Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Parasocials!
Transcript
- 0:02The sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:10Hello and welcome to My sister's a therapist.
- 0:13My name is Virginia Jones, and my sister's a therapist.
- 0:16Hello, I'm Laura Ryan, licensed marriage and family therapist,
- 0:19and my sister Virginia Jones is a stand up comedian.
- 0:22Welcome to our podcast where we talk about brain stuff, mental
- 0:27health stuff, comedy stuff. Those are the main things we
- 0:31talked about in TikTok. So, Virginia, what are we
- 0:33talking about today? This is a listener suggestion,
- 0:36so thank you listener Steve M. Thanks, Steve.
- 0:40Anyone who does have suggestions or questions can always write us
- 0:44at hello at my sister's a therapist and we could use them
- 0:48and you could be famous like. Steve, another way to get famous
- 0:51is to write us a review on Apple Podcasts and at the end of every
- 0:56episode I will read it. She chooses the very best ones,
- 0:59so write a really good one. We don't read the crummy ones.
- 1:03No, we do not. So today our topic is parasocial
- 1:07relationships. Oh, that's cool.
- 1:09It's A1 sided connection where you imagine a personal bond with
- 1:13someone you don't know. Can be a celebrity, fictional
- 1:17character, or most commonly, social media influencer.
- 1:21Like my relationship with Trevor Noah.
- 1:23Yes, you're a very hot and heavy love relationship with Trevor
- 1:26Noah. My relationship with the
- 1:29fictional character Wolverine, although he's fast being
- 1:32replaced by Loki. But is this fictional?
- 1:35Is this not real? You don't think there's an
- 1:37exchange of some kind? In these relationships, one
- 1:40person may develop feelings of closeness and familiarity with
- 1:44the other person even though they have never met.
- 1:46I think this is a huge word right now.
- 1:48I first heard it in like maybe 20, 15 or something.
- 1:53What is your familiarity with the concept of parasocial
- 1:56relationships? Well, I can give you a perfect
- 1:58example of some parasocial relationships that I had.
- 2:03My sister Emily and I snuck into a Saturday Night Live after
- 2:07party. With the help of the strokes.
- 2:10Thank you, Stroke. That's right.
- 2:12The help of The Strokes. It was great.
- 2:14So let me paint a picture. Jack Black was the guest and The
- 2:18Strokes were the band. And at that time, my sister and
- 2:21I really only had two interests in life.
- 2:23We snuck in, but basically Emily said if we don't go to this show
- 2:28or go to New York and do this, I basically can't speak to you
- 2:31anymore. So I thought, all right, so
- 2:33anyway, we snuck into the party and I look around and I see all
- 2:38of these familiar faces. I see Will Ferrell, I see Chris
- 2:41Kattan, I see basically a who's who, a bevy right of people of.
- 2:48Popular performers of the time, I saw.
- 2:50Jimmy Fallon. And he was alone.
- 2:54So I cornered him and I said, hey, I saw you last night on a
- 2:58rerun, and it was this sketch that you did about where you
- 3:02were being Harry Connick Junior. And he said, oh, that's so cool.
- 3:04That was the first sketch I ever wrote.
- 3:06And that's adorable. It was adorable.
- 3:08And then he immediately turned his in and wouldn't talk to
- 3:14someone that. Knew, but I've had my
- 3:16interaction with you. I think I should talk to another
- 3:18famous person, another IP. Right.
- 3:20So basically I cornered a few people and what I realized after
- 3:23a few minutes is this is like going to an office party for
- 3:27business that's been around for a long time.
- 3:29These people all know each other extremely well and I'm just some
- 3:32rando. It's like being the spouse of
- 3:34someone who works at the office. Not even the spouse.
- 3:37I'm somebody's second cousin who was in town for the weekend.
- 3:39Like nobody wants to talk to us. No one is interested.
- 3:43Obviously Jack Black talked to me because we don't have a
- 3:46parasocial relationship. He and I are best friends.
- 3:49For the listener, Laura and Emily had spent a long time
- 3:53going to every Tenacious D show they could and getting backstage
- 3:57as often as they could, so she and Jack Black had a very real,
- 4:02somewhat creepy friendship. I don't think he enjoyed it, but
- 4:05he did recognize us. And as my mother said at the
- 4:09Paris airport when we ran into my daughters are rounded fans.
- 4:14Rounded, rounded. One of my most, most humiliating
- 4:18moments, I thought I didn't realize in my late 20s that my
- 4:21mother could still humiliate me. But you know what?
- 4:23My hat's off to her. I think that's something.
- 4:25That, we learn all the time, is that your mother can always
- 4:28humiliate you, unusually in front of Jack Black.
- 4:31Often that is my life example, you know.
- 4:34Will Ferrell waved at me and gave me a nice smile.
- 4:37He doesn't know me and I know a lot of things about him.
- 4:40So the term parasocial relationships was coined in 1956
- 4:44by two sociologists, Horton and Wall, and it was about
- 4:47television. It was about performers on
- 4:49television because more than any other time in history, this was
- 4:52a time when a lot of people could be exposed visually to a
- 4:56performer at the same time. But yeah, And probably people
- 5:00had the same feeling about radio celebrities before.
- 5:04Trevor Horn said video killed the radio star.
- 5:07Trevor Horn of Bugle, Spain. These sociologists said, you
- 5:09know, part of The thing is that television hosts are kind of
- 5:13fostering this relationship. They are.
- 5:15They're engendering intimacy. They're fostering the illusion
- 5:18of intimacy makes us feel that the person is talking to us
- 5:21personally. That's part of the skill of
- 5:23being TV performer, but it also creates this false sense of
- 5:27knowing. Much like my relationship with
- 5:29the cast of my favorite podcast, Smartless.
- 5:33I think that in this time, my first big parasocial
- 5:36relationship that became almost a friendship with two guys on a
- 5:40radio show that I was listening to.
- 5:41Because when someone's voice is directly in your ears, it is
- 5:46hard to distinguish someone you know and don't know.
- 5:48You could be on the phone with a person, you could just be
- 5:50listening to a person talk. But I think podcast performers
- 5:53definitely foster parasocial relationships.
- 5:56Absolutely. Because I think, I think you're
- 5:58talking about your own personal stories in your own life.
- 6:01Sometimes a listener will message me about something that
- 6:04I said at random and I won't even remember it.
- 6:07You know, they just heard it. So.
- 6:08And this is something that I've experienced also in stand up.
- 6:11But Laura was sharing with me this week that she reached for a
- 6:15tried and true anecdote family story in a therapy session, and
- 6:21her client said, oh, I know this story because you said I'm
- 6:24fucking. Right, so I'm rapidly running
- 6:27out of anecdotes to say in my therapy office.
- 6:31Running out of fresh material. I think a big parasocial thing
- 6:34that I think we've always experienced is celebrity death.
- 6:38It's one of my least favorite things on Facebook, but I
- 6:40understand why it happened. When a celebrity dies,
- 6:44especially, you know, if it's sudden or they're very young,
- 6:46but that you had a particular bond with parasocial
- 6:49relationship with everybody kind of does this public grieving for
- 6:52a stranger. Matthew Perry was a recent one.
- 6:54I remember there was a big deal when also when David Bowie.
- 6:57Passed, right? I was going to say for cool
- 6:59people it was Bowie and print, but you know, regular Douglas
- 7:04got really upset. The basics.
- 7:06The basics you. Know, but because it's wild,
- 7:09because you don't know the person, but you've experienced
- 7:12joy from the person. You've seen them.
- 7:15You think you know what they are, who they are.
- 7:18And then when someone really important to you dies.
- 7:21I remember when Amy Winehouse died.
- 7:23I was in the Bahamas floating on a tube in the ocean, and
- 7:28somebody yelled it out. I found myself feeling violently
- 7:31angry. Amy Winehouse, it was so tragic
- 7:33because her whole career pointed at her cause of death, right?
- 7:38Like, it felt like the completion of a story that was
- 7:42just terrible about addiction and about needing help that no
- 7:46one would offer. So that one was very hard.
- 7:48I was actually really angry with her because I thought, my God,
- 7:52you were given this level of talent and you just trashed it
- 7:56because of your bulimia and drug addiction.
- 7:58But that's not a very sensitive take.
- 8:00And because. Your history of trauma and
- 8:02because of your messed up dad who was on a documentary saying
- 8:05you know a lot of performers can function with a certain amount
- 8:09of heroin. Right.
- 8:10The song Rehab was written because of her dad.
- 8:13If you're making money and you are an addict but people are
- 8:16making money off of you, no one's going to help you.
- 8:19Even, McGregor said later after he got sober.
- 8:21I was so drunk on so many movie set and nobody said anything to
- 8:25me and it's because he wasn't messing with the money.
- 8:28Well, he's, you're basically the golden goose, right?
- 8:30You don't want to upset the golden goose because he's going
- 8:33to keep giving you more eggs. When I went to go see the Amy
- 8:36Winehouse Dock 3/4 the movie, there's the footage of her being
- 8:39wheeled out on a Gurney. A woman in the audience said Oh
- 8:42my God. And I'm like, did you not know
- 8:44this is what happened? It was a spoiler alert moment in
- 8:47the middle of the movie theater. Hey, this person you knew a
- 8:50little bit about guess why she's not making records to warm.
- 8:53The next thing I wanted to talk about is like, so you mentioned
- 8:56familiarity. And this is particularly a
- 8:58problem on YouTube because Youtubers are more than any
- 9:02other kind of performer, encouraged to put their quote UN
- 9:05quote real life out there. And especially paired with the
- 9:08fact that a lot of Youtubers are very, very young people have
- 9:11very strong parasocial relationships and it causes a
- 9:13lot of stress and pressure. There was a young lady,
- 9:15Christina Grimmie, who actually was shot at a meet and greet by
- 9:19a fan who called her his soul mate because he had he had
- 9:22developed just an out of control parasocial bond with her.
- 9:25Some might call it an obsession. But, you know, we've had a lot
- 9:28of that Johnny Versace, John Lennon, celebrity Andy Warhol.
- 9:33I mean, I don't know if she was a fan.
- 9:36The girl from my sister Sam, It was an 80s TV show where this
- 9:40girl lived in an apartment with her brother.
- 9:43I think it was very early days. That's why it was so crazy,
- 9:45because she was like 18 years old.
- 9:47I think the show had only been on for a little bit and
- 9:50somebody, yeah, attacked her and ended her life.
- 9:53Now John Lennon's death. Later they found a list of
- 9:57celebrities that Mark David Chapman had drawn up because
- 10:00John Lennon might not have died, because Mark David Chapman
- 10:03particularly had a bond with him, but because he just wanted
- 10:06to kill the most famous person he could.
- 10:08He was on the list. But that affected the career of
- 10:12Mr. David Bowie, who was doing Elephant Man on the West End at
- 10:16the time, because Bowie was on the list.
- 10:18So he made a decision. In that moment, he was like, I
- 10:21can't do stage performances anymore.
- 10:24Like where I'm I'm doing a theater performance where I'm in
- 10:26the same place every night because I'm too exposed, like
- 10:28I'm too dangerous. That is terrible that My Sister
- 10:32Sam was a show in 1986. I guess they had two seasons.
- 10:36Pam Dauber was the main character and then Rebecca
- 10:40Schaefer. Unfortunately, Paddy Russell was
- 10:42the woman and that's. Awful.
- 10:45Circling back to Youtubers, a lot of young Youtubers are
- 10:48quitting because not just because of the parasocial
- 10:51relationships, because of the immense stress of putting your
- 10:54whole life online. And they're recognizing and
- 10:56bless Gen. Z.
- 10:58You're going to save all of us. They're recognizing that it's
- 11:00not good for your mental health. No, I was watching documentary
- 11:03series on Netflix last night about these young women who are
- 11:08targeted by this cyber stalker. You know, they're all Youtubers
- 11:11and basically because everything is exposed, all of the
- 11:15information about them, this cyber stalker knows what she
- 11:17wore to X event and where it was and who she was with.
- 11:21And so he manages to get her whole phone book of friends and
- 11:25relatives and makes fake messages.
- 11:27And because everything that she does is documented a UK.
- 11:30You tuber Charlie McDonnell, who was the first guy in the UK to
- 11:34reach 1,000,000 subscribers on YouTube, quit this in March 2023
- 11:38and he said I have essentially quit YouTube.
- 11:40It turns out that tying up your perceived worth with your level
- 11:43of success on a website is a very bad idea.
- 11:47Oh, that's really sad and extremely true.
- 11:50Well, Laura has a a thriving TikTok presence that she's
- 11:55already experienced some of these feelings about because
- 11:59TikTok is born to frustrate and like, it's very intentional.
- 12:03TikTok will after you've had a Hot video that it's shown a lot
- 12:06of people and it's got a lot of views, your next one is going to
- 12:09eat crap by design. Right, let's check the Tic Tac
- 12:13numbers currently. I remember when Jenny was really
- 12:16obsessed with views and stuff and I was like, why does she
- 12:18care? But it's because it's like.
- 12:19Right here with. Cocaine.
- 12:22It's a constant dopamine beam rush.
- 12:23When you have a video that's doing well or you have a post
- 12:27that's doing well on Instagram, refreshing it and going back to
- 12:30look at it, it's a constant stream of dopamine.
- 12:33Right. So OK, so I had a a video blow
- 12:36up for me, 35 point 4K views, very respectable.
- 12:41And then the next one I curated, like I specifically picked
- 12:45something similar to the one that blew up and I had 76 views.
- 12:50That second video is probably just as good as the last video.
- 12:53It doesn't matter, but you're allowing an algorithm to mess
- 12:56with your head. Yes, it feels like the spigot
- 12:59was open and then they just shut it off.
- 13:02But it's because Tick Tock, Tick Tock doesn't care particularly
- 13:06if you're making good content or bad content.
- 13:09Tick Tock wants you to make content and to really get you to
- 13:12dance on the hot plate. They do this intermittent
- 13:15rewards thing. I'm extremely chill about it
- 13:17because I was where you were three years ago.
- 13:19It's just, I find it infuriating, you know, I just
- 13:22think because like you said, I think the content is just as
- 13:25good, but now no one's going to see it and that's annoying.
- 13:28Another hard talk in particular is the phenomenon of TikTok
- 13:32bullying like Laura has experienced that when you have a
- 13:36video that is getting, you know, 10% of your regular viewers have
- 13:40seen it, maybe 20, it's pretty chill.
- 13:43But as soon as you get something that is popular and people from
- 13:47the wrong side of TikTok see it, you're opening yourself up to
- 13:49abuse. Yeah, I had 32 rapid fire
- 13:53messages from the same guy on one TikTok.
- 13:56Remember the the guy who was telling me I was a misogynist?
- 13:59Everyone tells me I'm a misogynist.
- 14:01Why not? Well, they're not wrong.
- 14:03I'm a misandrist is what I am. What his mistake is, is that
- 14:07thinking that you care, or that it's necessarily a bad thing?
- 14:11Well, and what I wanted to say is, Sir, my opinions on the men
- 14:16are come from my life experience and I'm sorry that you don't
- 14:20like my life experience and my lived reality.
- 14:23I think I did say that, but. Yes, I had to encourage you to
- 14:26stop talking to him and walk away because it will eat your
- 14:30whole day. He also deleted all of his
- 14:32messages. Oh, that's interesting.
- 14:34It is. That means you've won.
- 14:37Another little side thing is the fallacy, the incredible waste of
- 14:41time. And everybody knows this
- 14:43intellectually that arguing with strangers on the Internet is a
- 14:46waste of time. But when you are doing it, you
- 14:49are feeling all of like you are getting activated and you're
- 14:52getting all your like, fight or flight and your heart's beating
- 14:56and you get very into it. I think over it took me until
- 14:59over lockdown, you know, 15 years of social media presence,
- 15:02I guess 20. I'm not going to change this
- 15:04person's opinion, and they're not going to change my opinion,
- 15:08and I should stop. I had a boyfriend who would tell
- 15:11me these long stories about arguments he'd gotten on on
- 15:15Facebook, but and they were like heroes.
- 15:17Stories about how I really told them the right way to play
- 15:20Dungeons and Dragons. Yes I learned the same lesson
- 15:24from my ex-husband which is why I usually don't interact with
- 15:27Internet bullies. But my sister told me that I
- 15:29should on TikTok to boost my ratings.
- 15:32OK. Here's the thing, you've made me
- 15:34look like an A hole and now I have to defend myself If someone
- 15:38says a couple things to you that you can be smart at, especially
- 15:42if you can respond with a video. This is free TikTok for you
- 15:45guys. Free TikTok advice if you're a
- 15:47TikTok creator. That can do very well, but when
- 15:50it goes past one or two exchanges, you got to walk away
- 15:53because it will eat your day. Yes, Virginia, Have you ever had
- 15:56the experience of a parasocial relationship where you are the
- 16:00celebrity? Oddly, yes it is very strange
- 16:04because I am completely non famous right?
- 16:06I have had interact. Magically invisible.
- 16:09So OK, you know, cards on the table, I have a very small tick
- 16:13tock following. It's 20,000 people.
- 16:14I love all of you. I love those of you who are
- 16:16listening to this podcast. That is not very small.
- 16:18I have 380. I've been performing stand up
- 16:21comedy for 18 years and the thing that happens to me, you'll
- 16:25be surprised it's a lot of men have a pair of social
- 16:28relationship with me. So it's led to a couple things.
- 16:30I'm usually pretty quiet about my personal relationships online
- 16:35because not everybody who's following me as a friend or
- 16:38family member, right? Even in small things like I'm a
- 16:40little more careful. Two, I learned a hard lesson,
- 16:44which is don't date a fan. You know, a couple years ago, I
- 16:47was feeling sad and I had a fan in Seattle who was, you know,
- 16:54kind of flirting with me. And I'm like, you know what,
- 16:56this is going to be great. This is someone who already
- 16:58likes me. I don't have to prove myself to
- 17:00this person. But what happened was he would
- 17:03say things to me that were my own jokes, like turned inside
- 17:07out or like rotated in a way he was telling my joke back to me.
- 17:11Do you? Okay, that's super weird.
- 17:13And like, sometimes it would be something that I didn't even, it
- 17:16would be something I said once on a podcast and then he would
- 17:19say it and he would look at me, but like, get it.
- 17:23Oh God. And it was incredibly creepy.
- 17:25Yeah, I think there's confusion about what you're doing all day.
- 17:29Like, I think that, you know, when people see you in a certain
- 17:32context all the time, they just think, oh, well, that's your
- 17:34whole life. I'm like, well, I had, you know,
- 17:3623 other hours that day. Right.
- 17:38And I definitely had experiences with female friends who if
- 17:41they're very good on Twitter, Marcella Arwella, who's
- 17:44incredibly funny and incredibly mean, but she's like, don't love
- 17:48my Twitter following and my Twitter feed, but then complain
- 17:51that I'm on the phone all the time.
- 17:53These two things go together. Right.
- 17:55They're connected. My son follows a you tuber
- 17:58pretty closely that he loves. And I think what a cool kid.
- 18:02Like I really like that kid. And I thought, wouldn't it be
- 18:04funny or interesting if we hung out with him?
- 18:07But then I thought, no, because he's constantly has his phone
- 18:10out recording everything he does.
- 18:12And that would be so irritating. My friend, I have a good friend
- 18:15in Toronto who had a celeb like a, you know, some sort of
- 18:19celebrity, you tuber come stay with him and his husband.
- 18:23And the person used footage from their house and the person used
- 18:27footage of them talking and like stuff that he wasn't supposed to
- 18:31do because there's no boundary. Yeah, I don't like that.
- 18:34So my son is obsessed with Ben of the Week of YouTube fame.
- 18:38Oh, right. Even I know Ben of the Week
- 18:40well. He's.
- 18:41Kind of, he's kind of a big deal.
- 18:42Well, I know him through my nephew, who is also your son,
- 18:45because you're my sister. Yes anyway, but I was watching a
- 18:48Ben of the Week recently and he went to a nail salon and got the
- 18:53longest nails. Gross.
- 18:55Yes. And then he decided they weren't
- 18:57long enough, so he glued chopsticks to the end.
- 19:00Is there people going to watch? But like if that were my son,
- 19:03that would be so annoying. If you actually had to live with
- 19:05someone who was doing that, talking a little bit more about
- 19:08the unique issues of being a woman on the Internet.
- 19:11So I am friends with three amazing comics, Tess, Barbara
- 19:16and Brandy, who have a podcast called Lady, the lady that's
- 19:19been going for over 10 years. And we were talking about
- 19:23parasocial relationships. You know, Brandy's like, this is
- 19:27a podcast kind of for women. It's three women talking.
- 19:31We would love our audience to be entirely women, but men are the
- 19:35ones who subscribe. Men are the ones who buy our
- 19:39merch. Men are much more comfortable
- 19:42with the parasocial thing than women, so they have to be along
- 19:46for the ride. Yeah, it's interesting.
- 19:47I was harassing a mom at school pickup about listening to my.
- 19:51Guest. She said, well, you know, I just
- 19:53don't really listen to podcasts. And I said, you know, it's
- 19:56interesting, most women don't because we don't have the time.
- 20:00And what I wanted to say to her probably sounded creepy.
- 20:03But what I was gonna say is, well, I listen to it while I put
- 20:06on my makeup and take a shower. But I've had conversations with
- 20:09other women performers and you have to make a decision to see
- 20:12right like the people who stalked me is because my
- 20:15schedule is on a website and you have to make a separation in
- 20:19your mind. What is the distance come
- 20:20someone can come see you from who is a fan and when does that
- 20:24crossover to stalking? And we decided it was 100 miles.
- 20:27You can like my comedy all you want, but if you try, if you
- 20:30traveled more than 100 miles to see me at my fame level.
- 20:34You're moving into unhealthy waters.
- 20:36It's also interesting, another pair of social things that has
- 20:38happened to me. I had a lady approach me and
- 20:41say, I'm a huge fan of your content on TikTok, and that was
- 20:45very flattering. Then she introduced me to a
- 20:48table of people and pulled like the opposite version of one of
- 20:51my jokes that makes me look like a pervert.
- 20:54I'm like, that's not what that joke is and that's not what it's
- 20:56about. And then I had to defend myself
- 20:59to this table full of women. But what you forget is that once
- 21:02you create something, people are going to take from it whatever
- 21:06they're going to take from it. People do with it whatever they
- 21:09like. I remember Billy Idol saying he
- 21:11thought it was so funny that people play white wedding at
- 21:14their wedding at. Their wedding like this, not
- 21:16actually this. Is not romantic.
- 21:18No but also people are kind of dumb.
- 21:22The stalking thing on TikTok is weird.
- 21:24Like tells everybody never reveal your location, never let
- 21:30people even have the area of where you live because you know
- 21:33in like other tik tokers, their whole thing is finding people
- 21:36from short. Video Yeah, there was this kid
- 21:39that I followed on TikTok. I think he was a psychic or
- 21:42something. He was a card reader.
- 21:44He was on the account that I had to close because I became
- 21:46inundated with tarot readings. Tarot readings and dowsing.
- 21:50Yeah, I got really tired. But anyway, I remember one of
- 21:54his like bits was he would walk around his neighborhood talking
- 21:56about stuff and I'm like, man, I can see the signs.
- 21:58I know where you are. There was a woman Tik Tokker who
- 22:02her whole account and TikTok I think is kind of maybe it's
- 22:04moving out of this area or maybe I'm just not seeing it as much.
- 22:07But it'd be people who did one thing that was barely anything,
- 22:10but they would do it all the time.
- 22:12And her whole thing was she would wear these robes that are
- 22:14covered in ostrich feathers, the merry widow robes, and like
- 22:19flounce around to music. And she made a video and like,
- 22:24it was creepy because it was only ever the inside of her
- 22:27house. There were very little other
- 22:29clues to her location, but I guess people recognized her.
- 22:34And so one night she's recording a video and there's a knock on
- 22:37her door and people showed up and said, hey, we know it's you.
- 22:41That's. So.
- 22:43Scary. And she was like, don't do that
- 22:45guys. Please don't.
- 22:47My son also, I'm just going to go ahead and help myself as a
- 22:50very bad parent because my son watches YouTube 22 hours out of
- 22:54the day. But he was showing me there's a
- 22:56guy on YouTube. People will bet him they can't
- 22:59locate them. He'll do it.
- 23:01In the creepiest I know there's a the Walmart that's in the
- 23:04distance behind you. There's only a place that has a
- 23:07Walmart and a stop and shop within a block of each other in
- 23:10Idaho. So I'm guessing your house is
- 23:12here. He's always right and it's very
- 23:14scary. And the the free time and like,
- 23:17I think I've mentioned it on this podcast before, but one
- 23:20time I told the story on a very popular podcast about two people
- 23:24who I had brief interactions with and did not like and people
- 23:28were sending me photograph like who found them on Instagram and
- 23:30said this them. I'm like, Oh no.
- 23:33Unfortunately, we didn't get that same kind of energy for
- 23:35Arthur Griebler. No one has stepped up stalking
- 23:38Arthur Griebler, the only person who really doesn't explorer.
- 23:41If anyone wants to DM me like everything about Arthur
- 23:44Griebler. God.
- 23:46So I now have a parasocial relationship with one of your
- 23:48trolls. Yes, who I was hoping was it
- 23:51filed like. That's part of why I thought it
- 23:53was funny. No, he was like a he was
- 23:55something year old man a. Full grown freaking plumber.
- 23:59Very gross. So the person who submitted this
- 24:01question, Steve, also spoke specifically about stand up
- 24:05comedy. And there's a lot of interesting
- 24:06things in this. Like, I've had interactions
- 24:08like, so I was waiting to go up at a show.
- 24:12I was talking to my friend Vance said, Vance, how are you?
- 24:15And he said, I'm I'm, I'm OK, I'm fine.
- 24:17And I'm like, oh, what's going on?
- 24:19He's like, oh, nothing really. And then he went on stage and
- 24:23talked about how his wife had been diagnosed with cancer and
- 24:27he has someone who has survived cancer and starting this like
- 24:31process again. And I was like, man, we're
- 24:34friends. But he didn't want to quote Burn
- 24:36the material just talking to me. That is very weird.
- 24:40And so our listener said, you know, sometimes I will watch
- 24:43other comics and I will know very intimate things about their
- 24:46lives even though I don't know them.
- 24:49And I have a weird feeling of getting to know them through
- 24:52their material. Is this something that happens
- 24:54in comedy? And like another thing is when
- 24:56you sit down and do a podcast with another comic, you will
- 24:58learn more about them than you have learned in 10 years of
- 25:01seeing them at show. But I also think it's because at
- 25:04the show, you know, everyone's just waiting to go up and you're
- 25:07reviewing your jokes and it's not casual.
- 25:10And it's, you know, you can't really let your hair down.
- 25:12You're just sort of getting ready.
- 25:14Yeah. And like, yeah, it's pre and
- 25:15post performance, but it is very weird the things you learn about
- 25:18each other on stage that you would never share just talking
- 25:21to each other. Right, because that's not normal
- 25:24social relationships. One time I was living in an
- 25:27apartment complex in Portland, OR, and the apartment manager
- 25:32told me a story about the people who'd lived in my apartment
- 25:34before. And he said they had a clogged
- 25:36toilet. And I had a plumber out to fix
- 25:38the toilet. And the plumber came to me and
- 25:42said, listen, I have to tell you what I pulled out of their
- 25:45toilet because it was a potato that had been carved roughly
- 25:50into the shape of a phallus and that had a blue condom on it.
- 25:53Wow, we couldn't put that in the trash, guys.
- 25:56Why toilet? And so my poor like apartment
- 25:59manager said he had to charge them back and he wrote on the
- 26:02thing, toilet abuse. So I have carried that story
- 26:06around with me for 20 years. Oh wow, I've never heard of.
- 26:09I'm glad that I was able to lead you there.
- 26:11What are the good and bad things about parasocial relationships?
- 26:14If you're a performer, having people have a little bit of a
- 26:16parasocial connection with you is good because it means they
- 26:19are in involved with you, they are committed and they're on the
- 26:25journey with you. But it can swiftly take a turn.
- 26:29Hugh Jackman, the actor who plays Wolverine, was jogging in
- 26:32London a couple years ago and. He didn't like that you were
- 26:35running behind him. A woman ran at him and screamed.
- 26:39I love you, Hugh. And then threw razors at him
- 26:44that had her own pubic hair in them.
- 26:47Which brought me to the question, did that work?
- 26:49I think the question that comes to mind for me is why I think
- 26:53you're going to say she threw roses at him.
- 26:55That makes sense. Right.
- 26:56That's something that would be kind of there's an A to B to C,
- 26:59No, She threw her own pubic hair at him.
- 27:02Or even a handful of pubic hair that kind of makes sense.
- 27:04But razors with pubic hair in them?
- 27:07You can't throw a handful of pubic hair and This is why,
- 27:09because it's just going to get caught in the wind.
- 27:12There's no it doesn't weigh enough.
- 27:14Maybe we could get some glue involved?
- 27:16So yeah, on the dark side, parasocial relationships could
- 27:19be very dangerous for the performer as well as, you know,
- 27:23for the fan. Like that man who shot the
- 27:27YouTube shot himself right afterwards.
- 27:29So Laura, if you had a person in your practice, a client, who was
- 27:33uncomfortable with their level of parasocial relationship with
- 27:37a celebrity, what advice would you give them?
- 27:39Well, I think if it were a teenager, I would say this is
- 27:42normal. You know, when I was 14, I had a
- 27:45Morrissey shrine in my bedroom, which I think is perfectly
- 27:49normal. Also, if they're autistic
- 27:51spectrum disorder or ADHD or yeah, you're gonna do that.
- 27:55That's part of being a neurodivergent.
- 27:58What? You are.
- 27:58Right. It's about getting really
- 28:00obsessive about stuff, I think, much like the doll head, I think
- 28:04if it starts to interfere with your daily relationships.
- 28:08This is a reference to a previous episode Returning
- 28:11listeners will remember when we talked about the woman who was a
- 28:14Dick knitting a doll head episode.
- 28:17She was on the show My Strange Obsession.
- 28:20And, you know, since you've mentioned teenagers, I've
- 28:23realized that like, yeah, this radio show was by number means
- 28:26my first parasocial relationship, my first
- 28:28parasocial relationship. Was with Boy George.
- 28:32Yes. And then Simon Le Bon right?
- 28:35And then Robert Smith, The Cure, which has continued until today.
- 28:39Until you were today years old when you realized you were still
- 28:42at an insane parasocial relationship with Robert.
- 28:45Smith. Yeah, and like the Robert Smith
- 28:47thing in particular when he married, Like I was a teenager
- 28:50when he married. The love of his life, Mary
- 28:52Poole. They're still together today.
- 28:54Hashtag couples goals. Me and every goth girl I knew
- 28:57was torn up by this. You thought I had a shot?
- 29:02Didn't we almost have it all, Robert?
- 29:04Why would you choose a fellow adult who's from your hometown
- 29:08and not a 14 year old in suburban Dallas?
- 29:11Morrissey, why would you choose to date exclusively men instead
- 29:15of a 13 year old from Dallas? But you're right, you touched on
- 29:19something that's interesting that I know, which is that
- 29:21fangirl phase, the hero worship is a normal part of our romantic
- 29:27development. Right.
- 29:28I think it's just a part of growing up.
- 29:30I think because we're not old enough to have real
- 29:32relationships, we're we're trying out the kind of fixation
- 29:37obsession part of relationships. And yeah, and like, girls today.
- 29:40Well, like who's your favorite K pop boy?
- 29:42Like, well, I like, you know, Shujan because he's the bad boy.
- 29:47Instead of realizing that none of this is real, people have
- 29:50created this. These are just regular daggler
- 29:53guys who got tricked into being in a boy band.
- 29:56I went to go see The Cure last year and we were running late
- 30:01and I was aggravated by this and my boyfriend at the time said do
- 30:06you really think that if the lights come up, Robert's going
- 30:09to look at your seat in section? 100 and five 812.
- 30:15Right at the Hollywood Bowl and say we can't stop yet.
- 30:18Virginia is not here. Is this why you guys broke up?
- 30:22Yeah. And I said listen, Buster, you,
- 30:25along with every relationship I've ever had, including my
- 30:29ex-husband, are just a placeholder for the time that
- 30:34Robert Smith somehow meets and falls in love with me.
- 30:37That tracks. I hear you.
- 30:39That makes sense. You will.
- 30:39Be lifted out of your position. Robert Smith will be dropped in.
- 30:43He'll be teleported in. And I'm very clear with this,
- 30:47with all relationships. The person I'm seeing now, I
- 30:50told him like, hey, I really like you.
- 30:52If Robert Smith knocks on my door at any time.
- 30:55It's over. I won't even complete the
- 30:58sentence. I'm saying to you, I will just
- 31:01grab my bag and go. You will never see me again
- 31:04except for on television. Having a productive relationship
- 31:07with Robert Smith. It's weird how much of that I
- 31:09have experienced even at the very low levels that I am at.
- 31:12People have said to me, your comedy got me through a rough
- 31:15time. People like people have said to
- 31:17me, oh, you know, I really thought about this for a long
- 31:20time and will tell me their take on it and it's completely
- 31:23different than my intention. It's very odd and also when
- 31:26people say oh I met the celebrity and they were rude or
- 31:30I met the celebrity and like they were mean to me.
- 31:33And if you scratch the surface frequently, it's just that the
- 31:36person didn't want to sit down and have a multi hour
- 31:38conversation with them, right? Or didn't have time to engage on
- 31:43the level that they felt that they deserved.
- 31:44I'm like, hey, what if they're just a person living their?
- 31:46Life, right? They're on their way to their
- 31:49daughter's ballet performance and they don't have time to talk
- 31:53to you in the middle of Times Square.
- 31:54They're trying to get through this.
- 31:55I'm just remembering my parasocial relationships when I
- 31:58met John Schneider of Dukes of Hazzard OK in New.
- 32:03York. City in New York City.
- 32:04I think I was 15 at the time. I, you know, still thought he
- 32:08was really something. I couldn't find a pen to get him
- 32:11to sign my Playbill because we had just seen him in a play and
- 32:14I swore and he did not like that because he said Nope.
- 32:18And then I realized, oh, he and I have gone in real different
- 32:21directions. Real difference.
- 32:22The Dukes of Hazzard. So circling back to some sort of
- 32:25therapeutic value, if you had an adult client who was
- 32:30uncomfortable with their level of interest in a stranger, a
- 32:33celebrity they didn't know, what is your advice to that?
- 32:35I mean, I guess the first question would be, why are you
- 32:37uncomfortable? Like, what is it about it that
- 32:40makes you uncomfortable? And I think, you know, if it's
- 32:42interfering with other parts of your life, then you should do
- 32:45something about it. If it's a nice escape, if it's
- 32:47something that makes you feel good and makes you feel happy,
- 32:50then I would say continue. Like, let's just say I have an
- 32:54obsession with Scarlett Johansson.
- 32:56I can't stop thinking about her. I'm continually fighting the
- 33:00desire to write her and contact her and I'm really struggling.
- 33:05What do I do then? I would first try to find out if
- 33:07there's a diagnosis because if you start getting into that
- 33:11level of obsession, there's probably something biochemically
- 33:15happening. There's something going on with
- 33:16me and Robert Smith that I really need to address.
- 33:18Yes, if my fixation with Scar Jo is getting to the point where I
- 33:23can't get through a day without looking at her.
- 33:25This is kind of what we talked about in the sex addiction
- 33:27episode we'll talk about in an upcoming episode about fantasy.
- 33:32If it's not a coping strategy anymore and it starts to become
- 33:36something that's making your life harder and making it
- 33:39difficult to get through the daily activities of life, then
- 33:42you should probably figure something else out.
- 33:44So Laura, what are your final thoughts on this topic of
- 33:46Parisocial relationships? Well, I think they're mostly
- 33:49harmless. I had a very brief experience
- 33:52with being the person who was the celebrity.
- 33:56Laura had a cool opportunity to talk about her practice on
- 34:00television in Austin. Right.
- 34:02I was on a radio show and I was on local TV.
- 34:05So for the following, I don't know, a few months anytime a new
- 34:10patient came in I would see something really weird happen to
- 34:14their face when they met me. They would light up.
- 34:17Right. And I realized, Oh my gosh, this
- 34:19is what I'm doing to It's very uncomfortable and unpleasant.
- 34:25It's this very weird. You don't know me, but you're
- 34:27excited that I'm around. So it just reminded me of that
- 34:30because I'm used to being the person on the giving end, but
- 34:32I'm not used to being the person on the receiving end.
- 34:35And my little taste of it was not great.
- 34:37Right. Borderline unpleasant.
- 34:39Yeah. I guess my final thoughts on
- 34:41parasocial relationships is I do think they're an important part
- 34:44of emotional development. I think that we all do it.
- 34:48And I think it's a good thing if you're a young man or young
- 34:51woman to develop who you are based on these people that
- 34:55you've never met, but starts to get weird once you passed a
- 34:59certain threshold. And I think we all have to kind
- 35:02of decide what that threshold is for ourselves.
- 35:04So Virginia, yeah. What are your final thoughts on
- 35:07this topic? So it's interesting to think
- 35:09about, you know, the positive aspects of a parasocial
- 35:12relationship. And you're right, like ways you
- 35:14can kind of play out well and try on personalities
- 35:18relationships in the world of make believe.
- 35:20But it can also be it can be very creepy to be on the
- 35:23receiving end. You know, again, very limited
- 35:26experience. I've talked about it before, but
- 35:27the way you can tell is someone's eyes light up.
- 35:31They seem like they're your friend, but you've never seen
- 35:33them. Before right there's a a look of
- 35:35recognition from a total stranger, and that is really
- 35:38creepy. Yeah, I guess I just hadn't
- 35:40thought about the positive aspects of it before.
- 35:42And that's interesting. And as the entertainment
- 35:45landscape becomes more and more flat and like at ground level,
- 35:50there's fewer TV shows being made.
- 35:51CBS bought 0 pilots this year for pilot season, which has
- 35:56never happened before. People are looking at YouTube
- 35:58and TikTok and quote UN quote ordinary people for their
- 36:02entertainment now, and it's going to lead to more bizarre,
- 36:05specific parasocial relationships.
- 36:07But as long as you as a performer keep yourself safe and
- 36:10as a fan you keep a respectful distance, like we can all kind
- 36:13of benefit from them. Yeah, I think it's about the
- 36:16boundaries. You just triggered a memory.
- 36:18I remember when I was walking home from school and, and I did
- 36:21this more than once because I don't know ADHD, but I used to
- 36:25listen to, you know, The Smiths on my Walkman and sing loudly
- 36:30because I'm me. But I used to have this fantasy
- 36:32story in my head that for some reason Morrissey was in my
- 36:36crappy little suburban town and he would be able to hear me and
- 36:40he would come outside and rush out and we would be best
- 36:44friends. I'm just going to tell you,
- 36:45surprisingly, it never happened. Really weird one that I had.
- 36:49I was in love with Agent Mulder from The X-Files and many people
- 36:53would say, oh you have a crush on David Duchovny?
- 36:56No, specifically Agent Mulder, not the actor who played him.
- 37:00Because the character extremely conventionally good looking man
- 37:04who doesn't know that he's good looking and is very shy and
- 37:07weird. That's something that happens
- 37:08all the time in life. That's the combo that you liked.
- 37:11But I used to have a weird free floating fantasy as an adult.
- 37:15Like, I had a job I was working at like an apparel company and I
- 37:19thought, what if, like, Mulder had to come in here for
- 37:22something? What if Mulder was looking for
- 37:25special fabric that repelled aliens?
- 37:27God, it was a Daydream and I never it was not a real thing.
- 37:30He never acted on it because. Well, nothing act on.
- 37:33Yeah, there's no reason for him, for Agent Mulder, who's not a
- 37:36real person, to be in Fort Worth, TX during the day.
- 37:38So Virginia, if somebody wants to reach out and find out more
- 37:43about your comedy and your online career, where would they
- 37:47find you? You can find me at badinia.com
- 37:50BADINIA that's also my TikTok and my Instagram.
- 37:54I do have dates on a calendar on my website whichisbadinia.com.
- 37:58Please come to shows, but not if it's over 100 miles away.
- 38:02Also don't harass her at the shows, just come and enjoy the
- 38:06comedy. After the show, you can say that
- 38:09was great, I am a fan and I'll say thank you very much.
- 38:12Would you like a sticker, Laura? Where can people find you
- 38:15online? Well, you can find me at
- 38:17lauraryan.org, my professional website.
- 38:20You can also find me on TikTok. I am Laura Ryan.
- 38:24Or in addition, you can go to my website,
- 38:27mysisters@therapist.com. And if you want to send us an
- 38:30e-mail, you would e-mail us at hello at my sisters at
- 38:34therapist.com and tell us all about why you think our show's
- 38:37so great. Also, if you'd like to hire us
- 38:39to speak at your women's conference, mental health
- 38:41conference, Wellness event, women's retreat, educational
- 38:44seminar, corporate event or workshop, you can e-mail us at
- 38:48Hire us at my sister's a therapist.com.
- 38:51Laura. This is the segment where we
- 38:53usually do a listener review. Do you have a listener review
- 38:56for us this week? I in fact do this one is from
- 38:59EMCO. I am Co.
- 39:01I am Co thank you. So Amco said blending therapy
- 39:04and comedy offers a fresh perspective.
- 39:06This podcast is for anyone looking to delve deeper into
- 39:09mental health topics with a light hearted and accessible
- 39:12approach. I love how the sisters share
- 39:14relatable anecdotes from their lives along with practical tools
- 39:18for listeners who want to learn more.
- 39:19The contrasting backgrounds of the sisters creates an engaging
- 39:22dynamic and humor. Highly recommended.
- 39:25That is very sweet and very detailed.
- 39:27Thank you. Thank you, Emco, That was very
- 39:29kind. So in closing, in the immortal
- 39:32words of Billy Ray Valentine, Capricorn, we can make it, baby.
- 39:36Me and you. Bye bye.