holiday of Halloween. He like at one point he like takes the bite of a c like candy bar and he like spits it out. He's like grossed out by it. I'm like, man, this guy doesn't even like chocolate. Like what's going on? Just hates it Ryan Does: Yeah. What's wrong with you, dude? Josh Link: all. he's the principal's neighbor, which is also very funny. So you get to see some his interactions with him. He's just kind of a dick all the time. Like it's it's yeah. Ryan Does: Wilkins, you're burying dead bodies over there? Josh Link: So good. So good. And since he is the one that's like the most like outspoken in his hatred of the holiday, Sam, our little mascot, takes a special interest in him. and really terrorizes him in the last segment, which is really, really well done. Like it it kind of feels almost like a slasher movie in that that sequence where it's like Ryan Does: Yeah. Josh Link: he's stalking them in the house and creepy things keep happening and great use of a jack-o'lantern in that as well. Just really well done. And there's a great unmasking of Sam during that sequence that is fantastic. Where if you didn't know going in what you were getting, it's it's quite the shock when you do see it. Ryan Does: They so when they unveil his when they the sack is taken off of his head. I kind of had a flashback back to Halloween three. And if if the if Josh Link: yeah, yeah, I could see that. Ryan Does: the kid if the kid in the like room had gotten up like, my gosh, you're Sam Josh Link: Ha ha ha. Ryan Does: from Trick or Treat anyway, if you haven't seen Halloween three season of the Witch, you should go see it. there is a gnarly, like melting face scene. But Sam looks like that. Speaking of Sam, he's not a traditional slasher. he's I wouldn't even say he's he's not a slasher. but he has di he has elements of it. Like he's masked and he has a sharp weapon with the lollipop. But he's not he's punishing people who break the rules of Halloween, so he goes after Krieg as the buzzkill. D where why do you think fans of both Halloween the Holiday and then of this movie gravitated to Sam. he he's a weird character, but like you said mascot earlier. And Darty Josh Link: Yes. Ryan Does: in kind of my research for this chat, Darty had thought like, hey, there's not a mascot for Halloween. Like Christmas has Santa. And you know, like Halloween doesn't really have anybody. So Sam is kind of an attempt at that, I guess. Josh Link: Yeah, yeah. I i that that's exactly right. I think there's a few things that make him so likable. One is that he's a little kid. well, he appears to be a little kid. So he's got this cute factor to him, even though he's what he's doing is very creepy. Ryan Does: Right. He's tiny. Josh Link: yeah, little guy. the costume itself is great. Like the burlap sack over the head and like the little like PJ onesie kind of thing that he's wearing, very fun. Ryan Does: Yeah, be yeah. Josh Link: his weapon of choice, which is like a Jack-O-Lan and lollipop that he bites and turns into a razor weapon, which is very fun, very creative. just stuff like that is just so fun. So just visually he's a really fun character. And he doesn't speak, so like you can kind of project whatever you want onto him, much like a lot of the great slasher villains as well. So he's just like a perfect little representation of the Holland. Ryan Does: I I I think, along those lines, him having elements of of slasher pieces, you know, like he is just like he's kind of everything like ice all the like slasher villains kinda like take the ticks piece here, ticks piece here, and he kinda has a little bit of a Chucky vibe, like if Chucky was Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: nonverbal, where the he's creepy because he's small and then like when Krieg and he start fighting, when Brian Cox goes ham on this kid. For a brief second I was like, I how is this a fair fight? And then you realize Sam also doesn't fight fair. so I I l but I I love Sam as this like attempt at a mascot to encapsulate the spirit of Halloween. do you think now, like with you know, the film being out having been out for almost two decades now, like is Sam more associated with the holiday? And probably not, you know, we're not talking Santa and Christmas level, but Is Sam more prevalent now with holiday? Josh Link: Yeah, so I go to horror conventions. I actually just got back from one y Sunday, so down in Ryan Does: Awesome. Josh Link: Kentucky. So every horror convention I've ever attended, and most of the comic conventions I've attended, there's always one kid dressed as Sam at least. Every single time. Cause he like it's it's like if parents Ryan Does: Yeah. Josh Link: are gonna bring their kid to a convention, the perfect costume is Sam. So I see Sam costumes everywhere. I see Sam tattoos on people. all the time at these conventions. he is beloved by horror fans. And he really has become like the mascot for Halloween for a lot of these people, myself included. Ryan Does: Yeah. Yeah. And and and like like we said, there's literally a movie called Halloween that is, ubiquitous with, the horror community. But it it's not so much about the holiday, it's it takes place on Halloween. Whereas Trickle Tree is this love letter to the spirit of Halloween. So Josh Link: Yes. Ryan Does: I I just my my last thing for for you, Josh, and then I Would love to know if you have anything else The the spirit of Halloween in this movie is so evident. And some people might think like, you know, this it's a movie where like kids get killed and you know there's revenge if you break the unwritten rules of Halloween. How could this encapsulate the spirit of Halloween? Now, don't get me wrong, I love other movies because of how they interpret the spirit of Halloween, like The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown is j Josh Link: Yeah. Ryan Does: right up there. Like that but that that's a very different thing. Why why does this movie, for all of its transgressions and all of its, you know, bloody, gross, dark humor takes on things, why does this movie for you encapsulate the spirit of Halloween? Josh Link: I and I you kinda hit it right there with the dark humor Ryan Does: Okay. Josh Link: aspect of it. Because that is really what it is, where even though these are really dark things that are happening, they're done with a orneriness to them, this glee about how silly it is at the same time. And like it feels like we're all in on the joke. Like it Ryan Does: Okay. Josh Link: it it's it's treating the audience like, you love this stuff, you love Halloween and horror movies. Ryan Does: Yeah. You sick animals. Josh Link: You've been watching this since you were too young to be watching this. you get it. You love this. And that's exactly what it is. Where it's like, yeah, this is just fun. It's all the things that you love about an R-rated horror film that maybe is aimed at a younger audience than it should be, but we all know it's really aimed at this younger audience, right? we we get Ryan Does: Yeah. Josh Link: it. So we're all in on the joke that Michael Doherty is kind of handing us. And and Ryan Does: Yeah. Josh Link: so are all the actors too. Like everybody's performance is so good in this where like they're hamming it up just just enough. Where it's like a little bit unrealistic but in a way that's very fun and easy to to watch. Ryan Does: They're dialing it up to like where where it should be, but then they're going like one dial further. And Josh Link: Yeah, yeah. Ryan Does: so I I I I love it. I love it for for all of that. Josh, before we call call this one quits and we go out and celebrate Halloween ourselves, is there anything missing from this conversation or something we started talking about that you want to wrap wrap up? Okay. Josh Link: One thing, one thing. And it is so I have you only seen it the one time so far? Ryan Does: So I am planning my second watch for either either the night we are recording this or Halloween night. Josh Link: Excellent. Okay, so the more you watch it, the more you'll catch all the little Easter eggs that Ryan Does: Laps. Josh Link: are peppered throughout. But there's one thing in particular that people usually miss, and the only reason I knew about it is because I the DVD had the director's commentary on her didn't tell me exactly Ryan Does: Correct. Josh Link: what it was but back when they did this in in movies. the opening sequence, there's an homage to Halloween, where the woman is like taking down the decorations and there's a creepy guy across the street with the mask on that's like wild. Blank white mask, kinda like Michael Myers, right? And she is thinking that this person might be up to no good. And it turns out it's just just some kid that's waiting to be picked up by his friends. But she's zeroed in on it, and so are we, the audience. If you look, while this is happening, all the zombie kids from the end of the movie are walking down the sidewalk. Ryan Does: No. Josh Link: But no one's looking at them because we're all looking at the guy in the mask. So if you watch that scene. They're there heading over to Krieg's house to kill him. Ryan Does: then canonically that happens be Josh Link: Yeah, so it's all right there. and there's other instances of different characters crossing paths with other characters from different stories, but that one is the one that's like a real hidden treat that is so, so satisfying once you see it. 'Cause it's really playing Ryan Does: Project. Josh Link: the Misterette game with that guy in the mask, just like it's distracting the main character in that scene, is also distracting us as viewers, which is very, very clever. Ryan Does: I love shit like that. I have heard also a rumor that like that there's a sequel is coming out, but I'm sure that's not been a new rumor. Josh Link: That's been a rumor since about two thousand nine. It's been forever and it just yeah, I just don't believe it's happening at this point. I know. I know, like it's so frustrating. Ryan Does: It feels like found money. just just do it. it's a a a a holiday like trick or treat or a holiday like Halloween that has so many different traditions and urban legends and all of that. How could you not come up with four Josh Link: I know. Ryan Does: or five other stories just to at least get Sam back on the screen? but Josh Link: Yeah, it's a bomber. Ryan Does: Man, but it's a fantastic film and we will include links for Josh's substack in the episode description. and we will we will tarry no longer because there is fantastic fun to be had on Halloween. so as we head out here I'm gonna remind you that the horrors may persist, but so can we.